Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5D Forgetting and Memory Disortion (Nevid p224 235)
5D Forgetting and Memory Disortion (Nevid p224 235)
lead to simplifications, omissions of (r) _______ , or even knowledge about the subject, same-(t)_______ identifica-
outright fabrications. tion, and leading or suggestive questioning.
5. Identify factors influencing the reliability of eyewitness 6. Explain why the concept of recovered memory is controversial.
testimony. Some recovered memories may be credible, but others are
Factors affecting the accuracy of eyewitness testimony not. We presently lack the tools to determine which are
include ease of (s) _______, confidence in memory, general (u) _______ and which are not.
Recall It
1. What is the type of memory that corresponds to 3. Match the concepts on the left with their descriptions on the right:
“knowing how”? I. sensory memory a. process by which short-term
memory is converted to
2. Which of the following is not correct?
long-term memory
a. Constructionist theory suggests that memory recall II. short-term memory b. also known as “working”
may not be accurate. memory
b. Information is best recalled when it is consistent with a III. consolidation c. process that uses semantic
person’s memory schemas. coding to transfer short-
c. Eyewitness testimony may be influenced by term memory to long-term
misinformation. memory
d. Flashbulb memories are immune to distortion. IV. elaborative rehearsal d. storage system for fleeting
iconic and echoic memories
Think About It
■ Why is it incorrect to say that memory works like a ■ What factors influence the accuracy of eyewitness
mental camera? testimony?
Everyone is forgetful. Some of us are more forgetful than others. But why do we
CONCept 6.15 forget? Is it simply a matter of memories fading over time? Or are there other
The oldest theory of forgetting, decay the- factors that account for forgetfulness? Degenerative brain diseases, such as Alz-
ory, may explain memory loss that occurs heimer’s disease, are one cause of forgetfulness; another is amnesia, a memory
due to the passage of time, but it fails to
disorder we discuss at the end of this module. Our main focus here, however, is on
account for why some memories are more
normal processes of forgetting. We recount several leading theories of forgetting
enduring.
and highlight the factors that make it easier or harder to remember information.
We begin with decay theory.
Copyright 2018 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part. WCN 02-200-203
M O D U L E 6.2 225
known as decay theory (also called trace theory), was bolstered by early exper- 100
imental studies conducted by one of the founders of experimental psychology,
80
Percent retained
Hermann Ebbinghaus (1850–1909).
An interesting aspect of Ebbinghaus’s experimental work on forgetting is 60
that the only subject in his early studies was himself. To study the processes
40
of memory and forgetting, Ebbinghaus knew he had to eliminate any earlier
associations to the material to be remembered. He devised a method for testing 20
memory that used nonsense syllables (combinations of letters that don’t spell
out anything), such as nuz and lef (Ebbinghaus, 1885). He presented these lists
1 2 3 4 5 6
of syllables to himself and determined the number of trials it took for him to Days
recall them perfectly. He then tested himself again at different intervals to see
how much he would forget over time. The results showed a decline in mem- fIGURE 6.7 Ebbinghaus forgetting
ory that has since become known as the Ebbinghaus forgetting curve (see ■ Fig- Curve
ure 6.7). Forgetting occurred rapidly in the first few hours after learning and then Ebbinghaus showed that forgetting
declined more gradually. It seemed as though memories simply faded over time. By occurs most rapidly shortly after learning
the end of the first day, 66 percent of the information had been lost, and after a and then gradually declines over time.
month, nearly 80 percent was gone (Rupp, 1998).
Ebbinghaus also employed a savings method to test his memory retention. He
first counted the number of times needed to rehearse a list of nonsense syllables in
order to commit it to memory. Then he counted the number of times it took to re-
learn the list after a period of time had elapsed. If it took ten repetitions to learn the
list the first time and five the second, the savings would be 50 percent.
Memory researchers recognize that when people attempt to memorize informa-
tion, they generally retain more information when they space their study sessions
than when they cram them together within a single day (Cepeda et al., 2006). One
reason for this effect, called the massed versus spaced practice effect, is that massed,
or crammed, practice causes mental fatigue that interferes with learning and reten-
tion. A practical implication of this effect should be obvious: When studying for
exams, don’t cram. Rather, space out your study sessions. You’ll learn more and
remember more of what you learn. Also, spaced practice produces the same learning
benefits for other animals, which is useful to keep in mind when trying to train your
dog (Aamodt & Wang, 2008).
Antoine Rouleau/Getty Images
Decay theory helps account for memory loss due to the passage of time. How-
ever, a major weakness of the theory is that it fails to account for the unevenness
with which memory decays over time. Some memories remain well preserved over
time, whereas others quickly fade. One reason for this unevenness is that more dis-
tinctive or unusual information tends to be remembered better over time (Hunt &
Worthen, 2006; Unsworth, Heitz, & Parks, 2008). You’re likely to remember your
first date better than your 14th. You’re also more likely to later recall the name of a
man you were introduced to at a party if the man’s name was Oscar than if it had decay theory A theory of forgetting that
been Michael or Chris. posits that memories consist of traces
laid down in the brain that gradually
Ebbinghaus studied retention of meaningless syllables. When we examine recall
deteriorate and fade away over time (also
of more meaningful information, such as poetry or prose, we find a more gradual called trace theory).
loss of memory over time. Then again, little if any forgetting may occur for impor-
tant life events and knowledge we acquire about our work or career. Another factor savings method A method of testing
that helps explain forgetting is interference (Wixted, 2005). memory retention by comparing the
numbers of trials needed to learn material
with the number of trials needed to relearn
the material at a later time.
Interference Theory: When Learning More Leads massed versus spaced practice
to Remembering Less effect The tendency for retention of
learned material to be greater with spaced
Chances are you have forgotten what you ate for dinner a week ago Wednesday. practice than with massed practice.
The reason for your forgetfulness, according to interference theory, is interference interference theory The belief that
from memories of dinners that preceded and followed that particular dinner. On forgetting is the result of the interference
the other hand, you are unlikely to forget your wedding day because it is so unlike of memories with each other.
Copyright 2018 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part. WCN 02-200-203
226 Chapter 6 MeMory
CONCept 6.16 any other day in your life (except for those, perhaps, who have taken many walks
Interference theory posits that memories down the aisle). Interference theory helps explain why some events may be easily
held in short-term or long-term memory forgotten while others remain vivid for a lifetime. The greater the similarity between
may be pushed aside by other memories. events, the greater the risk of interference. There are two general kinds of interfer-
ence, retroactive interference and proactive interference.
Interference occurring after material is learned but before it is recalled is called
retroactive interference. Perhaps you have found that material you learned in your
9:00 A.M. class, which seemed so clear when you left the classroom, quickly began to
fade once you started soaking in information in the next class. In effect, new memo-
ries retroactively interfere with unstable earlier memories that are still undergoing the
process of memory consolidation (Wixted, 2004).
Proactive interference is caused by the influence of previously learned material.
Because of proactive interference, you may have difficulty remembering a new area
code (you keep dialing the old one by mistake). Or you may forget to advance the
year when writing checks early in a new year. ■ Figure 6.8 illustrates retroactive and
proactive interference.
Though some interference is unavoidable, we can take steps to min-
imize its disruptive effects:
■ Sleep on it. Want to improve your recall of newly learned material?
Sleep on it. Sleep is believed to play an important role in converting
fragile new memories into lasting ones (Cohen et al., 2012). By first
learning course material and then sleeping on it, you may retain
more of what you learn.
CandyBox Images/Shutterstock.com
Retroactive
1
Interference
Proactive
2
Interference
retroactive interference A form of
interference in which newly acquired
information interferes with retention of
material learned earlier. Study philosophy Study psychology Test in psychology
proactive interference A form of at 9 A.M. at 11 A.M. the next day
interference in which material learned
earlier interferes with retention of newly figure 6.8 retroactive and Proactive interference
acquired information. In 1 retroactive interference, new learning (psychology in the first example) interferes with
overlearning Practice repeated beyond recall of previously learned material (philosophy). In 2 proactive interference, previously
the point necessary to reproduce material learned material (philosophy in the second example) interferes with recall of new material
without error. (psychology).
Copyright 2018 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part. WCN 02-200-203
M O D U L E 6.2 227
■ Give yourself a break. Try not to schedule one class directly after another. Give
your recent memories time to consolidate in your brain.
■ Avoid sequential study of similar material. Try not to study material that is
similar in content in back-to-back fashion—for example, avoid scheduling a
French class right after a Spanish one.
Interference may help explain the serial position effect, the tendency to recall
the first and last items in a list, such as a shopping list, better than those in the
middle of the list. The unfortunate items in the middle are often forgotten. Putting
the serial position effect to the test, researchers asked college students to recall
Copyright 2018 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part. WCN 02-200-203
228 Chapter 6 MeMory
CONCept 6.17 to encode more specific details of a coin to recognize one or use it correctly, such
The serial position effect explains why we information may not be encoded and thus cannot be retrieved (see also the Try This
are more likely to forget the middle items Out titled “What Does a Dime Look Like”?).
in a list than those at the beginning or end. Events that stand out tend to be better remembered. You are also more likely to re-
member events that occur irregularly (for example, visits to a doctor because of an in-
CONCept 6.18 jury) than regularly occurring events (for example, routine medical checkups). Events
Memory retrieval may be impaired by a
that are similar are generally encoded in terms of their common features rather than
failure to encode information and by a lack
their distinctive characteristics. Because similar events tend to be encoded in similar
of retrieval cues to access stored memories.
ways, it becomes more difficult to retrieve memories of the specific events.
Copyright 2018 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part. WCN 02-200-203
M O D U L E 6.2 229
william87/Getty Images
first few letters or sounds of the word or name (“I know it starts
with a B”), or perhaps a similar-sounding word comes to mind.
TOTs may result not only from a lack of available retrieval cues
but also from more general difficulties with word retrieval. TOTs
tend to increase later in life, when word retrieval typically be- ”What’s his name? Wait, I’ve got it on the
comes more difficult (Theocharopoulou et al., 2015). tip of my tongue.”
Copyright 2018 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part. WCN 02-200-203
230 Chapter 6 MeMory
CONCept 6.21 an essay question, you are asked to reproduce information you have committed to
The methods used to measure memory, memory. There are three basic types of recall task. In free recall, you are asked to re-
such as recall tasks and recognition tasks, call as much information as you can in any order you wish (for example, randomly
affect how much we are able to recall. naming starting players on your college’s basketball team). In a serial recall task, you
are asked to recall a series of items or numbers in a particular order (for example, re-
CONCept 6.22 citing a telephone number). In paired-associates recall, you are first asked to memo-
There are two general types of amnesia: rize pairs of items, such as pairs of unrelated words like shoe–crayon and cat–phone.
retrograde amnesia (loss of memory of
You are then presented with one item in each pair, such as the word shoe, and asked
past events) and anterograde amnesia
to recall the item with which it was paired (crayon). If you’ve ever taken a foreign
(loss or impairment of the ability to form
or store new memories). language exam in which you were presented with a word in English and asked to
produce the foreign word for it, you know what a paired-associates recall task is.
In a recognition task, you are asked to pick out the correct answer from among a
range of alternative answers. Tests of recognition memory, such as multiple-choice tests,
generally produce much better retrieval than those of recall memory, largely because
recognition tests provide retrieval cues. You’re more likely to remember the name of the
author of Moby Dick if you see the author’s name among a group of multiple-choice
responses than if you are asked to complete a recall task, such as a fill-in-the-blank item
in which you are required to insert the author’s name (Herman Melville).
William Perugini/Shutterstock.com
Types of Amnesia
The medical student suffered from retrograde amnesia, or loss of memory of past
events. A football player knocked unconscious by a blow to the head during a game
may remember nothing beyond suiting up in the locker room. A boxer knocked cold
in the ring may not remember the fight. A blow to the head can interfere with mem-
ory consolidation—which, as we noted in Module 6.1, is the process of converting
free recall A type of recall task in which unstable, short-term memories into stable and enduring ones. When this process is
individuals are asked to recall as much disrupted, memories of events occurring around the time of the disruption may be
information as they can about a particular lost permanently. Some cases go beyond problems with memory consolidation. The
topic in any order. medical student’s memory loss extended beyond the time of his head injury to before
recognition task A method of measuring he had met his wife. In such cases, whole chunks of memory are lost. Nonetheless,
memory retention that assesses the ability recent memories are generally more susceptible to retrograde amnesia than remote
to select the correct answer from among a events (James & MacKay, 2001). In another form of amnesia, anterograde amnesia,
range of alternative answers. people cannot form or store new memories or have difficulty doing so.
amnesia Loss of memory.
retrograde amnesia Loss of memory of Causes of Amnesia
past events. Amnesia may be caused by physical or psychological factors. Physical causes include blows
anterograde amnesia Loss or impairment to the head, degenerative brain diseases (such as Alzheimer’s disease; see Chapter 9), block-
of the ability to form or store new age of blood vessels to the brain, infectious diseases, and chronic alcoholism. Amnesias in
memories. some cases may be reversed if the underlying physical problem is successfully treated.
Copyright 2018 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part. WCN 02-200-203
M O D U L E 6.2 231
Decay theory Gradual fading of memory traces as a function Facts you learned in school gradually fade out
of time of memory over time.
Theories of forgetting
Interference theory Disruption of memory caused by interference After sitting through your biology lecture, you
of previously learned material or newly forget what you learned in chemistry class the
learned material hour before.
Retrieval theory Failure to access material stored in memory You have difficulty remembering something
because of encoding failure or lack of you know is stored in memory.
retrieval cues
Motivated forgetting Repression of anxiety-provoking material You cannot remember a traumatic childhood
experience.
Recall task Test of the ability to reproduce information You recite a phone number or the capitals of U.S.
Measuring
Recognition task Test of the ability to recognize material held You recognize the correct answer in a
in memory multiple-choice question.
Retrograde amnesia Loss of memory of past events After suffering a blow to the head in a car
accident, you are unable to remember details
Amnesia
Types of
Anterograde Loss or impairment of the ability to form or Because of a brain disorder, you find it difficult
amnesia store new memories to retain new information.
Recite It
7. Describe the major theories and factors in forgetting. (c) _______ theory holds that forgetting is the result of a
(a) _______ theory holds that forgetting results from the failure to access stored memories.
gradual deterioration of memory traces in the brain. (d) _______ forgetting, or repression, is the Freudian be-
(b) _______ theory is the belief that forgetting results lief that people banish anxiety-provoking material from
from the interference of memories with each other. conscious awareness.
Copyright 2018 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part. WCN 02-200-203