Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Geochemistry and Petrology of Selected Coal Sample
Geochemistry and Petrology of Selected Coal Sample
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Indonesia has become the world's largest exporter of thermal coal and is a major supplier to the Asian coal
Received 31 January 2008 market, particularly as the People's Republic of China is now (2007) and perhaps may remain a net importer
Received in revised form 31 July 2008 of coal. Indonesia has had a long history of coal production, mainly in Sumatra and Kalimantan, but only in
Accepted 1 August 2008
the last two decades have government and commercial forces resulted in a remarkable coal boom. A recent
Available online 7 August 2008
assessment of Indonesian coal-bed methane (CBM) potential has motivated active CBM exploration. Most of
Keywords:
the coal is Paleogene and Neogene, low to moderate rank and has low ash yield and sulfur (generally b 10 and
Indonesia b 1 wt.%, respectively). Active tectonic and igneous activity has resulted in significant rank increase in some
Coal coal basins. Eight coal samples are described that represent the major export and/or resource potential of
Geochemistry Sumatra, Kalimantan, Sulawesi, and Papua. Detailed geochemistry, including proximate and ultimate
Organic petrology analysis, sulfur forms, and major, minor, and trace element determinations are presented. Organic petrology
Paleogene and vitrinite reflectance data reflect various precursor flora assemblages and rank variations, including
Neogene sample composites from active igneous and tectonic areas. A comparison of Hazardous Air Pollutants (HAPs)
elements abundance with world and US averages show that the Indonesian coals have low combustion
pollution potential.
Published by Elsevier B.V.
Fig. 1. A. Map showing the location of the Indonesian archipelago and the 8 coal samples. B. Map showing the generalized location of coal-bearing sequences in Indonesia. Adapted
from Friederich et al. (1999).
2005, Indonesia exported 93 Mt (Setiawan, 2006) from a total bituminous — 27%; bituminous — 14%; and anthracite — b0.5% (U.S.
production of 134 Mt. Indonesia has grown from the position in 1992 Embassy Jakarta, 2000). Most of the coal mined for export has calorific
of sixth largest exporter of thermal coal (Sherer, 1994). In 2007, China values that range from 5000 to 7000 kcal/kg, with low ash yield and
became a net coal importer and Indonesia became the world's largest sulfur (United States Embassy Jakarta, 2000). Low grade coals are
thermal coal exporter and dominates the Asian market. The Indonesian characterized by high moisture contents (20 to 40%) and a calorific
export is primarily to Japan and Taiwan, with lesser but increasing value of less than 5000 kcal/kg; these coals are currently considered
amounts to South Korea, the Philippines, India and China. The number of uneconomic for export due to the high moisture content. Kalimantan
coal terminals is now 17, with a capacity between 5000 and 200,000 has higher quality coal and is the site for much exploration and
DWT (deadweight tonnes) with plans for increasing access and shipping development, although other areas such as Papua, with pressing
potential as coal export increases. energy needs, are also being explored and developed.
This paper provides geochemical and petrographic data from a Early Paleogene rifting along the margins of Sundaland, a back-arc
selected group of Indonesian coal samples covering a range of coal setting of the Indian Ocean Plate (Kusnama et al., 1993; Cole and
types, localities, and ages, collected for the USGS WoCQI program Crittenden, 1997), produced various shallow basins. Initial fluviatile
(Tewalt et al., 2005). sequences were followed by coastal plain and/or lacustrine deposits
depending on location. The lithologies that were deposited, probably
2. Study area starting in the Early Eocene, include carbonates, clastics and coal. Coal
sequences of Eocene age are known in the following basins: Barito
2.1. Geological setting (Central Kalimantan), Pasir and Asam Asam (South and East
Kalimantan), Upper Kutai [also spelled Kutei] (East and Central
Most of the coal deposits are geologically young (Cenozoic) and this Kalimantan), Melawi and Ketungau (West Kalimantan), Tarakan
is reflected in the rank distribution of the resources: lignite — 58%; sub- (East Kalimantan), Ombilin (West Sumatera), and the Central Sumatra
262 H.E. Belkin et al. / International Journal of Coal Geology 77 (2009) 260–268
Basin (Riau), together with generally thin coal seams in other small basin is one of the most important coal mining regions in Indonesia
basins in Java and South Sulawesi. (Thomas, 2005). This basin is tectonically active and the coal in some
Marine transgression and deposition ended the Early Paleogene parts has been affected by igneous activity. The basin formed in the
rifting and associated coal-forming environment. After this extensive Early Paleogene as a back-arc basin northeast of the Barisan
transgression, uplift and compression led to basin formation by the Mountains. The Oligocene to middle Miocene Gumai Formation is
Middle Miocene. Miocene (and perhaps younger) coal-bearing composed of fossiliferous marine shale with thin, glauconitic lime-
sequences are being mined from the Kutai [also spelled Kutei] Basin stone that represents a rapid, widespread maximum transgression.
(Kalimantan), Barito Basin (Central Kalimantan), South Sumatra Basin The middle Miocene Air Benakat Formation was deposited during the
(South Sumatra), Bengkulu Basin (Bengkulu), and the Tarakan Basin regression that ended deposition of the Gumai Shale. The Air Benakat
(East Kalimantan). The Miocene coal is exceptionally low in mineral Formation changes upward from deep marine to shallow marine
matter and sulfur, and is low in rank unless affected by igneous activity. conditions. Marine glauconitic clays decrease in frequency and marine
The environment of formation is thought to represent ombrogenous sands increase. The formation ranges from 1000 to 1500-m thick. Coal
peat formed above the water table that produced coals free from the beds mark the upper contact with the overlying Muara Enim
influence of water-borne detritus and sulfur input from brackish Formation. The Late Miocene to Pliocene Muara Enim Formation,
waters, similar to modern ombrogenous peat deposits elsewhere in also known as the Middle Palembang Formation, was deposited as
Indonesia (e.g., Cobb and Cecil, 1993; Esterle and Ferm, 1994). shallow marine to continental sands, muds, and coals. The formation
The Paleogene and Neogene export coals are markedly low in thins to the north from a maximum of 750 m in the south. Uplift of the
mineral matter and sulfur. Details of their petrogenesis have been Barisan Mountains provided source terrains for clastics from the south
extensively studied in order to understand the environment of and southwest during deposition of the Muara Enim Formation
formation that led to these characteristics (Cobb and Cecil, 1993). (Bishop, 2000). The Muara Enim Formation is the main coal-bearing
For more detailed discussion of the local geologic setting, the reader is unit being mined (cf. Susilawati and Ward, 2006). The studied coal is a
referred to Friederich et al. (1999) and Soehandojo (1989) and run-of-mine composite sample of the Mangas seam from the Air Laya
references therein. The majority of coal currently mined in Indonesia pit; Susilawati and Ward (2006) discuss the details the coal seams of
is derived from Eocene and Miocene strata on two islands, Sumatra the Muara Enim Formation.
and Kalimantan. Cenozoic coal-bearing sequences also exist in Java
and Sulawesi, and Neogene (Steenkool Formation) and Permian coal 2.2.3. Sample CQ03 — South Sumatra Province (Sumatera Selatan), 2°
occurs in Papua (Fig. 1B). 25′ S, 103° 15′ E
An exploration site of Kota Tengah has sampled coal of Miocene to
2.2. Sample descriptions Pliocene age. The exploration site is in the South Sumatra Basin, and
the geological description is the same as for sample CQ02. The studied
The run-of-mine or representative exploration-site samples (~ 1 kg coal was a sample of a seam tentatively identified as the Mangas seam.
each) described in this report were collected in 2000 by Hadiyanto,
now Director of Mineral Resources Inventory, Directorate of Mineral 2.2.4. Sample CQ04 — Central Kalimantan Province (Kalimantan Tengah),
Resources Inventory, Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, 1° 20′ S. 115° 10′ E
Directorate General of Geology and Mineral Resources, Bandung, The Kandui village exploration site is located in Central Kalimantan
Indonesia. For the sample locations, we have used the most recent Province in the North Barito district, Gunung Timang subdistrict,
Indonesian province designations; seven provinces were created since which has large reserves of high-quality Miocene age coal. The studied
2000 and, where appropriate, we also give the former province name. coal represents a composite sample from the exploration site.
Fig. 1A indicates the sample locations.
2.2.5. Sample CQ05 — East Kalimantan Province (Kalimantan Timur), 0°
2.2.1. Sample CQ01 — West Sumatra Province (Sumatera Barat) 0° 40′ S, 27′ N, 117° 35′ E
100° 45′ E The Kaltim Prima coal mine, operated by Kaltim Prima Coal PT
The Ombilin Basin, a small (20 × 60-km) Paleogene onshore basin, (KPC), is the largest Indonesian coal mine. It is owned by an
is located just west of the much larger Central Sumatra Basin. It Indonesian Company, PT Bumi Resources, who bought out British
contains thick Eocene to Miocene marine and terrestrial sediments Petroleum (BP) and Rio Tinto coal mining interests in 2003. This
that share a similar tectonic and stratigraphic history which is similar operation in Sangatta (also spelled Sangata), East Kalimantan, has
to all of the rift basins on Sumatra. The economic coal occurs within produced Miocene age thermal coal since operations were initiated in
the Eocene Sawahlunto Formation which is composed of gray 1991. Plans for expansion to the nearby Bengalon area were
mudstone and siltstone and coal seams with minor quartz-rich announced in 2004 (Mining-Technology.com, 2006). A total of 13
sandstone (Friederich et al., 1999). Three coals seams, locally up to 8-m seams range in thickness from 1 to 15-m; typically in the range of 2.4
thick, occur in the upper part of the Sawahlunto Formation and are the to 6.5-m. Seam dips vary from 3° to 20° at the outcrop. The coal occurs
main units mined. in the Balikpapan and Pulubalang Formations, and the three main coal
The Ombilin mine, located 57-km northeast of Padang, West seams are called Kedapat, Pinang, and Sangatta (Soehandojo, 1989).
Sumatra, is owned by state-owned PT Tambang Batubara Bukit Asam The coal is generally low mineral matter and low sulfur, and has a low
(PTBA), and includes both underground and surface operations in-situ moisture content. In some parts, the coal rank has been
mining Eocene age coal. The underground mine uses a longwall increased by igneous intrusion to a high volatile bituminous coal and
retreating system, with semi-mechanized equipment, operated this is what was sampled. As of mid-2004, PT Bumi cited reserves at
manually, and fully mechanized longwall equipment, operated 462 Mt at Sangatta, plus 157 Mt at Bengalon. The company also has
hydraulically. Sample CQ01 is from the open-pit operation and measured and indicated resources of some 2200 million t (Mining-
represents a multiple seam composite at the time of sampling. Technology.com, 2006). The studied coal is a run-of-mine sample of
the Sangatta seam.
2.2.2. Sample CQ02 — South Sumatra Province (Sumatera Selatan) 3° 45′
S, 103° 47′ E 2.2.6. Sample CQ06 — South Kalimantan Province (Kalimantan Selatan),
The state-owned PT Tambang Batubara Bukit Asam (PTBA) 2° 58′ S, 116° 16′ E
currently mines a Miocene age coal deposit at Banko Barat (also The Senakin mine, South Kalimantan, operated by PT Arutmin
spelled Bangko) in the South Sumatra Basin. The South Sumatra coal Indonesia, mines Eocene age coal. This economically important coal
H.E. Belkin et al. / International Journal of Coal Geology 77 (2009) 260–268 263
Table 1
Vitrinite reflectance and maceral content
% total Rmax sd Rr sd Vit Ulm Tex Det Cor Fus Sem Mic Mac Fun Spo Cut Res Suber Clay Sul Carb Qtz
CQ01 0.8 0.04 0.73 0.04 80.2 2.4 1.6 0 0 10.4 0.2 2 0.8 0.4 0.0 2.0 0.0 0.0
CQ02 0.33 0.02 0.3 0.02 61.2 8.2 14.6 0 0 7.2 2.8 3.4 0 0.8 T 1.8 0.0 0.0
CQ03A 49.0 0.4 0.03 0.38 0.04 20 6 17.3 3.3 5.8 5.5 0 0 36.5 1.5 0 1 0 0.0 3.3 0.0 0.0
CQ03B 28.8 0.8 0.05 0.76 0.05 68.8 7.9 9.6 0 0 5 1.3 1.3 3.8 0 0.0 2.5 0.0 0.0
CQ03C 22.2 1.61 0.09 1.53 0.1 95.6 1.1 1.7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 1.7 T 0.0
CQ04 0.42 0.04 0.38 0.04 71.8 2.8 8.6 0 0 11 1 2 1 0 0.0 1.8 0.0 0.0
CQ05 0.52 0.06 0.48 0.06 57.0 8.4 11.2 0 0 15.4 1.6 0.8 2.8 0.6 0.0 2.2 0.0 0.0
CQ06 0.57 0.03 0.51 0.04 77.0 1.2 3.4 0 0 13.4 0.6 1.8 0.8 0 0.0 1.8 0.0 0.0
CQ07 4.94 0.32 4.04 0.38 96.8 2.2 0.8 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 0.2 0.0 0.0
CQ08 0.31 0.04 0.29 0.04 18 9.6 13 9.2 12.2 17.4 0 0 18.6 1.4 0 0.6 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Abbreviations: Rmax = vitrinite maximun reflectance, Rr = vitrinite random reflectance; sd = one sigma standard deviation; Vit = vitrinite; ulm = ulminite; Tex = textinite; Det =
detrohuminite; Cor = corpohuminite; Fus = fusinite; Sem = semifusinite; Mic = micrinite; Mac = macrinite; Fun = funginite; Spo = sporinite; Cut = cutinite; Res = resinite; Suber =
suberinite; Sul = sulfide; Carb = carbonate; Qtz = quartz; T = trace.
occurs near the base of the T2 member of the Tanjung Formation. The New Guinea. This coal is of Permian age and the associated floras have
laterally continuous basal coal unit is up to 9-m thick, but is more Gondwana affinities as described by Rigby (1998). Permian coal in
typically 4 to 6 m (Friederich et al., 1999). The lower part of the Eocene West Papua also has been investigated as source rock for oil and gas
seam is low in sulfur, whereas the upper part has higher sulfur levels (Sutriyono and Hill, 2000). Potential coal production in the Mimika
due to increased pyrite content or subsequent sulfate alteration. The regency containing the Timika site will be important to support the PT
coal bed varies vertically in mineral matter and sulfur content, but this Freeport Indonesia Company and the mining in the Tembagapura
variation is laterally consistent and predictable (Friederich et al., district. In May 2006, PLN (Perusahaan Listrik Negara; Indonesia State
1995). At Senakin (also spelled Senaking), the workings are two Electricity Company) announced an additional coal-fired power
underground operations. The concession area, known as Kalimantan project in Timika with a capacity of 14 MW (United States Embassy
Block 6, covers narrow strips of land in the southeast corner of Jakarta, 2006).
Kalimantan Island plus the northern tip of neighboring Pulau Laut
Island. The studied coal is a sample of the T2 member of the Tanjung 2.2.8. Sample CQ08 — South Sulawesi Province (Sulawesi Selatan), 4° 50′
Formaiton. S, 119° 52′ E
The Malawa exploration locality is situated near the Palae River, a
2.2.7. Sample CQ07 — Papua Province (formerly Irian Jaya), 4° 42′ S, 136° tributary of the Batuputih, near the village of Telampenua, South
55′ E Sulawesi. The geology consists of mainly sandstones, slates, marls, and
The Timika coal sample is from an exploration site along the some greywackes. Intercalated with these rocks are layers or lenses of
southern or Australasian Plate side of the main suture zone in western coal, some of which are up to 1.5-m thick. Together these form the
Fig. 2. Reflected-light photomicrographs. A. Sample CQ01, B. Sample CQ01, C. Sample CQ02, D. Sample CQ03.
264 H.E. Belkin et al. / International Journal of Coal Geology 77 (2009) 260–268
Malawa Formation of Eocene age. The Malawa Formation overlies 4.1.1. Sumatra
unconformably the Balangbura Formation of Cretaceous age, and is CQ01 is a high volatile A bituminous coal (Rmax = 0.8) with abundant
itself overlain conformably by the limestone of the Tonasa Formation vitrinite and a significant proportion of funginite (Fig. 2A). Liptinite
(Radja, 1970). These formations are part of an early Paleogene rift occurs in a variety of forms, including faint suberinite (Fig. 2B).
basin that extends offshore of South Sulawesi and has been the target CQ02 is a sub-bituminous coal (Rmax = 0.33) with a relatively large
of oil and gas exploration (Cucci et al., 1994). The studied sample is proportion of inertinite macerals. The inertinite is dominated by
from the Malawa Formation. fusinite + semifusinite, but also includes 7.2% funginite (mineral-
included basis) (Fig. 2C).
3. Methodology As noted above, CQ03 is actually a blend of three ranks of coal
(Rmax = 0.4, 0.8, and 1.61), with nearly half of the total sample being
Proximate and ultimate analyses and determination of sulfur forms coal of sub-bituminous rank (Table 1). This led to an earlier report
were carried out by Geochemical Testing, Somerset, PA following ASTM describing a high volatile C bituminous rank (Belkin and Tewalt,
standard procedures. Major, minor, and trace element analyses were done 2007). The sub-bituminous component of the blend is notable in
at the U.S. Geological Survey, Denver, Colorado using standard techniques having over 36% funginite (mineral-included basis) (Fig. 2D).
describe by Bullock et al. (2002) and by Activation Laboratories, Ancaster, Fungal forms present in all three Sumatran coals include both
Ontario, Canada. Petrographic studies were conducted on polished resin- spores and sclerotia. Forms seen are similar to those reported by Grady
bound particulate pellets using Leitz microscopes, with reflected-light, oil- et al. (1993) from two cores of peat deposits in Sumatra. Fig. 2 shows
immersion techniques and a final magnification of 400–625×, at the two different types of sclerotium. Both are similar in overall size, but
Center for Applied Energy Research, Lexington, KY. Reconnaissance the left is characterized by more, smaller cells that appear almost
scanning electron microscope–energy dispersive analysis (SEM–EDS) geometric and have an overall near circular outline, while the right is
and electron microprobe analysis (EMPA) were conducted in the U.S. characterized by fewer, larger cells that appear rounded and give the
Geological Survey, Reston, Virginia using a JEOL JXA-8900 SuperProbe. sclerotium an irregular outline. Spores are not recognizable due to
their small size and the difficulty in identifying diagnostic features in
4. Results and discussion reflected-light examination.
Fig. 3. Reflected-light photomicrographs. A. Sample CQ04, B. Sample CQ04, C. Sample CQ05, D. Sample CQ06.
H.E. Belkin et al. / International Journal of Coal Geology 77 (2009) 260–268 265
cutinite, and resinite, the liptinite assemblages contain suberinite different from previous sclerotia although it is somewhat similar to
(Fig. 3D). the right-most one in Fig. 2A.
Fungal remains were identified from a Kalimantan Tengah peat by
Moore et al. (1996). That study looked at both palynologic prepara- 4.2. Mineralogy
tions using transmitted light and polished blocks and pellets using
reflected light. While the specific fungal types were not named, they Reconnaissance mineralogy studies using a separate set of polished
include spores, individual hyphae, and sclerotia. All three types are pellets were conducted with SEM–EDS to characterize the major
visible in the Kalimantan coals examined in the present study. Some inorganic phases; WDS electron microprobe analysis of the sulfides
differences occur in the spores and sclerotia seen in the three was also carried out. Based on texture and composition, the following
Kalimantan samples. Figs. 3A and 4A show two different varieties of phases were identified: detrital = TiO2 polymorph, quartz, albite,
“large” fungal sclerotia. That in Fig. 3A probably represents a true plagioclase, ilmenite, K-feldspar, monazite, zircon, barite, and some
sclerotium, while those in Fig. 4A may be immature fruiting bodies clay and pyrite; authigenic, epigenetic and/or cleat = pyrite, chalcopyr-
similar to those of Phomites sp. (Kalgutkar and Jansonius, 2000). ite, carbonates, quartz, clay, sulfates, oxyhydroxides, and phosphates.
Fig. 3C shows a “small” sclerotium in the upper left of the image. Pyrite framboids filled by later pyrite were observed in samples CQ03,
Immediately right of this is a thick-walled dicellate spore that has CQ05, CQ06, and CQ07. EMPA analysis shows that most pyrite of any
some detail of the juncture between the two cells visible in the right- texture is stoichiometric, with As and Se contents at or below
most cell. Fig. 4A appears to contain (left side of the image) a five- detection limits of 200 ppm. As-bearing pyrite (As = ~2000 ppm) was
celled variety of Multicellaesporites similar to M. grandiusculus observed as framboid fillings and overgrowths in samples CQ06 and
(Kalgutkar and Jansonius, 2000). Other spores visible in the photo- CQ07. The general paucity of inorganic material in these coals is
micrographs are not easily identifiable to genera owing to small compatible with their low ash yield.
sizes and difficulty recognizing distinguishing features in polished
specimens. 4.3. Geochemistry
Fig. 4. Reflected-light photomicrographs. A. Sample CQ06, B. Sample CQ07, C. Sample CQ08, D. Sample CQ08.
266 H.E. Belkin et al. / International Journal of Coal Geology 77 (2009) 260–268
Table 2
Proximate, ultimate analysis, and calorific value of Indonesia coals
Total moisture Residual moisture Air dry loss Ash Volatile matter Total carbon Hydrogen Nitrogen Calorific value
CQ01 3.10 1.05 2.07 7.33 42.84 73.16 5.41 1.35 7340
CQ02 18.02 6.40 12.41 9.68 39.93 50.69 3.74 0.77 4780
CQ03⁎ 9.68 2.42 7.44 10.05 40.99 62.37 5.02 0.96 6290
CQ04 26.49 7.36 20.65 5.38 33.03 48.38 3.42 0.94 4610
CQ05 19.36 3.39 16.53 4.33 34.99 57.47 4.10 1.31 5580
CQ06 5.29 1.63 3.72 12.63 42.58 63.69 5.33 1.10 6490
CQ07 5.23 1.16 4.12 3.54 7.48 84.28 2.07 0.84 7500
CQ08 48.27 10.68 42.09 2.99 25.42 34.87 2.56 0.52 3280
represented by Neogene coals of higher rank, are likely to be affected usual organic affinities, such as Be, also tend to be in low abundance.
by tectonic and igneous activity. The South Sumatra basin, a region Inspection of all the trace element data in Table 4 and comparisons
with shallow Neogene coals, has Plio-Pleistocene igneous activity in shown in Table 5 reflect well on the desirability of these coals for
some areas. Thermal metamorphism associated with this activity has, power plant use.
in some areas, increased the coal rank from sub-bituminous to
bituminous and anthracite (Susilawati and Ward, 2006). Sample CQ01, 5. Coal-bed methane prospective
a high volatile bituminous coal from Ombilin, is from a small basin in a
tectonically active area in West Sumatra. Some Ombilin coal has been Although the coal from Indonesia tends to be shallow and low rank,
affected by local andesite intrusions and the proximity of the conventional oil and gas wells that drill though the coal seams tend to
intrusions has increased the coal rank up to anthracite (Darman and experience blow outs and log gas spikes; both of these features are
Sidi, 2000). Sample CQ02, from Banko, has been affected by this good indicators for coalbed methane (CBM). A recent assessment of the
metamorphism and is now a high volatile bituminous coal. Sample potential CBM resources in Indonesia identified 12.7 trillion m3 (450
CQ03, also from the Kota Tengah exploration area in the South Tcf) within eleven onshore basins (Stevens and Hadiyanto, 2004). More
Sumatra Basin, is a run-of-mine composite of three coals of different detailed analysis of coal rank, geochemistry, and geology in Indonesia
ranks. Local igneous activity has produced a significant gradient in has led to an increased estimate of Indonesian CBM potential (Nugroho
rank at this exploration site. and Arsegianto, 1993; Stevens et al., 2001; Stevens and Hadiyanto,
2004). Stevens and Hadiyanto (2004) ranked six basins with high CBM
4.3.1. Trace element geochemistry potential; South Sumatra Basin, Central Sumatra Basin, Barito Basin,
Minor and trace element geochemistry of coal is extremely Kutei Basin, Berau Basin, and North Tarakan Basin. They recommended
important to assess and model coal combustion and the potential testing, using in-country mining rigs to drill expendable core holes, for
for pollution. A search of the literature in preparation for this paper coal seam gas measurement content and permeability followed by
yielded no trace element determinations of Indonesian coals available production pilot wells. The government of Indonesia is moving rapidly
in the public domain, although meeting talks featuring such data may to settle the regulations and terms for CBM production, as the demand
have been given (Sappel and Hariyanto, 2004). Table 4 provides data for clean energy in Indonesia continues to grow. Accurate coal char-
on 34 minor and trace elements. The generally low abundance of these acterization is critical and necessary to support CBM research and
elements is compatible with the low ash yields. development.
The 1990 Amendments (United States Public Law, 1990) to the 1970
Clean Air Act name 189 substances as Hazardous Air Pollutants 6. Conclusions and the future of Indonesian coal
(HAPS), including 14 elements or their compounds found in coal in
trace concentrations. Table 5 shows a comparison of the HAPs element The Indonesian coals studied in this report are representative of
abundance in the studied Indonesian coals compared to the world the current steam-coal export by Indonesia. Exploration samples
range and U.S. coal average (Swaine, 1990; Finkelman, 1993). The indicate that future production for export will be coals of low ash yield
abundance of all elements in the eight Indonesian coal samples is in and low sulfur. Coal-fired power plants concerned about HAPS
the lower part of the world range. This is especially noticeable for element emission can use Indonesian coal as its low mineral matter
those elements with inorganic affinity that are usually related to the content yields low hazardous element concentration at moderate
ash yield, such as Cd and Sb. In addition, those HAPS elements with calorific value. The calorific value of the studied samples ranged from
Table 3
Sulfur forms and major oxides for selected Indonesia coals
Ash S S(sulf) S(py) S(org) SiO2 Al2O3 CaO MgO Na2O K2O ⁎Fe2O3 TiO2 P2O5 SO3
CQ01 7.9 7.70 0.53 0.01 0.05 0.47 44.7 30.1 0.73 0.85 0.48 2.0 5.7 0.96 0.03 1.0
CQ02 6.6 11.2 0.29 0.01 0.01 0.27 41.6 19.5 8.7 1.8 5.6 0.76 2.6 0.79 0.17 4.0
CQ03⁎ 2.3 11.5 2.45 0.10 0.85 1.50 31.7 21.0 9.1 1.4 0.2 0.46 17.4 0.84 b0.02 11.1
CQ04 7.1 7.20 1.36 0.24 0.06 1.06 30.4 12.5 10.6 3.1 0.4 0.35 17.3 0.78 0.19 17.4
CQ05 2.9 5.30 0.46 0.03 0.02 0.41 41.8 23.7 3.1 2.5 2.3 1.9 6.0 0.81 1.6 7.3
CQ06 0.6 13.6 0.83 0.02 0.17 0.64 44.9 37.7 0.94 0.38 0.38 0.25 2.9 2.0 0.04 1.4
CQ07 1.1 4.00 0.65 0.01 0.07 0.57 45.3 13.3 3.5 2.4 0.53 0.67 19.7 0.36 0.14 7.4
CQ08 9.6 5.30 0.28 0.02 0.01 0.25 33.0 7.80 17.2 6.6 0.23 0.31 20.3 0.51 b0.02 9.5
Sulfur forms are reported on a whole coal, dry basis and major oxides on an ash basis. Major oxides values are in percent. Ash determined at 525 °C. Abbreviations: S = sulfur; (sulf) =
sulfate; (py) = pyritic; (org) = organic; As. det. moist. = as-determined moisture.
⁎Fe2O3 = total iron. b = below detection limit at that value.
CQ03⁎ = a run-of-mine composite of three coals of different rank.
H.E. Belkin et al. / International Journal of Coal Geology 77 (2009) 260–268 267
Table 4
Minor and trace element content of selected Indonesia coals
Minor and trace elements on a dry, whole coal basis and are in ppm except Cl, Cl = wt.%.. Abbreviation: b = below detection limit at that value.
CQ03⁎ = a run-of-mine composite of three coals of different rank.
sub-bituminous to high volatile A and C bituminous coal; anthracite has plans to increase power production through coal-fired plants), (3)
occurred in Permian coals in Papua Province. The rank of some with the high petroleum prices increasing coal demand, especially in
Neogene coal has been increased by tectonic and/or igneous activity Asia, Indonesia is well suited geographically to supply the Asia-Pacific
and the distribution of this enhanced-rank coal is complex and varies region, and (4) at present, Indonesia is economically and politically
at any particular mine location. stable. In Indonesia, growth in coal production will also be driven by an
Indonesian coal export and production is expected to steadily expansion of supply to the domestic sector for the power industry,
increase for the following reasons: (1) the coal is environmentally cement plants, and the pulp industry. While falling in most regions,
friendly (low mineral matter and low sulfur), (2) the emerging domestic coal's contribution to the fuel mix is expected to rise significantly in the
and international market for coal (Indonesia has an energy shortage and ASEAN (Association of South East Asian Nations, comprising Brunei,
Cambodia, Indonesia, Lao People's Democratic Republic, Myanmar,
Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Viet Nam) region. The
shift to coal-fired generation in the ASEAN region — particularly in
Table 5 Malaysia and Thailand — is driven by the development of independent
Hazardous air pollutants (HAPS) elements comparison power projects and energy security considerations that are leading to a
Element World coala U.S. Coalb 8 Indonesia samples shift from lignite and oil to sub-bituminous and/or bituminous coal-
fired generation and, to a lesser extent, natural gas in the fuel mix
Range (ppm) Mean (ppm) Mean (ppm) Range (ppm)
(Ekawan et al., 2006). The abundant Indonesian lignite (calorific
Sb 0.05–10 1.2 0.29 0.06–0.79
As 0.5–80 24 3.6 0.4–11 value b 5000 kcal/kg) is currently uneconomic, although the Indonesian
Be 0.1–15 2.2 0.54 0.13–1.5 Government is developing plans to utilize lignite for (1) mine-mouth
Cd 0.1–3 0.47 0.02 0.01–0.04 power plants, (2) upgrading to higher energy values, and (3) coal
Cl 50–2000 614 260 b150–300 briquettes (Umar et al., 2005). This scenario of increased production,
Cr 0.5–60 15 7.4 1.1–24.9
domestic use, and export of Indonesian coal will require more detailed
Co 0.5–30 6.1 3.6 1.2–9.2
Pb 2–80 11 3 0.4–10 coal geochemistry and petrography to adequately characterize the
Mn 5–300 43 88 3.6–246 current mines and future exploration seams.
Hg 0.02–1 0.17 0.10 0.02–0.19
Ni 0.5–50 14 7.3 0.8–16
Acknowledgements
Se 0.2–1.4 2.8 0.64 0.24–1.4
Tl b 0.2–1 1.2 0.12 0.01–0.49
U 0.5–10 2.1 0.49 0.19–1.2 We gratefully acknowledge the very helpful and constructive
Arithmetic means all values are as-determined on air-dried or oven-dried whole coal.
comments of Colin R. Ward (Sydney), Paul C. Hackley (Reston), and
a
Swaine (1990) Table 6.1. Frank T. Dulong (Reston). We thank Sandra G. Neuzil (Reston) for
b
Finkelman (1993) Table 1. reviewing an earlier version of this report.
268 H.E. Belkin et al. / International Journal of Coal Geology 77 (2009) 260–268