Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT ley, 1984; Veizer et al., 1989). In contrast, Sawkins (1976) suggested that
Systematic temporal variations in the distribution of several im- the abundance of sediment-hosted Cu deposits (Fig. 1C) was related to the
portant groups of metal deposits reflect the cyclic aggregation and breakup of supercontinents in the Middle Proterozoic, Late Proterozoic,
breakup of large continents. In particular, metal deposits that form in and Phanerozoic. Our purpose is to show how such tectonic cyclicity
continental basins or are associated with anorogenic magmatism were resulting from the interaction between large continents, such as Pangea,
extraordinarily abundant in the Middle Proterozoic (2.0 to 1.4 Ga), and mantle convection (Anderson, 1982; Gurnis, 1988; Worsley et al.,
corresponding to the assembly of the first large continents. It is impor- 1985), combined with decreasing global heat flow, provides a relatively
tant to note that peaks in the abundance of continental metal deposits simple but coherent explanation for the uneven temporal distribution of a
also coincide with a postulated Late Proterozoic supercontinent (1.0 wide range of metal deposit styles.
to 0.8 Ga) and the near maximum extent of Pangea. In contrast, metal Cyclicity in orogenic and anorogenic activity has important implica-
deposits that form, or are preserved, in convergent-margin orogens tions for eustasy, seawater chemistry, and biotic evolution (Worsley et al.,
were most abundant in the late Archean (2.9 to 2.6 Ga), corresponding 1985), as well as the generation and distribution of continental crust, and
to a period of high global heat flow and rapid stabilization of continen- is, therefore, likely to affect both the spatial and temporal distribution of
tal crust, and the past 200 m.y., which corresponds to the present metal deposits. Numerical modeling of mantle convection and plate mo-
tectonic cycle. Similar mineralization was also present, albeit less tion by Gurnis (1988) confirms the conjectures of Anderson (1982) and
abundant, in Early Proterozoic orogens, as well as in Late Proterozoic Worsley et al. (1985) that fragments of continental crust move off upwell-
and Phanerozoic orogens. Future metals exploration may benefit from ing domes and aggregate above convective downwellings to form super-
the application of sequence stratigraphy, as used by the oil industry, to continents. Such large continents inhibit subduction and mantle cooling,
recognize such cycles, particularly in the Precambrian rock record. which results in buildup of heat, large-scale convective upwelling (includ-
ing hotspots), uplift of the continental lithosphere, injection of mantle
melts into the crust, extensive crustal melting, and eventually breakup and
INTRODUCTION divergence of continental lithosphere. The resulting continental fragments
In two important papers summarizing the distribution of mineraliza- may then be swept toward convective downwellings, where they reaggre-
tion through time, Meyer (1981,1988) clearly demonstrated that there are gate, initiating another cycle. Estimates of the time between assembled
characteristic peaks in the abundance of specific styles of metallic mineral- supercontinents are in the range from a few hundred to 2000 m.y. (Gurnis,
ization (Fig. 1). This uneven temporal distribution of different styles of 1988). Worsley et al. (1985) recognized an - 5 0 0 m.y. tectonoeustatic
metal deposit is related to three major factors: (1) the evolution of the cyclicity for the post Archean. Vail et al. (1977) recognized first-order
hydrosphere-atmosphere, (2) a secular decrease in global heat flow, and cycles (or megacycles) of 210 to 325 m.y. for the Phanerozoic, and
(3) long-term tectonic trends. The first of these has been extensively dis- Hoffman (1989) and Krapez and Horwitz (1992) interpreted megacycles
cussed (e.g., Holland, 1984) and has resulted in the restricted distribution of similar length for the North American Proterozoic and Australian Ar-
of deposit styles for which transport of metal is strongly dependent on chean, respectively.
oxidation-reduction conditions (e.g., banded iron formations in the Pre- In this scenario, metal deposits that are related to anorogenic magma-
cambrian; Fig. 1A). These deposit styles, therefore, are not discussed tism, or are preserved in intracontinental basins (anorogenic and continen-
further in this paper. Similarly, secular decrease in global heat flow is tal deposits), would be most abundant toward the end of a period of
thought to be responsible for the restriction of Kambalda-type, komatiite- aggregation and during the initial stages of the breakup of a large conti-
associated nickel deposits to the Archean and Early Proterozoic (Fig. 1 A). nent. Deposits that are related to convergent tectonics or preserved in
However, the relation between the abundance of specific metal de- orogenic belts (orogenic deposits) would be most abundant during periods
posit styles and long-term tectonic trends is less clear cut. For example, of rapid plate movement and supercontinent aggregation.
major peaks in the abundance of metal deposits that form, or are pre-
served, in convergent-margin orogenic belts (such as mesothermal lode METAL DEPOSITS, TECTONICS, AND TIME
gold and volcanogenic massive-sulfide mineralization; Fig. IB) in the late Phanerozoic
Archean (2.9 to 2.6 Ga), and metal deposits associated with either anoro- The Phanerozoic was dominated by the breakup of a Late Protero-
genic magmatism or continental sedimentation (such as Olympic Dam- zoic supercontinent, its reassembly as Pangea at - 3 0 0 Ma, and its
type U-Cu-Au mineralization, Ni, Cr, platinum-group elements [PGE], subsequent breakup. This provides the basis for interpreting evidence of
and Fe-Ti-V mineralization in layered intrusions, and sediment-hosted earlier supercontinent cycles in the Precambrian rock record. The near
Pb-Zn and Cu mineralization; Fig. 1C) in the Proterozoic are difficult to maximum assembly of Pangea (400 to 200 Ma) corresponded with a
reconcile with the now generally accepted idea that plate tectonic proc- period of widespread cratonic subsidence and the development of exten-
esses have operated since the late Archean. This metallogenic problem has sive intracontinental sedimentary basins (Kominz and Bond, 1991). At this
been explained in terms of an evolutionary trend in global tectonics from time there were important peaks in the abundance of sediment-hosted
an Archean permobile regime, through a stable cratomc Proterozoic, to the Pb-Zn and Cu mineralization (Fig. 1C). This mineralization is interpreted
operation of plate tectonics in the Phanerozoic (e.g., Meyer, 1988; Wind- to have formed in either epicontinental or foreland settings to the
.
Banded iron-formations
contain Ni sulfides and PGE mineralization, such as Norilsk (in Siberia)
1 III 1l l l l l l
Kambalda-type nickel
1 • 1
and Insizwa (in Transkei) also formed during the early stages of the
breakup of Pangea (Sawkins, 1990). Because they developed on thick,
relatively stable continental crust, these deposit styles are highly likely to
have been preserved.
In contrast, metal deposits that form or are preserved at modern
| i. 1 convergent-plate margins were particularly abundant during the past 200
A. Precambrian metal deposits m.y. (Fig. IB), following the breakup of Pangea. These deposit types are
most abundant in island arcs and basins along the margins of the Pacific
Ore type 3000 Ma 2000 1000 and include most types of gold deposits, volcanic-hosted massive sulfide
deposits, podiform chromite in ophiolites, and porphyry-style Cu and Mo
Cyprus-type mineralization (e.g., Sawkins, 1990; Sillitoe, 1989). The scarcity of
Volcanic-hosted sulfide
{ i . L.
Abitibi-type
nicka, 1973; Veizer et al., 1989).
I . • ii During the aggregation of a supercontinent, the likelihood of preser-
vation of metal deposits partly depends on whether they become part of
Kuroko
• illi
1
1 metamorphic-grade rocks following continental collision. The chance of
preservation of metal deposits that form in the upper crust is even lower in
Porphyry deposits
Porphyry coppers internal orogens than in peripheral orogens. However, deposits that form
in continental magmatic arcs (such as granite-associated and mesothermal
Uranium in
weathered profile i©
1
hosted massive sulfide mineralization is found in Phanerozoic orogens such
as the Caledonian-Appalachian and Hercynian orogenic belts in northern
America and Europe (e.g., Sawkins, 1990) and the Tasman fold belt in
Australia, which were active convergent margins during the aggregation of
Pangea.
I.
Anorogenic
intrusions
Kiruna-type
Late Archean
Olympic Dam-type
J. In terms of global tectonics, the extraordinary abundance of Au,
llmenite-anorthosite
..h volcanic-hosted massive sulfide (Fig. IB), and Kambalda-type, komatiite-
associated Ni (Fig. 1A) mineralization in late Archean greenstone belts
Lead-zinc in clastic
sediments
t , ,1®
1
Sediment-hosted sulfide
Lead-zinc in carbonates
Mississippi Valley type