Professional Documents
Culture Documents
c) Distribution network
The short-circuit power is an important factor in power
quality management. Under constant emission a higher
short circuit power results in a better voltage quality.
Fig. 1 main influences on power quality. Today the short-circuit power is mainly determined by
the upstream network. In the IEC electromagnetic-
All three areas are expected to see significant changes in compatibility standards standards a reference impedance
the future. This means that power quality issues will also (cf. IEC 60725) is used as a link between compatibility
change with the consecutive development of future grids. levels (voltages) and emission limits (currents). In future
The following comments shall give some examples for grids with high penetration of generation significant
possible future developments in power quality. Further differing supply scenarios may be possible, from supply
expected developments are also discussed in Section 5. by a strong upstream network to an islanded (self-
balanced) operation. This may lead to a significantly
a) Generating equipment higher variability in short circuit power than today. Thus
The penetration of microgeneration (typically defined as the approach based on fixed reference impedances may
generation with a rated power of less than 16 A per be inadequate or the use of high emitting loads may only
phase) in the low-voltage networks is expected to be acceptable for certain operational states of the network
increase continuously. In domestic installations this will or only in conjunction with power quality conditioners
be mainly single phase equipment based on self- (owned by a customer, by the network operator, or by a
commutating inverters with switching frequencies in the third party).
range of several kHz. Emissions in the range of low order Due to the continuous decrease of resistive loads
harmonics can usually be neglected. The emissions shift providing damping stability issues may become
into the range of higher frequencies, possibly between 2 important for low-voltage networks too. In conjunction
and 9 kHz, where a serious discussion is needed on the with increasing capacitive load (the EMC filters of
choice of appropriate limits. We will come back to this in electronic equipment) resonance points with decreasing
Section 5.1. resonant frequencies as well as lower damping can
Furthermore micro-generation equipment will often be appear.
connected single-phase. This could increase the negative-
sequence and zero-sequence voltage in the low-voltage 4 Power-quality monitoring
grid. In weak distribution networks, existing limits could
be exceeded rather quickly. Reconsidering the limits for
Growing service quality expectations and reduced
negative-sequence voltages and introducing limits for
possibilities for grid enforcements make advanced
zero-sequence voltage could be possible needed.
distribution automation (ADA) an increasingly necessary
development for network operators and the next large
b) Consumer equipment
step in the evolution of the power systems to smart grids.
The introduction of new and more efficient technologies
The management of the distribution system is mainly
is the main driver for changes in consumer equipment.
based on the information collected from the power flows
One widely-discussed example is the change from
by an integrated monitoring system. This enables real-
incandescent lamps to energy saving lamps. Compact
time monitoring of grid conditions for the power system
fluorescent lamps are at the moment the main
operators. It also enables automatic reconfiguration of the
replacement for incandescent lamps, but they are
network to optimize the power delivery efficiency and to
probably only an intermediate step before the LED-
reduce the extent and duration of interruptions. The basic
technique will become widely accepted. Seen from the
part of the monitoring system infrastructure is based on
network, each of the new lamp technologies results in the
sensors, transducers, intelligent electronic devices (IED)
replacement of a resistive load by a rectifier load. The
and (revenue) meters collecting information throughout
fundamental current is reduced significantly whereas the
the distribution system.
harmonic currents are increased. High penetration
A number of network operators have already proposed
together with high coincidence of operation may lead to
that the smart grid of the future should include:
an increase of low order harmonics. Several network
Network monitoring to improve reliability,
operators fear an increase of especially the fifth harmonic
Equipment monitoring to improve maintenance,
voltage above the compatibility levels. Discussion is
Product (power) monitoring to improve PQ.
ongoing in IEC working groups about the need for
In order to achieve these goals, the actual distribution
additional emission requirements on new types of
system infrastructure (especially meters and remotely
lighting of low wattage. The same would hold for other
controlled IEDs) should be used to gather as much
improved (energy-efficient drives) or new (photovoltaics,
information as possible related to network, equipment
battery chargers for electric and hybrid cars) equipment.
and product (i.e. power quality and reliability) to improve
As mentioned before, such limits should however not
the distribution system overall performance.
result in unnecessary barriers against the introduction of
Among the most important ADA operating systems, that
new equipment. Alternative paths, like an increase of the
a smart grid will include, it can be mentioned:
Volt & var control (VVC),
Fault location (FL), The impact of these applications on the distribution
Network reconfiguration or self-healing. network and its customers is permanently evaluated.
Network operators with an ambitious energy efficiency
The infrastructure belonging to ADA systems can be
program have focused on two targets:
shared by a power-quality monitoring system capable of
Capacitor banks installation,
real time monitoring.
Voltage control.
Depending on the type of ADA application or system, the
There is also another important goal: to reduce the
monitoring can be done either at low-voltage or at
duration of interruptions. To answer to these challenges,
medium-voltage level. In the first case monitoring
pilot projects are being conducted on conservation
devices may belong to an Advanced Metering
voltage reduction and fault location based on power
Infrastructure (AMI) and in the second case they may
quality related measurements provided by IEDs and
belong to the distribution major equipment itself (i.e.
revenue meters.
controllers) (see Fig. 2) [16].
The VVC system requires a permanent monitoring of the
voltage magnitude (averaged over 1 to 5 min) at the end
of the distribution feeder and the installation of switched Distribution Automation Flow of Information
capacitor banks. Besides that, the monitoring allows the New Technologies
detection of power quality disturbances such as long-
duration undervoltages and overvoltages, and voltage and • T
• T • T
current unbalance.
• T
• T
Basically, the voltage regulation system at the substation
is replaced with an intelligent system that uses network
measurements to maintain a voltage magnitude for all DATA Applications Business needs
(How?) (Why?)
(Using what?)
customers within the acceptable upper and lower limits. Voltage
Voltage Control
Energy Efficiency
Optimised Load Flow
The VVC system also analyzes the reactive-power Fault Current
Load Current
Fault Location
Reliability
Distributed Resources
Faulty Equipment
requirements of the network and orders the switching of Temperature
Number of Operations
Power Quality Evaluation
Power Quality
Customer Satisfaction
…
capacitor banks when required. Alarms
…
An important goal is to prevent potential power quality Fig. 2. Distribution Automation flow of information
problems due to the switching operations of capacitor
banks (with rating up to 1.2 Mvar). [13]. The smart grid will allow a continuous power-quality
Another goal was to evaluate the joint impact of the VVC monitoring that will not improve directly the voltage
system and voltage dips occurring on the grid. The results quality but will detect quality problems helping to
of the study indicate that the impact can be quantified by mitigate them.
two effects:
Increasing number of shallow voltage dips is 5 Different Power-Quality Issues
expected. Voltage reduction from 2 to 4% is
obtained due to VVC system. Added to this is the 5.1 Emission by new devices
voltage drop due to the fault: drops of 6 to 10% (not
counted as dips) become drops of 10 to 12% (which When smart grids are introduced, we expect growth both
are counted as dips). in production at lower voltage levels (distributed
Equipment malfunctioning or tripping: the joint generation) and in new types of consumption (for
contribution of the VVC system and the disturbance example, charging stations for electric vehicles, expanded
brings the residual voltage level below a critical high-speed railways, etc.). . Some of these new types of
threshold, around 70% of the nominal voltage for consumption will emit power-quality disturbances, for
many devices. example harmonic emission. Preliminary studies have
Fault location is based either on a voltage drop fault shown that harmonic emission due to distributed
location technique that uses waveforms from distributed generation is rather limited. Most existing end-user
power quality measurements along the feeder or on a equipment (computer, television, lamps, etc) emit almost
fault current technique based on the measurement of the exclusively at the lower odd integer harmonics (3, 5, 7, 9
fault current at the substation. According to [14] the etc), but there are indications that modern devices
average error in locating the fault with the first technique including certain types of distributed generators emit a
was less than 2%, in terms of the average main feeder broadband spectrum [6][7][8][9][12]. Using the standard
length. An accurate fault-location technique results in a methods of grouping into harmonic and interharmonic
significant reduction in the duration of (especially) the groups and subgroups below 2 kHz will result in high
longer interruptions. The information collected by the levels for even harmonics and interharmonics. For
fault-location system can also be used for calculating dip frequencies above 2 kHz high levels have been observed
related statistics and help to better understand the grid for the 200-Hz groups. An example is shown in Fig. 3:
behaviour [15]. the spectrum of the emission by a group of three full-
The third application, network reconfiguration or self power converter wind turbines, where 1 A is about 1% of
healing, is based either on local intelligence (belonging to
major distribution equipment controllers) or on decisions
taken at the power system control centre, which remotely
controls and operates the equipment used for network
reconfiguration (reclosers and switches).
the rated current. It is also true that modern devices can interfere with
power-line-communication, either by creating a high
0.5 disturbance level at the frequency chosen for power-line
communication, or by creating a low-impedance path,
0.4 effectively shorting out the power-line communication
signal. The latter seems to be the primary challenge to
Current (A)