Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/262346446
Introduction to the Special Issue Mobile Commerce: The Past, Present, and
Future of Mobile Commerce Research
CITATIONS READS
117 5,563
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by George Giaglis on 05 September 2016.
International Journal of Electronic Commerce / Summer 2012, Vol. 16, No. 4, pp. 5–17.
Copyright © 2012 M.E. Sharpe, Inc. All rights reserved.
1086-4415/2012 $9.50 + 0.00.
DOI 10.2753/JEC1086-4415160401
approach), which ran contrary to the Internet’s openness and user control culture
[7, 18]. Their market failure with customers deprived operators of incentives
to further develop them, thus rendering m-portals even less valuable to users
over time. This vicious circle essentially led to their withdrawal from today’s
m-commerce market.
Then, technological advances, such as the high speeds afforded by 3G
mobile broadband, coupled with the gradual retreat of the mobile operators
from the center stage of m-commerce business models and the emergence of
Internet-capable smartphones, gave rise to a second era of m-commerce (from
circa 2000), with users enjoying direct Internet access through their mobile
devices. Thus, m-Internet business models emerged and obliged traditional
e-commerce providers to tailor their Web sites’ design, interaction, and func-
tionality to the capabilities of mobile devices [1] so as to have their offerings
available through m-commerce as well. The successful introduction of the first
genuine (i.e., not originating from e-commerce) m-commerce offerings, such
as location-based services, coupled with the fast proliferation of smartphones
and microbrowsers around the world, drew the first sizable audiences of in-
novators (in marketing terms) to the m-commerce world and rapidly expanded
the value of the m-commerce market.
This, however, naturally also drew in the largest players in the ICT market,
who, seeing a tremendous market opportunity, started competing furiously
in the open m-commerce market. Companies such as Apple (iPhone, iPad,
iTunes), Google (Android), Microsoft (Windows Phone), and others developed
device and platform innovations that managed to capture large audiences in
various forms of, mostly closed-ended, mobile applications (m-apps) in what
can be termed the third era of m-commerce (circa 2007 to date). Such business
models popularized manufacturer-hosted third-party application distribu-
tion to combine the freedom of choice afforded by the open mobile Internet
with the network effect benefits of proprietary innovations to allow users to
discover, download, or purchase mobile applications, thereby creating a new
m-commerce ecosystem [9]. The huge audiences drawn to such m-apps have
in turn attracted similarly large groups of developers who compete to provide
the best offerings, thereby creating a large pool of m-apps that in turn draws in
even more customers. This “virtuous” circle has contributed to a huge market
success, with the value of the m-commerce market expected to reach $31 bil-
lion in the United States alone by 2016, a figure that accounts for 7 percent of
online retail and 1 percent of total retail [11].
an analysis of published sources and empirical work. The road map classifies
m-commerce research into four dimensions, namely, technology (infrastructure
and devices), service (applications, content, payments), value (business models,
users/workers), and enablers (security and privacy, policy, and regulation).
Further, the authors used the results of surveys and workshops to synthesize
and prioritize short-, medium-, and long-term research challenges in each of
these dimensions.
We are aware of no other studies that have taken a holistic view to analyzing
m-commerce research, but there are works that have taken a narrower stance
to examine particular m-commerce dimensions, for example, mobile payments
[3], context-aware systems [8], and mobile marketing and advertising [15,
16]. Hence, we set out to investigate how research in the field has matured in
the years since the aforementioned publications and how this maturity cor-
responds to the actual dynamics of m-commerce practice discussed earlier.
We performed an analysis of m-commerce-related journal articles from
2000 to 2011 by querying Thomson Reuters’s Web of Science database with
the terms mobile, wireless, pervasive, and ubiquitous. We included the latter two
terms because pervasive and ubiquitous information systems represent the
next step of mobile computing systems and share significant similarities [10].
We narrowed our results to articles that have been published in top informa-
tion systems (IS) and e-commerce journals, excluding engineering-oriented
sources, such as IEEE transactions journals. All references were exported into
an Endnote database, including the following data: year of publication, authors,
article title, journal, abstract, and keywords.
We first computed the distribution of published articles per source and
per year. Then, we classified each article under the five axes of the Ngai and
Gunasekaran framework. Based on this, we report a trajectory of the pub-
lished m-commerce research and we discuss avenues for further research in
the field.
Our search yielded 1,031 articles from 41 journals (see Table 2). Almost a quar-
ter of the articles (22.4 percent) were published in two journals, namely, the
International Journal of Mobile Communications and Telecommunications Policy.
This is unsurprising considering the scope of both journals (IJMC focuses on
mobile communications, and TP is concerned with policy, regulation, and
governance issues of telecommunications systems).
It is interesting to note that some of the top IS journals (e.g., Information
Systems Research, Journal of Management Information Systems, MIS Quarterly,
and Journal of the Association for Information Systems) are low on the list, having
published only a few articles related to m-commerce. This may be somewhat
expected considering the high publication lead time of these journals and the
narrow focus of m-commerce against the entirety of the IS research field. Still,
it is notable how the practical significance of the m-commerce market diverges
from the interest that seems to be paid to the field by researchers and top
journals, despite the potential of the field to inspire the development of new
theories and models in several areas of IS research, such as design science, user
adoption, decision making, and strategy formulation. Interestingly, in 2012,
MIS Quarterly published a large-scale study of mobile Internet consumers
in which Venkatesh et al. [17] refined their unified theory of acceptance and
use of technology (UTAUT) to include three additional constructs: hedonic
motivation, price value, and habit.
articles, or 16.7 percent of the total), Network Infrastructure (125 articles, 12.1
percent), and User Infrastructure (103 articles, 10.1 percent).
in the early days of m-commerce research, strategy and economics was the
preferred subject of m-commerce theorists.
This special issue originated from ideas and discussions that took place during
the Ninth International Conference on Mobile Business (ICMB 2010), which
was jointly organized with the Ninth Global Mobility Roundtable (GMR 2010)
in Athens, Greece, in June 2010. IJEC’s editor-in-chief agreed with the confer-
ence organizers (the guest editors of this special issue) on the transformational
nature of m-commerce practice and the significant challenges it poses for
research in the area, and approved this special issue as an outlet where state-
of-the-art research on m-commerce would be presented to provide an overview
of the current status and future prospects of the field. Proving the significant
interest of researchers in the area, the call for papers for this special issue in
September 2010 attracted 60 submissions, which were reviewed in a double-
round, double-blind review cycle. In the first round, the guest editors with
external reviewers short-listed 21 papers, which were then further reviewed
with the help of a team of 30 external reviewers. We would like to thank all
the authors who submitted their work to this special issue, all the reviewers
of both rounds for their hard work and constructive comments, and IJEC’s
editor-in-chief for his continuous support and enthusiasm—their contribution
to the quality of this special issue cannot be stressed enough.
In line with the m-commerce publication patterns presented in the previous
section, the majority of initial submissions were behavior and adoption studies.
Specifically, almost half of the submissions (29 articles in total) discussed vari-
ous types of adoption models in several application fields, including mobile
banking, mobile entertainment services, mobile video, and others.
Business model and economics issues also had a strong presence in the
special issue submissions. Nine submitted articles investigated all aspects of
the mobile ecosystem—from firm performance to m-commerce value chain
orchestration and service distribution models. Interestingly, two articles
discussed the emergence and growth of app stores and explored how these
platforms affect the strategy of m-commerce value chain actors.
We also received four papers presenting the architecture and results of
m-commerce applications and cases in fields such as parking, exhibits man-
agement, and learning. Likewise, we received three submissions discussing
software implementations supporting data management for location-based
services, personalized workforce communications, and analysis of user reviews
to evaluate mobile apps.
The remaining fifteen submissions were distributed to taxonomies and lit-
erature reviews of m-commerce (three articles), models investigating the social
dimension of m-commerce (social networks and word-of-mouth effects—four
articles), development of research instruments and design and evaluation
frameworks of m-commerce applications and technologies (three articles),
segmentation and user modeling studies (three articles), one study on mobile
References
1. Adipat, B.; Zhang, D.; and Zhou, L. The effects of tree-view based pre-
sentation adaptation on mobile web browsing. MIS Quarterly, 35, 1 (2011),
99–121.
2. Barnes, S.J. The mobile commerce value chain: Analysis and future
developments. International Journal of Information Management, 22, 2 (2002),
91–108.
3. Dahlberg, T.; Mallat, N.; Ondrus, J.; and Zmijewska, A. Past, present and
future of mobile payments research: A literature review. Electronic Commerce
Research and Applications, 7, 2 (2008), 165–181.
4. de Reuver, M., and Haaker, T. Designing viable business models for con-
text-aware mobile services. Telematics and Informatics, 26, 3 (2009), 240–248.
5. Dhar, S., and Varshney, U. Challenges and business models for mobile
location-based services and advertising. Communication of the ACM, 54, 5
(2011), 121–128.
6. Fouskas, K.G.; Giaglis, G.M.; Kourouthanassis, P.E.; Karnouskos, S.;
Pitsillides, A.; and Stylianou, M. A roadmap for research in mobile business.
International Journal of Mobile Communications, 3, 4 (2005), 350–373.
7. Goncalves, V., and Ballon, P. Adding value to the network: Mobile
operators experiment with Software-as-a-Service and Platform-as-a-Service
models. Telematics and Informatics, 28, 1 (2011), 12–21.
8. Hong, J.Y.; Suh, E.H.; and Kim, S.J. Context-aware systems: A litera-
ture review and classification. Expert Systems with Applications, 36, 4 (2009),
8509–8522.
9. Jain, A. Apps marketplaces and the telecom value chain. IEEE Wireless
Communication (August 2011), 4–5.
10. Kourouthanassis, P.E.; Giaglis, G.M.; and Karaiskos, D.C. Delineating
“pervasiveness” in pervasive information systems: A taxonomical frame-
work and design implications. Journal of Information Technology, 25 (2010),
273–287.
11. Mulpuru, S. Mobile commerce forecast: 2011 to 2016. June 17,
2011.<<What type of work is this? Also, provide organi-
zation and location>>
12. Mylonopoulos, N.A., and Doukidis, G.I. Introduction to the special
issue: Mobile business: Technological pluralism, social assimilation, and
growth. International Journal of Electronic Commerce, 8, 1 (2003), 5–22.
13. Ngai, E.W.T., and Gunasekaran, A. A review for mobile commerce re-
search and applications. Decision Support Systems, 43, 1 (2007), 3–15.
14. Ngai, E.W.T.; Li, C.L.; Cheng; T.C.E.; Lun; Y.H.V.; Lai; K.H.; Cao, J.; and
Lee, M.C.M. Design and development of an intelligent context-aware deci-