1. Provide two pros and two cons of running a broad auction. Explanation: Pros: –Maximizes potential competitive dynamics and probability of achieving maximum sale price –Helps to ensure that all likely bidders are approached Cons: –Difficult to preserve confidentiality –Unsuccessful outcome can create perception of an undesirable asset (“taint”) 2. Under what circumstances might a targeted auction be more appropriate than a broad auction? Explanation: A targeted auction is more appropriate if there is a select group of clearly defined buyers; also may be preferable if the seller wants to preserve confidentiality both externally and internally. 3. Why would a company hire an advisor? Explanation: Given the high stakes involved in an M&A transaction, companies need the specialized skills of investment bankers. For example, sell-side advisors have buyer relationships, sector knowledge, modeling and valuation expertise, execution experience, and dedicated resources. 4. What are the four primary methodologies for valuing a target company? How are they used by the sell-side advisor during the sale process? Explanation: The four primary methodologies are comparable companies, precedent transactions, DCF analysis, and LBO analysis. The sell-side advisor does upfront work to frame valuation expectations. Through the first and second rounds, the advisor needs to refresh the valuation range to negotiate with prospective buyers and interpret bids.
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
5. Under what circumstances might the sell-side advisor recommend a negotiated sale? Explanation: When there is a clear, natural buyer with synergies, who is prepared to launch a preemptive bid. 6. How many parties are typically contacted in a targeted auction? Broad auction? Explanation: Targeted auction = 5 to 15. Broad auction = 10 – 100+. 7. How long does a typical auction take? a) 4–6 months b) 4–6 weeks c) 24 months d) 20 days Answer: A 8. What are the key stages of an auction process? Explanation: –Organization and preparation –First round –Second round –Negotiations –Closing 9. What do the first round and second round refer to? Explanation: First round refers to the time from the initial contacting of buyers to receipt of initial bids. Second round refers to the time from the management presentation to receipt of final bids. 10. What is sell-side advisor due diligence? Why is it important? Explanation: The sell-side advisor performs in-depth due diligence on the target in order to: –Fully understand the company –Enable the positioning of the company, which is key for marketing to buyers –Help craft the financial projections –Establish valuation parameters
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
11. Who generally crafts the target’s financial projections? Explanation: Target management crafts the financial projections with help from the sell-side advisor. 12. Why are financial projections in an M&A sale process so important? Explanation: Financial projections provide the foundation for the buy-side valuation work. They need to be realistic and defensible. 13. What criteria are used to select the prospective buyers’ universe? Strategics vs. Financial Buyers? Explanation: When evaluating strategic buyers, the banker looks first and foremost at strategic fit, including potential synergies. Financial capacity or ability to pay, which is typically dependent on size, balance sheet strength, access to financing, and risk appetite, is also closely scrutinized. Other factors play a role in assessing potential strategic bidders, such as cultural fit, M&A track record, existing management’s role going forward, relative and pro forma market position (anti- trust concerns), and effects on existing supplier and customer relationships. When evaluating potential financial sponsor buyers, key criteria include investment strategy/focus, fund size, track record, fit within existing portfolio, sector expertise, fund cycle , as well as ability to obtain financing. The deal team also looks for sponsors with existing portfolio companies that may serve as attractive combination candidates for the target. 14. Traditionally, which type of buyer has been able to pay a higher price? Why? Explanation: Strategic buyers have been able to pay a higher price due to the ability to realize synergies, lower cost of capital, and lower return thresholds. 15. What are the key marketing materials in an M&A sale process? Explanation: Marketing materials include the teaser and CIM in the first round and management presentation in second round.
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
16. What are the key content items in a teaser? Explanation: The teaser is generally a brief one- or two-page synopsis of the target, including a company overview, investment highlights, and summary financial information. It also contains contact information for the bankers running the sell-side process so that interested parties may respond. 17. Why is it important for legal counsel to review and approve external marketing materials in an M&A sale process? Explanation: Marketing materials should be reviewed because of legal issues, most notably disclosure requirements for public companies and potential anti-trust issues for all companies. 18. When is the teaser distributed to prospective buyers? Explanation: The teaser is distributed at the start of the first round after the initial contact is made. 19. At what stage is the CIM distributed? What is the key gating item for the seller prior to distribution? Explanation: The CIM is distributed in the first round. The key gating item is the execution of the confidentiality agreement. 20. Select ALL that apply. Which of the following marketing documents contain detailed financial projections? a) Final Bid Procedures Letter b) CIM c) Management Presentation d) Teaser Answer: B and C
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
21. Provide an illustrative outline for a CIM. Explanation: Table of Contents 1. Executive Summary 2. Investment Considerations 3. Industry Overview – Segment Overview – Competition 4. Company Overview – History – Strategy – Products and Services – Customers and Suppliers – Management and Employees 5. Operations Overview – Manufacturing – Distribution – Sales and Marketing – Information Systems – Legal and Environmental 6. Financial Information – Historical Financial Results and MD&A – Projected Financial Results and MD&A Appendix – Audited Financial Statements – Recent Press Releases – Product Brochures 22. Select ALL that apply. Which of the following are key provisions of a confidentiality agreement? a) Use of information b) Term c) Permitted disclosures d) Non-solicitation/no hire Answer: All of the above
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
23. Why is a confidentiality agreement critical in an M&A sale process? Explanation: The confidentiality agreement prohibits the dissemination of non-public information by prospective buyers. Without it, the seller would be less willing or unwilling to share critical information. It also prohibits the solicitation to hire employees and, potentially, the unsolicited purchase of the target’s equity and debt (standstill agreement). 24. When are buyers contacted? Who generally makes the call? Explanation: The buyers are contacted at the start of the first round, marking the formal “launch.” Typically, a senior member of the sell-side advisory team makes the call, potentially with a sector coverage officer. 25. What document outlines the details and process for submitting a 1st round bid? a) Final bid procedures letter b) Teaser c) Initial bid procedures letter d) Confidentiality agreement Answer: C 26. What is the purpose of the management presentation? Explanation: The management presentation is a critical component of second round buyer due diligence. It provides a detailed overview of the target and interactive session with the management team. 27. Who gives the management presentation? Explanation: The core team presenting typically consists of the target’s CEO, CFO, and key division heads or other operational executives, as appropriate. 28. What is the core content of a management presentation? Explanation: Generally, the content maps to that of the CIM, but is more crisp and concise. It also tends to contain an additional level of detail, analysis, and insight, which is more conducive to an interactive session with management and later-stage due diligence. The outline typically includes an executive summary and overviews of the industry, company, operations, and financials.
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
29. What is the primary function of the data room? Explanation: The data room generally contains a broad base of essential company information, documentation, and analyses. In essence, the data room is designed to provide a comprehensive set of information relevant for buyers to make an informed investment decision, such as detailed financial reports, industry reports, and consulting studies. 30. Where is the data room housed? Explanation: Typically online, although pre-internet (and still in select cases) it was a physical location with paper files (typically at the sellers’ legal counsel offices). 31. What type of information may be intentionally excluded from the data room? Why? Explanation: Sensitive information critical to the target’s business plan may be excluded from the data room, especially if competitors are involved in the process. 32. What is a stapled financing? Explanation: Pre-packaged debt financing offered in support of the target being sold. The staple is targeted toward financial sponsors was and common during the LBO boom. 33. Who runs the staple process? Explanation: A separate financing deal team that operates separately from the M&A deal team is set up to run the staple process. 34. What role does the staple play in framing valuation? Explanation: It establishes a theoretical valuation floor due to the implied equity contribution percentage on top of the debt package. 35. How are the staple terms determined? Explanation: The staple terms are determined through an objective assessment of the target’s leverage capacity based on LBO analysis among other analyses, which examine cash flows, credit statistics, debt repayment, asset coverage, and equity cushion. The financing team must also assess the marketability of the structure given prevailing capital markets conditions.
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
36. How long are buyers generally given to assess the target and submit a first round bid? a) 2 weeks b) 4–6 weeks c) 4–6 months d) 12 weeks Answer: B 37. What does accretion/(dilution) analysis measure? Explanation: Public strategics use accretion/(dilution) analysis to measure the pro forma effects of the transaction on earnings, assuming a given purchase price and financing structure. 38. Why is it only relevant for public strategic buyers? Explanation: Private companies are not focused on EPS, but may look at “accretion” to EBITDA or EBIT margins. 39. Under what circumstances might a buyer pursue an acquisition that wasn’t accretive in Year 1? Explanation: In the event it is strategically important and holds promise for future growth opportunities (i.e., will be accretive in future years). 40. How can the sell-side advisory team use accretion/(dilution) analysis to guide purchase price negotiations? Explanation: For a specific strategic buyer and given a set of assumptions governing financing mix/cost and synergies, the sell-side advisor can determine its ability to pay and negotiate accordingly. 41. Why might a higher bid be rejected in favor of a lower one? Explanation: Concerns over the certainty of closing and ability to finance, as well as other structural and contract issues may cause a higher bid to be rejected in favor of a lower one.
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
42. Given the assumptions below, calculate the accretive/dilutive effects of the transaction on both a dollar and percentage basis. ($ and shares in millions) Assumptions Acquirer Net Income $100.0 Acquirer Diluted Shares Outstanding 50.0 Target Net Income $25.0 New Shares Issued 10.0 Explanation: ($ in millions, except per share data; shares in millions) Accretion Dilution Analysis Acquirer Net Income $100.0 Target Net Income 25.0 Pro Forma Combined Net Income $125.0
Acquirer Diluted Shares Outstanding 50.0
New Shares Issued 10.0 Pro Forma Fully Diluted Shares Outstanding 60.0
Pro Forma Combined Net Income $125.0
/ Pro Forma Fully Diluted Shares Outstanding 60.0 Pro Forma Diluted EPS $2.08
Accretion/(Dilution) - % ($2.08/$2.00 – 1) 4.2% 43. What is the key legal document establishing a formal agreement between a buyer and seller to purchase the target? a) Confidentiality agreement b) Final bid procedures letter c) Definitive purchase/sale agreement d) Credit agreement Answer: C
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
44. What is buyer due diligence? What forms does it take? Explanation: Buyer due diligence is comprehensive data gathering, analysis, and assessment to fully understand the investment opportunity represented by the target. It consists of management presentations, site visits, studying the data room, and follow-up inquiries. 45. What event usually marks the launch of a typical auction process? a) Receipt of the CIM and management projections b) Management presentation and access to the data room c) Buyer contact and distribution of the teaser d) Receipt of final bids from prospective buyers Answer: C 46. What event typically marks the launch of the second round? a) Receipt of final bids from prospective buyers b) Management presentation and access to the data room c) Receipt of the CIM and management projections d) Buyer contact and distribution of the teaser Answer: B 47. What are site visits? Why are they important? Explanation: Site visits are an essential component of buyer due diligence, providing a first-hand view of the target’s operations. The typical site visit involves a guided tour of a key facility, such as a manufacturing plant, distribution center, and/or sales office. The site visits tend to be highly interactive as key buyer representatives, together with their advisors and consultants, use this opportunity to ask detailed questions about the target’s operations. 48. What reservations may the seller have with regard to site visits? Explanation: –Internally—maintaining confidentiality so as not to alarm employees about a potential sale –Externally—may be sensitive to share this info with strategic buyers, especially competitors.
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
49. How do the final bid letter requirements differ from those of the initial bid letter? Explanation: The final bid letter requires a mark-up of the definitive agreement, evidence of committed financing or ability to pay, and timeline for regulatory, shareholder, and board approvals (if necessary). 50. What is the definitive agreement? Explanation: A legally binding contract between a buyer and seller detailing the terms and conditions of the sale transaction. 51. Select ALL that apply. Which of the following are key provisions of a definitive agreement? a) Representations and warranties b) Closing conditions c) Historical financial overview d) Summary of operations Answer: A and B 52. Who prepares the draft definitive agreement and when is it typically distributed to prospective buyers? a) Seller’s legal counsel; during the first round b) Buyer’s legal counsel; during negotiations c) Buyer’s legal counsel; along with the initial bid procedure letter d) Seller’s legal counsel; along with the final bid procedures letter Answer: D 53. Select ALL that apply. What are some of the key representations and warranties made by a seller? a) Its financial statements are accurate b) It has the necessary funds to complete the deal c) No material adverse change has occurred since signing d) Its business has not deteriorated, if using its stock as consideration Answer: A and C
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
54. Select ALL that apply. What are some of the key representations and warranties made by a buyer? a) It has obtained a fairness opinion b) It has the necessary funds to complete the deal c) No material adverse change has occurred since signing d) Its business has not deteriorated, if using its stock as consideration Answer: B and D 55. What indemnities does the seller typically provide to the buyer? Explanation: Breaches of representations and warranties, covenants, and specific liabilities, such as environmental exposures. 56. What is a break-up fee? Who is it designated to protect and why? Explanation: Break-up fees were historically reserved for payment to the buyer as a deal protection device to compensate the buyer in the event the seller pursues a “superior” bid consistent with the board’s fiduciary duties to seek the highest value (relevant for public targets). During the mid-2000s, it became customary for financial sponsors to agree to pay a "reverse break-up fee," typically if all of the conditions to the transaction were satisfied, but the buyer did not come up with the funds to consummate the transaction. 57. How many final bids might the seller expect to receive? Why? Explanation: The seller may receive two to three; others typically withdraw at some point during the second round. 58. What is a fairness opinion? Explanation: A fairness opinion is a letter opining on the “fairness,” from a financial point of view, of the consideration offered in an M&A transaction. It is supported by detailed analysis and documentation providing an overview of the sale process run (including number of parties contacted and range of bids received), as well as an objective valuation of the target.
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
59. Who prepares the fairness opinion? Explanation: Historically, the investment bank serving as sell-side advisor to the target has typically rendered the fairness opinion. In recent years, however, the ability of the sell-side advisor to objectively evaluate the target has come under increased scrutiny. As a result, some sellers hire a separate investment bank/boutique to render the fairness opinion from an “independent” perspective that is not contingent on the closing of the transaction. 60. What regulatory approval is often required to close a given M&A transaction, especially between two competitors? a) Sarbanes-Oxley b) Hart-Scott-Rodino c) Glass-Steagall d) Securities Act Answer: B 61. An M&A transaction involving a public target where its shareholders vote on whether to approve or reject the proposed transaction at a formal shareholders’ meeting is commonly referred to as a _______ merger. a) One-step b) Two-step c) 338(h)(10) d) Asset deal Answer: A 62. An M&A transaction involving a public target where a tender offer is made directly to the target's shareholders with the target's approval pursuant to a definitive agreement, with any untendered shares to be “squeezed out” if a certain threshold is met, is commonly referred to as a _______ process. a) One-step b) Two-step c) 338(h)(10) d) Asset deal Answer: B
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
63. Under the most favorable scenario, approximately how long can a two- step process take? a) 2 weeks b) 2 months c) 10 days d) 1 month Answer: D 64. What are some of the primary reservations in running a negotiated sale process between two competitors? Explanation: –Limits seller negotiating leverage and competitive tension –Potentially leaves “money on the table” if other buyers would have been willing to pay more –May require sharing of sensitive information with competitor without certainty of transaction close –Provides less market data on which board can rely to satisfy itself that value has been maximized 65. Why might a negotiated sale achieve the same result as an auction? Explanation: If the negotiated sale is with the best buyer, then it could have the same result as an auction, especially if the buyer strongly desires the asset. 66. Why do negotiated sales often involve a strategic buyer? Explanation: A strategic buyer may have the ability to pay a pre- emptive price due to its ability to realize synergies. Often, the principal executive officers have an existing relationship and have had previous conversations about a potential combination. 67. Why might a negotiated sale with a strategic buyer be completed more quickly than an auction? Explanation: It can be completed more quickly because there is less need for sector due diligence and less upfront marketing if the buyer is a competitor that is already familiar with the target.
Chapter 6_M&A Sale Process_Q&A
68. Select ALL that apply. From the seller’s perspective, what are some of the key advantages of a negotiated sale? a) Maximizes competitive tension b) Maintains confidentiality c) Minimizes potential “taint” d) Ensures all potential buyers are contacted Answer: B and C