Professional Documents
Culture Documents
KINJAL SHAH
H AV E N I N T H E M E A D O W S
SCAN THIS QR CODE TO
KNOW MORE ABOUT ME
I would like to thank our alumni Hilary Bales and Tim Rommel for helping me
with the industry knowledge and giving me time throughout the project. Last but
not the least, I couldn’t have enjoyed my graduate life without my friends and
classmates. Ray Holliday, AIA, ASLA, APA, ASID, LI
(Studio Professor)
01 INTRODUCTION
1.1 ABSTRACT
1.2 PROBLEM STATEMENT 04 INVESTIGATIONS
4.1 HUMAN EXPERIENCE
4.2 CONNECTION TO PLACE
In today’s scenario, the need for mental health services have increased. The
attention to overall health can only be achieved if both physical and mental
health are taken care. There are many counties in United States which lack
basic mental health services. This project is located in Larimer County, Colo-
rado, the county lacked any behavioral health services for its residents. Hence
the need for facility was evident. With this intention, the “Larimer County Com-
munity Master Plan for Behavioral Health: Changing the Paradigm” was cre-
ated to comprehensively evaluate the behavioral health service needs; identify
gaps in the continuum of treatment and support services and outline a Five
Year Strategic Plan to address them.
The project consists of 16- bed unit cluster each for acute mental health pa-
tients, substance use, outpatient facility and residential treatment. The de-
sign is based on principles of biophilic design and salutogenic approach. The
research carried out for this project aims to identify the design guidelines to
explore how architecture can be of aid in relieving psychological disorders by
promoting a eunoia state of mind. The planning process was more focussed
on creating secured and non secured environments without a physical barrier
and facilitating spacial orientation in more natural way.
The investigation ahead will act as toolbox for designing behavioral health fa-
cilities with new outlook. The environment around the facility gives the patient
a sense of coherence and choice control leading to feel more like home. At
the end, the architecture needs to be make a person believe that this mental
and behavioral disorder can be controlled and this place will heal them. Hence
the facility is a “ Haven” for all the patients to give them new life purpose
and the zen to feel “Eunoia”.
The task of reducing mental health stigma associated with the place (archi-
tecture) necessitates considering a wide range of diverse issues. To meet
standards of quality for mental health facilities, the space need to ensure the
protection of in-patients’ dignity and privacy while maintaining security, as
well as appropriate humanisation of hospital space with respect for local and
cultural determinants. This allows focusing on the patients and facilitates their
engagement on a personal and social level while appropriate therapy is being
carried out.
The enviroment should be welcoming so that care can be given without any
judgements. Mental health architecture should be neither the architecture
of madness nor the architecture of stigma, but an architecture of therapy,
humanity, empathy and safety.
COMPLEXITY OF
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
3.1 BEHAVIORAL HEALTH vs
MENTAL HEALTH 1in 5 adults in America experience a mental illness
3.2 TREATMENT AND WELLNESS
Psychotherapy
The term “behavioral health” originated just a few decades ago, but the mean- 1. Psychotherapy - Its also known as “talk therapy” has to be specially tailored
ing has changed over time. There are several important differences between around the patient’s anxieties in order to be effective. Cognitive Behavioral
mental and behavioral health. therapy (CBT) is a type of psychotherapy that encourage the patients to find
different ways of thinking, behaving, and reacting to anxiety-producing and
Mental health is a state of wellbeing in which an individual can cope with fearful situations. CBT is composed of cognitive therapy which is used to
stress and be a productive member of the community. Your biology, habits and identify the problems and exposure therapy which represents confronting the
psychological condition all impact and are impacted by your mental health. fears, CBT is done individually or with a group of people and usually requires
Depression, generalized anxiety disorder, bipolar disorder and schizophrenia some “homework” to be done.
are all examples of mental health disorders that are not directly a result of be- 1in 3 adults in America suffering from mental illness do Support Group
haviors. While some mental health challenges are related to behavioral health, not undergo treatment
2. Self help or Support Groups - Some people will benefit from these group
others are caused by genetics or brain chemistry. meetings as sharing their problems and achievements can be deeply satisfying
. Group meetings, support groups and chat rooms, even talking to trusted
Behavioral health is the way your habits impact your mental and physical friends can have a beneficial impact on one’s mental health.
wellbeing. That includes factors like eating and drinking habits, exercise, and
addictive behavior patterns. Substance abuse, eating disorders, gambling and 3. Dialectal Behavioral Therapy (DBT) - DBT can be adapted for many substance
sex addiction are all examples of behavioral health disorders. These condi- abuse cases, but mainly focuses on treating severe personality disorders,
tions stem from maladaptive behaviors and may require behavioral health such as borderline personality disorder. DBT works to reduce cravings, help Dialectal Behavioral Therapy (DBT)
Mental illness Addiction
services to overcome. patients avoid situations or opportunities to relapse, assist in giving up actions
that reinforce substance use, and learn healthy coping skills.
People who have substance use disorders as well as mental health disorders
are diagnosed as having co-occurring disorders, or dual disorders. This is 4. Stress Management Techniques (SMT)- SMT and meditation can help
also sometimes called a dual diagnosis. Approximately 10.2 million adults have co-occuring people with anxiety disorders, calm themselves and may enhance the effects
mental health and addiction disorders of therapy.
Stress Management Techniques (SMT)
INVESTIGATIONS
4.1 CASE STUDY 4.2 RESEARCH
Evidence- Based Design:
A deliberate attempt to base the building design decisions on the best available research evidence with the goal of improving outcomes
Location : Cincinnati Form Inspirations Taken:
-Spine connecting wings.
and of continuing to monitor the success or failure for subsequent decision making.
Area: 93,890 sq.ft
-Connection to nature.
Beds: 64 single inpatient -Downtown/Neighborhood/ Hous-
rooms, 16 bed division ing Concept.
-Secured Courtyard between the RESEARCH GOAL 1 RESEARCH GOAL 2 RESEARCH GOAL 3
building.
-Rooms facing the woodlands. Improving the patient safety Improving other patient outcomes Improving staff outcomes through
through environmental measures through environmental measures environmental measures
Lindner Center of Hope
-Reducing Patient injury and co- -Considering Patient’s social -Decreasing staff injuries
morbidity choices -Decreasing the staff stress
-Reducing medical errors -Reducing depression -Improving patient-staff
-Reducing Healthcare- acquired and anxiety communication
Location : Tampere, Finland Form Inspirations Taken:
infections -Reducing spatial disorientation
Area: 122,917 sq.ft -Multiple Courtyards with different
uses -Improving patient privacy
Beds: 180 single inpatient
-Connection to nature
rooms, 15 bed division -Distinct Entries to create sense of
arrival
-Window Style. Salutogenesis:
-Rooms facing the courtyards. A holistic approach towards healing process in all dimensions of a person – body, mind, social and spirit.To achieve this four factors of
environment are considered:
Tampere Psychiatric Clinic
To translate the research into a built environment, a visioning process is determined to conclude the design strategies. This visioning
process aims in imagining an environment that could check all the research goals and creates a salutogenic environment.
How do we want the How should patients feel How should staff feel
facility to look and feel? about the facility? about the facility?
Staff
Aggression Depression effectiveness
Flexible and Behavior Anti- ligature furniture and Safety for staff and patients
adaptable rooms finishes
Defining the design strategies (blue boxes) in relation to patient/staff outcomes (grey boxes). Understanding the Behavioral Psychology and defining the space relation
ANALYSIS 1
National and local statistics indicate that one in five Americans has a mental
health issue, and depression is the leading cause of disability worldwide. It
is estimated that 41,000 Larimer County residents have a mental illness and
30,000 have a substance abuse disorder (some residents have both conditions).
Larimer County holds one of the highest suicide rates in the country. While the Land use context around the site Satellite site image
County has many solid services, it does not currently have the continuum of
care needed to meet differing severity and scope of needs. It also lacks a
centralized facility where care can be effectively and efficiently managed in
a continuum of care. A 2015 study of Larimer County Jail frequent utilizers
(those booked four or more times in a year) found that 9 in 10 had substance
use problems and half had a mental illness.
DOWNTOWN
Total NSF NTG Departmental
GF
14
NEIGHBOURHOOD
4 Total NSF NTG Departmental
GF
5
8. Community Hall (on mezzanine level) 1510 30% 1963
y 9. Large Group therapy room 510 30% 663
10 Entr
blic 10. Courtyards 2000 30% 2600
Pu
11. Family Visitation 460 30% 598
13 HOUSING
1 Total NSF NTG Departmental
GF
12
0 10 20 25
POND GARDEN
ST
AF
FE
NT
RY
15
SE
16
RV
IC
EE
17
NT
RY
15
14
9
OR
ID
RR
13
CO
PUBLIC USE 11
D
RE
COURTYARD
CU
SE
UN
10
12
5
6 8
1
GROUP THERAPY
Y
TR
COURTYARD
Waiting area view facing towards group therapy courtyard with ample of daylight
EN
IC
BL
and visual access to nature for calming environment
PU
SECURED ENTRY N
0 10 20 25
42 | Haven in the meadows Haven in the meadows | 43
NEIGHBOURHOOD
Access to spaces for public, Social Dynamics: Analogy to Everyday Life: Edge Conditions: Visual and Physical
staff and patients from CMW Choice of Large or private Connection to housing Group closer to non secure and access to nature
unit and IRT unit space for family visit transitional housing units
1. Waiting Area
2. Family Visitation Room
3. Large Activity Room
POND GARDEN
GA RDS
3
EN
RD
ND A
PO TOW
2
2
RY
ENT
2 IRT
2 PUBLIC USE
COURTYARD
RY
ENT 1
CMV
R INE
OO N
FL ZZA
ME
TO
GROUP THERAPY
COURTYARD
View of Group therapy courtyard between the downtown and housing units, the
group therapy courtyards are meant for casual counselling between the patient and
care giver. An open outdoor space helps in reducing the anxiety and aggression.
N
0 10 20 25
44 | Haven in the meadows Haven in the meadows | 45
HOUSING
1. Secured Vestibule 9. Nourishment
2. Single Patient Room 10. Medication
3. Double Patient Room 11. Storage
4. Quiet Room 12. Day Room
13. Exam room/
5. Nurse Station
Counsellingroom
Access to spaces for staff Social Dynamics: Analogy to Everyday Life: Edge Conditions: 6. Small Activity Room
14. Storage
and patients from CMW unit Choice of Single or double Front yard and Backyard Small Alcoves between rooms. 7. Detox Bays – Open and 15. Staff lounge
and IRT unit patient rooms concept, Open plan Choice of informal space – quiet Enclosed
16. Seclusion room
room, seating and activity area. 8. Clean/soiled Utility
2
3
POND GARDEN
2
8
8 13
6 16 12 14 15
9 10
2
3
RY
ENT
IRT
7
PUBLIC USE
2
COURTYARD
3
16
8 Y
TR
3 8 9 EN
2 CMW
4 12 5 1
13 10 3
3 14
3
2
GROUP THERAPY
COURTYARD
View of Group therapy courtyard between the downtown and housing units, the 15
group therapy courtyards are meant for casual counselling between the patient and
care giver. An open outdoor space helps in reducing the anxiety and aggression.
N
0 10 20 25
46 | Haven in the meadows Haven in the meadows | 47
Physical Activity Room Conference Conference Waiting Area
Room Room
Large Group Therapy Family Family Family Family Family Waiting Area Reception Lobby
Visitation Visitation Visitation Visitation Visitation
Room Room Room Room Room
SECTION
FACADE DESIGN
Downtown MECHANICAL
ROOM JANITOR
SECURED ENTRY 8
10 7
TOILET TOILET
1. Waiting Area 11
6
2. Administrative office reception
VIEW TO
3. Conference Room HILLS SHRUBS S
Access to spaces for,staff and out- De-institutionalized & 4. Workstations
FOR
PRIVACY
6
11
patients and emergency patients for Homelike environment
GROUP THERAPY
E
5. Clinical Director COURTYARD
4
CSU and MMW 6. Executive Director C
13 13 13
7. Facility Director
8. Medical Director U
9. Storage
R
10. Pantry CSU ENTRY
11. Consult Rooms E
FOR ENTRY
VIEW TO
Secure Entry
PRIVACY TO UNITS OUTPATIENT 1
HILLS TRIAGE
ENTRY
C
14. Sally Port
O
15. Legal processing 36 35
16.Seclusion Room R 25
5 17. Seclusion Toilet LAWN FOR
PHYSICAL
18. Debug/furnace room ACTIVITY R 29
3 19. Storage
I 23 23
20. Secured Lobby 24 24
30 31
4 21. Transport lounge D
22. Secured Entrance Vestibule 24
VIEW TO
HILLS O 24
2 SHRUBS
HORTICULTURE
27
Triage
FOR
THERAPY
PRIVACY R 24
24
32 32
1
23. Consult/ Hot Office Room 24 33 34
24
1 2 3 4 5 33. Nourishment
Involuntary After legal
34. PPE storage VIEW TO INVOLUNTARY PATIENT ENTRY
Patient is kept Then patient is Once the HILLS
patient in seclusion processing done examined as per diagnosis is 35. Lab
arrives room till the by staff, the their condition in done, patient 36. Reception
through sally point stable patient is kept exam room is tranferred to N
port first and in observation housing unit
screened. room
0 10 20 25
52 | Haven in the meadows Haven in the meadows | 53
Housing
1. Secured Vestibule GROUP THERAPY
COURTYARD
2. Single Patient Room
3. Double Patient Room
4. Quiet Room 14
5. Nurse Station
VIEW TO 2
Access to spaces for staff and Social Dynamics: Analogy to Everyday Life: 6. Seclusion Room HILLS 3 SHRUBS
FOR
patients from MMW unit and Choice of Single or double Front yard and Backyard 7. Exam Room PRIVACY
S
CSU unit patient rooms, group seating concept. Open plan for better 8. Clean/soiled Utility 3
GROUP THERAPY
11 COURTYARD
options visibility 9. Nourishment E
10. Medication 7
15 3
C
11. Storage 2
zone outside
room 13 C
Dedicated staff
space away from O
Quiet room with patients for staff LAWN FOR
360 degree view respite PHYSICAL R
ACTIVITY
to hills
R
Flexible and
13
adaptable rooms I
Curved edges with views to hills 2 D
to smoothen the and courtyard VIEW TO
HILLS
3
SHRUBS HORTICULTURE
walls and calmer FOR
PRIVACY
THERAPY O
aesthetics 6
3
R
10
Breaking the 3 8 9
stereotypical sally 2
15 3
7
3 11
Choice of small Open floor plan
activity space for allows more
people with acute visibility from VIEW TO 2
3
0 10 20 25
54 | Haven in the meadows Haven in the meadows | 55
Quiet Day Room Secured Glass Corridor Exam Room Triage Bull Pen
Room Entry Space
SECTION
MILIEAU SPACE
INPATIENT ROOM DESIGN
Zinc roof
cladding
Roof Level
35' - 0"
Combination of
Douglas fir col-
umns 4”x6” and Level 2
15' - 0"
12” dia columns
for larger span
support
14
13
11
10
9 11'
8
B
6'-11"
7
6
5
4 1'
3 4'-1"
2
7"
1
Level 1
Walls made of 06' - 0"
limestone and
Level 0
wooden panel 3'-8"
0' -0"
cladding
flow systems. Mixed-flow systems tend to be louder because of the higher Fascia guardrail
4"
14
Metal gutter
lower pressure drop, smaller fans, and less energy consumption. Fan
3'-2"
13
Timber connector
DV can use fewer diffusers and less ductwork. DV introduces supply air
Metal frame nailed
at the playing/teaching floor, improving indoor air quality by reducing
Level 2
11
15' - 0"
to connector 2” thk
Skit -proof tile
accumulation of CO2, odor, and indoor contaminants. DV has a higher Double pane glazing
14
13
11
10
9 11'
10
6
6'-11"
5
4 1'
3 4'-1"
exhaust is used, the heat gain due to the lights and roof can be eliminated
2
7"
1
Level 1
DETAIL AT ‘A’
06' - 0"
Plaster
from building cooling loads.
3'-8" Level 0
9
0' -0"
RCC Slab
1
Double pane glazing PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
KEY SECTION 8 PART SECTION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
7
6
Tile floor skirting
6'-11"
5
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
RCC Slab 14
Rigid insulation
13 14
M.S Pipe section
handrail
4 1'
4'-1"
10
17
2
to rigid insulation with
10
silicon membrane 18
DETAIL AT ‘B’
8 20
9 1 1
18'-6"
7 21 2” thk
8
6
Skit -proof tile
5
4'-1"
3
7
RCC Slab 4
silicon membrane 1
7"
1'
support
6'-11" UP 1/2” nosing 1
5
Rigid insulation
4'-1"
8'-10"
3'-5"
4 1'
RCC bund wall 3'-4" Stringer
Plaster
Steel edging
13 STAIRCASE PLAN
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PART SECTION 2
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
7"
70 | Haven in the meadows
DETAIL AT ‘C’
11 1 Haven in the meadows | 71
RODUCED
PRODUCEDBY
STUDENTVERSIO
VERSI
Zinc Roof Panel
WALL DETAIL
AUTODESKSTUDENT
Douglas fir beam
BYAN
Snap - clad clip
with fasteners A
ANAUTODESK
5/8” plywood
AUTODESKSTUDENT
sheathing
ANAUTODESK
Fascia nailer
STUDENT VERSION
Metal gutter
Wooden Rafter
STUDENT
70"
BYAN
160"
70"
PRODUCED
VERSION
160"
Wooden battens
BY
Wooden decking
PRODUCED
PRODUCED
VERSION
L -angle to hold
VERSION
the layers
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT
DETAIL AT ‘A’
BY AN AUTODESK
Gypsum board
70"
160"
Rigid insulation
Wooden Sheathing
B
50"
50"
Water-proofing
70"
membrane
160"
Limestone cladding
DETAIL AT ‘B’
Limestone cladding
Skirting
Wooden flooring
Metal Fastener
50"
RCC Slab
PRODUCED
Cardboard box for
earth insulation
Metal angle clip
C
Brick Cladding
RCC Bund Wall
Support
50"
Steel edging
Water-proofing
membrane
DETAIL AT ‘C’
72 | Haven in the meadows Haven in the meadows | 73
06
A PLACE TO FEEL NORMAL
CONCLUSION
This project de-stigmatizes the way we look at
mental health care, a place where all the levels of
care given and designing the spaces not just focuses
on all the users. The concept of patient-centered
care has taught us, such as incorporating natural
light, ensuring views of nature, providing access to
the outdoors, offering a choice of one activity room or
another, and offering a choice of where to sit in public
rooms, such as by a window or in a quiet alcove.
When people have a choice of where to be, they
are less likely to become dangerous to themselves
or others. The design strategies act as a toolbox for
future projects and it will change the state of facility
across the world. At the end, this project solves the
question-
1. Addiction or Substance Use Disorder – a primary, 7. Eunoia - It means “well mind” or “beautiful thinking”. [1] Shepley, M.M., & Pasha, S. (2017). Design for Mental [8] Ulrich, Roger. (1984). View Through a Window May
chronic disease of brain reward, motivation, memory, It is a rarely used medical term referring to a state of and Behavioral Health (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi. Influence Recovery from Surgery. Science (New York,
and related circuitry. Dysfunction in these circuits normal mental health. org/10.4324/9781315646916 N.Y.). 224. 420-1. 10.1126/science.6143402.
leads to characteristic biological, psychological, social,
and spiritual manifestations. This is reflected in an 8. Intensive Residential Treatment (IRT)- This unit provides [2] Sachs NA, Shepley MM, Peditto K, Hankinson [9] Marcus, C. C., & Sachs, N. A. (2014). Therapeutic
individual pathologically pursuing reward and/or relief up to 30 days total inpatient care for patients with MT, Smith K, Giebink B, Thompson T. Evaluation of a landscapes: An evidence-based approach to designing
by substance use and other behaviors. mental health diagnoses. This unit complies with the Mental and Behavioral Health Patient Room Mockup healing gardens and restorative outdoor spaces.
ASAM criteria 3.5 and is intended to be “soft locked”. at a VA Facility. HERD. 2020 Apr;13(2):46-67. doi:
2. Behavioral Health – includes not only ways of If a patient has dual diagnoses (mental health and 10.1177/1937586719856349. Epub 2019 Jul 15. PMID: [10] Shepley, M. M., Pasha, S., Ferguson, P., Huffcut, J. C.,
promoting well-being by preventing or intervening substance abuse disorder), they may stay in the IRT up to 31304785. Kiyokawa, G., & Martere, J. (2013). Design
in mental illness such as depression or anxiety, but also 90 days. research and behavioral health facilities. The Center
has as an aim preventing or intervening in alcohol/ [3] Sakallaris, B. R., MacAllister, L., Voss, M., Smith, K., & for Health Design.
substance abuse or other addictions. 9.Medically-Monitored Withdrawal Management Jonas, W. B. (2015). Optimal healing environments. Global
(MMWM)- This unit provides short-term (less than 5 days advances in health and medicine, 4(3), 40–45. https:// [11] Shepley, M. M., Watson, A., Pitts, F., Garrity, A.,
3. Continuum of Care (Levels) – a system that guides total) inpatient care for patients requiring medical doi.org/10.7453/gahmj.2015.043 Spelman, E., Fronsman, A., & Kelkar, J. (2017). Mental
and tracks patients over time through a comprehensive assistance in their detox efforts (that is, using drugs to and behavioral health settings: Importance and
array of health services spanning all levels and intensity aid in detox with a severe alcohol, benzodiazapine, or [4] How Kiyoshi Izumi Built the Psych Ward of the Future effectiveness of environmental qualities and features as
of care. heroin/other opiates addiction). by Dropping Acid. (n.d.). Retrieved September 21, 2020, perceived by staff. Journal of Environmental Psychology,
from https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/ypp8ax/how- 50, 37–50
4. Co-Occurring Disorder (Dual Diagnosis or Co-existing) 10. Mental Health – It includes our emotional, kiyoshi-izumi-built-the-psych-ward-of-the-future-by-
– refers to an individual who has a co-existing mental psychological, and social well-being. It affects how we dropping-acid-5886b6e98308bb45d5e26ae6 [12] Ulrich, R. S., Bogren, L., Gardiner, S. K., & Lundin, S.
illness and a substance-use disorder, or another think, feel, and act. It also helps determine how we (2018). Psychiatric ward design can reduce aggressive
combination of disorders (such as mental disorders handle stress, relate to others, and make choices [5] Mazuch, R. (2017). Salutogenic and Biophilic Design behavior. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 57, 53–
and intellectual disability). as Therapeutic Approaches to Sustainable Architecture. 66. doi:10.1016/j.jenvp.2018.05.002
11. Triage – The process of determining the priority of Architectural Design, 87(2), 42-47. doi:10.1002/ad.2151
5. Crisis Stabilization Unit (CSU) – within a behavioral patients’ treatments based on the severity of their [13] Behavioral Health Services (Behavioral Health).
health facility, a level of care and services provided conditions.1 [6] Ulrich, Roger. (2008). Biophilic theory and research for (1970, May 01). Retrieved from https://www.larimer.org/
for individuals to receive crisis stabilization services healthcare design. Biophilic Design: The Theory, Science, behavioralhealth
in a safe, structured setting. 12. Wellness – The quality or state of being healthy in and Practice of Bringing Buildings to Life. 87-106.
body and mind, especially as the result of deliberate
6. Clinically-Monitored Withdrawal Management (CMWM) effort. [7] Mazzi, A. (2020). Toward a Unified Language (and
-This unit provides short-term (3-5 days total) care for Application) of Salutogenic Design: An Opinion Paper.
patients who mostly require supervision while detoxing. HERD: Health Environments Research & Design Journal.
This unit complies with the ASAM criteria 3.2WM. https://doi.org/10.1177/1937586720967347
This unit has fewer bedrooms but includes smaller
spaces for detox similar to a “Sobering Unit.”
82 | Haven in the meadows