Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/345495856
CITATIONS READS
3 5,202
6 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Muhammad Zahid Latif on 22 November 2020.
ABSTRACT
Introduction: A variety of research studies have shown that caffeine usage is highly prevalent among
university students and many of them have different perception of its effect on their mental and physical
health. These perceptions can influence the intake of caffeine which may lead to its addiction, resulting in
serious public health consequences. Aims & Objectives: The objective of the study is to determine the
frequency of caffeine consumption and the perception of its effects among university students. Place and
duration of study: This study was conducted within 6 months duration, from May 2018 to October 2019
among students of three private universities in Lahore, Pakistan. Material & Methods: This was a
descriptive cross-sectional study. A sample size of 670 university students was taken and the data were
collected from three private universities of Lahore through convenience sampling technique. The perception
of effects of caffeine was determined through a pre-validated questionnaire, Caffeine Expectancy
Questionnaire (CaffEQ) from consumers and nonconsumers of caffeine. Results: A total of 670 university
students participated in the study, out of which, 278 (41.5%) were males and 392 (58.5%) were females. 506
(75.5%) participants were consumer of caffeine, while 164 (24.5%) were non consumer. The occurrence of
caffeine consumption was more in males (79.9%) than in females (72.4%). Participants reported that they
consume caffeine because it makes them feel more alert (83.4%), they experience caffeine withdrawal
without caffeine (83%) and caffeine makes them feel more energetic (80.6%). The perceptions due to which
participants don't consume caffeine were that they expect caffeine makes their heartbeat irregular (81.7%),
they don't like the way caffeine makes them feel (80.5%) and caffeine makes them irritable (76.8%).
Conclusion: The study concludes that male students had more tendencies towards caffeine consumption than
females. Perceptions for consuming caffeine were feeling of alertness, experiencing caffeine withdrawal
symptoms, feeling of energy and ability to work over long periods of time after having caffeine. The
perceptions for not consuming caffeine were irregular heartbeat, bad feelings, irritability, and sleep
disturbances.
Caffeine is believed to be the most widely used habits and hereditary traits.4 Although the moderate
use, 400 mg/day is considered safe but children
psychoactive substance globally and easily especially girls in the reproductive age are at higher
accessible in Pakistani society.1 It is commonly used risk of adverse issues due to the altering quantity of
as an additive in drinks manufactured for weight caffeine intake.3
reduction, sports enhancement and medications.2 The consumption of caffeine among youth is
Caffeine is the constituent of variety of food sources remarkably high worldwide and variety of
including tea, coffee, drinks and chocolates. The caffeinated products are easily available.5 The
amount ranges from 40 to 180 mg/150 ml for coffee, regular use of caffeine has been reported among
24 to 50 mg/150 ml for tea, 15 to 29 mg/180 ml for 92% of college students in United States.6 Another
cola, 2 to 7 mg/150 ml for cocoa, and 1 to 36 study conducted among Dutch university students
mg/28g for chocolate.3 The common use of the concluded that 87.8% participants ingested caffeine
46
Caffeine Consumption & Perception of Its Effects Amongst University Students
products during the last 24 hours.7 The consumption MATERIAL AND METHODS
of caffeine products among Canadian youth adults
was found to be 73.6%. Similarly, high (94%) A descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted
proportion of university students in Pakistan during a period of six months, from May 2018 to
consumes caffeinated products.8 The intake of October 2019 after taking approval from the Ethical
caffeine reported is 97% in India and 98.5% in Review Board of Azra Naheed Medical College.
United Arab Emirates.9,10 The data was collected from the students of three
The literature describes multiple positive and private universities of Lahore, Pakistan. The sample
negative factors related with regular caffeine size was calculated by taking Z1-α/2= 1.96
exposure. Caffeine may enhance multiple cognitive (Standard normal variate at 5% type I error), P=
and behavioral processes which are associated with 0.68 (Expected proportion in population)and d=
effective sports, exercise and cognitive performance 0.05(absolute error).8 The required sample was 335,
like concentration, energy levels, and feelings of however to improve the power and accuracy of
fatigue. The moderate intake of caffeine may study, it was increased to 670. Non-probability
enhance alertness, decrease tiredness and reduces convenience sampling technique was adopted and
the risk of certain diseases.11 On the other hand, the three private universities in Lahore were selected.
negative effects of caffeine consumption include Students were approached in common areas of
hunger suppression, mood swings, sleep problems universities including cafeterias, grounds, mosques
and anxiety.12 The abrupt withdrawal in chronic etc. Students of age group 18-25 years (both male
caffeine users may lead to severe headache, muscle and female) were included in the study. Drug
pain, stiffness, vomiting and nausea.13 The excessive addicts and pregnant female students were excluded.
consumption of caffeine is associated with multiple The perception of effects of caffeine was
health related adverse effects like cardiovascular determined through a pre-validated questionnaire,
problems, decrease in bone density and calcium Caffeine Expectancy Questionnaire (CaffEQ) from
deposition.4,8,9,14,15 consumers and nonconsumers of caffeine.18 A
Caffeine is also used as an analgesic due to its pain written Informed consent was taken from 698
relieving effects.16 Although it reduces fatigue, but students, out of which 21 refused to take part in the
the excessive quantity may lead to intoxication and study and seven were not fulfilling the inclusion
result in insomnia, anxiety and restlessness. The criteria. A total of 670 students filled the
above mentioned health concerns are challenging questionnaire. The questionnaire comprises of 7
after consumption of pharmacologically active factors, out of which 5 factors were describing
caffeine. However, the psychological variations perception that led to consumption, and 2 factors
such as determination, motivation, mood states and were describing perception that led to
beliefs are associated with perception of oral nonconsumption of caffeine. Consumers and
caffeine consumption nonconsumers were asked about the perception for
The use of caffeine in youngsters especially students consuming and not consuming the caffeine
in the form of coffee, tea, energy drinks and respectively. These seven factors include 47
chocolates is an established phenomenon. The questions, each of which was individually validated
excessive intake may lead to addiction, resulting in in a previous study. The validity of individual
serious public health consequences. Based on the questions ranges from 0.36-0.98 and reliability of
review of the literature, a gap was detected questionnaire ranges from 0.80 to 0.94.18 The data
regarding caffeine consumption and its perception was analyzed through SPSS version 24. The data
among university students.17 This study aims to was analyzed by using the Chi-square test and a p-
determine the frequency of caffeine consumption value of ≤0.05 was considered as significant.
and the perception of its effects among university Statistical analysis:
students. The findings will help to overcome the Data was entered and analyzed by using SPSS 24.
issue through awareness, educational programs and The quantitative variables e.g. age were presented as
also improve the quality of life of university Mean ± S.D. The qualitative variables e.g. gender
students. and perception of effects of caffeine was presented
as frequencies and percentages.
RESULTS
47
Caffeine Consumption & Perception of Its Effects Amongst University Students
the total subjects, 278 (41.5%) were males and 392 Perception of effects of caffeine in
Frequency %
(58.5%) were females, 506 (75.5%) participants consumers
were consumer of caffeine, while 164 (24.5%) were Suppress feeling of hunger 390 77.1
non consumers. Caffeine consumption was more in Decrease appetite 342 67.6
Appetite
males (79.9%) than in females (72.4%). The p value Suppression
Allows to skip meals 310 61.3
Helps to avoid eating more
(0.03) calculated through chi square test showed that (n=506)
than usual
298 58.9
gender was associated with caffeine intake and Helps to control weight 316 62.5
caffeine consumption among males was Caffeine makes friendlier 354 70
significantly higher than females. The most Conversations are better
318 62.8
common form of caffeine intake was tea (54.1%) with caffeine
followed by coffee (22.9%), chocolates (13.4%) and Social/Mood Feel more sociable after
having caffeine
354 70
energy drinks (9.5%) respectively. (Table-1) Enhancement
(n=506) Feel more confident after
Perception of effects of caffeine in five categories having caffeine
352 69.6
were asked from consumers of caffeine. These caffeine makes feel happy 404 79.8
categories include appetite suppression, social mood Caffeine improves mood 344 68
enhancement, energy/work enhancement, Caffeine makes feel more
422 83.4
withdrawal/dependence, and physical performance alert
enhancement. In the category of appetite Caffeine picks up when
feeling tired
384 75.9
suppression, largest proportion (77.1%) of
Caffeine makes feel more
participants perceived that caffeine suppresses their energetic
408 80.6
hunger. Regarding social mood enhancement, the Energy/Work Feel less sleepy after having
320 63.2
majority of participants perceived (79.8%) that Enhancement caffeine
caffeine makes them feel happy. In questions related (n=506) Caffeine helps to work over
long periods of time
404 79.8
to energy/work enhancement, the largest proportion
Caffeine increases
(83.4%) perceived that caffeine makes them feel motivation to work
372 73.5
more alert. About questions related to withdrawal/ Caffeine improves
394 77.9
dependence, the majority of students (75.5%) concentration
perceived that they will experience headaches Caffeine improves attention 390 77.1
without caffeine. In the category of physical Experience caffeine
withdrawal without caffeine
420 83
performance enhancement, the largest proportion of
Need caffeine everyday 372 73.5
participants perceived that caffeine improves their Get headache if went
athletic performance. (Table-2) without caffeine
382 75.5
Strong desire without usual
amount
370 73.1
Feel miserable without usual
Male Female Total p- caffeine
328 64.8
Variable Withdrawal
n=278 n=392 n=670 value /Dependence Difficulty starting day
without caffeine
324 64
(n=506)
222 284 506
Yes Feel sick if went without
326 64.4
Caffeine (79.9%) (72.4%) (75.5%) caffeine
Consumer
0.03*
56 108 164 Trouble giving up caffeine 366 72.3
No
(20.1%) (27.6%) (24.5%) Often crave caffeine 360 71.1
55 61 116 Get anxious if abstained
Coffee from caffeine
380 75.1
(24.8%) (21.5%) (22.9%)
Unable to function without
115 159 274 caffeine
374 73.9
Tea
Caffeine (51.8%) (56.0%) (54.2%) Workouts are better after
intake form
0.716 336 66.4
29 39 68 Physical having caffeine
Chocolate
(13.1%) (13.7%) (13.4%) Performance Exercise longer if have
286 56.5
Energy 23 25 48 Enhancement caffeine
(n=506) Improves athletic
drinks (10.4%) (8.8%) (9.5%) 370 73.1
performance
P value≤0.05 was considered significant Table-2: Perception of effects of caffeine in consumers
48
Caffeine Consumption & Perception of Its Effects Amongst University Students
anxiety/negative physical effects, majority of in the relevant global literature describing that the
participants (81.7%) reported that they don’t take caffeinated products are more commonly used in
caffeine because it makes their heart beat irregular males.20
and in the category of sleep disturbance, the largest It is worth mentioning that (77%) of the participants
proportion (74.4%) reported that they don’t reported to use the caffeinated products for the
consume caffeine because they feel difficulty in suppression of appetite. However, this finding is not
sleeping after caffeine. (Table-3) supported by the literature which describes that
caffeine is not an effective appetite suppressant.21
Perception of effects of caffeine in The participants reported that they consume caffeine
Frequency %
non-consumers because it enhances their mood. This perception was
Caffeine makes feel supported by another study which concludes that
110 67.1
nervous caffeine improves mood and enhances cognitive
Easily stressed after
106 64.6 performance.22
having caffeine
Participants were using caffeine because they think
Caffeine makes jittery 114 69.5
Anxiety/ Even small amount of that it enhances their energy. This perception was
Negative caffeine makes anxious 100 61 also supported by literature.23 Another reason for
Physical consuming caffeine was that perception of
Effects
Don’t like the way
132 80.5 experiencing withdrawal effects. This finding is
(n=164) caffeine makes feel
Caffeine makes irritable 126 76.8 consistent with the findings of a previous study.24
Caffeine makes There is evidence that this caffeine dependence can
134 81.7
heartbeat irregular be reduced by education about caffeine sources and
Caffeine makes to sweat 118 72 its ability to produce physical dependence.24
Caffeine upsets stomach 104 63.4 The non-consumer of caffeine reported that they
Using caffeine late in experience anxiety and sleep disturbances after
120 73.2
day disrupts sleep consuming caffeine. These perceptions are also
Caffeine late in day gives supported in literature because caffeine
Sleep 102 62.2
insomnia
Disturbance consumption is found to be associated with anxiety
(n=164) Difficulty sleeping after 122 74.4 related behavior and insomnia.25
having caffeine
Caffeine at any time of The availability of caffeinated products and foods
96 58.5 has been rising over the past decade. Due to this
day throws off sleep
Table-3: Perception of effects of caffeine in non- increased availability and usage people generally
consumers link certain perceptions with caffeine consumption.
The optimal amount of caffeine usage varies in
DISCUSSION literature and depends on various factors like age,
gender and presence of any disease. A considerable
The aim of current study was to determine the amount of literature has been published on the
frequency of caffeine consumption and perception benefits and harmful effects of caffeine
of its effects among university students and we consumption.4,7,8,9,10,26,27 The majority of the
found that high proportion (75.5%) of the literature suggests that mild to moderate caffeine
participants was caffeine user. These findings are consumption is relatively safe, but that higher doses
consistent with the results of different studies of caffeine consumption (>400 mg) can cause
describing a high consumption of caffeine among physiological, psychological, and behavioral harm.28
youngsters worldwide.4,7,8,9,10 The present study The current article addresses an important public
concluded that among all the caffeinated products, health issue and contributes to providing better
the use of tea was found to be most common understanding of perceptions that are linked with the
(51.8%). These results also corroborates with the effects of caffeine. The findings of this study are
findings of a similar research which shows a high beneficial and can lead to implementing changes to
consumption of tea among Pakistan population.19 promote healthier life style among university
This high utilization of tea may be associated with students
the societal dietary patterns as it is considered as the
mandatory component of the breakfast. It has also CONCLUSION
been found that the consumption of caffeine was
significantly high (p=0.03) among males as The study concludes that male students had more
compared to female participants of the study. These tendencies towards caffeine consumption than
findings are also aligned with the evidence available females. Major perceptions of consuming caffeine
49
Caffeine Consumption & Perception of Its Effects Amongst University Students
50
Caffeine Consumption & Perception of Its Effects Amongst University Students
its relationship with gender, age and the types of The Authors:
caffeinated beverages. INT J MENT HEALTH Dr. Umer Maqsood
AD. 2018; 16(4):981-99. Assistant Professor
21. Panek-Shirley LM, DeNysschen C, O’Brien E, Department of Physical Therapy,
Temple JL. Caffeine transiently affects food Azra Naheed Medical College, Lahore.
intake at breakfast. J Acad Nutr Diet. 2018;
118(10):1832-43. Dr. Roop Zahra
22. Irwin C, McCartney D, Khalesi S, Desbrow B. Lecturer
Caffeine content and perceived sensory Department of Physical Therapy,
characteristics of pod coffee: Effects on mood Azra Naheed Medical College, Lahore
and cognitive performance. Curr Res Nutr Food
Sci Jour. 2018; 6(2):329-45. Prof. Muhammad Zahid Latif
23. Diaz-Lara FJ, del Coso J, Portillo J, Areces F, Director,
García JM, Abián-Vicén J. Enhancement of Department of Community Medicine & Medical
high-intensity actions and physical performance Education,
during a simulated brazilian jiu-jitsu Azra Naheed Medical College, Lahore.
competition with a moderate dose of caffeine.
Int J Sport Physiol. 2016; 11(7):861-7. Dr. Hena Athar
24. Juliano LM, Kardel PG, Harrell PT, Muench C, Lecturer
Edwards KC. Investigating the role of Department of Public Health,
expectancy in caffeine withdrawal using the University Institute of Public Health,
balanced placebo design. Human The University of Lahore.
Psychopharmacology: Clinical and
Experimental. 2019; 34(2):e2692. Dr. Gul Muhammad Shaikh
25. O’Neill CE, Newsom RJ, Stafford J, Scott T, PhD Scholar
Archuleta S, Levis SC, et al. Adolescent Department of Public Health,
caffeine consumption increases adulthood University Institute of Public Health,
anxiety-related behavior and modifies The University of Lahore.
neuroendocrine signaling. Psychoneuro-
endocrinology. 2016; 67:40-50. Syed Bilal Hassan
26. Rutherfurd-Markwick K, Ali A. Caffeine use in Lecturer,
the 21st century: Considerations for public Department of Public Health,
health. JJ Food Nutri. 2016; 3(1). University Institute of Public Health,
27. Reid JL, McCrory C, White CM, Martineau C, The University of Lahore.
Vanderkooy P, Fenton N, et al. Consumption of
caffeinated energy drinks among youth and Corresponding Author:
young adults in canada. Preventive Medicine Dr. Umer Maqsood
Reports. 2017; 5:65-70. Assistant Professor,
28. Temple JL. Review: Trends, safety, and Department of Physical Therapy,
recommendations for caffeine use in children Azra Naheed Medical College, Lahore.
and adolescents. Journal of the American E-mail: umer.maqsood@gmail.com
Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.
2019; 58(1):36-45.
51
V i e w p u b l i c a t i o n s t a t s