Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT
SUMMARIES AND MIND MAPS
RELEVANT FOR BATCH JUNE 2023 / DEC 2023
By Muzzammil Munaf
Associate Chartered Accountant
IQ SCHOOL OF FINANCE
CFAP 03 – STRATEGY AND PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT
BY MUZZAMMIL MUNAF | ACA | ADVISOR | TRAINER |
SUMMARIES AND MIND MAPS
FOUNDATION OF STRATEGY
FOUNDATION OF STRATEGY
Strategy is a pattern of activities that seeks to achieve the objectives of the organisation and adapt its scope,
resources and operations to environmental changes in the long term.
- consist of organised activities - purpose is to achieve an objective
- is always for long term - influenced by the environment
- is always flexible and dynamic - brings optimisation all the time
Mission - purpose of Vision - desired Goals and objectives Intended Strategy (planned
an organisation and optimal future state of SMART (Specific, through formal process)
the reason for its what the organisation Measurable, Agreed, Emergent Strategy (emerges
existence wants to achieve Realistic, Time-bound) without formal planning)
Future Basing [used to create a vision for implementing strategy at any level within an organisation]
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS
Strategic Groups
Porter's
PESTEL Analysis Porter's 5 forces and Market Capabilities Value Chain
Diamond
Segmentation
PESTEL ANALYSIS
Ecological/
Technological
Economic Social environmental
[government Legal
Political [interest rates, [population [considers ways
spending on
[consistent inflation, demographics, in which the [taxation,
research, new
policy, business cycles, income organisation employment
discoveries and
government unemployment, distribution, can produce its law, monopoly
development,
stability and disposable lifestyle and goods or legislation and
focus of
foreign trade income and leisure, levels of services with environmental
technological
regulations] energy education and the minimum protection laws]
effort, rates of
availability] consumerism. environmental
obsolescence.
damage]
Threat of
Competitive
Bargaining Power Threat of New Substitutes
Rivalry
of Customers Bargaining Power Entrants If an organisation
of Suppliers High levels of
Powerful buyers New entrants can has a lot of
competition can
can demand Powerful suppliers increase the cost of substitutes it will
lead to price wars
discounted prices can demand higher resources as well have to keep its
and high
and extra services prices for their as increasing the prices low to deter
expenditure on
(which add costs to product(s). power of other customers from
marketing and
the organisation). forces moving to these
innovation.
substitutes.
PORTER's DIAMOND
[Why are firms based in a particular nation able to create and sustain competitive advantage against the world’s
best competitors in a particular field]
Firm strategy,
Factor conditions structure and rivalry
- land, minerals and [organisational goals
weather Demand conditions can be determined by
Related and supported ownership structure.
- capital [strong home market industries
demand for the product Unquoted companies
- skilled and motivated or service] [suppliers and related may have slightly longer
human resources industries] time horizons to operate
- knowledge in because their financial
performance is subject
- infrastructure. to much less scrutiny
than quoted companies]
Strategic Group
[entities that operate in the same industry and that Market segmentation
have similar strategies or that are competing in their A market segment is a section of the total market in
markets in a similar way] which the potential customers have certain unique
and identifiable characteristics and needs.
Strategic Space
Instead of trying to sell to all customers in the entire
When all the companies in an industry are put into market, an entity might develop products or services
strategic groups and are analysed, a strategic space that are designed to appeal to customers in a
might become apparent. specific market segment.
A strategic space is a gap in the market that is not Market segmentation is the process of dividing the
currently filled by any strategic group. market into separate segments, for the purpose of
The existence of strategic space might provide an developing differing products for each segment.
opportunity for a company to make an initiative.
THRESHOLD STRATEGIC
1. these are necessary for any organisation to exist 1. these are particular to an individual business
and compete in an industry 2. they will be hard to copy
2. they are likely to be common to most rivals and 3. they will be valued by the customer (CSF)
easily copied
4. they will lead to competitive advantage.
3. they will not lead to success or competitive
advantage Example: A particular newspaper may be able to
stand out from its rivals if it has an exclusive deal
Example: any daily newspaper has reporters, editors, with the country's top sport star who will write a
printing staff etc. daily column on his/her sport.
Does your organisation also has a unique competence to use this resource? Threshold resource
Yes No
Threshold
Sustainable core competence?
competence
Yes No
Short term
Durable and very difficult to copy by
competitive
other competitors?
advantage
No. Competitors
Yes will copy in long
run.
Sustainable competitive advantages – The capabilities that allow an organisation to beat its competitors.
These capabilities must meet the needs and expectations of its customers. Unique capabilities are not
enough – they must be valued by the customers.
PORTER'S VALUE CHAIN
[identify which activities within the firm are contributing to a competitive advantage and which are not]
SUPPORT OR
SECONDARY
PRIMARY VALUE ACTIVITIES
VALUE
ACTIVITIES
Firm
Service infrastructure
all activities that [structure]
Operations Outbound occur after the
Inbound
transformation logistics point of sale,
logistics Marketing and
of the raw storing, sales such as Technology
[receiving, materials into installation,
distributing and development
storing and finished goods for example, training and
delivering
handling raw and services. sponsorship of repair.
finished goods
material inputs. For example, a sports
to customers. E.g., Marks & Human
For example, a using celebrity could
For example, Spencer’s Resource
just-in-time enhance the
skilled outsourcing friendly Development
stock system image of the
craftsmen could delivering could approach to [people]
could give a product
give a quality give a cost returns gives it
cost advantage]
advantage advantage. a perceived
quality
Procurement
advantage.
[purchasing]
STRATEGIC CHOICE
Cost Ledership
Quality
Design
Differentiation
Image
Competitive Support
Strategies
Cost focus
Focus
STRATEGIC
CHOICE Vertical
Ansoff Growth
Matrix integration
Market
Development
Growth Related
Strategies Diversification Horizontal
integration
Product
(related
Development
products)
Greiner's Growth
Model Unrelated
Diversification (Conglomerate)
Strategy
Evaluation
Benefits high volumes builds brand loyalty and develops brand loyalty
creates a barrier to entry repeat purchases little competition
can operate in higher margins often a first step
unattractive segments reduction in power of towards the other
win price wars customers generic strategies
reduced power of
substitutes
Suitability Large organisations with Innovative companies with Small businesses with
economies of scale large marketing budgets entrepreneurial flair, strong
market knowledge and a
risk taking attitude (often
new starts)
STRATEGIC CLOCK
1 = no frills: Very price-sensitive customers. Simple products and services where innovation is quickly imitated – price
is a key competitive weapon. Costs are kept low because the product/service is very basic.
2 = low price: Aim for a low price without sacrificing perceived quality or benefits. In the long-run, the low price strategy
must be supported by a low cost base.
3 = hybrid strategy: Achieves differentiation, but also keeps prices down. This implies high volumes or some other
way in which costs can be kept low despite the inherent costs of differentiation.
4 = differentiation: Offering better products and services at higher selling prices. Products and services need to be
targeted carefully if customers are going to be willing to pay a premium price.
5 = focused differentiation: Offering high perceived benefits at high prices. Often this approach relies on powerful
branding. New ventures often start with focused strategies, but then become less focused as they grow and need to
address new markets.
6, 7, 8 = failure strategies: Ordinary products and services being sold at high prices. Can only work if there is a
protected monopoly. Some organisations try option 8 by sneakily reducing benefits while maintaining prices.
This typically involves the use of a New products could arise from
new/improved competitive R&D, joint ventures, buying in
strategy. Key risks: other people's products, copying
competitor reaction. innovations of rivals or licensing. It
can lead to stagnation. might also come from product
augmentation (for
example, by upgrading
software capabilities).
Key risks:
market size and demand are
unknown
can lead to cannibalisation of
existing products
This involves finding new markets This involves moving away from
for existing products. These could existing core activities and offer a
be new segments in current new product to a new customer.
markets (e.g., new age groups) or More details are available
overseas markets. Key risks: elsewhere in this chapter. Key risks:
needs a new external analysis combines the risks of product
puts a strain on existing and market development
strategic capabilities need good corporate
parenting skills.
STRATEGY EVALUATION
Strategy Evaluation
whether the options are considers whether the options assesses whether the
adequate responses to the meet and are consistent with organisation has the resources
firm’s assessment of its the firm’s objectives and are it needs to carry out the
strategic position. acceptable to the stakeholders strategy
Greiner's Growth Model is a framework that describes how organizations evolve over time and identifies five stages of
growth that organizations typically go through. The five stages are:
Growth through creativity: In this stage, the organization is typically small, with a flat organizational structure and an
entrepreneurial culture. The focus is on developing new products or services and establishing a market niche.
Growth through direction: As the organization grows, it becomes more complex, with a need for more formalized
processes and structures. The focus is on creating more efficient operations and developing a more hierarchical
organizational structure.
Growth through delegation: In this stage, the organization becomes even more complex, with multiple layers of
management and a greater focus on delegation of authority. The focus is on developing a more decentralized
structure and improving communication within the organization.
Growth through coordination: In this stage, the organization becomes even larger and more complex, with multiple
business units and a need for greater coordination and integration. The focus is on improving coordination and
communication between different parts of the organization.
Growth through collaboration: In the final stage, the organization becomes highly complex, with a global reach and a
focus on collaboration with external partners. The focus is on developing a collaborative culture and a strategic focus
on innovation.
Greiner's model suggests that each stage of growth is marked by a crisis that must be overcome in order to move to
the next stage. By understanding the challenges and opportunities of each stage, organizations can better prepare for
the future and manage growth more effectively.
Organic Growth Mergers & Acquisition Franchising Licensing Business Partnering and Collaboration
Licensing is a limited legal business - can share the set-up and running Alliances can allow participants to
Growth by acquisition or merger is Rapid expansion and increasing
relationship where a specific party costs achieve critical mass, benefit from
much faster than growth through market share with relatively little
is granted rights to use certain other participants’ skills and can
internal development. An equity capital. - can learn from each other
Management can control the rate of registered trademarks of a brand. allow skill transfer between
acquisition can give the buyer The franchisee provides local participants.
growth more easily, and ensure that The business relationship is - can focus on relative strengths
immediate ownership of new knowledge and unit supervision.
the entity has sufficient resources between the licensor and licensee. - may reduce political or cultural The technical difference between a
products, new markets and new The franchiser specialises in
to grow successfully To use the registered trademarks of risks strategic alliance and a joint venture
customers, that would be difficult to providing a central marketing and another brand, the licensee pays is whether or not a new,
obtain through internal control function, limiting the range - it is better than going it alone and
the licensor an agreed-upon royalty independent business entity is
development of management skills needed. then competing
fee. formed.
The biggest disadvantage is The franchiser will seek to maintain In general, licensing agreements are - can often lead to disputes may Less risk – forming the alliance
An acquisition might be expensive. give access to strategic capabilities reduces the risk of the venture.
probably that there is a limit to the some control or influence over most often used by brands that are
The bid price has to be high enough and eventually allow the partner to
rate of growth a business entity can quality and service from the centre highly recognizable and marketable. Co-operative spirit – both
to make the shareholders of the compete in core areas
achieve with its internal resources. but this will be difficult if the For a licensing agreement to be companies must want to do this and
target company willing to sell their
Rival firms might be able to grow franchisee sees opportunities to beneficial to both parties, the - there may be a lack of be willing to co-operate fully.
shares. The return on investment
much more quickly by means of increase profit by deviating from business branding must already be commitment from each party Results, milestones, methods and
for the entity making the acquisition
mergers, acquisitions and joint the standards which the franchiser successful and known by a large - requires strong central support resource commitments must be
might therefore be very low.
ventures has established. portion of buyers. which may not be provided clearly understood.
A star has a high relative market share in a high-growth A cash cow has a high relative market share in a low-
A problem child (sometimes called ‘question mark’) is
market. growth market and should be generating substantial cash A dog product has a low relative market share in a low-
characterised by a low market share in a high-growth
This type of product may be in a later stage of its product inflows. growth market. Such a product tends to have a negative
market.
life cycle. cash flow, that is likely to continue. It is unlikely that a dog
Substantial net cash input is required to maintain or The period of high growth in the market has ended (the can wrest market share from competitors.
A star may be only cash-neutral despite its strong increase market share. product life cycle is in the maturity or decline stage), and
position, as large amounts of cash may need to be spent consequently the market is less attractive to new entrants Competitors, who have the advantage of having larger
The company must decide whether to do nothing – but and existing competitors. market shares, are likely to fiercely resist any attempts to
to defend an organisation’s position against competitors.
cash continues to be absorbed – or market more reduce their share of a low-growth or static market.
Competitors will be attracted to the market by the high intensively, or get out of this market. Cash cow products tend to generate cash in excess of
growth rates. Failure to support a star sufficiently strongly what is needed to sustain their market positions. Profits An organisation with such a product can attempt to
The questions are whether this product can compete support the growth of other company products. The firm’s appeal to a specialised market, delete the product or
may lead to the product losing its leading market share
successfully with adequate support and what that support strategy is oriented towards maintaining the product’s harvest profits by cutting back support services to a
position, slipping to the right in the matrix and becoming
will cost. strong position in the market. minimum.
a problem child.
- Stars tend to move vertically downwards as the market growth rate slows, to become cash cows.
- The cash that they then generate can be used to turn problem children into stars, and eventually cash cows.
E-
procurement
As well as
Intermediary creating larger Advertising
Competitive Bargaining On-going
Providing companies markets for The internet
rivalry with power of Alliances of Set-up costs. operating
Threat of new electronic Their business consumer has also Customer
existing suppliers Bargaining suppliers It can be fairly costs.
entrants auctions is based on goods and created new relationships
competitors Suppliers are power of In some expensive for A website has No in-house
In many These are acting as services, opportunities Promotion The internet Time to
The internet able to use the customers markets, a small to be updated skills
industries, the E-Shopping websites agents for communicatio for advertising Opportunities provides Type of establish the
encourages internet to Customers are businesses company to business frequently, to system A company
barriers to (customers where selling the ns networks and are provided opportunities
greater increase the able to obtain have created establish a keep it might not
entry have buying goods customers can (similar) and computer marketing. by the chance for companies Some It takes time
competition. number of information alliances with website for interesting employee
been lowered. or services by auction goods products or systems have Companies to send to build products and to establish a
Companies clients or about the rival shared selling its (and accurate), individuals
By using the placing an for sale, and services of a created new can advertise promotional customer services are website that
provide a customers for products of websites for products and and it might with the
internet, new order on put in bids for large number opportunities their products messages by relationships, easier to sell customers
large amount their products. many different selling their taking be necessary knowledge or
competitors company's auctioned of different for business- or services on e-mail to for example by on the internet know about
of information As a result, the competitors products to payment by to keep skills to
can enter the website) items. eBay is companies, to-business search engines potential providing than others. and want to
about bargaining by using customers credit card, making special maintain a
market more perhaps the and attracting purchasing by such as customers. support, user visit.
themselves power of search over a wider debit card, offers to website.
quickly and most well- customers to linking up the Google, or on forums and
and their suppliers is engines. geographical Interswitch or encourage
more cheaply. known their website. computer the websites FAQ
products on likely to area. PayPal. customers to
example. (foodpanda, systems of of other
their websites. increase. revisit the site.
sastaticket.pk) companies companies.
with those of
their main
suppliers.
6 I's OF E-MARKETING
Duplicate its existing brand identity online. However, if the quality of the internet site is poor, the brand could be damaged.
E-Branding
Extend the traditional brand by creating a slightly different version of the brand. For example, in the UK the BBC extended its name
image to its online services, giving the new services the slightly different name of BBC Online. This allowed the useful associations of the
BBC brand name to be retained, but also suggested to the customer that the services offered by BBC Online might be different
Create a new brand for the web. The new brand name allows an entity to break free from the perceptions associated with the old brand
name. The old brand might be perceived by customers as too traditional and if there is going to be a successful, dynamic presence on the
web, a new brand is needed without associations of tradition and conservatism.
The purpose of customer relationship management (CRM) is to help companies to understand better the behaviour of their customers, and modify their marketing operations to service customers in the best way possible.
BIG DATA
Big Data is the term used to describe huge volume of both structured and unstructured data that is so large it is difficult to process using traditional database and software techniques.
How Big Data can create value for organisations? Use cases of Big Data
Product adaptation A decision has to be made R&D strategy must allow for
Product renewal Products can be adapted for Developing new technology about how much in total to failures. Research might not
Developing new products Within the overall spending
Changing the design of a a new market segment. For spend on R&D each year. lead to any specific product
From time to time, new programme for R&D,
product can help to renew example, a product that is New products are The need for R&D spending development. Development
technology becomes decisions must be made to
or prolong its life. Many marketed successfully in the continually being invented will vary between different projects might fail.
available that creates allocate the spending
products therefore undergo US might be adapted by its and developed. Companies industries. High spending is Successful development
opportunities for new between research and more
design changes during their manufacturer for sale into test them and some of them needed in industries that projects might happen only
products and also for new specific project
life, in order to maintain or Europe, where customer are successful are at the leading edge of occasionally, and failures
ways of doing things. development.
increase sales. needs might be different scientific or technological might be much more
from those of US customers. developments. common.
[A ‘life cycle’ is the period from birth or creation of
MARKETING MIX
(For offline product or service based businesses. Refer '7Ps of e-marketing mix' for e-businesses)
PRODUCT PLACE
PRICE
[Product strategy is concerned with designing new [Place strategy is PROMOTION
[Customers expect value for money. Pricing is PHYSICAL
products and designing new variations of existing concerned with getting [Promotion is concerned with making the PEOPLE PROCESS
therefore an important element of the marketing ENVIRONMENT
products, to sell to a different market segment, or products to the places customer conscious of a product and wanting to
mix. In most cases, if the price is too high,
to renew customer interest in a product (if where customers want buy it]
customers will not want to buy it]
demand is falling), or to create new demand] to buy them]
Asset turnover = Sales/Capital Gearing ratios (a) If you are given data for more
Employed than one year, you should measure
D/E ratio = Debt/Equity
ROCE = Net margin × asset turnover changes over time.
ROCE = PBIT / Capital Employed × Financial Gearing = Debt / [Debt +
100 Receivable’s days = Receivables Equity] (b) If you are given financial data
Current Ratio = Current Assets / about a competitor, you should try to
balance/Credit sales × 365
Gross margin = Gross profit/Sales × Current Liabilities Investor ratios make a comparative analysis.
100 Payable’s days = Payable balance /
Quick Ratio (acid test) = [Current Dividend Cover = PAT / Total (c) If you are given information about
Credit purchases × 365
Net margin = Net profit/Sales × 100 Assets – inventory] / Current liabilities Dividend historical performance and targets,
Inventory days = Inventory / Cost of you should try to carry out numerical
ROE = PAT / Net equity × 100 Interest Cover = PBIT/Interest
sales × 365 analysis of the extent to which the
EPS = PAT / Number of shares × 100
Revenue per employee = Sales / organisation is on track for meeting
Number of employees PE ratio = Share price / EPS its targets.
efficiency product/service
quality measures in order entry delays
measurements of introduction
sales growth by every unit, evaluate and errors, wrong
resources, planned speed of response to proportion of new flexibility,
product or service, suppliers on the basis days absence, labour blueprints or returns from
against consume, customer needs, products and services product/service mix
measures of of quality, number of turnover, overtime, specifications, long customers, reject
measurements of customer feedback to old one, new flexibility, volume
customer base, customer complaints measures of job set-up times and rates, reworking
resources available and reviews, repeat product or service flexibility, delivery
relative market share received, number of satisfaction large lots, high defect costs, warranty costs
against those used, orders sales levels flexibility, time to
and position new accounts lost or count, machines that
productivity respond to customer
gained break down
measurements demands
BENCHMARKING
This method examines past performance over a period of time to For some activities, the process might be so unique that there
This method compares performance of the process against other
determine trends and best performance. Alternatively, a range of may not be competitive or activity benchmarks available. In these
firms in the same industry or sector. Major automakers, for
processes might be assessed in order to determine internal best cases, a conceptually similar process is sought as a benchmark
example, will buy cars made by their competitors then reverse
practice, which can then be used as the benchmark for other [for eg tunneling is conceptually similar to explorations into
engineer those cars to see how to improve their own product.
processes. volcanic crusts].
BALANCED SCORECARD
Internal process perspective
Financial perspective Customer perspective Innovation perspective
[whether the organisation’s processes are
[whether organisation is achieving its financial [whether the organisation is meeting customer [whether the organisation is continuing to
efficient as well as whether employees are
targets and meeting shareholders needs] needs] improve and develop]
satisfied]
How does the organisation create value for its What do customers value? How can the organisation continue to
owners? To achieve its financial and customer
By recognising what customers value most, improve and create value?
objectives, what processes must the
Financial measures of performance in a the entity can focus its performance targets The focus here is on the ability of the organisation perform with excellence?
balanced scorecard system might include on satisfying the customer more effectively. organisation to maintain its competitive
share price growth, profitability and return on Management should identify the key aspects
Targets might be developed for several position, through the skills and knowledge of
investment. of operational performance and seek to
aspects of performance such as cost (value for its work force and through developing new
achieve or maintain excellence in this area.
money), quality or place of delivery. products and services.
STRATEGIC CHANGE
[Change happens continually within organisations and their markets. Strategic development inevitably results in some change, which needs careful management. Change is either planned or unplanned.]
[A network is a schedule of the work for a analysis - CPA) is a technique that is widely possible time (and so must be completed at
occurs which is not greater than the float, the
project, showing all the tasks that have to be used to plan the timing and scheduling of a the earliest possible time) so that the project
overall project duration will not be affected.
completed, the inter-dependencies between project, by drawing the project network and as a whole will be completed in the minimum
There will be no spare time (float) on critical
them and the time-scale for completing them. identifying the activities on the critical path possible time. These activities go through
path activities.
A network is shown as a diagram or chart] and the total duration of the critical path. events where the earliest and the latest event
times are the same.
A Gantt chart is a horizontal bar chart. Each A chart can use colour coding to make it
Gantt Charts activity is shown as a bar, and the length of the The project can be planned in a way that easier to understand. For example, the
[A Gantt chart is another way of scheduling bar represents the duration of an activity (as minimises total employee numbers by making activities making up the critical path can be
the activities in a project, and identifying the shown in the chart below). They are usually use of float times, and delaying the start of shown in a distinctive colour. Activities that
critical path and float times. It is an alternative drawn with each activity starting at its earliest non-critical activities until employees working follow on from each other can be shown as a
to network charts] starting time and ending at its earliest finishing on another activity become free. continuous bar on the chart. This makes it
time. Float time is shown as a dotted line. easier to identify float time.
RISK MANAGEMENT
CATEGORIES OF RISK
Strategic Risk
Tactical Risks
These cannot be avoided because risks must be taken in order to make
Tactical risk refers to the potential for losses or negative consequences Operational Risks
profits.
resulting from a specific tactical decision or action taken by an Pure risks are risks that can often be controlled either by means of
Higher risks should be justified by the expectation of higher profits and
individual or organization. It is often associated with short-term internal controls or by insurance. These risks might be called internal
a company needs to decide what level of speculative risks are
decisions and actions that are taken to achieve a particular objective or control risks or operational risks.
acceptable.
goal.
Speculative risks are usually called business risk, or enterprise risk.
Market Risk Credit Risk Liquidity Risk Technological Risk Legal Risk Health & Safety Risk Reputation Risk Business Probity Risk Derivatives Risk
RISK MANAGEMENT
‘Risk-based approach’ is often used to describe risk management processes. It is an approach to decision-making based on a detailed evaluation of risks and exposures, and policy guidelines on the level of risk that
is acceptable (risk appetite)
A simple approach to risk mapping involves taking each risk that has been identified and placing it on a map. The
Risk appetite (Risk appetite is concerned with how much risk management are willing to take. Management might
map is a 2 × 2 matrix, with one side representing the frequency of adverse events or the probability that the risk will
be willing to accept the risk of loss up to a certain maximum limit if the chance of making profits is sufficiently
materialise and an adverse outcome will occur, and the other side representing the impact (loss) if an adverse event
attractive to them)
occurs or adverse circumstances arise.
A risk map can help management to identify risks where immediate control measures
are required, and where the need for control measures should be considered or
reviewed periodically.
High impact, low probability’ risks might include the risks of damage to assets from
fire or flooding, the risk of a terrorist attack or the risk of major legislation that will
affect the company’s business.
Some of these risks, such as risks of fire, theft and criminal damage, can be insured.
Insurance reduces the residual risk by the amount of the insurance cover obtained.
A risk dashboard can be used to identify which risks need further control measures.
On a simple dashboard, each risk that has been identified is represented by a ‘coloured light’.
These are usually green, amber and red, representing the colours of traffic signals.
When a risk has a red light, this indicates that further risk measures are needed.
A green light indicates that the risk is under control. An amber light indicates that the risk needs to be
kept under review.
It suggests rather that there is an acceptable level of risk in a given circumstance to achieve a
given objective.
It is important to remember that risk and return are usually linked in a positive way so that higher
return is often associated with higher risk.
Risk retention [means accepting the risk, in the expectation of making a return. When risks are retained, they should be managed, to ensure that unnecessary risks are not taken and
that the total exposure to the risk is contained within acceptable limits]
Risk appetite and Risk Retention [The choice between avoiding risks and accepting risk depends on risk appetite. Risk appetite is the amount of risk that an entity is willing to
accept by investing in business activities, in order to obtain the expected returns from the business. Risk appetite varies from one company to another. Some companies are willing to
take fairly large risks whereas others are ‘risk averse’. In general, companies expect higher returns by taking larger risks.
THEORIES OF MANAGEMENT
Fayol’s 14 Principles of
Scientific Management of Principles of organizations Rosemary Stewart on McGregor’s Theory X and Management Theory of
Administrative Weber’s Ideal Bureaucracy Peter Drucker
Taylor – Lyndall Urwick Bureaucracy Theory Y William Ouchi (Theory Z)
Management
EFFECTIVE RECRUITMENT
References:
On a job application form, applicants for a job are often asked to provide the name and address of one or two ‘referees’.
The main problem with references is that the referee may not give an honest opinion about the individual.
In particular, a referee may be reluctant to write anything critical about the individual, not wanting to damage his or her chances of getting the job.
LEARNING ORGANISATIONS
Learning styles: Honey and Mumford
Theorist These individuals like to understand the theory that Theorists learn best when they are put into complex situations where they have Theorists do not learn well when they are required to
supports the practice. Theorists learn with facts, concepts to use their skills and knowledge; and they have an opportunity to look at the participate in situations where emotions and feelings are
and models. ideas involved in a problem. important; and take part in an unstructured activity.
Reflector This individual learns by observing and thinking about what Reflectors learn best when they can watch others at work, when they are not Reflectors do not like learning when they are given tasks
he has seen. Reflectors prefer to avoid ‘jumping in’ to a given tight deadlines for writing reports when they have time to think and reflect. to do and complete without time to plan or think.
task, and prefer to watch.
Activist This individual learns by doing and acting. Activists like to Activists learn best when they are involved in new experiences and opportunities; Activists do not learn well when they are required to listen
‘get their hands dirty’. they work with others in team tasks: in a training situation, they enjoy role play; to lectures and long explanations; read, write and think
they are ‘thrown in at the deep end’ and are expected to get on with a task; and on their own; and follow precise instructions about what
they are leading discussions or chairing meetings. to do.
Pragmatist This individual like to see how theory is put into practice in Pragmatists learn best when they have an opportunity to apply ideas and Pragmatists do not learn well when there is no obvious
the ‘real world’. Pragmatists find abstract theories and techniques in practice, and are then given feedback on how well they have done; immediate purpose to what they are learning, and so no
concepts of no use unless they can see their relevance to and there is a model that they admire and can copy (such as a boss who acts as immediate benefit; the learning is ‘all theory’; and there
practical action. a ‘role model’). are no practical aspects or practical guidelines in the
learning.
Methods of development
Job rotation: means moving an individual from one job to another at fairly
regular intervals, so that the individual gains familiarity with other roles also.
Secondment: An individual might be ‘seconded’ to work somewhere else for a
period of time.
Deputising for a manager or supervisor. An individual may be given the
opportunity to deputise for his or her boss when the boss is absent from work.
Delegation, mentoring and appraisal.
Job enrichment means making the job ‘richer’ by building more responsibility
into it. When a job is enriched, the job holder is given more authority.
‘Self development’ is a term for the activities and learning that provide lifelong personal development, and at the same time contribute to the individual’s professional competence or the achievement
of the organisation’s goals.
The goal of self-development is to increase your readiness and potential for a position of greater responsibility.
Enhancing self-development
There are several ways in which individuals can try to achieve more self-development:
- They should use the staff appraisal system to agree targets for achievement and initiatives for training and development.
- They should follow up on their appraisal interview. They should try to achieve the objectives they have been set, or try to ensure that they get the training or development that they want.
- If they do not get the training they want from their employer, they could arrange for some training in their own out-of-work time.
MANAGEMENT CHALLENGES
Peformance Appraisal
[formal process for reviewing and assessing the competence of individual employees, and considering what might be done to develop them]
The following are ‘common sense’ requirements for good Barriers to effective performance appraisal
interviewing: - It has no purpose. Employees see the appraisal interview as
- Ask questions that allow the employee to give full answers. nothing more than an informal chat with the manager.
A staff appraisal may have three different components. - Give the employee time to ask questions and give opinions. - Employees see the appraisal interview as an occasion for
- A reward review: opportunity for the employee and his or her criticism from the manager.
- Don’t ask complicated questions.
manager to discuss pay and other rewards. - The interview is one-sided.
- Ask follow-up questions to clarify answers to initial questions.
- A performance review: assess the performance of the - The appraisal process might be seen as an annual event.
- Listen. Don’t talk too much.
employee since the previous appraisal. - Lack of training in appraisal interview techniques. A system
- Keep the discussion focused on relevant issues.
- Potential review: discuss the employee’s potential for career might be ineffective because managers are not given proper
development and promotion. - Handle difficult areas with sensitivity and consideration. guidance or training in what they should be doing.
- Let the employee know that you are listening - There must be formal records for an appraisal system.
- Look for constructive solutions to problems, and look for ways - An appraiser should be objective when appraising employee
to develop the employee. performance.
Techniques of assessment:
Examples of appraiser bias:
Approaches by management to the appraisal interview - Ranking. When employees are interviewed by the same
manager, the manager can rank them in order of competence. - The halo effect – this involves overly-focusing on one positive
1. Tell and sell method - The interviewer tells the employee how area to the detriment of being objective about other areas in
the assessment will be made. - Scoring. An organisation may use rating scales to score the need of development.
competence of an employee.
2. Tell and listen method – The interviewer invites the employee - Central tendency bias – this type of bias occurs when the
to respond to the assessment. - Grading. A similar approach to appraisal is to give the reviewer groups the bulk of employees into mid-level grades
employee a grade or rating on a nonnumerical scale – such as meaning that most employees are considered ‘average’.
3. Problem-solving method – The interviewer and the employee excellent, very good, good, satisfactory, below average and
must agree in advance as to what the appraisal interview poor. - Recency bias – this describes biasing the review towards more
should try to achieve, and how it should be conducted. recent events to the detriment of objectively appraising
- Critical incident method. Another method of appraisal is to performance over the whole review period.
4. 360-degree approach – interview is based on an assessment focus on any critical incident that has occurred during the time
of the individual by a number of other people (‘raters’) who are since the previous appraisal interview. - Personal bias describes the situation where a reviewer favours
familiar with the individual’s work, and a self-assessment by the certain employees and discriminates against others for personal
individual. - Performance-related assessment. The competence of an (subjective) reasons rather than objective performance-driven
employee may be based on a comparison between the targets reasons.
or objectives.
Inform the employee of the problem 3. Suspension without Pay. Suspension is normally the next level after written warning(s). It is meant to suspend the employee for a
certain number of working days and the pay is docked for the number of days suspended.
4. Reduction of Pay within a class. At times when the management do not wish to remove the employee from the site but feel
Allow the employee to be accompanied
important to take a corrective measure then this alternative might be opted for in lieu of suspension without pay.
at the meeting
5. Demotion to a Lower Classification. The employee may be demoted temporarily or permanently depending upon the seriousness
of the problem area.
Decide on appropriate action 6. Dismissal: Generally, when all other progressive disciplinary actions fail to get the employee’s attention, dismissing him/her is the
action of last resort.
Advantages Disadvantges
Attract
Employees encouraged to
Motivate Encourage talented
help think more Meeting the Earning the
individuals to employees to employees, Meeting only Using more
organisations about the long- budget target, bonus –
achieve their focus on and make the lowest resources than Avoiding risks Taking risks
achieve their term prospects but not beating whatever it
performance continuous them want to targets necessary
strategic of their it takes to do this
targets improvement work for the
objectives. company.
entity
BUSINESS OPERATIONS
Operations Management [involves planning and controlling day-to-day activities in the operations department]
Production planning and control involves reconciling demand for Capacity planning and control aims to achieve a suitable balance
Inventory management involves making decisions about how much
resources and outputs with their supply [avoding stockouts and between the demand for production capacity and the provision of that
inventory to hold including buffer inventory
overholding of inventory]. capacity.
SUPPLY CHAIN:
There is a value chain within every business entity. There is also a supply chain from the producers of raw
materials and equipment through to the entities that sell the end consumer product to customers.
Network sourcing
Long-term strategic Parallel sourcing
Independent describes the situation [Network sourcing is
Competitive relationships founded on a tiered
[Improved Supportive in larger companies
relationship [this is where Passive Integrative Traditional sourcing network of small
professionalism and [Purchasing where each plant/
[this is where buyers organisations [Purchasing reacts to [Significant reliance on include a large number business suppliers.
attempt to formalise department is viewed factory/ location
negotiate hard to collaborate with key requests from other purchasing for of suppliers for each Network members
communication links as essential by top operates single
achieve the lowest suppliers and form departments] competitive success] major raw material tend to form long-term
with technical management] supplier sourcing but
possible price] long-term strategic from different relationships founded
functions]
partnerships] suppliers. on co-ordination and
mutual trust]
Practical Implications of JIT Wastes to be eliminated to implement a successful JIT system JIT techniques
Materials requirements planning (MRP I) Manufacturing resource planning (MRP II) Optimised production technology (OPT) Enterprise resource planning (ERP)
QUALITY MANAGEMENT
[quality related costs]
Prevention Costs Appraisal Costs Internal Failure Costs External Failure Costs
- Influencing long term strategy and policy. - Mitigating or reversing negative environmental, social Economic viability (shareholders’ wealth) - Providing insight and analysis to support decision
and governance impacts; gaining reputation and brand making bringing sustainability perspectives.
- Streamlining processes and improving efficiency. Social responsibility (impact on society)
loyalty - Improving the quality of stakeholder communications
- Benchmarking and assessing performance Environmental responsibility (impact of environment) and the reporting of sustainability information.
- External stakeholders understand the organization’s
- No environmental & governance failures. true value, and tangible and intangible assets. - Accountants in audit and advisory roles, can consider
- Comparing performance between organizations how they could embrace sustainability issues
IFAC Sustainability Framework: Business Strategy perspective (bringing sustainability into strategy, governance and values of business)
Key theme Key considerations for professional accountants
Defining Establishing an understanding of sustainability; by Create awareness of how the finance function can get involved.
sustainability and developing a strong business case. Ensure clarity on uses of the business case
business case Identifying significant, material, and relevant environmental and social issues.
Putting forward impacts of activities on society/environment
Vision and Requires change and leadership from senior Integration of sustainability into the key business drivers requires leadership and ownership within the governing body.
leadership management. Managerial and operational structures deliver the vision.
Stakeholder Stakeholder engagement develops an Reinforce the importance of stakeholder engagement.
engagement understanding of what sustainability means. Dialogue with stakeholders is necessary.
Build the knowledge and professional skills needed to deal with the challenges of understanding and balancing stakeholder
expectations
Goals and target Develop goals and targets to facilitate the delivery Establish goals, targets, and performance measures
setting of high-level vision and strategy. Engage employees involved in executing strategy
Link to rewards
Establish a baseline against which progress can be monitored
Integration with Risk management approach identifies opportunities, Integrate sustainability issues into risk management and other management systems
risk management risk factors, and causation. Gather information and assess cost benefit
Assess potential impact
Engagement of Working closely with suppliers. Identify opportunities linked with sustainable procurement.
suppliers Communicate how an organization builds relationships.
Carbon neutrality
The effect on the environment of economic activities by individual companies may be measured in terms of emissions of carbon-based pollutants.
Carbon neutrality exists when a company is able to counterbalance its use of carbon products, and particularly its carbon dioxide emissions, with activities that reduce the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere.
Example: Environmental conscience: There are many examples of large environment conscious companies. One company has listed some of the initiatives it has taken to create a sustainable business as:
- Setting a target of zero waste generation and zero waste emissions. - Conserving energy and resources such as oil, coal, natural gas, water and minerals
- Recycling materials to reduce the need for disposals - Reducing packaging waste and developing new products and processes that reduce the environmental risks
- Managing land efficiently to increase habitats for wild life - Making, using, handling and transporting materials safely and in an environment friendly way
Social footprint
A social footprint is the effect of economic activity on society and people. In general, economic activity is seen as providing benefits for society, although some companies are much more ‘people-friendly’ than others.
Companies might seek to measure the contribution of their activities towards society in terms of:
Total numbers employed or increase in the total number of employees
The proportion of the total work force employed in different parts of the world
The proportion of the total work force that is female or from different ethnic groups
Health and safety at work (for example, numbers of employees injured each year per 1,000 of the work force).
There is no standard format or content for a code of ethics, but a typical code contains general statements about ethical conduct by employees, and specific reference to company's dealings with each stakeholder
group, such as employees, customers, shareholders and local communities.
Shareholders
Employees Customers
A code of ethics might not include much
- human rights, including the right of all A code of ethics might include statements Competitors about shareholders, because the
General statements about ethical conduct employees to join a trade union about: relationship between a company and its
A code of ethics might include statements
A code of conduct should specify that - equal opportunities for all - fair dealing with customers about: shareholders might be contained in a code
compliance with local laws is essential. In of corporate governance that the company
- refusal to tolerate harassment - product safety and/or product quality - fair dealing with competitors
addition, employees should comply with the follows.
policies and procedures of the company. - concern for the health and safety - the truthfulness of advertisements - the use of techniques for obtaining The key issue with shareholders is to
- respect for the privacy - respect for the privacy of confidential information about competitors maintain and develop trust and confidence,
- company policy on bribes information about each customer. which might be achieved through disclosure
of information (openness and transparency).
WHISTLEBLOWING
[means reporting illegal or improper behaviour]
An employee considering 'blowing the whistle' should consider these before deciding to actually blow the whistle Problems with whistleblowing
Some individuals
make allegations
Is there an internal When an
Are all the facts They should about colleagues
Establish whether audit department individual reports
correct? Could double-check they Consider Double-check or managers that
there is scope to who could be concerns about
they have Is there sufficient have thought discussing events Think about the company policy are unfounded.
discuss events made aware of Consider if there is illegal or unethical
misinterpreted evidence to justify about the in confidence with impact on the and The allegations
confidentially with relevant events a legal obligation conduct, the
something or blowing the situation an independent person's career whistleblowing might be made for
the human and take to report individual is often
mistakenly drawn whistle? objectively and confidential third and job procedures in the reasons of malice
resources ownership of victimised, by
the wrong with neutral party staff handbook. and dislike, or
department. reporting any colleagues and
conclusion? emotion because there has
issues? management.
been an argument
at work.
Ethical threats to
A model for resolving
Fundamental principles compliance of Nature of ethical safeguards Mirror Test
ethical conflicts
fundamental principles