Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
ScienceDirect
With a wide variety of techniques and compatible materials, material, and quantity. Small quantities can be printed at a
three-dimensional (3D) printing is becoming increasingly useful relatively low cost using simple methods such as fused
in environmental applications in air, water, and energy. Through deposition modeling. Still, mass-production, especially
the advantages of quick production, cost-effectiveness, with more complex printing methods, has not been widely
customizable design, the ability to produce complex implemented due to high costs [2]. Some additional
geometries, and more, 3D printing has supported challenges to the widespread use of 3D printing include
improvements to air quality monitors, filters, membranes, the limited ability to produce large structures, print defects,
separation devices for water treatment, microbial fuel cells, and low selection of compatible materials [2]. Addressing
solar cells, and wind turbines. It also supports sustainable these challenges can help to increase the potential applica-
manufacturing through reduced material waste, energy use, tions of 3D printing.
and carbon emissions. Applications of 3D printing within four
environmental disciplines are described in this article: As new fabrication methods and printable materials
sustainable manufacturing, air quality, water and wastewater, continue to be developed, 3D printing is becoming
and alternative energy sources. progressively useful in a diversity of applications, includ-
ing the automotive, aircraft, medical, food, and robotics
industries. Some environmental uses of this technology
Addresses
1 have been developed for air, water, and energy. Although
Water Infrastructure Division, Chemical Methods and Treatments
Branch, Center for Environmental Solutions and Emergency Response, most of these are small, individual devices for sampling,
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 26 West Martin Luther King sensing, or separating [3], these early applications dem-
Drive, Cincinnati, OH, 45268, USA onstrate that 3D printing has the potential to make
2
Department of Chemical and Environmental Engineering, University of significant impacts within environmental applications in
Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH, 45221, United States
the future. As the challenges within 3D printing are
Corresponding author: further researched and addressed, the technology is likely
Nadagouda, Mallikarjuna N (Nadagouda.mallikarjuna@epa.gov) to bring improvements to separation devices, sensors,
alternative energy technologies, and more. Additionally,
3D printing supports sustainable manufacturing by
Current Opinion in Chemical Engineering 2020, 28:173–178
reducing waste, energy demand, and carbon emissions.
This review comes from a themed issue on Materials engineering: This article describes four broad areas of environmental
principles and technologies in additive manufacturing
applications that are benefitting from advancements in
Edited by MN Nadagouda, JA Sekhar and T Kyu 3D printing: sustainable manufacturing, air quality, water
For a complete overview see the Issue and the Editorial and wastewater, and alternative energy sources. These
Available online 6th September 2020 areas are outlined in Figure 1.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.coche.2020.08.002
2211-3398/Published by Elsevier Ltd. Sustainable manufacturing
3D printing offers a new approach to manufacturing that
changes environmental implications throughout the
entire product life cycle and increases the potential for
sustainability. Resource demands and manufacturing
waste can be significantly reduced because additive
Introduction manufacturing builds products layer-by-layer rather than
Three-dimensional (3D) printing is a method of producing cutting away from a larger volume. Conventional produc-
three-dimensional objects by joining materials layer-by- tion requires raw material to be altered and formed into a
layer under the direction of a computer. The development product through subtractive processes, which inherently
of computer-aided 3D modeling technology supported the create waste [4]. Because 3D printing is an additive
emergence of 3D printing in the 1980s [1]. This technology process, scraps are not produced. The only material losses
allows for more customizable products, complex structures, are generally support structures printed with the product
and lightweight design. It also offers the advantages of which are cut out following production, and these materi-
speed, flexibility, sustainability, risk reduction, and acces- als can be reused in most 3D printing methods [5]. 3D
sibility. Cost is cited as both an advantage and disadvantage printing also reduces waste from defects [4]. This
of 3D printing as it depends on the printing technique, resource efficiency reduces material-related energy
EcoPrinting system worked effectively, demonstrating filters and scrubbers for the removal of pollutants. Xu et al.
promising developments in 3D printing by both operating [18] developed a flexible air filter from a 3D printed grid
without electrical connection and by using collected ABS that acts as a photocatalyst to remove NO from the air. 3D
plastic waste as the printing material. printing facilitated the sophisticated interior of the filter
and allowed the product to be scalable for other applica-
tions [18]. The filter was optimized experimentally and
Air quality
through simulation, and the final product obtained 52.6%
3D printing can be used to develop instrumentation for
NO conversion [18]. Scrubber components can also be
air quality monitoring. Salamone et al. [14] used 3D
produced via 3D printing, such as the circular channel of
printing to produce a nano environmental monitoring
the Vortecone scrubber used by Kumar et al. [19]. In this
system, nEMoS, to quantify indoor air quality. nEMoS,
application, 3D printing offered the advantage of produc-
shown in Figure 2, was designed using low-cost sensors
ing the unique geometry of a curved surface.
and an Arduino board housed in a 3D printed case to be
inexpensive and give consistent data [14]. It reports CO2
concentration in addition to lighting levels, airspeed,
Water and wastewater
Advancements have supported a variety of techniques for
radiant temperature, air temperature, and relative humid-
water and wastewater treatment in 3D printing, including
ity [14]. Under controlled conditions, nEMoS gave read-
developments to membranes. Membrane technology is
ings within 5% of those by commercial tools [14]. Casings
replacing many conventional methods for treatment
for other monitors, including iAir for indoor air quality
because it is cost-effective and highly efficient [20].
[15] and the HOPE sensor for outdoor air quality [16]
Because 3D printing supports designs with multiple
have also benefitted from the customization capabilities
levels of hierarchy, it has the potential for use in mem-
of 3D printing. Wang et al. [17] developed another per-
brane production [20] and can offer a lower-cost alterna-
sonal monitor using 3D printing, but for particulate
tive to traditional membranes [21]. 3D printing works
matter. This was intended to be small, portable, and
well with ceramic membrane-based treatment materials
wearable for work and health-related environments
[22] but is limited because printers cannot efficiently
[17]. Their system was printed using a digital light
print below submicron resolution [20]. Another limitation
projection method and features microchannels that sepa-
is that only certain materials are compatible with specific
rate the incoming aerosol particles by mass and size [17].
3D printing techniques [22], and not all will provide
Once separated, the mass concentration of the aerosol
desired membrane characteristics such as wettability
particles is measured by capacitance sensors [17]. The
[20]. The development of new materials for 3D printed
system developed by Wang et al. demonstrates progress
membranes and increased strength are topics for future
toward more accurate miniaturized sensors [17]. 3D print-
research to support their improved performance [21].
ing technologies facilitated the smaller design of their
Akowanou et al. [23] demonstrated the viability of 3D
system.
printed ceramic water filters.
In addition to producing instruments to detect air pollu-
Similarly, the ceramic meshes developed by Chen et al.
tion, 3D printing can be used to create devices such as
[24] to separate oil and water were 3D printed and
combined with aluminum borate whiskers that grew in
Figure 2 situ. 3D printing allowed the team to develop different,
complex internal structures optimized for three specific
situations. Another device for oil/water separation, a
superhydrophilic membrane, was developed by Li et al.
[25] and printed using direct inkjet writing. The ceramic
mesh and superhydrophilic membrane both performed
with high separation efficiency, demonstrating the poten-
tial for future 3D printed separation devices.
Figure 4
(a) (c)
(b)
A printed turbine blade (a), blade connection to the hub (b), and printed rotor in operation (c) (taken from Ref. [35]).
dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs). DSSCs collect sun- Improvements in production speed, the scaling-up of
light using dye molecules that are adsorbed to the surface printing processes, and the development of materials
of oxide semiconductors [31]. These thin films are compatible with a variety of 3D printing techniques will
generally produced using random assembly sintering provide even more opportunities for environmental
processes, but Knott et al. [31] used a two-photon poly- applications.
merization 3D printing method. This gave a higher level
of control and allowed them to implement light scattering
designs, which enhanced the cell’s photocurrent up to Disclaimer
25% [31]. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency funded and
collaborated in the work described here. It has been
Additionally, 3D printing is being used to produce parts subjected to the Agency’s review and has been approved
for wind energy applications. Momeni et al. [32] printed for publication. Note that approval does not signify that
turbine blades to mimic plant leaves. The unique geom- the contents necessarily reflect the views of the Agency.
etry was made possible by the printing process and Mention of trade names, products, or services does not
reduced strain within the blades. A self-heating mesh convey official EPA approval, endorsement, or
for blade de-icing was developed by Ming et al. [33] and recommendation.
produced using 3D printing to enhance turbine perfor-
mance. Functional small-scale wind turbines have even Conflict of interest statement
been built for residential use using 3D printing. A turbine Nothing declared.
designed by Davis et al. [34] was printed from ABS plastic
and equipped with a generator and bearings for a total cost
of 21.63 USD. It could generate 0.2 kW, useful for Funding
charging 12 to 24-volt batteries, or as part of an array None.
for residential electricity generation. Lipian et al. [35] also
produced a small-scale wind turbine rotor using 3D
References and recommended reading
printing for its quick production abilities. The compo- Papers of particular interest, published within the period of review,
nents of the turbine are shown in Figure 4. The ‘fast have been highlighted as:
track’ method presented in the study may help to simplify of special interest
and expedite experimental aerodynamics in the future, as of outstanding interest
3D printing can produce a prototype within a day. 3D
printing offers the advantages of speed, low cost, and the 1. Savini A, Savini GG: A short history of 3D printing, a
technological revolution just started. 2015 ICOHTEC/IEEE
ability to form complex shapes to support improvements International History of High-technologies and their Socio-cultural
to wind turbines and their parts. Contexts Conference (HISTELCON); IEEE: 2015:1-8.
2. Ngo TD, Kashani A, Imbalzano G, Nguyen KTQ, Hui D: Additive
Conclusion and perspectives manufacturing (3D printing): a review of materials, methods,
applications and challenges. Compos Part B Eng 2018, 143:172-
As 3D printing becomes more prominent, it has presented 196.
new opportunities for sustainable manufacturing, air pol- 3. Hu L, Jiang G: 3D printing techniques in environmental science
lution monitoring and filtering, water treatment, and and engineering will bring new innovation. Environ Sci Technol
renewable energy. While there are trade-offs between 2017, 51:3597-3599.
different printing techniques and materials, the technol- 4. Ghobadian A, Talavera I, Bhattacharya A, Kumar V, Garza-
Reyes JA, Regan N: Examining legitimatisation of additive
ogy generally reduces waste compared to traditional manufacturing in the interplay between innovation, lean
manufacturing methods. It also brings the benefit of more manufacturing and sustainability. Int J Prod Econ 2020,
219:457-468.
customized design, enabling innovations like light- If more widely adopted, additive manufacturing may help to significantly
scattering designs in solar cells and the optimization of reduce or eliminate waste. The authors pose five propositions to advance
oil–water separation devices for a variety of situations. legitimation of the technology.
Increases in surface area, and therefore performance, of 5. Gebler M, Uiterkamp A, Visser C: A global sustainability
perspective on 3D printing technologies. Energy Policy 2014,
microbial fuel cells and floating photocatalysts were pos- 74:158-167.
sible because of high-resolution printing techniques.
6. Folk E: How Sustainable is 3D Printing? 2019. 3Dprint.com.
Other intricate designs facilitated by 3D printing include
the flexible air filter and microchannels within the 7. Abdulrahman KO, Akinlabi ET, Mahamood RM: Laser metal
deposition technique: sustainability and environmental
personal particulate matter sensor. impact. Procedia Manuf 2018, 21:109-116.
8. DePalma K, Walluk MR, Murtaugh A, Hilton J, McConky S,
Additionally, printed products can be designed to be Hilton B: Assessment of 3D printing using fused deposition
lightweight and portable, which are essential design modeling and selective laser sintering for a circular economy.
J Clean Prod 2020, 264:12.
considerations for floating photocatalysts and personal
9. Faludi J, Hu Z, Alrashed S, Braunholz C, Kaul S, Kassaye L: Does
air quality monitoring systems. The cost was kept low material choice drive sustainability of 3D printing? Int J Mech
in some systems but is an area for improvement in others. Mechatron Eng 2015, 9:216-223.
10. Suarez L, Dominguez M: Sustainability and environmental 23. Akowanou AVO, Deguenon HEJ, Groendijk L, Aina MP, Yao BK,
impact of fused deposition modelling (FDM) technologies. Int J Drogui P: 3D-printed clay-based ceramic water filters for
Adv Manuf Technol 2020, 106:1267-1279. point-of-use water treatment applications. Prog Addit Manuf
2019, 4:315-321.
11. Kim Y, Yoon C, Ham S, Park J, Kim S, Kwon O, Tsai PJ: Emissions
of nanoparticles and gaseous material from 3D printer 24. Chen Z, Zhang DW, Peng E, Ding J: 3D-printed ceramic
operation. Environ Sci Technol 2015, 49:12044-12053. structures with in situ grown whiskers for effective oil/water
separation. Chem Eng J 2019, 373:1223-1232.
12. Chan FL, Hon CY, Tarlo SM, Rajaram N, House R: Emissions and
health risks from the use of 3D printers in an occupational 25. Li X, Shan H, Zhang W, Li B: 3D printed robust superhydrophilic
setting. J Toxicol Environ Health Part A 2020, 83:279-287. and underwater superoleophobic composite membrane for
high efficient oil/water separation. Sep Purif Technol 2020,
13. Mohammed MI, Wilson D, Gomez-Kervin E, Rosson L, Long J, 237:116324.
IEEE: EcoPrinting: Investigation of Solar Powered Plastic
Recycling and Additive Manufacturing for Enhanced Waste 26. de Vidales MJM, Nieto-Marquez A, Morcuende D, Atanes E,
Management and Sustainable Manufacturing. 6th IEEE Blaya F, Soriano E, Fernandez-Martinez F: 3D printed floating
Conference on Technologies for Sustainability Technologies photocatalysts for wastewater treatment. Catal Today 2019,
(SusTech) Nov 11-13; Long Beach, CA: IEEE: 2018:249-254. 328:157-163.
EcoPrinting technology uses waste plastic as source material and is A floating photocatalyst was developed using 3D printing technology by
powered by a solar charging battery system, giving it a near-zero carbon combining LDPE with photocatalyst TiO2. The resulting product was
footprint. This system was used for humanitarian aid in the Solomon lightweight and able to float on water to use UV radiation as an activator.
Islands.
27. Bernasconi R, Carrara E, Hoop M, Mushtaq F, Chen XZ,
14. Salamone F, Belussi L, Danza L, Ghellere M, Meroni I: Design and Nelson BJ, Pane S, Credi C, Levi M, Magagnin L: Magnetically
development of nEMoS, an all-in-one, low-cost, web- navigable 3D printed multifunctional microdevices for
connected and 3d-printed device for environmental analysis. environmental applications. Addit Manuf 2019, 28:127-135.
Sensors 2015, 15:13012-13027.
28. Calignano F, Tommasi T, Manfredi D, Chiolerio A: Additive
15. Marques G, Pitarma R: A cost-effective air quality supervision manufacturing of a microbial fuel cell-A detailed study. Sci Rep
solution for enhanced living environments through the internet 2015, 5:10.
of things. Electronics 2019, 8.
29. Bian B, Shi D, Cai XB, Hu MJ, Guo QQ, Zhang CH, Wang Q,
16. Rebeiro-Hargrave A, Motlagh NH, Varjonen S, Lagerspetz E,
Sun AX, Yang J: 3D printed porous carbon anode for enhanced
Nurmi P, Tarkoma S: MegaSense: cyber-physical system for
power generation in microbial fuel cell. Nano Energy 2018,
real-time urban air quality monitoring. 2020 15th IEEE
44:174-180.
Conference on Industrial Electronics and Applications (ICIEA)
2020. 30. Ruiz-Morales JC, Tarancon A, Canales-Vazquez J, Mendez-
17. Wang Y, Valega Mackenzie F, Ingenhut B, Boersma A: Ramos J, Hernandez-Afonso L, Acosta-Mora P, Rueda JRM,
Miniaturized 3D printed particulate matter sensor for personal Fernandez-Gonzalez R: Three dimensional printing of
monitoring. 17th International Meeting on Chemical Sensors; components and functional devices for energy and
Vienna, Austria: 2018:402-403. environmental applications. Energy Environ Sci 2017, 10:846-
859.
18. Xu X, Xiao SN, Willy HJ, Xiong T, Borayek R, Chen W, Zhang DQ,
Ding J: 3D-printed grids with polymeric photocatalytic system 31. Knott A, Makarovskiy O, O’Shea J, Wu YP, Tuck C: Scanning
as flexible air filter. Appl Catal B Environ 2020, 262:9. photocurrent microscopy of 3D printed light trapping
3Dprinting was used to produce a flexible photocatalytic air filter for NO structures in dye-sensitized solar cells. Sol Energy Mater Sol
removal from the air. Because the filter was printed, it was designed with a Cells 2018, 180:103-109.
complex interior structure and is scalable for other applications. 3D printing supports a high level of control in the production of thin films
for dye-sensitized solar cells, allowing for the implementation of light-
19. Kumar AR, Levy A, Kumar A, Schafrik S, Novak T: Computational scattering designs to improve performance.
fluid dynamics modeling and laboratory analysis of aerosol
particles’ capture on thin swirling water film in a Vortecone. 32. Momeni F, Sabzpoushan S, Valizadeh R, Morad MR, Liu X, Ni J:
Powder Technol 2020, 361:499-506. Plant leaf-mimetic smart wind turbine blades by 4D printing.
Renew Energy 2019, 130:329-351.
20. Tijing LD, Dizon JRC, Ibrahim I, Nisay ARN, Shon HK,
Advincula RC: 3D printing for membrane separation, 33. Ming Y, Duan Y, Zhang S, Zhu Y, Wang B: Self-heating 3D printed
desalination and water treatment. Appl Mater Today 2020, continuous carbon fiber/epoxy mesh and its application in
18:22. wind turbine deicing. Polym Test 2020, 82:106309.
21. Issac MN, Kandasubramanian B: Review of manufacturing 34. Davis MS, Madani MR: 3D-printing of a functional small-scale
three-dimensional-printed membranes for water treatment. wind turbine. 6th International Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Environ Sci Pollut Res 2020, 27:36091-36108. Conference (IRSEC) Dec 05-08; Rabat, MOROCCO: IEEE:
2018:410-415.
22. Dommati H, Ray SS, Wang JC, Chen SS: A comprehensive
review of recent developments in 3D printing technique for 35. Lipian M, Kulak M, Stepien M: Fast track integration of
ceramic membrane fabrication for water purification. RSC Adv computational methods with experiments in small wind
2019, 9:16869-16883. turbine development. Energies 2019, 12.