Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Processed cheese is often expected to be a stable product with a very long shelf-life. However, even products without any
bacteriological contamination retain their high quality only for a few months at room temperature. During storage, structure and
flavour slowly change. The following possible causes for such changes are reviewed in the present paper: loss of water vapour,
hydrolysis of polyphosphates, changes in ionic equilibria, crystal formation, oxidation, nonenzymic browning, enzymatic activity as
well as interactions with packaging materials. The changes with age of processed cheese are influenced by four main factors: product
composition, processing, packaging and storage conditions (time and temperature). No work about the changes with age of ready-
made fondue appears to have been published.
15
lwt/vol. 35 (2002) No. 1
of commercial processed Emmental cheese and ready- Clostridium butyricum, Clostridium tyrobutyricum,
made Fondue. Actual information about chemical and Clostridium sporogenes can be destroyed. Post-sterilisation
physical changes in processed cheese is summarised in infection is prevented by hot filling (85–95 1C) into the
the present review article. packing (Sturm, 1998).
16
lwt/vol. 35 (2002) No. 1
by high-temperature condensation (Chambre and improve calcium binding (Berger et al., 1989; Caric and
Daurelles, 1997). They are hydrolysed in an aqueous Kalab, 1997). The rheological properties of various
solution (Berger et al., 1989). This reaction begins processed cheese slices were measured during 1 mo of
during melting and continues during the storage of storage at 4, 13 and 20 1C (Ney, 1988). A measuring
processed cheese (Ney, 1988). The hydrolysis quickly device was developed, which bends the slices until they
leads first to triphosphates and diphosphates (pyropho- break. The breaking angles generally decreased during
sphates) then more slowly to orthophosphates which are storage and were not caused by pH or loss of water
excellent pH buffers (Mair-Waldburg, 1958; Ruf and vapour. The results were described as a hardening effect
Gläser, 1971). A part of added polyphosphates is and related to the hydrolysis of polyphosphates
already hydrolysed during the melting process. The rest (Ney, 1988).
is completely hydrolysed after 7–10 wk of storage (Caric Klostermeyer (1990) reported measurements of the
and Kalab, 1997). The hydrolysis of oligo- and firmness, viscosity and elasticity of various processed
polyphosphates creates new acid functions thus lowering cheeses. Products containing phosphates first showed,
the pH-value of the product and inhibits an eventual pH however, a decreasing resistance after production. After
increase (Chambre and Daurelles, 1997). The buffering about 3 wk a minimum was reached, thereafter the
capacity of polyphosphates depends on the chain length: measured resistance rose again. This effect was not
the higher the chain length, the lower the buffering observed with products containing citrates as emulsify-
capacity. Commercial mixtures of emulsifying salts ing salt. The curves presenting minima or maxima often
often contain short-chain oligophosphates with the result from opposite processes, likely a slow destruction
required good balance of calcium binding and buffering of the primary gel structure and the formation of a
properties. Long-chain polyphosphates are added to secondary structure. The author supposes that these
17
lwt/vol. 35 (2002) No. 1
phenomena are related to precursors in the submicelle of cheese analogues made from rennet casein. The
range. plasmin content significantly influenced the proteolytic
and rheological changes during 1–35 wk of storage.
Beta-casein was more extensively hydrolysed than as1-
Changes in Ionic Equilibria casein. As rennet (EC 3.4.23.4) is a relatively heat-
sensitive enzyme, its activity in processed cheese seems
After the melting and cooling of processed cheese, the negligible (Mulvihill and McCarthy, 1993). Heat-stable
ionic equilibria and hence the pH settle slowly. During lipases may also be active: processed cheese made with
storage, the loss of water vapour and the hydrolysis of ripe Camembert cheese may develop a noticeable
polyphosphates in turn influence the ionic equilibria in lipolysis during storage (Morgenthaler, M. Gerber
processed cheese. In addition, interactions between Cheese Ltd., Thun, Switzerland: pers. comms., 2000).
protein, emulsifying salt, sodium and calcium influence
water binding and texture. Processed cheeses typically
become firmer during storage. Spreadable, ‘creamed’ Nonenzymic Browning
products should be stored below 20 1C, preferably at
10–15 1C, to avoid a firmer, shorter texture (Chambre Nonenzymic browning (‘Maillard reaction’) is an im-
and Daurelles, 1997). portant and widely occurring reaction in foods. The
primary reaction is the carbonyl-amine addition between
reducing sugars and amines (usually the e-amino groups
Formation of Crystals of lysine). It is followed by rearrangements, scissions,
hydrolyses and other carbonyl-amine reactions, as well
Crystals are due to compounds with a low solubility. as numerous further reactions (Feeney and Whitacker,
The following possible crystals have been reviewed 1982). The Maillard reaction and its prevention
(Berger et al., 1989; Caric and Kalab, 1997; Uhlmann have been reviewed (Feeney and Whitacker, 1982;
et al., 1983): calcium phosphate, calcium diphosphate, Pizzoferrato et al., 1998; Yaylayan, 1997). Its relevance
calcium lactate, lactose, crystalline amino acids such as in processed cheese was discussed by Berger et al. (1989).
tyrosine, and calcium tyrosinate. Crystals of emulsifying It plays a key role in products containing high amounts
salts may be observed in processed cheese as a result of of lactose (10–80 g/kg). During storage, especially at
(i) an excess of emulsifying salt, (ii) an unsuitable elevated temperatures, the formation of a brownish
mixture of emulsifying salts or (iii) insufficient dissolu- colour and an off-flavour limit the shelf-life of the
tion of the latter in the mixture during processing. product. The extent of Maillard reactions is reduced by a
Tyrosine or other crystals may act as nuclei for the lower lactose content, less severe heating conditions and
formation of further crystals (Berger et al., 1989; a lower storage temperature (Berger et al., 1989;
W. Berger, pers. comms., 2000). In general, the Piergiovanni et al., 1989). The influence of manufactur-
formation of crystals is favoured by excessive amounts ing procedures and composition of stirred-curd Cheddar
of emulsifying salts or lactose, a high calcium content in cheese were investigated for their effects on the non-
the natural cheese, a high pH-value and a long storage enzymic browning of processed cheese (Bley et al., 1985).
of the processed cheese at low temperatures (Caric and The correlation between galactose content of Cheddar
Kalab, 1997). and the brown colour intensity in process cheese was
Crystallisation on the surface of processed cheese slices very high. Faster cooling of processed cheese reduced the
is influenced by mechanical treatments as well as the intensity of brown colour. In another study, non-
phosphates/citrates ratio in the emulsifying salt (Uhl- enzymic browning of processed cheese was examined in
mann et al., 1983). Small white crystals, identified as a model system. The processing temperature and storage
calcium citrate or tertiary sodium calcium citrate, may temperature were found to be more important factors
occur on the surface of processed cheese slices (Berger than the concentrations of protein and lactose. The
et al., 1989). results indicated the advisability of storing processed
Microcrystals of calcium phosphate and calcium pyro- cheese at low temperature (approx. 5 1C), since otherwise
phosphate dihydrate have been described (Pommert the Maillard reaction continues during storage (Piergio-
et al., 1988). These microcrystals do not affect the taste vanni et al., 1989).
and the appearance of the processed cheese, in contrast
with the other crystals responsible for spots or lines on
the product surface. Reactions Induced by Light and Oxygen
18
lwt/vol. 35 (2002) No. 1
transparent foil are usually conditioned under a content. Other compositional factors such as lactose
protective atmosphere (nitrogen/carbon dioxide) with content or emulsifying salts also influence the shelf-life.
an oxygen content below 20 mL/L. Oxidative reactions Most changes with age can be slowed down by lower
leading to colour change (Kristensen et al., 2001) and storage temperatures.
the formation of off-flavour due to methional and While these global effects of storage on processed cheese
carbonyl compounds as well as cholesterol oxides are well known, this review clearly highlights the need
depend on processed cheese composition (oxidising for further research on specific topics such as changes in
and antioxidative components), light expose (emission equilibria and interactions between the product compo-
spectrum, intensity, duration) and properties of the nents. The chemistry of the system during the ‘hard-
packaging. Studies on various milk products, including ening’ of processed cheese as well as discrepancies
processed cheese, show, that the formation of cholester- between effects noted by various authors in different
ol oxides is negligible under normal processing and studies should still be experimentally explored and
storage conditions (Bosset et al., 1993). The influence of explained. Moreover, two main fields should be
different packaging materials (tin cans, polystyrene investigated: the storage of ready-made fondue, which
cups, LDPE tubs) and storage temperature was exam- was never dealt with, and the relationship between
ined in an Indian study (Goyal and Babu, 1991). storage duration and storage temperature.
Samples packaged in tin cans had the least chemical
changes.
Acknowledgements
Interactions with Packaging Materials
We are grateful to Mr Wolfgang Berger (Römerberg,
Germany), Mrs Annie Imbert (Fromageries Bel, Ven-
A typical aluminium foil (11–15 mm) for processed
dôme, France), Mr Robert Sieber (FAM) and Mrs
cheese is coated with a protective polymer and a
Gerda Urbach (Australia) for their careful review of the
polyvinyl co-polymer with a sealing temperature of
manuscript.
65–75 1C (Sturm, 1998). This coating protects the
aluminium from corrosion due to salts and acids present
in the matrix and also prevents the undesirable
migration of aluminium into the cheese body. Factors References
leading to the corrosion of aluminium foils have been
described (Flückiger, 1964; Berger et al., 1989; Meyer, BERGER, W., KLOSTERMEYER, H., MERKENICH, K. AND
1970). In an off-flavoured product packed in aluminium UHLMANN, G. Die Schmelzkäseherstellung. Ladenburg:
foil, Stark and Urbach found that the contaminant was Benckiser-Knapsack GmbH (1989)
BLEY, M. E., JOHNSON, M. E. AND OLSON, N. F. Factors
the vinyl monomer (G. Urbach, unpublished work by affecting nonenzymatic browning of processed cheese.
Stark and Urbach, pers. comms. 2001). Journal of Dairy Science, 68, 555–561 (1985)
Interactions with packaging materials were reviewed by BORLE, F., SIEBER, R. AND BOSSET, J. O. Photo-oxidation and
Gallmann et al. (1997). The migration of butylhydrox- photoprotection of foods, with particular reference to dairy
ytoluene (BHT) and Irganox 1010 into processed cheese products. An update of a review article (1993–2000).
Sciences de Aliments, 21, 579–598 (2001)
slices was measured (Schwope et al., 1987). Migration BOSSET, J. O., GALLMANN, P. U. AND SIEBER, R. Einfluss der
strongly depended on molecular weight: BHT with a low Lichtdurchlässigkeit der Verpackung auf die Haltbarkeit
molecular weight migrated faster than Irganox 1010. von Milch und Milchprodukten - Eine Übersicht. Mitteilungen
aus dem Gebiete der Lebensmittel und Hygiene, 84, 185–231
(1993)
CARIC, M. AND KALAB, M. Processed cheese products. In:
Conclusions FOX, P. F. (Ed). Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and
Microbiology. London, New York: Elsevier Applied
Processed cheese is a ‘semi-preserved food’ with a Science, pp. 467–505 (1997)
limited shelf-life. Products without bacteriological spoi- CHAMBRE, M. AND DAURELLES, J. Le fromage fondu. In:
lage retain their good quality typically only for ECK, A. AND GILLIS, J. C. (Coordinateurs). Le Fromage.
Paris: Technique et documentation Lavoisier, 3rd Edn,
4–12 mo at room temperature. During storage, appear- pp. 691–708 (1997)
ance, structure, colour and flavour slowly change. The EIDGENÖSSISCHES DEPARTEMENT DES INNERN Verordnung über
possible causes of these changes are: loss of water, die in Lebensmitteln zulässigen Zusatzstoffe, Bern: SR
hydrolysis of polyphosphates, changes in ionic equili- 817.021.22, 30.Januar (1998)
bria, formation of crystals, oxidation, nonenzymic FEENEY, R. E. AND WHITACKER, J. R. The Maillard reac-
tion and its prevention. In: CHERRY J. P. (Ed).
browning, enzyme activity, interactions with packaging Food Protein Deterioration. Mechanisms and Functionality.
materials. Several mechanisms for these changes can be ACS Symposium Series, vol. 206. Washington, DC:
active concurrently. American Chemical Society, pp 201–229 (1982)
The changes with the age of processed cheese can be FLÜCKIGER, E. Korrosion der Alufolie als Ursache für die
influenced by four main factors: product composition, Blähung von Schmelzkäse. Schweizerische Milchzeitung, 90,
231 (1964)
processing, packaging and storage conditions (tempera- GALLMANN, P. U., BOSSET, J. O. AND SIEBER, R. Lebensmittel,
ture and duration). Firm products retain their quality Verpackung und Stoffmigration, Lebensmittel-Technologie,
longer than spreadable products with higher water 30, 326–336 (1997)
19
lwt/vol. 35 (2002) No. 1
GOYAL, G. K. AND BABU, K. E. Influence of packaging and the Maillard reaction during processing and storage. Italian
storage on the chemical quality of processed cheese. Indian Journal of Food Science, 1, 11–20 (1989)
Journal of Dairy Science, 44, 274–279 (1991) PIZZOFERRATO, L., MANZI, P., VIVANTI, V., NICOLETTI, I.,
KLOSTERMEYER, H. Zur Struktur des Schmelzkäses - Fakten CORRADINI C. AND COGLIANDRO E. Maillard reaction in
und Hypothesen. Die Molkerei-Zeitung Welt der Milch, 44, milk-based foods: nutritional consequences. Journal of Food
214–219 (1990) Protection, 61, 235–239 (1998)
KRISTENSEN, D., HANSEN, E., ARNDAL, A., TRINDERUP, R. A. POMMERT, J. F., LLAEBE, J., PERIE, J., LEBUGLE, A. AND PUECH,
AND SKIBSTED, L. H. Influence of light and temperature on J. Observation and analysis of crystalline phases in
the colour and oxidative stability of processed cheese. processed cheese. Journal of Food Science, 53, 1367–1369,
International Dairy Journal 11, 837–843 (2001) 1447 (1988)
MAIR-WALDBURG, H. Anwendung und Wirkung kondensierter RUF, F. AND GLÄSER, A Einfluss der Hoch-Kurz-Sterilisation
Phosphate in Milcherzeugnissen. Kondensierte Phosphate in auf mechanische Eigenschaften des Schmelzkäses und
Lebensmitteln. Giessen: Brühlsche Universitätsdruckerei, dessen Phosphat-Schmelzsalze. Die Molkerei-Zeitung Welt
pp. 104–121 (1958) der Milch, 25, 1197–1201 (1971)
MARIACA, R., GAUCH, R., BERGER, T., BOSSET, J. O. AND SCHWOPE, A. D., TILL, D. E., EHNTHOLT, D. J., SIDMAN,
SCHÄR, W. Volatile compounds of Swiss processed cheese. K. R., WHELAN, R. H., SCHWARTZ, P. S. AND REID, R. C.
Mitteilungen aus dem Gebiete der Lebensmittel und Hygiene, Migration of BHT and Irganox 1010 from low-
89, 625–638 (1998) density polyethylene (LDPE) to foods and food-simulating
MEYER, A. Joha-Schmelzkäsebuch, Ludwigshafen: Benckiser- liquids. Food Chemistry and Toxicology, 25, 317–326
Knapsack GmbH (1970) (1987)
MULVIHILL, D. M. AND MCCARTHY, A. Proteolytic and STURM, W. Verpackung milchwirtschaftlicher Lebensmittel.
rheological changes during ageing of cheese analogues Kempten: Edition IMQ (1998)
made from rennet caseins. International Dairy Journal, 4, SWISS ASSOCIATION OF PROCESSED CHEESE MANUFACTURERS
15–23 (1994) (SESK), Jahresbericht 2000, Elfenstrasse 19, Postfach, CH-
MULVIHILL, D. M. AND MCCARTHY, A. Relationships between 3000 Bern 16 (2001)
plasmin levels in rennet caseins and proteolytic and UHLMANN, G., KLOSTERMEYER, H. AND MERKENICH, K.
rheological changes on storage of cheese analogues made Kristallisationserscheinungen in Schmelzkäseprodukten - I.
from these caseins. Journal of Dairy Research, 60, 431–438 Phänomen und Ursachen. Milchwissenschaft 38, 582–585
(1993) (1983)
NEY, K. H. Gerät zur Messung des Biegebruchverhaltens von YAYLAYAN, V. A. Classification of the Maillard reaction:
Schmelzkäsescheiben. Alimenta, 2, 31–36 (1988) A conceptual approach. Trends in Food Science and
PAQUET, D. La fonte des fromages: aspects physico-chimiques. Technology, 8, 13–18 (1997)
Cahier ENSBANA, Dijon: Janvier, pp. 227–241 (1988) ZEHREN, V. L. AND NUSBAUM, D. D. Process Cheese. Madison,
PIERGIOVANNI, L., DE NONI, I., FAVA, P. AND SCHIRALDI, A. Wisconsin: Cheese Reporter Publishing Company,
Nonenzymatic browning in processed cheeses. Kinetics of Incorporation, (1992)
20