You are on page 1of 16

Financial Management Challenges In Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises:

A Strategic Management Approach

Hande Karadag
Wharton School, University of Pennslyvania, Sol C. Snider Entrepreneurial Research Center, |
email: hkaradag@wharton.upenn.edu

Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu |

Abstract

Due to their significant role in creation of new jobs, rise in GDP, entrepreneurship and innovation, small and medium-sized enterprises
(SMEs) are recognized as the drivers of socio-economic growth, both in developed and developing economies. In Turkey, 99.9 % of all
enterprises fall into SME category. Therefore, the significance of SMEs for Turkish economy and society is much higher in Turkey,
compared to other emerging and developed countries. Small and medium-sized companies are faced with a number of challenges whereas
the problems arising from “poor financial management” are reported as the major causes of business failures in SMEs. Strategic financial
management (SFM) which is a research area that has attracted the interest of researchers after 2010, is one of the key managerial areas of
SMEs, due to its vital role on the survival, growth and performance of SMEs. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the central role of
financial management and identify the financial management challenges and practices that influence the organizational performance in
Turkish SMEs, from a strategic management perspective. Within the course of this paper, the importance and challenges of SMEs in
Turkey are presented in the first section, while the literature on strategic and financial management in SMEs is reviewed in the second part.
In the third section, the recent strategic financial management concept, the implications of strategic financial management practices for
SMEs in Turkey and the relationships between strategic financial management practices and SME performance, are discussed. Small and
medium sized enterprise finance in Turkey is a developing research area; therefore this paper aims to make a significant contribution to the
existing literature by analyzing the major challenges at the conduct of financial management in Turkish SMEs and the influence of
strategic financial management practices on the performances of small and medium sized companies in Turkey. Additionally, the
conceptual framework developed is expected to be useful to academics in developing an agenda for future empirical research.
Keywords : SMEs, financial management, strategic management, strategic financial management (SFM) practices

New articles in this journal are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States License.

This journal is published by the University Library System of the University of Pittsburgh as part
of its D-Scribe Digital Publishing Program, and is cosponsored by the University of Pittsburgh Press.
Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

problems of SMEs have a financial nature (OECD, 2006),


Financial Management poor financial management is a critical and common cause
Challenges In Small and of business failures in SMEs (Jindrichovska, 2013).
Particularly lack of financial management knowledge
Medium-Sized Enterprises: A combined with uncertainty of the business environment
often leads SMEs to face serious problems regarding
Strategic Management financial and overall performances, which can even
threaten the survival of the enterprise (Kaya & Alpkan,
Approach 2012).

As Turkey is a developing country where


Hande Karadag insufficient levels of equity capital and poor access to
external finance are considered as the major financial
challenges for SMEs (Öndeş and Güngör, 2013; Şahin,
1. Introduction 2011; Çetin, Akyüz and Genç, 2011; Güler, 2010;
Koyuncugil and Özgülbaş, 2008), previous literature on
Small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs) form financial characteristics of Turkish SMEs focused mainly
a large part of economy and are regarded as the drivers of on financial problems of small and medium sized
socio-economic development in all countries. In OECD companies with respect to their funding requirements
countries, over 95% of all enterprises fall in the SME (Uluyol, 2013; Koyuncugil & Özgülbaş, 2008; Topal,
category, while over 50% of the private sector employment Erkan & Elitaş, 2006; Arslan, 2003), the research area of
is supplied by SMEs (Lukacs, 2005). Although most of the financial management practices in SMEs in Turkey has
enterprises in all countries are SMEs (Özdemir, Ersöz & been significantly neglected up to date. Therefore, this
Sarıoğlu, 2011) the interest to micro, small and medium- paper aims to make a contribution to the literature by
sized companies both among practitioners and academics is analyzing the major financial management challenges of
quite recent. The importance of SMEs in the economy has SMES in Turkey, and the practices of financial
been widely recognized after 1980’s, as the focus shifted management which are closely related to SME
from large corporations smaller sized enterprises. Since performance, in other terms, which have a “strategic”
then, these economic units are regarded as the core of importance in terms of improving or worsening the
developmental macro and socioeconomic policies on both performance of the SME. The conduct of financial
national and international levels. strategies formulated by the owners and/or managers of the
enterprises is a concept which can show variations among
In Turkey, the significance of SMEs is relatively different contexts, as which financial practices are more
higher, which is caused by not only their large share, common or more strategic importance in the overall
amounting to 99.9% of all formally declared businesses in financial management of SMEs can differ from one setting
the economy, but also from their resilience to the shocks in to another, depending on the development of the context of
turbulent Turkish macro economy. Turkish SMEs, which corporate sector (Butt, Hunjra and Rehman, 2010).
were faced with serious challenges during and after the However, the questions regarding how these practices can
severe economic crises that hit the Turkish economy within be identified within their own contexts and used as strategic
the last three decades, increased their share in the economy tools for overcoming the financial and overall managerial
significantly, while Turkish government took radical steps challenges and attaining a higher organizational
towards attaining a more stable macro economy and performance, have not been investigated in depth. Thus, as
sustainable growth. During that restructuring period, SMEs an additional contribution, the conceptual framework
became one of the key elements of the macroeconomic developed within this study can provide a basis to
improvements in Turkey, due to their significant role in the academics for future empirical research. Within the course
growth of overall GDP, new job creation and exports. of the paper, Section 2 briefly reviews the literature on the
concept of SME and the importance and challenges of
Despite the positive outlook and growth trends of SMEs in Turkey. Section 3 starts with the analysis on
the sector, SMEs in Turkey, as in most developing strategic management in SMEs, and continues with
economies, are faced with a number of challenges, such as identification of strategic financial management practices in
insufficient managerial skills, lack of trained personnel, small and medium sized companies, both in international
poor access to financial resources and low utilization of and local contexts, by introducing a “strategic management
new technologies. Among these, lack of an efficient and model of financial practices in SMEs”. The details of the
effective financial management system is a core problem model constructs as well as their role on the overall
area for Turkish SMEs. As financial management is the performance of the SME are presented in the same section.
centre of the overall management system in a small The implications of strategic financial management
business (Meredith, 1986) the ineffectiveness and practices for academics and practitioners are discussed in
inefficiencies of financial conduct have detrimental effects section 4.
on the longevity and performance of an SME. As most

Financial Management Challenges In Small and


Medium-Sized Enterprises: A Strategic Management Approach

Page |26| Emerging Markets Journal


Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

II . Significance and challenges of SME sector in and responsiveness to customer needs as means of
Turkey competing with large-scale mass producers” (Hallberg,
2000; Snodgrass and Biggs, 1996). SMEs emerged as the
key economic actors in both developed and developing
economies, within the last three decades, particularly due to
The SME concept the shift towards a more global business context and
developments in information technologies.
There are different categorizations of small and medium-
sized enterprises due to varying socio-economic conditions Despite their several advantages over large-sized
of each economic region or country focused. While Storey competitors, small and medium sized enterprises have
(1994) argues that “there is no single definition” of the weaknesses and challenges of their own. Zimmerer and
SME concept, Bolton Committee Report (1971) describes Scarborough (2005) state “managerial mistakes, failure to
SMEs as the “enterprises with a relatively small share of develop a strategic plan and poor financial control” among
the market, managed by owners or part-owners in a the most important reasons of business failures in small
personalized way, and not through the medium of a businesses, ranking “poor management” as the primary
formalized management structure; and acting as separate cause. Among various problems of SMEs, financial
entities, in the sense of not forming part of large enterprise challenges have a unique situation as, according to OECD
or group” (Bolton Report, 1971). SMEs and reports, most problems of SMEs have a financial nature
entrepreneurship are accepted “to be a key source of (OECD, 2004, 2006). In the study performed by Hall and
dynamism, innovation and flexibility in advanced Young in UK (1991), 86,6% of the respondents reported
industrialized countries, as well as in emerging and that, the reasons of their business failures had a financial
developing economies” (OECD, 2006). SMEs are called as nature (Hall and Young, 1991). The correlations between
the “backbone of the European economy” as they constitute outcomes of the financial strategies and decisions and the
98% of all enterprises with a total of 20.7 million performance of the enterprise have also been well
businesses and account for 67% of total employment and documented by various researchers (Salazar, Soto and
58% of gross value added in European Union, as of 2012 Mosquedo, 2012). SMEs in developing economies are
(EC,2012). more prone to experiencing finance-related difficulties,
particularly with respect to external funding (OECD, 2006).
The role of SME’s in social and economic
development has been widely recognized in developed
countries as well as developing economies (OECD,2006)
particularly after 1980’s. SME development is “closely SMEs in Turkey
linked with growth” (Ardiç, Mylenko and Saltane, 2011;
Beck, 2010) as the researchers found out “a robust, positive According to the bylaw dated 04.11.2012 and published in
relationship between the relative size of the SME sector the Official Gazette of Turkish Republic, the SME
and economic growth, even when controlling for other definition in terms of employee number and annual revenue
growth determinants” (Ardıç, et al., 2011; Beck, 2010). in Turkey is as follows:
Apart from their role in GDP growth, SMEs have other
significant socio-economic characteristics such as their Number of Annual
contribution to new job creation and reduction of poverty. employees turnover
The potential economic and social benefits of SMEs can be Micro Enterprises < 10 < 1 million TL
stated as “creating jobs at low cost of capital, contributing Small Enterprises < 50 < 8 million TL
positively to the Gross Domestic Product (GDP), Medium-sized < 250 < 40 million TL
improving forward and backward linkages between sectors, Enterprises
creating opportunities for employing appropriate
technology, providing an opportunity to expand the
entrepreneurial base, expanding a pool of skilled and semi- SMEs are the most significant tools for economic
skilled workers, providing support to large-scale development, gross domestic product and workforce in
enterprises, providing the required flexibility to adapt to Turkish economy (Nurrachmi, Abd Samad & Foughali,
market failures, entering into market niches which are not 2012). There are a total of 3,222,133 small and medium-
profitable for larger enterprises, contributing to sized enterprises in Turkey, which constitute 99.9% of all
development policies that are more oriented towards enterprises, while 76% of total employment, 53% of total
decentralization and rural development, supporting wages and salaries, 63% of annual sales turnover, 53.3% of
governments’ efforts alleviate the negative aftermath of value added at factor cost and 53.7% of gross investment
structural adjustment programs” (Zonooz, Farzam, Satarifar intangible goods are supplied by SME sector (Turkstat,
& Bakshi, 2011; Tolentino, 1995). 2013). According to main groups of industry, 40.8% of
SMEs operate in wholesale and retail trade together with
Small and medium-sized companies are often the repairing of motor vehicles and motorcycles, while
viewed as being more innovative than larger firms and 16.4% operate in transportation and storage industries and
considered to follow niche strategies in developed 12.8% work in manufacturing industry. The percentage
countries, while adopting “high product quality, flexibility share of SMEs within the total exports is 62,6% in 2012,

Hande Karadag
Emerging Markets Journal | P a g e |27
Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

rising from a 56% in 2009, where the share of micro Administrative costs and burdens: The complexity and cost
enterprises is 20.6%, small enterprises is 24.3% and of bureaucratic transactions and the costs of launching a
medium-sized enterprises is 17.7% in total exports. The new business are also among the major challenges SMEs
proportion of the SMEs’ export and import volumes face in Turkey. While significant developments have been
indicate the contribution of SME sector to the balance of made regarding the attainment of a more SME-friendly
payments deficit of Turkish economy, as the percentage business climate and “simplified legislative procedures”,
share of SMEs in total exports is 38.5% in 2012, compared reduction of red-tape is an important issue for new venture
to their % 62,6 share in total exports. launches and encouraging entrepreneurship. Among other
countries, Turkey ranked as the 69rd in the “World Bank
Despite their vital importance within the Doing Business Report”(Worldbank,2014). However, at the
economy, SMEs in Turkey are faced with major challenges. ranking of “starting a business”, the country’s rating fell
While common problems of SMEs particularly in significantly from 73. place to 93 between 2013 and 2014,
developing economies are mainly reported as insufficient resulting mainly from the high costs of launching a new
use of new technologies, lack of business related training, business as illustrated in Table 1 .
inadequate managerial capabilities, high rate of taxes and
other bureaucratic problems (Abdulsaleh and Worthington,
2013, Ardıç, et,al, 2011), KOSGEB, which is the main
public body responsible from SMEs, reported the basic Table 1. Turkey’s Ratings for Starting a Business
challenges experienced by SMEs in Turkey, as follows
(KOSGEB, 2012) : Europe &
Indicator Turkey Central Asia OECD
Technology and innovation Insufficient know-how and low
The total number of procedures required to register a firm 6 5 5
levels of technology are common in most Turkish SMEs.
Most manufacturers in Turkey currently operate in
medium-low and low level industry sectors, reaching to a The total number of days required to register a firm 6 12.8 11.1
very high percentage of 89%, which prevent them from
benefiting low cost advantage. Low regard for innovation, Cost is recorded as a percentage of the economy’s income per capita 12.7 6.7 3.6
due to high costs of R&D, is a major cause of low levels of
technology of SMEs. SMEs face various challenges when
conducting R&D projects and realizing business ideas The amount that the entrepreneur needs to deposit in a bank or with a notary
which can be turned into business opportunities. In 2012, before registration and up to 3 months following incorporation (recorded as a
16.6 percent of R&D expenditure was performed by SMEs percentage of the economy’s income per capita) 13.2 3.5 10.4
and regarding R&D personnel distribution, 25.3 percent
was employed in SMEs (Turkstat, 2013). Source : World Bank Doing Business Report (2014)
Marketing and Exporting: As lack of information on
foreign market opportunities, inadequate financing and
technical knowledge lower the competitiveness of products Financial challenges: As in most developing economies,
and services, SMEs in Turkey mostly target the domestic financial difficulties are very common for most of the
market. SMEs in Turkey. Due to collateral, personal and financial
statement-related problems in utilizing bank loans and low
Entrepreneurship: With its young demographic structure, levels of equity, SME credits are still at a low level of
Turkey has a significant but mostly unutilized potential for around 25% , which is an important factor behind the low
entrepreneurship, where the main causes are insufficient technological capacity and less modernized production
technical knowledge on preparing business plans and facilities of SMEs. Alternate sources of finance such as
difficulties in finding the startup capital, needed to angel investors, credit guarantee funds and venture capital
undertake the high costs of launching the business. companies are insufficient and most of the time,
inaccessible, for SMEs in Turkey. In addition to that,
Environment: In Turkey, as in most parts of the world, the background and knowledge level of SME owners, play an
demand for environmentally-friendly products and services important role financial problems of SMEs. As most SME
is increasing. However, the complexity of environmental owners/managers come from a technical or engineering
legislation and the height of costs to comply with the background, their knowledge about finance and accounting
legislation are discouraging the SME owners and is most cases, is significantly limited. Whilst that, most
entrepreneurs from meeting that demand. SME owner/managers refrain from hiring professional
finance managers for not delegating their “managerial
Labor: Due to high percentage of social security premiums, power”, which causes their financial problems to grow and
cost of skilled labor in Turkey is higher than most even threaten the survival of their enterprises.
developing economies. This, combined with low levels of
education and technical capabilities of employees, creates a
major disadvantage for competitiveness of SMEs.

Financial Management Challenges In Small and


Medium-Sized Enterprises: A Strategic Management Approach

Page |28| Emerging Markets Journal


Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

Previous studies have shown that, among these generally tended to overlook the strategic management
several problems, challenges related with financial processes, which had to go through serious changes with
decisions and actions have a strategic importance for SMEs the developments in the business environment, as the
in Turkey, as the efficient and effective conduct of financial entrepreneurs and small business owners became more
management has the potential to elevate or diminish the aware of the challenges and the opportunities of the
performance of a small and medium sized company (Öndeş contexts they are competing in and the sustainable
and Güngör, 2013; Şahin, 2011; Çetin, Akyüz and Genç, competitive advantages their enterprises had to develop, for
2011; Güler, 2010; Koyuncugil and Özgülbaş, 2008). reaching their organizational goals (Zimmerer and
Regarding the financial management challenges, the Scarborough, 2005). Within that respect, the potential
following section analyzes the major practices of financial advantages of a strategic outlook for SME owner/managers,
management conduct in Turkish SMEs, from a fresh summarized by Wickham (2006) as: “encouraging the
strategic management perspective. entrepreneur or small business owner to evaluate and
articulate a vision, ensuring the scanning and analyzing of
the organization and its environment, facilitating the
discovery of
3 . Strategic financial management practices new opportunities and strengths, guiding the restructuring
of the enterprise, guiding the processes of decision making,
within the enterprise, providing a starting point for the
specification of objectives, acting as a common language
Strategic Management in SMEs for the enterprise’s stakeholders” (Wickham, 2006) were
soon realized by SME owner/managers, to targeted to
Strategic management is “a set of managerial decisions and maintain a sustainable organizational performance and
actions that determines the long-run performance of a improved levels of competitiveness.
corporation” (Wheelen and Hunger, 2010) As the
description emphasizes, strategic management of an In academic studies, until 1980’s the general
enterprise concerns with attaining a sustainable positive perspective of strategic management is regarded to be
performance and contains four basic elements, which are broad and non-distinctive among types of businesses,
environmental scanning, strategy formulation, strategy assuming a general applicability of strategic management
implementation and evaluation and control. Strategic concepts and processes of large firms to all businesses
management creates “ a clearer sense of strategic vision for (Davig,1986). Among the few researchers whose views
the firm, sharper focus on what is strategically important” contrasted with this generalization were Cohn and Lindberg
and “improved understanding of a rapidly changing (1972), who stated that smaller firms needed specific
environment” (Wilson, 1994). Within that respect, strategies for survival and growth, Pleitner, et.al. (1989: 72)
conducting strategic management in SMEs have a crucial who pointed out the criteria of firm size and entrepreneurial
importance as SMEs have to operate and compete within types as the two bases of distinction between management
contexts of high risk and uncertainty. of companies, and Carter (1990) who suggested that small
companies faced higher adaptation problems due to “higher
Zimmerer and Scarborough (2005) describe regulatory and competitive uncertainty” (Carter, 1990). In
“strategic management” in small businesses as “the this new stream of thought, entrepreneur and
process of developing a game plan to guide a company as it entrepreneurial characteristics were considered to be the
strives to accomplish its vision, mission, goals, and core of the discussion. (Dean, Brown and Bamford,1998).
objectives and to keep it straying off-course” (Zimmerer A recent study by Liberman, Jaoni and Hooper (2010)
and Scarborough, 2005: 65). Strategic management supported that argument, revealing that, personal
behavior in small and medium sized enterprises involves characteristics of SME owner-managers, such as
“an attempt to cope more effectively with the great and experience, social relationships, level of information and
rising demands emanating from both outside and inside the ethical values, strongly affects strategic decision-making
firm by (i) giving the development of the firm a long-range processes in micro enterprises, while further models and
direction; (ii) formulating and applying an overall concept analyses regarding the distinctions between large and small
of the firm; (iii) generating, implementing, and controlling companies were not limited solely to entrepreneurial
basic strategies and sub-strategies; and (iv) utilizing such characteristics, taking other factors e.g. industry
special "strategic" tools as strengths/weaknesses analysis environment, firm specific competitive behaviour and
and opportunity/risk analysis, among others” (Pleitner and strategic decision making processes in these firms, into
Barney; 1989). consideration. In an empirical study, Chen and Hambrick
(1995) studied 28 US airline companies and found out that,
The need for applying the methods and small business competitive behavior is different from that
techniques of strategic management in small and medium of larger firms and suggested that, small firms had higher
sized businesses can be attributed to the changing speed in initiating strategic behavior but were low-key,
conditions of conducting business. Although small even secretive in their strategy implementation. Following
businesses are exposed to higher risks and uncertainty their study, Dean, Brown and Bramford (1998) conducted
compared to large sized enterprises, the traditional business an empirical research on a large sample of US small and
management style of SME owners or entrepreneurs large manufacturing firms, where they found strong

Hande Karadag
Emerging Markets Journal | P a g e |29
Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

evidence for their proposition that “small and large firms traditional “deliberate” approach of strategic management
possess different resources and capabilities that make them which strictly requires the formal planning and controlling
particularly well suited to different environmental activities, their chaotic environment and the limited
contexts”. resources force them to be much closer to the “emergent”
strategic management approach led by Mintzberg (1994),
Due to the growing interest to the impact of strategic which is more flexible, leaving room to changes and
management on the improvement of SME performance, the developments in the environment. However, the need for
role of financial decisions and actions within the overall the deliberate (planned) strategic management is evident in
strategic management system is becoming more popular the phases of environmental scanning and the strategy
among the scholars, particularly after the introduction of formulation, while the emergent approach can be argued to
the recent strategic financial management theory by Liu, in be useful in the strategy implementation phase for small
2010. The theory and its implications on the practices of and medium sized companies.
financial management both at the international context and
in Turkey, are analyzed in the following section. Within the financial management literature, there
has been a considerable amount of research focusing
classifying of main constructs of financial management.
Strategic financial management practices Among these, Mc Mahon, Hutchinson and Forsaith (1993)
have been leading researchers, analyzing and categorizing
After the studies showing that “The main causes of the practices of financial management in Australia, UK and
business failure are the lack of financial planning, limited US SMEs. Later, various scholars worked on several
access to funding, lack of capital, unplanned growth, low aspects of financial management practices in different
strategic and financial projection, excessive fixed-asset contexts (Okafor,2012; Chung and Chuang, 2011;
investment and capital mismanagement” Hunjra,Butt,Rehman,2010; Pham,2010; Nguyen 2001).
(Salazar,Soto&Mosqueda, 2012), the concept of strategic With regard to the independent variable of financial
financial management practices in enterprises started to management practices in these studies, in contrast to the
gain popularity among researchers. previous studies advocating a general categorization for the
elements of financial management, Butt, Hunjra & Rehman
Strategic financial management (SFM) refers to (2010) argued that, major constructs of financial
“financial management theories according to which management practices in SMEs can vary from one country
financing should be conducted in the most proper way, the to another, depending on the development of the context of
collected capital should be utilized and managed in the corporate sector. Empirical studies conducted on SMEs of
most effective way in enterprises and decisions on the different countries supported their argument, indicating
reinvestment and distribution of profits should be made existence of a significant variance among the major
most reasonably” (Liu, 2010). Strategic financial constructs of financial management practices in different
management consists of “financial strategies which are contexts of research. For example, Peel and Wilson (1996)
goals, patterns or alternatives designed to improve and regarded capital budgeting and financing activities as the
optimize financial management in order to achieve major elements of financial management practices for small
corporate results” where financial strategy “represents a businesses in UK, while Nguyen (2001), conducting a
path to achieve and maintain business competitiveness and research study on Vietnamese SMEs, argued that the
position a company as a world-class organization” practices which are more related to the profitability and
(Salazar,et.al, 2012). performance of SMEs in Vietnam are the practices related
to the ‘accounting information systems, financial planning,
Studies show that, despite the importance of working capital management, fixed-asset management and
strategic thinking and implementation on the conduct of financial reporting and analysis” (Nguyen, 2001). Later,
financial management in SMEs which have to operate in Kennedy and Tennent (2006) used “financial record
contexts of high risks and uncertainty with limited keeping” the general indicator of financial management
resources, SME owner/managers regard production/service conduct in small businesses in Australia’ and Butt, Hunjra
or marketing functions as priorities particularly in the start- and Rehman addressed “capital structure decision, dividend
up phase of new ventures, which eventually results with policy, investment appraisal techniques, working capital
poor financial management, and in most cases failure of and financial assessment” as the most common financial
business (Jindrichovska, 2013). It is also reported that, management practices in Pakistan (Butt, Hunjra &
SME owners or entrepreneurs, until recently have a general Rehman, 2010). In Turkey, studies conducted up to date on
tendency to overlook the elements of strategic management financial management of SMEs, indicate both similarities
(Zimmerer and Scarborough, 2005), whereas the lack of and diversifications with regard to previous studies
“strategic outlook” in the financial issues is a major threat conducted in other contexts, which is explained in detail in
on the longevity of SMEs as “many of the factors that the following section.
contribute to failure can be managed properly with
strategies and financial decisions that drive growth and the Interestingly, no research study, to date, attempted to
organization’s objectives” (Salazar, Soto, Mosqueda, analyze the variances in the practices of financial
2012). While SMEs are reportedly more distant from management in SMEs within different contexts and

Financial Management Challenges In Small and


Medium-Sized Enterprises: A Strategic Management Approach

Page |30| Emerging Markets Journal


Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

approach the conduct of these practices from a strategic As Turkish SMEs are mainly dependent on
management viewpoint, taking the influence of these external sources of funding, previous literature on financial
practices on organizational performance, as a base. The problems and practices of SMEs in Turkey, has mainly
following section presents a conceptual model as a new focused on funding challenges in SMEs (Uluyol, 2013;
perspective of looking at the financial conduct in small and Koyuncugil & Özgülbaş, 2008; Topal, Erkan & Elitaş,
medium sized companies, by firstly identifying the 2006; Arslan, 2003), leaving the research area of other
“strategic” practices of financial management in Turkey, important financial management constructs of SMEs
followed by a discussion on their interrelationships and significantly neglected, up to date. The following findings
their impact on organizational performance. have been reported as the results of some of the empirical
studies regarding financial management practices of SMEs
in Turkey:

4. Strategic financial management practices and SME Çakır (2013) studied 58 manufacturing
performance companies in Turkey and found out that higher cash
conversion cycle is associated with higher profitability
In Turkey, as in most developing economies, lack of capital (Çakır, 2013).
and poor access to finance are considered as the main
financial challenges for small and medium sized companies Güngör and Öndeş (2013) conducted a research
(Öndeş & Güngör, 2013; Şahin, 2011; Çetin, Akyüz & study on 30 SMEs in Erzurum region of Turkey. Their
Genç, 2011; Güler, 2010; Koyuncugil & Özgülbaş, 2008). findings indicated that, lack of financial management
While Turkey experienced the greatest expansion in SME knowledge and collection of receivables in working capital
lending among OECD countries within the period of 2007- management are among the most common financial
2011, the proportion of the SME share in total credits is problems in SMEs In addition to that, 97% of these SMEs
still significantly below the SME credit utilizations of the used equity financing instead of debt financing, and
developed economies (OECD, 2012). capacity utilization ratio in these SMEs were found to be
very low, causing significant amounts of financial losses
Whilst commercial banks are still the most and decreases in the rate of employment. (Öndeş and
common sources of SME finance in Turkey mainly due to Güngör, 2013).
the underdevelopment of venture capital and credit
guarantee systems, problems related to collateral, Uluyol (2013) implemented an empirical research
credibility and financial statements inhibit the effective on financial management practices of 260 SMEs in
utilization of banks loans by the SMEs. Therefore, majority Kahramanmaraş, Hatay, Şanlıurfa, Adıyaman and
of Turkish SMEs finance their working capital needs by Gaziantep cities of southeastern region of Turkey. The
either using equity financing (Şahin, 2011) or other findings implied that, the conduct financial management
external sources such as family financing or individual practices is “unsatisfactory” in SMEs, as most practices are
loans (KOSGEB, 2011). Regarding other challenges related reported to be “partially” undertaken. The major
to financial management, inefficient use of financial implication of the research study was the reporting of a
resources (Uluyol, 2013) and insufficient working capital general lack of financial knowledge in practices of financial
management in terms of cash inventory and receivables management.
management constructs, are reported as key financial
challenges for SMEs in Turkey. Among these, cash-flow Güler (2010) investigated the working capital
problems have a unique situation, as the deterioration of management and other financial management practices in
cash-flow in an enterprise causes the owners to finance 111 SMEs in Ankara region of Turkey and found that
daily operations with equity capital or personal funds, and SMEs mostly use the payback period method, when
when this situation continues for long, the melting equity making fixed-asset investment decisions. The findings also
capital threatens the survival of an enterprise (KOSGEB, indicate that, SMEs have the highest regard for the
2011). In addition to that, an efficient inventory collection of receivables and cash flow management, as
management is stated to lead to improved competitiveness practices of working capital management.
in SMEs (KOSGEB, 2011). The importance of cash and
inventory management for SMEs in Turkey is also well Çetin and Bıtırak (2009) carried out an empirical
documented in other studies (Uluyol, 2013; Kaya & study about financial management, working capital and
Alpkan, 2012). As other important constructs, insufficient investment budgeting practices of 40 SMEs in Antalya city
overall and financial planning, lack of feasibility analyses of Turkey. Findings of their research indicated that, follow-
before making investment decisions, inadequate keeping of up of doubtful receivables and managing cash are the basic
financial records and lack of analyses of financial reports working capital management practices in SMEs, while
due to insufficient financial knowledge of SME payback period method is the most widely used method in
owner/managers, are among the main problem areas of fixed-asset investments.
SMEs in Turkey, with respect to financial management
(Kaya & Alpkan, 2012; Alkış a& Temizkan, 2012; Çetin, Akyüz and Genç (2008) conducted a
Güler,2010; Kutlu & Demirci, 2007; Arslan, 2003). research on SMEs in Usak city of Turkey and found out
that 80% of the SMEs did not have a finance department,

Hande Karadag
Emerging Markets Journal | P a g e |31
Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

and majority of them faced difficulties at collecting their Figure 1. Within the three basic phases of strategic
receivables and utilizing bank loans, while 85% had to financial management, SME owner/managers in Turkey
postpone their investment plans during the economic crisis tend to have a higher regard for the implementation phase
period of 2008-2009. of financial management practices, such as paying more
attention to the daily transactions related to various
Koyuncugil and Özgülbaş (2008) studied the working capital management practices including cash,
financial data of 697 SMEs which are quoted to İstanbul receivables, inventory and accounts payables management,
Stock Exchange. The findings of their analysis presented as well as making detailed evaluations before making
that, 62% of these SMEs’ financial performance was weak, fixed-asset investments. This indicates that, the “emerging”
compared to with the others. The SMEs with lower scores approach of strategic management which also facilitates
had the common problems of low ROE and net profit finding immediate solutions to unanticipated financial
margin, faced difficulties in the collection of receivables problems with its unstructured and flexible nature is
and had financial management problems (Koyuncugil and common among Turkish SMEs, in their conduct of
Özgülbaş, 2008). financial management. On the other hand, the “deliberate”
strategic management approach, regarding the elements of
Çetin (2006) studied financial management, strategy formulation and control, is found to be in much
working capital and fixed-asset budgeting practices of 42 lower levels, as most SME owner/managers reportedly do
SMEs in Antalya and Isparta cities in the Mediterennian not show a great interest or lack the technical knowledge
region of Turkey. Findings of the study indicated that the related with the financial planning and the financial
SME owner/managers are not well- informed about money reporting and control practices, which eventually become
and capital markets, as well as about basic concepts of significant factors of poor performance results and even
financial management. About the practices of working failure of business.
capital management, SMEs considered collection of
receivables and practices of inventory management, as The flow and interrelationships of the strategic
important. SMEs also regarded acquisition of basic financial management practices with respect to SME
machinery and equipment, as their core investments in performance are illustrated in the strategic management
fixed-assets. model of financial management practices in Figure 1. The
strategic financial management elements of the model,
Topal, Erkan and Arıtaş (2006) conducted a study namely financial planning, working capital management
about financial management practices of 48 SMEs in with three sub-constructs of cash, receivables and inventory
Afyonkarahisar city of Turkey. Findings of their study management, fixed-asset management and finally,
indicated that, machinery and equipment acquisitions, financial reporting and control, are determined according to
conducted with the motivation of growth of business the significance of their correlations with the overall
volumes, are the basic fixed-asset investments and SMEs performance of the company, as regarded by the SME
use profitability and pay-back analyses in assessing their owner/managers. Other elements of financial management,
fixed-asset investments. SMEs also reported frequent uses such as accounting information systems, are not included in
of working capital management practices, most important the model, as these practices have been reported by the
ones being receivables and inventory management, but also SME owner/managers, as being significantly correlated
including cash budgeting and follow-up of periodical with SME performance in Turkey.
monetary target

While the literature on SME strategic


management suggests that SME owner/managers do not
always employ the processes of strategic management
when running their businesses (Zimmerer & Scarborough,
2005), the empirical studies conducted on financial
management constructs of Turkish SMEs present indicators
of employment of an “emergent” approach of strategic
management at the implementation phase of the conduct of
financial management practices, particularly when
managing daily financial operations and during processes
of large investments. On the other hand, the
owner/managers of SMEs experience problems in taking a
“deliberate” approach of strategic management, regarding
the strategy formulation and feedback and control phases of
financial management, which results in poor financial and
overall organizational performance results. The flow of
financial management practices and the phases deliberate
and emergent illustrated in the strategic management model Figure 1: Strategic management model of financial
of financial management practices in SMEs, as shown in management practices in SMEs

Financial Management Challenges In Small and


Medium-Sized Enterprises: A Strategic Management Approach

Page |32| Emerging Markets Journal


Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

The inadequacy of an effective and efficient Proposition 1 : Strategic financial planning has a positive
conduct of financial management and the challenges impact on SME performance.
regarding main practices of financial management in
Turkish SMEs are well documented in several studies Strategic working capital management: Working capital
(Uluyol, 2013; Koyuncugil & Ozgulbas, 2008; Cetin, management has a particular importance for firms in
2006). Therefore, the conceptual model is designed to emerging markets, as the companies operating in these
identify the key practices of financial management and countries are mostly SMEs who have limited access to
deriving proposals about how the model can be used as a long-term capital markets, therefore are much reliant on
“strategic tool’ for overcoming the financial management owner financing,, trade credits and inventories to finance
problems in order to attain a higher organizational their funding requirements for cash, accounts receivables
performance in small and medium size companies. and inventories (Abuzayed, 2011). Studies show that, in
Turkey, as in most developing economies, cash, receivables
Strategic financial planning: Problems related with access and inventory management are the key areas of financial
to financial resources are vital for Turkish SMEs. However, management where SME owner/managers allocate most of
studies show that the planned, accurate and goal-oriented their time as they regard these practices as “strategic” for
utilization of the acquired funds is more critical for a their enterprises. Despite this high managerial awareness,
successful SME performance (Uluyol, 2013). A high regard interestingly, most business failures are reported to result
for financial planning resulting with the development of “a from the ineffective and inefficient management of
solid financial plan” (Zimmerer and Scarborough, 2005) is working capital, particularly cash and receivables (Uluyol,
considered as the key for launching and operating a 2013; Kaya and Alpkan, 2012), implying the presence of
successful enterprise, as the lack of financial planning and serious deficiencies in the strategic thinking and
projection is argued to be one of the major causes of implementation processes regarding the management of
business failures, particularly in SMEs (Malette, 2006). working capital. As the follow-up and collection of
Within the overall financial management system, financial doubtful receivables and bad debts, the management of
planning can have several major functions, such as raising inadequate or excess cash and the finding and keeping of
the required capital for the start-up phase of the enterprise optimum levels of inventory are highly important for the
or efficient and effective management of enterprise’s daily survival and performance of small and medium sized
operations. Any process of strategic management starts enterprises, SME owner/managers create snapshot solutions
with “strategy formulation”, where environmental scanning to immediate crises at these areas. Therefore, it can be
is undertaken for identifying the factors which have the argued that they tend to apply a more emergent strategic
potential to affect the organization’s survival and success, management approach when dealing with conflicts and
followed by the formulation of strategies for reaching problems about the management of working capital. The
organizational goals. While the conduct of financial key point therefore, which would differentiate a successful
planning is executed when managing daily operations of and highly performing SME from an unsuccessful one, is
the company, such as making deciding on the receivables how effectively and efficiently the process of strategic
collection period or bank credit maturities and amounts, a management is carried out by the SME owner/managers.
more strategic outlook adds a ‘long-ranged view’ and Empirical studies show that, the profitability of the
‘goal-orientation’ elements to overall managerial enterprise can be increased by accurately managing the
perspective, resulting with the direction and focusing of the cash in and out movements, besides minimizing the amount
limited financial resources towards the required ends. of excess cash (Block and Hirt, 2004) or reducing the
Therefore, this “seeing the big picture” and formulating number of days of cash collection period, showing that the
financial plans and actions accordingly, contributes to the enterprise has the ability to shorten its receivables
improvement of both financial and overall performance of collection period or lengthen its accounts payable period
the company, to a large extent. This phase is very critical (Cakir, 2013; Gul, et. al, 2013). Efficiency and
for every company, as lack of strategy formulation results effectiveness in inventory management is the final critical
in a “going with the flow” style of management and factor in working capital management in SMEs as
eventually ineffective and inefficient use of resources and inventories generally form the largest asset on the balance
low organizational performance. Formulation of financial sheet. SME owner/managers are more prone to utilize the
strategies is important for small and medium sized “observation method” for detecting the amount of
companies as well as large corporations, as SMEs have to inventory, which causes them to face problems due to
compete with very limited resources in contexts of high having too much or too little inventories, resulting with
risk and uncertainty. Therefore, it can be proposed that, an either low customer satisfaction or high costs of financing
effective and efficient strategic financial planning would excess levels of inventory (Hodgetts and Kuratko, 1998).
result with improved performance in small and medium However, in Turkey, management of inventories has the
sized companies. least managerial priority compared to cash and receivables
management, which constitutes the other important reason
for high inventory costs, decreasing profitability and
eventually poor financial performance (Cetin, 2006; Topal,
Erkan & Arıtaş, 2006). Combining the influence of the
three key factors of working capital management over SME
performance, it can be stated that, an SME which has a

Hande Karadag
Emerging Markets Journal | P a g e |33
Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

higher regard for a strategic approach when managing its and cash flow statement, are “powerful tools” small
working capital would be more successful in terms of business owners can use in managing their companies
financial and overall performance. (Hogetts and Kuratko, 1998). However, mostly due to the
inadequacy of accounting and finance knowledge of SME
Proposition 2: Strategic working capital management has a owner/managers, studies show that, only 11% of small
positive impact on SME performance. business owners/managers “analyze their financial
statements as part of the managerial planning and decision-
Strategic fixed-asset (capital budgeting): Despite that the making processes” (Zimmerer and Scarborough, 2005).
decision about whether to make a fixed-asset investment is Evaluation of financial reports presenting the trends and
crucial to SMEs regarding the impact of this decision on snapshots of past and current financial performance of the
the long-term cash-flow of a small or medium sized company act as the “control and feedback” function of
company, lack of a well-structured strategic approach when strategic financial management process., thus, lack of
making fixed-asset decisions is a major problem area for information on the financial situation and crucial
SMEs operating in Turkey (Guler, 2010; Çetin & Bıtırak, performance indicators threatens the overall awareness of
2009). As generally the funds tied to the acquisitions of the company owner required for a sound strategy
fixed-assets, such as buildings or equipment, are in large formulation and implementation., whereas the performance
amounts with long maturity periods,, problems in fixed of the enterprise is positively impacted when this important
asset investment decisions potentially carry the risk of follow-up function is executed on a timely, rational and
threatening the cash requirements of daily knowledge-based basis. Therefore, it can be proposed that,
production/service operations, particularly when the cash- the utilization of a “deliberate” strategic management
flow impact is not clearly analyzed before making the approach, resulting from the formal and rational nature of
investment. A careful and detailed technical evaluation is a the feedback and control phase of the strategic
major requirement for making a successful fixed-asset management, would significantly improve of SME
acquisition, as in most cases, the contribution of the performance, by pointing out the red and green signals
investment to the overall productivity and performance of about the past and current major financial performance
the company becomes highly questionable without a indicators such as sales growth, profitability or debt/total
feasibility analysis conducted beforehand. As the basic assets ratio and about the optimum and actual levels of
motivation behind fixed-asset investments in small critical balance sheet items such as cash, receivables,
businesses is “to increase the efficiency, thus profitability inventory, payables and fixed-assets, when managing the
of the enterprise” (Zimmerer and Scarborough, 2005), the financial operations of the company.
errors and deficiencies in making these decisions and acting
accordingly harm the profitability thereby the financial and
overall performance of the company, while inadequate
investments towards having more advanced production or Proposition 4: Strategic financial reporting and control has
service facilities limits the growth of the organization, a positive impact on SME performance.
which underline the importance of a strategic outlook when
taking and implementing fixed asset investment decisions.
The outcomes are likely to be more positive when these
vital decisions are made considering the organizational 4 . Discussion and conclusion
goals such as growth or profitability and directing the
limited resources accordingly, starting with the basic
questions of “how much that investment is needed for a
better overall performance?” and “how can we allocate our The significance of SMEs in the social and economic
limited resources to this investment in the best way context, have been recognized worldwide, particularly after
possible, if that investment is a requirement for our short 1980’s, and since then, factors affecting the development
and long-term goals and objectives?”. This way, the means and growth of SMEs have been among the key concerns of
and ends would be managed in a more proper way, in terms public authorities, academicians and business circles.
of maximizing the effectiveness and efficiency of the fixed- Although a number of empirical studies investigated
asset acquisition. various financial management practices and their impact on
organizational performance in different countries, the main
Proposition 3 : Strategic fixed-asset management has a focus of previous SME finance literature, particularly in
positive impact on SME performance. developing countries, have been the challenges SMEs face
to access to financial resources. However, the efficient
Strategic financial reporting and analysis: In Turkey, the utilization of the obtained funds, such as having a sound
inadequacy of financial literacy of SME owners and the cash management system, is equally important, for the
impact of that problem area on poor managerial and overall survival of SMEs. Thus, the shift of research on financial
performance of SMEs is well documented in various management in SMEs from the one-dimensional “funding
studies (Uluyol, 2013: Kaya & Alpkan, 2012, Cetin, 2006). focus”, towards a more comprehensive “strategic financial
Financial reports and statements, particularly main management” perspective has the potential to provide
statements such as balance sheet, profit and loss statement positive implications for academics and policy makers, as

Financial Management Challenges In Small and


Medium-Sized Enterprises: A Strategic Management Approach

Page |34| Emerging Markets Journal


Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

well as practitioners of SME financial management in Arslan, Ö. (2003). Küçük ve Orta Ölçekli
terms of introducing new dimensions and factors to the
concept of improving SME performance. İşletmelerde Çalışma Sermayesi ve

The conceptual model, which is designed to present Bazı Finansal Yönetim Uygulamaları.
how the strategic management practices are interrelated
with each other and with the overall organizational Cumhuriyet Üniversitesi, İ.İ.B.F.
performance and which type of strategic management
approach is more appropriate for a specific financial Dergisi, 4 (1): 121-135.
management practice, underlines the importance of a
strategic perspective for an efficient and effective conduct
of the financial management, in order to achieve a Arı, A. (2013). KOBİ’ler, Esnaf ve Sanatkarlar
successful business performance. The analysis of specific
elements of strategic financial management practices of the Özel İhtisas Komisyonu Raporu.
model, namely strategic financial planning, strategic
working capital management, strategic fixed-asset Trakya Kalkınma Ajansı. http :// www
management and strategic financial reporting and control
practices, and to what extent the execution of an .trakya 2023 .com /uploads /docs /0907
“emergent” or “deliberate” strategic management approach
in the conduct of these financial management practices 2013y l8AAu.pdf
would lead to better performance results, can provide
significant contributions to SME financial management.
Ayrıçay, Y. (2010). Ekonomik Krizin Sanayi
This new approach also has the potential to lead a way
to future empirical studies conducted to test the impact of Kuruluşları Üzerine Etkisi: İşletme
the strategic financial management practices on indicators
of SME performance, such as growth or profitability. This Finansına İlişkin Bir Çalışma/Effects of
way, it can contribute to the previous studies investigating
the factors of success and failure in SMEs, from a financial Economic Crisis on Industrial
management perspective, combined with a strategic
management outlook. The key practices regarding financial Enterprises: A Study about Business
management conduct can differ from one context to
another, therefore other interesting research areas would be Finance. Atatürk Üniversitesi Sosyal
the investigations on the variance of the strategic
management practices in SMEs operating in different Bilimler Enstitüsü Dergisi, 14(1).
contexts, or with that of larger companies.

Beck, T. (2010). SME Finance: What Have We

REFERENCES Learned and What Do We Need to

Alkış, H., & Temizkan, V. (2012). Kobi’lerin Learn? The Financial Development

Yönetsel Sorunlarının Cözümünde Report: 187-195.

Japon Yönetim Sisteminin Rolü.


Bolton, J. E. (1971). Small firms: Report of the
Karabük Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler
Commission of Inquiry on Small
Enstitüsü Dergisi, 2(1).
Firms. London, Her Majesty’s

Ardic, O.; Mylenko, N. and Saltane, V. (2011). Stationary Office.

Small and Medium Enterprises A


Butt, B.; Hunjra, A.; and Rehman, K. (2010).
Cross-Country Analysis with a New
Financial Management Practices and
Data Set. World Bank Policy Research
Their Impact on Organizational
Paper 5538.

Hande Karadag
Emerging Markets Journal | P a g e |35
Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

Performance. World Applied Sciences Çetin, A. C.; Akyüz, Y; and Genç E. (2011).

Journal, 9(9): 997-1002. Küresel Kriz Sürecinde İmalat Sanayi

İşletmelerinin Finansal Sorunlarının


Carter, N. M. (1990). Small Firm Adaptation:
Değerlendirilmesi Uşak İli Örneği.
Responses of Physicians' Organizations
Journal of Suleyman Demirel
to Regulatory and Competitive
University Institute of Social Sciences,
Uncertainty. Academy Of Management
1(13): 55-68.
Journal, 33(2): 307-333.

Çetin, A. C. and Bıtırak, İ. A. (2009). Antalya


Chen, M.J. and Hambrick D. C. (1995). Speed,
İli Küçük ve Orta Ölçekli
Stealth, and Selective Attack: How
İşletmelerinde Finansal Yönetim,
Small Fırms Differ From Large Firms
İşletme Sermayesi ve Yatırım
in Competitive Behavior. Academy Of
Bütçelemesi Uygulamaları. Akdeniz
Management Journal, 38(2): 453-482.
Üniversitesi Alanya İşletme Fakültesi

Chung, S. and Chuang, J. (2011). The Effect of Dergisi, 1(1): 119-137.

Financial Management Practices on


Davig, W. (1986). Business Strategies in
Profitability of Small and Medium
Smaller Manifacturing Firms. Journal
Enterprise in Vietnam. Miho
Of Small Business Management, 24(1):
University,
38-46.
http://ir.meiho.edu.tw/handle/98765432

1/1473. Dean, T. J.; Brown, R. L.; and Bamford, C. E.

(1998). Differences in Large and Small


Cohn, T. and Lindberg R.A. (1974). Survival
Firm Responses to Environmental
and Growth: Management and
Context: Strategic Implications From a
Strategies for the Small Firm. New
Comparative Analysis of Business
York: American Management
Formations. Strategic Management
Association.
Journal, 19(8): 709-726.

Çakır, H.M.(2013). Nakit Döngüsünün Firma


European Commission. (2012). Annual Report
Karlılığına Etkisinin Sektörel Analizi.
on Small and Medium-sized
Journal of Yaşar University, 30 (8):

4948-4965.

Financial Management Challenges In Small and


Medium-Sized Enterprises: A Strategic Management Approach

Page |36| Emerging Markets Journal


Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

Enterprises in the EU: EU SMEs in Applied Sciences Journal, 9(9): 997-

2012: At the crossroads. 1002.

Güler, S. (2010). İstanbul Menkul Kıymetler Jindrichovska, I. (2013) Financial Management

Borsasına (İMBK) Kayıtlı Küçük ve in SMEs. European Research Studies

Orta Büyüklükteki İşletmelerin (KOBİ) Journal, 16 (Special Issue on SMEs):

Sermaye Yapıları Üzerine Bir 79-96.

Uygulama. Suleyman Demirel


Jindrichovska, I.; Ugurlu, E.; and Kubickova,
University, The Journal of Faculty of
D.. (2013). Changes in Capital
Economics and Administrative
Structure of Czech SMEs: A Dynamic
Sciences, 15(3): 353-371.
Panel Data Approach, Ekonomika a

Güngör, N. and Öndeş, T. (2013). Kobi’lerin Management, 2(3): 36-49.

Finansmanı Erzurum Organize Sanayi


Kaya, S. and Alpkan, L. (2012). Problems and
Bölgesinde Bir Araştırma. İktisadi ve
Solution Proposals for SMEs in
İdari Bilimler Dergisi/Journal of
Turkey, EMAJ: Emerging Markets
Economics and Adminstrative
Journal, 2(2): 178-196.
Sciences, 27(1): 59-71.

Kennedy, J. and Tennent, B. (2006). Financial


Hall, G. and Young, B. (1991). Factors
Management Practices in Small
Associated with Insolvency Amongst
Businesses: Regional and Metropolitan.
Small Firms. International Small
Small Enterprise Research, 14(1): 55-
Business Journal, 9(2): 54-63.
63.

Hallberg, K. (2000). A Market-Oriented


KOSGEB. (2011) KOBİ Stratejisi ve Eylem
Strategy for Small and Medium-Scale
Planı 2011-2013, http: //www . sanayi.
Enterprises. IFC Discussion Paper 40.
gov . tr /

Hunjra, A. I.; Butt, B. Z.; and Rehman, K. U. Files/Documents/KOSGEB_Katalog.pd

(2010). Financial Management f

Practices and Their Impact on


KOSGEB.(2012). Enhancing The
Organizational Performance. World
Competitiveness Of SMEs in Turkey,

Country

Hande Karadag
Emerging Markets Journal | P a g e |37
Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

Report.http://www.comcec.org/UserFil McMahon, R. Holmes, P.; Hutchison, S.; and

es/File/%C3%BClkeraporlar%C4%B1/ Forsaith, M. (1993). Small Business

28_isedak_%C3%BClke_rap/T%C3% Financial Management: Theory and

BCrkiye.pdf. Practice, Journal of Management, l

(15): 5-19.
Koyuncugil, A. S.; and Ozgulbas, N. (2006). Is

There a Specific Measure for Financial Meredith, G. G. (1986). Financial Management

Performance of SMEs. The Business of the Small Enterprise. McGraw-Hill,

Review, Cambridge, 5(2): 314-319. Sydney, New South Wales.

Kutlu, H. A. and Demirci, N. S. (2007), Mintzberg, H. (1994). Rise and fall of strategic

Kobi’lerin Finansal Sorunları ve planning. Simon and Schuster.

Çözüm Önerileri. 4. KOBİ’ler ve


Nguyen, K. M. (2001). Financial Management
Verimlilik Kongresi.
and Profitability of Small and Medium

Liberman-Yaconi, L.; Hooper, T.; and Enterprises. Theses..

Hutchings, K.. (2010). Toward a Model


Nurrachmi, R. N.; Abd Samad, K.; and
of Understanding Strategic Decision-
Foughali, I. (2012). The Development
Making in Micro-Firms: Exploring the
of SMEs in Turkey. Strategic
Australian Information Technology
Management Journal, 11: 124–136.
Sector. Journal Of Small Business

Management, 48(1): 70-95. OECD, Organisation for Economic Co-

operation and Development (2004).


Liu, Z. (2010). Strategic Financial
Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises in
Management in Small and Medium-
Turkey, Issues and Policies. http://
Sized Enterprises, International Journal
www. oecd. org/ industry /smes /3193
of Business & Management, 5(2): 887-
2173.pdf
894.

OECD, Organisation for Economic Co-


Lukács, E. (2005). The Economic Role of
operation and Development (2006).
SMEs in the World Economy,
The SME Financing Gap (Vol. I):
Especially in Europe, European
Theory and Evidence. OECD.
Integration Studies, 1(4): 3-12.

Financial Management Challenges In Small and


Medium-Sized Enterprises: A Strategic Management Approach

Page |38| Emerging Markets Journal


Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

OECD, Organisation for Economic Co- Pleitner, Hans J. (1989). Strategic Behavior in

operation and Development (2012). Small and Medium-Sized Firms:

SME Policy Index Western Balkans Preliminary Considerations.". Journal

and Turkey,2012. OECD. of Small Business Management, 27

(4): 70-75.
Okafor, R. G. (2012). Financial Management

Practices of Small Firms in Nigeria: Salazar, A. L.; Soto, R. C.; and Mosqueda, R.

Emerging Tasks for the Accountant, E. (2012). The Impact of Financial

European Journal of Business and Decisions and Strategy on Small

Management, 4(19): 159-169. Business Competitiveness, Global

Journal of Business Research (GJBR),


Ondes, T. & Gungor, N. (2013). Kobi’lerin
6(2): 332-349.
Finansmani Erzurum Organize Sanayi

Bolgesinde Bir Arastirma. Ataturk Snodgrass, D. R. and Biggs, T. (1996).

University Journal of Economics and Industrialization and the Small Firm:

Admistrative Sciences, 27 (1). Patterns and Policies. ICS Press.

Özdemir, S.; Ersöz, H. Y.; and Sarıoğlu, H. İ. Storey, D. J. (1994) Understanding the Small

(2011). Küçük Girişimciliğin Artan Business Sector. Cengage Learning

Önemi ve KOBİ’lerin Türkiye EMEA.

Ekonomisindeki Yeri. Sosyal Siyaset


Şahin, O. (2011). Kobi'lerde Finansal
Konferansları Dergisi, 12(3): 67-83.
Performansı Belirleyen Faktörler.

Peel, M. J. and Wilson, N. (1996) Working Zonguldak Karaelmas University

Capital and Financial Management Journal of Social Sciences, 7(14): 76-

Practices in the Small Firm Sector, 91.

International Small Business Journal,


Topal, Y.; Erkan, M.; Elitaş, C. (2006). Küçük
14(2): 52-68.
ve Orta Boy İşletmelerin Finansal

Pham, H. (2010). The Impact of Financial Yönetim Uygulamaları: Afyonkarahisar

Management Practices on Profitability Örneği, Süleyman Demirel

of Small and Medium Enterprises Üniversitesi, İ.İ.B.F. Dergisi, 11(1):

(SMEs) in Vietnam. Master’s Thesis. 281-298.

Hande Karadag
Emerging Markets Journal | P a g e |39
Volume 5 No 1 (2015) | ISSN 2158-8708 (online) | DOI 10.5195/emaj.2015.67 | http://emaj.pitt.edu

Tolentino, A. L. (1995. Guidelines for the Zonooz, B. H.; Farzam, V.; Satarifar, M.; and

Analysis of Policies and Programmes Bakhshi, L. (2011). The Relationship

for Small and Medium Enterprise Between Knowledge Transfer and

Development, International Labour Competitiveness in "SMEs" with

Office. Emphasis on Absorptive Capacity and

Combinative Capabilities, International


TURKSTAT, Turkish Statistical Institute.
Business and Management, 2(1): 56-78.
(2013). http://www. turkstat . gov . tr /

Pre HaberBultenleri.do?id=15881..

Wheelen, L. T. and Hunger, D. (2010).

Strategic Management and Business

Policy–Achieving Sustainability.

Pearson International Edition.

Wickham, P. A. (2006). Strategic

Entrepreneurship. Pearson Education.

Wilson, I. (1994). Strategic Planning Isn't

Dead—It Changed. Long range

planning, 27 (4): 12-24.

Worldbank. (2014). Doing Business Report.

http://www.doing business .org /data

/explore economies/turkey/

Zimmerer, T. W. and Scarborough, N. M.

(2005). Essentials of Entrepreneurship

and Small Business Management: the

Foundations of Entrepreneurship, The

United States of America: Pearson

Education.

Financial Management Challenges In Small and


Medium-Sized Enterprises: A Strategic Management Approach

Page |40| Emerging Markets Journal

You might also like