Professional Documents
Culture Documents
tools
Share this story
As CNC router technology has emerged in the wood industry, there have been many
questions surrounding parameters of feed rate and RPM of tooling. The concepts are fairly
simple, but it is not surprising that many operations struggle with these questions once we
consider all the variables in machines, materials and tools.
In the metal working industry, tooling manufacturers are able to supply exact ‘chip load’
recommendations for every tool. However, steel milling applications are performed with far
fewer variables to consider. Material properties are relatively similar and generally more
consistent throughout the part. Fixturing and ‘hold down’ of parts is usually reliable and
consistent, resulting in minimal vibration or part movement. The existence of flood or misted
coolants also provides a critical advantage for cutting tool performance and longevity.
By comparison, wood machining applications are performed under far less consistent cutting
conditions. Extreme variation in material density and consistency make decisions regarding
cutting parameters very difficult. Furthermore, fixturing and hold down methods are less
consistent, which can lead to increased part/tool vibration or part movement. Very few wood
cutting applications allow for any type of coolant or misting to be used, which makes cutting
speeds a critical factor in preventing heat generation at the cutting edge. There are three
important variables that must be managed to prevent heat generation resulting in reduced tool
life.
The image above illustrates three variables that must be considered.
1) Number or flutes (wings)
2) Feed Rate (feed speed)
3) RPM (spindle speed)
The relationship between these three variables determines ‘chip load,’ which refers to the
actual physical size of chip being cut by each flute. Chip load is a critical factor that will dictate
the quality of cut and the life of the cutting tool.
IMPORTANT FORMULAS:
4) Chip Load = Feed Rate / (RPM x # of flutes)
5) Feed Rate (IMP)= RPM x # of flutes x chip load
6) Speed (RPM) = Feed Rate / (# of cutting edges x chip load).
There are numerous ‘chip load calculators’ available online, which are a useful tool for
machine programmers and operators. However, not all calculators con- sider all the variables
required to make the decision.
An Excel version of a chip load calculator Dedicated to CNC Spiral tooling can be
downloaded from: www.woodworkingcanada.com/spiralchip.
This calculator considers variables such as, depth of cut, tool geometry, and material density
and provides a moderate starting point for a CNC operator.
Obviously all the wood machining inconsistencies listed above make decisions about feed
rate and RPM more difficult than metalworking. We have established that there isn’t always a
black and white recommendation, but rather a set of guidelines that can help a machine
operator or programmer to make an informed decision. A logical process should involve the
following procedures:
If there are any questions regarding these concepts, contact your tooling or machine
supplier to ensure your machinery and tools are running at optimal feed rates and
RPM. If you require a copy of the ‘chip load calculator’ discussed in this article, feel
free to email me at: sburton@royceayr.com