Professional Documents
Culture Documents
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/283044615
CITATIONS READS
0 302
4 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Muhammad Hafeez Osman on 21 October 2015.
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. All in-text references underlined in blue are added to the original document
and are linked to publications on ResearchGate, letting you access and read them immediately.
International Conference on Advances in Civil and Environmental Engineering 2015
© Faculty of Civil Engineering, Universiti Teknologi MARA Pulau Pinang
Abstract
When a distributed load from a structure is applied to a soft soil stratum, there will be some
settlement of the structure. The term settlement refers to the vertical downward
displacement at the base of a foundation or other structure due to ground improvement.
This settlement may be due moisture movement, seismic disturbance, and adjacent
excavation and so on. The compressibility characteristic of the marine clays is usually
determined from consolidation test by using an apparatus called an oedometer. In this
paper, test was assist by geotechnical software Data System 7 (DS7) that is functioning to
analysis of test data to produce the data results required by the standards. The remoulded
samples were taking at the Seberang Perai Utara and Seberang Perai Tengah as a material
used in consolidation test. The analysis data of consolidation test was used to draw e/logσ '
curve by using Casagrande’s method with only loading stage is carried out. Data result
from the consolidation test was used to find the correlation between compression index and
initial void ratio. Linear equation from correlation for Seberang Perai Utara is Cc =0.3599e0
- 0.1925, for Seberang Perai Tengah is Cc =0.506e0 - 0.5515. Meanwhile, the correlation
for combined area is Cc =0.3685e0 - 0.1984. Linear equation from these correlations will
use to predict the settlement within scope of paper areas. The preconsolidation stress value
from e/logσ' curve also consider used as a useful guide to limit the settlement in over
consolidated clays.
Keywords: marine clay; compression index (Cc); initial void ratio (e0); oedometer test;
consolidation; settlement;
1. Introduction
Compression index is determined by conducting oedometer test. Whereby,
undisturbed specimen is applied with loading plates. These loading plates are
equal to certain pressure According to Balasubramaniam and Brenner (1977), a
lot of correlations regarding compression index and physical properties of soil.
Extensive researches had been carried out to find correlation between
1
2 OSMAN M.H., ALBAR A., MD. HASAN A.S.,OSMAN M.
compression index and basic physical properties of soil. The compression index
had been correlated with properties like initial void ratio, water content and liquid
limit. The current methods of finding compression index of soft soil are quite
complicated and time consuming. Deformation due to elastic compression and
that due to expulsion of air from voids, take place immediately on application of
load, but deformation due to removal of water takes place gradually. We are left
with only two types of compression deformations, which cause reduction in
volume of soils. Out of these two, the first one is caused by compaction i.e.
change in volume due the removal of air and reduction of pore space and is an
immediate process, whereas the second one occurs due to removal of water from
the pores on sustained loading, and is caused by consolidation, which is a slow
and a gradually process. The soil compression characteristic is a fundamental
mechanical property of the soil that relates the effect of compressive stress on a
soil volumetric parameter. Typically, the characteristic is illustrated by plotting a
logarithm (usually to base 10) of the normal compressive stress (σ') against soil
void ratio (e) or vertical strain (ε). When expressed in this way, the characteristic
has two distinct regions, an elastic rebound curve at low stress and a linear virgin
compression curve at a higher stress. The modulus of the slope of the virgin
compression curve is commonly called the compression index (Cc). Soil
condition are apt to change, often considerably, from before, to during, and also
after construction. Most building damage occurs when unforeseen soil conditions
arise, inadequate site investigation and a lack of understanding of soil behaviour
are largely to blame. Methods are available such as consolidation test by which
both the amount and the rate of foundation settlement can be estimated. These
estimates will remain reasonably reliable providing that the assumed soil
condition represent the actual conditions, and likely to persist throughout the life
of the building. By using Oedometer or Consolidation test, the compressive index
can be estimated. The index is a slope of the normal compression line (NCL) that
measured from the plotting graph e/log σ ' curve. The data collected from the
oedometer test enable changes in void ratio to be related to changes in effective
stress.
2. Soil Profile
According to Bergado et al. (1994), most of the coastal area in Malaysia,
Philippines, Taiwan and Hong Kong are normally consolidated marine clay.
Hence, this type of soil profile invites many -problems to the construction such as
stability and settlement. According to Abdullah & Chandra (1987), the soil
profiles on the west and east coast of Malaysia consist in most cases of layer of
soft clay, stiff clay, silty clay, sandy clay and sand. A typical soil profile is shown
in Figure 1. The soft clays are generally grey in colour and are marine in origin,
supplemented with the presence of seashell fragments at many locations. Soft
coastal alluvial deposits occur widely in the coastal areas of Peninsular Malaysia.
Their general distribution is in Figure 2.
The thickness of soft clay sedimentation can reach up to 30 m (Ting & Ooi,
1977). The thickness of soft clay in Peninsula Malaysia is shown in Table 1
According to Flodin and Broms (1981), until 1948, soft clay that have shear force
less than 25 kPa. In terms of their particle size, their size is less than 0.002 mm.
Craig (1993) had classified clay as follows:-
Soft clay can be physically moulded by light finger pressure. The typical
compression ratio is about 0.2 to 0.4 and coefficient of consolidation, (cv) is about
0.5 to 1.5 m2/year for this type of soil (Neoh, 2000). Soft clay characteristics are
different from normal clay. The depth of the soft clay also affects some portion of
the characteristic.
Table 2 : Correlation of Compression Index (Cc) and Initial Void Ratio (e0)
(Sridharan and Nagraj, 2000)
needed for various calculations in soil mechanics. Usually most of the values fall
within a range of 2.50 to 2.90. From the specific gravity test that doing in
laboratory, the values fall in range 2.00 to 2.20 for Seberang Perai Utara and
range 2.00 to 2.30 for Seberang Perai Tengah. It means the overall values for both
locations fall in range 2.00 to 2.30. The types of soil basically were influence the
value of specific gravity. Marine clay is soft clay and basically value of specific
gravity was decrease when soft clay is used. The marine period is known to have
been influenced greatly by the inflow of fresh water. The clay size content,
plasticity and natural water content increase with increasing distance from the
ocean. The results summary are shown in Table 4.
Minimum Maximum
Site
Seberang Perai Utara 2.03 2.18
Seberang Perai Tengah 2.03 2.25
Correlation graph below shown that linear equation for Seberang Perai Tengah in
Pulau Pinang is Cc = 0.506e0 - 0.5515. Meanwhile the value of R- squared is
0.6383 for linear regression. From the analysis data, R-squared value is over 50%.
It means the correlation is strong and can used to predict the settlement within
scope of paper area.
Cc versus e0
1.2
Comoression Index (Cc)
0.8
0.6
0
2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 3 3.1
Initial Void Ratio (e0)
Correlation graph above shown that linear equation for Seberang Perai Utara and
Seberang Perai Tengah in Pulau Pinang is Cc = 0.3685e0 - 0.1984. Meanwhile the
value of R- squared is 0.5626 for linear regression. From the analysis data, R-
squared value is over 50%. This percentage represents how strong the correlation
between compressive index and initial void ratio of the paper area. It means the
correlation is quite strong and can use to predict settlement within scope of paper
area.
10 OSMAN M.H., ALBAR A., MD. HASAN A.S.,OSMAN M.
Cc versus e0
1.2
0.8
0.6
y = 0.3685x - 0.1984
0.4
R² = 0.5626
0.2
0
2.3 2.5 2.7 2.9 3.1 3.3 3.5
Initial Void Ratio (e0)
In this paper, remoulded sample of marine clay from different location in Penang
which is Seberang Perai Utara and Seberang Perai Tengah is tested. From the test
that were done in the laboratory, correlation between compression index and
initial void ratio of samples in Seberang Perai Utara and Seberang Perai Tengah
had been acquired. The correlations are shown in Equation 2 and 3. Meanwhile,
combination of correlation for both areas is shown in Equation 4.
Linear equation from correlation for sample of Seberang Perai Utara is:
Cc = 0.3599e0 - 0.1925 Equation 2
Linear equation from correlation for sample of Seberang Perai Tengah is:
Cc = 0.506e0 - 0.5515 Equation 3
The compression index, Cc shows the how amount of sample being compressed.
The index was obtained from the calculation the slope of the virgin curve. If the
sample is unloaded to a certain amount, which usually 1/4 of the total pressure,
and load back, the unloading and reloading line can be seen. This line shows the
elastic behaviour of the soil. Theoretically the line should parallel with the line
before the preconsolidation pressure. For this paper, some of the compression
curve from the analysis, some of the unloading line did not parallel with upper
line. This is maybe due to disturbance to loading plate of the consolidation test.
During the test, the particle size is deformed. During unloading, the deformation
of the particle back to the original size. This behaviour is called elastic
deformation. Consolidation test is a test where the water is forced out by the
pressure applied. During it been applied, the water seep out from the specimen.
When the water seeps out, there is a void between the particles. So, with high
amount of pressure, the soil particle to rearrange to fill the void.
The linear equation represents the value of compression index is proportional with
initial void ratio. This equation can be used to predict the settlement. This
Oedometer test and subsequent calculation can be used to predict with some
degree of accuracy, changes in the elevation of building components over time.
As theoretical, when a distributed load from the structure is applied to a soft soil
stratum, consolidation settlement will occur. Because the hydraulic conductivity
of clay is significantly smaller than of sand, the excess pore water pressure
generated by loading gradually dissipates over a long period. Thus, the associated
volume change in the clay may continue long after the immediate settlement. The
settlement caused by consolidation in clay may be several times greater than the
immediate settlement. So this paper as possible will help to predict settlement in
construction.
8. Conclusion
From this research, one of objective that is to find the correlation between
compression index and initial void ratio of remoulded Penang Marine Clay is
achieved. This correlation is proven exist with linear equation from correlation
graph.
1) The linear equation from correlation between compression index and initial
void ratio is useful to predict a settlement in construction especially in
Seberang Perai Utara and Seberang Perai Tengah. The linear equation for
combine areas of paper is Cc = 0.3685e0 – 0.1984.
2) This paper also was achieved it second objective to determine the
compressibility characteristics of the Marine clay by using Oedometer test.
As theoretical, when structures are built on soil there will be some settlement
of the structure. This settlement due to several things like moisture content,
seismic disturbance, adjacent excavation and so on, but the most probable
cause is voids between soil grains being eliminated as the weight of the
structure presses down on the soil. The voids between the soil grains are
usually filled with either air or water. As construction progresses, air are
expelled from the void rather quickly, the soil grains move closer together
and settlement reaches its limits.
3) Settlement usually ceases sometimes during construction or shortly after
completion of the structure. In this case, the consolidation is one of the
primary tests that almost used. Along the research is conducted, the
Oedometer test is used to get the result and make some calculation that would
be applied in correlation according to main objective of research.
References
1) Abdullah, A.M.L.B. & Chandra, S. (1987), Engineering Properties of Coastal
Subsoil in Peninsular Malaysia, Proc. of the Ninth Southeast Asian
Geotechnical Conference, 7-11 Dec. 1987, Bangkok, pg 5-127, 5-146.
2) Balasubramaniam and A.S, Brenner R. P. (1981), Consolidation and
Settlement of Soft Clay, Soft Clay Engineering, Elsevier Scientific
Publishing Company.
3) Bergado, D.T. et al. (1994), Prediction Of Behaviour Of Reinforced
Embankments On Muar Clay Deposits, Procurement Of The Symposium on
Prediction versus performance in Geotechnical Engineering Bangkok,pg 145-
157.
4) Brenner et al. (1981), Engineering Geology of Soft Clay, Soft Clay
Engineering (Development in Geotechnical Engineering), Volume.20,
Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, pg 159-230.
5) BS 1377 (1990), Method of Test for Soil for Civil Engineering Purposes,
British Standard Institution.
6) Craig, R.F. (1993), Craig's Soil Soil Mechanic, Fourth Edition,
12 OSMAN M.H., ALBAR A., MD. HASAN A.S.,OSMAN M.