Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Key Ideas 4
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
In Depth 20
Test 22
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
3
Key Ideas
In this unit, we will focus on the identification of the topic and the main idea in a
passage or paragraph. Being able to understand and distinguish the difference
between the topic and the main idea in context is an essential strategy for deriving
the correct meaning of a message. Although both subjects relate to what is of central
importance in written or spoken language, they are not the same and can sometimes
be misinterpreted.
The content herein introduces information that will allow you to recognise, identify
and distinguish not only the topic from the main idea but also the topic sentence
from the supporting details in a text. These aspects will firstly be explained and then
backed by examples and some practical exercises.
These skills will be extremely useful to you as a translator because they will help you
to improve your comprehension of the original texts; this, in turn, will help you with
direct translations.
A paragraph is a group of related sentences that develop a main idea about a topic.
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
The structure of a paragraph includes three basic elements: a topic, a main idea or
topic sentence, and supporting details.
The topic is the general theme that the person responsible is going to discuss
throughout his paper or speech.
The main idea is the most important point that the author wants to present based
on that topic. The author develops the main idea through the passage by introducing
major and minor details that add new information to the text. These details are
needed to support the main idea. For example:
In the above passage, we can identify that the topic is Androgenic Alopecia.
We can also distinguish that the main idea discussed is that Androgenetic alopecia
is the most common form of alopecia.
We can see as well that the main idea is supported by the following two major
details: that Androgenetic alopecia is the result of genetics, aging, and hormonal
changes and that when these changes combine, they can cause changes in the hair
follicle.
In addition, note that in this case each major detail is at the same time supported
by a minor detail: that these changes in the hair follicle result in the
miniaturization of the terminal hair into vellus hair.
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
Occasionally, the main idea is expressed in a topic sentence. When the topic
sentence is written at the beginning of the text, the following sentences are used to
explain, support, or give details about the main idea. For example:
In this segment, taken from The New York Times, we can identify that the main idea
is expressed in the first sentence which is, at the same time, the topic sentence:
Also, notice that this topic sentence is supported by major details that provide
additional information to the reader. In this case, the author backs his main idea by
offering his own “metaphorical” definition of what good editing should be: It is what
separates hastily written, randomly punctuated, incoherent rants from learned
polemics and op-eds, …
At the same time, this definition is reinforced by a minor detail: … and cringe-worthy
fan fiction from a critically acclaimed novel.
In occasions, the topic sentence is written in the middle of the text. In those cases,
the preceding sentences behave as an introduction and the following as supporting
details. For example:
“No one wants to suffer a heart attack. A new study reports that doctors
have a new drug to reduce its risks. This drug is called statins. It may be
better than any other drug to protect you from heart attacks.” (Calman,
2019).
In this example, we can see that the main idea is expressed in the second sentence:
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
A new study reports that doctors have a new drug to reduce its risks.
Also, in this case, the first sentence is used to introduce the main idea: No one wants
to suffer a heart attack.
It may be better than any other drug to protect you from heart attacks. (Minor detail.)
There are also cases when the topic sentence is written at the end of the passage. In
those cases, the preceding sentences are used to introduce or clarify the main idea.
For example:
“Attention, fast food devotees. If the start of a new year were not enough
to make you change your eating habits, the results of new research might
be. A long-term study has specifically linked consumption of fast food to
obesity and type 2 diabetes.” (Wrong, 2005).
In the above passage, we can see that the main idea is expressed in the last sentence:
A long-term study has specifically linked consumption of fast food to obesity and
type 2 diabetes.
Also observe that the two sentences that precede are used to introduce and support
that central idea: Attention, fast food devotees. (Introduction.) If the start of a new
year were not enough to make you change your eating habits, the results of new
research might be. (Supporting detail.)
Nevertheless, sometimes both the topic and the main idea in a passage are not
clearly stated in just one sentence: they are only implied. Therefore, to figure out an
implied topic or main idea, you must look at the supporting details. For example:
“Experts across Europe had warned that closing countries to contain the
coronavirus pandemic would be far easier than opening them up again.
More and more, that is looking to be true.” (Cohen, 2020)
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
In this extract taken from the New York Times, the main idea is not explicitly stated
and must be deciphered or inferred by looking at the supporting details. In this
example, we can see two detailed sentences that give support to each other: Experts
across Europe had warned that closing countries to contain the coronavirus
As a translator, you have to be aware of the fact that finding the implied main idea is
not always easy. In those cases, analysing what the major and the minor details of
the passage have in common is the best strategy to figuring it out. Once you look for
similarities, you will be able to summarize the passage and state the main idea in your
own words. Therefore, to decipher the implicit main idea you must skim the passage
of the text and then look for key words and related ideas. You can ask yourself the
following question:
Then again, in your own words, you must state the common relationship among the
details of the passage and the author's point of view about this relationship. After
that, you will be able to create a concise sentence expressing the central idea that
the author wants to transmit without altering the meaning of the message that
comes from the original source.
As you already know, the topic is the general subject of an entire passage. Here we
present two extracts. Read them and select the best topic from the options provided.
Ask yourself the following questions and justify your answer using your own words:
What is the topic of the text?
Why is this the topic of the text?
What does the author want to transmit?
Text 1
The first people to grow coffee beans lived in the Middle East. The Persians,
Arabs and Turks were drinking coffee many hundreds of years ago. Then, in
the 1600s, Europeans learned about coffee. They quickly learned to like it.
Soon there were coffee houses in many European cities. Europeans took
coffee with them when they travelled to new countries. That is how people
in other parts of the world learned about coffee. Now coffee is extremely
popular in North and South America, in Africa and in parts of Asia.
In this case the correct answer is letter A. The history of coffee. As you can see, the
writer presents a chronological description of how coffee has been grown and
introduced throughout the different continents. The other alternatives are not the
best for the following reasons: option B is too narrow as it specifically talks about
coffee houses in Europe, while options C and D are too broad as they both mention
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
Now read text 2 and analyse it. Try to justify your answer and compare it with the
solution below.
All around the world large cities have the same problem: air pollution. Air
pollution is not a new issue for Mexico City: in 1992, the United Nations
named Mexico City’s air as the most polluted on the planet. The city has
improved its air quality in recent years but the improvement has caused the
government to ease up on quality control.
In this case, the correct answer is letter B. Mexico City’s air pollution. The writer gives
details regarding the problematic situation of air pollution in Mexico City. The other
alternatives are not the best options for the following reasons: option A is too narrow
as it talks about problems in big cities, while options C and D are too broad because
they refer to either life in Mexico City or air pollution as general topics.
Now read text 3 and analyse it. Try to justify your answer and compare it with the
solution below.
Text 3
“The coronavirus has killed so many people in Iran that the country has
resorted to mass burials, but in neighbouring Iraq, the body count is fewer
than 100. The Dominican Republic has reported nearly 7,600 cases of the
virus. Just across the border, Haiti has recorded about 85. In Indonesia,
thousands are believed to have died of the coronavirus. In nearby Malaysia,
a strict lockdown has kept fatalities to about 100. The coronavirus has
touched almost every country on earth, but its impact has seemed
capricious. Global metropolises like New York, Paris and London have been
devastated, while teeming cities like Bangkok, Baghdad, New Delhi and
Lagos have, so far, largely been spared.” (Beech, 2020).
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
A. The coronavirus
B. Mass burials in neighbourhoods
C. The Covid-19 puzzle
D. Genetic differences in global metropolises
As already discussed, the main idea is the most important point that the author wants
to present regarding their topic. Here we present two extracts. Read them and select
the main idea from the options provided. Ask yourself the following questions:
What is the main idea of the text?
Why is this the main idea of the text?
Text 1
Vitamin E can be found in several foods. Vegetable oils, margarine, eggs, and
liver are especially good sources. This vitamin plays a role in the prevention
of certain blood disorders. It helps to prevent cell membranes from being
destroyed by substances that build up around the membranes and cause
them to break down. These substances tend to increase in quantity as a
person grows older. For this reason, vitamin E has been suggested as a
remedy for the effects of aging. However, doctors and researchers are still
studying the vitamin to find out if there is any real connection.
In this case the best alternative that encompasses the main idea is letter A. vitamin
E may help to reverse the aging process. As you can see, the writer presents detailed
arguments to support the implied idea that the consumption of vitamin E may
Now read text 2 and do the same thing as before: analyse it, justify your answer, and
compare it with the solution below.
Text 2
“Legends make children dream of princesses riding bare back through fields
of fragrant heather. They immortalize noble knights, champions for
humanity, who fought tyranny as they raced through a village with swords
brandished and banners waving in the afternoon breeze. Legends awaken
imagination in the young and spur creativity in the old. The famous and
trustworthy story of King Arthur is one of those great legends made famous
through repeated telling. According to the stories about King Arthur, he was
a man of valour, integrity, and honour in the face of challengers. He strove
to lead all of England down the path of goodness and prosperity without any
foolish moves or attacks of cowardice. Although he supposedly did all these
wonderful things, nobody knows how this legend came to be and some even
debate that he was once alive”. (Roell, 2019)
Which of the following statements best expresses the main idea of the paragraph?
A. King Arthur's legends have been inspirational for both the old and the young.
B. Legends, like that of King Arthur, can be inspirational despite their muddled
beginnings or deficient proof.
C. Legends can inspire both the young and the old.
D. Legends, like that of King Arthur, are inspirational to those who want to
believe in fairy tales.
The topic of this passage is Legends. In this case, the best option that paraphrases
the main idea is letter B. Legends, like that of King Arthur, can be inspirational despite
their muddled beginnings or deficient proof. As you can see, the author presents
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
supporting details to reinforce the idea that the story behind the existence of King
Arthur is a popular legend that has inspired many people, even though his existence
is still not verifiable. Option A is too narrow: it only mentions King Arthur's legend
and not legends in general, which is the topic of the text. Option C is too broad: it
Text 3
“The idea that women are not equal to men has been a prevailing and
common theme in literature since the beginning of time. Like their
predecessors, Renaissance writers staunchly laid down the tenet that
women were less valuable throughout the pages of effusive literary writings,
where women are alternately idolized as virtuous or shunned as harlots. One
man proved to be a glaring contradiction to this falsity. That man was
William Shakespeare and he had the courage in those turbulent days to
recognize the value and equality of women. His portrayal of women differed
from that of many of his contemporaries during the Renaissance era.” (Roell,
2019).
In this previous example, the topic discussed is the status of women in Renaissance
times. It emphasises how Shakespeare’s position on this issue differed from most
other writers during this period. The details that support the main idea are implicitly
stated in the last sentence: His portrayal of women differed from that of many of his
contemporaries during the Renaissance era. Therefore, if we look at the supporting
details, the main idea could be paraphrased as follows: Although most Renaissance
writers had the belief that women were not equal with men, Shakespeare's writings
portrayed women as equal to men.
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
As already discussed, the main idea is usually expressed in a topic sentence and the
other sentences in the text are used to support that idea. Here we present two
extracts. Read them and identify the topic sentence of the text. Ask yourself the
following questions and justify your answers using your own arguments:
Which is the topic sentence of the passage?
Why is this the topic sentence? Where is it located?
Is it explicitly stated or does it have to be inferred?
Text 1
In this case the topic sentence is the first one: Modern man often seems as
superstitious as his ancestors. Notice that the main idea is presented at the beginning
of the paragraph and this idea is expressed through this topic sentence. The following
sentences are used to explain and give details that support that main idea.
Text 2
In this case the topic sentence is the last one: English is a language that borrows
freely from many sources. Notice here that the main idea is previously supported by
detailed examples. These examples help us to conclude what is expressed in the last
sentence of the passage.
Finding details
As already explained, the author uses details to support the main idea. Details are
more specific than the topic or the main idea. Here we present two extracts. Read
them and identify the details. Ask yourself the following questions:
What is the author’s main idea?
What details are needed to support the main idea?
Text 1
“For the past few months, public health officers have been inflexible in their
posture that healthy people should not wear masks to protect themselves
from coronavirus.
However, with new information about how the virus is spread — potentially
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
through the air and by people with no symptoms — the Centre for Disease
Control and Prevention on Friday recommended that everyone wear
nonmedical face coverings in public settings.” (Parker-Pope, 2020).
For the past few months, public health officers have been inflexible in their
posture that healthy people should not wear masks to protect themselves
from coronavirus.
Notice, that this main idea is supported by two important details that at the same
time support each other. They are used to back up the fact that right now people
must wear masks in public places due to the way the coronavirus spreads in the
environment. See Details 1 and 2 below.
Detail 1
However, with new information about how the virus is spread — potentially
through the air and by people with no symptoms
Detail 2
Now read text 2 and analyse it. Find the main idea and identify the details which
support it.
Text 2
“If you’re like most people right now, you are spending a lot of time in front
of screens. This makes sense: In a time of social distancing, screens have
become our portals to the outside world. But how much screen time is too
much? And is screen-life balance even possible (or relevant) right now, given
how much of life is now taking place online? In short, yes, it’s possible — and
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
Main Idea
Throughout the text, the author develops her argument and presents supporting
ideas or details to back up the fact that we are spending more time than ever before
in front of screens and that it is necessary to create a balance. Have a look at Details
1, 2 and 3 below.
Detail 1
People are spending a lot of time in front of screens.
Detail 2
In a time of social distancing, screens have become our portals to the outside
world.
Detail 3
… creating it is more important than ever, precisely because we are spending
so much time on screens.
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
Beech, Hannah, Rubin, Alissa J., Kurmanaev, Anatoly and Maclean, Ruth. 2020 “The
Covid-19 Riddle: Why Does the Virus Wallop Some Places and Spare Others?”. The
New York Times. Updated Sept 25, 2020.
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/03/world/asia/coronavirus-spread-where-
why.html
Cohen, Nadia Shira. 2020. “Nations confront the possibility that reopening may be
harder than locking down.” The New York Times. Update May, 8, 2020
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/03/world/coronavirus-news.html?type=styln-
liveupdates&label=global&index=1&action=click&module=Spotlight&pgtype=Home
page#link-7d1e0ed1
Grabe, William, and Cui Zhang. 2016. Reading-writing relationships in first and second
language academic literacy development. Language Teaching 49, (3) (07): 339-355.
Topic and main idea: Clearing up the confusion. 1991. The Reading Teacher 45, (3)
(11): 252.
Guinness, Harry. 2020. “How to Edit Your Own Writing.” The New York Times. Update
Abril 10, 2020. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/07/smarter-living/how-to-edit-
your-own-writing.html
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
Parker-Pope, Tara. 2020. “Should I Start Wearing a Mask?”. The New York Times. May
7, 2020. https://www.nytimes.com/article/coronavirus-N95-mask-DIY-face-mask-
health.html?auth=login-facebook
Roell, Kelly. 2019 "Find the Main Idea Worksheets and Practice Questions."
ThoughtCo. Update July 05, 2019. https://www.thoughtco.com/find-the-main-idea-
worksheets-3211754
Topic and main idea: Clearing up the confusion. 1991. The Reading Teacher 45, (3)
(11): 252.
Wong, Kate. 2005. “Fast Food Linked to Obesity, Diabetes,” Scientific American.
January 3, 2005. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fast-food-linked-to-
obesi/
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
Grammar Songs by Melissa, “Main Idea,” Youtube video, 6:18. Nov 17, 2019.
https://youtu.be/mkZo2zVKJR4
This video gives us information about the topic, main idea, and supporting details in
paragraphs. It explains how good readers locate these essential components of basic
comprehension. The video also explains how the main idea should be supported with
meaningful details in the writing process.
Khan Academy, “What is a main Idea? Reading. Khan Academy” Youtube video: 5:13.
March 27, 2020.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=10&v=4swFGRhQoMI&feature=emb
_title&ab_channel=KhanAcademy
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
Townsend Press, “Lesson 3. Implied main ideas”, Youtube video: 6:42. August 28, 2014.
https://youtu.be/1IilfIagSko
As you have seen, the main idea may be clearly stated in one sentence of a selection.
However, as you know, the main idea is sometimes implied—and not clearly stated
in one sentence. The reader must infer such an implied main idea by considering the
© Universidad Internacional de La Rioja (UNIR)
supporting details.
A. The cougar.
B. Mammals of the Western Hemisphere.
C. Endangered species.
D. European colonists.