11/30/22, 4:23 PM Design Validation: How Do You Know if Your Design is Good

Blog / UX Design 2025 views

by Adam Fard, Co-founder & Head of Design

Design Validation: How Do You Know if

Your Design is Good

Intro
Throughout every project, designers make countless decisions. These include fonts, microcopy, user flows,
and product structure. The list goes on and on. The tricky thing though is figuring out whether these design
choices were optimal or at least good. This brings us to this article’s topic: how do you know if your design
rocks.

Download FreeDesign Validation Checklist

A few disclaimers before we jump in:

81
Shares

https://adamfard.com/blog/design-validation 1/11
11/30/22, 4:23 PM Design Validation: How Do You Know if Your Design is Good

This list of design validation methods presented in this article is by no means comprehensive. There are
books upon books on design validation. And rightfully so, might we add. 

Here’s a good overview of the design validation methods. Feel free to check out the whole UX testing
process here.

Source

The ways to test your design presented in this article are the ones we employ the most often. Therefore, we
deem them the most practical and share-worthy.

N.B. Also, please note that these methods work in conjunction. You can’t just pick one and rely solely on
its results; use as many as possible.

Design Validation through Usability Testing

Let’s kick off this list with the trusty old favorite - usability testing. This method is based on the axiom that
design without users is not design, i.e. every major design decision should be validated by the means of
testing it on actual users. Only then should it be considered validated.

81
Shares

https://adamfard.com/blog/design-validation 2/11
11/30/22, 4:23 PM Design Validation: How Do You Know if Your Design is Good

Usability testing is probably the most common and arguably the most potent design validation method.
There are a few reasons for that. Firstly, this design validation method involves interviewing actual users or
potential users, which is the most reliable source of information. Secondly, usability testing usually involves
creating interview scripts that allow you to compare answers to the same sets of questions. The downside
though is that usability testing is time-consuming and relatively not cheap.

Usability testing generally involves the following processes:

Defining objectives;

Looking for users. Consider using the following resources:

Contact your existing users;

See if you can find your competitors’ (or potential) users. Here are a few places to look:

Facebook groups;

LinkedIn groups;

Try usertesting.com;

Reddit.

Creating task scenarios and conducting the interview;

Analyzing the data and turning it into insights.

81
Shares

https://adamfard.com/blog/design-validation 3/11
11/30/22, 4:23 PM Design Validation: How Do You Know if Your Design is Good

Another important caveat is that you'll need 5 users per feature or a group of features. According to
research conducted by Nielsen Norman Group, 5 is the optimal number of users to test your design on. The
reason it's optimal is because 6 is the point of diminishing returns, while 4 and fewer users will not give you
as many insights as you need.

Source: https://www.nngroup.com/articles/why-you-only-need-to-test-with-5-users/

Hallway Testing & Peer review

We designers love to judge someone else’s design. That’s why once in doubt, have your designer friend or a
colleague take a look at your work. That’s an invaluable source of new ideas and feedback. 

Hallway testing is pretty much yanking anyone you can lay your eyes on and having them interact with your
design to gather feedback. Ideally, that “anyone” should be a potential user of the product you’re testing so
that Lucy from accounting doesn’t review an app for ER nurses.
81
Shares

https://adamfard.com/blog/design-validation 4/11
11/30/22, 4:23 PM Design Validation: How Do You Know if Your Design is Good

Think of both of these as quick-and-dirty usability testing. Did we mention that both of these methods are
free?

10 Nielsen Heuristics
Analyzing and validating a product design through the lens of design heuristics is quite common. It often
comes naturally from experienced designers. Experienced or not, though, a designer should have these
heuristics top of mind. To help you do that we’ve prepared a checklist and a template for Nielsen Heuristic
Analysis. Ideally, you’d need to print these templates and have an analysis session on your app.

We also have a comprehensive video that covers all aspects of heuristic evaluation. Consider taking a look at
it if you prefer watching over reading.

Heuristic Evaluation: The UX First Aid Kit for Your Product

The 10 Nielsen’s Heuristics include:

1. Visibility of System Status (users should know the status of the system and get feedback on interactions
with it);

2. Match between the system and the real world (the system should resemble the experiences that users
already had);
81
Shares
3. User control and freedom (users should be able to reverse their action if done by mistake);

https://adamfard.com/blog/design-validation 5/11
11/30/22, 4:23 PM Design Validation: How Do You Know if Your Design is Good

4. Consistency and standard (similar system elements should look similar);

5. Error prevention (minimize the likelihood of making mistakes);

6. Recognition rather than recall (users should be able to interact with the system without prior information
or context;

7. Flexibility and efficiency of use (both new and experienced users should be able to efficiently use the
system);

8. An aesthetic and minimalist design (declutter as much as possible, less is more);

9. Help users recognize, diagnose, and recover from errors (make error messages understandable, and
suggest ways to fix an error);

10. Help and documentation (if a user has a hard time interacting with your app, make sure there’s help
that’s easily accessible).

These heuristics serve as principles on which your design should be based. Done correctly, these are a
recipe for impeccable and validated design.

Design Validation through Analytics & Benchmarking

Metrics
The design drives business. Therefore, good design should define key product metrics. That means that
gauging metrics about design changes is how you can estimate if you made a good design decision.
However, there’s a downside to using this retrospective method. The data takes time to collect. Additionally,
you’d have to make as few changes as possible to estimate each decision separately, or else you won’t know
what works and what doesn’t.

81
Shares

https://adamfard.com/blog/design-validation 6/11
11/30/22, 4:23 PM Design Validation: How Do You Know if Your Design is Good

The screenshot is taken from Google Analytics

Benchmarking
Benchmarking partially helps overcome the retrospective analysis’ downsides we’ve mentioned. Benchmarks
are the industry standards for your product metrics. If the metrics are on par with the industry average, so is
your design.

Heatmaps
Heatmaps are visual representations of how users interact with your product. Take a look at the heatmap
below. The redder the area is, the more users click on it. Conversely, the bluer it is, the fewer clicks it gets.

Additionally, there are plenty of plugins for Figma, Sketch, or other UX tools that, with the help of AI, predict
how users’ attention distributes across the design elements. Luckily, this use case is free and doesn’t take
much time. This distribution should ideally coincide with the information architecture and hierarchy you’re
going for. If it doesn’t, you know what to focus on. Take a look at the gif below to get a better idea of what
we’re talking about.

81
Shares

https://adamfard.com/blog/design-validation 7/11
11/30/22, 4:23 PM Design Validation: How Do You Know if Your Design is Good

Video shot with Loom. Designed in Figma. Heatmapped with Visual Eyes.

A/B Testing
In a nutshell, A/B testing is creating multiple versions of the same piece of functionality and then seeing
whichever one performs best. It’s a potent method but takes time for the data to aggregate and needs
developers to help you implement the A/B testing. 

This method is more about finding out which design version is better. That means that you need at least two
versions of the same design. Also note that you need to make as few changes as possible in each version,
ideally one tweak per version.

Design Validation Through Stakeholder Interviews

So far, we've been talking about validating designs from the perspective of the users. However, there's
another layer to validation that isn't as talked about: stakeholder interviews. In a nutshell, stakeholders are all
people who have an impact on the product you're designing, i.e. marketers, executives, salespeople,
developers, governments, etc., etc. The kind of stakeholders you'll be dealing with will vary depending on the
product.

That said, stakeholders are going to be the ones who give the ultimate approval, not users. As such, to save
yourself the headache of redoing and burning deadlines, you'll need to consult quite a few people. Long story
short, the stakeholder interview algorithm looks as follows:

If you wanna learn more, we have a full article on stakeholder interviews that also features a template you
could use.

Outro
Validating your design is not an easy task. However, we hope that it’s now a tad easier for you. Make sure to
81 combine users’ feedback and user-generated analytics and you should nail your design.
Shares

https://adamfard.com/blog/design-validation 8/11
11/30/22, 4:23 PM Design Validation: How Do You Know if Your Design is Good

Free Checklist

Design Validation
Checklist
Download our checklist on
design validation to make
sure your decisions are well-
informed and have research
to back them up:

Download Free
Checklist

FAQ

What is design validation and verification?

How do you validate product design?

How do you validate usability of design?

Don't forget to share this post:

Related Stories

81
Shares UX Design 2622 views Startups 1372 views

https://adamfard.com/blog/design-validation 9/11
11/30/22, 4:23 PM Design Validation: How Do You Know if Your Design is Good

The Value of Customer Crafting a Product Vision

Experience (CX) Design Statement: Getting it Right in
In this article, we explore what CX design is, why it 2022
matters, and its relationship to UX.
This is a comprehensive guide to crafting a compelling
product vision statement. We uncover everything you
need to know in 2022.

UX Design 2150 views

UX Expert Review: Everything

you should know
This is everything you need to know about having a UX
expert review. Learn the value it adds to your business
and when to have one done.

Exclusive UX Articles & Strategies

for Startups, UX Designers & Entrepreneurs

Email Address Subscribe

Solutions

Fintech Design

Edtech Design

SaaS Design
81
Shares
UX Consulting

https://adamfard.com/blog/design-validation 10/11
11/30/22, 4:23 PM Design Validation: How Do You Know if Your Design is Good

UX Services

UX Agency

UX Projects

UX Design Process

About Us

Contact Us

Links

Careers hiring

UX Blog

Downloads

Connect with us on

LinkedIn

Youtube

Behance

TikTok

©2022 All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy

81
Shares

https://adamfard.com/blog/design-validation 11/11