Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Distribution channels
LECICO Case study
Presented to Dr. Heba Sadek
0
Distribution channels
Table of Contents
About Lecico corporation.............................................................................................................................. 2
Vision and mission: ....................................................................................................................................... 5
Thematic analysis of LECICO ......................................................................................................................... 7
Internal and External environment study ..................................................................................................... 8
1. PESTEL Analysis ..................................................................................................................................... 8
2. Porter’s Five Forces ............................................................................................................................. 28
3. SWOT Analysis..................................................................................................................................... 29
LECICO Distribution Channel Objectives ..................................................................................................... 30
LECICO Major Alternatives .......................................................................................................................... 30
LECICO efficiency template ......................................................................................................................... 33
Make or buy analysis .................................................................................................................................. 37
Return on Investment (ROI) .................................................................................................................... 40
LEVEL OF INTENSITY ...................................................................................................................................... 0
Refrences: ..................................................................................................................................................... 0
Appendix ....................................................................................................................................................... 1
Semi- structure interview ......................................................................................................................... 1
1
Distribution channels
History
Lecico has come a long way since its modest early beginning of manufacturing 1000 pieces of
sanitary ware per day. The company was the pioneer in the ceramics business in the Middle
East and its origin goes back to 1959 when it started its first manufacturing facility in Lebanon.
Lecico Egypt
Lecico Egypt is an Egypt-based public shareholding company engaged in the manufacture of tiles
and sanitary ware products. The company operates three factories in Egypt, one in Lebanon and
one in France, which produce over 6 million pieces of sanitary ware and 22 million square meters
of tiles annually.
Lecico founded in 1975 in Alexandria, Egypt S.A.E Group (Lecico Group) is one of the leading
sanitary ware and ceramic tiles companies in Egypt. In 1997, the Gargour family entered into a
50/50 joint venture with Sanitec Ltd OY (Sanitec), a prominent manufacturer of sanitary ware in
Europe.
Subsequently, in November 2004, Lecico Group executed Egypt’s first dual local and GDR offering
and is now traded in both the ‘London Stock Exchange’ and ‘Cairo & Alexandria Stock Exchange’.
As a result, the shareholders structure of the group is now as follows: Gargour family continues
to retain control through a 32% stake, while Sanitec’s share has been diluted to reach 15%, down
from 39% in addition to the free float that accounts for the remaining balance
Lecico Egypt S.A.E. is the principal operating company in Egypt and acts as the holding company
for the Lecico Group of companies. The following chart sets out the corporate structure of Lecico
and its principle subsidiaries.
Lecico for Ceramics Industries S.A.E was established in Egypt in 1997 as a joint stock company.
Lecico for Ceramics Industries directly owns the company exist Borg El-Arab sanitary ware plant
(the new Borg El-Arab factory currently under construction is owned separately by European
Ceramics S.A.E. ,as to which see below ) and its operations focus on the production of sanitary
ware for domestic and export customers.
2
Distribution channels
International Ceramics was established in Egypt in 2004 as a joint stock company. Lecico Egypt
currently holds 99.9% of international Ceramics S.A.E.
Sarrdesign S.A.E.
Sarrdesign was established in Egypt in 2009 as a joint stock company. Sarrdesign is a brassware
manufacturing joint venture between Lecico and the Shaarawi family with a design capacity of
300,000 units per year.
The company was established in 2007, the company’s purpose is trading and marketing of
sanitary ware, ceramics tiles, and trading in modern building material.
The company was established in 2006 as a joint stock company where Lecico, Egypt holds 70% of
its shares, the company’s purpose is distribution of ceramics, sanitary ware, tiles, kitchens and
bathroom accessories.
Stile
Stile was incorporated in 2009 in Italy. Stile is a joint venture between Lecico and the SFA Group.
The JV is responsible for the marketing and distribution of ‘Stile’ as a new sanitary brand in the
Italian market with a full, exclusive range of Italian-designed products manufactured in Lecico
Egypt.
Lecico Poland
Lecico Poland was incorporated in 2009 in Poland. Lecico Poland is focused on the marketing and
distribution of the sanitary ware and related products of the Group in Poland and the markets of
the CEE.
3
Distribution channels
Lecico France
Lecico France SARL was established in France in 1994 and is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Lecico
(UK). The operations of Lecico France focus on the marketing and distribution of the sanitary
ware products of the Group in France.
Lecico plc
Lecico plc was established in England in 1987 and is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Lecico (UK).
The operations of Lecico plc. focus on the marketing and distribution of the sanitary ware
products of the Group in the United Kingdom and Northern Ireland.
Products:
Tiles
Lecico’s tile segment returned to profitability at the gross level in 2017 from losses in 2016. The
inflationary impact of floatation of the Egyptian Pound forced local producers to increase prices
despite overcapacity in the industry.
4
Distribution channels
We at Lecico believe we can only grow our business by focusing on our customers’ needs and
improving customer loyalty through a positive customer service experience.
Product Warranty
Strategy:
5
Distribution channels
Lecico’s strategy is to leverage its large production base in Egypt to build a significant presence
across the Middle East and Europe by providing innovative, modern design and world class
quality ware at competitive prices.
Expand regional and International Exports. Lecico’s strategy is to continue developing its
presence and foot print in regional and European export markets under its own brands and as an
OEM producer for leading global manufacturers.
Lecico’s exports to Europe account for over 80% of exports and over 35% of the company’s sales.
The Lecico brand has a 10% market share in the UK, France and Ireland combined. Lecico plans
to increase it’s market share in Europe by targeting new markets and OEM customers while also
widening its offering in existing markets. Lecico will also continue to selectively explore any
opportunities to make value-enhancing acquisitions.
As a result of Lecico’s focus on growing its presence in regional markets, the company’s sanitary
ware and tile exports to the Middle East have grown 50% annually over the last five years. Lecico
sees strong opportunities for continued growth in regional markets, particularly in those
countries with large populations and underdeveloped or rapidly-growing economies. Lecico has
established small trading subsidiaries in Saudi Arabia and Algeria to better access these markets.
Lower production costs. Lecico’s production base in Egypt provides it with relative cost savings
in energy and labour that allow it to be a competitive producer of world-class quality products
for European and regional markets. The company is dedicated to constantly improving efficiency,
cost control and vertical integration in an effort to remain competitive.
6
Distribution channels
Thematic analysis used in qualitative research and focuses on examining themes within data. This
method emphasizes organization and rich description of the data set. Thematic analysis goes
beyond simply counting phrases or words in a text and moves on to identifying implicit and
explicit ideas within the data. Coding is the primary process for developing themes within the
raw data by recognizing important moments in the data and encoding it prior to interpretation.
The interpretation of these codes can include comparing theme frequencies, identifying theme
co-occurrence, and graphically displaying relationships between different themes. Most
researchers consider thematic analysis to be a very useful method in capturing the intricacies of
meaning within a data set.
7
Distribution channels
Table (2): Thematic analysis for LECICO that emerged during the interviews:
8
Distribution channels
The regularity and richness of the annual Nile River flood, coupled with semi-isolation provided
by deserts to the east and west, allowed for the development of one of the world's great
civilizations. A unified kingdom arose circa 3200 B.C., and a series of dynasties ruled in Egypt for
the next three millennia. The last native dynasty fell to the Persians in 341 B.C., who in turn were
replaced by the Greeks, Romans, and Byzantines. It was the Arabs who introduced Islam and the
Arabic language in the 7th century and who ruled for the next six centuries. A local military caste,
the Mamluks took control about 1250 and continued to govern after the conquest of Egypt by
the Ottoman Turks in 1517. Completion of the Suez Canal in 1869 elevated Egypt as an important
world transportation hub. Ostensibly to protect its investments, Britain seized control of Egypt's
government in 1882, but nominal allegiance to the Ottoman Empire continued until 1914.
Partially independent from the UK in 1922, Egypt acquired full sovereignty from Britain in 1952.
The completion of the Aswan High Dam in 1971 and the resultant Lake Nasser have reaffirmed
the time-honored place of the Nile River in the agriculture and ecology of Egypt. A rapidly growing
population (the largest in the Arab world), limited arable land, and dependence on the Nile all
continue to overtax resources and stress society. The government has struggled to meet the
demands of Egypt's population through economic reform and massive investment in
communications and physical infrastructure.
Inspired by the 2010 Tunisian revolution, Egyptian opposition groups led demonstrations and
labor strikes countrywide, culminating in President Hosni MUBARAK's ouster in 2011. Egypt's
military assumed national leadership until a new parliament was in place in early 2012; later that
same year, Muhammad MURSI won the presidential election. Following often violent protests
throughout the spring of 2013 against MURSI's government and the Muslim Brotherhood, the
Egyptian Armed Forces intervened and removed MURSI from power in July 2013 and replaced
him with interim president Adly MANSOUR. In January 2014, voters approved a new constitution
by referendum and in May 2014 elected former defence minister Abdelfattah ELSISI president.
Egypt elected a new legislature in December 2015, its first parliament since 2012. ELSISI was re-
elected to a second four-year term in March 2018.
Economical
Occupying the northeast corner of the African continent, Egypt is bisected by the highly fertile
Nile valley where most economic activity takes place. Egypt's economy was highly centralized
during the rule of former President Gamal Abdel NASSER but opened up considerably under
former Presidents Anwar EL-SADAT and Mohamed Hosni MUBARAK. Agriculture, hydrocarbons,
manufacturing, tourism, and other service sectors drove the country’s relatively diverse
economic activity.
Despite Egypt’s mixed record for attracting foreign investment over the past two decades, poor
living conditions and limited job opportunities have contributed to public discontent. These
9
Distribution channels
socioeconomic pressures were a major factor leading to the January 2011 revolution that ousted
MUBARAK.The uncertain political, security, and policy environment since 2011 has restricted
economic growth and failed to alleviate persistent unemployment, especially among the young.
In late 2016, persistent dollar shortages and waning aid from its Gulf allies led Cairo to turn to
the IMF for a 3-year, $12 billion loan program. To secure the deal, Cairo floated its currency,
introduced new taxes, and cut energy subsidies - all of which pushed inflation above 30% for
most of 2017, a high that had not been seen in a generation. Since the currency float, foreign
investment in Egypt’s high interest treasury bills has risen exponentially, boosting both dollar
availability and central bank reserves. Cairo will be challenged to obtain foreign and local
investment in manufacturing and other sectors without a sustained effort to implement a range
of business reforms.
Services cover government activities, communications, transportation, finance, and all other
private economic activities that do not prod . . . more GDP - composition, by sector of origin field
listing
This entry gives the annual percentage increase in industrial production (includes manufacturing,
mining, and construction). Industrial production growth rate field listing
Agriculture: 25.8%
Industry: 25.1%
10
Distribution channels
Unemployment rate
Fiscal year
1 July - 30 June
This entry furnishes the annual percent change in consumer prices compared with the previous
year's consumer prices. Inflation rate (consumer prices) field listing
Electricity – production
Electricity – consumption
11
Distribution channels
This entry is the total natural gas exported in cubic meters (cu m). Natural gas - exports field
listing
Social
Egypt is the most populous country in the Arab world and the third most populous country in
Africa, behind Nigeria and Ethiopia. Most of the country is desert, so about 95% of the population
is concentrated in a narrow strip of fertile land along the Nile River, which represents only about
5% of Egypt’s land area. Egypt’s rapid population growth – 46% between 1994 and 2014 –
stresses limited natural resources, jobs, housing, sanitation, education, and health care.
Although the country’s total fertility rate (TFR) fell from roughly 5.5 children per woman in 1980
to just over 3 in the late 1990s, largely as a result of state-sponsored family planning programs,
the population growth rate dropped more modestly because of decreased mortality rates and
longer life expectancies. During the last decade, Egypt’s TFR decline stalled for several years and
then reversed, reaching 3.6 in 2011, and has plateaued the last few years. Contraceptive use has
held steady at about 60%, while preferences for larger families and early marriage may have
strengthened in the wake of the recent 2011 revolution. The large cohort of women of or nearing
12
Distribution channels
childbearing age will sustain high population growth for the foreseeable future (an effect called
population momentum).
Population pressure, poverty, high unemployment, and the fragmentation of inherited land
holdings have historically motivated Egyptians, primarily young men, to migrate internally from
rural and smaller urban areas in the Nile Delta region and the poorer rural south to Cairo,
Alexandria, and other urban centers in the north, while a much smaller number migrated to the
Red Sea and Sinai areas. Waves of forced internal migration also resulted from the 1967 Arab-
Israeli War and the floods caused by the completion of the Aswan High Dam in 1970. Limited
numbers of students and professionals emigrated temporarily prior to the early 1970s, when
economic problems and high unemployment pushed the Egyptian Government to lift restrictions
on labor migration. At the same time, high oil revenues enabled Saudi Arabia, Iraq, and other
Gulf states, as well as Libya and Jordan, to fund development projects, creating a demand for
unskilled labor (mainly in construction), which attracted tens of thousands of young Egyptian
men.
Between 1970 and 1974 alone, Egyptian migrants in the Gulf countries increased from
approximately 70,000 to 370,000. Egyptian officials encouraged legal labor migration both to
alleviate unemployment and to generate remittance income (remittances continue to be one of
Egypt’s largest sources of foreign currency and GDP). During the mid-1980s, however, depressed
oil prices resulting from the Iran-Iraq War, decreased demand for low-skilled labor, competition
from less costly South Asian workers, and efforts to replace foreign workers with locals
significantly reduced Egyptian migration to the Gulf States. The number of Egyptian migrants
dropped from a peak of almost 3.3 million in 1983 to about 2.2 million at the start of the 1990s,
but numbers gradually recovered.
In the 2000s, Egypt began facilitating more labor migration through bilateral agreements, notably
with Arab countries and Italy, but illegal migration to Europe through overstayed visas or
maritime human smuggling via Libya also rose. The Egyptian Government estimated there were
6.5 million Egyptian migrants in 2009, with roughly 75% being temporary migrants in other Arab
countries (Libya, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Kuwait, and the United Arab Emirates) and 25% being
predominantly permanent migrants in the West (US, UK, Italy, France, and Canada).
During the 2000s, Egypt became an increasingly important transit and destination country for
economic migrants and asylum seekers, including Palestinians, East Africans, and South Asians
and, more recently, Iraqis and Syrians. Egypt draws many refugees because of its resettlement
programs with the West; Cairo has one of the largest urban refugee populations in the world.
13
Distribution channels
Population
Ethnic groups
Languages
Arabic (official), Arabic, English, and French widely understood by educated classes
Religions
Muslim (predominantly Sunni) 90%, Christian (majority Coptic Orthodox, other Christians include
Armenian Apostolic, Catholic, Maronite, Orthodox, and Anglican) 10% (2015 est.)
Age structure
The age structure of a population affects a nation's key socioeconomic issues. Countries with
young populations (high percentage under age 15) need to invest more in schools, while
countries with older population . . . more Age structure field listing
65 years and over: 4.28% (male 2,058,217 /female 2,192,791) (2018 EST.)
14
Distribution channels
Median age
This entry is the age that divides a population into two numerically equal groups; that is, half the
people are younger than this age and half are older. It is a single index that summarizes the age
distribution of a population. Currently, the median age ranges from a low of about 15 in Niger
and Uganda to 40 or more in several European countries and Japan. Total: 23.9 years
Birth rate
15
Distribution channels
Death rate
Population distribution
Approximately 95% of the population lives within 20 km of the Nile River and its delta; vast areas
of the country remain sparsely populated or uninhabited
Urbanization
This entry gives the percent of the total labor force ages 15-24 unemployed during a specified
year. Unemployment, youth ages 15-24 field listing
16
Distribution channels
Technological
The Minister of Communications and Information Technology, who is nominated by the Prime
Minister and is a member of the cabinet, leads MCIT. The current ICT Minister is Amr Talaat
who assumed the position on 14 June 2018.
MCIT is headquartered in Smart Village Egypt, in 6th of October, Giza Governorate, in the
Cairo metropolitan area.
Mobile subscribers
Mobile penetration
ADSL subscribers
1) The percentage of government sector enterprises using internet reached 95.3% while
the percentage of government sector enterprises accessing the internet using wireless
broadband reached 16.5%.
2) The percentage of government sector enterprises Providing information about
electronic governmental services reached 25.7%, while the percentage of government
sector enterprises availing for users download government forms/applications online)
19%.
3) The percentage of government sector enterprises having website and use it for media
publishing reached 76.9% while in (information about provided services) 73.6%
17
Distribution channels
4) The number of ITI graduates to receive software training till July - September 2018
reached 12.18 Thousand trainees.
5) The number of graduates to receive software training till July - September 2018: 22.73
Thousands graduates.
Scientific Research and Invention Patents
Egyptian Patents which inverted to The Innovation Development Agency and What Market
of it
18
Distribution channels
19
Distribution channels
20
Distribution channels
Environment
In June 1997, the responsibility of Egypt's first full time Minister for Environmental Affairs was
assigned as stated in the Presidential Decree no.275/1997. From thereon, the new ministry has
focused, in close collaboration with the national and international development partners, on
defining environmental policies, setting priorities and implementing initiatives within a context
of sustainable development.
According to the Law 4/1994 for the Protection of the Environment, the Egyptian Environmental
Affairs Agency (EEAA) was restructured with the new mandate to substitute the institution
initially established in 1982. At the central level, EEAA represents the executive arm of the
Ministry.
An Environmental Protection Fund (EPF) will in accordance with the Environment Act of 1994
(amended by Law 9/2009) be set up. The Fund will receive the amount specifically allocated to it
in the General State Budget by way of support, donations and grants presented by national and
foreign organizations concerned with environmental protection, fines and compensation
awarded by courts of law or via out-of-court settlements for damage caused to the environment,
as well as revenues from the protectorates fund.
The EPF shall have a legal personality and shall be affiliated to the competent Minister for
Environmental Affairs. The financial resources of the Fund shall be exclusively used for realizing
its objectives.
The Agency will offer incentives to institutions and individuals engaged in activities and projects
directed to environmental protection purposes.
21
Distribution channels
Water
22
Distribution channels
Sectorial Consumption of Natural Gas and Petroleum Products and CO2 Emissions 2015/2016
23
Distribution channels
Air
Annual Average Concentration of Sulfur Dioxide, Nitrogen Dioxide and Thoracic Particles
Legal
Country name
Government type
Presidential republic
Capital
Name: Cairo
Geographic coordinates: 30 03 N, 31 15 E
Time difference: UTC+2 (7 hours ahead of Washington, DC, during Standard Time)
Administrative divisions
27 governorates.
Independence
28 February 1922 (from UK protectorate status; the revolution that began on 23 July 1952 led to
a republic being declared on 18 June 1953 and all British troops withdrawn on 18 June 1956);
note - it was ca. 3200 B.C. that the Two Lands of Upper (southern) and Lower (northern) Egypt
were first united politically
24
Distribution channels
Constitution
Legal system
Mixed legal system based on Napoleonic civil and penal law, Islamic religious law, and vestiges of
colonial-era laws; judicial review of the constitutionality of laws by the Supreme Constitutional
Court
Accepts compulsory ICJ jurisdiction with reservations; non-party state to the ICCt
Citizenship
Citizenship by birth: no
Dual citizenship recognized only with prior permission from the government
Suffrage
Executive branch
Head of government: Prime Minister Mostafa MADBOULY (since 7 June 2018); note - Prime
Minister Sherif ISMAIL (since 12 September 2015) resigned 6 June 2018
Cabinet: Cabinet ministers nominated by the executive authorities and approved by the House
of Representatives
25
Distribution channels
election results: Abdelfattah ELSISI relected president in first round; percent of valid votes case -
Abdelfattah ELSISI (independent) 97.1%, Moussa Mostafa MOUSSA (El Ghad Party) 2.9%; note -
more than 7% of ballots cast were deemed invalid
Legislative branch
description: unicameral House of Representatives (Majlis Al-Nowaab); 596 seats; 448 members
directly elected by individual candidacy system, 120 members - with quotas for women, youth,
Christians and workers - elected in party-list constituencies by simple majority popular vote, and
28 members appointed by the president; member term 5 years; note - inaugural session held on
10 January 2016
election results: percent of vote by party - NA; seats by party -- Free Egyptians Party 65, Future
of the Nation 53, New Wafd Party 36, Homeland's Protector Party 18, Republican People's Party
13, Congress Party 12, Al-Nour Party 11, Conservative Party 6, Democratic Peace Party 5, Egyptian
National Movement 4, Egyptian Social Democratic Party 4, Modern Egypt Party 4, Freedom Party
3, My Homeland Egypt Party 3, Reform and Development Party 3, National Progressive Unionist
Party 2, Arab Democratic Nasserist Party 1, El Serh El Masry el Hor 1, Revolutionary Guards Party
1, independent 351; composition - men 507, women 89, percent of women 14.9%
Judicial branch
highest courts: Supreme Constitutional Court or SCC (consists of the court president and 10
justices); the SCC serves as the final court of arbitration on the constitutionality of laws and
conflicts between lower courts regarding jurisdiction and rulings; Court of Cassation (CC)
(consists of the court president and 550 judges organized in circuits with cases heard by panels
of 5 judges); the CC is the highest appeals body for civil and criminal cases, also known as
"ordinary justices"; Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) - consists of the court president and
organized in circuits with cases heard by panels of 5 judges); the SAC is the highest court of the
State Council
judge selection and term of office: under the 2014 constitution, all judges and justices selected
by the Supreme Judiciary Council and appointed by the president of the Republic; judges
appointed for life
26
Distribution channels
subordinate courts: Courts of Appeal; Courts of First Instance; courts of limited jurisdiction;
Family Court (established in 2004)
27
Distribution channels
1) Approximately 150% Increase in Annual Costs Since 2014 due to Government Series of
Significant Cost Increases on Energy.
Natural Gas 517% from an average of EGP 17.4/mbtu to EGP 107.4/mbtu (Approximately
15% of costs).
Electricity 229% from EGP/KwH of 0.25 to 1.15 (Approximately 6% of costs).
Diesel Fuel 400% from EGP/liter 1.10 to 5.50 (All goods, material and personnel transport
affected).
1) Local Competition is Fierce as Egyptian market facing surplus capacity of around 30% in
tiles.
Threat of Substitutes (medium)
1) High Cost of Ceramic Tiles Family Substitutes (Marbles, Granite and Porcelain)
2) High Cost of Ceramic Tiles Substitutes (Wood, MDF and HDF).
3) Low cost of ceramic tiles family substitutes “cement tiles”
28
Distribution channels
3. SWOT Analysis
- Strengths
1) Brand Awareness.
Theme 2 in Thematic Analysis.
2) Product Availability.
Theme 7 in Thematic Analysis.
3) Information Sharing.
Theme 16 in Thematic Analysis
- Weakness
- Opportunities
1) Increased Inflation Rate and Low Threat of Substitutes May Increase Demand
Economic Factors in PESTEL and Threat of Substitutes in Porter’s Five Forces
2) One Week Waiting Time is an Advantage for Transportation Organizing or Sharing with Cross
Merchandize Products to Decrease Transportation Costs.
Theme 9 in Thematic Analysis.
3) The Improvement in ICT Infrastructure and Increase of Internet Subscribers will be useful in
Effective and Efficient Information Sharing.
Technologic Factors in PESTEL.
- Threats
29
Distribution channels
LECICO Strategy
LECICO strategy is to provide affordable, high quality products to the low- to mid-price market
segments in Europe and the Middle East.
A direct channel of distribution describes a situation in which LECICO sells products directly to a
consumer without the help of intermediaries.A direct chain of distribution may involve face-to-face
sales, computer sales or mail order but does not involve any form of distributor other than the
original producer.
LECICO target the Large Customers with bulk orders as containers as an example New Capital,
Bashayer El Khair …etc.
30
Distribution channels
LECICO had its own outlet in most of Egypt cities, as an example LECICO Trading in Alexandria, cover
five districts:
1) Abo Yousef
2) Loran
3) El-Asafrah
4) El-Dawly 45
5) Khorshid
Indirect Distribution Channel
In indirect channels of distribution, there are one or more intermediaries between the manufacturer
and consumers. There is no direct contact between the producers and the customers.
LECICO had one Intermediary of Indirect Distribution Channel as it had retailers only.
LECICO had retailers in most of Egypt cities, as an example LECICO Retailers in Alexandria:
1) Batiaa
Location: Km 19.5 Cairo Alexandria Agricultural Road
Location: Korshid
6) Kiro Home
Location: Wingate
Location: Khorshid
In Dual Distribution Channel, Manufacture uses more than one marketing channel simultaneously to
reach the end user.
LECICO apply dual distribution channel as it open their own showrooms to sell the product directly
while at the same time use other retailers to attract more customers.
Ceramic tiles compete with conventional flooring materials such gray cement tiles, cement mosaic,
marble and granite.
Service Output Demand for Each Segment mentioned in the Table below
32
Distribution channels
LECICO generally targeting Cost Sensitive and Reasonable Sensitive Segments, LECICO had an
opportunity to target Service Sensitive Segment as due to Economic Climate now in Egypt; Ceramic
Tiles Price Booming; many customers will change their preferences among the available ceramic tiles
and According to Theme analysis LECICO had a Weakness in both Product Variety and Customer
Service.
LECICO Tiles Sale Volume in 2018 was approximately 40 million square meter and Informal Market
Data Suggests that actual local production is around 340 square meters; LECICO Local Market Share
is around 12%. LECICO had the opportunity to Increase its market share by target new segments.
NOTE:
Informal market data suggests that installed tile capacity in Egypt reached 490 million square meters
per day while actual production is around 340 million square meters
1- The types and the amount of work done by each member to perform the marketing
functions.
2- The importance of each channel function to the provision of end-user service output.
3- The share of total channel profits that each member should reap.
33
Distribution channels
Retailer
Benefit Lecico
Potential Final Manufacturer Rep / or End-
Cost (H,M,L) weight Lecico Bateaa User Total
Physical 28 H 31 35 40 25 100
possession
Ownership 15 M 17 30 40 30 100
Promotion 10 M 12 60 40 0 100
Negotiation 5 L 2 20 60 20 100
Financing 18 M 21 25 40 35 100
Risk 10 M 12 40 40 20 100
Ordering 6 L 2 20 60 20 100
Payment 5 L 1 20 40 40 100
Distributor “Lecico
Lecico End-User
Rep./Bateaa”
34
Distribution channels
35
Distribution channels
From the previous analysis of the approximated template, it can be found that:
These values must be compared with the actual data obtained from full activity costing analysis of
the performance of channel functions if possible, this may provide reasonable estimates instead.
36
Distribution channels
The SCM literature views vertical integration as one extreme of vertical coordination of supply chains.
Strategic concentration in supply chains marks a key issue for manufacturing firms. Vertical
integration means some companies, such as for example the Spanish clothier “Zara”, owning nearly
the entire supply chain, from design and production, to distribution and logistics, to stores
worldwide. Zara's retail clothing peers, such as Benetton, The Gap, and Hennes & Mauritz, continue
to rely on outside production partners through complete or strong outsourcing (Ferdows et al., 2004).
Many researchers herald the role of integration as the most important aspect of well‐functioning
supply chains (e.g. Richey et al., 2009). Simultaneously, the current prevalence of outsourcing has
forced many supply chains to become more specialised, making integration across company
boundaries even more important. Some theorists even believe outsourcing per se can increase the
efficiency of supply chains (Kroes and Ghosh, 2010). Although outsourcing is prevalent in certain
industries and segments, it has been argued that different economic and technological circumstances
require distinct supply chain governance strategies (Grossman and Helpman, 2002; Rothaermel et
al., 2006). In fact, the outsourcing of the buying firm can be seen as the downstream vertical
integration of the supplying firm, in which the vertical integration results from the customer's
outsourcing strategy. However, this paper focuses of a manufacturer's deliberate strategy to
integrate vertically downstream
37
Distribution channels
Relational governance
or “quasi-vertical”
Vertical integration is when one organization does all the work (such as: production, sales,
inventory)
Forward – a manufacturer integrates the distribution function
Backward – a distributor or retailer produces its own branded source of product
Outsourcing is when an organization decides to buy the services from a third party
Lecico
Functions
Make or buy decision
This function begins with the movement of the physical product from the manufacturer
through all the parties who take physical possession of the product until it reaches the
ultimate consumer.
Physical
Lecico need to store large volume of inventory which require a
possession big space area of inventory places.
Lecico is following the outsourcing strategy in the physical possession function.
products are stored and transported through distributors channel “ ex: bateaa co.”
38
Distribution channels
any type of marketing communication used to inform or persuade target audiences of the
relative merits of a product, service, brand or issue. The aim of promotion is to increase
awareness, create interest, generate sales or create brand loyalty. It is one of the basic
elements of the market mix, which includes the four P's ,i.e., Product, Price, Place,
Promotion
Promotion
Lecico is following the Relational governance integration strategy in promotion function as
following.
- Promote to retailers "Bateaa".
- Advertising.
- Sales persons.
Manufacturers and distributors in marketing channels commonly establish prices, margins,
and other trade terms through negotiations. These negotiations have significant impact on
channel members' profit streams over the duration of the business relationship
Lecico is making negotiation with retailers " ex: Bateaa" as the follows:
Negotiation
1- Legalities.
2- Terms and conditions of the agreements
Lecico is following the relational governance integration in the negotiation function.
Most companies deal in advance payments or a credit limit. However, it is not necessary
that the channel member is getting the payments from customers within that period of
time. A company might take advance payment for product X but maybe that product sold
after 40 days. So till 40 days, the financial burden of that product was on the channel
member. Channel member should be ready for such financing.
Financing
Lecico is following relational governance strategy in terms of the following
1- trading terms
2- Warranty.
3- Cancellations
4- Refunds
6- Goods in storage.
Assuming the risk connected with carrying out channel work or being a part of a channel. If
the distributor or channel member is buying a product, it does not sell, or the distributor
suffers bad debts or any untoward thing happens, then these are risks which the channel
member has to take and it is the function of channel member
Risks are as follows but not limited to:
Risk - Insurance
- Loss of production.
- Incompatible quality.
- Guarantee.
- Damage
Lecico is following Relational governance strategy in the risk related functions
Order processing such as IT department
Lecico is following relational governance strategy in the ordering function and all related
Ordering activities
39
Distribution channels
During this analysis, each channel member must respect that the functions per- formed by every
other channel member require certain competences. No party should merely assume that it can take
over another party's functions and perform them better and/or more cheaply. Arrogance has no
place in a vertical integration decision, which must be undertaken with respect for the competence
of other types of organization.
Unfortunately, the decision also must consider opportunism. Such self-interest
seeking often prompts negative responses (e.g., "it represents the worst of human nature").
As we can see, the more specialized a channel member is, the better he will perform in any of
the above given functions. In the end of this case study we will provide some recommendations
from our point of view and based on the output data from the study.
40
Distribution channels
So;
ROI = 1.91
______________________________________________________________
41
Distribution channels
ROI = 2.1
42
LEVEL OF INTENSITY
Refrences:
7) LECICO Locations
http://www.lecicoegypt.com/support/where-to-buy/
Appendix
S Question
16 Did you find Lecico staff have information about the product?
1
Distribution channels
Results
S Interview
7 N/A N/A No
Limited retailers.
8 N/A N/A 1- Large for receiption.
2- Small for kitchen and
bathroom.
9 N/A N/A One week
12 N/A N/A No
need to see it live.
13 N/A N/A In cash
14 N/A N/A No
15 N/A N/A No
2
Distribution channels
S Interview
3 Tiles Tiles WC
WC WC WB
WB WB (I don't know that Lecico
Mixers mixers produces tiles)
4 Yes No No
1- Limited variety
2- Old designs
3- Bad surface finishing
5 Good No N/A
1- Adv. Low price
2- Disadv. Low variety.
Old designs.
6 Good (Medium) N/A N/A
7 Yes N/A No
11 No N/A N/A
Limited
12 No N/A N/A
Visit the retailer is
better
13 In cash N/A N/A
14 No N/A N/A
3
Distribution channels
16 No N/A N/A
Limited experience.
17 1- Increase sales staff 1- New designs 1- Marketing compaign
experience. 2- Increase variety. 2- Increase number of retailers
2- New designs 3- Enhance the product
3- Increase variety finishing quality.
4- Marketing compaign
S Interview
3 WC Tiles Tiles
WB WC WC
Mixers WB WB
Tiles Mixers
4 No Yes Yes
Sanitary and WB
5 N/A 1- V. Good material 1- Good
2- Fair designs 2- Adv. Low price
3- Adv. Durable and low cost. 3- Dis, Adv. Poor designs
4- Disadv. Old designs.
6 N/A Good N/A
12 N/A No No
See it is better
13 N/A Both are ok Credit
4
Distribution channels
14 N/A Yes No
I willpay if needed.
REASON, they will take the risk
of damage and bad assembly.
15 N/A Great No
S Interview
3 Tiles WC WC
4 No No No
Not found Bad decoration UnKnown products
7 No No No
10 Planning
11 N/A No N/A
12 No Yes No
5
Distribution channels
14 No Yes Yes
If there is a guarantee If there are a guarantee
15 No Yes No
S Interview
6
Distribution channels
12 No No No
14 No Yes Yes
15 Yes Yes No
S Interview
7
Distribution channels
11 Yes No No Yes
12 No No No Yes