Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Composites: Part B
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/compositesb
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The present paper describes concepts and a preliminary project of a helicopter device, to investigate the
Received 20 March 2014 use of natural fiber composites for semi-structural applications, such as electronic racks. The aim of the
Received in revised form 13 September 2014 study consists on the evaluation of the substitution of the steel electronic rack, mounted on the helicopter
Accepted 16 September 2014
Eurocopter AS 350 Écureuil, with a new version, utilizing hemp fabric/epoxy composite material. This
Available online 6 October 2014
replacement will permit to have an environmental friendly product and lower disposal costs and weight.
Lower weight for helicopters and more in general for aircraft means lower fuel consumption, lower
Keywords:
pollution and costs. The new rack has been designed using structural static and dynamic analysis through
A. Glass fibers
A. Polymer–matrix composites (PMCs)
Finite Element Method (FEM). Results are promising from the structural point of view. In fact, a weight
C. Computational modeling reduction of 8.01 kg (55.6%) with respect to steel has been obtained without significantly increasing the
C. Finite element analysis (FEA) production cost. A comparison with glass fabric/epoxy composites is also provided. The results for both
Natural Fibers Composite Materials (NFCs) the composite materials are very similar, but the advantages for the environment demonstrate that is
worthy choosing natural fiber composites configuration.
Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2014.09.010
1359-8368/Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
C. Scarponi, M. Messano / Composites: Part B 69 (2015) 542–549 543
applicable to the rotorcrafts Eurocopter AS 350 Écureuil and AS 355 The fiberglass material selected to be considered for the design
Écureuil II (Fig. 1). is an E-Glass balanced woven roving, embedded with the epoxy
The old rack was manufactured using extruded steel bars with resin SP System Ampreg 26, described in Table A3 in Appendix A.
‘‘L’’ section (30 mm 30 mm 3 mm thickness). Each bar was The experimental data and the parameters to be used in the code
welded to obtain parallelepiped edges. The geometrical sizes are: are reported in Ref. [6].
With the exception of the triangular elements, the rack is Two lateral parts.
entirely conceived to be realized using composite materials, more One base (at the bottom).
in particular NFCs and glass fiber composites, as a matter of com- One cover (on the top).
parison. In Fig. 4 is represented the hemp plain weave fabric man-
ufactured in Italy (Linificio – Canapificio Nazionale S.p.a.); the cost Each segment is built as a plate having all outer edges 90°, bent
is only 8 €/m2 [12] for a small quantity (10 kg). Some physical and for 20 mm; such a solution allows easing the final assembly of the
mechanical properties are described in Table A2, Appendix A. structure. The complete description of the fabrication process is
The matrix is the bi-component epoxy resin Hexion L-285 out of the limit of the present paper, so only the fabrication con-
(hardener H-285), widely used in aeronautics, such as gliders and cept can be considered here. For instance, any single part can be
small airplanes [13]. It shows very good features as mechanical fabricated in an easy way, such as vacuum bag technique and cur-
and thermal properties and a wide operating temperature range ing process in furnace. In case of this choice, the sequence could be
(Table A2). shortly described by the following steps:
4. FEM model
Fig. 3. Rack 3D FEM model, PATRAN (MSC Software).
PATRAN and NASTRAN (MSC Software) have been utilized (Sol
Plies cutting 101 linear static and Sol 103 for normal modes) [15]. All the details
Matrix preparation: the resin Hexion L-285 must be mixed are reported in Appendix B.
with the hardener H-285 with 100:40 parts by weight The FAR 27 standards [16] establish that each element in cabin
mix ratio. must resist to specific inertial load, listed in Table 1.
Hand lay-up process and vacuum bag: classical procedure in A safety factor k = 1.5 must be applied to all structure [17] and a
clean room over a female mold made in epoxy resin. fitting factor kf = 1.15 must be applied only to shear forces having
Curing: in furnace (see materials data sheet described in effect on screws strength [18].
Table A4, Appendix A). The used Nastran FEM code requires the choice of an opportune
NDI and rack assembly: visual inspection, ultrasonic control, safety margin. The best solution for isotropic materials is the well
drilling, bonding of parts. known Von Mises failure criterion, while for the composite struc-
tures the Hoffman criterion has been chosen. The criterion takes
The described fabrication technique has been used in the past in account stresses and strengths of all the laminate plies and is
[6] in order to obtain the specimens for the measurement of the described as following:
mechanical parameters used for the present analysis. However,
r21 r22 r1 r2 Xc - Xt Y -Y s2
excellent results were obtained elsewhere using Resin Transfer þ r1 þ c t r2 þ 122 6 1 ð1Þ
Moulding (RTM) [14]. Xc Xt Y cY t XcXt XcXt YcYt S
C. Scarponi, M. Messano / Composites: Part B 69 (2015) 542–549 545
Table 1 Table 3
Static load applied. NASTRAN output for natural fibers composite.
Table 4
NASTRAN output for triangle-shape elements.
Table 5
Alternating forces frequency for AS 350 and AS 355.
Table 7 Table A1
Environmental impact data of racks. List of electronic devices: device n.1 on the bottom of rack, device n.9 on the top.
Value China reed fibers E-Glass fibers Steel Device Screws Weight (kg)
Total weight (kg) 6.40 6.1 14.4 1 (Bottom) 4 9
Composite weight (kg) 6.06 5.76 – 2 4 1
Fibers weight (kg) 3.88 3.71 – 3 4 10.5
Energy use (MJ) 14.12 176.54 442.94 4 4 10.5
CO2 emissions (kg) 2.56 7.48 37.67 5 4 8
CO emissions (g) 1.71 2.95 459.36 6 4 8
SOx emissions (g) 4.77 32.38 46.37 7 4 2
NOx emissions (g) 4.15 11.46 47.66 8 4 1
Particulate matter (g) 931.20 3712.80 – 9 (Top) 4 3
Table A2
Table 8 Hemp woven and Hexion L-285 features.
Materials cost. Feature Quantity Unit
Value Hemp rack E-Glass rack Hemp woven
Woven price (€/m2) 8 6 Areal Weight 244 g/m2
Matrix price (€/kg) 7 7 Young’s Modulus 52 GPa
Total area (m2) 1.6 1.6 Shear Modulus 20 GPa
Woven area (m2) 12.8 6.44 Density 1480 kg/m3
Matrix weight (kg) 2.18 1.92 Range
Woven cost (€) 102.4 48.64
Hexion L-285 Resin
Matrix cost (€) 15.26 13.45
Density 1180–1200 kg/m3
Total cost (€) 117.66 62.09
Young’s Modulus 3.0–3.3 GPa
Tensile Strength 70–80 MPa
Compressive Strength 120–140 MPa
Elongation at Break 5.0–6.5 –
Operational temperature 60 to +50 °C
amount of production, so the cost could be considerably 60 to +80a
reduced in case of higher production level in the near future; a
After heat treatment.
3. the E-glass is very close to the Hoffman limit, so the margin
of safety is negligible.
Table A3
E-Glass woven and SP System Ampreg 26 Resin.
7. Conclusions
Feature Quantity Unit
Table A5
Gel time for Hexion L-285 and Hardeners H-285, H-286, H-287.
Appendix B
Table B1
Al 7075-T6, AISI 304 and Dumpers Features.
References [14] Sèbe G, Cetin NS, Hill CAS. RTM Hemp fibre-reinforced polyester composites.
Appl Compos Mater 2000;7(5–6):341–9.
[15] MSC Nastran 2012: Quick Reference Guide, MSC Software. p. 139–41.
[1] Mougin G, Magnani M, Eikelenberg N. Natural-fibres composites for
[16] FAR 27 (Amdt. 16) Airworthiness Standards: Normal Rotorcraft Category: Sec.
automotive industry. Int. J. Mater. Prod. Technol. 2009;36(1–4).
27.561, FAA Regulation.
[2] http://www.lotuscars.com/gb/engineering/eco-elise; [accessed 16.04.14].
[17] FAR 27 (Amdt. 16) Airworthiness Standards: Normal Rotorcraft Category: Sec.
[3] http://www.mercedesbenz.co.za/content/south_africa/mpc/mpc_south_africa_
27.303, FAA Regulation.
website/en/home_mpc/passengercars/home/passengercars_world/innovation_
[18] FAR 27 (Amdt. 16) Airworthiness Standards: Normal Rotorcraft Category: Sec.
sustainability/sustainability/corporate_responsibility/resources.html; [accessed
27.625, FAA Regulation.
16.04.14].
[19] FAR 27 (Amdt. 16) Airworthiness Standards: Normal Rotorcraft Category: Sec.
[4] http://w3.uniroma1.it/sealab/materiali_fibra.html; [accessed 1.10.13].
27.251, FAA Regulation.
[5] http://canapalifestyle.com/canapa/12-la-canapa-nella-bio-edilizia; [accessed
[20] Scarponi C, Andreotti C. Industrial applications of natural fibres advanced
16.04.14].
composites: environmental effects and comparative Life Cycle Analysis. Int J
[6] Iacobellis S, Scarponi C, Sarasini F, Santulli C. Design of a Naca cowling in
Mater Prod Technol 2009;36(1–4).
woven hemp fabric reinforced epoxy composite. In: Proceedings of 1st
[21] Joshi SV, Drzal LT, Mohanty AK, Arora S. Are natural fiber composites
International conference of Natural Fibers, Guimaraes, 9–11 Giugno 2013.
environmentally superior to glass fiber reinforced composites? Compos Part
[7] Certification of aircraft and related products, parts and appliances, and of
A: Appl Sci Manuf 2004;35(3):371–6.
design and production organizations, Annex to Regulation (EC) No 1702/2003
[22] MSC Nastran 2012: Quick Reference Guide, MSC Software. p. 1497–500.
– (Part 21).
[23] MSC Nastran 2012: Quick Reference Guide, MSC Software. p. 2829–32.
[8] http://www.assocanapa.org/>; [accessed 14.04.14].
[24] MSC Nastran 2012: Quick Reference Guide, MSC Software. p. 2953–57.
[9] http://www.toscanapa.com/; [accessed 14.04.14].
[25] MSC Nastran 2012: Quick Reference Guide, MSC Software. p. 3041–42.
[10] http://www.fidiaglobalservice.com/ita/tessuti_lino_canapa.html; [accessed
[26] http://www.vibrostop.it/products-en/rubber-mounts-en/111-vibrostop-aa-
14.04.14].
en; [accessed 1.10.13].
[11] http://www.canapuglia.it/; [accessed 14.04.14].
[27] MSC Nastran 2012: Quick Reference Guide, MSC Software. p. 1365–68.
[12] http://www.linificio.it/en/; [accessed 1.10.13].
[13] Technical Information: Laminating Resins MGSÒ L 285, Hexion (Specialty Chemi-
cals), <http://www.metyx.com/Uploads/GenelDosya/301201393220901.pdf>.