Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/357332261
Green Investing and Financial Services: ESG Investing for a Sustainable World
CITATIONS READS
3 346
1 author:
Artie Ng
International Business University
84 PUBLICATIONS 760 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Technological Innovation for Sustainable Development under Globalisation: Complementary Policy, Business and Financing Models View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Artie Ng on 28 December 2021.
Artie Ng
Contents
1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
2 Multiple Stakeholders as Advocates for Sustainable Finance and Investments . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
3 Emerging Global Governance Architecture for Developing Green Financial Products
and Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
4 Green Financial Instruments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
4.1 Green Bond, Loan, and ESG Equities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
4.2 Other Green-Derived Financial Products and Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
5 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
Abstract
This chapter aims to explore the range of green investing and financial services
developed largely over the past decades across the 2008/2009 global financial
crisis. It highlights the motives and incentives for developing and offering these
green investing and financial services: (i) the increasing expectation from stake-
holders for financial institutions to embrace corporate social responsibility and
sustainability, (ii) the emerging global governance architecture for green finance
that supports the development of pertinent innovative financial products and
services offered to the end customers, and (iii) the international trend to integrate
green and sustainability features into various innovative financial instruments for
ESG performance. Examples of contemporary green investing and financial
services are identified. Their future prospects and challenges as a cross-
disciplinary attempt are deliberated.
A. Ng (*)
Global Centre for ESG Education and Research, The Hong Kong Management Association,
Central, Hong Kong
e-mail: artieng@hkma.org.hk
Keywords
Green investing · Green financial services · Sustainable finance · Sustainable
investing · ESG investing
1 Introduction
While the world has gone through various financial crises and corresponding
mitigating regulatory measures over the past decades, the global financial crisis in
2008/2009 is considered the most impactful with respect to adverse consequences to
the society at large (Stiglitz 2010). It resulted in the collapse of one of the largest,
oldest, and most profitable investment banking institutions. Subsequent to this global
financial crisis, a wide spectrum of stakeholders started questioning the role of the
financial markets as a crucial component of capitalism to the world’ s overall
sustainability, particularly on the social and environmental aspects (Stiglitz 2017).
For instance, Hopwood et al. (2010) noted that if business and financial organi-
zations, including both public and private ones, are to meet the mounting challenges
of attaining sustainable development, they need to embed sustainability consider-
ation in their decision-making processes. Nevertheless, such desirable pursuits are
from time to time constrained by the lack of a systematic approach to follow through
the actions by allocating sufficient resources. In particular, lacking a complementary
financial system that advocates green finance and sustainability is a major concern.
As evidenced by supportive financial policy initiatives, it is encouraging to note that
global financial centers around the world have started incorporating ways to enhance
sustainability in their corresponding strategic developments (Boubaker and Nguyen
2019; Ng and Law 2019).
The concepts of Socially Responsible Investment (SRI) and Principles for
Responsible Investment (PRI) were introduced well before the global financial crisis
in 2008/2009 (Krosinsky and Robins 2008; Blowfield and Murray 2014,
pp. 226–229). Such cross-disciplinary movement toward green and sustainable
finance and investment has gained momentum over time as more stakeholders are
concerned about social and environmental sustainability as well as issues and risks
associated with climate change. It is recognized that corporate financial activities
could be critical drivers for desiring a sustainable society and environment beyond
their traditional business function that concentrates on the objectives of economic
growth and generating financial returns to the shareholders (Waygood 2011). Over
the last decade, noticeable efforts have been devoted by financial regulators from the
developed economies to advocate financial institutions in the private sector not only
to focus merely on creating values to the investors but also embrace broader social
and environmental issues around their business activities particularly under the
threat of climate change (TCFD 2017).
This global financial development represents a new paradigm beyond the concept
of corporate social responsibility (CSR) for financial institutions and asset manage-
ment firms that are now proactive in innovating their portfolio of financial products
Green Investing and Financial Services: ESG Investing for a Sustainable World 3
and services with tangible green features for social and environmental sustainability.
The practice for environmental, social governance (ESG) performance is observed as
integrative strategy in alignment with UN SDGs a while sustaining the overall
corporate performance among the prominent ones (Blackrock 2021).
The chapter is presented and structured as follows. Section 2 highlights the key
stakeholders as advocates for this global development for developing green
investing and financial services. Section 3 explains the evolving global financial
regulatory system or architecture for regulating market-based profit-seeking institu-
tions and firms to deliver ESG performance. Section 4 then provides a stocktaking of
the key green financial products and services emerged from this global movement.
Section 5 concludes by highlighting the opportunities and challenges ahead with
securitization of green investments as the world moves toward the sustainable
development goals.
In order to facilitate a legitimate and effective global development for green and
sustainable investing, it is anticipated that more international standards similar to
PRI will be developed and endorsed under an emerging global governance archi-
tecture since there are heterogeneous financial markets and related regulations
around the world. As explained by Alexander et al. (2006, p. 239) on the challenge
of governing financial systems on a global scale, “the application of global gover-
nance to financial regulation must take account of certain standards and principals
of corporate governance, some of which are advocated by international financial
bodies that address the internal operation and management of financial
institutions.”
In the meantime, the emergence of global financial markets for green and
sustainable financing is to enable more institutional funding to be allocated into
firms that in turn invest into sustainable infrastructure, assets, and business opera-
tions (see Fig. 1). Development of green financial instruments is a global trend
Green Investing and Financial Services: ESG Investing for a Sustainable World 5
Firms
Global Financial
Resources
A firm raises funding from the financial markets markets
allocation into
Green and
Financial institutions
sustainable Retained earnings allocating investments
infrastructure as for reinvestment into sustainable
well as utilization
financial Instruments:
of such assets for Dividends and e.g. ESG equities and
sustainable Investment returns debt repayments Green Bonds with
Taxes
operations
potentials for
securitizations
Fig. 1 Firms and the global financial markets for green and sustainable investing
promotion of green bonds (Liu 2018). The number reaches US$2.5 billion with the
implementation of the government’s Green Bond Framework in 2019 (HKMA
2021). The offerings are led by the Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA)
under its Government Green Bond Program (GGBP) for allocating such bond
funds into public environmental projects for a low-carbon economy while at the
same time augmenting the breadth and depth of the local bond market”. According to
the HKMA (2021), the green bonds are now being settled and listed on the stock
exchanges of Hong Kong and London. These green bonds have been assigned with
high-grade credit ratings from S&P and Fitch (AA+, AA-, respectively) (HKMA
2021). Furthermore, more Chinese Mainland enterprises are expected to become
more active within Hong Kong’s international green bond market in relation with
their offshore developments.
With respect to the private sector, there have been various examples of issuing
green bonds particularly for investing in the development of large-scale green
infrastructure projects in the emerging economies (Fu and Ng 2021). For instance,
Towngas, an energy utility based in China, has developed its own green bond
framework and green bond principles. The promised usage of proceeds is financing
for Green projects, such as wastewater treatment projects that purify wastewater in
meeting discharge standard) as well as landfill gas projects (natural gas synthesis) or
biomass projects that possess the technologies to convert waste to biofuel (HKCG
2019). These infrastructure projects financed by green bond have an objective to
reduce GHG emissions through more effective circular uses of natural resources as a
means to enhance environmental protection in the pursuit of global sustainability.
On the other hand, green loans are bank loans offered to companies or associa-
tions which allow them to finance for existing or future eligible green projects.
Typically, there should be clearly stipulated objectives related to environmental
sustainability based on specific criteria on materiality of environmental risk assess-
ment. Some green loans are invested under the principle of a green financial
framework developed by a private firm for financing of commercial development
projects, including property and real estate development projects (Liu 2018). It is
observed that the popularity of green loans has exceeded over some of traditional
loans in recent years, and it is predicted that the trend will continue (Liu 2018).
For example, HSBC – a global commercial bank – has launched its sustainable
financing program for providing support to company pursuing low-carbon foot-
prints. These loans are offered to enterprises in acquiring eco-friendly machines and
adopting evidence-based sustainable strategies. In such arrangement, the commer-
cial bank provides a loan of a fixed amount and a defined repayment period (HSBC
2021). The repayment of green loans could be flexible with installment; in addition,
cash rebate is available for carbon saving at a percentage of the loan amount per
annum (HSBC 2021). Such financial incentives are expected to generate more
interests in green loans to finance investments in improving the sustainability
amount of the small and medium enterprises.
8 A. Ng
improve the energy efficiency rating of a home. Such rating is offered by Cooper-
ative Financial Services (CFS) in UK. Besides, the “Generation Green Home Loan”
is offered by Bendigo Bank in Australia for financing both new and old homes, with
a per annum reduction on the current variable interest rate and exemption of the
monthly service fee. These green mortgage features provide measurable financial
incentives to the home purchasers of flats that are rated with high-energy efficiency.
UNEP-FI (2007) identified that green auto loan can provide below-market interest
rates to consumers who purchase vehicles with low GHG intensity or rated with
outstanding fuel efficiency. A bank could make assessment of the GHG rating
associated with a vehicle type when determining an appropriate loan interest rate. In
Europe, some banks that offer green car loans attach educational services about the
relationship between the transportation sector and GHG emissions. As such, a package
is given to the borrowers with information on reducing emissions and fuel-efficient
driving tips. For instance, a credit union in Australia has introduced a clean air auto
loan for low-emitting vehicles with a prime rate which is lower than that of an average
car loan. More recently, the Government of Canada has provided defined financial
incentives as rebates to consumers who purchase or lease an eligible zero-emission
vehicle (Transport Canada 2021). Such a policy scheme by the government is consid-
ered complementary to the incentives offered by the market-based green auto loans.
It is also pointed out that green credit and debit cards offered by a financial
institution can be linked with environmentally friendly activities (UNEP-FI 2007).
For example, credit card companies offer a donation based on a defined percentage
on the amount of every purchase. In addition, the credit cards are no longer made of
plastic but of more environmentally friendly materials. It is promised that green
credit cards provide discounts and lower borrowing rates to the car owners when
they purchase environmentally friendly product and services. Therefore, it offers
green credit card owners to adopt a lifestyle of embracing environmentally friendly
products and services that are attached with various financial incentive features.
At last, there have been more green and ESG funds being offered in various
financial markets around the world for greater interests in sustainable investing at
both corporate and individual levels. Asset management companies have developed
and offered mutual funds with green and ESG elements for personal investments.
These companies are expected to comply with the disclosure requirements when
offering these products with respect to the claimed green and ESG features in their
asset allocations. For instance, the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) in
Hong Kong has the regulatory responsibility to review the offerings of securities
products regardless of being green or not prior to being introduced and offered to the
public at large (SFC 2021). But the growing interest in sustainable and green
investing from the market has created demands for green and sustainable securities.
5 Summary
with about US$ 150 billion of new funding injected into ESG-associated investment
products resulting in an estimated total global asset of US$ 1.6 trillion in these
products (Webb 2021). It is noted that about 60% of the young retail investors in the
USA within the age group of 18–34 are interested in selecting funds focusing on ESG
performance (Webb 2021). Comparable results are found in Europe as young investors
consider the people and the planet in their investment decision-making.
Similar movement is seen in the pension fund market that serves people across
different generations who have retired or are planning for retirement under different
spectrum of time. For example, there has already been a regulatory environment for
responsible investing by the pension funds in UK, which is further coordinated by
the stakeholders to support alignment of pension investments with the carbon
neutrality goals under the Paris Agreement (PRI 2020b). In addition, there are
interests in investing in more fixed income instruments that are aligned with policies
for ESG investing. Development of investment products through securitization of
ESG financing and investments has gained growing interests among the international
capital markets (PRI 2020c).
As a method of bundling the underlying receivables of a financial institution,
securitization of these assets has been frequently used to create liquidity while
developing investment products that can be sold to a broader group of investors.
Over time, as there are more viable listed companies and equities emerging from the
green industries as well as the vast amounts of green bond being issued, there are
opportunities to securitize these assets into various innovative green financial and
investment products for both institutional and retail investors.
Despite such emerging global enthusiasm in ESG consideration for green financ-
ing and investing, risk management is desirable in avoiding potential green washing
among these securitized products distributed to broader groups of investors. Perti-
nent regulations and standards for improving ESG disclosures and monitoring ESG
performance throughout the international financial markets with transparency are
seen increasingly relevant and necessary. Effective ESG due diligence could be
challenging if there is no systematic approach to integrating ESG factors in their
assessments of these securitized products. ESG investment for global sustainability
can be considered as an interdisciplinary practice that requires talents with adequate
knowledge and education particularly environmental and social sustainability
beyond conventional finance and investment.
References
Alexander K, Dhumale R, Eatwell J (2006) Global governance of financial systems: the interna-
tional regulation of systemic risk. Oxford University Press, Oxford/New York
Blackrock (2021) Climate risk and the transition to a low-carbon economy. https://corpgov.law.
harvard.edu/2021/03/02/climate-risk-and-the-transition-to-a-low-carbon-economy/
Blowfield M, Murray A (2014) Corporate responsibility: a critical introduction, 3rd edn. Oxford
University Press, Oxford/New York
Boubaker S, Nguyen DK (2019) Corporate social responsibility, ethics and sustainable prosperity.
World Scientific Books. World Scientific. Number 11460
Green Investing and Financial Services: ESG Investing for a Sustainable World 11
Carney M (2021) Building a private finance system for net zero: priorities for private finance for
COP26. https://emergingrisks.co.uk/building-a-private-finance-system-for-net-zero/
Climate Bonds Initiative (CBI) (2021) Sustainable debt global state of the market 2020
Fidelity (2020) Fidelity prospectus for Hong Kong investors. Retrieved from https://www.
fidelityinternational.com/legal/documents/FF/HK-en/pr.ff.HK-en.HK.pdf
Fu J, Ng AW (2021) Scaling up renewable energy assets: issuing green bond via structured public-
private collaboration for managing risk in an emerging economy. Energies 14(11):3076. https://
doi.org/10.3390/en14113076
Gray R, Adams CA, Owen D (2014) Accountability, social responsibility, and sustainability:
accounting for society and the environment. Pearson, Boston
HKCG (2019) Towngas green bond framework. Retrieved from https://www.towngas.com/tc/
Green-Bond/towngas-green-bond-framework.aspx
HKEX (2020) HKEX to launch new sustainable and green exchange. Retrieved from https://www.
hkex.com.hk/News/News-Release/2020/200618news?sc_lang¼en
HKMA (2021) HKSAR Government’s green bonds offering. Retrieved from https://www.hkma.
gov.hk/eng/news-and-media/press-releases/2021/01/20210127-3/ Hong Kong as a Regional
Green Finance Hub. May 2016. Financial Services Development Council
Hopwood A, Unerman J, Fries J (2010) Accounting for sustainability: practical insights. Earthscan.
https://doi.org/10.4324/9781849776332
HSBC (2021) Sustainable financing programme: supporting businesses towards a low-carbon
economy. Retrieved from
IFRS Foundation (2020) Consultation paper on sustainability reporting
IOSCO (2021) IOSCO sees an urgent need for globally consistent, comparable, and reliable
sustainability disclosure standards and announces its priorities and vision for a Sustainability
Standards Board under the IFRS Foundation
Krosinsky C, Robins N (2008) Sustainable investing : the art of long-term performance. Earthscan
Liu YY (2018) Current situation and development direction of green finance in Hong Kong.
Retrieved from https://www.bochk.com/dam/investment/bocecon/SY2018026(en).pdf
Ng A (2018) From sustainability accounting to a green financing system: institutional legitimacy
and market heterogeneity in a global financial centre. J Clean Prod 195:585–592
Ng AW, Law VT (2019) Towards a global financial system for sustainability: implications for an
emerging global financial center, chapter 10. In: Boubaker S, Nguyen DK (eds) Corporate social
responsibility, ethics and sustainable prosperity. World Scientific, pp 285–304
PRI (2020a) Investment consultants and ESG: an asset owner guide
PRI (2020b) Private retirement systems and sustainability: United Kingdom
PRI (2020c) ESG incorporation in securitised products: The Challenges Ahead
PRI (2021) About the PRI. https://www.unpri.org/pri/about-the-pri
SFC (2021) List of green and ESG funds. Retrieved from https://www.sfc.hk/en/Regulatory-
functions/Products/List-of-green-and-ESG-funds
Slebos M, MacKenzie C (2017) Long-term social issues drive economic growth, so why aren’t
investors behind the wheel? PRI academic network RI quarterly, vol 12, pp 3–6
Stiglitz JE (2010) Lessons from the global financial crisis of 2008. Seoul J Econ 23(3):321–339
Stiglitz JE (2017) The globalization of our discontent, Chazen Global Insights. https://www8.gsb.
columbia.edu/articles/chazen-global-insights/globalization-our-discontent
Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) (2017) Recommendations of the Task
Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures
Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) (2021) Overview. https://www.fsb-
tcfd.org/about/
Transport Canada (2021) Zero-emission vehicles help fight climate change. https://tc.canada.ca/en/
road-transportation/innovative-technologies/zero-emission-vehicles#/find/nearest?
country¼CA
12 A. Ng
UNEP (2015) Establishing China’s green financial system: detailed recommendation – create a
green IPO channel
UNEP Finance Initiative (UNEP-FI) (2007) Green financial products and services current trends
and future opportunities in North America: a report of the North American Task Force (NATF)
of the United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative
Waygood S (2011) How do the capital markets undermine sustainable development? What can be
done to correct this? J Sustain Financ Invest 1(1):81–87. https://doi.org/10.3763/jsfi.2010.0008
Webb MS (2021) Why ESG investing is becoming the norm. https://moneyweek-com.cdn.
ampproject.org/c/s/moneyweek.com/investments/investment-strategy/esg-investing/603220/
why-esg-investing-is-becoming-the-norm?amp