You are on page 1of 16

Learning from the Nolli Map: Representing

the Landscape through Figure-Ground

César Torres Bustamante

ABSTRACT Cartographic practices associated with INTRODUCTION


planning and designing cities, landscapes, and buildings Cartographic practices associated with planning and
rely on maps for representing three-dimensional envi- designing cities, landscapes, and buildings rely on
ronments in two-dimensional depictions. The simplest two-dimensional depictions to represent three-
depiction is figure-ground, a method that allows a clear dimensional environments. The various strategies
and powerful reading of a space through a binary map- that illustrate subsurface, temporal, aqueous, and ter-
ping of built space (object) and empty ground (field). The restrial conditions form a rich and symbolic language
most influential example of figure-ground is Giambattista that describes existing and imagined landscapes.
Nolli’s 1748 Pianta Grande di Roma; Nolli’s figure-ground These strategies use representational techniques capa-
technique was adopted in the 1960s by faculty at the ble of persuasion, description, and projection
Cornell University Urban Design program as a primary (Desimini and Waldheim 2016). The minimal carto-
tool for formulating their urban design theories. The most graphic visualization is figure-ground, a convention
common use of figure-ground focuses on a binary orga- that allows a clear and powerful reading of the space
nization that creates false hierarchies and denotes figure through a binary method that separates the object
and ground as exclusionary poles, privileging the figure from the field. Figure-ground is the “simplest possi-
and legitimating its position. Elizabeth Meyer argues “for ble representation of urban texture” (Ratti and
a definition of landscape architecture as a hybrid activity Richens 2004, 2), and it is built on the perception of
that is not easily described using binary pairs as opposing fills as shapes. Traditionally the figure, or built space,
conditions” (Meyer 1997, 50); this way of thinking limits is shaded in black, leaving the ground empty, or
our ability to see, listen, and create. Figure-ground renders white when delineated on paper.
© 2020 by the Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System

the landscape amorphous or totally dependent on the Figure-ground maps offer a reductionist graphic
depicting the plan-form of buildings that omits most
Landscape Journal 39:1 ISSN 0277-2426 e-ISSN 1553-2704

building for its shape and structure. This article reviews


the origin of figure-ground and focuses on two perceptual levels of information typically mapped in built-up
principles used in Pianta Grande di Roma (proximity and areas, such as topography, highway infrastructure, or
contour) that could arguably shift figure and ground from administrative boundaries. These maps are the most
biased and exclusionist poles, into mutualistic and con- common type of images used in town planning to
tingent entities. This alternative perception of figure- represent objects or buildings, and they reveal voids
ground may allow a better integration of the ground within formed by streets, squares, gardens, parks, and out-
the figure and offers the potential to map in-between door spaces (Hebbert 2016). The figure-ground
conditions, temporalities, and changes in the landscape. technique was used by Giambattista Nolli in his
1748 Pianta Grande di Roma and was revived by
KEYWORDS Figure-ground, mapping, poché, raster, con- Colin Rowe in his urban design theories during the
tour, Gestalt mid-20th century. Rowe’s figure-ground interpreta-
tion was a simplification of Nolli’s technique. A
deeper look into the Nolli map reveals opportunities
to reconceptualize figure-ground relationships using
Gestalt principles of contour and proximity as

Learning from the Nolli Map: Representing the Landscape through Figure-Ground 39
representation methods. This article reviews the ori- FIGURE-GROUND
gins of figure-ground as an 18th-century mapping The term “figure-ground” evolved in the science of op-
technique, its revival during the mid-20th century, tics and psychology, denoting the processes by which
its consequent adoption in planning as a represen- the eye and brain distinguish objects in a visual field.
tational procedure, and its potential in mapping Gestalt psychology focuses on explaining the stability
materials and temporalities in landscape architecture. and coherence of everyday experiences via perceptual
processes, the most important of which concerns the
Approach to Analysis distinction between figure and ground. Figure-ground
The following section places the representation relies on the visual discernment of regions to recognize
technique of figure-ground in a chronological car- figures and forms instead of lines and curves: to see a
tographic framework. It starts with the emergence figure, one must be able to group regions within which
of the method as an alternative to iconography and figures appear (Dent 1996). Starting in the early 20th
elaborates on its widespread use during the 18th century, Gestalt psychology established theoretical
century with the seminal example of Nolli’s Pianta principles like heterogeneity, contour, surroundedness,
Grande di Roma. The technique fell into abeyance orientation, size, convexity, and familiarity that assist
with modernism and was resurrected by Colin in the recognition of figures (MacEachren 1995;
Rowe and Fred Koetter in their figure-ground Robinson et al. 1995; Tyner 2010).
plans. Their drawings reduced the complex form of Colin Rowe was familiar with Gestalt theory and
the city to a black-and-white plan (poché). How- its application to the visual arts, and as a Renaissance
ever, this reduction simplified figure and ground to historian, he knew the Nolli map (Caragonne 1995).
binary and hierarchical relations and overlooked In the mid-1960s, Rowe and Fred Koetter started
two perceptual principles that appear in the Nolli teaching at Cornell University (Koetter met Rowe
map: proximity and contour. These principles, dis- previously while earning his master’s degree in
cussed in the subsequent sections, are presented not architecture from Cornell). Their ideas about con-
from a semiotic perspective but within a Gestalt textualism denounced the failures of modernist urban
psychology framework to understand their graphic planning and its destructive consequences in the his-
constitution and visual qualities and their potential toric city. In Collage City (1978), Rowe and Koetter
in cartography to reconstitute figure and ground. A interpret the city as the location where, over time, the
section focusing on proximity explores the idea of cultural and political aspirations of its citizens shaped
perceived spaces in between figures when drawn its built form—the city was seen as a memory theater,
with parallel patterns, as presented in specific sec- “a record of a man’s aspirations and failures” (Hurtt
tions of the Nolli map. The discussion includes a 1982, 71). They used two methods of analysis and
literature review that frames this interstitial condi- drawing in representing their urban design theories:
tion in architecture and landscape architecture and one was the aerial axonometric (an aerial perspective
ends with an example of its use in depicting land- that reveals the spatial qualities of a sector in a city),
scape architecture elements. A subsequent and the other one was an abstract technique to depict
examination of “contour” investigates the figure’s urban space, referred to as figure-ground. Rowe and
ability to represent changes over time based on var- Koetter used the figure-ground technique to simplify a
iations in edge definition. Changes are exemplified three-dimensional complexity into a two-dimensional
by analyzing detailed representations in Pianta plan that clarifies the structure and order of urban
Grande di Roma that illustrate the current and past spaces. A figure-ground approach to spatial design is
conditions of important buildings. The article con- an attempt to manipulate the solid and void relation-
cludes by outlining the limitations of a simplified ships by adding, subtracting, or changing the physical
black-and-white mapping technique and asks for geometry of the pattern (Trancik 1986).
the incorporation of perceptual principles in urban
study and landscape architecture mapping to po- Origins
tentially capture a more complex figure-ground The cartographic representation of settlements dates
relationship. back to circa 6200 BCE wall paintings of Çatal

40 Landscape Journal 39:1


Hüyük in central Turkey (Elliot 1987). In many or palm and justice as a blindfolded figure holding a
cases, the style of representation was dictated by the sword and scales. Iconographies were heavily orna-
materials used for inscription, such as the ground mented and often contained realistic depictions of
plans of Tuba, a suburb of the city of Babylon. These miniature buildings. The precision of a site plan was
fragments of clay tablets demonstrate the typical Ba- sacrificed for a more pictorial cartographic style, and
bylonian style of incising in straight strokes, where the illustration served little use for way-finding or ur-
possible, as the clay was usually too soft to permit ban management.
curved lines. Although no town plans survive from An alternative approach to iconographies is
ancient Greece, the symmetrical form of cities sug- documented in the Imola map of 1502 by Leonardo
gests that urban surveying was a well-developed da Vinci, an exact survey-based plan that is not icon-
science. The legacy of Roman land surveyors (agri- ographic but ichnographic: it represents the ground
mensores) survives in fragments of marble tablets plan of buildings instead of their appearance (Harvey
bearing parts to a larger city plan of Rome. The agri- 1980). Cesare Borgia, son of Pope Alexander VI,
mensores’ techniques were lost at the end of the asked da Vinci to produce a survey to strengthen
Western Roman Empire in the 5th century CE, and the town’s fortifications. To construct the survey,
reemerged in Europe between the 9th and 12th cen- military engineers needed a different kind of
turies with the copying of the treatises of the representation that depicted the layout of sites, struc-
agrimensores. Most plans are unscaled “picture tures, routes, spaces, and barriers (Hebbert 2016).
maps” in which walls and buildings are drawn in In producing an ichnographic survey suitable for
profile in a simplified ground plan. military purposes, da Vinci used new technologies
Realistic depictions of 15th-century European (e.g., a special odometer and a magnetic compass)
towns started appearing in painting backgrounds and to accurately measure and record proportions and
manuscript miniatures (Elliot 1987). These realistic relationships between land features. The Imola map
impressions of urban areas were typically drawn introduced a novel technical precision in cartography
from a bird’s-eye viewpoint, even though aerial with the use of scaled ground plans, which later be-
travel was not attainable at that time. During the came common throughout northern Europe during
Renaissance, the prevalent study of projective the first half of the 16th century.
geometries and perspective drawings had a direct ef- Until Theatrum Orbis Terrarum, the first true
fect on urban cartography. By the 17th century, these urban atlas published in 1570, the portrayal of cities
views privileged the city’s architectural splendors was usually rendered through paintings, manuscripts,
over the street patterns. The bird’s-eye view allowed book illustrations, or details on topographic maps.
a cartographer not only to convey the dimensionality Theatrum Orbis Terrarum was a systematic collec-
of the buildings and architectural features but also tion of maps of uniform style (Elliot 1987). Further
to impress the power and grandeur of such work on developments in surveying methods improved urban
the reader. cartography through the 18th century. Newer maps
Elliot (1987) notes that urban cartography abandoned the decorative bird’s-eye and map-view
sought an emotional response that reflected the pride, forms, and town plans were produced to a higher
dignity, and sense of importance the city-dweller felt standard of accuracy.
for the community. Bird’s-eye views were character- The most influential and detailed ichnography
ized by meticulous illustrations of cities and of that time is Nolli’s Pianta Grande di Roma. The
buildings, as well as the inclusion of elaborate allego- mid-18th century was the culmination of a period
ries, metaphors, and symbols. In the history of of considerable urban development after the Re-
cartography, iconographies usually merged symbolic naissance and Baroque periods. Pope Clement XII
qualities of an art work, such as biblical scenes, por- decreed “a rational reorganization of [Rome’s] social
trayal of the influential person who commissioned and juridical administration through a finalized plan”
the work (a king or pope), or integrated abstract (Aurigemma 1979, 27). Pianta Grande di Roma was
concepts such as peace and justice. Peace was gener- published in 12 sheets (Figure 1), each measuring
ally represented as an angel holding an olive branch 44 cm · 69 cm, and it focused on documenting

Learning from the Nolli Map: Representing the Landscape through Figure-Ground 41
Figure 1
Plate 5 from Pianta Grande di Roma. The buildings are depicted as a solid color that contrasts with public interiors and spaces.
(Source: The New Plan of Rome by Giambattista Nolli part 5/12 (1748), Public Domain. https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index
.php?curid=4364463.)

modern Rome without use of any preexisting data. (see Figure 1). The map abandoned traditional
Every building, ruin, apartment block, and alley had perspectival views and made a clear and legible dis-
to be measured anew to ensure the greatest precision. tinction between public and private spaces for the
In addition to creating an ichnographic map, Nolli first time (Warner 2005).
employed unusual techniques for the time, including Cartographers and historians have found Pianta
orienting the map with north located at the top of the Grande di Roma to be a source of discoveries and
map (ending the practice of placing that cardinal di- insights, not only for the inclusion of unusual urban
rection at left), and distinguishing between true and elements (e.g., covered or open drains and water
magnetic north by including a compass rose that in- fountains) but also for the unique articulation be-
dicated both directions (Maier 2015). tween public and private space. Nolli carefully
Nolli’s preference for an ichnography generated delineated the interior plans of nearly 2,000 build-
a map that epitomizes the authoritative image of a ings, showing detailed plans of churches, theaters,
plan in which everything can be seen at once: “the courtyards, and porticos of buildings, as well as the
plan and section can never actually be experienced, entrances and stairways of major palaces (Verstegen
but through their privileged status as a visible object, and Ceen 2013).
they simultaneously represent and generate the Pianta Grande di Roma set a standard for sur-
whole” (Pai 2002, 56). The Nolli map revealed, vey accuracy at the scale of a whole city, which was
in an accurate figure-ground, the relationships of emulated by other maps. The ichnographic plan be-
buildings and spaces in the city: it showed publicly came the most recognizable style to vividly express
accessible interiors as extensions of the street realm the figure-ground basis of urban space during the

42 Landscape Journal 39:1


18th century. Although the figure-ground approach Koetter referred to this binary condition as the
was not the only technique used for mapping, the figure-ground phenomenon, Gestalt diagram, or
vast majority of map impressions on steel or copper poché. The term poché was commonly used at the
plates vividly expressed the figure-ground basis of École des Beaux-Arts in Paris, and its earliest re-
urban spaces. By the turn of the 19th century, the corded reference is Gustave Umbdenstock’s Cours
growing skills of surveyors and cartographers shifted d’architecture (1930). Umbdenstock, a French archi-
town plans from decorative to utilitarian objects, and tect who taught at the École Polytechnique, defined
by mid-century, the Industrial Revolution provided poché as a plan that contains all the sections of the
means to mass produce inexpensive, up-to-date street walls about 1 meter from the ground, seen from
plans (Elliot 1987). Rapid urban growth also meant below the ceiling. He believed that poché should
that town plans would quickly become obsolete and depict the protrusions or reliefs of the walls in rela-
required constant revisions by cartographers to keep tion to the ground, which could be tinted in any
up with the demands of a literate urban population. color (he recommends black because of its rigor and
The ichnographic plan became a city’s most readily monumentality).
recognizable urban identifier, and figure-ground dia- In The Study of Architectural Design (the only
grams were used to illustrate urban principles, such English publication on the Beaux-Arts method, com-
as Camillo Sitte’s publication City Planning Accord- monly used in US architectural schools until the late
ing to Artistic Principles (1889). 1940s), poché is defined as “the walls of a plan
The introduction of lithography from the 1820s blackened in; the study of a plan with reference to
onward made map-making easier and less expensive the walls and piers only” (Harbeson 1927, 310).
than laborious and costly engraving on copper. This This publication highlights the “richness” of poché
new technique was extensively exploited in the Uni- for monumental buildings formed by ornaments, ni-
ted States and Canada, with commercially produced ches, small columns, and so on. It also identifies
county and city atlases and a revival of the bird’s-eye hierarchies in the different parts of a building: for ex-
view to depict even the smallest communities. The ample, bigger rooms will usually have thicker walls
fast development of industrial societies shaped mod- to support the great spans required for the roof, and
ernism. Town planners started rejecting the street as these walls may have pilasters, engaged columns,
the primary public space and the facade as the public panels, or niches intended for the services of the
aspect of a building. Thus, modernism had no use for building. The “richness” of poché “give[s] scale and
figure-ground as a mapping technique. Figure-ground character to a plan” (Harbeson 1927, 137).
rarely appears in the postwar reconstruction plans of The ateliers or studios of the École des Beaux-
the 1940s and was absent from later modernism in Arts made a differentiation between two types of po-
the 1950s. Instead, the new urban design movement chés: poché pur, a tinting that highlighted structural
favored three-dimensional visual techniques such as elements, and poché dilué, a shading with a diluted
sketching and photography, or conceptual mapping ink for secondary elements such as non-load-bearing
where “figure-ground played no part” (Hebbert walls (Castellanos Gómez 2012). The Study of Archi-
2016, 712). tectural Design makes a similar recommendation for
drawing the poché:
Revival of Figure-Ground
The rediscovery of figure-ground in the mid-20th The poché is in black ink, both the outline drawn
century is attributed to Rowe and Koetter, who used with the ruling pen, and the surface between.
it as a primary graphic tool in formulating urban de- All the other lines of the plan are drawn with a
sign theories. The technique became a powerful diluted ink, and should be sufficiently dark so
pedagogical corrective to the idea that urban renewal that they will not be lost in the first washes of the
meant tabula rasa as it did not consider historical rendering after being rubbed (to remove pencil
context (Hebbert 2016). Figure-ground represented lines and dirt) in preparing the drawing for
built spaces with a fill and left as empty (or white) rendering—and yet not so dark as to conflict
space what was not building (ground). Rowe and with the poché. (Harbeson 1927, 138)

Learning from the Nolli Map: Representing the Landscape through Figure-Ground 43
In Complexity and Contradiction, Robert beth Meyer, this binary association blinds us from
Venturi (1977) used the term poché to discuss the seeing complex webs of interrelationships. The ar-
relationships between the inside and the outside of a rival of modern architecture and the binary pair
building, such as the spatial impressions and accom- architecture-landscape “have relegated the landscape
modations by the mass of a wall. According to to what is not architecture” (Meyer 1997, 47), con-
Venturi, an exterior wall should “induce simulta- ceptually and graphically.
neous awareness of what is significant on either side. This connotation of figure-ground is evident in
An in-between space in this sense provides the com- architectural historian Sigfried Giedion’s publication
mon ground where conflicting polarities can again Space, Time and Architecture, in which he character-
become twin phenomena” (1977, 82). The wall is izes architecture and nature as binary terms that are
not just a separation between inside and outside but juxtaposed and “directly confronted” (1967, 138). In
a device that mediates these spaces, characterized by Global City Blues, architect and urban designer Daniel
the “richness” of intermediary elements, such as pro- Solomon refers to the figure-ground drawing as a
trusions and depressions. “black plan,” a method of drawing a plan in which
Venturi’s poché highlighted the struggle between “buildings are depicted as solid black, and everything
the interior requirements of a building and those of else is the white of the paper” (Solomon 2003, 88–89).
its exterior shape. As a technique, it became an ap- Meyer argues that figure-ground has limited
propriate intellectual and representational tool that analytical capabilities in that these maps fail to
urbanists Rowe, Koetter, Leon Krier, and Rob Krier represent the spatiality of trees, landforms, and other
used against the object-focused architecture of Le “in-between” conditions. She refers specifically to the
Corbusier and other modernists, in which buildings notion of a forest or bosque as a solid mass: the spa-
were designed only as figural objects, while “space tiality of a grove of trees “is neither solid nor void,
[was] only a back-ground to those figures” neither figure nor field; it exists in an extraordinary
(Wortham-Galvin 2010, 62). Modernist architecture realm between the two that changes in layering, den-
constantly deferred to the efficient use of material sities, and transparencies from year to year and from
and construction practices, producing flat planes and season to season” (Meyer 1997, 57). Meyer ex-
generally rectangular volumes. In contemporary ar- emplifies efforts to address the spatiality of plants in
chitecture practice, poché has become more a the 1950s drawings of James Rose (where line and
drawing convention and less a spatial condition. tone drawings create transparency and layering) and
Poché represents the graphic code used in working in Garret Eckbo’s Landscape for Living bird’s-eye
drawings to denote the space between the outer and perspectives. Eckbo not only focused on the organi-
inner wall surfaces and to indicate the materials used zation of space in plants (a three-dimensional
(La Marche 2003). The simplification and objectifica- silhouette of complex and variable enclosure) and
tion of the technique is epitomized in Mario their kinetic character (“a living, growing struc-
Gandelsonas’s definition of the poché plan: “a plan ture”), he also communicated the spatial, structural,
where city blocks and building-objects have been re- and temporal character of plants as design material
presented as solids” (1999, 90). The shift in poché as using transparency and detailed texture in his per-
a representational technique omits Venturi’s building spectives (Eckbo 1950, 94).
interior-exterior struggles and highlights the objectifi- The prevalent use of poché as a graphic style in
cation of buildings. urban planning has been contested with some experi-
The contemporary use of the term poché centers mental visualization techniques that build on the
on a definition as mere representational graphic relational “in-between” condition of figure and
code, reducing the word’s ability to convey spatial ground. In the work of architect Mario Gandelsonas
richness and its capacity to render exterior or interior and landscape architect Nadia Amoroso, drawings
characters. City blocks and building-objects are the use poché techniques to represent nonbuilding enti-
solids, against a mute landscape, an “invisible back- ties. In his analytical drawings of the US city,
ground awaiting a building’s design to establish place Gandelsonas criticizes the traditional role of draw-
and order” (Meyer 1997, 47). According to Eliza- ings as static representations of the city and develops

44 Landscape Journal 39:1


mapping trees, offering an alternate understanding of
the city and questioning its configuration not only by
its solids but also by its public spaces.
The experimentation with poché techniques be-
yond the traditional architecture-landscape binary set
opens up possibilities for spatial representation.
More than just a drafting convention, poché can be
used to explore better integration between figure and
ground. This integration takes place at a perceptual
level: Gestalt principles of perception explain the
processes that assist in the visual discernment of fig-
ures. “Proximity” and “contour” are two of these
principles, and they were used as graphic techniques
for the construction of Pianta Grande di Roma. Both
principles show a potential to expand the perception
of the (solid) figure, which may be constructed using
transparency and layering effects.

PROXIMITY
The Gestalt law of proximity states that elements
that are close to one another appear to form groups,
and create the illusion of shapes or planes even if
these items are not touching. In the Nolli map, build-
ings appear to be poché or a solid fill (Figure 3,
right). However, a close inspection will show the ma-
jority of these figures are created using parallel fields
Figure 2 of lines: a “raster” pattern, as seen in Figure 3, left.
Greenbelt in Ottawa, Canada. Students were instructed to create Raster is a term borrowed from Latin rāstrum, a
a vegetative figure-ground for a 2 km2 area, then followed by a
zoom-in 500 m2 to create figure-ground of street block network “hoe with two to six tines” (Merriam-Webster n.d.);
and figure-ground of built form. (Image used with permission raster alludes to the parallel pattern left by this tool.
and courtesy of Daniel Rozanski and Hillary Eppel, from Nadia
Amoroso’s Landscape Architecture Design Studio course at the
Raster scan was a method used for image storage
University of Guelph.) and transmission in early computers and televisions,
based on a systematic line-by-line scanning process to
create an image. A parallel concept of the raster is
poché graphics that concentrate on articulating chan- seen as a painting technique by De Stijl artists at the
ges between architecture and city. As shown in beginning of the 20th century. Flatness was then seen
Figure 2, Amoroso asked her design studio students as a universal quality. De Stijl proponents advocated
to use poché to understand cities’ fabric and connec- that pure abstraction will not have a perspective of
tions. Figure-ground graphics of built form, street depth: the difference between the form and its sur-
blocks, and vegetative elements reveal the fabric, roundings (or between figure and ground) needed to
shape, patterning, and connective tissue of the city be eliminated in a painting. Vilmos Huszár and Piet
(Amoroso 2017). This representation assigns new Mondrian dissolved the visual illusion of depth and
subjects to the blackening of poché, rendering legible achieved an ideal flat composition in their paintings
figures that are not buildings. Although the approach by interweaving forms in a raster pattern (Blotkamp
is not innovative, the reading of a city based on the 1986; van Campen 1997).
patterns created by vegetative elements subverts the In Pianta Grande di Roma (see Figure 4), build-
conventional definition of the figure-ground map. It ings are perceived as a poché (a solid fill, almost
shifts figure from mapping only buildings into also black), but on close inspection, one can discern a

Learning from the Nolli Map: Representing the Landscape through Figure-Ground 45
Figure 3
Detail of plate 5 showing the raster figural pattern. The image on the left has been magnified 200% of its original size to enhance
the horizontal hatching; the image on the right shows a detail of plate 5 at its actual scale. (Source: The New Plan of Rome
by Giambattista Nolli, part 5/12 (1748). Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=4364463.)

Figure 4
Detail of Pianta Grande di Roma disegnata colla situazione di tutti I monumenti antichi (plate 2, volume 1) by Giovanni Battista Piranesi
(1756). The image on the left is a detail printed at the actual scale; the image on the right has been reduced 25%. Piranesi depicted
the plan of Rome and the location of antique monuments as fragments of a map. These fragments are placed on a flat surface
rendered gray using a horizontal hatch. The shadows projected by the map, the monuments and the artwork title (“ROME”) are
achieved through another pattern superimposed on the original hatch. Nevertheless, the additional superimposition does not result in
a completely solid black figure. (Source: Public domain, courtesy of Yale University Art Gallery, https://artgallery.yale.edu/collections
/objects/214783.)

46 Landscape Journal 39:1


Figure 5
Detail of plate 5 showing the double raster pattern. The image on the right (shown at actual scale) displays a portion of the Pantheon (top
center), a letter R that stands for rione or district (middle center), and the circular wall of the Baths of Agrippa rotunda (bottom center).
The image on the left is printed at a 200% enlargement, showing the superimposition of a double raster pattern. (Source: The New Plan
of Rome by Giambattista Nolli, part 5/12 (1748). Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=4364463.)

detailed horizontal linear parallel pattern. This tech- scious decision to include more information that
nique was not exclusive to Nolli’s work but was a otherwise would have been lost in a completely
convention that engravers used to represent blacked-out figure, thus subverting the exclusionist
shaded areas. condition of figure. The number of layers that one can
Figure 4 uses a closely spaced diagonal hatching add to this figural construction is limited by the avail-
to depict a gray background for an illustration that ability of interstitial figural spaces: figural raster is
maps fragments of ancient Rome by Giovanni Bat- formed by meaningful white space contained within it.
tista Piranesi. The space between the lines permits a It is important to find the right balance between
superimposition of additional information or layers: including additional layers and their discernibility as
the figure can include other figures onto itself by us- figures. Figural raster is perceived as a solid if the
ing the white spaces left by the pattern. In Piranesi’s composition lines are close to each other. The incor-
illustration, the additional pattern is seen as a sha- poration of ground in figural interstices allows for
dow projected on the background by the fragmented more figures to be included. Nevertheless, if the sepa-
pieces: this shadow is darker than the gray back- ration between lines is too great, the eye may have
ground, but it is not a completely solid black figure. difficulty perceiving it as a whole. This condition of a
This overlapping technique allowed 18th-century figure embedded in a ground is used by Peter Eisen-
cartographers to superimpose layers and include ad- man to analyze the spatial conditions of his United
ditional figures within figures. Nolli added the Nations project in Geneva, in which “the ground no
number and name of Rome’s districts, which appear longer frames the object, but becomes part of the ob-
as darker shapes on figural fields or a double raster ject itself, thus transgressing both the conditions of
pattern, as seen in Figure 5. The overlapping of fig- container and contained and the figure/ground
ures on figures shows that the technique not only dialectic” (Eisenman 1998, 34). Eisenman calls this
was driven by the technical requirements used in the subversive character of binary figure-ground the
engraving process at that time but was also a con- interstitial.

Learning from the Nolli Map: Representing the Landscape through Figure-Ground 47
Interstitial Figures and is therefore separate from the binary techniques
The interstitial presents a condition of figure-ground analyzed in this article.
that is neither all solid nor all void but something The interstitial character of the figure, which al-
that contains both. Eisenman questions the binary lows layering of additional figures, is a condition that
condition of solid and void as depicted in Piranesi’s painter and art theorist Gyorgy Kepes referred to as
1762 Campo Marzio dell’antica Roma engraving. transparency. In Language of Vision, Kepes writes
Piranesi was an Italian artist interested in mapping about an optical quality in which “figures are able to
who also helped in the publication of the Nolli map interpenetrate without an optical destruction of each
(Dixon 2002). In Campo Marzio, Piranesi “inserted other. Transparency however implies more than an
even in the smallest voids between the figure’s addi- optional characteristic, it implies a broader spatial
tional figures, which can be called interstitial figures” order” (1951, 7). Consequently, through transpar-
(Eisenman 1997, 243). These interstitial figures are, ency, a figure can superimpose and overlap on other
ideologically and graphically, a condition of space figures without losing its perceptual properties. This
and spacing: instead of a solid poché, they are “a condition is achieved by inserting interstitial figures,
presence within an absence” (243), setting up two which can be used to represent different materials and
conditions of figure. The figure is no longer inert or spatial conditions in the landscape, such as the various
static but a presence that is articulated. The rear- overlapping types of vegetation and their variations in
ticulation of the figure adds another layer to the height and densities in tree canopies or forests.
map: a relationship that avoids binaries and proposes Figure 6 shows a figure-ground map of Canberra
a new way of seeing that focuses on the “spaces in Parliamentary Triangle, drawn with a thin hatch to
between.” The ambiguous figure operates similar to map all permeable surfaces. The technique assigns
Meyer’s rediscovery of space between binaries, “the figural values to gardens with low vegetation, grassed
space of hybrids, relationships and tensions.” She parkland, and paths, and leaves a large central sec-
uses the phrase “articulated space” to define a “spa- tion of the map blank, denoting Lake Burley Griffin.
tiality between the built object and the figural void,” In the map, a thicker superimposed figural pattern
a “layered space” that relies on transparencies and represents the crown of deciduous trees. These two
densities (Meyer 1997, 58). figural layers map vegetation and distinguish be-
Nolli created interstitial figures in his (mono- tween grasses and trees. The conscious differentiation
chromatic) maps by superimposing figural patterns. assigns programmatic values to the ground, which is
The differentiation between figures can be also be consequently read as parking lots, roads, buildings,
done through tints (including poché pur and poché and so on. The superimposition of figures not only
dilué) or through encoded coloring. Designers and operates graphically but also reveals a spatial condi-
cartographers have used color techniques to create tion of surfaces; for example, none of the trees are
additional layers capable of articulating gradations planted in tree pits—they are all planted on grassed
and nuance. The diversity of figure-ground through areas or along vegetated strips.
color and shades is useful when a more detailed The construction of a figure pattern with poten-
character of the built fabric is needed, such as the tial for additional figural layering reveals more
distinctions between public-private, land-water, possible levels of information communicated for a
softscape-hardscape, vertical-horizontal, and single condition. This can be a useful mapping tech-
surficial-subterranean. Although the information is nique to translate temporal or enhanced conditions,
rich, the masses and voids, along with other layers, where figure and ground are no longer defined as op-
are not as immediately legible as they would be in a posing concepts but become “complementary aspects
classic figure-ground. Color allows for adding layers of the same medium” (Hoesli 1997, 95). The layering
but there is a trade-off between wealth of informa- of figures can address dynamics of the same agent or
tion and clarity of intention. The drawing can be a condition, such as variations on vegetation types
composite of so many figure-ground layers that it (vine, ground cover, root, herbaceous, shrub, under-
may “exceed the categorization” of a classic figure- story, and overstory layers) or seasonal changes in
ground drawing (Desimini and Waldheim 2016, 138) canopy density and growth for deciduous trees.

48 Landscape Journal 39:1


some sections of the Nolli map the contour may ap-
pear as a thicker line than the hatching pattern it
encloses, the contour disappears perceptually when
the map is seen from afar—as does the pattern. The
contour is only visible up close. From a distant view,
the principle of proximity visually merges the con-
tour with the figure.
Nolli used a variety of contours to convey
more information about Rome’s built environment,
such as the city’s condition at that time and its past
configuration. Surviving ancient buildings are
emphasized with a double raster pattern, so it is per-
ceived as a solid black to contrast with the hatched
gray of later constructions. An example of the dou-
ble raster pattern can be seen in the Pantheon, the
Baths of Agrippa, and the detail for the letter R for
rione or district in Figure 7. For partially ruined
structures, he distinguished existing architectural
members from those he had reconstructed by depict-
ing the latter in outline only. Nolli included
buildings that no longer stood, as long as there was
reliable record of them, by using stippling to “show
the conjectural nature of his representation” (Maier
2015, 216). These techniques illustrated the passage
Figure 6 of time, which is absent from other maps at that
Top image depicts Canberra Parliamentary Triangle with
parklands and Lake Burley Griffin (center), Kings Park (bottom time. The raster figure not only documented the cur-
left), Commonwealth Park (bottom right); the lighter figures rent condition of Rome, it also gave a glimpse of the
depict grassed parkland and low vegetation with deciduous trees
as a superimposed raster layer (darker figures). Bottom image past by including certain scenarios that left a trace in
shows parkland (lighter figure) with deciduous trees (darker the urban fabric.
figure), illustrating the two layers of figural patterns. (Bottom Some of these mapping techniques are com-
image is a 1800% enlargement of the rectangle at the left side of
top image). monly used in current graphic conventions to
represent spatial and temporal conditions and there-
fore may not seem innovative. For example, in
CONTOUR technical drawings, a continuous line style is used to
The Gestalt principle of contour, or “the place depict edges directly visible, and short-dashed lines
where the perceived figure appears to end” (Dent are used to represent edges that are not directly visi-
1996, 86), is also seen in the figural aspects of 18th- ble. The dashed line reveals a spatial condition that is
century ichnographies. Nolli drew sharp borders to no longer there (Nolli’s map) or that may be behind
limit the nearly 2,000 buildings and interiors in the other objects and thus not visible (technical draw-
inhabited center of Rome. The impenetrability of the ing). Similarly, the depiction of topographic contour
figure is well conveyed through this visual strategy, lines using continuous and dashed lines implies tem-
delineated by parallel filling to communicate the pri- poralities. The use of dashed and continuous lines for
vate character of such spaces. Pianta Grande di existing and proposed contour lines shows the poten-
Roma uses this customary contour to define figures, tial change in the terrain. Although this convention is
emphasizing the perception and legibility between inverse to Nolli’s representation, these uses of line
areas. Figures that lack contour generate a fuzzy style imply a temporal condition: a building that is
edge and weak experience of figure as they fade into no longer there (Nolli’s map) or a topographic con-
the background (MacEachren 1995). Although in figuration that is yet to be (proposed contour).

Learning from the Nolli Map: Representing the Landscape through Figure-Ground 49
Figure 7
Detail of plate 5 showing Teatro dei Satiri; the existing ruins are shaded in a darker raster pattern, while the footprint of the original
theatre is completed in an outline (image on the left is magnified 200%; image on the right printed at original scale). (Source: The
New Plan of Rome by Giambattista Nolli, part 5/12 (1748). Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=
4364463.)

Perception on the originally perceived black plan. The raster


The reading of figure-ground as poché depends on pattern of figural variations such as letters over fig-
the distance at which Pianta Grande di Roma is ures, lines over figures, and figures over figures only
read: parallel hatchings blend into gray from an aver- appears with close scrutiny.
age viewing distance (Verstegen and Ceen 2013). Its The amalgamation of contour in Nolli’s work
perception operates similarly to modern cartographic creates a perceptual figure, which varies from the
interfaces such as Google Earth and its zooming way Rowe, Koetter, and Wayne Copper used figure-
function, a feature that was inspired by Charles and ground to describe urban morphologies. At the Cor-
Ray Eames’s 1968 film Powers of Ten. The features nell University Urban Design studio, Rowe and
of the map transform and give the viewer access to Koetter used figure-ground to evaluate classical and
multiple distinct registers of information and the abil- modernist cities, and Copper identified reversibility
ity to see or read things that might not otherwise be between buildings and spaces (Copper 1983; Rowe
legible (Gretchen 2010). These perceptual qualities and Koetter 1984). Figure-ground maps are essential
are also exemplified by the uncanny nature of aerial in urban investigations because they juxtapose
photographs as they reveal aspects of the land that clearly articulated information to compare a city’s
would otherwise remain hidden or unseen. The change and growth across different periods of time
viewer must apprehend the aerial photographs in a or with different cities. These figure-ground patterns
slow and contemplative manner. At first glance, the focused on depicting a binary built void through a
images appear to be grasped immediately but then poché that no longer references the relationship be-
demand “to be read more as a map of a visual text tween figure and ground. Subsequently, these binary
that must be decoded” (Corner and MacLean 1996, depictions become a “simplified poché,” stripped
xvi). The initial perceptual intention of poché is from the perceptual differentiation between poché
achieved when the Nolli map is viewed from afar, pur and poché dilué, and from the general awareness
but when closely seen, one starts to find ambiguity between inside and outside.

50 Landscape Journal 39:1


When referring to Venturi’s use of poché, Rowe ture. As a representational tool, figure-ground offered
and Koetter recognized that the term was either control, constancy, and permanency to urban plan-
forgotten or relegated to a catalog of obsolete ners, but with limitations. Hebbert acknowledges
categories, particularly when used at the urban scale that the figure-ground technique is parsimonious and
as a mediator between two opposed conditions that the simplification of the city to a pattern of sol-
(Rowe and Koetter 1984). By the 1990s, poché was a ids and voids omits all the variables of interest to
well-established and effective tool to map the urban social science, as well as aesthetics, visual culture,
fabric. Michael Hebbert argues that the changes en- and ecology (Hebbert 2016). In The Genealogy of
abled by the computer, and the ability to deconstruct Cities, David Grahame Shane also recognizes that the
digital maps into layers, enhanced the value of the technique “severely [restricts] the information these
technique and made figure-ground “plentiful and ac- drawings could convey [and] urban designers [limit]
cessible as never before” (2016, 719). Hebbert also themselves to the plan in an effort to compress all the
points out that this accessibility increased with the information into a single surface” (Shane 2009, vii).
spread of figure-ground through the internet, not The use of poché to depict only buildings is com-
only in cartography and planning but also as a popu- monly found in contemporary urban maps. It creates
lar graphic for branding T-shirts, lampshades and a binary model with false hierarchies and amorphous
placemats. As evidenced by a course that University space, something Meyer (1997) referred to as the un-
College London offers to students seeking a career differentiated space surrounding a building.
in the built environment, the technique is a skill that Nolli’s Pianta Grande di Roma constructs intri-
can be learned online. In a free two-hour course, cate figures by layering linear patterns to convey the
the viewer can learn how to create a figure-ground past and present complexities in city form. Using Ge-
diagram, “one of the simplest and most common stalt principles of proximity and contour, the linear
diagrams used by planners and urban designers, patterned (rasterized) figures on the Nolli map may
showing which land is covered by buildings and be perceived as solid or inert and could articulate dy-
which is not” (UCL 2019). namic processes, densities, and variations, such as
Poché as a representational method remains seasonal changes between evergreen and deciduous
widespread in current urban design practices and is plants. The perception of figures can also incorporate
mostly used to represent the present, past, and future representations of landscape phenomena, such as
of towns and cities. As a technique, it is used to ana- spatiality, temporality, and materiality, which, ac-
lyze existing urban tissue, generate master plan cording to James Corner, are “unique to the medium
parameters for street alignment and dimensions, set of landscape” (Corner 2002, 146). Corner has also
frontage lines, and determine the footprint appropri- asked for propositions that do not necessarily have
ate for new construction. Poché construction does to be new and radical but rather “derive . . . from a
not require exceptional representational ability and, subtle realignment of codes and conventions of some
although tedious and time-consuming, is a “pure tool convention or technique” (Corner 1999, 164).
for urban design” (Hebbert 2016, 724). Reconstructing figures with proximity and con-
tour principles is an approach built on Corner’s idea.
CONCLUSION With realignment of the figure-ground convention,
This article identified techniques in Nolli’s Pianta a solid fill is dissolved to allow the figure to embody
Grande di Roma that create inclusive relationships representational features analogous to the spatial and
between figure and ground. The figural raster em- material conditions being mapped. For example,
braces a latent ground in which the figure is visually Amoroso’s figure-ground maps of trees reveal unex-
solid (poché) and allows for engaging visualization pected urban patterns. Through hatched patterns and
and interpretation, depending on the distance at contour definition, more layers of mapping infor-
which the map is viewed. mation could be added, such as tree species, health
The Cornell University Urban Design studio re- conditions, the trace of extinct species, or even the
vived the figure-ground in their urban design theories visualization of an urban tree canopy over time. The
as a critique to modernism’s object-focused architec- shift from a uniform line that limits figures into a

Learning from the Nolli Map: Representing the Landscape through Figure-Ground 51
figural raster allows for mapping dynamic edge con- Aurigemma, M. G. (1979). Giovan Battista Nolli. Architectural De-
ditions. Figural raster as a mapping tool can sign, Profile 20(3–4), 27–29.

document activity, exchange, hybridization, and in- Blotkamp, C. (1986). De Stijl, the Formative Years, 1917–1922. MIT
Press.
terreliance, not just between ecotones in natural
systems but also in cities and other built ecosystems. Caragonne, A. (1995). The Texas Rangers: Notes from an Archi-
tectural Underground. MIT Press.
In the postindustrial era, city edges are not “an ab-
Castellanos Gómez, R. (2012). Plan Poché. Fundación Caja de
stract line or vector . . . they exhibit physical width
Arquitectos.
in the real world” (Karl 2011, 70). They are the
Copper, W. W. (1983). The figure / grounds. Cornell Journal of
by-product of a plethora of cultural processes and
Architecture 2(Fall), 42–53.
needs, including active, redundant, or dormant ease-
Corner, J. (1999). Eidetic operations and new landscapes. In Re-
ments; political boundaries; waterfronts; and rivers. covering Landscape: Essays in Contemporary Landscape
A figural raster can map these interstitial edge spaces, Architecture, ed. J. Corner, 153–170. Princeton Architectural
transitional and reinforced edges, and other Press.
boundary-forming conditions. . (2002). Representation and landscape (1992). In Theory in
The reconstitution of figure-ground through ras- Landscape Architecture: A Reader, ed. S. R. Swaffield, 144–
ter is derived from subtle realignment of the mapping 165. University of Pennsylvania Press.
method used by Nolli in Pianta Grande di Roma; a Corner, J., & A. S. MacLean. (1996). Taking Measures across the
close reading of the Nolli map shows how this tech- American Landscape. Yale University Press.

nique achieves better integration between figure and Dent, B. D. (1996). Cartography: Thematic Map Design. Wm. C.
Brown.
ground. The figural raster is visually perceived as so-
lid, but its layering reveals and addresses dynamic Desimini, J., & Waldheim, C. (2016). Cartographic Grounds: Pro-
jecting the Landscape Imaginary. Princeton Architectural
figure-ground relationships. An approach to recognize
Press.
figural raster through perceptual principles of proxim-
Dixon, S. (2002). The sources and fortunes of Piranesi’s archaeo-
ity and contour expands the dimensions for realizing logical illustrations. In Tracing Architecture: Aesthetics of
interstitial spaces and dynamic edge conditions Antiquarianism, ed. D. Arnold & S. Bending, 49–67. Blackwell.
around figures. Similar to Eisenman’s understanding Eckbo, G. (1950). Landscape for Living. F. W. Dodge.
of solid/void and figure/ground as “conditions [that] Eisenman, P. (1997). Zones of undecidability: The interstitial fig-
are possibly embedded within one another” (Eisen- ure. In Anybody, ed. C. C. Davidson & Anyone Corporation,
man 2007, 53), rasterized figure and perceived 240–247. MIT Press.
contours allow ground to be embedded in the figure. . (1998). Zones of undecidability: The process of the inter-
This mode of representing and thinking creates an ac- stitial. In Anyhow, ed. C. C. Davidson & Anyone
tive reciprocity between figure and ground: in design Corporation, 28–35. MIT Press.
fields, it offers alternatives for graphic representation . (2007). Written into the Void: Selected Writings, 1990–
that articulate fluctuating and temporal conditions. 2004. Yale University Press.

As the landscape is a living biome with unfolding Elliot, J. (1987). The City in Maps: Urban Mapping to 1900. British
Library.
flows of before and after, it “cannot be spatially
reduced to a single point of view” (Corner 2002, Gandelsonas, M. (1999). X-urbanism: Architecture and the Ameri-
can City. Princeton Architectural Press.
147–148). Its constant flux and change cannot be
Giedion, S. (1967). Space, Time and Architecture: The Growth of a
captured in a single moment in time. This review of
New Tradition. Harvard University Press.
the raster technique with perceptual principles pres-
Gretchen, W. E. (2010). Distributed Urbanism: Cities after Google
ents a mapping approach that creates a dynamic
Earth. Routledge.
figure, which may be better able to communicate the
Harbeson, J. F. (1927). The Study of Architectural Design: With
fluid conditions and patterns in the landscape. Special Reference to the Program of the Beaux-Arts Institute of
Design. Pencil Points Press.
REFERENCES Harvey, P. D. A. (1980). The History of Topographical Maps: Sym-
Amoroso, N. (2017). The figure ground of cities. World Land- bols, Pictures and Surveys. Thames and Hudson.
scape Architect. https://worldlandscapearchitect.com/the Hebbert, M. (2016). Figure-ground: History and practice of a
-figure-ground-of-cities-by-nadia-amoroso/ planning technique. Town Planning Review 87, 705–728.

52 Landscape Journal 39:1


Hoesli, B. (1997). Addendum. In C. Rowe, R. Slutzky, & B. Hoesli van Campen, C. (1997). Early abstract art and experimental Ge-
(Eds.), Transparency (pp. 85–99). Birkhäuser Verlag. stalt psychology. Leonardo 30(2), 133–136.
Hurtt, S. (1982). Conjectures on urban form: The Cornell Urban Venturi, R. (1977). Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture,
Design Studio 1963–1982. Cornell Journal of Architecture 2 2nd ed. New York Graphic Society.
(Fall), 54–141. Verstegen, I., & Ceen, A. (2013). Giambattista Nolli and Rome:
Karl, K. (2011). Thin parks / thick edges: Towards a linear park Mapping the City before and after the Pianta Grande. Studium
typology for (post)infrastructural sites. Journal of Landscape Urbis.
Architecture 6(2), 70–81. Warner, N. (2005). The Monuments of Historic Cairo: A Map and
Kepes, G. (1951). Language of Vision. Paul Theobald. Descriptive Catalogue. American University in Cairo Press
La Marche, J. (2003). The Familiar and the Unfamiliar in and Bloomsbury.
Twentieth-Century Architecture. University of Illinois Press. Wortham-Galvin, B. D. (2010). The woof and the warp of archi-
MacEachren, A. M. (1995). How Maps Work: Representation, tecture: The figure-ground in urban design. FOOTPRINT 7,
Visualization, and Design. Guilford Press. 59–74.
Maier, J. (2015). Rome Measured and Imagined: Early Modern Maps
of the Eternal City. University of Chicago Press.
Merriam-Webster. (n.d.). Raster. Merriam-Webster.com. Retrieved AUTHOR CONTRIBUTION The author is solely
April 26, 2020, from https://www.merriam-webster.com responsible for developing and presenting all aspects of
/dictionary/raster this article.
Meyer, E. (1997). The expanded field of landscape architecture.
In Ecological Design and Planning, ed. G. F. Thompson & F. R.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS None.
Steiner, 45–79. Wiley.
Pai, H. (2002). The Portfolio and the Diagram: Architecture, Dis-
course, and Modernity in America. MIT Press.
AUTHOR César Torres Bustamante is an associate
Ratti, C., & Richens, P. (2004). Raster analysis of urban form.
professor of landscape architecture at California
Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 31, Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, whose
297–309. research interests include landscape representation,
Robinson, A. H., Morrison, J. L., Muehrcke, P. C., Kimerling, A. J., & mapping, diagramming, and visualizing temporal
Guptill, S. C. (1995). Elements of Cartography, 6th ed. Wiley. phenomena. He earned a B.Arch. from Universidad de
Rowe, C., & Koetter, F. (1978). Collage City. MIT Press. las Américas in Puebla, Mexico, and his MLA and PhD
Shane, D. G. (2009). Foreword. In C. P. Graves, The Genealogy of from the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology in
Cities. Kent State University Press. Melbourne, Australia. He teaches design studios,
Solomon, D. (2003). Global City Blues. Island Press. visualization, and 3D courses, in which he experiments
Trancik, R. (1986). Finding Lost Space: Theories of Urban Design. with conventional and innovative representation
Van Nostrand Reinhold.
techniques and media.
Tyner, J. (2010). Principles of Map Design. Guilford Press.
UCL. (2019). Urban graphics 1: The city footprint. UCL. https://
PEER REVIEW STATEMENT This article was subjected
www.ucl.ac.uk/short-courses/search-courses/urban
-graphics-1-city-footprint
to a blind review by at least two external peer
Umbdenstock, G. (1930). Course d’architecture. Ecole Poly-
reviewers.
technique.

Learning from the Nolli Map: Representing the Landscape through Figure-Ground 53
Copyright of Landscape Journal is the property of University of Wisconsin Press and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the
copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email
articles for individual use.

You might also like