Feedback for Initial Presentation - 7 May 2021

Feedback Feedback Feedback Feedback Feedback Feedback

Group Selected Topic Product
Pak Oliver Pak Benjamin Pak Evert Pak Djoko Pak Arifin Bu Ellya
plusses and concerns on the Clear problem definintion. Very nice to even think for extraappreciation for group 1 ... cool how about threshold of pressure
sensor dicission is clear (Oxygen). Strapping gives fine pressure ideas by thinking out of the box.ideas & solutions..there are several and saturated oxygen?
If the child can feel the vibration it distribution, Conclusion: conbine Nice presentation + good steps to help this patient become
Technology for Post- 3D Cast Fixation seems to me the best choice. I like all? I prefer idea 2)Fibration since language. What to do when the normal..one of the important is the
1
Operation Patients (Child) the shoebinding idea. How wil you it is less stigmatizing (short/light boy grows? use of gradual angles in 3d cast
make sure that the user will straps signals will probably not damage fixation to reduce pain due to
the cast fixation sufficiënt each the skin) muscle stiffness ... what solution &
time? ideas do you use for this?
Nice visualisations and research. It Nice prototype of the electronic Good steps for the process, well - Interesting presentations and Have you design output of audio in
was a bit unclear what the device part. Nice 3D models. I prefer Idea taught about it. extra + for ideas from group 2 ... what is the stereo format? I think it will be
will do and how it will work. 3 - the mini tactile plan, easy to Literature research. Nice to see it solution for showing a 3D map on better..About the map design you
Technology for Visual keep it with you. was an Belgian student. What the conditions for marking certain should decide based on scorimg
2 3D Tactile Map
Imparment about the size of the module? And conditions on sidewalks or roads among design alternatives...and
what's the information that you get traversed by blind people for a you should clearly describe about
from touching the bottoms? specific target? simple information in the form of
single braille char.
Nice spiderman design :D. I have Question: is it the user that need to So many difficult words for me :-). wow ... good idea from group 3 ... great idea for using uc imn your
no idea how you will integrate the be alarmed or better the parents? Good to listen to the patient and nice and funny ... the most design, but you should include
Arduino, but would a round pcb Are you using more than one the parents, being such a young important thing about the helmet your system with real-time clock for
one not be more interesting, than a sensor, better using lots of them? child. Good overview on the sildes. craniosynostosis therapy is the measure duration of usage, and
square one. Check for example: better send a message to the Already in testing stage with control of the direction of skull also for schedluing of cleaning,
Adafruit GEMMA M0 parents instad of buzzer? arduino is a positive point. How is growth as expected. there is a part patient treatment, and others.
arduino integrated in the helmet? that holds it & there is a part that is threshold values of pressure....it is
made a hole to direct the growth of crucial in preliminary step..so you
Technology for Post- Craniosynostosis
3 the skull bone. how to keep the should make this data first..
Operation Patients Helmet
patient's head fit and easy to clean
at the same time. To clean, the
inside can be removed for
washing. this will result in the
possibility of loosening with
frequent cleaning. how is the
solution to this. especially for long
term use.
I would try to support the Iphone in Good evolution in different ideas, It's good to use colours in the very interesting idea of group 4 ... it is nice to add motor to set the
some way. It's quite dangerous ending in idea 3 as the best one. design. Two points to keep in the lens used is a portable 20 estimated length using feedback
how it solved now if it falls down on Handle is indeed great idea, in mind. the weight of the device in diopters lens .. put on the front .. information provided by ultrasonic
the ground. Why do we need a idea 3 you did take in to acount totale and also the whole used for how to maintain the center of sensor. Could you please complete
Technology For Eyes handle? Why not using the device point of gravity. You can add a the lenses. Many smartphones gravity. Another thing is how to your preliminary data of sensor
4 Funduscopy
(Funduscopy) by holding in the region of the smartphone cover which is have several cameras. To sad that adjust the distance between the data resolution versus resolution of
Iphone or have the handle attached to your device to avoid the soud was not great, but the lens and the eye on the part that length. Motot would be used in
somewhere in that region? high local pressure on the screen pictures on the slides were good. sticks to the patient's face, where your design is still not clear wheter
(avoid to crush the smart phone your design only sticks to one DC motor or stepper?
glass). point.
I like the broad scope of The programmed grip modes Nice background check on the greetings to ultraman ...one of the it is great if you detect muscle It's a great presentation. I wonder
possibilities/ideas. I think an activated by a button, in different numbers ! Good slides. it's most important is the ease of activity to control movement..such how extend the tip of an arm can
important aspect for making a combination with a muscle activety good to listen to the child for the following the patient's growth. how an emg instrumentation should be control the tool. I see it's a great
good choice is "feasability for you sensor to open/close, makes this comic caracters. Being the guide long are you targeting? how is it included in your design. you idea and very prospective to be
as a team and impact for the user" to a doable and great idea. Idea of for the process. How do you know related to the convenience of the mentioned about a japan brand implemented; as not many people
vision camera is great but too the muscles activities of the child hand socket? .. another thing, how system, it include an embedded thought about the utilization of the
Prosthetic Hand for complex and time consuming for to use the sensor? Voice control about the low cost solution for the controller with a sophisticated tip of arm to control the prosthetic
5 Technology for Amputee
Kids this project. from his brothers voice or even insurance cover problem which is algrothm. you should learn more hand. For the alt. 3: be careful with
Ultraman! :-) I didn't real hear the only 2.5 million rupiah. and completely about your model. accident may happen. As it is
favorite idea. easily removed, there will be a big
possibility to be unintentionally
removed. Otherwise, we need
some steps before the prosthetic
hand being removed.
Feedback for Initial Presentation - 7 May 2021
Feedback
Group Selected Topic Product
Pak Oliver
I would use ABS instead of PLA.
Durability, Outdoor performance,
strenght, ... and you can design it
lighter. I would rethink the ideas for
Technology for Post- 3D Cast Fixation attachment. I think if u use idea 3
6
Operation Patients (Child) and rethink it a bit you might find a
workbale solution. For instance a
cliplock which you can turn 90° to
tighten it.
Technology for Post-Stroke
7 FES Upper Limb
Rehabilitation
Same here: Nice broad scope of
possibilities/ideas. I think an
important aspect for making a
8 Technology for Amputee Prosthetic Hand
good choice is "feasability for you
as a team and the impact for the
user"
Feedback
Pak Benjamin
Idea of the cords allows more
ability to allow motions inside the
orthosis, in this way high pressure
in specific regiona are less
present. This is because the cord
can move a little and conduct
higher forces to other regions of
the orthosis.Use ABS, not PLA for
this products (stronger, better
resistant to deformation, ...)
Superficial muscles can be
stimulated by FES, some deepe
muscles are less accessible.
Sure you can mean a lot for this
person! It is time to make clear
choices. It would be great to
combine all 3 ideas: mechanical
enhanced with motors and the
capacitive sensor for activation.
Feedback
Pak Evert
Good wake up start of the
presentation. Go Power Rangers
Go. Nice, clear slides. Good to do
benchmarking on the existing
products. The paitent has almost
no fingers; is that important for the
design? For the cast to stay on.
Where do you put the battery for
the sensors? Some info about
pricing.
Customer emphathy map gives a
good overview of the patient.
Already some testing for FES.
Game rehabilitation is great!
Indeed you need to look to the
numbers.
You can feel the group works good
together. Good presentation and
language. Nice to have 2 different
possibilities. How is the patient
able to touch the buttons?
Feedback
Pak Djoko
power ranger versus ultraman ...
PLA material is easier to work with
but heavier and easily affected by
humidity. need to consider
materials other than PLA. the use
of velcrow ties with finishing
stitches is often a problem if it is
often removed and installed.
seams are easily damaged.
Feedback Feedback
Pak Arifin Bu Ellya
reason why use the sensors it is okay for not being able to take
should be more clearly explained. the cast independently; because
placement of the sensors, how the most important value for this
many force sensors are needed product is the rigidity to ensure it
are also some important variables works well.
you should aware, that they are
important...
very good innovation for applying Thank you for the toughtful
closed-loop FES, it will be hoped topresentation. Who set the amount
improve the current cllinical setting.
of time or frequency to do the
Fuzzy logic ontroller, with theraphy? The therapist or the
adaptaion of its parameter sound patient? If the amount has been
good to realize..you already set up at the beginning, why it still
preapare your adaptation, so just needs sensors or control, as it is
try your code...of course some already being considered by the
issues in subject consent is therapist. Can he operate the tool
important, please do carefully.. by himself? or he needs someone
else to help him?
some ethical issue should be just suggestion, for example the
clearly prepared well. because electrical is for the finger, while the
your work involving a patient. data mechanical is for wearing the
should be keep confidential. prosthetic hand; as the prosthetic
hand must be fit and not easily
unintentionally removed