Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CURRENT
OPINION Update on results and complications
of cyclophotocoagulation
Kyoko Ishida
Purpose of review
This review highlights recently published studies on transscleral and endoscopic diode
cyclophotocoagulation (TCP, ECP) and summarizes the treatment results and complications.
Recent findings
Although both TCP and ECP are efficacious procedures for the treatment of refractory glaucoma, no
consensus exists for optimum treatment protocol. TCP has mainly been used as a last-resort treatment for
intractable glaucoma with very limited visual potential. Repeated treatment is often required. Serious
complications include vision loss, hypotony, and phthisis. High treatment energy per session and
underlying abnormality seem risk factors for these complications. Recent growing numbers of investigations
are giving promising results for TCP as a primary surgery in eyes with good vision. Although ECP came
later into clinical use for glaucoma treatment, it is becoming more accepted and no longer reserved for
end-stage cases. ECP is most commonly performed in conjunction with cataract surgery and shows overall
good success with relatively low complication rates. Serious complications include hypotony, phthisis,
cystoid macular edema, and retinal detachment.
Summary
Recent literatures suggest that both TCP and ECP are performed increasingly as the primary surgery for
various types and stages of glaucoma. Both treatments are effective procedures, although potential for
serious complications exists.
Keywords
cyclophotocoagulation, diode laser, endoscopic cyclophotocoagulation, glaucoma, transscleral
cyclophotocoagulation
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Update on results and complications of cyclophotocoagulation Ishida
1040-8738 ß 2013 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins www.co-ophthalmology.com 103
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
104
Glaucoma
Table 1. Summary of IOP results and laser parameters in published studies of TCP
Mean IOP Mean IOP Overall No. of No. of No. of Mean energy Mean total
Country Follow-up No. of % POAG pretreatment end of FU % IOP success Definition Retreatment treatment treatment burns per per treatment energy
Study and year (months) eyes %NVG and CACG (mmHg) (mmHg) reduction rate (%) of success (%) per eye range treatment episode (J) per eye (J)
Egbert et al. [1] Ghana, 2001 13.2 92 0 100 29.3 25.7 12.3 48.0 22 20.0 1.27 N/A 20 45 or 62.5 N/A
Gupta and India, 2000 12.0 52 11.5 11.5 44.7 15.2 66.0 92.0 <22 42.0 1.69 1–4 40 120–160 N/A
Agarwal [2]
&
Ramli et al. [3 ] Singapore, 2012 17.1 90 38.9 9.9 41.8 17.8 57.4 54 5IOP21 13.3 N/A N/A 30 N/A 83.3
Lai et al. [4] China, 2005 26.5 13 0 100 36.4 18.7 48.6 92.7 21 15.4 1.15 1–2 17.5 72.1 82.9a
Hauber and USA, 2002 12.0 47 6.3 80.9 29.4 16.2 44.9 94.4 <21 0 1 1 25.6 102.5 102.5
Scherer [5]
www.co-ophthalmology.com
Noureddin USA Middle 13.7 36 16.6 19.4 35.8 19.1 53.0 72.2 21 25.0 1.25 1–2 26–28 121.5a 151.9a
et al. [6] Eastern,
2006
Murphy et al. [7] UK, 2003 17.0 263 46.4 18.6 40.7 17.7 52.6 79.5 5 IOP 21 34.2 1.5 1–7 N/A 104.1 155.2
Mistlberger USA, 2001 9.2 206 31.1 12.7 42.1 20.3 51.7 72.2 IOP 22 16.0 1.29 1–6 18.6 N/A N/A
et al. [8]
Frezzotti et al. [9] Italy, 2010 17.0 124 21.8 36.2 29.9 20.8 31.3 63.0 21 21.7 1.27 1–4 9.1 36.7 46.6a
Iliev and Gerber[10] Switzerland, 30.1 131 61.1 12.2 37.7 15.3 55.0 69.5 6 IOP 21 38.9 1.54 1–6 22 86.8 133.9
2007
Schlote et al. [11] Germany,2001 12.0 100 16.1 20.4 30.6 20.6 32.7 74.2 5 IOP 21 59.0 1.86 1–4 10–15 47.0 87.4a
a
Kramp et al. [12] Germany, 2002 13.9 193 6.2 64.8 24.6 19.3 21.5 76.4 10 IOP 22 21.2 1.3 1–6 24–30 92.4 120.1a
a
Leszczyński Poland, 2004 12.0 81 24.1 0 46.0 18.0 60.9 60 10 IOP 21 N/A 1.5 1–4 N/A 83.2 124.8
et al. [13]
Grueb et al. [14] Switzerland, 2006 24.0 90 0 73.3 21.0 16.0 23.8 36.7 4 IOP 18 and 30.0 1.3 1–3 15–20 80.0 104.0a
20% reduction
Kaushik et al. [15] India, 2008 14.3 66 27.3 13.6 36.4 15.6 57.1 78.8 5 IOP 21 16.7 1.16 1–6 18 87.8 N/A
Osman et al. [16] Saudi Arabia, 80.2 35 11.4 60.0 35.1 18.8 46.4 62.8 22 0 1 1 16 24–40 24–40
2010
Goldenberg-Cohen Israel, 2005 15.8 32 34.4 37.5 35.9 21.1 41.2 62.5 IOP < 21 N/A 1.22 N/A 20–40 67.5–160 N/A
et al. [17]
Pucci et al. [18] Italy, 2003 26.0 120 12.5 52.5 30.4 20.3 35.0 76a 21 45.8 1.7 1–5 10 43.6a 75.2a
Vernon et al. [19] UK, 2006 65.7 42 11.9 21.4 31.4 15.6 50.3 88.1 <22 59.6 2.17 1–6 14 56.0 121.52a
Nabili and Kirkness UK, 2004 22.5 20 100 0 34.4 18.2 45.0 60 <22 35.0 1.45 N/A 15 60.0 87.0
[20]
Ansari and UK, 2007 12.5 74 54.0 39.0 40.3 21.1 43.0 82.0 30% reduction 1.4 1.01 1–2 30 80.0 124.1a
Gandhewar
[21]
Rotchford et al. [22] UK, 2010 60.0 49 2.0 42.9 28.0 15.3 45.4 89.8 6 IOP 21 36.7 1.73 1–6 14.4 57.6 99.7
CACG, chronic angle-closure glaucoma; IOP, intraocular pressure; N/A, not available; NVG, neovascular glaucoma; POAG, primary open angle glaucoma.
a
Calculated, based on the data in the article.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Update on results and complications of cyclophotocoagulation Ishida
According to the study [15] that assessed the treat- implantation at 24 months. Visual acuity decrease
ment parameters of TCP in Asian Indian eyes, was observed in 24% in TPC group and 27% in AGV
pigmented eyes appeared to require less energy group. The eyes that underwent AGV implantation
level than that reported in Caucasian eyes with had more complications than those treated with
comparable outcome. There are many reports TCP.
[1–4,6,15,16,29,32,36,37] on TCP treatment for TCP has been shown to be effective for pain
those pigmented eyes; however, a clear relationship relief and IOP control in NVG [7,10,17,42–44],
between laser energy and IOP response remains to but on its own does not lead to regression of anterior
be demonstrated. segment neovascularization. There has been some
As mentioned before, many investigators recent interest in combining TCP with intravitreal
reported that TCP was less effective in younger injection of bevacizumab (IVB). Ghosh et al. [45]
patients than older patients [10–13,28–31]. There reported that combined IVB and TCP treatment for
are several studies [30,31,38] that especially focused NVG provided rapid control of anterior segment
on pediatric glaucoma. In Kirwan et al.’s study [30], neovascularization within the first week in 86%
72% of refractory pediatric glaucomas had a clin- and led to improve symptomatic relief in 92.3%
ically useful reduction in IOP (<22 mmHg or by and IOP control (30% reduction from the baseline)
30%), although repeated treatment was required in 64.3%. Other study [46] reported that no statisti-
in 62%. In Autrata and Rehurek’s study [31], IOP cally significant differences in the reduction of IOP,
decreased from 34.1 to 20.8 mmHg after a mean of visual preservation, or complications were found
2.13 laser treatments in pediatric glaucoma (age between a combination of TCP and IVB treatment
<15 years). After one treatment session, 66% of eyes and TCP treatment alone. Further long-term
had a successful reduction in IOP (21 mmHg), but prospective randomized studies are needed to
this had fallen to 41% by 1 year. With repeat TCP, thoroughly evaluate the utility of combination
79% of eyes had surgical success for 1 year. Com- TCP/bevacizumab treatment in NVG.
pared with adults treated with similar protocol, the
degree of IOP lowering was similar but for a shorter
duration and younger eyes may recover from treat- COMPLICATIONS OF TRANSSCLERAL
ment more rapidly. DIODE CYCLOPHOTOCOAGULATION
When a tube shunt (Tube) fails to adequately Documented complications after TCP include pain,
control the IOP, limited treatment options remain. uveitis, IOP spikes [47], pigment dispersion [48],
These options include a sequential Tube [39], revi- transient pupil ovalization [18], atonic pupil [1],
sion or replacement of the existing Tube, or a cyclo- hyphema, vitreous hemorrhage, cataract pro-
destructive procedure [39–41]. Efficacy of the gression [39], lens subluxation [49], malignant glau-
supplemental TCP was assessed in 21 eyes with coma [50], necrotizing scleritis [51], vision loss,
uncontrolled IOP, despite the presence of Tube sympathetic ophthalmia [52], hypotony, and phthi-
and maximally tolerated glaucoma medications sis. It was not always clear-cut whether complication
[40]. Adjunctive TCP was viable option to lower was related to TCP treatment itself or to the com-
IOP in 71.5% of cases. Sood and Beck [39] examined plexity of eye abnormality. A literature review [19]
the efficacy of a sequential Tube versus TCP follow- suggests that the risks of hypotony and phthisis are
ing failure of an initial Tube in treatment of refrac- related to the amount of laser energy delivered in
tory childhood glaucoma and found that both a treatment session. Table 2 [1,2,4–22,33,38,42,
strategies showed similar efficacy (IOP < 22 mmHg: 43,53] details the rates of these complications
62.5% in Tube versus 66.7% in TCP) and compli- (hypotony: 0–25% [20] and phthisis: 0–9.9% [10])
cation rates. In cases with failed tube, high compli- and treatment protocols of 26 studies. Except for the
cation rate after TPC treatment was reported [41]. studies that included many patients with NVG, it
Although, the mean IOP decreased from 28.6 to seemed that treatment protocols employing less
14.7 mmHg, complications including hypotony than 80 J per treatment session are almost free of
(12.5%), loss of two or more lines of visual acuity hypotony and phthisis. However, protocols employ-
from baseline (56.3%), and loss of light perception ing more than 80 J per session, reveal a definite
(15.6%) were observed. The possible benefits of IOP tendency toward higher rates of both these compli-
&
control in TCP after failed tube need to be weighed cations. Ramli et al. [3 ] reported that underlying
against the risks of complications. A prospective abnormality rather than the amount of energy used
comparative study [42] between TCP and Ahmed is the more important factor affecting rates of hypo-
Valve (AGV) implantation as a primary procedure in tony. Among several factors, univariate analysis
NVG reported that the success (5 < IOP < 21 mmHg) showed that only NVG was a risk factor for
were 63.6 and 59.3% for the TCP and AGV developing hypotony.
1040-8738 ß 2013 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins www.co-ophthalmology.com 105
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Glaucoma
Table 2. Comparison of rates of complications (hypotony and phthisis) and treatment protocols
% POAG Mean IOP Mean IOP No. of Mean energy Mean
and pretreatment end of FU treatment per treatment total energy Hypotony Phthisis
Study %NVG CACG (mmHg) (mmHg) per eye episodes (J) per eye (J) (%) (%)
Gupta and Agarwal [2] 11.5 11.5 44.7 15.2 1.69 120.0–160.0 N/A N/A 1.9
Goldenberg-Cohen 34.4 37.5 35.9 21.1 1.22 67.5–160.0 N/A N/A 3.1
et al. [17]
Noureddin et al. [6] 16.6 19.4 35.8 19.1 1.25 121.5a 151.9a 2.7 0
Mistlberger et al. [8] 31.1 12.7 42.1 20.3 1.29 55.8–111.6 N/A N/A 1.9
Murphy et al. [7] 46.4 18.6 40.7 17.7 1.5 104.1 155.2 9.5 5.3
Hauber and Scherer [5] 6.3 80.9 29.4 16.2 1 102.5 102.5 0 0
Kramp et al. [12] 6.2 64.8 24.6 19.3 1.3 92.4a 120.1a N/A 1.6
Walland [43] 60.0 N/A 49.4 21.8 1.4 90.0 126.0a 18.0 N/A
Kaushik et al. [15] 27.3 13.6 36.4 15.6 1.16 87.8 N/A 9.1 N/A
Iliev and Gerber[10] 61.1 12.2 37.7 15.3 1.54 86.8 133.9 17.6 9.9
Leszczyński et al. [13] 24.1 0 46.0 18.0 1.5 83.2a 124.8 2.4 1.2
Grueb et al. [14] 0 73.3 21.0 16.0 1.3 80.0 104.0a 1.1 0
Ansari and 54.0 39.0 40.3 21.1 1.01 80.0 124.1a 0 0
Gandhewar [21]
Izgi et al. [38] N/A N/A 34.5 24.2 N/A 61.2–80.0 N/A 0 0
Lai et al. [4] 0 100 36.4 18.7 1.15 72.1 82.9a 0 0
Egbert et al. [1] 0 100 29.3 25.7 1.27 45.0–62.5 N/A 0 0
Yildirim [42] 100 0 43.4 18.7 1 48.0–60.0 48.0–60.0 9.1 0
Schlote et al. [33] 0 0 30.7 19.4 2 40.0–60.0 80.0–120.0a 0 0
Nabili and Kirkness[20] 100 0 34.4 18.2 1.45 60.0 87.0 25.0 5.0
Rotchford et al. [22] 2.0 42.9 28.0 15.3 1.73 57.6 99.7 0 0
Pokroy et al. [53] 37.9 62.1 29.0 19.5 1.67 53.8a 88.6 5.1a 0
a
Vernon et al. [19] 11.9 21.4 31.4 15.6 2.17 56.0 121.52 0 0
Schlote et al. [11] 16.1 20.4 30.6 20.6 1.86 47.0 87.4a 0 0
a
Pucci et al. [18] 12.5 52.5 30.4 20.3 1.7 43.6 75.2a 0 0
Osman et al. [16] 11.4 N/A 35.1 18.8 1 24.0–40.0 24.0–40.0 0 0
Frezzotti et al. [9] 21.8 36.2 29.9 20.8 1.27 36.7 46.6a 0 0
CACG, chronic angle-closure glaucoma; IOP, intraocular pressure; N/A, not available; NVG, neovascular glaucoma; POAG, primary open angle glaucoma.
a
Calculated, based on the data in the article.
High pretreatment IOP [7], treatment range [43], In the 19 studies [1,4–11,13–15,18–20,22,28,
&
and glaucoma subtype including NVG [3 ,7,10,13, 54,55] cited, loss of visual acuity more than two
20,43], and uveitic glaucoma [7] are reported as risk Snellen lines occurred in 22.5% on average (range:
factors for development of hypotony and phthisis. 0–55.2%) (Table 3). Recent studies conducted on
In 81 eyes with different types of secondary glau- the earlier use of TCP have been including cases with
coma, patients with NVG are reported to be at high good visual acuity. In groups with good prelaser
risk for severe complications such as hypotony vision, Ansari and Gandhewar [21] reported that
(10%) and phthisis (5.0%) [13]. In Nabili and the mean visual acuity post-TCP (POAG; 6/19,
Kirkness’s [20] and Iliev and Gerber’s [10] studies CACG; 6/29) was no worse than the prelaser level
in which NVG accounted for 100 and 61.2% of (POAG; 6/22, CACG; 6/26). A retrospective study
patients, respectively, hypotony and phthisis [56] of 21 eyes with visual acuity 20/80 or better
occurred in 25 and 5%, and in 18 and 10%. On demonstrated that visual acuity remained within
the contrary, diagnostic categories, mainly primary one line of the pretreatment level in 81%. Rotchford
glaucoma, have been reported to have significantly et al. [22] investigated the effect of TCP for glaucoma
lowered these complication rates (hypotony: on central visual function in patients with visual
0–1.1% and phthisis: 0–1.6%) [1,5,12,14,18]. To acuity better than or equal to 20/60 (mean: 20/30).
avoid undesirable complications, more conservative At 5-year follow-up, mean visual acuity was 20/60
approach to TCP in terms of energy delivery may be with a line loss of two or more of Snellen visual
useful especially eyes with NVG. acuity recorded in 30.6 and 67.3% retained visual
The other common complication was the loss of acuity 20/60 or better. Visual loss was unrelated to
two or more lines of visual acuity from baseline. total treatment dose, initial acuity, or initial IOP
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Update on results and complications of cyclophotocoagulation Ishida
Table 3. The effect of TCP on visual function described as visual acuity changes more than 2 Snellen lines
% POAG No. of Mean energy Mean total Visual acuity Visual Visual acuity
Follow-up No. of and treatment per treatment energy worsened (%) acuity improved (%)
Study (months) eyes %NVG CACG per eye episodes (J) per eye (J) 2 lines stable (%) 2 lines
Vernon et al. [19] 65.7 42 11.9 21.4 2.17 56.0 121.5a 55.2 37.9 6.9
Nabili and Kirkness[20] 22.5 20 100 0 1.45 60.0 87.0 40.0a 60.0a 0
Schlote et al. [28] 42 21 N/A N/A 2.80 80.0 224.0 36.0 52.0 12.0
33 25 N/A N/A 2.36 80.0 189.0a 33.3 52.4 14.3
Iliev and Gerber[10] 30.1 131 61.1 12.2 1.54 86.8 133.9 34.0 55.0 11.0
Lai et al. [4] 26.5 13 0 100 1.15 72.1 82.9a 30.8 61.5 7.7
Rotchford et al. [22] 60 49 2.0 42.9 1.73 57.6 99.7 30.6 N/A N/A
Shah [54] 30.5 28 N/A N/A 1.58 90.0 141.8a 25.9 63.0 11.1
a
Pucci et al. [18] 26 120 12.5 52.5 1.7 43.6 75.2a 24.2 55.0 20.8
Egbert et al. [1] 13.2 92 0 100 1.27 45.0–62.5 45.0–62.5 22.8 69.6 6.3
Murphy et al. [7] 17.0 263 46.4 18.6 1.5 104.1 155.2 19.9 74.7 5.3
Mistlberger et al. [8] 9.2 206 31.1 12.7 1.29 N/A N/A 18.7 N/A 2.4
Noureddin et al. [6] 13.7 36 16.6 19.4 1.25 121.5a 151.9a 13.9a 61.1a 25.0a
Frezzotti et al. [9] 17 124 21.8 36.2 1.27 36.7 46.6a 12.9 73.5 4.0
Hauber and Scherer [5] 12 47 6.3 80.9 1.0 102.5 102.5 12.8 85.1 2.1
Schlote et al. [11] 12 100 16.1 20.4 1.86 47.0 87.4a 11.8 19.3 68.9
Grueb et al. [14] 24 90 0 73.3 1.3 80.0 104.0a 11.1 78.9 10.0
a
Leszczyński et al. [13] 12 81 24.1 0 1.5 83.2 124.8 10.8 78.3 9.6
Kaushik et al. [15] 14.3 66 27.3 13.6 1.16 87.8 N/A 4.5 N/A N/A
Ocakoglu [55] 11.4 32 N/A N/A 1.69a 105.4 178.1a 0 6.3 93.75
CACG, chronic angle-closure glaucoma; N/A, not available; NVG, neovascular glaucoma; POAG, primary open angle glaucoma.
a
Calculated, based on the data in the article.
level. In a prospective study in Ghana [1], TCP was IOP 21 mmHg, success rate was 94% at 1 year
used as primary surgical treatment in one eye of and 82% at 2 years. Forty-five eyes with refractory
patients with POAG. There was a reduction of visual glaucoma underwent ECP treatment (73.3% of
acuity in 23% of cases, but also a similar reduction in which had combined surgery) [59]. IOP decreased
fellow eyes treated with medications alone. Report- significantly from 32.6 to 14.0 mmHg. The success
ing from the national survey [57] evaluated current (IOP < 22 mmHg) rate was 82.2% at 21 months. No
practice of TPC treatment in the United Kingdom statistically significant association was noted for
(47% of respondents were glaucoma subspecialist), preoperative diagnosis, and extent of treatment or
60% of the respondents performed diode laser at any rout of ECP with success or failure of the procedure.
visual acuity, whereas 22% performed combined Efficacy of ECP has been reported not only for
cyclodiode and cataract surgery. After TCP, it is refractory glaucoma [58–60], but also for severe
difficult to ascertain whether loss of vision results corneal disease [61,62], pediatric glaucoma
from treatment or from the natural progression of [61,63,64–66], and aphakic glaucoma [65,66].
glaucoma. Although these favorable data may be Twelve eyes of pediatric glaucoma with corneal
related to lower energy settings and the relatively opacities were treated [61]. Baseline IOP was
higher proportion of POAG and less severe forms of 36.8 mmHg before ECP versus 28.2 mmHg after first
glaucoma than in prior studies, these results suggest treatment. Success (IOP 21 mmHg) of first ECP was
a possible role for the use of TCP in the selected eyes 17% at 12 months. ECP were performed in 36 eyes of
&&
with significant visual potential [23 ]. pediatric glaucoma [64]. Baseline IOP decreased
from 35.1 to 23.6 mmHg after an average of 1.42
endolaser procedures. Success rate of the initial
TREATMENT RESULTS OF ENDOSCOPIC procedure was 34% and cumulative success rate after
DIODE CYCLOPHOTOCOAGULATION all procedures was 43%. Carter et al. [65] performed
ECP was performed in 68 eyes with refractory ECP for 25 patients under 16 years of age with
glaucoma [58]. The mean IOP decreased from 27.7 aphakic or pseudophakic glaucoma. The average
to 17.0 mmHg. Using a success definition of number of procedures per eye was 1.5. Pretreatment
1040-8738 ß 2013 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins www.co-ophthalmology.com 107
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Glaucoma
IOP averaged 32.6 mmHg, compared with a final significance was reported at all time points compar-
postoperative average of 22.9 mmHg. Success (IOP ing IOP with from baseline (23.1 mmHg) to 2
of >24 mmHg and IOP lowering of less than 15%) (12.1 mmHg) years. The number of preoperative
rate was 53%. Although endoscopy itself is valuable medications decreased from 1.44 drops preopera-
in pediatric cases with anatomic limitations or alter- tively to 0.37 drops at 2 years. Qualified success
ations, the success rate is not as high as in adult cases (5 IOP 21) was achieved in 90.8% and complete
[64–67]. success (5 IOP 21 without medications) was in
Some studies [68,69] reported the results of ECP 55.7%. A randomized prospective trial [74] compar-
treatment related to tube shunt surgery. In the ECP ing cataract extraction combined with trabeculec-
treatment of uncontrolled glaucoma with a prior tomy (TLE) versus ECP was performed. Success was
Tube, the mean IOP dropped from 24.0 to defined as IOP less than 19 mmHg with a stable
15.4 mmHg and number of medications decreased visual field and optic nerve. A similar decrease in
from 3.2 to 1.5 [68]. Complications seen were IOP (TLE ¼ 32%, ECP ¼ 29%) and success rate
decrease in vision (16.0%) and corneal graft failure (TLE ¼ 72%, ECP ¼ 77%) was obtained at 6 months.
(8%); however, there were no case of hypotony or The success of TLE without medications was higher
phthisis. Lima et al. [69] prospectively compared than ECP (54 versus 32%). The ECP group had much
ECP to the AGV with alternating allocation in quieter eyes than those in the trabeculectomy
68 patients with uncontrolled IOP (35 mmHg) group. The majority of evidence in literature
on medications. The success (6 IOP 21 mmHg) suggests ECP is efficacious in controlling low-risk
rate at 2 years was similar in both groups: 71% for glaucoma of low-risk patients at the time of
the AGV group and 74% with ECP. The eyes that cataract surgery.
underwent AGV had more complications than those
treated with ECP and significantly more worsening
of visual acuity. COMPLICATIONS OF ENDSCOPIC DIODE
Recently, ECP is most commonly performed in CYCLOPHOTOCOAGULATION
conjunction with cataract surgery in cases that Although, there are no clinical trials favoring ECP
are not refractory to maximal medical therapy over TCP, direct visualization of ciliary processes
& &
[70 ,71–78]. Lindfield et al. [70 ] retrospectively allows a targeted, titratable approach with fewer
reviewed 56 patients undergoing phaco-ECP. associated side effects. Histologic studies [79,80]
All patients were early glaucoma (mean devia- confirm that there is less tissue disruption associated
tion > 6 dB) and 86% had POAG. Although, no with ECP than TCP. A study [81] of rabbit eyes shows
statistically significant change was observed that both treatments are associated with occlusive
throughout in number of medications (1.97 at base- vasculopathy, but the endoscopic route is associated
line and 2.07 agents at 24 months), mean IOP with late reperfusion and therefore less chronic poor
decreased from 21.5 to 14.4 mmHg at 24 months. perfusion. Complications associated with ECP in
An article [71] on 40 eyes with 6-month follow-up 5824 eyes reported by The ECP Collaborative Study
documented encouraging IOP reduction. Signifi- Group [75,77] were followings: IOP spike (14.5%),
cant IOP reduction of combined phaco-ECP was hemorrhage (3.8%), serous choroidal effusion
achieved when 1808 (23.6–16.0 mmHg) or 3608 (0.36%), retinal detachment (0.27%), acute graft
(24.5–13.0 mmHg) was cyclophotocoagulated. rejection (5.3%, 3/57), visual loss more than two
Both groups also required statistically fewer drops lines (1.03%, 54/5219), hypotony or phthisis
at 6 months than at baseline (1808 ¼ 2.47–1.93 (0.12%), and cataract progression (24.5%, 261/
drops, 3608 ¼ 2.56–0.52 drops). In the Berke’s stud- 1066). Chronic graft failure, chronic inflammation,
ies [72,77], 626 phaco-ECP eyes were compared with or endophthalmitis was not observed. The incidence
a comparable cohort of 81 eyes with cataract and of serious complications was very low and occurred
glaucoma that underwent phacoemulsification primarily in the NVG and refractory glaucoma
alone. In the phaco-ECP group, IOP decreased by groups. In Lima et al.’s study [73], complications
3.5 (from 19.2 to 15.7 mmHg), whereas in the con- associated with phaco-ECP included IOP spike
trol group, IOP decreased by 0.7 (from 18.2 to (14.4%, 53/368), postoperative fibrin exudates in
18.9 mmHg). The number of glaucoma medications anterior chamber (7.06%), cystoid macular edema
decreased from 1.53 to 0.65 in the phaco-ECP (CME) (4.34%), transitory hypotony (2.17%), and
group, but remained unchanged from 1.20 in phaco iris bombé (1.08%). In Barke’s study [72,77], com-
alone group. As a primary surgical treatment, a paring phaco-ECP to phaco alone, there were no
Brazilian article [73] documented results of serious complications in either group, and no
phaco-ECP for 368 eyes with POAG and cataract. additional complications in the combined group.
The mean follow-up was 35.2 months. Statistical The incidence of CME was equal in both groups
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Update on results and complications of cyclophotocoagulation Ishida
1040-8738 ß 2013 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins www.co-ophthalmology.com 109
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Glaucoma
29. Zhang SH, Dong FT, Mao J, Bian AL. Factors related to prognosis of refractory 56. Wilensky JT, Kammer J. Long-term visual outcome of transscleral laser
glaucoma with diode laser transscleral cyclophotocoagulation treatment. cyclotherapy in eyes with ambulatory vision. Ophthalmology 2004;
Chin Med Sci J 2011; 26:137–140. 111:1389–1392.
30. Kirwan JF, Shah P, Khaw PT. Diode laser cyclophotocoagulation: role in the 57. Agrawal P, Dulku S, Nolan W, Sung V. The UK National Cyclodiode Laser
management of refractory pediatric glaucomas. Ophthalmology 2002; Survey. Eye 2011; 25:168–173.
109:316–323. 58. Chen J, Cohn RA, Lin SC, et al. Endoscopic photocoagulation of the ciliary
31. Autrata R, Rehurek J. Long-term results of transscleral cyclophotocoagulation body for treatment of refractory glaucomas. Am J Ophthalmol 1997;
in refractory pediatric glaucoma patients. Ophthalmologica 2003; 217:393– 124:787–796.
400. 59. Murthy GJ, Murthy PR, Murthy KR, et al. A study of the efficacy of endoscopic
32. Kumar A, Dada T, Singh RP, Kedar S. Diode laser trans-scleral cyclophoto- cyclophotocoagulation for the treatment of refractory glaucomas. Indian J
coagulation for glaucoma following silicone oil removal. Clin Exp Ophthalmol Ophthalmol 2009; 57:127–132.
2001; 29:220–224. 60. Yu MB, Huang SS, Ge J, et al. The clinical study of endoscopic cyclopho-
33. Schlote T, Derse M, Zierhut M. Transscleral diode laser cyclophotocoagula- tocoagulation on the management of refractory glaucoma. Zhonghua Yan Ke
tion for the treatment of refractory glaucoma secondary to inflammatory eye Za Zhi 2006; 42:27–31.
diseases. Br J Ophthalmol 2000; 84:999–1003. 61. Al-Haddad CE, Freedman SF. Endoscopic laser cyclophotocoagulation in
34. Fankhauser F, Kwasniewska S, Van der Zypen E. Cyclodestructive proce- pediatric glaucoma with corneal opacities. J AAPOS 2007; 11:23–28.
dures. I. Clinical and morphological aspects: a review. Ophthalmologica 62. Lee RM, Al Raqqad N, Gomaa A, et al. Endoscopic cyclophotocoagulation in
2004; 218:77–95. osteo-odonto-keratoprosthesis (OOKP) eyes. J Glaucoma 2011; 20:68–69.
35. Manna A, Foster P, Papadopoulos M, Nolan W. Cyclodiode laser in the 63. Barkana Y, Morad Y, Ben-nun J. Endoscopic photocoagulation of the ciliary
treatment of acute angle closure. Eye 2012; 26:742–745. body after repeated failure of trans-scleral diode-laser cyclophotocoagulation.
36. Preussner PR, Ngounou F, Kouogan G. Controlled cyclophotocoagulation Am J Ophthalmol 2002; 133:405–407.
with the 940 nm laser for primary open angle glaucoma in African eyes. 64. Neely DE, Plager DA. Endocyclophotocoagulation for management of difficult
Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 2010; 248:1473–1479. pediatric glaucomas. J AAPOS 2001; 5:221–229.
37. Chang SH, Chen YC, Li CY, Wu SC. Contact diode laser transscleral 65. Carter BC, Plager DA, Neely DE, et al. Endoscopic diode laser cyclophoto-
cyclophotocoagulation for refractory glaucoma: comparison of two treatment coagulation in the management of aphakic and pseudophakic glaucoma in
protocols. Can J Ophthalmol 2004; 39:511–516. children. J AAPOS 2007; 11:34–40.
38. Izgi B, Demirci H, Demirci FY, Turker G. Diode laser cyclophotocoagulation in 66. Plager DA, Neely DE. Intermediate-term results of endoscopic diode laser
refractory glaucoma: comparison between pediatric and adult glaucomas. cyclophotocoagulation for pediatric glaucoma. J AAPOS 1999; 3:131–
Ophthalmic Surg Lasers 2001; 32:100–107. 137.
39. Sood S, Beck AD. Cyclophotocoagulation versus sequential tube shunt as a 67. Lin SC. Endoscopic and transscleral cyclophotocoagulation for the treatment
secondary intervention following primary tube shunt failure in pediatric glau- of refractory glaucoma. J Glaucoma 2008; 17:238–247.
coma. J AAPOS 2009; 13:379–383. 68. Francis BA, Kawji AS, Vo NT, et al. Endoscopic cyclophotocoagulation (ECP)
40. Semchyshyn TM, Tsai JC, Joos KM. Supplemental transscleral diode laser in the management of uncontrolled glaucoma with prior aqueous tube shunt.
cyclophotocoagulation after aqueous shunt placement in refractory glauco- J Glaucoma 2011; 20:523–527.
ma. Ophthalmology 2002; 109:1078–8104. 69. Lima FE, Magacho L, Carvalho DM, et al. A prospective, comparative study
41. Ness PJ, Khaimi MA, Feldman RM, et al. Intermediate term safety and efficacy between endoscopic cyclophotocoagulation and the Ahmed drainage implant
of transscleral cyclophotocoagulation after tube shunt failure. J Glaucoma in refractory glaucoma. J Glaucoma 2004; 13:233–237.
2012; 21:83–88. 70. Lindfield D, Ritchie RW, Griffiths MF. ‘Phaco-ECP’: combined endoscopic
42. Yildirim N, Yalvac IS, Sahin A, et al. A comparative study between diode laser & cyclophotocoagulation and cataract surgery to augment medical control of
cyclophotocoagulation and the Ahmed glaucoma valve implant in neovascular glaucoma. BMJ Open 2012; 2:1–6.
glaucoma: a long-term follow-up. J Glaucoma 2009; 18:192–196. The authors reviewed 58 cases treated with phaco-ECP and proposed the role of
43. Walland MJ. Diode laser cyclophotocoagulation: longer term follow up of a the phaco-ECP in management of glaucoma.
standardized treatment protocol. Clin Exp Ophthalmol 2000; 28:263–267. 71. Kahook MY, Lathrop KL, Noecker RJ. One-site versus two-site endoscopic
44. Martin KR, Broadway DC. Cyclodiode laser therapy for painful, blind glau- cyclophotocoagulation. J Glaucoma 2007; 16:527–530.
comatous eyes. Br J Ophthalmol 2001; 85:474–476. 72. Barke SJ, Sturm RT, Caronia RM, et al. Phacoemulsification combined with
45. Ghosh S, Singh D, Ruddle JB, et al. Combined diode laser cyclophotocoa- endoscopic cyclophotocoagulation (ECP) in the management of cataract and
gulation and intravitreal bevacizumab (Avastin) in neovascular glaucoma. Clin medically controlled glaucoma: A large, long term study. In: American Glau-
Experiment Ophthalmol 2010; 38:353–377. coma Society 16th Annual Meeting; 2–5 March 2006; Charleston, SC;
46. Fong AW, Lee GA, O’Rourke P, Thomas R. Management of neovascular 2006. Abstract 22:47.
glaucoma with transscleral cyclophotocoagulation with diode laser alone versus 73. Lima FE, Carvalho DM, Avila MP. Phacoemulsification and endoscopic
combination transscleral cyclophotocoagulation with diode laser and intravitreal cyclophotocoagulation as primary surgical procedure in coexisting cataract
bevacizumab. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol 2011; 39:318–323. and glaucoma]. Arq Bras Oftalmol 2010; 73:419–422.
47. Contreras I, Noval S, González Martı́n-Moro J, et al. IOP spikes following 74. Gayton JL, Van Der Karr M, Sanders V. Combined cataract and glaucoma
contact transscleral diode laser cyclophotocoagulation. Arch Soc Esp Oftal- surgery: trabeculectomy versus endoscopic laser cycloablation. J Cataract
mol 2004; 79:105–109. Refract Surg 1999; 25:1214–1219.
48. Hossain P, Ghosh G, Vernon SA. Assessing the ’cyclodiode G-probe’ using a 75. The ECP Collaborative Study Group. Complications of ECP: a large, long
grey scale test: reproducibility and differences between probes. Eye 2003; term, multicenter study. Ocul Surg News. February 2006.
17:167–176. 76. The ECP Study Group. Comparison of phaco/ECP to phaco alone in 1000
49. Rao VJ, Dayan M. Lens subluxation following contact transscleral cyclodiode. glaucoma patients; a randomized, prospective including fluorescein angio-
Arch Ophthalmol 2002; 120:1393–1394. graphy in all patients in both groups. Presented at the ASCRS; June 2002;
50. Muqit MM, Menage MJ. Malignant glaucoma after phacoemulsification: treat- Philadelphia, PA.
ment with diode laser cyclophotocoagulation. J Cataract Refract Surg 2007; 77. Berke SJ. Endolaser Cyclophotocoagulation in glaucoma management. Tech
33:130–132. Ophthalmol 2006; 4:74–81.
51. Shen SY, Lai JS, Lam DS. Necrotizing scleritis following diode laser transscleral 78. Yip LW, Yong SO, Earnest A, et al. Endoscopic cyclophotocoagulation for the
cyclophotocoagulation. Ophthalmic Surg Lasers Imaging 2004; 35:251–253. treatment of glaucoma: an Asian experience. Clin Exp Ophthalmol 2009;
52. Kumar N, Chang A, Beaumont P. Sympathetic ophthalmia following ciliary 37:692–697.
body laser cyclophotocoagulation for rubeotic glaucoma. Clin Exp Ophthal- 79. Pantcheva MB, Kahook MY, Schuman JS, Noecker RJ. Comparison of acute
mol 2004; 32:196–198. structural and histopathological changes in human autopsy eyes after endo-
53. Pokroy R, Greenwald Y, Pollack A, et al. Visual loss after transscleral diode scopic cyclophotocoagulation and trans-scleral cyclophotocoagulation. Br J
laser cyclophotocoagulation for primary open-angle and neovascular glauco- Ophthalmol 2007; 91:248–252.
ma. Ophthalmic Surg Lasers Imaging 2008; 39:22–29. 80. Pantcheva MB, Kahook MY, Schuman JS, et al. Comparison of acute
54. Shah P, Lee GA, Kirwan JK, et al. Cyclodiode photocoagulation for refractory structural and histopathological changes of the porcine ciliary processes
glaucoma after penetrating keratoplasty. Ophthalmology 2001; 108:1986– after endoscopic cyclophotocoagulation and transscleral cyclophotocoagu-
1991. lation. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol 2007; 35:270–274.
55. Ocakoglu O, Arslan OS, Kayiran A. Diode laser transscleral cyclophotocoa- 81. Lin SC, Chen MJ, Lin MS, et al. Vascular effects on ciliary tissue from
gulation for the treatment of refractory glaucoma after penetrating kerato- endoscopic versus trans-scleral cyclophotocoagulation. Br J Ophthalmol
plasty. Curr Eye Res 2005; 30:569–574. 2006; 90:496–500.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.