The King asks Nagasena to explain the distinguishing marks of consideration and wisdom. Nagasena responds by using the analogy of a barley reaper - consideration is like grasping the barley with the left hand, while wisdom is like cutting it off with the sickle in the right hand. An earnest student of yoga takes hold of the mind with consideration and cuts off defilements with wisdom. The King is impressed by Nagasena's dexterous explanation. He then asks Nagasena to clarify which "skilled mental states" he was referring to in a previous statement.
Original Description:
Original Title
Milindas Questions vol.1 (trans. I. B. Horner) (1) 99
The King asks Nagasena to explain the distinguishing marks of consideration and wisdom. Nagasena responds by using the analogy of a barley reaper - consideration is like grasping the barley with the left hand, while wisdom is like cutting it off with the sickle in the right hand. An earnest student of yoga takes hold of the mind with consideration and cuts off defilements with wisdom. The King is impressed by Nagasena's dexterous explanation. He then asks Nagasena to clarify which "skilled mental states" he was referring to in a previous statement.
The King asks Nagasena to explain the distinguishing marks of consideration and wisdom. Nagasena responds by using the analogy of a barley reaper - consideration is like grasping the barley with the left hand, while wisdom is like cutting it off with the sickle in the right hand. An earnest student of yoga takes hold of the mind with consideration and cuts off defilements with wisdom. The King is impressed by Nagasena's dexterous explanation. He then asks Nagasena to clarify which "skilled mental states" he was referring to in a previous statement.
(viii) The King said: " What is the distinguishing
mark of consideration, what the distinguishing mark of wisdom, revered sir ?" " Examination1 is the distinguishing mark of con- sideration, sire, cutting oif is the distinguishing mark of wisdom."2 " How does consideration have the distinguishing mark of examination, how does wisdom have the dis- tinguishing mark of cutting off ? Make a simile." " Do you, sire, know about barley-reapers ?" [33] " Yes, revered sir, I do." " How, sire, do barley-reapers reap the barley ?" " Revered sir, grasping a handful of barley in the left hand and a sickle in the right, they cut it off with the sickle." " As, sire, a barley-reaper grasps a handful of barley in the left hand and a sickle in the right and cuts it oif with the sickle, even so, sire, does the earnest student of yoga,3 taking hold of the mind with consideration, cut oif the defilements with wisdom. It is thus, sire, that examination is the distinguishing mark of consideration, thus that cutting oif is the distinguishing mark of wisdom." " You are dexterous, revered Nagasena."
(ix) The King said: " Revered Nagasena, when you
said: ' And because of other skilled mental states,'4— which are these skilled mental states ?" 1 uhana. At Vism. 142 =Asl. 114 used to explain vitakka, initial or applied thought, or just thinking. Translated at P . Pn., p. 148 as " hitting upon " which might also fit the translation of uhananti at M. i. 243, etc. The BHS. meaning (see BHSD) seems to be removal, getting rid of, destruction, putting away, which would accord with this passage, as does the " prescinding" of Expos, i. 150. Proper mind-work, with its removal of attention, is a necessary preparation for cutting off unskilled states of mind. 2 " The sword of wisdom " at Dhs. 16 is for cutting off the defile- ments; cf. Asl. 148. At Miln. 86 comprehending is given as the, or a, distinguishing mark of wisdom. At M. i. 144 sword is given as a synonym for ariyan wisdom. 3 4 yogdvacara. Above, p. 43.