4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

Subject-Wise Law Notes Lifting Of Corporate Veil Of The Companies In India

Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in

India
Corporate Law Subject-Wise Law Notes

LawBhoomi ● January 6, 2021

Share & spread the love

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 1/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

Contents
1. Abstract
2. Definition of a Company
3. What is corporate veil?
4. Lifting of corporate veil:
5. Conducts on which corporate veil can be lifted:
6. Statutory Provisions dealing with Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in
India
7. Judicial Interpretations of Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India
8. Conclusion

Abstract
A company is seen as an individual person in eyes of law. A Company is treated as
a significant human in legislation. There are various aspects and duties performed
by employees of the company and Directors of the company under companies act,
2013. Responsibilities of directors stipulated by the Indian companies Act of 2013,
under its section 166:    A director of a company shall act in accordance with the
Articles of Association (AOA) of the company. A director of the company shall act in
good faith. A director of a company shall exercise his duties with due and
reasonable care, skill and diligence and shall exercise independent judgment. A
director of a company shall not involve in a situation in which he may have a direct
or indirect interest that conflicts, or possibly may conflict, with the interest of the
company.

A director of a company shall not achieve or attempt to achieve any undue gain or
advantage either to himself or to his relatives, partners, or associates. Company and
its members have different persona, but every member that works under the
company have similar intention to expand and establish it in renowned way. The
members who perform unethically and in false way always choose the option to
work unlawfully behind the company, from which whole company Is held liable for
their immoral work.

  In this company’s character is shown wrong and their misdeed members behind
this unlawful work easily hide their inexpert character behind company spiffing
character. these member’s take advantage of company for their selfish motives by
perform illegal acts. Thus, this article elaborates, define the various aspects of the

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 2/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

doctrine of lifting the corporate veil and judiciary to identify the real culprit behind
such unlawful acts.

Definition of a Company
The word company has no strictly technical or legal meaning. it may be described
to imply an association of persons for some common object or objects. The word
company, in simple term, may be described to mean a voluntary association of
person who have come together for carrying on some business and sharing the
profits there from.

A more precise, global and modern definition of a company could be:

A business entity which acts as an artificial legal person, formed by a legal person or

a group of legal persons to engage in or carry on a business or industrial
enterprise.

According to the law in the USA:

A company can be a “corporation,  partnership, association,  joint-stock

company, trust, fund, or organized group of persons, whether incorporated or not,
and (in an official capacity) any receiver, trustee in bankruptcy, or similar official, or
liquidating agent, for any of the foregoing”

The Companies Act 2013 of India defines a company as-

A registered association which is an artificial legal person, having an independent

legal, entity with a perpetual succession, a common seal for its signatures, a
common capital comprised of transferable shares and carrying limited liability.

What is corporate veil?

Corporate veil helps in differentiate between the personality of corporation from
the personality of its shareholders, and protects them from being personally or
individually liable for the company debts, unlawful Acts, and other obligations.

Lifting of corporate veil:

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 3/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

At times it may happen that the corporate personality of the company is used to
commit frauds and improper or illegal acts. Since an artificial person is not capable
of doing anything illegal or fraudulent, the façade of corporate personality might
have to be removed to identify the persons who are really guilty. This is known as
‘lifting of corporate veil’.

It refers to the situation where a shareholder is held liable for its corporation’s
debts despite the rule of limited liability and/or separate personality. The veil
doctrine is invoked when shareholders blur the distinction between the corporation
and the shareholders. A company or corporation can only act through human
agents that compose it. As a result, there are two main ways through which a
company becomes liable in company or corporate law: firstly, through direct
liability (for direct infringement) and secondly through secondary liability (for acts
of its human agents acting in the course of their employment).

There are two existing theories for the lifting of the corporate veil. The first is the
“alter-ego” or other self-theory, and the other is the “instrumentality” theory.

The alter-ego theory considers if there is in distinctive nature of the boundaries

between the corporation and its shareholders.

The instrumentality theory on the other hand examines the use of a corporation by
its owners in ways that benefit the owner rather than the corporation. It is up to the
court to decide on which theory to apply or make a combination of the two
doctrines.

Conducts on which corporate veil can be lifted:

This explains if shareholders can be held liable for corporate veil. This operation
helps to identify the real culprit behind illegal work conducted in company and
separate false accused or shareholders of company. This also explains the real
personality of the company by exposing personality of culprit performing illegal
tasks inside company.

In other terms, where the shareholders take the corporate personality of the
company as a means to commit fraud and unlawful tasks, then the court will break
through the corporate shell and apply the principal of “lifting of piercing through
the corporate veil “. In united states V. Milwaukee refrigerator Co., it was observed
that “A corporation is considered to have a separate legal entity as a general rule

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 4/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

but when the notion of legal entity is used to defeat public convenience, justify
wrong, protect fraud or defend crime the law will regard the corporation as an
association of persons”.

Statutory Provisions dealing with Lifting of Corporate

Veil of the Companies in India
Section 5 of the Companies Act defines the individual person committing a wrong
or an illegal act to be held liable in respect of offenses as ‘officer who is in default’.
This section gives a list of officers who shall be liable to punishment or penalty
under the expression ‘officer who is in default’ which includes a managing director
or a whole-time director.

Section 45– Reduction of membership below statutory minimum: This section

provides that if the members of a company is reduced below seven in the case of a
public company and below two in the case of a private company (given in Section
12) and the company continues to carry on the business for more than six months,
while the number is so reduced, every person who knows this fact and is a member
of the company is severally liable for the debts of the company contracted during
that time.

In the case of  Madan lal v. Himatlal & Co.  the respondent filed suit against a
private limited company and its directors for recovery of dues. The directors
resisted the suit on the ground that at no point of time the company did carry on
business with members below the legal minimum and therefore, the directors
could not be made severally liable for the debt in question. It was held that it was
for the respondent being  dominus litus,  to choose persons of his choice to be
sued. 

Section 147-  Misdescription of name: Under sub-section (4) of this section, an

officer of a company who signs any bill of exchange, hundi, promissory note,
cheque wherein the name of the company is not mentioned is the prescribed
manner, such officer can be held personally liable to the holder of the bill of
exchange, hundi etc. unless it is duly paid by the company. Such instance was
observed in the case of Hendon v. Adelman.

Section 239– Power of inspector to investigate affairs of another company in same

group or management: It provides that if it is necessary for the satisfactory
completion of the task of an inspector appointed to investigate the affairs of the

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 5/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

company for the alleged mismanagement, or oppressive policy towards its

members, he may investigate into the affairs of another related company in the
same management or group.

Section 275- Subject to the provisions of Section 278, this section provides that no
person can be a director of more than 15 companies at a time. Section 279
provides for a punishment with fine which may extend to Rs. 50,000 in respect of
each of those companies after the first twenty.

Section 299-  This Section gives effect to the following recommendation of the
Company Law Committee: “It is necessary to provide that the general notice which
a director is entitled to give to the company of his interest in a particular company
or firm under the proviso to sub-section (1) of section 91-A should be given at a
meeting of the directors or take reasonable steps to secure that it is brought up
and read at the next meeting of the Board after it is given. The section applies to all
public as well as private companies. Failure to comply with the requirements of this
Section will cause vacation of the office of the Director and will also subject him to
penalty under sub-section (4).

  Sections 307 and 308-  Section 307 applies to every director and every deemed
director. Not only the name, description and amount of shareholding of each of the
persons mentioned but also the nature and extent of interest or right in or over any
shares or debentures of such person must be shown in the register of shareholders.

Section 314-  The object of this section is to prohibit a director and anyone
connected with him, holding any employment carrying remuneration of as such
sum as prescribed or more under the company unless the company approves of it
by a special resolution.

  Section 542-  Fraudulent conduct: If in the course of the winding up of the

company, it appears that any business of the company has been carried on with
intent to defraud the creditors of the company or any other person or for any
fraudulent purpose, the persons who were knowingly parties to the carrying on of
the business, in the manner aforesaid, shall be personally responsible, without any
limitation of liability for all or any of the debts or other liabilities of the company, as
the court may direct. In Popular Bank Ltd., In re it was held that section 542 appears
to make the directors liable in disregard of principles of limited liability. It leaves
the Court with discretion to make a declaration of liability, in relation to ‘all or any
of the debts or other liabilities of the company’. This section postulates a nexus
between fraudulent reading or purpose and liability of persons concerned.
https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 6/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

Judicial Interpretations of Lifting of Corporate Veil of

the Companies in India
By contrast with the limited and careful statutory directions to ‘lift the veil’ judicial
inroads into the principle of separate personality are more numerous. Besides
statutory provisions for lifting the corporate veil, courts also do lift the corporate
veil to see the real state of affairs. Some cases where the courts did lift the veil are
as follows:

Daimler Co. Ltd. v. Continental Tyre and Rubber Co. (Great Britain) Ltd This is
an instance of determination of the enemy character of a company. In this case,
there was a German company. It set up a subsidiary company in Britain and entered
into a contract with Continental Tyre and Rubber Co. (Great Britain) Ltd. for the
supply of tyre . During the time of war, the British company refused to pay as
trading with an alien company is prohibited during that time. To find out whether
the company was a German or a British company, the Court lifted the veil and
found out that since the decision-making bodies, the board of directors and the
general body of shareholders were controlled by Germans, the company was a
German company and not a British company and hence it was an enemy company. 

Gilford Motor Co. v. Horne– This is an instance for prevention of façade or sham.

In this case, an employee entered into an agreement that after his employment is
terminated, he shall not enter into a competing business or he should not solicit
their customers by setting up his own business. After the defendant’s service was
terminated, he set up a company of the same business.

His wife and another employee were the main shareholders and the directors of
the company. Although it was in their name, he was the main controller of the
business and the business solicited customers of the previous company. The Court
held that the formation of the new company was a mere cloak or sham to enable
him to breach the agreement with the plaintiff. 

Re, FG (Films) Ltd–  In this case the court refused to compel the board of film
censors to register a film as an English film, which was in fact produced by a
powerful American film company in the name of a company registered in England
in order to avoid certain technical difficulties. The English company was created
with a nominal capital of 100 pounds only, consisting of 100 shares of which 90
were held by the American president of the company. The Court held that the real

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 7/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

producer was the American company and that it would be a sham to hold that the
American company and American president were merely agents of the English
company for producing the film. 

Jones v. Lipman–  In this case, the seller of a piece of land sought to evade the
specific performance of a contract for the sale of the land by conveying the land to
a company which he formed for the purpose and thus he attempted to avoid
completing the sale of his house to the plaintiff. Russel J. describing the company
as a “devise and a sham, a mask which he holds before his face and attempt to
avoid recognition by the eye of equity” and ordered both the defendant and his
company specifically to perform the contract with the plaintiff. 

Conclusion

There are many corporate companies and many their members who perform fraud,
illegal Acts and blame it under the name of company. This doctrine of lifting or
piercing of corporate veil helps to find the real culprit behind such unlawful acts.
this doctrine provide justice to personality of company by exposing malicious
personality of culprit. This doctrine works as a very useful tool for judiciary to find
the imposter in crew. There is strict punishment for such unlawful offences under
companies Act ,2013.

Author: Simran Singh Chandel [Student, New Law College, BVDU, Pune]

Attention all law students!

Are you tired of missing out on internship, job opportunities and law notes?

Well, fear no more! With 22,000+ students already on board, you don't want to be
left behind. Be a part of the coolest legal community around!

Join our WhatsApp Groups (Click Here) and Telegram Channel (Click Here) and
get instant notifications.

Follow us on Instagram (Click Here) for amazing legal content.

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 8/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

PREVIOUS NEXT

Contract of Bailment under Indian Incorporation of a Company under

Contract Act Companies Act, 2013

You might like

volenti non fit injuria

Criminal Misappropriation of Property IPC

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 9/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

Order 9 Rul 4 CPC

Submit Posts

Search Search

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 10/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 11/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 12/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

Law Notes

Case Briefs

Law Notes for All Subjects

Administrative Law Notes

Arbitration & Conciliation Act Notes

Law of Contracts Notes

Constitutional Law Notes

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 13/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

Corporate Law Notes

CRPC Notes

Cyber Law Notes

Environmental Law Notes

Law of Evidence Notes

Family Law Notes

Human Rights Law Notes

International Law Notes

Indian Partnership Act Notes

Indian Penal Code Notes

Intellectual Property Rights Notes

Jurisprudence Notes

Law of Torts Notes

Sale of Goods Act Notes

Transfer of Property Act Notes

Other Laws Notes

Subscribe for the latest posts NOW!

We promise, we won't spam!

Email

Email

Submit

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 14/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

Leave a Reply
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Name *

Email *

Website

Add Comment *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Post Comment

About LawBhoomi

Started by NLU grads, LawBhoomi is a portal that provides information on the latest

internships, jobs, legal opportunities, law notes, career guidance, study materials, and
books for various exams like the judiciary, CLAT PG, AIBE, CLAT UG, etc. Apart from all
these, interviews and internship experiences help students explore more opportunities in
law.

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 15/16
4/22/23, 4:33 PM Lifting of Corporate Veil of the Companies in India

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

Important Statistics

Site visitors: 3,00,000+ per month

Page views: 5,50,000+ per month

Instagram followers: 9,000+ (Click Here)

LinkedIn followers: 16,250+ (Click Here)

WhatsApp groups: 12,000+ members (Click Here)

Contact Info

You may reach out to us by dropping an email to:

contact@lawbhoomi.com or lawbhoomi@gmail.com

Copyright © 2022 LawBhoomi. 

https://lawbhoomi.com/lifting-of-corporate-veil-of-the-companies-in-india/ 16/16