Manuscript ID: | PJMD-ZU-

Title: | Root Resorption Patterns Of Primary Mandibular Molars And Location

Of Premolar Successors Through Radiographs

Article Category: | Original Research

Name and Affiliation of the Reviewer:

Dr. Imran Alam Moheet
Baqai Dental College

MANUSCRIPT REVIEW
SCOPE Agree or Explanations of
Disagree Disagreement
 Is the article in line with the aims and
scope of the journal? Agree
TITLE
 Appropriate for the manuscript Agree
 Reflective of the content in the
article
ABSTRACT
 Structured with 4 headings:
Background, Methods, Results, Agree
conclusion
 Minimum of 250 words for Original Agree
Article and 150 words for others
 Relevant information presented Agree
KEYWORDS
 Minimum 3 and maximum 10 Agree

ISSUES
 Conflict of Interest Agree
 Ethical Issues
INTRODUCTION
 Comprehensively introduces the
research and the topic Agree
 Rationale and objective highlighted Agree
 Appropriate references cited Agree
METHODOLOGY
 Explicitly states setting and type of
study. Agree
 Criteria for inclusion & exclusion Agree
depicted
 Was the sampling appropriate
Agree
  The method of data collection is
explained Agree
 Statistical analysis employed
mentioned and justified
RESULTS

 Fulfills the objectives and explain Agree

research discovery
 Comprehensive data reflecting Agree
research and analysis is provided
with logical sequence
 Appropriate statistical analysis has Agree
been conducted
DISCUSSION
 Linked to appropriate literature Agree
 Does the article support or Agree
contradict previous theories
CONCLUSION
 Match the research objectives and Agree
answer the research question
 How research has moved the body of Agree
scientific knowledge forward
REFERENCES
 Vancouver Style employed with Agree
complete citations
 Recent five year sources. Disagree Old and new
references are used
Tables, Figures, Images:
 Are they appropriate? Agree
 Do they properly show the data?
 Are they easy to interpret and Agree
understand
ORIGINALITY
Requirements:
 Should be novel and new
 Work should not be published
anywhere else
 Work should not be redundant or Agree
explored in detail previously
 Support for literature, especially
local to the region
PRESENTATION QUALITY
 Cohesiveness of Manuscript and
readability Agre
 Appropriateness of language, e
grammar, diagrams
Is this research original?
Does this (PAPER) contribute to the field of TOPIC described:
Recommendations

Accept without revision:

I recommend minor modifications:

I recommend moderate modifications: Agree

I recommend major modifications:

Reject (reason):

Submit to another publication (specify):

Additional comments (Including comments/suggestions for improvement, if any):