Comments Response Sheet (CRS) : Project No / Title LTC/C/NFE/3945/18 - NORTH FIELD EAST PROJECT Onshore LNG Facilities

Comments Response Sheet (CRS) Project No / Title LTC/C/NFE/3945/18 - NORTH FIELD EAST PROJECT Onshore LNG Facilities
PROJECT DOCUMENT No. 3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Revision C Rev. Date 05-Feb-2023
VENDOR DOCUMENT No 18OP-00458-FDS-SWD-171
SOFTWARE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN SPECIFICATION (FDS) FOR ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL

Document Title: Return Code 02
SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
S/No Section/Para/Dwg. CPY Comments Vendor's Reply
Comments and revised document to be discussed and

3945_18-EL20613A-00167
1 aligned between CPY-CTJV-Siemens prior to re-issue to the Noted
Page 1 of 113
next revision
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
2 Need to be clarified how it is initiated by ELICS? This function shall not be included in ELICS design. Hence removed from the document.
Page 12 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
3 Please clarify/confirm this function is included This function shall not be included in ELICS design. Hence removed from the document.
Page 12 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Noted and Incorportated.

4 Please add a section to describe this function.
Page 12 of 113 Refer Section- "Disturbance Records" in page-33.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
5 Add VSR (Monitoring + control) Noted and Incorporated
Page 14 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
6 Add VFDG Noted and Incorporated as per comment 9 in row 20 of this CRS.
Page 15 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
7 Unclear if there is any control of HVAC in ELICS Noted and Incorporated
Page 15 of 113
If this is for 11kV switchgear, suggest to add a note that this

3945_18-EL20613A-00167
8 control is limited to 11kV switchgear to avoid confusion with Noted and Incorporated
Page 15 of 113
the compressor.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
9 Not clear what this. If GTG it is already covered. Noted and Incorporated. Equipment included with VDFG
Page 15 of 113
HOLD to be cleared in next revision. As per system

3945_18-EL20613A-00167
10 architecture 3945_18-EL20613A-00151, offshore package Noted and Incorporated
Page 17 of 113
will be connected into the server level (ELS-6502-01)
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
11 The interface shall be the RTU (RTU-6103) Noted and Incorporated
Page 17 of 113
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
12 Add the title Noted and Incorporated
Page 18 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Please define where this interface will be. That is at SS-6502
13 Noted and Incorporated
Page 18 of 113 or at NMCB. Please state here
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
Page 19 of 113
1) Where are the cybersecurity software/license (e.g.

Whitelisting, Antivirus, backup software, 2FA, NSM, etc.) ?
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
15 Please add it to this table It will be part of cybersecurity FDS.
Page 20 of 113
2) where are the Windows servers license for cybersecurity
servers.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
16 What about software for cyber security server/ controller.
Page 20 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
17 If Windows 10 Enterprise LTSC, please mentioned it clearly. Noted and Incorporated
Page 20 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Noted and Incorporated.

18 Add a snapshot of a typical WinCC report.
Page 31 of 113 Refer Fig-11 in Pg-30
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
Page 32 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
20 To be removed Noted and Incorporated
Page 34 of 113
Please confirm that the capacity of the servers can handle

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 the amount of data given that these servers will have all Yes. The systems are segregated and assigned to the redundant server pairs to handle the amount of data
21
Page 35 of 113 these RTUs connected. This should not have an impact on the fetched from these systems.
performace.
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
The distribution of the different RTU's in the servers should

take in mind the commissioning & handover sequence given
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 that at some point parts of the system will be LIVE and
22 Noted
Page 35 of 113 operating, while other parts will be under pre-commissioning
& commissioning.
Please add the same statement for the Gateways if both are
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
23 also active all the time. If not please explain the redundancy Both the gateways will be active all time to achieve redundancy.
Page 40 of 113
change-over.
Based on the comment, please add " A failure or

3945_18-EL20613A-00167
24 disconnection of one port does not create any failure or loss Noted and Incorporated
Page 40 of 113
of data."
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 No more redundancy for UPS and BC , use another example

25
Page 41 of 113 with redundancy with Modbus TCP/IP
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
26 General comment: add title to all the figures Noted and Incorporated
Page 43 of 113
What about the other substations listed in the table above The PMS network for the other substation will be communicating to the Master PMS controller by single
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
27 SS-6201, SS-6301, SS-7201, SS-7301, etc. ? how the PMS mode fiber optic communcation links. These links will be connected to the redundant aggregate switch
Page 46 of 113
network will be dispatched ? provided in substation SS-6501, 6502 and 7501.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
28 WWR/WWT Noted and Incorporated
Page 47 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
29 WWT Noted and Incorporated
Page 49 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 The same data set and path used by both station gateways ?
Page 51 of 113 Shouldn't be DATSET2 and BRCB2 ?
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
Please add that the primary time source shall be NFE master
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Noted and Incorporated
31 clock (provided by DCS) and the backup source shall be the
Page 51 of 113 Refer section - 6.8
GPS signal (provided by ELICS)
Is IRIG-B signal be utilized in NFE ELICS. If not, suggest to

3945_18-EL20613A-00167
32 remove the section. If yes, then need to detail which Noted. Section removed
Page 52 of 113
equipment will be synchronized via IRIG-B signals.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
33 Received as a NTP signal? Yes, updated the section as per comment.
Page 52 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
34 Please mention antena provided by ELICS Noted and Incorporated
Page 52 of 113
For the import from Kahramaa, please consider, the following

:
- 180 MW as a maximum limit to be imported from
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Kahramaa
Page 53 of 113 - 35 MW as a minimum limit to be imported from Kahramaa
- Power factor 0.9
Adjustable dead bands to be defined by the authorized
operator. +/-3 MW can be set as a default value
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
36 To be added to the abbreviation list Noted and Incorporated
Page 53 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 and the minimum import (35MW) to prevent export power to

Page 53 of 113 Kahramaa grid.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 An alarm shall be raised to the operator when reaching 225

Page 53 of 113 MW
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
39 No control based on outdoor temperature Noted and Incorporated
Page 53 of 113
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 How the priorities are set between all generators and Explained in detail.
40
Page 53 of 113 Kahramaa ? Refer section 7
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Including the power from generators taken out from the Explained in detail.
41
Page 53 of 113 PMS? Refer section 7
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
42 can also initiate Noted and Incorporated
Page 53 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
43 Frequency Noted and Incorporated
Page 53 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Please add the PMS control on the generators (GTG/STG) is

Page 54 of 113 only possible when the GCP is set to "Remote"
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
45 Corresponding curves set in the PMS to be provided here.
Page 54 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
46 from which input data? Updated as per comment-39 in row-50. Refer Section-7.2
Page 54 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 So in base Load mode the machine is taken out from the
47 CTJV to provide control philosophy for Baseload mode.
Page 54 of 113 PMS?
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
48 To be detailed Noted and Incorporated
Page 54 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 If this is done by selecting or de-selecting "Auto" for each

Page 54 of 113 generator, then please state that.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 This statement contradicts the first bullet point that states
50 Noted and updated the statement
Page 54 of 113 PMS will do that.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Which from Synch panel? This statement is not clear,

51 Noted and updated the statement
Page 55 of 113 especially the highlighted sentence.
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
52 Synch. panel? PMS
Page 55 of 113
As commented in rev B, suggest to add one figure for GTG,

STG and VFD as they are not necessary the same. also to
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
53 show or list in a table format the signals that are exchanged VFGD pending for update
Page 55 of 113
for PMS control.
This will also give clearer understanding on the interface.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Please elaborate the PMS control during Island mode, or

Page 55 of 113 refer to the section which details that.
Please add that if the network is islanded from the grid and
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
55 only one generator is oneline, PMS will set that generator to Noted and Incorporated
Page 56 of 113
ISOCH mode. No PMS control will be active in that case.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
56 occurs Occurs only if the turbine / generator is in auto mode
Page 56 of 113
What if only one GTG was online with the grid and was in
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
57 "Manual" or "MW" mode, then grid is opened. PMS should still PMS can only change the generator to ISOCH when the generator is in Remote and Auto.
Page 56 of 113
be able to change to ISOCH
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Explained in detail.
58 Unclear
Page 56 of 113 Refer section 7.3.3
Not if operating as an island. To avoid confusion, split this
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Noted and Incorportated.
59 section in different subsections each corresponding to a
Page 56 of 113 Refer section-7.3.4
network configuration
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 If generator is set to Remote, PMS will set the generator to
Page 56 of 113 ISOCH mode.
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
To re-arrange the scenario according to the likelihood of

operation:
1) All generators connected to Kahramaa,
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 2) Plant Islanded from Kahramaa (all generators connected),
Page 56 of 113 3) Split islands (part on Kahramaa) part islanded. All with all
generators,
4) Single machine in Iso on one bus, very unlikely but why
not,
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 In order to prevent any mis-operation, wouldn't it be

Page 56 of 113 preferable to narrow this range (0.88 to 1)?
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 If all generators set to remote and Auto, PMS will set the
Page 57 of 113 generators to DROOP mode.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 refer to the section where the details of this control are
64 Part of same section - 7.3.3
Page 57 of 113 described.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
65 in Remote and AUTO Noted and Incorporated
Page 57 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 refer to the section where the details of this control are
66 Part of same section - 7.3.3
Page 57 of 113 described.
For discussion: what about generators:
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
67 1) not in remote control Noted. To be discussed
Page 57 of 113
2) not set to Auto mode
This needs to include to check the generator is in remote +
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
68 Auto. Noted and Incorporated
Page 58 of 113
Please add these checks in the flow chart
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
69 please describe what is checked here. Is it ISOCH/DROOP? Noted and Incorporated
Page 58 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
70 Island + Noted and Incorporated
Page 58 of 113
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
71 selection Noted and Incorporated
Page 58 of 113
If not described elsewhere, suggest to describe here the

upper and lower limits for the KM import. Low limit is to
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
72 avoid export to the grid. Upper limit is to avoid importing Noted and Incorporated in Section-7 page-54
Page 58 of 113
more than the contractual limit. alarm should be provided
when reaching any of the limits.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
73 and Baseload mode CTJV to provide control philosophy for Baseload mode.
Page 58 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 To be discussed. Transient shall be managed by generator

74 Noted. To be discussed
Page 58 of 113 controllers
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 A dead band into which variations are not compensated by

Page 58 of 113 PMS shall be defined.
The sharing requirements have eventually been clarified as

follows:
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 -STG's at their maximum loading.
Page 58 of 113 -Minimum import from Kahramaa of 35MW.
-GTG's at 60% loading minimum to maintain combustion
within the Pre-mix DLN mode.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 VFDG will be set to manual mode. Contribution will be

Page 58 of 113 decided by Process operator.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 To be clarified or explained here what is meant by this

78
Page 58 of 113 statement. What does PMS actually do on a network change.
Anyway PMS shall not react too fast. Transient is managed
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
79 by generator controllers. Balancing by PMS has to be a Noted
Page 58 of 113
slower process in a steady network condition.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Active and reactive power control are independent. This link
Page 59 of 113 is confusing.
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
As discussed in the meeting, this functional overview needs

to show more details how the functionality/PMS actually
calculates and conducts the load sharing & PMS control.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
81
Page 59 of 113 - Which measurements are used for controls
- what type of signals
- which controller does the calculation,
- how the calculation is conducted
The flow is different when the plant is connected to

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Kahramaa and when it is islanded. This shall be reflected
82
Page 59 of 113 (either as separate flow charts or as different branches in the
chart), in particular with regards to pf control.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
83 Baseload mode is missing from above figure CTJV to provide control philosophy for Baseload mode.
Page 59 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 To also indicate what are the possible controls for reactive
84
Page 60 of 113 power (manual and / or automatic?)
This section need to include

- the control of reactive power based on voltage of 33kV and
how the capability changes,
- VFDG can export reactive power in motor & generating
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 mode
85
Page 60 of 113 - the capability depends on the number of VFD threads on
line.
- A sketch showing the interfaces between 33kV - VFDG -
MarkVI and PMS would be good to explain the interfaces and
the exchange of the signals listed below.
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
VFDG's shall be operated in manual mode. Process Operators

shall define the amount of active power to be shared. VFDG's
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
86 shall be regarded as base load machines. Only reactive Noted and Incorporated
Page 60 of 113
power shall be available at all time and shall participate to
the PMS in automatic mode.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 suggest to add the source - VFDG Master controller or Mark

Page 60 of 113 VI
At 66kV buses the action of OLTC's (TR-65809, TR-65810,
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
88 TR-75809) shall ensure a voltage close to 66kV regardless of Noted and Incorporated
Page 61 of 113
Kahramaa voltage.
This is not how the plant will be normally started. Start shall
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 only be possible with Kahramaa. The description provided is
Page 62 of 113 exceptional and would only occur during a blackout from
Kahramaa.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
90 and SB-65901 Noted and Incorporated
Page 62 of 113
This is not the correct place for this scenario. This

corresponds to a return from a blackout not the normal
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
91 operation / first energisation. As long as Kahramaa is Noted and Incorporated
Page 63 of 113
available it shall be the source of power used to start the
plant.
this flow chart refers to start-up with one GTG only. Please
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
92 update the flowchart to reflect normal operation with multiple Noted and Incorporated
Page 63 of 113
generators, or add another.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 here should include a step where the pulses are sent to the
93 Flowchart has been updated with clear details
Page 63 of 113 generators, correct?
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
As discussed in the meeting, please add a section to provide

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 more explanation of this flow chart and provide definitions of
Page 63 of 113 the equations used and define each parameter & how it is
measured and/or calculated.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 An operational limit shall be available to Operators (factor to

Page 64 of 113 allow 100% usage or lower)
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Or partially islanded; i.e. part of the plant is islanded while

Page 64 of 113 another part remains connector Kahramaa)
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
97 please state which bus Noted and Incorporated
Page 64 of 113
Note: any power swing will first be compensated by the
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
98 generator governors. PMS shall then act as a secondary Noted and Incorporated
Page 64 of 113
regulator after steady condition is achieved.

more explanation of this flow chart.
- Need to Define which bus is monitored with tags..e.g.
132kV bus, 66kV bus in T8&9 or T10&11 or both together
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 with a fail-over.
99
Page 64 of 113 - provide definitions of the equations used and define each
parameter & how it is measured and/or calculated.
To describe the function in details with tags and how it

actually achieves the functions.
Please add a section as to how the GTGs will be managed to

be operating in Pre-mix mode, especially when multiple
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
100 machines are online.
Page 64 of 113
This is valid for both Grid connected & island modes.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 shall target (depending on the number of generators

Page 65 of 113 available - to be operator adjustable)
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
Please include VFDG in the flow chart in details (e.g. all the
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
102 coditions from the VFDG should be part of the flowchart and
Page 65 of 113
description)
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
103 Automatically switch to voltage control?
Page 65 of 113

more explanation of this flow chart.
- Need to Define which bus is monitored with tags..e.g.
132kV bus, 66kV bus in T8&9 or T10&11 or both together
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 with a fail-over.
104
Page 65 of 113 - provide definitions of the equations used and define each
parameter & how it is measured and/or calculated.
To describe the function in details with tags and how it

actually achieves the functions.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
105 Describe also when pf target is achieved.
Page 65 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 as discussed, suggest to add the overall synchronization

106
Page 66 of 113 block diagram in this section
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
107 Update Couplers Noted and Updated
Page 66 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
108 Please make the figure more legible.
Page 66 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
109 To be either described or removed.
Page 66 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
110 Indications difficult to read.
Page 66 of 113
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
Page 67 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
112 + CB ready to close Already mentioned - "Permissive to Close"
Page 67 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
113 ? Noted and Updated
Page 67 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
114 2 bus couplers available. Selection to be reflected. Noted and Incorporated
Page 67 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 To indicate link with ELICS / PMS console for remote synch.
Page 67 of 113 Request
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Please add to all:

Page 68 of 113 SYNCH Panel
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Input means input to SYNCH panel controller or PMS? please

117 Signals to PMS. Updated the table heading accordingly
Page 68 of 113 add to & from to make it clearer
The logic to distribute the raise / lower signals to the

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 different STG/GTG will be done in PMS? Yes, pulse outputs for raise lower will be triggered from PMS according to the inputs received in PMS from
118
Page 68 of 113 During the meeting it was understood it will be all managed synchronizer controller.
by the synchronizer controller
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
119 shouldn't these be two input signals separately Currently considered as a single signals where state 0= Bus A and 1= Bus B
Page 68 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
120 both positions to be monitored or only one? Both posiiton can be monitored.
Page 69 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
121 110VAC or 4-20 mA? 110VAC
Page 70 of 113
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
Page 70 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
123 To be detailed Noted and Incorporated
Page 71 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
124 See comments 6.3.9.2. Noted and Incorporated
Page 71 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
125 Update Couplers Noted and Incorporated
Page 71 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
126 add titles to all Figures / Sketchs Noted and Incorporated
Page 71 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
127 Same comments as SS-6500 Noted and Incorporated
Page 72 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
128 Same comments as SS-6500 Noted and Incorporated
Page 76 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Step 1 should be the operator selects which breaker he

Page 78 of 113 wants to synchronize across
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
130 at the synchronization panel Noted and Incorporated
Page 78 of 113
here need to describe if this pulses will go from the synch

panel as one pulses and distributed by the PMS based on a
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
131 logic of determining how many generators are online, in Noted and Incorporated
Page 78 of 113
remote etc, or the pulses are multiplied by the Synch panel
and just transited via the PMS.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Pulses will be sent to the generators NOT on the reference

Page 78 of 113 bus.
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
133 Generators controlled by each synch. panel to be listed
Page 78 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Step 1 should be the operator selects which breaker he

Page 78 of 113 wants to synchronize across
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
135 at the synchronization panel Noted and Incorporated
Page 78 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
136 is this duplicate? Sentence has been rephrased
Page 78 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
137 Describe also synch. failure (as per section below). Noted and Incorporated
Page 79 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
138 always Noted and Incorporated
Page 79 of 113
This is valid for bus coupler only, if yes, please please state
that.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Also please make the statement more clearer; ELICS

Page 79 of 113 automatically defines the reference and variable bus based
on the spinning reserve. The bus with higher spinning
reserve becomes the variable bus (bus update if this is the
intent).
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Please add a snapshot form the ELICS Synchronization

Page 79 of 113 graphic page here
The SAFOP has lead to a different requirement of operation.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
141 Both transformers shall remain connected permanently. Noted and Incorporated
Page 80 of 113
Control is no longer required.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Could have been defined by operator in ELICS OS Client Station. But now as per revised philosophy
142 HOW THIS IS DEFINED
Page 81 of 113 (comment-141, row-152) this option is no longer required.
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
143 To be discussed Noted
Page 82 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
144 and/or Noted and Incorporated
Page 85 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
145 than what Noted and Incorporated
Page 85 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 which is part of the switchgear protection relay settings and

Page 85 of 113 not the ELICS system.
Please add a section the explain how the network sections

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 are determined with exact tags and which CB are monitored.
147
Page 86 of 113 This should define how many multiple networks/islands can
be managed.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
148 NFE1-SEL-EL-SDR-00007
Page 86 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
149 Please define in details, i.e. from GCP's via analogue signals Noted and Incorporated
Page 86 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 measured from Relay IED or 132kV breaker via 4-20mA? -

Page 86 of 113 please for all be specific and give all details
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 This shall be calculated by LSC based on the max Kahramaa

Page 86 of 113 power as it is not available as a readily available signal.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 IN EARLIER PARA 6.3.5 IT IS MENTIONED THAT 6.3.5

152
Page 86 of 113 PARTICPATES IN LOAD SHARING
Note: a safety margin (operator adjustable) shall be provided
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
153 so as to start load shedding before the stability limit is Noted and Incorporated
Page 86 of 113
reached.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 unclear statement. LS should be fast in one shot. not
Page 86 of 113 multiple sheds. always better to shed more than less.
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 trip of associated transformers (step up or interties shall also

Page 87 of 113 be considered for faster response).
In case of unailability of the measure of error of measure

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 (while it is confirmed the load is still connected), the rated
156 Noted
Page 87 of 113 can be used unless it is expected to exclude this consumer
altogether.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
157 To be developped Noted
Page 87 of 113
This should be performed in a more predictive way to shorten

the overall sequence:
At each cycle, the LSC shall determine for the loss of each
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
158 generator, bus coupler, etc, what would be the spinning Noted
Page 88 of 113
reserve (of each island) and be ready to apply the
corresponding shedding plan in case of occurence of a crisis
signal in the next cycle.
Please include the equations of for determining LS and for

3945_18-EL20613A-00167
159 determining the load to be shed together with this Noted and Incorporated
Page 88 of 113
description.
as commented above, please define how the isolated
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
160 networks are defined, which breakers are monitored and how
Page 88 of 113
many islands are considered.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 There are also loads on the 132kV GIS (CO2 compressors & CO2 compressors and desalination loads are considered by calculating the sum of Active power from 132kV
161
Page 88 of 113 Desalination plant). feeder to transfomers TR-60601A and TR-60601B.
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
General comment on LS section:

The overall LS section does not include the following and
needs to be describe/explained.:
1) when is a generator considered active in LS and when it is
not. If there are modes when a generator is out of LS
spinning reserve calculation, to be clearly defined.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
162
Page 89 of 113
2) how is the generator load acceptance considered. To be
described for each type of generator and explained how the
controller will calculate/ compute that.
3) VFDG's not to be considered in spinning reserve

calculation.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
163 To be updated based on comments above.
Page 89 of 113
As discussed in the meeting, please include the flowchats
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
164 with full details as to how the LSS controller calculates or
Page 89 of 113
measures the values at each step
How is this determined.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
165
Page 89 of 113 After this there should be two lines, if network is split and if
network is not split, please show complete.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
166 Please define what is this set Limit
Page 89 of 113
This should be:
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
167 loads to be shed shall be the priority group corresponding to
Page 89 of 113
the Load to be shed or next priority.
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
Please include:
1. When load shedding is activated, the signal shall be kept
active to prevent restarting, until a LS RESET is given.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
168 2. LS RESET can only be given by Supervisor level at the
Page 89 of 113
ELICS workstation.
3. Motors not running shall be inhibited to start until a LS
RESET is made.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
169 Please define this special permission Noted and Incorporated
Page 90 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
170 shedding list? Yes, Noted and Updated
Page 90 of 113
This paragraph to be elaborated further as to when it is

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Noted and Incorporated.
171 active, and how the logic works. Suggest to make this a
Page 90 of 113 Refer section 8.9.1
section "Load Inhibition during Essential power"
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
172 what is the aim/benefit of this list? Noted and Incorporated
Page 91 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 It is not clear the difference between this list and the LS list
173 Updated the section with more details
Page 91 of 113 in the next page.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
174 Please change to "LS Enabled" Noted and Incorporated
Page 91 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
175 Please change to "LS Disabled" Noted and Incorporated
Page 91 of 113
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
As per CPY lesson learn , add below functionality for rest of

motor start inhibit commands:
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 - one general button to reset all motor start inhibits when
Page 91 of 113 normal power has been recovered.
- one button per motor to reset individual motor start inhibit
when Operator decide to restart a specific motor.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 why is this necessary. it should just be an alarm or reset with

177 Noted
Page 91 of 113 the global LS reset. -
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
178 (post shedding operation) Noted and Incorporated
Page 91 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
179 Special permissions to be defined here Noted and Incorporated
Page 92 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 As per comment in previous section, need to evaluate the

180 Updated the section with more details
Page 92 of 113 need of having three lists
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Please add a section to describe features of this function.

181
Page 92 of 113 what can be done etc..
To be discussed what is meant by this statement. If there is
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
182 any agreement to be done, it is to be carried out now and Noted
Page 92 of 113
included in the design.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
183 Please refer to appendix 1 for the complete LS list Based on the loads listed in appendix 1 the Load shedding list graphics screen is prepared.
Page 93 of 113
How is this determination made. Please explain in details

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 based on the logic.
Page 94 of 113 It may be easier to have the condition the determination of a
black-out, which is done by EPDCS.
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
To simplify the essential load shedding, the principle has
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 been revised: the response to the loss of an EDG shall be the
185 Noted
Page 94 of 113 trip of 6.6/0.415kV transformer feeders (see list 10.3.1.2 of
the Operation and Control Philosophy)
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 A table with all the priorities / transformer and their priorities
186 Priority details of transformers to be provided
Page 94 of 113 to be included.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Safety margins shall be set based on unit data sheets, and
Page 94 of 113 not Supervisor.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
188 update above Noted and Incorporated
Page 94 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 what are the difference between this setting and the
189
Page 95 of 113 maximum & minimum setting as described in PMS section
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 suggest to move this section under the LS calculation

Page 95 of 113 explanation section
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Suggest to reword to: "Back-up load shedding is a function

Page 95 of 113 with the switchgear protection relays and not part of ELICS"
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 to ensure they are open (though they should already be open
Page 96 of 113 by undervoltage protection
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
193 send opening commands to Noted and Incorporated
Page 96 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
194 (see flow chart next section) Noted
Page 96 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
195 reconfiguration of the 33 kV network followed by the Noted and Incorporated
Page 96 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 is this required based on the energization philosophy of

196 Yes, based on the Essential Netrwork Reconfiguration philosophy.
Page 96 of 113 exciting all transformers together. To be reconfirmed
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
This should be as per the design and transformer
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
197 energization study. Operator may be given option to change Noted
Page 96 of 113
if required.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
198 Update control Noted and Incorporated
Page 96 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
199 once the EDGs start, Noted and Incorporated
Page 96 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
200 Update overloaded, (tentative), acceptable Noted and Incorporated
Page 96 of 113
This is not an operator selection. Energization of

transformers and closing of downstream switchgears shall be
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
201 automatic by EPDCS based on a sequence defined once the Noted and Incorporated
Page 96 of 113
essential voltage is stable. The sequence shall be defined
here in this document.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
202 To be defined by Energization study Noted
Page 96 of 113
closing of 11kv, 6.6kV & 415V to occur only after the EDG's
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
203 are online and dead paralleling is complete and voltage is Updated the flowchart according to Operation and Control Philosophy Rev1
Page 97 of 113
stable
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 To be updated according to rev. 1 of the Operation and
204 Noted and updated
Page 97 of 113 Control Philosophy.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
205 This should be managed by EDGs - to be discussed Updated the flowchart according to Operation and Control Philosophy Rev1
Page 97 of 113
A list of all breakers (with tags) to be :

1) opened before EDG start.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 2) closed before dead parralelling
206 Updated the flowchart according to Operation and Control Philosophy Rev1
Page 97 of 113 3) closed after dead paralleling
to be inlcuded in a table after this flow chart
CRS
658480324.xlsx

SYSTEM (ELICS)
Review Details
A logic should be included in case any one or more of these

3945_18-EL20613A-00167
207 interties does not close. Updated the flowchart according to Operation and Control Philosophy Rev1
Page 97 of 113
Please refer to QG-3&4/QCS project.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
208 after a total blackout Noted and Incorporated
Page 98 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167
209 ELICS EPDCS Noted and Incorporated
Page 98 of 113
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 to be discussed. The request would be by operator from

210 Noted
Page 98 of 113 EPDCS.
3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Suggest to replace with the list to be provided by Process

Page 100 of 113 department
CRS
658480324.xlsx

Comments Response Sheet (CRS) : Project No / Title LTC/C/NFE/3945/18 - NORTH FIELD EAST PROJECT Onshore LNG Facilities

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Comments Response Sheet (CRS) : Project No / Title LTC/C/NFE/3945/18 - NORTH FIELD EAST PROJECT Onshore LNG Facilities

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Comments Response Sheet (CRS) Project No / Title LTC/C/NFE/3945/18 - NORTH FIELD EAST PROJECT Onshore LNG Facilities

PROJECT DOCUMENT No. 3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Revision C Rev. Date 05-Feb-2023

VENDOR DOCUMENT No 18OP-00458-FDS-SWD-171

SOFTWARE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN SPECIFICATION (FDS) FOR ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL

Comments and revised document to be discussed and

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Noted and Incorportated.

If this is for 11kV switchgear, suggest to add a note that this

HOLD to be cleared in next revision. As per system

PROJECT DOCUMENT No. 3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Revision C Rev. Date 05-Feb-2023

VENDOR DOCUMENT No 18OP-00458-FDS-SWD-171

SOFTWARE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN SPECIFICATION (FDS) FOR ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL

1) Where are the cybersecurity software/license (e.g.

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Noted and Incorporated.

Please confirm that the capacity of the servers can handle

PROJECT DOCUMENT No. 3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Revision C Rev. Date 05-Feb-2023

VENDOR DOCUMENT No 18OP-00458-FDS-SWD-171

SOFTWARE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN SPECIFICATION (FDS) FOR ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL

The distribution of the different RTU's in the servers should

Based on the comment, please add " A failure or

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 No more redundancy for UPS and BC , use another example

PROJECT DOCUMENT No. 3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Revision C Rev. Date 05-Feb-2023

VENDOR DOCUMENT No 18OP-00458-FDS-SWD-171

SOFTWARE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN SPECIFICATION (FDS) FOR ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL

Is IRIG-B signal be utilized in NFE ELICS. If not, suggest to

For the import from Kahramaa, please consider, the following

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 and the minimum import (35MW) to prevent export power to

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 An alarm shall be raised to the operator when reaching 225

PROJECT DOCUMENT No. 3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Revision C Rev. Date 05-Feb-2023

VENDOR DOCUMENT No 18OP-00458-FDS-SWD-171

SOFTWARE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN SPECIFICATION (FDS) FOR ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Please add the PMS control on the generators (GTG/STG) is

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 If this is done by selecting or de-selecting "Auto" for each

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Which from Synch panel? This statement is not clear,

PROJECT DOCUMENT No. 3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Revision C Rev. Date 05-Feb-2023

VENDOR DOCUMENT No 18OP-00458-FDS-SWD-171

SOFTWARE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN SPECIFICATION (FDS) FOR ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL

As commented in rev B, suggest to add one figure for GTG,

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Please elaborate the PMS control during Island mode, or

PROJECT DOCUMENT No. 3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Revision C Rev. Date 05-Feb-2023

VENDOR DOCUMENT No 18OP-00458-FDS-SWD-171

SOFTWARE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN SPECIFICATION (FDS) FOR ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL

To re-arrange the scenario according to the likelihood of

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 In order to prevent any mis-operation, wouldn't it be

PROJECT DOCUMENT No. 3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Revision C Rev. Date 05-Feb-2023

VENDOR DOCUMENT No 18OP-00458-FDS-SWD-171

SOFTWARE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN SPECIFICATION (FDS) FOR ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL

If not described elsewhere, suggest to describe here the

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 To be discussed. Transient shall be managed by generator

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 A dead band into which variations are not compensated by

The sharing requirements have eventually been clarified as

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 VFDG will be set to manual mode. Contribution will be

3945_18-EL20613A-00167 To be clarified or explained here what is meant by this

PROJECT DOCUMENT No. 3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Revision C Rev. Date 05-Feb-2023

VENDOR DOCUMENT No 18OP-00458-FDS-SWD-171

SOFTWARE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN SPECIFICATION (FDS) FOR ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL

As discussed in the meeting, this functional overview needs

The flow is different when the plant is connected to

This section need to include

PROJECT DOCUMENT No. 3945_18-EL20613A-00167 Revision C Rev. Date 05-Feb-2023

VENDOR DOCUMENT No 18OP-00458-FDS-SWD-171

SOFTWARE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN SPECIFICATION (FDS) FOR ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL

VFDG's shall be operated in manual mode. Process Operators