You are on page 1of 5

These questions were raised by Mr.

Tanzeel Ahmed on his blog at Tribune, and when I replied to his question, the moderation never allowed it, so here I am posting to it, I hope people learn about the biasness of tribune and such blogs who are trying to divert the real facts. Here is a link on which I was not allowed to reply,

http://blogs.tribune.com.pk/story/7723/letsplay-20-questions-for-zulfiqar-mirza/comment-page-2/#comment-64047
1) If you claim to be so truthful, why have you never made these revelations before?

I would like to reply the article writer in detail, first of all it is Newtons law ... action having reaction, what you did is a mere reaction: Ans1) lets talk about Quran, why the revelation came at last? y it came on Muhammad S.A.W at the age of 40? Muhammad S.A.W was honest since childhood but never revealed anything before, it is just an example. its not about when a person decides to take initiative and talk the truth, so your first question is just a lame allegation like most of Atheist, just challenging other's faith rather than making an attempt to understand the fact.
2) According to you, Rehman Malik does everything on the discretion of President Asif Ali Zardari. Why then is Rehman Malik accused of conspiring against the Peoples Party and not President Zardari?

Ans2) Dr. is party person addressing a party as whole rather than how loyal mr. Malik should be to president. He himself is saying that Malik is with killers involved and working under cover so your question is rather fragile one.

3) Is the president of Pakistan Asif Ali Zardari a fool to not understand the shrewdness of Rehman Malik?

Ans3) President is worried about how to keep all parties united so that government runs, than again a political motive and he therefore relay on Malik for assistance to maintain good social relations with other parties as if they withdraw their support, a government can fall. No one is stupid, but compel to one or other reason to remain in active in taking right step.

4) Mirza Sahab, why did you never raise your voice in 2001 (or afterwards) when you got to know that MQM chief Altaf Hussain wrote a letter against the ISI?

Ans4) Since you have not given a thought that its not about when did the letter was written, but in fact that when did Dr. Mirza finds about it, may be the hypothesis is that he find it later or the second hypothesis is that he find it earlier and was not sure that how true is it, but as he was confirmed about it, he exposed it, again i will say need to revise your emotions before you write on blogs!
5) What exactly made you speak up after the discovery of the torture cells and ammunition from Lyari?

Ans5) The conscience of men makes him speak, react or act when ever it take over him. Again, it take almost 10 hours for you to speak about Dr. Mirza, why didn't you

speak about it before? because you need fact findings, that may be case with the person you are trying to criticise? asking Dr. Question can you ask the accused party for that toture cells? have you come up with any justified explanation about those cells? meet mr Aqeel (near fauji chawni-Korangi dhai number), MQM activist, give him a bottle to drink, he will tell you that it was self justification to bring justice to people, so do you think that law in hand is right? I have the recording of videos that are from units, and i will assure you, you need to be more research oriented to write on blogs, again, your question is not based on the historic facts and findings.

6) You acknowledge that Rehman Malik is a good politician and a good human being but maintain that he is also a compulsive liar. What does this mean?

Ans6) Most people are in this world are compulsive liar, does the meta physics take them out from being human or good human category? Human is the most unpredictable species, they can change according to situations, environment and incidents, liar is one aspect but being human possibility is that might Malik has done some good deeds? your question is based against natural theology.

7) You placed the Holy Quran on your head and said that MQM has a false mandate in Karachi and Hyderabad. How many petitions have you filed in court about this?

Ans7) Do you personally think that petitions should be filled and they are answered? since MQM said once the minutes of 12 may revealed that justice Iftikhar, Qurd and Ahtizaz Ahsan her responsible of killing on may 12, 2007, why didn't the petition was filled against these three members by Mr. Wasim Akhtar? again, your question is simple divert-er to divert the mind of readers from real subject.
8) Why are superior courts, Pakistani forces and Pakistani law enforcement agencies not taking any action on the MQMs alleged crimes? Is the MQM really that powerful?

Ans8) Yes, when the pakistani forces take action, we have witnesed the cleanse operation in early 90's, the political dilemma and internal conspiracies never let the operations take place, why was Dr. Shoaib Sadle transfered from I.G position when PPP came in rule and appointed him. he was one of the most active police man in shooting the killers on early 90's. wasn't it a request of Dr. Ishrat to transfer him or else would withdraw support from government?
9) CPLC recovered most of the kidnapped people from Lyari. Is this the reason why the CPLC chief, Ahmed Chinoy, has suddenly turned into a villain?

Ans9) No, this is not the sole reason, the reasons are already mentioned by Dr. Mirza, his BHATA system was making him a villan, How About the statement of Sharukh and Ajmal Pahari, does that statements serously makes MQM a real penetrator of peace? as they themselves have confessed their links in target killing with MQM?

10) You seem to be very worried about the people of Sindh. Why are you obsessed with Karachi only? Has karo-kari, dacoity and corruption ended in interior Sindh?

Ans10) Your question needs modification, compare the graph of interior sindh with Karachi, and compare it, which place is of serous concern? of course, you are denying the fact that in recent target killing, karachi has become a mess and required all nation to stand and find solution, just throwing a question at Dr. Mirza is not helping you to bring peace in Karachi, or is it?
11) How many hospitals and schools have you built in your own constituency?

Ans11) do you personally think that your question is logical? if it is, when Altaf was in Pakistan how many schools, hospitals he built? wasn't he a person who said, sell out all books, n stuff, buy weapons? how about Sabza Zar, and green week issue where Mustafa kamal has either block property as not paying BHATA or waste the money of government on flowers, couldn't he open some alms house or donate to EIDHI,? sure you need to think out of box about it.
12) You say that you will fight against the criminal elements of Karachi in your private capacity. Is this legal?

Ans12) So what do you think how should you fight? private act was not to take any politically refered police man, is it wrong? shouldn't be this way? how about those torture cells of MQM, were they right?

13) Keeping in mind that a civilian cannot take the law into his own hands, how would you decide who is a criminal and who is not?

Ans13) Keeping the facts and figure in hand, how can we deny that MQM was regarded as most racist party by CANADIAN HR Activists, what is happening in Karachi, people who have guns in hand, come and attack you, what will you do, what opinion will you have? Ok taking another round of it, someone steal at your home, when you go to report, police ask any doubts, you just say names you think can be possible people to do it, so it that wrong? may be Dr. Mirza was doing same! your question is biased to greater extent.
14) You claim that you havent recruited any MQM worker in the Sindh Police, and that recruitment in the police department was done on merit only. If this is so, then why does corruption and incompetency still prevail in the Sindh Police?

Ans14) He has just recruited, he has not fired yet any, the corruption may be or may not be linked with the earlier recruited police man by political affiliation? Rome was built but not in a day, a policy you implement today will take years to create its real impact, the change is brought today, as an researcher wait and observe it in long run rather than doing prejudice.

15) Why are the ISI chief and Army Generals not taking action on your substantiated evidence?

Ans15) Than again, its a seed-grain, the problems are emerging, once the options remain to limit, no critical step is advised, it is not a game to come and take actions straight away, keep generating data, sort it and you will eventually decide the last legal step, on the basis of evidences, the first step will be research data collection, these may be hypotheses, you may never know, may be its time to have some real investigation of facts? again, jumping to conclusion will not help questions.
16) When are you going to the Supreme Court to submit this evidence?

Ans16) The question about future, Dr. Mirza should answer it, but for time being i will say WHEN THE RIGHT TIME COMES, today was RIGHT TIME to reveal so it happen, lets hope the light of lamp brighten for long.
17) How exactly have President Asif Zardari and the late Benazir Bhutto helped you in acquiring such a huge amount of money, villas, cars, sugar mills and thousands of acres of lands?

Ans17) question is personal, since he mentioned that his father was justice and has all those things from different sources, what about Altaf? his source of income for last 20 or odd years? how he gained so much of luxuriousness life, hope you have read those articles about his assets? rounding the question, ask most of the leaders about their assets, targeting only one is not going to make you sound more rational,
18) You alleged that during a meeting in London, the MQM chief Altaf Hussain had told you that America and other world powers had decided to break Pakistan, and that Altaf Hussain had supported their idea. Since when has Altaf Hussain started sharing such secrets with you?

Ans18) Do Altaf has any secrets? honestly, i would ask you isn't Jinahpur the idea of Altaf? didn't he wanted to separate the land, what about those mas founded? why he left pakistan and never returned? hope hou have read PArliament sy Bazar e husan and A history of Pakistan and its origins By Christophe Jaffrelot., though your question is valid that how Dr. Knows about it, but the answer is same that Dr. Mirza knows about it like everybody in Pakistan knows about Osama bin ladin!
19) If America wants to break Pakistan up, according to you, then why did you go to the enemy country for a 40-day vacation?

Ans19) Is it unfair to go and travel to different part of world, Syed ahmed khan was against British system but visited cambridge and oxford in september years before his death, what about Q.A Jinah, he was against their policies, but frequently travelled? going to spend vacation in any country is a personal choice, america is not against Mirza, same as british was not against syed ahemend khan, it is about the region domain.

20) Sir, do you still stand by your slogan Pakistan na Khappay (We dont want Pakistan)?

Ans20) unfortunately, the last question is also a reaction, it is a double barrel question, the slogans should have been associated if it has been used by all members and at all meetings, y didn't you opt for HAR GHAR SAY BHOTO NIKLAYGA SLOGAN....? or ROTI KAPRA AND MAKAN? article writer lacks a basic of rationality, should go and search that what good you can find from the conference, how you and I can together save a NATION, i m not correcting you, but replying you so that you don't think that what you think is right, every coin has two side, you got the other side, i hope you pose 40 more questions but all based of research, facts and remain unbiased. I myself am not associated with any party, this is just a reply to make you and 3 0r 4 followers of yours who are appreciating the counter attack that this is just a weak excuse to keep eyes shut from the FACTS.... Peace,

You might also like