IMMA M@ PRI VP WM DVAA MDD » 2 © GRAND L-70L9 TUNE 1g, 19 NAL EN | TH i teod during — ite delibecchone the entite ted of the bill. OF course, the Conchitutidin doce not cequire, Gorgiet to employ ti the fille of an enactient langucge of cuch precian as ft mic-Tat goppiees if Th _ appmpriete ocho’ Hecean, art, thuc prevent curptic, PAGE DATE tile shauld serve lators , the, peacone witerected 1h scope ond eoncefence of the popeted toto fo uiquile iifo bady of the bi) wdlidy and dicancc the some, tole __ pen the legit latore, The tec of fhe suppitrenty of Ale re whether or aot tic mitkeading ; and, technical accurmey Ke aot eccurtial, and Mo Subject peed not he stated 1A _eaprees teme whero di clearly wiferabie from the dételle set forth, @ hile wich Moo fain thet the aveogec peaon feodity it weuld nv} be infornecl of the. purpoce of the ehock- went or poten anquiny oc fo ie contewle jor ghiich é aicleoding either un refering fe oF fidleching one subject where onothtr or diferent one ic really embraced in the Act, or th oniting any expression or indtcohici of Me. real subject ortenpt of the ack, We bad Sigee the Pefitiner (¢@ quolificd voter fam the affeded barrio, he hac ery Aaht & become a Suitor t challenge the corcttutivnelity of the Act ot Pocced ty (eagres - - - “We. pups. ef He Conchuhoral demend hab ib suijed of fhe_ bl, and fle. pub - perattin And _tsfoon_the I “fhe .2f Be nd _ thi, to leadPI Gd No (42S 2 VICENTE PELN CRUX - Ve — tadfare, Crlitonct, No. "GRCTE! ith the elm fe Ueayetec polce Pose fo procte — cin and Elosie Ordinance of Rocout, Bulsean woe pocete and Cobar ¢ptrafore ed thi fikdionality of saved mplalc thuc aght fo engoge 19 a fowful bucinece fee tht, uot cnoeked pir S jose cut their basinesc. The loval erdinenee quant RA 93 which reode “AN AUT GRANTING MUNE eLPAL oR CTY BoRRDS AND toulNerLs THE PowER to REGULATE TRE CCTABLEGHMENT, MBINTENBNCE AND OPERA “To of CERTPan PLACES oF Raise MENT wrTHnl TREED “RESPECTIVE TERRTTOREAL JU _RESBLOTSONS,” the fice section of ith oye thet the wuniapal or section of which cys thet the muni cipol or clly board of council of each chartered _city hall hove, the po wer to regulate, but likewsce prhibit by ordinonce the ectoblithiment, maintenance, and _ operation of might clubs, cabared<, doncing schele ond the Ihe «The lower courte cule thet #ie prohibition iS a valid exercive of police power fo promote general welfare , fuuc_the appeal to the S TUE! wheter or neh He Powe granted by RA G3 icludes Peohiihcn acide | regulation WELD? VEC, The Court culed thet fhe power gronted Femaine that of cequlaton, net proti= Ibn following fe ule thet * Every bil hall embrece, only one, Sulytet which ball be ox preaed Ui tre title. tered: a "RArco OEEDINDE: The cout nde thal thee 10 displ 0c He fille reguletiog . Orcinances by vice ¢f the gettrel welfere Uarce mock be reovenall Consononce with the [ows ond publi peli of he ctete- Octinancec by wirtve gentral welfore Clow must he reatonablt sin tancorance with the Tos ond publi poll “of the skee- Such séping erate of foomoling pave nventonete oH is eer vox ef Pesenal ond papery Aghte. Municipal corpocshoig cannot prohitit He opercion ¢ Ss ight dulas_ But it con cegulate. such- -peewtnen y, 1104 mpvok Beriamin © ARAL S 7 _Freac: Prior fe Repubhe fied No HeRS alo kecusn oc" Act Conveding the Muni eipality 4 Mondolyong vito a Aighly Urtraied Cty to be bron ox te City. of Mandaluyong — Mendaligorg and fon Juan belonged f nly one Iegitlativy 4 Petihenere mole _te declare uneorchtutiana) R.A-No- HS, specifically cde Vil Sechen 99 theeea. Ati evil, in 41 of RB No- HFS provides? Ais_o highly -urbon ui i itch with tne fect ceprecentdive fo be chee Mand alugong hell have ite eon kegasletie. fed_ tn the next nafional eltetion< after the posage_of fis Aet- The remainder of the __ __ RATIO DECCOEN OT: the Cheoton of @ a Spaicalt, beg! omer [rgelelive died of Son Juan Mandebyong shel geceme the nus fegielabive fick of Son Wan with its ficet_repreceatative tt be lected at the vene eltetion: iecug. whether or ast fhe e/eshon Of Swarete, tongreccional_distd'et 4 Mendeluyong undér_A-A Hote tonplieg with the one fitle one subject cule ichion of the, tone hile - one gubreet fle hos been inva riclly HELO! YES, a liberal tonchru edoptea by # Court 0 of net 40 tripple. impede [gitlobisay recaniel ditael 4 ~for Mandaloyong ic nat a wubject separate and dichinel fron the subjtet of ‘fc conversiin tifd 4 highly tc - honited tity bul te a Neko! dro! logical toncequtnce qf ite eznvertion into a Aghly urbo- ized erly The pile neccesary inddec and contemplelec the wsubptch treated under Sechon, HE ragordig_ the creation of a aeparnte tongltetinnal dictich for Meudaliyong A libero! _ condiaiction ¢f he one fiffen one wubjct* rule_hot been invanably adopted by this court «toc nol te Cripple or inpede tegiclobon-ses 8 ee ve, eR Re RH HY see eaan . @ PND #1994 FemdupRy 24, 14et DEMETRIO G- OEMgTAR vs ow MONUEL ALBA _ - rere: Deaefid Orwelia. fike_o pellria for prohibiton ich Payer fora wit prelinitog rryurn wi HE tonchifionolty ofthe fel poegrph of ck of Peace Deane. Ne: 1, otheeate. noon ‘ht Re Decree of 1992" Tie cad_PD cule” nope Presiden fe tener oy fund appropietd fe is eta ay ef wi at 1 oe ethivity of cny_depactuent he Sellcttor Gareal_filed a (eoindie with o-neo ede me lly Sin 16(2) rev. te 1 Ccliny— Fecedot Constiitin 4f Mach 28, 10¢6 hae allegedly_cendered the. inefant pehiion meal rd. ocad mig — IccuE! whelhee of att Bedged Reform Decree. ic constitutionel. HELD: Tacton! pediin ic GRANTED. Pacgraph 14 Seohwi 4 of Frecidertial Decree fo pamo Dect ON OE; The Syprent. Court it nol ealy fhe highest acliler of egal quedicne bot aleothe Contelence of Me goverment: There are finee ofen_altheugh the daub hoe de aed it hil)_cught to he rested: Gusher devnarde fiat the lout ack only. for — the Wadicchein of the. xts_aight but algo for te quidone ef and of a sed-aint vpon fhe dluve - ThE prohihen 40 freneftr cm _appnpeicon for ene them #0 rch nas_expltit. -_= nd toler oder He 33_Cntitchen PO 1G) dal ate cated thepolege — granted. unde seid Seehoa 160 firhelo iil: 14 doce not only completely ch cep acl the. andacde_get ci Ye fundonenfol low , Gncunhing ty on tack, _delegen_of egidative pute, hud Rh goecbyond ke tour. Suc toncibhiel ipeaiite rode He peaicin in — _quechen_ nul nevi _ -* * »r er DR HHH DD SRN W “nppre 22,1991 TAFT Te GUINGONA IR 6 _ _ HON GUTULERMb GARA GUE FAY? The ______(with Peery Ballon for debt cerviee,) ond P1C6-3 Allon apprpricted under Pe = ___pulls_ Net No 4681 otherwiee Kaoun oc fhe Genesal Aypropahicns Act, or a feel. of es P 283: ¢ filliin- The pebjicier ov quechsning the Conctifuhdnably of the qufomehe — Oppropriahon for debt serviée i void budget Aubmebo appoptatin for debt service. _ i autho dyed by B-A-No- (B60 ac amtaded , Schon 37 of P-0-No.iifpand PO. No. 1767. However, pehhoners argue, thot being audamahc. , the lout ore uidonsstent pith Section 24, Aide VI og the Conchibuton wheiely all opppaicaon bile chall on'= gincte exclusively i the Howes op Reprecentoniec. IQUE! Wither oF not the eufonohe qppropnitton for debt ctevce. wi the 1970 bude get_jucuant fo R-A-Nb- 4460 ,a¢ amended , Section Stop pl: No. IIE and Pa: _ Nob 194} Coc file lawful quitertaton 6r_apaa pion ~ HELD: YEG, the oufinchic oppeopiion fer debt secuin pnt {le billy for see ee ye debt oogement wah sed fle ptaadic. cnedment of loc: a ~ - <0 connie _ il their eecentval_t and Condifivac ond Suppit cut steondardc are. indi cated _there~ - - tn The pugpoceof thece lows ix to tneble the goveriitont +b make prampt_peyntat. 1nd for_0d ve intou' H hi ne i 7 ecard _ other pomal henkisg chergee on the loons ,.tetdits or_tided tnees ,ac on the. bands, cle~ - hentues of! idence, i ecs_vold a_iyy evo eFHFTFFHFRFHFAHVAADDRA “P No 13100 pucut 11, 1404 _PAULEPPENE CONSTETULToN Aasoctarzon ve jon. SALVADOR EN RI QUER FAK! The Genero! Appropaiaton Net preps F $b-3 butheri for debt uervicne spcetol_prowdn which parvided thot the amount qpprprictsd chalh honal debt only and_not fo be poid fo the Wabibfrer + ___the Corral Bonk the oppropy for OPut_alse _pduided Yhat fhe mayjum cmon! Pt be contracted for the moiintcAanc. onal made are bridge should nel ex _________ teed a0_ the appmpetahon_for_meet zine by the Annee Forcer of the, Philippines —____quireal_appoval_Congeece forthe. erkors_of funde In ee A fpepiat is fd ¢ 1094 1 jation for the Aawtal tore of the Philppines_cantrine F the_gppoepciahon for 4 ine eal Shed —_______paovitina authori ping the Chisf of ef 1 te Wee. SOving ctx thes_appropiicl Ee ia pet end Bcf “tate The President vetoed the cuthoorohar given ty the Chicf of Stee 10 wee coving t_augrnent the penn and_ grobity fund: Sevseal sencters quectined the vali of the veto- GUE! whether or not the Praident & velo {¢ valid? _ - HELO: Pebhon apeM IED. tongrees ot wickide ithe general appeepr'a hone male that shuld be tnackd io Cepamte, Kgiclahon_and_ if it doce 0, the tn — —apppdels_ protic mutt be treated oC on_dsm_and_can_hevetred. by the Pre— _sident- - __Congites added 0 be used for payin RATIO Decco or! The paitich in GAN authoriding the Chit of State fouge so~ __vinge_te_ougment the psrsion ond geatuity fund vinlatec (cclion 26 (porageaph gQ_ ened Seton J4 Cpacegrnph of Artie, @ of the. 11% Concitvhin. daly. the P= a ——Sideat ic_autborived fo cugment itemne fron coviegs ti the genteel apprpaction to _ - ___the_exctutive hoorch. Ale pucucat 1 Section 29 — Ne money boll be,paol out of — the teeasuyy except on uctucake, of an appropdote. made, by fou» __ afugit 26, 114 RNG neice __ AR TURD MA TOLENTZND: THE SbCQETARY Of FINANCE — —_———— Fars! pelo nino che i quetenng tho_conclfubsnelly of PA FHM ofterwice ____known as the Expanded Volue, Added Tox CENAT) bow Hl 1119} wor fuk “i the Houce of Reprexceatahives where it paced three ten. and_ thet fttrwords. it ling it wo_ceperrecl 40 the denaty hoy toe sent to the Snake where, offen ficct ond Meanc Conmiiiee, the Strate. dil not powy ‘ton geeond ond third Ceoditge ord ear psd aan Wtenon (NO: 180). oped on Mey. 24,1014 The peihd- eee orgued thet ox the tare Qi ec_nbt the_weton_pocced hy. the. HOR buf inctead sac fhe Genale vests therfore. the bill did not exclusively ovig fron the Howe. of Repreceniaties ord wblalec Sechon 24, ide & of the danctittdion TSC’ Whether oc not the, Seale na props an _anendment fo Houce_Cenenutes bilby enooting ike own vesinn of a foyer bull > _ Reco: YES, the Court firde that while Art. vl, ection 24 pawidex that oll op pupae Hon, PEE Nye or forge fille, bile thonging imcucace, of the. publiedelit, bike of focol_opplizchein ,or_privett bille must * erginate exclusively tn the Houce of Represen~ ation ec Representotiver,* it alto prides “but the Serole ay propast, or eentur with _areadments. _— RATIO DECLDENOT* The Couct uk thot ii fhe. exerci of hic paver, the lencke may. prope. on citve, aww bill oc a ubcHtvle. meotur fucthtrmass the Couct finde thet thee 1¢ algo _ ap. prvhibifion fo the fill of 4 Cercle Bil im antici john the _ceipt of the Pall coming fron the true, o« long ag thee i¢ Ao further ction by tH Getafe pending receipt of Me Howe Bll To wit whet fhe dncution only requec i thet the itching muck Gm fron He HOR on the thon that thy oromore. cenci five f the neede ond problems of their locality _a >%YDADA DA BD TUBE 24, 200 MING CENTER Of THE PHELE PPINES NY lung Ceater of the Phillppiner woc agcecced Reol Proper pedy Jove by the _ wy Oeexcor_o of Queion City: Pehtionte Comtends thot jt ¢ exempt from _ Reol Propedy Tea 0¢ 6 thenitatle Tndhtshon furcucat 1 Ale ul Sechin oe C8 ofthe Condi = tuton The papital mi ite queeahons odaife atioake renders meditel services ,leaveg pechons ot 4h lend fo private, Porkt<, ond cere out perhone of Hie _herpital to pri- Vatt_medlcal peditionees oon which it denivec wicome 10 be weed foc aptenfctal - Li penges~ TGs * lohether or not the lung denter o¢ q chontable widtitubon i cent {om Peal Paperty Tore on the. pnuely it oseupieg, Heub: Porticlly GRANTED. The exempicin fiom Real Prpedy Tarec ix Pactially grated: rar Ie The Court Aled that only they portion 1 the lend occupied by a sed for fe otieuts usbethtr paysag or non pang ore setayt fm ot i aaa a tne pat mae i al on er He too clainc the ckemphcn muct heor fhe, burden to prove, by eer andl une. unefuivotal pang, thet eats tic a cl en (al jog fiec ore, BOTURWY, OLRECTLY ord EXCLUSIVELY Used for charitable prsrpacer thee ne fond eit fect> 2 FHF FMF AMRAAAXAIXAXAAMXAAAIAAAAPD eee e ea SRN. 107264 ocTOBER 1914 | Purzlb 2. TAN - vi a = RAMON R. ok ROLARIO TR» ____ --- , deducfitne from, gress vicene of Keble income Lt no. TH 4b inifed Ae. rofecnibnicle (h the. _tomputahionc of tl that ated th taxchon_ord_due_pre-. nox Argued lated the requirement of untfocmily 1 taxchion or cep | cea brea tingle ppchestipe ord pefecconal acre tomed. dipper fron Cor Taub! wheter or no deducfene theuld_be unfor for all? hho ORMIGED: rhe Court rukd thot RA 74M ic conctifutienol Rarto DECLORNOT: Uniformity doce not _paohibit clots fication 0 long os the tequile mente for o voli Closdfieahon under the equal profecten clatce an, complied wth Shigting the toyotin of vidividuals to the. Scheduled system which makes fhe wicome fox depend on the lind of topable uicone ond mointining for_corpuotions the. glebel. treatment shieh fect 1h cention all kinds if foxable Wicony of the toxpeyer le not _orbiteg- ; : _22222 2xFD7D PD > 2» 29 oe eee HD DXHAD 2 GA Ab 11273 sul CONGREG MAN EN AL GUE f 6A v 2 a __ TH CVE CUTEVE SECRETORY EES FACIE: Extauhve Orker no 436 don addihbro) daly af 9% on corde oll cnc cig foil products tilts xteubive Order t¥y unipeted a special daty_on crude oll cand _oif producte- Pebfioneac cloimed that both f0% art unconshituhbnol because oll. ceverut meacurec mut oginote fom the haw ¢ Representatives ord the Feniy_ ond uclome Code authored the precident fo trreace, fu fanfe duticc only to protect local “jnducfaiec bub not 4 Coie oddihenal revenue for the goverment _ TsUE: Whether oc nok the tanye catex imposed are val? HELO! Pehon OremscseD for lock of ment The ascaled Frtqutive, Order are Valid: AATO DECEDENDT: Congecs may by kav author's. the president fo fit fen cond obbe dutres within specpied linifs. The icuarce of these £0< authored My Gechion Tof_and 4014 of the taafe and Custome Code. there ic Aothing in the law thet Suggests that He auttoaly may only b€ verared to paoteet ovo! inductee. Cuc- fons dutied may be deaynated 10 cchiove more than one polly objective, the protec: fron ¢ local wiductrice and fo calse, revenue for the gaveenment- - ORIQNS:MO TNE cctoaer “H, a) HAY Peoples ALTERNATIVE conlttgoN a #20. series 0 ten Preadent Fide] Re- mes * CREATING AND DESTGNATING A PORTION OF THE AREA covered BY THE FoR-_ MER Camp JOHN CHAVI ASTAE JOHN HAY SPecopL Economie Zong PupsuANT JO __AGPUBLIG_NO- Jorp"+ Petitioners allege that Proclamebon No» 420 1 uncendifutorial Wi $0 for a it gents tev_cxemphons mevely through the president, when such power c@ades with the Iegicltive. though Reticle V1, dechon IY (4) of the Constitution whith powtlec thot No law granting cry tay Oxemptor sholl b& posed without the ¢onue rence i the menbers of Congres TRUE! Whether ce not Pro dondlisa_No- 420 ic Unconchitutivel mh prying for Nebo ~ el ond loco! tox exemtion sithin are grenting other Economie inicentives f the John Hay Cpecial_Etonomic 2one- HELO: YES, tox exemption geoake ic (unconctituhional «Incentives under RA: 428% are oxclucive fo the Subic. Spveral Fconomie Pone- RAtIO OECLDENOT: The Cowt cultd that iti ther legick alec lim __prowision_of the. stots conclihuhon , that hes full pawte fe txcayt ary pecmn or tor - porclicn or clots of property rum fev.ahen its paver fo exenpt betig os brood _oc_ ZA paver 4 4ox- jn the. cose ot herd, the tor. excempticn would efrgumvent_the Cong pitutione Cequicenent the © | ing_ory ta) pin must hove th lon urea of c wejoty_ all the. tembeer_f tong 4628 GRAND RVG ‘SUPTEMBER Ie, nag TRESITA G FRaraN HON: ANIANO A. OEStEPTO PACE! Geehion eT of PA G0 wor oseailed. on the ground thet it provides foo Ga. op fal ts the Gpreme Curt fron_decinone ui edninidratve Covee dtc by Hhe On= buciman: Lt ig contended that the pervisions gece egoinct Section a0¢f Actido & 9 a the 1964 Conctdution which slolec that “no law shall he Posed iicroting the appa fot. sirisdietion op the Syprem Caurt os provitled tithe Conditufion without ite ad vice and concent, Hue “whether or nob or nok the Court may apptal fron decinont of the Ombudeman? __ eww echin 2 Jt op RA: 6#0 cannot valelly Guthort 1 the Supceme, Couct_ few. decistine of the Ombudeman 1A ndeinicive dcplaey tate RAT OECEOEN AT: Tt Gonsequently vidlatce the proseriphon of Sechan 30 Article, ___t bof 1 the 19§f Conchituhion against a_law — mn rae fhe Spptliote udedichon of the Supreme, Couct- No Countervay gente fo —— Jacty such_dictegard of the tonctitutiona oni al way Fat ge the Spree lout 0 acasurt of contol over faced under its Ardichon, atherwice the ridiscri mitate tnactment of legis letion ae : p= pelle juvedichon would uineeestarly burden the Sypromy CourtGR Me WeSC Aue 36, 1994 ARTURO M. TOLENTING ee ve _ _ THE SECRETARY OF FEM ANCE __ EI T_contends ti fat by 0 woving fhe. extmphion of the prea fon montaining those granted * » ete th 1 fou diccrimineter againgt thy prest. cee _ cacerts that RA. No-TH1b impoue the obligeficine of contracts and ee ne fue thet tower shivld be uniform ord Equitable ard thet Conyrecs chrall “eolee a ca grecsive syctem of taxatvin CUP arguec that legiclature wae 1o edopt a depiatte. 7 pig nti oye pap ate pce Gna ee embo~_ — dies prviaone on ¢oo; MCE TO Sul i the ld, there fon. be ine, a. tahonel polity- TSUE * whether of not RA. F¥1b i¢ unconct tuhionel . _ HELO’ \lo- fn withdrew ing the ekemptitin, the, fous merely Subjtets the prece to the sSane tax burden fo which other businece ove long ogo been subject + The yAt (¢ not a Lneence, tow {tit impaced purely gor revenue durpocer. Rao Deez oenor: Equoliy ond uniform ‘axctich mean thot all toxedle ar- _ticlec or bind of ey pecly of the soate clog be tered atthe some rote If ic CAough thet the, yuna or ordinance, applice equally #2 all pecconc ficme and Corpacatione ploced ti scimilor_cituahen =Suit 1, 194 palur E CONSTITUTION Adoct ATOny ve = AeN. SALVADOR ENALOUER hionens ogcoiled cd the validity of RA teu: 103 or or Gene - Genecal Ppprepniafivne Ret : 41194. GAR conaine a. recial povinda Hef allows any mem beer of the Gongerece He resiignment- of Ley Mlocaticn for Operational Expences_ povided thot the fotel of Seid allocation i¢ not ceeded: Philtonca claims that only the Senate, President Ged the Sprcleer of the Houce of lative are. the _onee autleried under the __ tencitutss to fe ign_Sov inge,_n04 the idividital members of Lorgrecs Hitmsel vec. —_fresidenb signed the low, but Veloee certoia partusions of the low. cad ae Cer - fain prnvisions of the law ond smpored Cectain_provis el condibiing : thet fhe AEP “the Wef of oye 1 outhonited fo vet sowings 40 augment the pension a = —___uréte the Retirene, stand. Seporatyon Benefits of the AFP. — IGUE* Whether or pot RA Webs _i< Wolotive of Actioly VI, Secon IC ©). 4. De Conctitubin: — HELO! Yes, only tte rete President ard the Sproker op the fou qreallowtd_fo. appaove the reolignment: PALO DECEDRNOE Furterree, tue condine muct be mel 1) the fuck fo be tld es aly cogent 3 we fe gta fing the eae of crpeacituree fo hich cid =A 40 the Cectoin_ _ tondifion given to ie AFP chicg of mnmnAWnDDD 7 “88 GP_NO tos S94 ApRE- 16, 1992 CESAR BENGFON NG _ Hon FRANRLIN N- DRILON FACKS! Repubho Ack No- 1H povided thal Penne of uct of the Supreme, _t Appeale who served for 10 years shell be adjuded «In 14, | Precident al Decree b+ repealed RA na but woe not publithed In 179, (ourt_issucd_@ eealtion adjusting Mee peostens in Accordance bo RP. 11- Genteal A, fick cucthorived the Chibe Guclice uce savings forthe — adjusted, prociong «The preaient vetoed all poctcine contoining ceperenctd fo the ad- Justment of peanons - EGU the or ak the. seb veo of the preteat vel82 HELO. Peto’ GRANTED. a _ a RATIO ECL DENOE « The veto poworte | Do absolute. The Constitution provides sc thal $s rte dn bic uh pain or appropricte bill doce not gn es ct te pe iy ‘pork, pit tein:@eov ( Faep ss Republi Bek 994 probed that the_reonganisation pln depled by te __pactnent of Labor ond Enplymnent and submited it fo the precident for _appave]. thall deemed ac approved by the Cangreee ater he adjeurnment_unlecc 1h_the mean~ fing, ange by fealuhin cicoppeved He plan ond ovale ic concitetibnaliy TiCLE:_ whether er tof enacineat of Low by Legislative (iachon ic vale? HELD The contemploed pacedue. viele fhe eonchtatoal powcns regu lingo Siva and 9 > d y eer Gj PNO 1 6991E jpret_s4, 116° TAA AoW _ 7 bon: Jugal C- TUERA, FREE The pene file rd for wit of 1 ard for « imandemus compe) Peep u varbuc prtcidentiol deceec , leffere ae ic ard « adminicjreive ordere- ordere. The date. dicmitced cutnight on the ground fh haven legal peccona ly or ctonding 1 fo being Kic_tictont pet for Generals The vit ic submitted thot wi the ab petition are peeanaly a disc ofict- on barons ant fhe preadentiol sateen He ier hand, petitioners maintain thet since the_ _w ubjeek of the. postin Cer pubhe. night and its_object 1s t compe! she mente. of a puble, duty thoy need pot ow ay specif in Heal fc Ht ae a —e glen dato A park tne! __ iat pn eaten ts eae a _pebtioners_ herein Ka public Aght tecogaed by nd Kee than the fundanentol aud _ ____of the lated Ree wridenke ont iN in theo, Gazette ic not a gin qua non sequirement for the. ea gf lave their own effechiviy dete. Lt ie thuc Submitted that slice the pestilence auction. pean pro: Siping 00 fo the dote. tha are fotoke effect; publitehon ui the Official Gore 1 hot _____piditpeacable. for the ttpectivty- _Tssugt Whether or nob pub heaton wn the Ofgicsal Garette- 16 required Before cy lw tr Glotute becomes valid ord enforceable + The tout hereby eve re recgendenk fe publih fhe Cfo acto t= public precidentol iccuenes edith, ar of genteel quphtation, ced unletc co publited they hall hove po binding forte and effect + Arktle 2 of the Civil dade, doce not pre~_ clude the ceguicement og publicction mi the Ota! Gareile .Cven if fhe [cus itcelt __prouttee for the date a cfpechiily PATO OBCLOENDI: The clear objert of thic_ pro wilon_1& fo give. te govral publ odequdt notieé, «f the Vanier. [awe which are to eegulot their adionc ard can- duck a¢_cetinenc- without such nokiee and publitatoin there. weuld be, no fa for the oppliection @ #6 navden ignarantia fegic_nominen exewat- .. @>2.@%00? >» 77FRT9RFPFVIVA IVIVDIOD ? » »>XI7XV9O0IO090 ees ft weuld be fhe height of uiyoctice fo punith or otherwiie: burden o edtiten for a the_franeg rescion_of law which Ne hed aot or Ae notice whatsoever pot ven a ~conctructive one: The vey fret clause Cechon 1 af Oh 39 rkade: there cto be publithed i the officiel Gorette Brhe. weed “Sha f” therein impoces upon reépon= dent ofrsle on unptrative, ty Tht ty. muctb¢ trgorced if the. conctituhidfe! ~ git te people 40 be uitemned on matte of Public cence I¢ to be gon tab fonce_and Validity - = oo