Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION
SAG PJV recognized that the optimization of drill and blast practices to
maximize the productivity of mine and mill operations would contribute
2001 to its profitability. PJV and explosive supplier Dyno Nobel embarked on
this project with the goal of optimizing fragmentation for downstream
MINING AND MINERAL PROCESS ENGINEERING processes. The initial aim was to increase SAG mill throughput when
UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA milling hornblende diorite. The process is tonnage constrained on this
Vancouver, B. C., Canada ore. The JKMRC was sub-contracted to provide technical expertise.
Porgera Joint Venture is a gold mine located in the remote and rugged
Porgera Joint Venture (PJV) and Dyno Nobel initiated a project to highlands of Enga Province in Papua New Guinea (see Figure 1).
optimize drilling and blasting practices for downstream operations. The
SAG mill was identified as a production bottle neck when treating
hornblende diorite ore. Consequently, it was agreed that the project
would focus on optimizing the fragmentation size distribution for the
crushing and SAG milling circuits. The Julius Kruttschnitt Mineral
Research Centre (JKMRC) was sub-contracted to investigate the impact
of blasting on SAG mill throughput.
The operation employees about 2,000 people. The mine is operated by optimizing the blast design to achieve the results that maximize the
Placer Dome and produced over 900,000 oz of gold in calendar year overall profitability rather than individual operations.
2000.
Identification of each opportunity to increase process efficiency is very
The Porgera Gold Mine moves over 210,000 tonnes per day of material important to the success of the approach. Potential areas of impact
including about 18,000 tonnes of ore. Mobile equipment consists of 36 include, but are not limited to:
Cat 789 haul trucks, 8 Cat 777 haul trucks, 6 OK RH200’s, 2 Cat 992
loaders, 1 OK RH40, 3 Cat 16G graders, 3 Cat 824 wheel dozers and q Increase in comminution efficiency leading to higher mill throughput,
auxiliary contractor equipment. The mine runs 24 hours per day utilizing q Improvement in loader/excavator productivity due to better
3 shifts per day. diggability, and fill factors,
After blasting, the ore is loaded and hauled to the primary crusher or run- A typical mine to mill blast optimization project involves several phases
of-mine (ROM) stockpiles. At the primary crushing plant, the ore is such as:
reduced to minus 150 mm size material in a single pass through a
gyratory crusher to produce a SAG mill feed. 1. Scoping
2. Auditing
Apron feeders draw the crushed ore from a coarse ore stockpile to feed 3. Modeling and Simulations
two parallel primary grinding lines. Each line consists of a variable 4. Validation
speed SAG mill measuring 28 feet in diameter by 11 ft long. The mill 5. Implementation
motors are rated at 5,500 HP. At the discharge of each SAG mill is a
pair of vibrating screens. The screen oversize material from both SAG
mills is conveyed to a shared pebble crushing circuit consisting of two SCOPING
Omnicone crushers.
The mine to mill blast optimization project is interdisciplinary in nature
The SAG screen undersize from both SAG mills is pumped to a common and it impacts on several aspects of mining and milling operations. This
distributor where it is split to feed three parallel ball milling circuits. The means a team approach is required with members from the mine and
ball mills are in closed circuit with hydrocyclones. The grinding circuit the mill, and a project champion to drive the project. At Porgera, the
product measures 80% passing 106 microns and feeds the flotation initial scope of the mine to mill project was limited to maximizing the
plant. SAG mill throughput by altering blast design and crusher settings to
provide an optimum feed size distribution to the mills. Hornblende
A bulk flotation process using conventional cells produces a gold-bearing diorite was chosen for the study because it is the hardest ore at
sulphide (mainly pyrite) concentrate. The concentrate is thickened Porgera.
before it is pumped to the pressure oxidation circuit. Oxidized slurry is
re-circulated to destroy most of the carbonates prior to the concentrate The impact of blasting results on the efficiency of load and haul
being fed to four parallel autoclaves. In the autoclaves, the sulphides are operations was investigated, but the details of that study are not
decomposed to expose the gold. The autoclave discharge is cooled, covered in this paper. Likewise, the effect of blasting on ore body
thickened and washed. After pH adjustment, the oxidized slurry is dilution and damage to the pit walls will be studied separately.
cyanide leached in a leach/CIP circuit. The loaded carbon is stripped,
and the gold and silver are electrowon from the pregnant solution.
Bullion is poured on site. AUDITING
During this phase, an audit of all the processes from drilling and blasting
WHAT DOES A MINE TO MILL PROJECT INVOLVE? to milling was conducted. A trial blast (#340319) was conducted on
hornblende diorite in May 2000 with the standard design and the ore
The “Mine to Mill Blasting” approach involves identifying the leverage from this blast was processed through the mill without any blending.
that blast results have on different downstream processes and then During this trial all critical input and output parameters from drilling and
I-275 I-276
blasting to SAG milling were monitored, especially the size distribution of In this test the ore was broken in a range of sizes under a range of
ore from in situ to the final product of the grinding circuit. energies. The relationship between t10 and the specific breakage
energy is defined by Equation 1.
Rock / Ore Characterization
Generally ore domains are classified based on grade and geology and t10 = A (1- e-bEcs) (1)
do not take into account the breakage characteristics. The breakage
characteristics of rock /ore are very important for the design and where A and b = ore specific parameters,
optimization of any mine to mill process. Therefore, it is essential to Ecs = specific breakage energy (kWh/t),
understand these differences and characterize the rock mass in terms of t10 = percent passing 1/10th original particle size.
its blastability as well as comminution properties.
th
By convention, t10 is the percent passing 1/10 of the original particle
th
Blastability size, whilst the t50 is the percent passing 1/50 etc.
Blasting loosens the existing rock mass structure to liberate rock blocks Drill and Blast Audit
and creates new fractures within the intact material. Fines are produced
by the crushing action of the explosion in a zone that surrounds each drill A blast auditing exercise was undertaken to understand the
hole. Blastability is a function of mechanical properties of intact rock (eg. implementation of blast design, the explosive performance and to
stiffness and strength) and the rock mass structure (size of ‘insitu quantify fragmentation, throw and back break. The designs for the trial
blocks’). Zones within a mine that are of similar strength and structure blast and subsequent modified blasts are given in Table 1.
should blast in a similar way and hence form a blasting domain. It
should be recognized that the blasting domains may be different from the Table 1. Blast Design Parameters
current geological domains. Blast 340319 Blast 320314 Blast 310316
The structural characteristics of ore in the trial blast were estimated from (Bench mark) Oct 2000 Dec 2000
the scan line mapping and face photographs. The mean in situ block Bench height m 10 8.6 10
size was estimated to be between 0.5m to 0.6m.
Burden m 5.3 4.5 4.5
Cores from the ore samples collected from the trial blast were subjected
to various rock mechanic tests to measure the strength and stiffness Spacing m 6.3 5.5 5.5
properties. Rock samples were also subjected to point load testing to Hole depth m 10.6 9.1 10
estimate the strength.
Column height m 5.3 3.6 5.15
Comminution Characteristics
Stemming height m 5.3 5.7 4.7
The micro fracture network, grain size and grain characteristics may be Subdrilling m 0.6 0.5 0.5
important in comminution processes such as crushing and grinding. It is
necessary to understand the comminution properties of different ore Explosive Titan 4070 Titan 4070 Titan 4070
types to optimize the integrated mine-to-mill operation
Density 1.25 1.25 1.25
The JKMRC use a ‘drop weight test’ to determine the breakage VOD 5100 4900 -
characteristics of rocks. A detailed description of the tests for
determining the comminution properties is given by Napier-Munn et al RWS 80 80 80
(1996).
Powder factor kg/t 0.242 0.31 - 0.35 0.38
I-277 I-278
The actual blast design parameters such as hole depth, burden, spacing
and stemming height for each hole was measured and compared with
7 SAG mill scates
However in case of maintaining the drill depth, 20% of the holes were
either drilled 0.5m deeper or shorter than the design depth. This CV12
1 SAG
variation in the drilled depth causes either severe damage to the floor MILL
5
(excessive drilling) or leaves toe (short drilling) therefore producing an screen
sampling points
can result in oversize from the collar (excessive stemming) or in weightometers 4
CV108
Fragmentation Assessment SAG
MILL
6
screen
During this trial, photographs were taken of the muck piles and at the
rear of trucks while the ore is dumped at the primary crusher. These
photographs were analyzed with the Split image analysis system to
estimate the fragmentation size of ROM material. Approximately twenty Figure 2: Schematic of Porgera Primary Crushing and SAG milling
images from the muck piles and thirty five images from the rear of trucks Circuits with sampling points
were analyzed. The images taken at the primary crusher dump pocket
provided a better estimate of the ROM fragmentation size. This is After the steady state portion of the survey, the SAG mill circuit was
because the surface of the muck piles are not true representations of the crash stopped to collect samples from the belt conveyors, to allow
entire blast. inspection of the mill interior and to carry out load measurements.
Subsequently, the SAG mills were ground out to determine the ball
Mill Survey #1 load. Photographs were taken to estimate the rock and ball size
distribution of the muck load using the Split system.
The first survey was conducted on 28 May 2000 to provide a baseline of
current practice and performance. The blast (#340319) was un-modified Cameras were also installed to monitor the SAG feed conveyor belts for
and the primary crusher gap was set between 120 and 180 mm to subsequent feed size distribution determination using the Split imaging
maintain crusher throughput. system.
The ore from the trial blast was campaigned through the mill without any All samples were processed through the lab to determine % solids, and
blending and a full mill survey was conducted. SAG mill throughput was size distribution. Portions of the sized SAG mill feed were collected and
maximized at 673 dmtph of fresh feed. When the mill reached steady sent to JKMRC for drop weight and Bond Ball mill work index tests. The
state, samples were collected from various locations in the circuit every results of these ore characterization tests are summarized in Table 2.
15 minutes over a period of one hour. The major circuit variables were
also monitored and collected from the control system. Figure 2 page I- Table 2. Comminution Characteristics of Hornblende Diorite
278 illustrates the primary crushing and SAG milling circuits, and the
sampling locations. Survey Blast A b ta Wi (Kwh/t)
1 340-319 61.3 0.66 0.29 18
2 320-314 63.3 0.65 0.32 18.5
3 310-316 63.2 0.65 0.33 19.8
I-279 I-280
The results of the mill survey are summarized in Table 3. Mill survey #2 SAG Feed Size Distributions (Survey #1)
and #3 results are also shown; these will be discussed under their own
section. 100
90
survey 1, SAG 1
100
90
Survey #1
80
70
Survey #3
10 60
Survey 1, SAG 1 50
Survey 1, SAG 2 40
Survey 2, SAG 1
30
Survey 2, SAG 2
20
Survey 3, SAG 1
Survey 3, SAG 2
10
1 0
0 1 10 100 1,000
10 100 1,000 10,000 100,000
Size (mm)
1,000,000
Simulations were run to predict the influence of different blast designs on Figure 5: Effect of High Powder Factor on SAG Feed Size
SAG milling throughput. A tighter drill pattern was selected as the Distribution
method to increase the amount of fines in the SAG mill feed. The key The results of the mill survey were summarized in Table 3. The SAG
parameters of the blast designs were shown in Table 1. mill throughput with the modified design and no pebble crusher running
I-283 I-284
was only about 5% less than the benchmark throughput achieved with an higher during survey #2, probably due to the return of uncrushed scats
unmodified blast but a pebble crusher running. When the scats were to the mill which would enhance abrasion type breakage. This is
dumped to the ground, the SAG throughput increased by 48%. Mill consistent with survey #2 exhibiting a finer SAG mill product (smaller
throughput with a pebble crusher running would have been between 631 transfer size) to the ball milling circuit than survey #1 (See Figure 6).
and 935 dmtph for the feed size distribution achieved by this blast
design. The results of the two scenarios clearly demonstrate the
negative impact of uncrushed scats on SAG mill throughput. SAG Screen Undersize Size Distributions
100
Because the pebble crusher was unavailable, the following simulations
were run to compare the predicted and the actual throughput: 90
80
Simulations of the two scenarios during survey #2 predict throughputs In blast #310316 the powder factor achieved was very close to the
within about 5% of the actual results. The models predict that the mill design (design powder factor was 0.4 kg/t). The stemming height in the
throughput would have been 803 dmtph if the pebble crusher had been modified blast was reduced from 5.7m to 4.7m because some oversize
running. Furthermore, the simulations predict a throughput of only 530 blocks were noticed from the stemming region of the previous blast.
dmtph on the standard blast (#340319) with no pebble crusher,
compared to 673 dmtph (standard blast with a pebble crusher). The ore from this blast was campaigned through the mill. Unlike in
survey #1 or #2, there were no oversize blocks. From visual
Surveys #1 and #2 exhibited different breakage rate curves (see Figure observation the fragmentation looked very fine. The crusher ran with a
4) in the fines fraction. This is attributed to the different conditions in the 100 mm closed side setting and the power draw was consistent. There
mill. The breakage rate of particles less than 10 mm in size is much
I-285 I-286
were no crusher motor trips and the throughput was good with no because critical size material will occupy more mill volume and not
queuing of trucks at the crusher break efficiently. It is better to remove this material from the mill and
crush it. PJV are currently using grates with 75 mm openings.
A full mill survey was conducted and samples processed. As expected,
the SAG feed size distribution was finer than the baseline survey and Simulations were also run with several different SAG discharge screen
somewhat finer than what was achieved in survey #2 (see Figure 5). aperture sizes. The simulations suggested that SAG mill throughput
gains would be marginal by increasing the screen aperture dimensions.
The results of survey #3 were summarized in Table 3 along with the Also, the transfer size to the ball milling circuit would increase.
survey #1 and #2 results. During survey #3 a milling rate of 774 dmtph However, since each SAG mill has two parallel screens on its
was achieved. This represents a 15% increase in throughput compared discharge, one screen has been fitted with 12 mm aperture panels and
to the baseline (survey #1), and is also within 5% of the throughput the other unit with 15 mm aperture panels. This arrangement provides
predicted by the model. operating flexibility depending on the feed being milled and which part
of the grinding circuit is the bottleneck. So far the operating evidence
Ore characterization were performed and established the ore to be suggest that the ball milling circuit can handle the coarser transfer size
similar to the survey #1 and #2 material (refer to Table 2). from the SAG mill when the screen fitted with 15 mm aperture panels is
Consequently, the SAG mill throughput increase can be attributed to the run.
finer feed size distribution produced by the high powder factor of the
blast and tighter primary crusher setting. The choice of ball size is normally dictated by the hardness and size
distribution of the feed. The simulator predicts higher SAG throughputs
In general, the breakage rate curves were similar in shape to the with the 125 mm ball compared to the 150 mm ball. The 125 mm ball
previous surveys (see Figure 4). The breakage rate in the fines fraction can provide the necessary energy level to break the rocks. Since the
is somewhat less than for survey #2, which is expected since the scats number of 125 mm balls for a given volume is greater than for 150 mm
were crushed in survey #3. balls, the number of breakage events is more for the 125 mm ball (other
mill variables being equal). This translates into a higher breakage rate
The mill inspections once again showed that there was packing between with the 125 mm ball. Industrial trials are continuing to resolve this
the belly lifters. Mill trajectory simulations also indicate that some issue.
grinding balls are being thrown well over the toe of the charge. PJV is
now looking to optimize shell lifter design in terms of the face angle and According to simulations, SAG mill throughput can be increased by
number of lifter rows. running with a higher ball charge. However, the total (ball and rock)
charge would have to be reduced so as not to further exceed the motor
rating. A higher ball charge and lower rock load would tend to promote
MILL SIMULATIONS impact breakage and reduce the amount of abrasion breakage. These
factors would lead to a coarser transfer size. PJV is running the SAG
mills at approximately a 12% ball charge and the ball milling circuit is
The purpose of the “Mine-to-Mill” project was to determine the impact of not often constrained.
blasting on SAG mill feed size distribution and hence mill throughput. It
was also important to establish if the milling rate could be increased by The effect of the pebble crusher’s closed side setting (CSS) was also
making modifications to the operation of the existing circuit instead of simulated. Increasing the CSS does not appear to reduce the SAG
altering the feed size distribution. The effects of changing several major feed throughput by much. Nevertheless, the smallest CSS possible is
circuit variables were simulated. targeted without causing excessive crusher vibration. Bypassing of the
crusher does have a significant negative impact on SAG throughput as
Different grate size openings were simulated and the results indicated shown by survey #2 results and predictions.
that an opening smaller than 70 mm would be detrimental to SAG mill
throughput. This prediction is not surprising if the breakage rate curve is
examined (Figure 4); the 20 to 75 mm material does not break efficiently
in the SAG mill. A smaller grate opening will result in lower throughput
I-287 I-288
The “Mine-to-Mill” project is being implemented at Porgera. Hornblende The authors would like to thank the management of Porgera Joint
diorite is being blasted at the higher powder factor and mill throughput Venture, Dyno Nobel and JKMRC for their permission to present this
monitored. The blast design for hornblende diorite continues to be paper. We also wish to gratefully acknowledge all those who
refined. contributed to the work presented.
Optimization of waste blasting is being investigated. The high stripping 2. Jankovic, A., Valery, W., Kanchibotla, S. et al, 2001, “Mine-to-
ratio (10:1) at Porgera offers huge potential benefits. Mill Optimization at Porgera Gold Mine” Research Report, JKMRC
The impact of blasting at higher power factors on ore dilution and wall 3. Napier-Munn et al, 1996, Mineral Comminution Circuits, JKMRC
damage is also being investigated. Monograph Series in Mining and Mineral Processing, 2nd edition.
CONCLUSIONS
The Mine-to-Mill project has indicated that the milling rate of hornblende
diorite can be increased by improving the feed size distribution. From the
surveys, it is clear that the blast fragmentation has an impact on primary
crusher and mill performance. An increase in the powder factor of the
blast by tightening the drill pattern, and running the primary crusher at a
smaller closed side setting has resulted in a measured 15% increase in
the milling rate of hornblende diorite ore.
A model has been calibrated for hornblende diorite ore. This model has
been able to predict the circuit’s response to changes in feed size
distribution. Simulations also suggest that improving the feed size
distribution by optimizing the blast design will increase the SAG mill
throughput more than modifying the configuration of the existing circuit.