Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • MANTILLA, Anjessette C. - Conception-Bautista v. Salonga - de La Llana v. Alba

    Uploaded by

    Anjessette Mantilla
    21 views72 pages

    Original Title

    MANTILLA, Anjessette C._ Conception-Bautista v. Salonga - De La Llana v. Alba

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    21 views72 pages

    MANTILLA, Anjessette C. - Conception-Bautista v. Salonga - de La Llana v. Alba

    Uploaded by

    Anjessette Mantilla

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 72
    SFOS ee serena nans { Fer eee eH HEHEHE BHO ea! vo vboboudvy Vue OURO S \ » v vvvopd vey ved y > 6: Sets ——-—MARv_@ncépcton Baurzcrh ve _ — SENATOR OVITO ALONG FACS! The President apporifed Moy Conception Bouticta os te charten ¢ the Lommiission_en Huren Righte Puctuant f the seceyd Sentence mn Seclion 1h. Act VA, tobhout the cengicmepion of te COM becouee fray are oneng the oficers oy govern ~ meit “whon hel Che President) moy be authen'ted by law fo appoint.” Section 2(6) Executive Order Nov thes, aufhorivec the President fo qygorint the choirman and Menbere of the Commission of Human Rights » CoA clicappaned Boytictat alle - ged od vitean qppointment ot Cheirperton of the CHR ui view of her cefutel Yo. Submit 40 the pudcdichon of the Comics on Appoistmentc. [6% Whether OF ht Bautictat appeintatt 16 subject fo C$ confirmation HELO: Hho, Bevfitat opporidment i nct subject fo Coll canfianotion Panto Oece enor: The pecificn of chowriren eo ct 4 t oneng the pein ménfioned ui the _fiest senkence of Art} feo. 1h ofthe indiduton hi ——_ Relsned on te fast sertnee of fc thot the appointments whtch ore 1 be nade a fhe Confirmahon of Ch | qe « > s c. _ & 3s _G&RNO- Te Sto. APRIL ofa +1992 a © — PETER Foun) 0. CALOERON a a) ys: = a) BARTOLOME cappue ear arene nore neoneereerecaeeaaan \ vvove \ ae vv» vod vobo \ \ + FAIS: toey cenyned Corie ef a ot ent eee Sarre roto aida setae Lal 7he_qpontet “ aa rd ar ct tin the el Be EO ig ec el Lage yb lee pict be A sit mented the ed sfedence of Seer th Ad? fhe focbichn sian posta —__“*fuire. tonpirmoboi by he Be ie, Taw dod ie_confimadion by the aut extended by He. Fido gore Picers_tlifool f tase exprecsly men trond the picst tenfence of Sec 16 , ACE tof the Concibon whore appontamente ce~ quite_congiomofren by the CA ATL WENDT? Gong rect cont , by Ic Wee confimation by the donm'c- Sen intents extended by the Presideut 1 ittanal 40 thote exprectly menhoted m the fiest Sentence. of See He, Article Vil of the Conch tao hare appoint mente peguite onficmahoin by the nmi ssioit on Appoint mente. RR eee © Page 6. forge putt it, 929 NESUWTO_f}- MANALD —— ve PEDRO G- Spc Troup _ FACIL! RA 697£ coor teddy Coenen Aquino , creeting OIL6. Section lo 8 fhe. ac PNP. es_od mens 06 — an je confirmed by the cit acsuming Ahoy dutit Hive, fe = lang the IC : ted Her, the to panarert copocily me pelitnae aail the legalty of such eppointinedt because .mvoking sad prowiain af Af OFC , confimahon g” dp i¢ Aveded- ZGSUE! whether or nok PNP offites are Abin fo the AFP, ehoce pacifione nec A Confirmation - HELD! NO, pNP ofrecer are not abun fo the AFP. whoce poctiinc need CA ton. RATT “The ic we Y thea Mh ih) record ote ity rt at dee ba Pine Nalin! Police . they do tet poll nder Hie pies} quup a Cec: Tle, Artie vi. =AG7- RNo 137 SC MARE my ELPLOEO_G- SeRIANO - —_— REUBEN UcTA v's \ \ FACT: bight fice of the Philypine. Gast Guard (pc6,) are. promoted by the _ President tv Vice Adiga) , Rear Adnital, Coemedoce, Naval Captcih , ord they setuned office without confiimation by the Commission on Appa monte (CA). Be Hong, ox a toxpeyer filed_a pettion with the Syrenc Court ques ioniy donciationohty of ran deaylel of office, which aa congittatch_ of fhe OA ce ececeeceonan 2 J6GUg whdher or nof accumphon of ite b POL requiee Ch onfimohion HELD! No, octumphon of office fo PEC doce ay require A_cvyfirmotion . a @ @ « « « “4 « RATIO OEGUENAT: Philjpine Coad Guard ore not eitthin fhe first goyo af See tle Actile Wil. The Clawe “efpirers og the omed fercec from fhe rank of alone] or Noval: captoin* copes fo_rrilifany picees_alenc \ -ORIONS. a | PRP ewe pee | er s | eer > —_ = \ FR ee eee \ | VIF \\ G-RNO. dT : Se &: PIMENTEL ——————— “bere SECRETARY EDUARDO R-ERMITD aa pers: while < ecto GMA appurited Athur Yop chal a _seerdoniec ¢ eur regecfve.deportmeite: Senator Aquilio Pineal averted tol. GMA Conot male such ita ‘lthart the concent of te Commicacti_on Appointment eve cutive Ceerefory tduacl brmita overreol " hol the preodent ——eepepered by fechon Ib, Are “ef the 11g Conchihon_fo_1ccue apport pin ree_wif ‘the Consent — nen ach jority fo depactment £ . — iit rn hfe Cg Fle. este ~ Nos a storie recident fo 1ssue, fem Seeuée pryided thot the temporary dedynateh “hal ack ex, veel one year: ___ 1668 F whether or not the_oppainimente made ly the Pecident ic val - © appointments node by the President tc vahd RAT. mR The Grqument reased by Entifa ix Comet Further £0192 ee cah_$» tha} will not be abuéed hence the ___—fsselp_ pro a provi serany derignahon shall not exceed he year. In thie - un lee aftec the initial apporh {werls mode shen He _ ee mn GMA sued the ad item appointment e- hic alco _ cpproses_ ot p0ove thet the. president 0c vi goed ih po IONS. aa = “ff8 . TG a Noe Fe 07 8 NOVEM BER_07,_1900- 6 Ia Re! Appointments dated Maret do. 1999 OF — —_« HON: MATEO A VALENWUELA a eo" - - — & ——___FAWIS: Regerred 10 the rt co hort are the cppaitnente ceed by the Pe _ em tent date Mark 30,1978 of fon: Mae Valente and Hecilo™ Vallarta _ Eyudgec of the RIC of Ba90 City ord Cabonarian City, cepertivey. there _~& appointment appear pra fore, at Kod, fo be expreely propibited by Sec: 10 “ Act Wl of the Bnctiuhoi «The Said Conclituporial provicton prohibite phe President — g > fia olaig ony eppoirinenb tuo months mineetly beer the not presidortial = Sei ts n ad ad Hc eat taper cyentnctc oe — one - — © 5 ——___titfive bly ervice, OF a Sndonger aires <— — g? _LESUE: phether or aot during the pened of the bon on Qppaintmente impose! by - 5 ee: JC Act Vil of the Conchfution , fhe ‘dent i Menesbeleec ceguited fo pill — the. ja di (ees. 4(1) ond 9 of Act Vu =i. vocanciec (i the ju dicey ato Mica af of yo? / Mo, huang the pertbel of Mic bon on Sppoinmente imp by : : _ _. the Consiifupein the Presid< Manctiekee requred b fill Vocals 1h ~ & . the. judlesony wi vicw of Secs. 9) and 9 of Art vill -~,-? a? Barto OE CLOENOF? Bat the penta! stoked Wi Sec 16 _ f(b Vl of the ects - Jo mon: before the_nex{ Hol electine ard % - his team * the, Theded ic whe equi safe appointments fo he Goud poe a Atel Bat Te apa of taka ule ard Vell nguecfiina- __ by tede da ‘od 0) <0 in of He pro a) Ahytion Celoting fo ramamene -_ = a - _ « a noe “ Dave 7 a a —GRNO. 13148 FepRupRy gy, 017 aa « ; FO RAOD L DE RAMA ~ : « Ss a ——____ — - THE Court of ApPEALC _ Go has: tp fie capt h he peste Ma Pele. ace, ob vo tr lantodo te. Rama wrote a leher fo the - Soll of fhe cppeiitements of 14 munica) eee "Penn seded te ea — tee He. + aligal tel tg tcl oi oly att — Pane Hee ae e ca ent requ forte ceal he. ipinent of — hue 14 ment. 4 i ge es rit ohindet pig wot. al the ‘ollie! pen clitd c « « G @ s o eee t going Pres — « cn oneal snack opt elecprvts_qpiciale. fhe C4 gin tet « ie enh e~ . « % ob » Issug! Whether or not fhe opporitt mess Mede ty the cufgoirng Mayor are, fecbib- den order Ad Vil, Gee 4° o the Cns{yfutos - HELO: No. fhe. jtnerte made by the cufgoirg Mayor are not for biden unl Act- Vil fee 12 ¢ phe tonetitufion - a v 2 RATIO Ob Cz DEVOI: = oe, ert Auld Hak he coche paohibitiin on — 7 i «— Aching Presiden}: there is no fow thet profrbrls focal e— _ qppotntmente unig the [oct days of Ais o her fenure. _ ORIONS:. ¢ a a Ce s, GAN 149036 ADR ed s902. t MAJ ANGELINA 6: MANAG 2 a <—” DL: BENTPAYD 7 <— _ FACE! Ma: F- tegen Beipay sseapeattee cing Divecter (Vo the Come = < the Lew Department Pefitiong Depoctmes} «she cited Civil Seeysce Gmmiccied Menderdun coe o-# re- lace mindijy heade wat_ofpibee thob ard_detale g \ = i ec at he a ee ee fnent. pebtibn er filed tha vant petilor ques tment card phe aght f in Ini Office of Benieye , Bora ond a — LiSug:twhetber or not fhe ecu (Of fy en poy eT . the botig of We acm in_am 2 fon ote Beye: deen _ “HELD! No, phe ceca 44 pity Bae | and Jusason_on the basic gpstitineat Probibited oc eetually not prohe = lide Dee te teditdts fie _od_mitean ame filed. iy tbo 18. .. . . QRIONS. el ’ ’ e; 2 an es "PAHO Deez Oster: Nom od cic mained! Ha Demloneat apmuit = PATIO O62 OFOT: Ne, On ed mieain_cpovitnent 1 a Permenent.appeint ~ e i 0a lenger be sith dean by c 5 a C- G 0 \ 0 Wh \ » » y = 7 - ~- _ = - = \_—* _ _ - - —* — =, Ons’. "earls ny ‘ PAGE a S DATE y 5 ‘ —— 2 a ‘ GR NO. TgEAe 1 __ a? — AOULIND Tak . a — é 5a « — 2 2 venue (0th). fe woe on eo oute. of te Peace, Jax Serice In 1112, 3 the sa Lexin gone mskcnduc- fic toni wa t= ated he toc ts Peed the Some, Hine, an adminicfretive tom = > Thin nc a beam of Dc -en fosed on He Londigon~ «- ——__hayor Conviction, erected a conmifee ® tivechgate Larin- Everdvally , Lane ee __& —____moia] 40s recommended . the President dichissedd Lari. é 2 “ — - _ 3 TCQUB: kheiar e- not Loin na rendved fron ofice papecy 2 vb HELO: No, lorn nce nat removed fron office Jape _ ATO Oi i bain ic pret fia) i v il Le Ithaugh “ft i » \ » Jn the case of bor, the himilohon con be found mi the foot that Lean arn core- 1d See lini. juho fol) under caret x i : . oc sub voy SOR He CHE HO ee 4a pt Pgh pnd a ak: ec pe cia ee oe bc fico hin ie gen. - not one of Hee grands enum pccme,. ‘i nto cae gc art “Thee Supreme. bouctaduelly abtlved Laan ee eo ORION. WPalng PITTET Edy | SHOE BOOB A ll ®ve YYY 2 \"\ *y tI) dy © \ » 2 \ » © \ RM Lig AF ean - 8 an E —___ FAS: Norberto Jinenea ord Loreto Remo quiife were chorged with Pe crime, 4, turer. Tinenea. woe sertencedl_to Wje_tipdinanent white Fomoqusit? ren — momed af large \ Before | for pp peal. fod cupited , Tien. become which grants @aneety wi favor op all pecans issn with on od penakied under te under de, Routed Penel ete 1h ifeuce. fo the, Cnemy or against pecens cadiig 0 tre, wor ro eng ed dag peace fon Inconb t7 &, = ve ele ae ect fy gate ated cal Theme POE fe a th had then b cgpreltaged did a to aca eee the, pet oer ye fle Curt a ive of tonbengs aladdin ea yin thot Since th Bag et dey ignite en debits —___—Connot_mivalte_the. benefits of amnety= —_ ZeSub: whether oc not admiésin of guilt be Aecesrony ¢n Amncaty. HELD: Alo cdentoion of guil} K aot necesory in cmeecly. _ - PaniD LECLDEN AL» Pmneoly 1 gronted Pe claster of peasons oc COnmunifice — who ena gully & petal oftercee , gerorlly before of aptec te (ichituhen 4 _ ita sh err Se pi gh of. the Pred gf hich fhe idical_po toe Bole bebe ie sheu| Gordhition precedent. He Pandey pees nt ce fe we oc slae qua 00%, adnit avi ee i dig ney adi Se eee sshast thal the offence. contd. dere, , Py Peta Hence, iF ic aot Comerd £2 tate ef fa fof “invocation of fhe Sensi ome Ain the Noto of a plea of confe- wSnon.od avoidance: -- ORIONS. "Fang ~ganu_31, 19 FACE: fern, Piguerae , Ambac, Flodd an, _—2 ——_# complex ing_with leo_Lopnnes> They {ni th — fs het ety pl od ect fee © —_the_sth_ Gu Gommicion » None of dhe pehhorene aw tg come ——_ntted_the trie -V Wes nar be a enly One who fol, the a ln det _ & billed Loyanes: rhe Commission valid it could a jbo wivebed by deferdane ie) tot cals = 3 eed « ay. ND. L ie 19 194 =< 6 ubencto_VERD_ ~ 5s — NG = 9% PEOPLE OF THE PHTLTPAINES s 2 a. + elie, we thagged wth — | b _ & fhe frenefite of anneaty could on 44 il sl Commitee! in 7 4? pathos ihecetelne_nesmast_orl_duppalated egos puters who 3 tee tet ig te lene tcp hon en alee fhe amnec- — “a Qrofher - ao nila pad hale note oem teas tae deeded fa - «a? Beit e falo Vera dn ‘atc, fo the. jeolé ,o6 - - e ___ Mirig the CN false cule one wey or another , af the murder Cove. But the ch i Jed thot amnecy appliec only to 10 hed ada but < should not be Punidhed ‘for the Crime done, ac ti purcuqnee of redictance: tothe tre «<_— ny it oko Sod it Could mt Yoke eognizance. of he murder care because that : pa Came, fen the annedly Cormicsen, which hed_no sen diction over the murder Cage- The cate, 06 brought to the Court on spiel aie er ep vc Llonika, whith a oid thet itasog thconsitlog for an appellant to yichy an ack orseck fargivencss fa «> something which he sail he hac not commit! a aa ISSUE! whether or not edmiinin of guilt ic Aecossory m_amneaty. HELD! YBC, edison guilt it wecetseny m Qunedly. a «- RATT Obeg DENOI: Aecely presoppasee fhe Commisann gf 2 caine ond when the a cctused meintaine that he Noe not Committe! crime, he Cannot / c cnnerly there an awmedly prdlomefior mpaec Cefoin conditiac ce ii_this cage, «HAC eae pe Hele © pet edo tc to ion s+ G7... .. - QRIONS. "Eley PAGE = DATE iNecafen of owned i ic tite nore of 4 pl . oa ard aoidonce, ——_tahch ttt i de edo: ‘he otetdebe afta his ut dicdoins— — Rhy efor count of nt ea ig fats sch pad —bnig the trine chorged within # yeoclomafon = - ORIONS. H oe Nd e e-* es — ecemaen 2 17 &, oo «, ——1" _ =o ‘ ALTO LABRADOR « PACES: Tepid Soros te Wonuited of ectafe ord sentenced p> meiihe of pa) Lonpedsonment ord 1 return the aneunt Foken- pespie thit, Sanbog cattinvedl #2 2 be a registered elector 1j_Malaten , Rital ,ond between 1134 and 1234 ever “oe fered Ge Muni i On Augud? 22 1934 the Elechon Gide uo< Spprved, 6 which hod ¢ i6n_that_dicqualgiec Sam imig_or voting - Holing — ed ¢ fored by final o ing. agouict propedy, Sarles ap-_ par pide wth she Precidost for on obslite pardon which wiac given tin_en Beceanbor 24, ~ 1937. Hic full Civil ard political aghte bs fuc-night fo hole «- le office tae finiled only Yo pacitine which wivolved’no Money or property rec od ibility ~ ited @ pehtion fo have Santor excluded fram the Voters (it G2 0 the bacie_of Schon 94 the. Cannanecatin Ret No- 352. The feud asked Sorts excluded hin rom tre dicquelpicaton by “tte the parton given Serbs oecaded hin fin the di¢qualicatie ceeated | ca the New Eeeton Ode. - Cribb Lgpprcled arguing that fhe Pardoning paver doce « a 1d to the cajqyment of political aghts world allow the Presi ~ 4-2 ——___dot_fo enach on tie; He. legis lepkire) ti ng Sete. Penge. a fleet th label aid Ae Pali par fe Exc oO dace nat ae. or eiply to igidatve prhibilfoss and wield cneunt to an colaufisl execig of the fxeeubie of a Kattlohve funci>n - ee «7? — _a TEU: whether Or dot the Pordenng power everited here would amount fo — on enlewpsl everase. of He Drerident of a [epic flive_fonchn« ec? 7 _ HELD: No, the pardening power evercated here aiould aof emaust 1 an Unleaifi) ea cuease x we President of a legitletive fanchon- st para 0er ENOL the perdonirg Power comet be rectnited er controlled by kegic~ e-—- _ lotive achon - [f mut remoin_ whee the sovereign authorfy has placed itand must e7 be cxccised by y the, Aig heed aujhority 4 whom it i< éntusted. iq absolute par~ a don not only blotc cut fhe eine Commifteo! but cerpuec all dicabilitiec cesulting C from de conudhoin «in phic care, fhe dicabilty 1 Hae refull of A. Convicherd e without hich there would 0° base for ais qeilificaton Voting -thife fhe ete. ORION: a PAGE DATE i the sence that he will tal or menual yn ne — poate extant ® rejededt Sane 15 Cnalioel o —— ite fac opine ely fe pian hic aie tii. money oc papel gency Lia ily Dili hcl for oc it pain pe full eiutl ard pelifcal as He lon frat _ the _dicquallpicati mipaced tn tas yA the, Purvrow tg pi fg Se Teele he uaneraee 4 vt ihe once ned snd ltd fc More fo IF fhere wou [ ry y ng fe political pavilege nha cove of his Detare, oveept though Legislative: et pro "Ber a GRO L 4gfo0 - ——Flobinicio PeroRtl0 Mee —4REGORTO PAWTIND e018, gata Peas comucted dey diel ed_fron vehig ond Aatoned ford yeare, four mentht ord one _4-* -~«¢ ite ld tf 1916, bee gral a fonditinal pore ye Gt. = fivttal_ared on 1940, cn abgohite. poten by the President= Pelobelle ishvtee quo. _ wenrent preceding s quedtritiie hit fight 2a mayer elect of Temyjer. _¢ Meniadigie It wae bite on $00 14) eae oe Code ~G — - Dy SGU! whether Or aot the abtolufe pardon _grented 4 eagle oF {on fe lips: a Ou weident % criminal convidhon Under — tleon bode - —- +. — HELD Yes, the atolute. perdlon.grantcal Oveapled him fom the ditqualificahor. G@ ~ iiigideut 1 taininal Convichon Under paragcaph (a) op See> 94 of He tee “ fon Cade 4 <- Ramo DecrOewat VEC. ety Crisbbel Vv. taliade Gourt held tha he « learn rer fe only uly th ind ced hy th fu < and cannot be contolled o¢ restaofed by tie Gxfon Thervapler, he had ex ~ =! trdliped the aght sey cage, elecfecl Councibr of Jomijus, Morinda gue, specthe. (3 — * elected muatapal thot mui or Pality in the dlectoin foc local officiate in December 1940 Under these cursus ,- pances jt ic evident thol the, plrpare. si gecating fr absolute pardon wac fo be ae erable hn fb osceme. the pesition in deference t> fhe popu far will- The pardon ‘ _ noc thas extended oa mrenticned! theresichove fore the date — — fee 4 Bch decaf ep on et ic whol tn ical pit Hic of o—- _ he conctidufl Nal grent ¥7he_Ahiey ule St ; et pee RIONS. "early Ca wou bu bb uuu bod pe part - a In RE MARCELEND LONTOR _ | ———— FALE: Monclino fontol voc Conucteal of biany ane yentenced fe { geore impajsoment- fle wer Perdoned by the Governor Geneva! on the Condition thet he Shall nol agcin be guilly of cny ticconduct - case, wot fiked by the Akomey Gentrel fr have br disbarred hecouce fvhae convicted of @ cring, uivolung al dupitude- Lomb, fesreyer, acgueol tat Pardon reaches the qfeacec ard bet ‘cut that he wey tel be locked upon ac guity of it: IéSUg! weer of not th ¢ffect of poten mey provert Lontok from dichoenmeyt Yee, Hee Lon did og then preceeding « 4 dale. On Nome. from the colle oon a one founded on, and di abne, ona makin fa —__udiion_for o felony ground for dichamment , it hac been held thot a pordon wip chor ir U4 (i Revie aisteetive._ Gui. Spericat Bt fae pln 2) Sect (i) of the a f pot Sul dice! £ he, “ ma 2 the Revised Penal de a jun dicia/ act consishig eine and a3 conviction of dlatien_o¢ a_Cenelitibnel Porden there the Preddent opts fo pro~ — ceed _under Seedon 64 (i) fhe Revie Admini drative Ode, pv yiudictial Pronougee v Ment of pull: ofa MUbseeguent (ime is fecescan) much lee Conviction therefor by 1A ial foc oa ocdér thot a Pecemnendest for a3 the _yidlelvon_o fie condifonal Pordon. Under At 727 of the RPC, pawl ~ ee or_conviict who ix regorded as having an rn e PoVAstonS. theceep mus? be a chauggeel , prosecuted! ond convicted. be made. 1c penalty preserbed. fn th resident hae oS _______agounet_the petitioner under (ochon G4 (i) of the Reyes ile Cade. Iho E cut ie, Ord 16 iby * Choice jon Cer fo dicial Conutiny - J ae an owe bbooy oe * . AND. Ty nI8'Y Quaust 16,20 INTEGRATED BAR OF THE PALLIPPINES ve Horl- Rony Atdo B. 29 Mody FIRS Lavolang Bit Jowrtce as Gommarker =n ~ Chel Under See: 1¢ sit Wd of — Fhe Gonstifuhion , the Precideat clivected the AEP Chitf of Soy ond PNP Chicf fo Coord inale_wsith cach ath por tho paper deplyment- orcl Ufilibedion a he Marinee —f_aanit the ANP 1 prevent or Suppecssing erinivel or lawlear ioleace. Te —__fresident declared thet ihe serwces of the 24enines yn the, anti ~ Caine Conpo'gn are merely feaporay) pi nofurt. are for a tasenable period only , anfil Such tine, when fhe situctién ell hove proved the TBP filed a peblion erleing bde~ Clare fhe. deployment of the Philppne, Manhes null ced Nore cncl Un conttitufona « thor 0c nok the President & fect! defemmnalion af the. necessity of Cel~ ig tr ried freee ic subject tuo rome —_ ——— thetic 06 not the calling of the. med focec P asict dhe PNP ta oink were ______ bility pobale vidlotee the canchtutiona| provision en ciuilian Sipremacy oyer she lta ond the_cidion chorwcler of Pwd — HELD ten te President colle tre armed facec prevent orcuptrese Lexkeee wo= _____fenet., savecion_or peboiion Ae necessanly ovaciiee a discrtenayy power Solely See: 1, Act Wil of fhe, dastifuton, Gong ress ney weucke _veiteal i ncdon ash such podanation of martial fow or sucpornon of fhe Paialege 4 the, ont of hobeac ——__tarrpinc_and the Gaurt meg) centers the. suppicnenoy 4 tho foofual baste ffs = vers thersis pot. or no such €qulkaleut pavision dealing wth the roel or ———revnena_of the. President ¢ oct fo calf cub the ormedl faces. the dichncton places ___Hecalltig out jasee oh a different chicgegy from A: fotste f dltclart. macho) tow ed >giptntl fhe poriltge of the ort ¢ fabeor capa s otkeresie,, ___the_framere_of the foncifuroi would hove Spl binped Aegedtir foe 2. pve ancl ___ provide! for fheie cevecetloa_and coving voithaut any qualficatcn ______ Pn Og cunsN OF: The. ceacen fe me dp. the treckneah oe void p>- nee fghighte the ite: # grout the Psidon te wile fewey on becodect de ie Kesey onc wert, _ ____cretidn_uniusiang the pewer fi coll out hecauce. it 1S considered os th pe ORION: PAGE pare _ — bengh fee at ga ages tal ae dc a hae Su cetouk bose iil able ond al suc nese tetiig safeguard by Congrece ond reyiced ly the ae Za ws of the Condit five| witent to give th President fullecrefonay —. 44 — © . — ga — _ 5 + — ©, a = 2 ans _ ORIONS. ena » _& Wyss ____FEBRUARY_5, 00 _ — — SBNLARAC represented by REP a SM: BOUT STA — — VG - EXECUTIVE SECRETARY - SECRETARY ANGELD REYES EAqS: Dunng the nee husre & Tay $4 oe , some three - hundred Jone te alte ni eH oe af tm whe redghation Y reese and jhe PNP 7 ey Tese_a te Oonchtuke @ bla of Bei i eur clomareri_No- %. tee Pebellon Ni cal Order Nb 4 , the Pilppinee woe deck Highone teole place and the ofear went back their taracks im the enenihg of the some dey. On fuguct 11 2003, both the Proclamolion and General Orekre Wee Ifed, and Prodamation No- 136 ,dedanng the Cematon of the Stade oy Rebellion, We rected L6SuE! whether or pot he pebtienees have a (egal stadig-2-leu standli_fo bring suit.ond whether or not Proclanativn No. 43% and Gener! Oreler No- 4 are Gacitchonel - _ __ HELO! the Gurl ended thet fic both Predemation Nb 429 and Gena] croler Nb: 4 Gre_conctifudione! RAto OFcLoeNOr: Seefion 1¢ Arbtte vil doce not expreadty prohibit declonng «lote or rebellion Eo 39% ofc. fan Japon (as ther woe J 4 Foner: to he ag doe est - fied te valality of te said itig that the Said £0 wee cd. | ih - the ‘cme Wat ee bd of Tox Ny suled n EST. igston LOGUE: bhelher or not the £0 i cubject to He. Concurrence of of leat Us of He. — Senate - HELD! No, evecuive. Agremenk are aot hike. treabits ahich ave subject B the, cone Cumence, of of oct *f3 of the memberc_¢ the Senate 0 be ihe Me con iden which fall chock ree ae commonly repomed 2 0c 0v ecutive. agreements ard are. por 0 leet Common our 9 than, | 16s: te Aventinc. ute fom of euchauges of fotet and at other Hines __ where _ordinaay cPrecpondence bet 5 ord other govenmente ends cand age: — ent ~ whe: fendni Nested e or - offence = begin Mey omrehirse Bedipiah of Peody occertoinment -Jtatzulel be “uccledc to undertow po diccace here. he loge venicly of Cxccutive agrecstent — a6 such fontluded from fhe 4 tig thodrede og eccautive agreensate other than shave entered mito under the trode agrecsente act, have been negatitsted _ —____sith_foreign_govecnments » It told fem fo be. sufficient 1 order f_shao that the je agreements under the act of 19.54 ore not _andmalous in Character, that Hho a tet fed ond 4 Bee ee out ORIONS.. PAGE _ DATE = —hictog tsftcfo_terkeuh ¢ Clattes of agrtenent: before enlereel nto by he x costes ated heal of the Sonede they cower cach subjects a¢_the ——lnspeetion gf veccele pavigahnn duet, sicome. tax on ship) fe fue, celmit- td tm te om oy ti tel eb ep tr ect Santen adiakion are ject Matter aad tani acte; while_til chere plat tothe inch gover, dently of any legelabon - -& ENO Lwaege "spree 9 ta Go Tee No DEPORTATION BOARD da Gd Tele wx arretta by the NB! opt te. search of an efele which eae bee eo fh be the Heodquertee of 0g othe ™ velligente Sex fion_,ACMY of the United Gletec”. He war alleged to have with brit at she time of fre. lac Cheelee (i_yiblatoa oy Arts ed fenel de_ard rendered huicelt an unde roble ahen : heb frial te Booval shovld recommended te the Precttent of he Prilpnines the mncdiale depor- toto 4 Go Tek acon Undesirable alidn- Concequcylly ,his precenct tn thie ecantry having been. ard enll always be and a merace to the Peace. welfare, and cecuinty of the Com munity - Ge tek fikeal a motion of dicmicc on the ground prof the domplaunt war premo - ture becaure there war a pending case agevict him in the, city fMcolt office o Manila fo wiolohon of. Article 70¢- He Contenled thatthe. biore! hod! no furitdichon 4 ty $e Coye in rettin or yiew) of the citer diéfum ti Gua Chee Gon thot fhe boacd may de- fot aliuc only on the goude specified wi Me Jaw Tie Boorel, wh i reédlution denied “Go Tek Motion The Boord cearoned out that a conwithon icad_a prerequiite, befor He State my eeocuse ike nahite #9 olepod. an undeniable alien - further, the Reod i< only a fot fiiding body Mice funchon & ® mabe arretod and ceconmendebon v0 the, President th whom WC lodged the evolurive power fi deport Gn alien I¢suk! whether gr not fhe Deportation Beare con entertain a dgectation percecdiig based Gn 0 ortund which i a. specified uj Scher 37 ote dnnigeton low : __ fel» YES, the Deporteltin Booed. Con exfertet o Aepateton parcerclig bajed on a ground hich i¢ Ao} Qeeyfitd 1 Secon St the Tamigroion aw» Rati _DECT AEAOI: Uncler the _euisheg leas the. deetahor 4 an urdeible alien may be. —____offected by ecder due, nivedgafor , puso yank £0 Lechon 69. the _ Rewued Adninicreakve, Cade ord by the. Conmigginée oy Innigerbon_upen ceconmendaton — fre Boord_of Cone Sone nde Secon 34 ef thee immiguatior Low ._ the Sick. hos the. hte ofa ctl Soest eit when he dene Such etfen neceskany for the peace, and aa ae hly ——____ the. nokion che lan Bot. at et Exceutive nnd that thece Ee ee ae : ~ORIONS: PAGE vate abe stare” coated othe hy 6 tigunous fo the public ited be may, ee Bren inthe _cbccic of expe CO : ORIONS: __GeRNo- 09S Novenber 14, 195 LEVEN _ NG _ _ ~ — TE NON: RAMON P Marea GAR- _ —_— ERGS: President Coreen Agung file 0 caitunc| comple fer bef qgoine} leit Beftech- Ine lel auee thet ie ceotone edie nscesctlle pel dental _menily font. pore. a Coneltve divcbilily t Ale. sete. contend Het iy enninal proceedings. 1 se ty uve ofthe Preddedé pling of her_conplant ~aprdevit, she nay seg have to bea wrfnece of the prasecudon, beiaging her under He {nbd courtt er Thic_ oul man widireef woy de tc paultge of ton jy feom quit ae hy testifying on the witnecd stard- it akn Contendé thot the or he could rot be ——eld_hable for fel becouse, of fie. privilgeal cheencfer oth. publicoon He aloo sey thet fo allow fhe tbe] cote Yo pracecd would priduce a * chilling Gpecd on on peece_frecdom ISSUES wheter o¢ Conchiluton_, nay EME whether or not the. President of He. Philippines surcler fe ee ke _ceininal prceeduige ogcinet the peiioes through the fillng oy Gmplal ee = affidavit _ Heo: YEE, the President of he Philpainec, ocr the Ensthdhin , may inikide eaical proceedings cgorich the pctihons theuph the filling 4 Complaint qpidotit~ RAID veg TOBNOT: Tie pret ¢ umiutly fom suit, pertain fo the President by b= — af the fice ard moy he tiveled enly ty He heldee ¢ the opice aot by amy ater prcton_wi the President £ fielaff thos, an aceustol wi a Crining! cape ty shich fhe re~ seat 1 le it colie_the_ presidente! julege as @ defence 1 prevent _ fhe Cate from proceeding egomgt fuch accused: Moreaver , frere iC nebhing wi cur lant thet woul prevent Me President from soivig Me priviege “Phuc, ifso mute the Pra deat mey dhed te pratechoi afforded by the 2 lysed ulin te court ju —atedicton choice of whether orf waive jf 1c sted ae . tide ive, Lt 1¢ a decision je_stuned nel inpasedl by —____2ny)_ofher person the rationale fot the geal br ‘he President of the paalege mins - — —— ni fee Mit 1S fo accure the ae jal a oie fadent fe aot na 2 fh 7 ade. ‘onsai ahh, te de — undivided a: __ GR NO 119-903 : husucr If. 2000 io HON. RICRRDO T GLORIA Vs Hons COURT oF APPEALS FROS! Dnvote respond ent Or. renee Icosano woe appointed as Solkolt Di- wision Superintendent _o, 19 dation of DECS Secre- Rivard Glon'a Teta 1s reayned A ee. tts Sf ference Gnd fice iC penne reas he same alekt om ack 4 the President, vileton of fh. doctrine of fees dental fnmusily from Suit ESSUE* hether or nob the filing of the cary wiofedec the *Precidentiol uinunrly ron iit" docting eWi_No. Hre frlrig of the. cage did no} idfofes the * presidential immunity fon suit " doctrine - RATLO DECEDEN OT: Pohiners’ conten fia ic untenable beccuse, ition rected agauict pefitionarc adore arco. tepid Be con not a boi fecc “head s_are not the ocke of —_ en gerne pect katt oe pte he ee FACS hulle - operse~ Troncfer Controc for the woke fo energy peyjeet wee fig - ned _befeiten JANG ard the Philipplace Goveranent. the BOT Gontact wae submitted fo President Ranos for approval bul uae phen_be close te the tnd cf Ais terms thet 1 teen expired without frin_signiag the contract: fle, however, tadorced the. ane 2 triconng President Ectrada - svth he chouge.,_adearnictraboa came chan: geen policy and! econamic, ovirorment,thus the oT tantrack wor not puted ard. umplementec JAN CoM aqppraed to the. frerident foc ceconcideraken and decpife 1 endeny of he ampeol MUD couced the publcalon of an orivifadoin to pre ~ qualify cad cubsiit popasole for volid warts. manegement ESSUE: Whelber or not decisions by ance. divisor may be. cppedled fo ti the Se A bane: Iy6L0 No, decisions by an 66 Biviaon consol be gpprokd fo in the CC en beng» RATIO OCT DOT! The Court En bonce 1 not an qypellake ch dees siwi_o fesolutiin_ of 0 Bivisioin mey be oppraed. A decinon of 0 Division gf the _(ouct i¢ a dectinon of the. Supreme court - “eR MO. ert) i Joy 13, a Re nde Luttoquio Gacell, Tr. aicoutsing Cniingl Core wot _antulled by the —$C_The_repondent judge woe olse senchiwied pilh_o eepnitend ard a fine. 4 — —F10,.n +2 _foc_ gas jgporanes_ of fre law The yudgement wot trade. by the Division 4 the ct» _ ___ PEOPLE _OF THE Pade PPIniEs _ ee — HON: GUA QUIO_2- Get, dro _ BRS For_ failure 2 chek Mh. ch of the peared the ect regperdent Iscut: whether or nol the Seand_Ovvision of the Sopcone Gut hot the geayetence.. date tivcy dip cep aden dye = tf 0: VEC, the Secerd Dida op the Speen Cavct tac the tompetence te edn ste tively dicdpine. cepenceut pindge = Lente Ne OeNor < se: [ALWIL of the Condifuton clearly dws Hat there are ochvd- 2 Lituatine envisaged jherein The fit chute vbich slater thet “tre. en bane: ________shell_ have, the power ty dic aplh ec cs" 16 @ declaration 4 the —grzatt_op that dis ciphroy paste to_,ord the determicoben ap the price dure. sh __ the, acct fon & the lowct tn bert,- tt wor nok thas tad thet oll adta’ _______nictanve, aicesplinay casee should be teard and decided ty the whe. Guuct sinceit auld recult tn an absurdity he second owe, which rcfees 2 the. afl wicone Kanntre ond Hat the Poyment of Such intome tox by Juctite and Judges doce pot foll wit tne conckivhoial poiechon ageuid decreace Y ther valonte dunt thei? Saloniee duaiy thar OontiNuance in offibe - a _ORIONS:. li “IN Rt FIR ENORCEMENT FROM SE} © ppt. 1 114 : HONORABLE RAUL M- GON IMLES FHCRC. An Anon morK [eter by “Concerned Emplycer op the frere dunt * odd ee 66d fo Hon: Real M: Gon alex referniy 1 charger for dis barnmient hrought by Mr. Miguel Qewo Ofori Mr Juctce Marcelo B- Ferten ard aclung Mc Goracka “fo do sowethiig about thic! The sélard ofachment ic act of a telegom fron Mr Miguel Quenco addrected # Hin- Roul M. Gonalee , where Mr Cuesko refer fo pleadings he opperertiy giled on Febnioy otq , 14¢Y with tre Syprene Soult wi Rel - Nictrotive Cage no~ 3125 vahidh. 1m te oprisn of Kir CuK sade improper ary “iaterventon ” by Me Rou! Gomrelee «Mr. Quencd Menethelec, crotornges Mir- Gon — Peleg “fo file ceeponcive Pleading Suprone court en bone fo comply ith pelijion lorcerned Empleyees Supreme Gyart oclung Taredbayah © intervention - AKCUE! Whether or aot the cutit comect iq Akmgajg the Moher for Meconndera - tion 2 Me cutnce . HELO! YES, the Cowt ig correct si digmieshg the Mohon for receriinterahon of Hr (uenco « RATIO OCLAEN DL: A acmber of the Supranc Court must first be Cemoved from Ofiee, via the eonctduinal ue of Impecchaett urder fechen f ard 3 of Article YI of the [467 toacfitution » Should the tenure of the Supreme Court Soctce be thas feminettcd by impeachment, he may then be held 1 archer either crinitelly aad- minicrotively (by dicharment prcecdiygs) for ay wrong or micbefoven drat may be proven againt hii i appropriate procecchigs The remedy g a1peren with a legi~ fnate, griewarce ic ® file impeachment proceeding s- : ORIONS. * Beil SRN Led Mabe 30, 190 __Téod0RD ¢- SANTIAGO, JR: Mc _ MISC JUANITA BAUTISTA FAUS Ae the shea) year 1164 1466 esos hen abaup fo tid , the “Conmitite on the Roting ¢ Students for fongr * woe concftufed by the feachea coyomed af sord schoolfor He purpete eg Selecting the “honor shidents’ af ite graduoting lem: Teo ~ depe_forbigt a grade six ghuderte or represented by hic moler, filed complaint olleging that tie Commitee conmvted grave alone of drccrehon wi chasing He fonor Sludents at Teodor was only given the tid rank will er while Potica Ligat who vec abys behind fini Kor Second m rank. The CFL of Mtebofe ditmised the core on the gerund fhat the _complouit therein utetec Ao cauce Of acho , ord moved for recennde - rotion but the vame proved fr be fuhle hence thie appro!” ESSUB! whether or not on Qaicrd of hotter: 0 student by @ Beare! of teachers fall urder yaredictien of the wrt - HELO! No, on award of honor fo a Stident by a bed Of teachers doce nof folle under yuncdiction of the burt RATIO DECLDEN OL: The aid commultte ¢f teachers doce not fall wiftwi the category of the tnbunol bearel, 0 ofpter Cvercising Yuditial functone Comtemplated by Pyle GC. Thorder thot special civil achon ¥ cenhtran’ may be wivoleed ui this yanisdiéfGn the following cireumcfancec must exist’ 1. that mere muct bea peat Gantroveay uivoNing nighte of persons or Prperty ord Socd Controversy I< baught before a Aalunal « Baar or officer for feantg_and defertination ¢ their respective aghts ard ebligoharc 2: the tribunal , boord or officer befere ahon the Controversy I6 brught muct have the Paver ord aultonty FP pronoune sidgeaest ond render a decision on the _controvery) Conciauing ard _applyiig He lows 1 thot end» 8: The frbunal board or officer mac pertain % tot branch of He Sovereign er which belongs tr the yudioiy vor of heart hich doe¢ Not belong 10 fe gitlatve or exeuhve departnert- _ - ORIONS:. 8 Fath PAGE: DATE oul- ast Al. CEUT ERED ACIS: Tn on eroforical Cartect held vi Nose, Camornes Jur (Sf fenaor wor g!- ven by the beard of uidgec 49 Neder Nocce ond vecord ener fo Emma Imperial * Sia days later Ena ached! He Court of fret Inifonce of Hob province fo reverse. that cword alleging Hot one of the yudyes hod falken #2 cor im grachig her pom focmonce -Affe- o heonng ard over He objection of faur Judger of Me contest Fie foort declared Erma o¢ winner. Hence, the special Cul achon chollergmg the Goust pooerto moclify the boad€ yerdict « ‘16CUE! whether oF Ob the Court has Juin cdiitton_dver the. board &_decsiion? HELD? NO He hurt dor not hove yoink dicho over the board ¢ decksion - Rpt OECEOEN OF: The yodicracy har nd Prwer 1 reverts the cward of the beard Of veges of an crofortcel toned: PCat mattr it seul not uiterfére on Heraly torfert. Beatty confecks_and cimilar Cong efitonc _ - ORIONS*. "Ely PM: a tése | Mqwe re, fa RUDENTERL_ RANA we JUDGE Jock p cACTRO FACE: Rchig on He “Refit for Rediess eve onerelieh ore for volurtary Tabi = pion. “filed by cecpondent Beyfamid M- Grecia bincelf. dak Februay & (97, Preuing thet the dectinen < Novenber & 196% ond fle reseluton of the. dental ef a te motion for ccconsi deration ¢ the oid decision 66 vet aide and @ New Ohe eH ~~ Hered ly this Gurt_dicmicting the odminichative complaint ond Cxoncratiig the cespndent The decttcn wor alte quéctoned ty the respondent due tr lack 4 cer ______hificoton by the enég yictice met the concluciinc ¢ the Gort were reached 14 tonsulfotion before the Core wos aaigned 1 a mcnber fer Mie writig of the opir Aion of fhe dourt- GUE! Whedter ar not phe deciiiin violoted fhe cenk plachon_cequitemest under the _Constitution RArIO ECE DENOL: Alo, the dtcasion ded ast violated the Certifiecda requirement order the _Ootcfifuton - The certiptation requirement refar fo deagone in judicen. aot odminic drake coves: But even tfuch Cerhgiction acre Cequired «if ic beyorel doubl thal the con clsnons of the Gurt i ite decision were arrived at_affar oon- whedon and delibteohon -The sighiig Or iynaturec of the menberr who actually fore port wi the deliderstont ard voted alest 1 thats Reader bung afer cudam deci Siocon opiron of the ourt af aahde, Here iC no Ponente alfraigh any sen ~ ber of He fourk wey be oKined wate the draft Ja such cares ,4 forme! certifi cofion_r¢ obuiducly not required: 6B MO- 76278 LC OR. AND MRo- MER LIA CoNLSING, a ae Ve _ _ THE Coury OF AAPEALS = - - FACES: A enimitcl Complamt piled by Sento agoinst Mértin Conciig. “charging hi taith phe Crvme, of Vid/aton of Municipo! Ordinance No-7, Sertee of 7904 of Monla~ Na for contechig to sell to nee the fwo lots in _queyhen without pisst secur securing _ fhe approval of the Monicipol Corcil o Mahina for hic Subdivicién plon Gr Bu- gust_2&, 191, the CPT rendered yudgencyt ftiding thet olthetgh the Gosingc May fave" corecdeo! the urequlariec ardlor have complied bith the legal require men for the operations of thai cubdivision they cohnet eccape fhe fre : bulity FO Santoc for Nearing sold to her porticng of fhe rade or atreefe deneminctién: Gg Aight -OF-wey which wae afpiomed by the CA ISSUE! whether OF not the decidch cendtced Ay the regparctent Court of Appeals yn phic care doce not Comply eth the ccquiremeute of petitle Vil Sechon 13, of the New Conctituion - HELD: No. the deciwn rendered by the céeponctent Court o Ajpeale m thie cave doce nok Comply wilh dhe cequireneste of Article vill, Secton 13, of the Naw dons - brfahon ~ RATIO DECeOENAT: The abence, however of the Cerhficaten would net nee scanly miton Het the cote sebmiled for decigiviy hod not been reached in conculfedion before, being cctigned fone member for fhe tortng (ythe opinion of the burt sigco phe regular pertormonce of opie! duly 1¢ presumed Lec: C60) of Rule 131, Ruec of oust Tne Jock of cerhgicatior at the orc! ¥ fhe deeraoh wauld only cere of oul doce of foilure observe the ctrhfication cequirement ard may be bevic fur holding He ofpiscl respenaible for tic amicion & cccourt therefor [fee Record of the lonctfu~ frenal Connigton Teo] «Such obrence of Certfiehon weuld not Reve He Cftect ob tivalidatiig the decllon~ _ PAGE DATE _G RN. FE EE became 6 2000” TSAGANI cRUr a vw _ SECRETARY OF ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL — _ Ress FACS. Petihenere oscar! the constitubinalty of te following provision of the JPRA and ite Implencrting Rules ond oc 0 the ground thet they amount Yo an unlewpl - deprivation ef the Soto ewperchip Over fends of the public denathr as well a mi nacle ard tte natured recoureer frerein, im viblatini_of the regain decane OK beched 1n Sechon & , Achicle Vil ¢ He Cnlituhon - IF preged fat See 3,56 hg $200_St, 69, £4 63, 6 ond ble ard other relefeel provisions of RA -¥3}1 ore ncondifvhonal ond vivald- TSUE! whether or nek the provisicne asteife are anconsfilupono! + HEOD* NO. the Prviaene assailed! 1¢ dot un constutoral . Ran Obct DENOI: As the Volec were equally divided (7% 3) ard the necestoy majorly wos nab ebfouled » the case wae redeliberated upon: Aowever , afer redelibeycton, He voting remained! the ome -Recordingly purcort to Pule £61 ection 7 of the Ruled of Civil Prceure,, the pehtion 1¢ dicaitied ond the law ic dedaned_tonditehinal ~ _G PND. b-S2Iod) ___ Mneey ac. 1g __RIcARDD_VAUAD® WD, _ NS: _ HON: BMADO_6- IN CONG _ Ri. Ritorde Vetladgia aod onplye- by JOM wi IG} 0¢ 0 Kekphott Saleh Wood operctor: Heed vbiequenty frondgrrea! to the pasion of cert -Calledlor betoua, fegwes a vifermation te he competfore ¢ the compony. Valladehil pUSel of filo! a waite requedt foro vacchon eave ov gfatlg frerein frat Me would report fr work on Jaruay €, (941 - He dict nel repet for werk on Jonuay ¢ but sent a tele gom for Bicol on Rouoy §. 1999 requeding for /C doy wick heave ac he 406 confined for flu of the ar. Bttrellade Chaic- Vettade hal reported! for work on Februay Ie, 1939 The Frecy tive Vice ~Preniclent , Mr Daniel Ya. allegedly refuceo! to achnit- him aud wisteod acted hm fo reciga-On February «22, 1229. Valladoliol fikd a am -_ Panit for silegal Dicoyscal with vaceltor and dick leave dey o poy

    You might also like