You are on page 1of 6

Business and Leadership

Patricia B. Strasser, PhD, RN, COHN-S/CM, FAAOHN

Occupational Health Nurses—The Solution to Absence


Management?
by Myra A. Wallace, RN, MSN, COHN-S

Business and industry are currently focused on increasing employee productivity, understand the root cause of absences
and how best to limit the costs asso-
reducing employee injuries and lost work time, and minimizing costs. Absence
ciated with them. This article focuses
from work due to either injury or health-related leave negatively affects both on why absence occurs, the costs to
direct and indirect costs. Absenteeism, regardless of reason, negatively impacts business, and methods to manage ab-
company profit. To decrease the multiple costs of unplanned absences, the sence while controlling cost, adding
occupational health nurse can collaborate with Human Resources professionals value to the bottom line.
and management to create cost-saving short- and long-term disability programs,
Review of the Literature
manage Family and Medical Leave Act programs, and case manage the care of Very few research articles on ab-
all employees with workers’ compensation claims. sence management were found in the
occupational health literature. Sev-

I
ndustry currently faces many ing health benefits, STD and LTD eral studies used worker or business
challenges, not the least of which programs, and employee attendance. surveys, but these studies may have
is to remain profitable while sus- Safety managers focus on absences been affected by self-report bias. Do
taining a productive, healthy work caused by occupational injuries. Risk the findings really represent the ideas
force. Industries are searching for managers evaluate lost time from li- or behavior of a particular group or
ways to reduce costs and increase ability and workers’ compensation just those who chose to complete the
productivity. Worker absence is at claims perspectives while attempting survey? Were the responses truthful
an all-time high as employers strug- to limit risk, company loss, or expo- and honest, or were they based on
gle to understand the causes of and sure in any given situation. Although fear of retaliation or a possible rep-
solutions to absenteeism. The per- these areas overlap and each depart- rimand? The surveys from different
centages of health-related absences, ment is responsible for some aspect companies were not compared. How-
including sick leave, short-term dis- of absence management, these de- ever, comparison might have given
ability (STD), long-term disabil- partments may not collaborate to en- another prospective to employee in-
ity (LTD), and workers’ compensa- sure that each employee’s absence is sight. In essence, a self-report survey
tion, range from an average low of covered under a particular program, from businesses is voluntary and thus
1.7% to an average high of 6.3% for ultimately affecting the company’s the researchers were unable to con-
all U.S. employers (Denniston & bottom line. Typically, risk and trol for selection bias.
Whelan, 2005). Human Resources safety managers focus on workers’ Williams (2003), a professor of
managers are charged with manag- compensation and Human Resources psychology at the University of Lon-
professionals manage health and dis- don, conducted a literature review
ability benefits, creating “silos” and focused on reducing work-related
About the Author
Ms. Wallace is an occupational health profes- duplication of coverage (Ferguson, psychological ill health and sickness
sional, Wm. Wrigley Jr. Company, LLC, Chatta- 2001). The cost of duplication can be absence. Five studies were reviewed
nooga, TN. detrimental to a business if absences that used stratified, cluster, random-
Dr. Strasser is President, Partners in Business are not managed with open com- ized uncontrolled, observational, and
Health Solutions, Inc., Toledo, OH; and Adjunct munication among all departments. matched control methods. Accord-
Assistant Professor, University of Michigan,
School of Nursing, Occupational Health Nursing
Businesses have recognized the cost ing to Williams, although the studies
Program, Ann Arbor, MI. of absenteeism, but still struggle to covered a wide range of employment

122 AAOHN Journal


business and leadership

sectors in the developed world and ing FMLA is cumbersome and labor Musculoskeletal disorders and stress
used rigorous methods, they demon- intensive. Since 1993, the percentage are the two most common reasons for
strated the association of work factors of workers using FMLA has nearly employee absence (O’Reilly, 2006).
and psychological health, suggesting doubled (National Business Associ- Workers are sometimes offered
a generic approach to improving psy- ation, 2007). This statistic indicates repetitive jobs that may predispose
chological health may be appropri- the need to strategically manage the them to a musculoskeletal disorder.
ate. This approach seems to be an FMLA program. Human Resources Occupational health nurses focus on
assumption by Williams and should managers are challenged by this pro- ergonomics and identifying repeti-
be further investigated to obtain more gram daily. Nona Hodnett, MBA, tive jobs. Although business has tried
reliable results with a more statisti- SPHR, states, “Managing a manufac- to limit these tasks in the workplace,
cally reliable method. turing plant with up to 2500 employ- musculoskeletal disorders are still a
Bartys, Burton, and Main (2005) ees with multiple locations requires common occurrence. Musculoskel-
conducted a cross-sectional survey expertise in all absence management etal disorders represent a significant
of 7,838 employees of multiple fac- programs and FMLA alone requires occupational health problem and cost
tory sites, assessing workers on risk skill with a constant and consistent business and industry projected prof-
factors and absences due to muscu- focus to manage the workforce and its (Bartys et al., 2005). Businesses
loskeletal disorders. Although the absenteeism” (personal communica- could reduce absence rates by focus-
study used a large cross-section of tion, December 2, 2008). ing on this phenomenon and address-
employees, the results could be bi- Workers’ compensation is a gov- ing workplace issues that expose em-
ased or skewed due to only a 50% ernment program that pays for health ployees to repetitive tasks during the
participation rate. care and wages when workers are in- workday.
In 2006, the Tennessee Bureau jured on the job. Workers’ compensa- Stress can cause employees
of Labor Statistics (www.bls.gov/ tion can be a high-cost program with physical and emotional distress,
eag/eag.tn.htm) reported that the substantial financial impact on the leading to absenteeism. Many situ-
state had 108,500 work-related inju- business. Often, the complexity of the ations can cause stress or perceived
ries, and 49 injuries resulted in death. program does not lend itself to effec- stress for an employee. Personal
With work injuries on the rise in Ten- tive management. The occupational situations, finances, poor health, and
nessee, it is increasingly important for health nurse is integral to coordinating job stress are all common causes of
manufacturing to strategically place care for injured or ill workers (Foster, stress that could result in absentee-
occupational health professionals at 2008). Workers’ compensation costs ism. The most common work fac-
the worksite. Occupational health can have a significant impact on direct tors associated with psychological ill
nurses have the expertise to educate and indirect costs that companies in- health were high work demands (long
employees and reduce the number of cur, but may go unnoticed by the nov- hours, workload, and pressure), lack
injuries for all industries. The occu- ice manager. of control over work, and poor sup-
pational health nurse can monitor ab- STD and LTD are leave pro- port from managers (Michie & Wil-
sences from illness, injury, or surgery grams in which benefits and quali- liams, 2003). Employers are down-
and positively impact the cost to the fication requirements vary. Nearly sizing and using a lean work force,
employer, while reducing the number 25% of businesses saw the incidence undoubtedly adding workplace stress
of lost days. of STD rise during 2005–2006 (HR on employees. Industries can con-
Journal, 2005). Most companies of- tract with occupational health nurses
Government and Private fer various benefits individualized to and employee assistance program
Leave Programs their business needs. Employees may staff to identify and address stress
Many government and private- use these programs to cover absences and mental health issues to prevent
sector industrial leave programs en- for a variety of health-related issues. absenteeism.
title employees to leave if they meet Regardless of the program, whether
the qualifications of the particular government or private, absences ulti- Impact of an Aging Work
program. The Family and Medical mately cost the business money either force
Leave Act (FMLA), enacted in 1993, directly or indirectly. Older workers bring a complex
allows 12 weeks of unpaid leave for set of issues to the workplace that
full-time employees who have ac- The Top Two Causes of can be managed. Companies must
cumulated 1,250 hours of paid work Absenteeism address employees’ needs and sup-
time in a rolling calendar year as de- Employees are absent for a va- port them with health programs and
fined by the company. This leave can riety of reasons. Employees may services. The baby boom generation
be used by employees for their own schedule needed surgery or proce- is still a significant part of the manu-
or a family member’s serious health dures with their physicians, have a facturing work force. They bring to
condition or after the birth or adop- family situation requiring attention, the workplace all of the physical ail-
tion of a child. FMLA can be taken or simply choose not to attend work ments associated with aging. Many
in increments or all at once. Manag- for physical or psychological reasons. are faithful employees with years of

MARCH 2009, vol. 57, no. 3 123


business and leadership

Tips for the Occupational Health Nurse cupational health professionals must
strategically manage these costs, re-
gardless of why they were incurred.
• Identify which area of absence (short-term disability, long-term disability, or Implementing policies and proce-
workers’ compensation) to analyze first. dures to administer benefit and leave
• Identify the percentage rate and cost of absence. programs will enable occupational
health professionals and Human
• Implement absence management tactics (i.e., case management).
Resources managers to successfully
• Partner with Human Resources to create a return-to-work (RTW) program. manage these programs.
The occupational health nurse
• Educate local occupational health professionals and other health care
must first decide what area of ab-
providers about the RTW program.
senteeism to target (i.e., STD, LTD,
• Educate employees about the RTW program and the benefits. or workers’ compensation). After
• Evaluate the RTW program, including interventions, strategies, participa- selecting a specific area to be ad-
tion rate, and resources the program saved the company; change the RTW dressed, the absence rate should be
program as needed. determined and brought to the atten-
tion of the Human Resources man-
• Implement the RTW program to reduce absences. ager. How much are these absences
costing the company, and how can
the occupational health nurse posi-
service and an admirable attendance companies address employee needs tively impact this problem? This ap-
record. During the aging process, and then support employees with proach will ensure employee support
employees may develop health-re- benefit and health programs and ser- of an absence management program
lated problems that require absence vices (Sidebar). (Sidebar).
from work. This is a dilemma for
employers as production decreases Direct and Indirect Absence Management
due to these absences and the cost Costs of Absence and Return to Work
of providing benefits increases more Today, industries are struggling Businesses are recognizing the
employees access their health care to reduce the cost of absenteeism value that occupational health nurses
benefits. Older workers may suffer and increase profit and productivity, bring to both employee health and
from chronic conditions that cause while operating in a lean employee company profit. Absence can occur
absences. These employees can be work environment. Employee ab- due to work injuries, personal ac-
a challenge for Human Resources sences cost companies money both cidents, mental health, surgery, or
managers because they may not un- directly and indirectly. Unscheduled acute and chronic diseases. Regard-
derstand disease processes and the employee absenteeism can cost an less of the reason, businesses are
implications for work attendance. average of $755 per employee per recognizing the need to manage ab-
Occupational health profession- year (HR Journal, 2005). sences and return employees to work
als can assess, monitor, and inter- Direct costs are usually easier as soon as possible, thus reducing
vene in employees’ care to ensure to identify and include health care cost and increasing productivity. On
that they have access to specialists costs and indemnity payments. In- any given day, approximately 3.9%
if needed. The challenge of an aging direct costs refer to production time of U.S. employees are absent from
work force calls for innovation in lost by the injured employee, fellow work, and more than half of employ-
health promotion programs, preven- workers, and supervisors; unaccept- ers are unaware of how their absence
tion of work-related and occupation- able product; dissatisfied customers; rate compares with that of their com-
al diseases, reduction in impairments cleaning time (time to clean and pre- petitors (Wassel, 2002).
resulting from diseases, support for pare machinery prior to running the Lost work time impacts em-
disabled workers, and promotion product); schedule delays; training ployee morale as workloads shift
of work ability (Ilmarinen, 2006). new employees; overhead cost (e.g., and added responsibility is given to
Businesses must address the aging electricity and employees’ salaries); workers who are present. Additional
work force and find creative ways legal fees; and increased insurance workload can add stress and poten-
to keep employees healthy, at work, costs (U.S. Department of Labor, tially result in increased numbers
and productive. This goal can be ac- 2004). of work-related injuries and over-
complished by establishing partner- Direct and indirect costs can be time. Absent employees may also
ships among local health care pro- financially devastating to a company be viewed by peers as abusing the
viders, occupational health nurses, if not managed. No longer can a busi- system, causing present employees
and employees. Older workers bring ness view these expenses as the “cost to become disgruntled. Addressing
a complex set of issues to the work- of doing business.” Knowledgeable absences and managing them can al-
place that can be managed only if Human Resources managers and oc- leviate this issue.

124 AAOHN Journal


business and leadership

The key to absence management produce more, while avoiding illness to employee assistance programs,
programs is to educate employees or injury. This work environment can and implementing company-spon-
on what services are available and put employees at risk for repetitive sored exercise programs can address
the process to follow if they need to trauma or other injuries. The nurse personal stress. Occupational stress
be absent. Once the process and the can evaluate additional risks and of- focuses more on how workers per-
managers are in place, employees fer ergonomic suggestions to improve ceive their workplace situation and
become comfortable with the flow, the situation. whether they perceive control over
whether it is a workers’ compensa- Human Resources and safety decision making. Occupational stress
tion injury or personal illness. managers are becoming aware of the can be caused by length and number
Health care costs are equiva- critical business need to employ an of work hours, workload and pres-
lent to 16% of the company’s pay- occupational health professional. The sure, control over work, decision
roll, while the cost of absence pro- health of employees and the health of making, social support, and manage-
grams—incidental absence, STD, employers’ bottom line are connected ment and work style (Michie & Wil-
LTD, and workers’ compensation to- and the occupational health nurse is liams, 2003). Occupational health
gether—equals 4% of payroll (Hall, pivotal in improving and maintaining nurses can address organizational
2007). These percentages are all the the health of both (Haag, Kalina, & stress by offering classes to teach
more reason to have Human Re- Tourigian, 2003). No longer can oc- managers and associates effective
sources managers and occupational cupational health nurses be viewed as coping mechanisms and stress man-
health nurses manage personal as luxuries; they are now an integral and agement tools. Also, nurses can edu-
well as work-related absences. Ab- value-added part of the management cate employers and employees on
sence management includes all lost team because of their health care ex- what causes job stress and how to
time, whether occupational or non- pertise and business savvy. alter the work environment. Effec-
occupational (Lipold, 2003). Ab- tive communication skills could also
sence management programs can in- Occupational Stress decrease organizational stress and
clude workers’ compensation, STD, Occupational health nurses bring improve morale. Evidence exists that
FMLA, or wellness programs that are skills that are value-added to indus- many organizations may be unaware
administered by occupational health tries that are drowning in the cost of of or even reluctant to acknowledge
nurses. Nurses can manage these ab- absenteeism. Occupational stress is the relationship between working
sence programs given their expertise quickly becoming the single great- conditions and employee health and
and clinical skills. In the author’s est cause of occupational disease performance (Noblet & LaMon-
experience, thousands of dollars can and can have far-reaching conse- tagne, 2006). Employers are begin-
be saved by businesses that employ quences for both the worker and the ning to recognize that work-related
occupational health nurses because workplace (Noblet & LaMontagne, stress can impact attendance and pro-
employees are more productive and 2006). Occupational health nurses ductivity. Stress, whether personal or
return to work earlier. Employees have addressed absences related to occupational, must be identified and
are less likely to take an unnecessary personal stress for many years, but addressed. The human and economic
sick day if they know absences are studies are now showing that orga- costs of job stress strongly suggest
managed by an occupational health nizational stress should also be ad- that employees, employers, and the
nurse. Managers must recognize the dressed. Company reorganization, community at large have a stake in
value and expertise of an occupation- downsizing, and lean manufacturing preventing or minimizing workplace
al health nurse and invite the nurse to all have impacted workers and the stress, and stress prevention or reduc-
management meetings. way they perform their jobs. Em- tion initiatives should be high on the
ployees and managers may not have workplace health promotion agenda
The Impact of the coping skills necessary to handle (Noblet & LaMontagne).
Occupational Health the added pressure, which can result
Nurses in psychological illness and absen- Case Study
Occupational health nurses are teeism. Occupational stress contrib- Mrs. Smith, a 50-year-old pro-
specialists and are often certified in utes to a number of outcomes critical duction worker, reported a back
their specialty. Their main focus is to organizational success (Noblet & injury after occasionally lifting 10-
employees, including work injuries, LaMontagne). Occupational or per- pound bags of sugar. She requested
absence management, regulatory sonal stress that is not addressed by to be evaluated by a physician. The
compliance, and health promotion. the worker can ultimately result in certified occupational health nurse
Many adults spend at least 50% of physical and mental illness and ab- offered Mrs. Smith a panel of phy-
their days at the workplace, so it sence from work. sicians from which to choose, a re-
makes business sense to have an Occupational health nurses can quirement of the Tennessee Worker’s
occupational health nurse on staff. address both personal and organi- Compensation program. The nurse
Today’s lean work force requires zational stress with many interven- also immediately began to case man-
employees to do more with less and tions. Counseling, referring workers age Mrs. Smith’s care. Back injuries

MARCH 2009, vol. 57, no. 3 125


business and leadership

I N SUMMA R Y al health nurse in a position that met


her restrictions. The nurse monitored
Occupational Health Nurses her care and ensured that she kept all
therapy and physician appointments,
The Solution to Absence Management? while assisting her with any barriers
Wallace, M. A. that arose. Case management by the
occupational health nurse and close
AAOHN Journal 2009; 57(3), 122-127.
observation of the injured employee
proved to be beneficial to her recov-
1 Occupational health nurses have the education and clinical expertise
to positively impact occupational and non-occupational absenteeism
for today’s industries.
ery.
Mrs. Smith had the herniated
disc repaired and was returned to
work without restrictions after a 6-
2 Occupational health nurses are valuable assets, positively affecting
companies’ bottom lines and increasing productivity.
month period, although the physician
had initially told her a minimum of a
year with restrictions.
3 Companies are operating on lean budgets and require optimum em-
ployee productivity due to decreased staff and increased production
demands.
If the salary for 1 year was
$55,000, then the salary for 6 months
would be $27,500. Thus, savings due
to nurse case management and the
RTW program totaled $27,500. These
can be costly and may lead to surger- Had the occupational health dollars are direct costs and do not in-
ies, employee absence, lost produc- nurse not managed Mrs. Smith’s clude indirect costs (i.e., increased
tivity, and litigation. Workers may care, the surgeon may have refused workers’ compensation insurance
earn less wages, lose mobility or the to allow her to return to work due premiums, employee replacement
ability to work, and endure painful to her restrictions. That approach cost, and lost productivity). The cer-
treatments and procedures. would have resulted in lost wages tified occupational health nurse saved
Mrs. Smith was treated by an or- for the employee because the Ten- the company a minimum of $27,500
thopedic surgeon. Magnetic resonance nessee Worker’s Compensation on one employee through skilled case
imaging was ordered and revealed a program pays workers only 66% of management and oversight of a RTW
herniated L-5 disc in her back. The their wages. If the employee’s sal- program for employees with personal
surgeon concluded that Mrs. Smith ary were $55,000 annually, the Ten- or work-related injuries.
needed surgery and advised that she nessee Worker’s Compensation pro-
have work restrictions now and after gram would pay only $36,426.50. In Conclusion
surgery. Mrs. Smith’s restrictions in- the current stressed economy, many In the lean manufacturing and
cluded not lifting more than 5 pounds, employees depend on 100% of their financially driven business world,
not bending, and not pushing or pull- salary to meet their financial obliga- emphasis is on reducing costs, man-
ing more than 5 pounds. The occu- tions; two thirds is not sufficient. aging absenteeism, and increasing
pational health nurse informed man- The employer benefits because productivity and profit margins. The
agement that these restrictions would employees can be productive in a occupational health nurse can be a
not allow Mrs. Smith to perform her job that honors their restrictions. A valued part of the management team
regular duties. The physician advised non-productive employee at home with expertise necessary to be suc-
the nurse that these restrictions would directly costs the company money cessful in this role. “With so much
last at least a year. The occupational (i.e., hiring replacement workers) money at stake, it is clear why em-
health nurse explained to Mrs. Smith and indirectly (i.e., possible compli- ployers have become increasingly
and the surgeon that the company of- cations due to inactivity). Employers focused on containing costs, not just
fered a return-to-work (RTW) pro- also benefit because employees are in their entirety, but also on the im-
gram for those associates who had a usually receptive to RTW programs, pact they have on the competitive ad-
personal or work-related injury. The as they increase morale and demon- vantage, and in how they compare to
RTW program is tailored to the indi- strate that the company cares about other employers in the increasingly
vidual’s restrictions. employee health and well-being. competitive worldwide business en-
RTW programs must have man- Often, RTW programs are a factor vironment” (Denniston & Whelan,
agement support and are often ad- in whether an employee seeks repre- 2005, p. 85).
ministered by Human Resources sentation for a work-related injury, a Occupational health nurses
with the collaboration of a certified costly and time-consuming situation have the expertise to implement
occupational health nurse specialist. for the company. RTW programs, which could result
This is a win-win situation for the Mrs. Smith returned to work in employees returning to work ear-
employer and the employee. with the assistance of the occupation- lier and increasing productivity. To-

126 AAOHN Journal


business and leadership

day, industries are recognizing the through the management of their em- Challenges for occupational health. Re-
trieved July 6, 2006, from www.occmed.
value of occupational health nurses. ployees’ health and the company’s oxfordjournals.org
Although Human Resources manag- absence programs. Lipold, A. G. (2003, April 9). Why your com-
ers manage employee benefit costs petitors are turning to absence manage-
and safety managers focus on injury References ment. Business and Health.
costs, neither can easily read physi- Bartys, S., Burton, K., & Main, C. (2005). A Michie, S., & Williams, S. (2003). Reducing
perspective study of psychosocial risk fac- work related psychological ill health and
cians’ progress notes or understand sickness absence: A systemic literature
tors and absence due to MSD: Implications
health-related implications of a par- for occupational health screening. Occu- review. Occupational and Environmental
ticular diagnosis. Millions of dol- pational Medicine, 50, 375-379. Medicine, 60, 3-9.
lars can be saved by companies that Denniston, P., & Whelan, P. (2005). Bench- Morris, J. (2008, May). Integrated absence
marking medical absence: Measuring the management and the Family Medical
employ certified occupational health Leave Act. Retrieved July 3, 2008, from
impact of occupational health nursing. Re-
nurses to manage absences, the as- trieved June 15, 2008, from www.aaohn. www.aaohn.org
sociated costs, and RTW programs. org National Business Association. (2007). Survey
In one year alone, an occupational Ferguson, T. (2001). Human resource planning: says: Intermittent leave creates challenges
health nurse can save a company The case for absence management and in- for FMLA management. Retrieved June
tegrated benefits. Retrieved June 12, 2008, 15, 2008, from www.kronos.com/about/
considerably more than the nurse’s pr_survey_sayssept24.htm
from www.humanresourceplanning.org
salary and benefits. Foster, D. (2008). Occupational health nurse Noblet, A., & LaMontagne, A. (2006). The
Managing absenteeism pres- practitioners’ roles in workers’ compensa- role of workplace health promotion in ad-
ents an opportunity for occupational tion. Retrieved June 28, 2008, from www. dressing job stress. Health Promotion In-
aaohn.org ternational, 21(4), 346-353.
health nurses to demonstrate their O’Reilly, S. (2006). How occupational health
Haag, A., Kalina, C., & Tourigian, R. (2003).
value and contribute to their employ- Short term disability, long term disability, can attend to absence. Retrieved June 30,
er’s bottom line (Morris, 2008). In Social Security disability insurance, and 2008, from www.ohj.org
today’s economy, businesses must Family Medical Leave Act: Relationship to U.S. Department of Labor. (2004). Safety
take advantage of the nurses’ role to case management practice. Retrieved June pays. Retrieved July 1, 2008, from www.
10, 2008, from www.aaohn.org osha.gov
remain competitive in a lean mar- Wassel, M. (2002). Improving return to work
Hall, R. (2007). Absenteeism: Measure cost,
ketplace, boost bottom-line profits, adjust incentives, and change behaviors. outcomes. Retrieved July 8, 2008, from
and increase productivity. The oc- Retrieved June 29, 2008, from www.shrm. www.aaohn.org
cupational health nurse’s position is org Williams, M. (2003). Reducing work related
HR Journal. (2005). A healthy bottom line. psychological ill health and sickness
a strategic investment for businesses absence: A systemic literature review.
Retrieved June 20, 2008, from www.shrm.
wanting to increase productivity org Retrieved July 10, 2008, from www.
and become financially successful Ilmarinen, J. (2006). The aging workforce: occenvmed.org

CE Answers
March 2008

Addressing Environmental Health Implications of Mold


Exposure After Major Flooding

1. D 6. B
2. C 7. D
3. A 8. A
4. B 9. C
5. C 10. D

MARCH 2009, vol. 57, no. 3 127

You might also like