Professional Documents
Culture Documents
w
XUAN Aiguo( % f !Sl)ab***, WU Yuanxin( Z %)', PENG Changjun( @ )", MA Pei-
WANG Cunwen(Z..kft)b and ZHANG Liangjun( $#hh$)d
sheng(4 8jk)",
a School of Chemical Engineering and Technology ,Tianjin University ,Tianjin300072,China
Department of Chemical Engineering, Wuhan Institute of Chemical and Technology, Wuhan 430073,China
Department of Chemistry, East China University of Science and Technology, Shanghai 200237, China
Hubei Key Laboratory of Novel Chemical Reactor and Green Chemical Technology, Wuhan 430073,China
Abstract A new model was proposed to calculate the viscosity of fluids under the pressure ranging from 0.1 to
llOMPa by improving the Tait equation, in which the viscosity p of liquids was linked with activation volume P.
The model with two adjustable parameters a and B was applied in calculating viscosities for alkane, aromatic and
alcohol family at high pressure. Results show that calculated values of viscosity are in good agreement with the ex-
perimental ones, and the average relative deviations for alkanes, aromatics and alcohols are 0.56%. 0.31% and
0.66%, respectively. Besides, the errors correlated by the model proposed in this paper were equivalent to the ones
from the pure empirical Tait equation, and obviously superior to those from Eyring equation.
Keywords viscosity, model, high pressure, Tait equation, activation volume
p = Aexp( g) (7)
where p, A, f ,R, T and P are the dynamic viscosity Equation (7) can be used to calculate the viscos-
of Newtonian liquids, a pre-factor, the volume of ac- ity of fluid at high pressure, in which the reference
tivation, the gas constant, temperature and pressure, state is the atmospheric pressure, because the viscosity
respectively. If it is supposed that the pre-factor A is at O.1MPa is usually known. Three parameters must
dependent on temperature only, the viscosity of the be regressed. However, it is discovered from experi-
reference pressure at the same temperature can be then ments that K is about 0.5 at different temperatures.
calculated: Thus, for simplicity, K is regarded as a constant. The
: : pL I
final expression of the model is
pEf= Aexp -
June, 2006
Correlation of Viscosities for Alkane, Aromatic and Alcohol Family at High Pressure by ModiFied W t Equation 367
Tgble 1 (continued)
Dev', %
Substance T, K P,Wa a~104 B,Wa References
Fq(8) Tait equation Eyring equation
298.15 0.1-110 10.377 139.925 0.13 0.2@ 1.64
303.15 0.1-110 10.339 138.675 0.14 0.2@ 1.63
n-hexane
323.15 0.1-110 11.350 117.017 0.20 0.4@ 1.97
333.15 0.1-110 12.174 100.133 0.29 0.4@ 2.25
298.15 0.1-110 13.059 377.844 0.03 0.2@ 1.06
303.15 0.1-110 13.105 266.349 0.05 0.2Q 1.38
cyclohexane 323.15 0.1-1 10 12.602 252.442 0.05 0.3@ 1.38 [3,9,221
348.15 0.1-110 12.822 203.638 0.08 0.5@ 1.62
373.15 0.1-200 13.253 173.361 0.08 0.08 O.%
298.15 0.1-110 10.149 172.392 0.09 0.3' 1.42
303.15 0.1-110 10.459 155.459 0.11 0.3Q 1.56
n-heptane
323.15 0.1-110 11.037 131.435 0.16 0.3@ 1.79
348.15 0.1-110 12.194 107.717 0.26 0.4@ 2.18
297.95 0.1-25 13.571 133.5543 0.82 0.83 1.32
313.05 0.1-25 14.442 40.1793 0.32 0.52 1.09
328.05 0.1-25 12.112 14972.443 1.61 5.22 2.87
n-octane [241
343.15 0.1-25 12.301 297.445 1.53 4.59 4.99
358.25 0.1-25 18.453 21.929 1.75 1.72 1.98
373.35 0.1-25 15.882 35.559 0.88 0.89 1.03
303.15 0.1-65 10.536 268.431 0.10 0.10 1.32
n-nonane
323.15 0.1-69 10.892 172.147 0.08 0.09 1.42
297.95 0.1-25 12.062 63.747 0.80 0.81 1.66
313.05 0.1-25 16.011 23.981 0.51 0.59 1.55
328.05 0.1-25 16.014 26.556 0.37 0.42 1.34
n-decane
343.15 0.1-25 16.465 25.723 0.78 0.77 1.65
358.25 0.1-25 17.123 29.2965 0.36 0.39 1.32
373.35 0.1-25 79.860 84776.407 1.19 1.19 2.54
298.15 0.1-30 13.254 305.131 0.25 0.25 1.87
n-hexadecane 323.15 0.1-148 12.543 280.052 0.48 0.38 1.46 ~ 7 1
348.15 0.1-150 12.093 247.615 0.79 0.65 1.65
298.15 0.1-92 12.614 235.837 0.10 0.3 1.47
323.15 0.1-150 11.651 251.732 0.32 0.35 1.69
348.1 0.1-422 9.998 407.379 2.01 2.21 1.35
n-dodecane 298.27 0.1-1 19 12.094 283.492 0.1 1 0.08 1.46 [7,15,271
323.35 0.1-261 10.891 354.752 1.01 1.01 1.98
373.21 0.1-501 9.492 422.211 2.77 2.78 1.57
348.15 0.1-150 11.380 225.492 0.39 0.37 1.55
total average 0.72 0.87 1.46
error 0.43@ 0.68@ 1.36@
@ Given by Ref.[7].
@ Error values were calculated by all the data from related references, including the error from Kashiwagi's model.
5.00 I
1.2 -
1.0 -
3.01 v1
b
E
i2.01 0.6
0.4 -
1.oo
I I I I I I I
0.2 1
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 0 30 60 90 120
P , MPa P, MPa
Figure 1 Pressure dependence of viscosity of alkanes at
Figure 3 Pressure dependence of viscosity of m-xylene at
298.15K
Merent temperature
,and the
(Symbols mean the literature datat3.7.Q~15.'e.23~2426.271 (Symbols are the literature dadQ1and the lines are the correla-
lines are the correlation results with present mode)
tion results with preasent mode)
0 n-hexane; A n-heptane; 0 n-octane(297.95K);
+298.15K; 0 303.153, A 323.153, 0 348.15K
+
A n-decane(297.95K); n-dodecane; W n-hexdecane
1.20 I I
1.oo
v1 0.80
o.20 t 298.15K
(Symbols mean the literature data[3'8*'0"7"81
, and the lines are
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 the correlation results with present model)
P, MPa 0 methanol; A ethanol; 0 I-propanol; A 2-propanol
Figure 2 Pressure dependence of viscosity of n-decane at
different temperature
rectly reported in their paper. The error from our
(Symbols are the literature dadz6]and the lines are the correla-
tion results with present model) model was about 0.72% if the error from Kashiwagi's
0 297.95K; A 313.053, +
328.05K; model was subtracted, while the error from Tait equa-
0 343.15K3: A 358.25K tion and Eyring equation were 0.87% and 1.46%, re-
spectively. If all the data were taken into consideration,
As illustrated in Fig.4, the experimental and cal- the total mean error correlated from our model was
culated values of the viscosities for n-alcohols at 0.43%, yet those from Tait equation and Eyring equa-
298.15K are presented. Pressures are in the range from tion were 0.68% and l .36%, respectively. On the other
O.1MPa to 120MPa for 1-propanol and 2-propanol, to hand, Kashiwagi and Makita have found that the de-
80MPa for methanol, and to 60MPa for ethanol. It is rivative of Tait equation with respect to pressure is
found that our model can reproduce commendably always negative"], which means that the Tait equation
P-p-T relations of alcohol family. is inapplicable to liquids whose viscosity increases
The results correlated using our model for other rapidly with pressure. Our model is better than Tait
liquids are also listed in Table1. A portion of data were equation, and is obviously superior to Eyring equation.
calculated from the model suggested by Kashiwagi This is because the activation volume in Eyring equa-
and Makita"] because the experimental data were di- tion is regarded as a parameter independence of the
June, 2006
Correlation of Viscosities for Alkane, Aromatic and Alcohol F d y at High Pressure by Modified ‘hit Equation 369
Boned, C., “Viscosity and density measurements of binary 24 Banufef M.A., Hall, K.R., Estrada-Baltazar, A., Igle-
mixtures composed of methylcyclohexane i-cis-decalin sias-Silva, GA., “Liquid viscosity of octane and pentane
versus temperature and pressure”, Int. J. Thermophys., + octane mixtures from 298.15K to 373.153 up to
24(2), 361-374(2003). 25MPa”, J. Chem. Eng. Data, 44,1310-1314(1999).
21 Estrada-Baltazar, A., Iglesias-Silva, GA., “Liquid vis- 25 Assael, M.J., Papadaki, M., “Measurements of the vis-
cosities of pentane and pentane+decane from 298.153 to cosity of n-heptane, n-nonane, and undecane at pressures
373.15K and up to 25MPa”, J. Chem. Eng. Data, 43, up to 70MPa”, Int. J. Thermophys., 12(5), 801 -
601-604(1998). 810(1991).
22 Isdale, J.D., Dymond, J.H., Brawn, T.A., “Viscosity and 26 Estrada-Baltazar,A., Alvarado, J.F.J., Iglesias-Silva, GA.,
density of n-hexane-cyclohexane mixtures between 25 “Experimental liquid viscosities of decane and octane +
and 100 up to SOOMPa”, High Temperature High Pres- decane from 298.15K to 373.15K and up to 25MPa”. J .
sures, 11,571-580( 1979). Chem. Eng. Data, 43,441-446(1998).
23 Assael, M.J., Charitidou, E., Dymond, J.H., Papadaki, M., 27 Tananka, Y.,H o s o ~ ~ wH..~Kubota,
, H., Makita, T., “Vis-
“Viscosity and thermal conductivity of binary n-heptane cosity and density of binary mixtures of cyclohexane
+n-alkane mixtures”, Int. J. Themphys., 13(2), 237- with n-octane, n-dodecane, and n-hexadecane under high
249( 1992). pressures”, Int. J. Themphys., 12(5), 245-264( 1991).
June, 2006