Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI: https://doi.org/10.52403/ijhsr.20221135
ABSTRACT
Plant based milk alternatives are emerging functional beverages. Dietary transition to veganism, rising
prevalence of endocrinal disorders, lactose intolerance, cow milk allergies and intolerances, acne is an
avenue for increasing need for milk alternatives. This review considered research papers from the past
11 years (2011 - 2022) from PubMed database, using keywords - plant based milk alternatives, plant
based milk substitutes, plant based milk analogues, nutritional composition of plant based milk versus
cow milk. Five commonly consumed plant milks were selected and discussed further. Coconut milk
had highest and almond milk had lowest total energy. Total carbohydrate was highest in rice milk and
lowest in almond milk, but oat milk had the highest sugar and coconut milk had no sugar. Soy milk
and coconut milk had better protein content. Coconut milk had higher fat - lauric acid and MCTs.
Vitamins A, D and E were found to be a good source in oat, soy and almond milk. All 5 plant milks
were a good source of calcium. Plant milks were beneficial for lactose intolerance, reducing
cholesterol, diabetes, CVD, cancer, and had immune boosting properties. Hence, it’s a healthier
functional beverage when cow milk needs to be replaced in the diet.
hypercholesterolemia (Sethi et al., 2016: are decreasing with the rise in plant-based
3408-3423). milk options (Narsaria and Rajyalakshmi,
These alternative milks are also called as 2020; Stewart, 2020).
plant extracts, ‘non-dairy alternatives’ The current review is being undertaken with
(Silva et al., 2020: 131; Vanga and the aim of understanding the various types
Raghavan, 2018: 10-20). Silva et al., (2020) of plant-based alternatives to milk as when
described plant-based milk alternatives as compared to cow milk, most of the plant-
water soluble extracts resulting from the based milk alternatives lack nutrient
breakdown of plant material (cereals, balance; however, they contain functionally
legumes, nuts and oilseeds) and then active components with health-promoting
homogenizing it to make it look like cow properties, which attracts health-conscious
milk (Silva et al., 2020: 131). In contrast to consumers. And this study was also
the above study, according to Pritulska et undertaken to understand the various kinds
al., (2021) the term “plant-based milk” is of plant-based milk alternatives and its
incorrect, as this beverage is extracted from nutritional content.
nuts, oilseeds, cereals and mixed with a Articles from the past 11 years (January
specific proportion of water. This name can 2011-June 2022) were included for review.
mislead the consumer thinking that it has The search strategy for the review was as
similar nutritional value like the cow milk. follows: a number of studies searched on
Thus, it should be named as “plant-based engines such as PubMed, and ResearchGate.
milk analogues”, as analogues seem to The key words used were Plant based milk
resemble or are similar to other things. And alternatives, plant based milk substitutes,
since these products have similar plant based milk analogues, comparison of
appearance and content, it is called milk. A plant based milk and cow milk, nutritional
general classification of the plant- composition of plant based milk were the
based/vegetable milk alternatives is given in different search terms used to find the
Table 1. article.
Plant-based milk such as soy milk, almond
milk, and oat milk have recently made their Plant Based Milk alternatives
way to the cafe menus and shopping lists of Plant-based or non-dairy milk substitutes
Indian consumers. Since around 2020, are a rapidly growing market worldwide due
plant-based milk accounted for 15% of the to changing needs and urbanization (Park,
total dollar sales in the United States 2021; Sethi et al., 2016: 3408-3423).
(Narsaria and Rajyalakshmi, 2020). Despite having fewer nutrients than cow
According to market research firm IRI, in milk, it is accepted due to its functional
the US 14% of the households buy vegan properties and the various downfalls of
milk (Chiorando, 2020). According to the cow’s milk. Firstly, due to the presence of
data below, it can be anticipated that Indian various pathogens such as Salmonella,
consumers may incorporate this product, Escherichia it can cause widespread
along with animal-derived dairy (Narsaria outbreak of diseases. Also because cow
and Rajyalakshmi, 2020). milk allergy is common in infants and
Both in India and US consumers claim that children, likewise another widespread
they will be using both types of milk and problem being lactose intolerance on
cow milk being their staple. Even among consumption of cow milk, as it is the
those who purchased plant-based primary source of lactose in human diet, and
alternatives, 90% continued to purchase yet other issues of cow milk consumption is
cow's milk. This clearly demonstrates that higher calories and hypercholesterolemia,
the potential for plant-based alternatives is and thus plant-based alternatives can
increasing alongside cow milk rather than provide them another option. Few studies
instead of it. However, the sales of cow milk have also discovered a link between higher
Oat Milk 131). Oat milk has more CHO than cow's
Oats also known as Avena sativa, contains milk, with starch and sugars (4g). One
functional component such as -glucan, downside of drinking oat milk by diabetics
protein (with good quality protein and is that it includes higher total carbohydrate
balanced amino acids) lipids, micronutrients per serving than cow's milk. All these
like vitamin A, D, E and B1 and minerals drawbacks are overcomed by using proper
like calcium, potassium, sodium, processing methods to provide health
magnesium and iron, as well as antioxidants benefits of oat milk (Cooper et al., 2020).
and phytochemicals (Ismail, 2015: 155-156;
Syed, 2020). Thus due to its excellent Soy Milk
nutritional composition oat milk is gaining Soyabean (Glycine max) and soy milk is
importance in today’s market. Thereby widely consumed as an alternative to cow
having potential health benefits such as milk due to similar nutritional composition
helps reducing and maintaining weight, to cow milk and possessing various health
blood glucose, cholesterol and triglyceride promoting properties (Nowshin et al., 2018:
levels that is due to the presence of soluble 158-163). It is also extensively used as a
fiber which delays the gastric emptying time milk alternative for those who have cow
as well as increases the gastrointestinal milk protein allergy and lactose intolerance.
transit time, has anticancer properties and However, people who have cow milk
also has beneficial effects on digestive protein allergy are highly probable to have
health (Ismail, 2015: 155-156; Sethi et al., soy allergy too (Silva et al., 2020: 131).
2016: 3408-3423; Silva et al., 2020: 131; Nevertheless, it is a good source of macro
Syed, 2020). It is also suggested as a milk and micronutrients. It contains essential
alternative for those who have irritable amino acids that are comparable to that of
bowel syndrome (IBS) and inflammatory humans but low in CHO. It also consists of
bowel disease (IBD), as it is a part of an essential fatty acids: monounsaturated and
anti-inflammatory diet (Basinskiene and polyunsaturated fatty acids (MUFAs and
Cizeikiene, 2020: 63-69). The nutritional PUFAs), vitamins and minerals and no
content of oat milk in 240ml milk is as cholesterol; is rich in phytochemicals (like
follows: 130 kcal, 24g CHO, 4g proteins, phytosterols, isoflavones, genistein,
2.5g fats, 350mg calcium, 101 IU vitamin saponins, phytic acid etc) and have lipid
D, 499 IU vitamin A (Bridges, 2018). lowering and antioxidant properties. All of
There are some of the drawbacks of oat the above properties make it suitable to have
milk. Firstly, the lipase which is present can therapeutic benefits and provide protection
cause rancidity and also shortens shelf life against several diseases like: CVD, diabetes,
of the product, but use of high temperature BP, cancer, renal issues, osteoporosis
can denature the enzyme (4). Secondly, (Anisur et al., 2016: 192-203; Eslami and
Phytic acid/ phytate- antinutritional factors Shidfar, 2019: 82-88; Nowshin et al., 2018:
are present in oat which hinders the 158-163). Thereby soybean is also called
absorption of some essential nutrients. They “golden miracle bean” (Kant and Broadway,
also attempted to replenish the nutrients that 2015: 1159-1162).
were lost during processing through In Spite of many benefits, it also has few
enrichment (Silva et al., 2020: 131). downsides. Firstly, because of its peculiar
Thirdly, using oat milk as a substitute for beany flavor but many techniques are
dairy milk can cause calcium deficiency, as utilised to reduce beany flavor and increase
oats are not rich in calcium. Thus, oats milk the shelf life. Secondly, it contains certain
needs to be fortified with calcium, as it is antinutritional components such as trypsin
important for growth and development inhibitor, phytates, oxalates which form an
before being used as a substitute (Sethi et insoluble complex and hinders mineral
al., 2016: 3408-3423; Silva et al., 2020: absorption. However, different processing
techniques are involved in removing anti- diseases, retards aging and nourishes skin
nutrients. Thus, its consumption declined and has soothing effects (Karunasiri et al.,
and preference for almond milk increased. 2020; Tulashie et al., 2022). In a study it
But at the same time it is widely consumed was found that on supplementation of
due to its nutritional content of soy milk in coconut milk HDL levels increased and
240ml is 100 kcal, 7.9g CHO, 8g proteins, thereby being protective against CVD
4g fats, 299mg calcium, 501 IU of vitamin (Ekanayaka et al., 2013). The nutritional
A, 119 IU of vitamin D; and also it is easily content of coconut milk in 100 ml is as
digested; is low in cost and has various follows: Energy - 60 kcal, CHO - 5.3 g,
health benefits (Bridges, 2018; protein - 3.2 g, fat - 3.3 g, calcium - 113 mg
Karimdastjerd and Konsukan, 2021: 294- (Tulashie et al., 2022).
310; Sethi et al., 2016: 3408-3423; Silva et
al., 2020: 131; Vanga and Raghavan, 2018: Almond Milk
10-20). Almonds (Prunus dulcis) are the most
widely consumed nut. This may be owing to
Coconut Milk its well-known therapeutic qualities, like:
Coconut (Cocosnucifera L.) is used in a having good quality lipids, antioxidants like
variety of forms like from fresh to processed alpha-tocopherol and arabinose and have
products - desiccated coconut, coconut milk immune boosting properties (Kundu et al.,
and coconut oil. Coconut milk is being 2018: 203-210). And also almond milk is
widely used at both household as well as getting more popular as it is low in calories
industrial level for preparations of a variety (Torna et al., 2014: 215-222). It has 50%
of food products and also as a milk less calories when compared to cow milk
alternative (Alyaqoubi et al., 2015: 967- and therefore is utlised by the people for
973). Coconut milk does not appear to cause weight reduction (Katz, 2018: 4-12). A
allergic responses and is appropriate for study has found that daily consumption of
those who are lactose intolerant. Although almond milk for four weeks has shown to
coconut milk is rich in calories and fats reduce weight, BMI and waist and hip
when compared with cow milk and other circumferences (Zaidan and Tamimi 2016:
plant based milks, it mainly contains 466-471). It consists of balanced nutrition
medium chain triglycerides, which are with CHO, protein, fats with higher
easily digested and also contains lauric acid percentage of monounsaturated fatty acids
which has been shown to cause apoptosis in and no cholesterol, fiber, vitamins and
breast and endometrial cancer cells, mineral like calcium, magnesium,
therefore boosting the immune system and phosphorus, potassium, sodium, selenium,
maintaining blood vessels pliability. The zinc, vitamin C, B1, B2, B3, B6, B9 and
lauric acid is converted to monolaurin which vitamin E (Torna et al., 2014: 215-222;
exerts anti-microbial, anti-bacterial, and Savchuk et al., 2015; Zaidan and Tamimi
anti-viral properties and protects against 2016: 466-471). Almond milk has been
infections (Alyaqoubi et al., 2015: 967-973; demonstrated to lower blood vessel
Tulashie et al., 2022). Also consumption of resistance and enhance the flow of blood,
coconut milk may reduce the risk for oxygen, and nutrients and maintain BP
cardiovascular diseases and stroke due to (Alozie, 2015: 117-121). It is also believed
the presence of lauric acid (Alyaqoubi et al., to enhance eyesight, help in the
2015: 967-973). It also contains some development of strong bones, and maintain
phenolic components and has antioxidant proper renal function (Savchuk et al., 2015).
properties (contains vitamin E) which It is also an appropriate alternative for
confers benefiting role against oxidative people with lactose intolerance however, is
stress and damage, has anti-cancer not suitable for those who have nut allergy
properties, prevents against degenerative (Katz, 2018: 4-12). The nutritional content
in 240ml almond milk is as follows: Energy calcium - 450mg, vit D - 100 IU (Bridges,
- 59kcals, CHO - 6g, Protein - 1g, Fats - 4g, 2018).
Sethi S, Tyagi SK and Anurag RK (2016) Plant-based milk alternatives an emerging segment
of functional beverages: a review. Journal of Food Science and Technology 53(9): 3408–23.
Table 2a. Overview of nutritional composition of plant based milk alternatives (per 100ml)
Plant milk and Energy CHO Sugar Fiber Protein Fat Vitamins and Minerals
Bioactive (kcals) (g) (g) (g) (g) (g)
Rice milk 54 11.25 5.8 0 0.42 0.82 Calcium 125 mg, high in selenium and magnesium
Oat milk 54 10 7.9 1.9 1.6 1 Calcium - 145.8mg Vitamin A -207.9 IU,
Soy milk 42 3.29 2.5 1 3.3 1.66 Calcium - 124.5 mg, Vitamin A - 208.7 IU, Vitamin
D2 - 49.5 IU
Coconut milk 60 5.3 - 3.2 3.3 Calcium - 133 mg, Vitamin E
Almond milk 25 2.5 2 0.9 0.41 1.66 Calcium-188 mg, Vit D2 - 41.6 IU, Vitamin E -
Table 2b. Bioactive compounds and their health benefits of plant based milk alternatives
Plant milk Bioactive Health benefit
Rice milk Phytosterol - b-sitosterol and c- Reduces cholesterol, has anti-hypertensive, anti-diabetic, anti-inflammatory and anti-
oryzanol oxidative properties
Oat milk 𝜷-glucan Reduces and maintains weight, blood glucose, cholesterol and triglyceride levels, delays
gastric and gastrointestinal transit time, used in IBS and IBD, has anticancer properties
Soy milk Phytosterols, isoflavones, Lipid lowering and antioxidant properties, provides protection against several diseases
genistein, saponins, phytic acid like: CVD, diabetes, BP, cancer, renal issues, osteoporosis
Coconut Lauric acid Anti-microbial, anti-bacterial, and anti-viral properties and protects against infections
milk Benefiting role against oxidative stress and damage, has anti-cancer properties, prevents
against degenrative diseases, retards aging and nourishes skin and has soothing effects
Almond Arabinose Immune boosting properties, maintain BP, enhance eyesight, help in the development of
milk strong bones, and maintain proper renal function
(3.29g) and was lowest in almond milk could provide for stronger evidence on
(2.5g). Of which, oat milk had the highest health benefits in humans.
sugar (7.9g) and coconut milk had no sugar.
Soy milk and coconut milk had better Declaration by Authors
protein content compared to the other 3 Ethical Approval: Not Applicable
plant milks. Coconut milk had higher fat
content (3.3 g) but lauric acid and MCTs. Acknowledgement: None
Oat milk and soy milk had better vitamin A
content. Vitamin D2 content was good in Source of Funding: None
soy milk and almond. Nut milks - coconut
milk and almond milk were good sources of Conflict of Interest: The authors declare no
vitamin E. All five plant milks were a good conflict of interest.
source of calcium. In addition, rice milk was
a good source for selenium and magnesium. REFERENCES
The health benefits and bioactives of five 1. Alozie YE (2015) Nutritional and Sensory
selected plant milk alternatives are Properties of Almond (Prunus amygdalu
discussed as follows. Oat milk, rice milk Var. Dulcis) Seed Milk. World Journal of
and soy milk were found to be beneficial in Dairy & Food Sciences 10(2) :117–21.
2. Alyaqoubi S, Abdullah A, Samudi M,
reducing cholesterol, providing Abdullah N, Addai ZR, Musa KH (2015)
cardioprotective benefits and hence Study of antioxidant activity and
effective in CVD. Rice milk and soy milk physicochemical properties of coconut milk
have phytosterols, soy milk also has (Pati santan) in Malaysia. ournal of
isoflavones and genestin. B-glucan soluble Chemical and Pharmaceutical Research
fibre from oat milk could be beneficial in 7(4): 967–73.
managing diabetes, cholesterol and irritable 3. Anisur M, Begum AA, Mazumder R (2016)
bowel syndrome. Coconut milk contains Soymilk as source of nutrient for
lauric acid - MCT providing anti-microbial, malnourished population of developing
anti-bacterial, and anti-viral properties, country: A review. International Journal of
Advanced Scientific and Technical
while its vitamin E provides antioxidant
Research 5(6): 192–203.
benefits. Almond milk contained arabinose 4. Aydar EF, Tutuncu S, Ozcelik B (2020)
and Vitamin E beneficial for immunity, eye Plant-based milk substitutes: Bioactive
health, bones and renal health. Soy milk and compounds, conventional and novel
almond milk were reported to be useful for processes, bioavailability studies, and health
renal disorders. Also soy milk and coconut effects. Journal of Functional Foods. 70:
milk had anti-carcinogenic properties. 103975.
5. Basinskiene L, Cizeikiene D (2020) Cereal-
CONCLUSION Based Nonalcoholic Beverages. Trends in
Plant milk alternatives are novel emerging Non-alcoholic Beverages. P: 63–99.
functional beverages. These can prove to be 6. Bridges M (2018) Moo-ove Over, Cow’s
Milk: The Rise of Plant-Based Dairy
a healthier alternative when cow milk needs
Alternatives The Rise of Plant-Based Milks.
replacement in the diet due to dietary Practical Gastroenterology p:20–7.
preferences, intolerances and health issues. 7. Chiorando M (2020) 41% Of US
The nutritional composition and bioactive Households Now Buy Vegan Milk, Says
offer health benefits and may offer some Data. 2020 [cited 2022 May 22]. Available
preventive benefits in diseases. However, at: https://plantbasednews.org/news/41-us-
there is future scope for more research on households-buy-vegan-milk/
plant based milk versus cow milk and in 8. Cooper H, Rivero-Mendoza D, Dahl WJ
conditions such as acne, PCOS. Also, well (2020) Plant-Based Milks: Oat. Available
designed RCT’s and larger sample size at: https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu (accessed 22 May
2022).
9. Ekanayaka RAI, Ekanayaka NK, Perera B, 20. Park YW (2021) The Impact of Plant-Based
de Silva PGSM (2013) Impact of a Non-Dairy Alternative Milk on the Dairy
traditional dietary supplement with coconut Industry. Food Science of Animal
milk and soya milk on the lipid profile in Resources 41(1): 8–15.
normal free living subjects. Journal of 21. Paul AA, Kumar S, Kumar V, Sharma R
Nutrition and Metabolism 2013. (2019) Milk Analog: Plant based
10. Eslami O, Shidfar F (2019) Soy milk: A alternatives to conventional milk,
functional beverage with production, potential and health concerns.
hypocholesterolemic effects? A systematic Critical reviews in food science and
review of randomized controlled trials. nutrition 60(18): 3005–23.
Complementary Therapies in Medicine 22. Pritulska N, Motuzka I, Koshelnyk A,
42:82–88. Motuzka O, Yashchenko L, Jarossova M, et
11. Ismail MM (2015) Which Is Better for al. (2021) Consumer preferences on the
Humans, Animal Milk or Vegetable Milk? market of plant-based milk analogues.
Journal of Nutritional Health & Food Potravinarstvo Slovak Journal of Food
Engineering 2(5):155–6. Sciences 15:131–142.
12. Kant R, Broadway A (2015) The Benefits of 23. Romulo, A (2022). Nutritional Contents and
Consuming Soya milk-A Review. Trends in Processing of Plant-Based Milk: A Review.
Biosciences 8(5): 1159–62. IOP Conference Series: Earth and
13. Karimdastjerd Atefeh, Konsukan Zehra Environmental Science 998(1), 012054
Gulsunoglu (2021) Health benefits of plant- 24. Savchuk Y, Usatyuk S, Smirnova J (2015)
based milks as alternatives to conventional Health Benefits of Almond Milk. National
milk. Health and Science p:294–310. University of Food Technologies
14. Karunasiri AN, Gunawardane M, 25. Sethi S, Tyagi SK and Anurag RK (2016)
Senanayake CM, Jayathilaka N, Seneviratne Plant-based milk alternatives an emerging
KN. Antioxidant and Nutritional Properties segment of functional beverages: a review.
of Domestic and Commercial Coconut Milk Journal of Food Science and Technology
Preparations. International Journal of Food 53(9): 3408–23.
Science. 2020;2020. 26. Silva ARA, Silva MMN, Ribeiro BD (2020)
15. Katz AC (2018) Milk Nutrition and Health issues and technological aspects of
Perceptions. University Honors Scholar plant-based alternative milk. Food Research
designation at Johnson & Wales University International 131, 108972.
p: 4–12. 27. Stewart H (2020) USDA ERS - Plant-Based
16. Kundu P, Dhankhar J, Sharma A (2018) Products Replacing Cow’s Milk, But the
Development of non dairy milk alternative Impact Is Small. Economic Research
using soymilk and almond milk. Current Service. Available at:
Research in Nutrition and Food Science https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-
6(1): 203–210. waves/2020/december/plant-based-
17. Narsaria D, Rajyalakshmi (2020) Insight on products-replacing-cow-s-milk-but-the-
the Plant - Based Milk Category in India. impact-is-small/ (accessed 22 May 2022).
GFI India & Ipsos. Available at: 28. Syed SJ, Gadhe KS, Shaikh RP (2020)
https://gfi.org.in/wp- Studies on quality evaluation of OAT milk.
content/uploads/2021/07/Insights-on-the- Journal of Pharmacognosy and
plant-based-dairy-category-in-India.pdf Phytochemistry 9(1).
18. Nowshin H, Devnath K, Begum AA, 29. Torna ED, Rivero Mendoza, Wendy J. Dahl
Mazumder MAR (2018) Effects of soaking (2014) Plant-Based Milks: Almond. Food
and grinding conditions on anti-nutrient and Research International 62: 215–222.
nutrient contents of soy milk. Journal of the 30. Tulashie SK, Amenakpor J, Atisey S, Odai
Bangladesh Agricultural University 16(1): R, Akpari EEA (2022) Production of
158–63. coconut milk: A sustainable alternative
19. Padma M, Jagannadarao PVK, Edukondalu plant-based milk. Case Studies in Chemical
L, Ravibabu G, Aparna K (2018) Physico- and Environmental Engineering 6:100206.
Chemical Analysis of Milk Prepared from 31. Vanga SK and Raghavan V (2018) How
Broken Rice. Int. J. Curr. Microbiol. App. well do plant based alternatives fare
Sci 7(2): 426–428. nutritionally compared to cow’s milk?
******