You are on page 1of 12

Efficacy of Hemostatic Agents in Improving

Surgical Hemostasis
David Green, Cynthia A. Wong, and Przemyslaw Twardowski

URTAILING operative bleeding has always with other topical agents to promote hemostasis.
C been a surgical priority. Perioperative hemor-
rhage, and the need for blood product transfusions,
However, the most popular use of thrombin is in
combination with fibrinogen to form fibrin glue.
increases morbidity, mortality, and cost. The driest Between 1990 and 1995, 318 articles described the
fields are usually attributed to the most skillful preparation, use, and adverse effects of this hemo-
surgeons. However, despite excellent surgical skill static material, and a review was published in these
there may be increased bleeding under a variety of pages in 1993. 3 Some of the salient points about
circumstances. These include extensive operations fibrin glue are summarized below.
versus limited ones, deep dissections versus super-
FIBRIN GLUE
ficial ones, and reoperations versus primary proce-
dures. Furthermore, other factors over which the Fibrin glue is prepared from a mixture of cryopre-
surgeon has little or no control may increase cipitated plasma, calcium, thrombin, and may in-
surgical hemorrhage. Examples include patient clude an inhibitor of proteolysis such as aprotinin.
diseases affecting the liver or kidney; recent expo- The cryoprecipitated plasma provides factor XIII,
sure to medications such as aspirin or anticoagu- fibronectin, and plasminogen in addition to fibrino-
lants; and operations requiting extracorporeal circu- gen. The cryoprecipitate may be obtained from
lation. To control blood loss under these conditions, either ACD or CPDA-1 donor plasma, although the
physicians have turned to a variety of topical and fibrinogen concentration is higher in the latter. 4
systemic agents thought to have hemostatic proper- Because there is concern about viral transmission
ties. In this article, we will examine the safety and from a product made from pooled homologous
efficacy of some of these agents. Plasma, platelets, blood, fibrin glue may be prepared from autologous
blood collected either preoperatively or intraopera-
and specific clotting factors will be excluded be-
tively. 5 The cryoprecipitate and concentrated bo-
cause a discussion of these blood components is
vine thrombin are applied separately to the surgical
beyond the scope of this article.
target, mixed, and allowed to set. The speed of
Table 1 lists some of the hemostatic agents that
formation of the seal is proportional to the throm-
have been used at one time or another to control
bin concentration, and its thickness and bonding
operative bleeding. Many of the topical agents
power are dependent on the concentrations of
listed are believed to be useful in surgical practice,
fibrinogen, factor XIII, and fibronectin in the
but most have not been subjected to rigorous
cryoprecipitate.
clinical trials. Seaweed extracts (Alginate) are used
Major benefit from fibrin glue is reported in
for the arrest of capillary hemorrhage. Styptic
those situations where the use of sutures or adhe-
pencils can diminish bleeding by cauterizing small
sive dressings would be associated with an inferior
vessels. Bismuth subgallate, an analogue of ellagic
result. Examples include dissecting aortic aneu-
acid, activates factor XII and may be applied to the
rysms, where suturing through the aorta may
tonsillar fossae along with epinephrine to stem induce bleeding and skin grafting, where the glue
bleeding. 1 Collagen and microcrystalline collagen serves as a sealant and enhances graft adherence. 6,7
(Avitene) enhance platelet adhesion and aggrega- Other applications include sealing the dura in
tion. They have found widespread use in cardiovas- patients undergoing neurosurgery, and preventing
cular, orthopaedic, and plastic surgery. 2 Gelatin leakage and fistulas from the pancreatic duct after
sponges and oxidized cellulose are applied to the
bleeding surface, compress severed vessels, absorb
fluid, and provide a scaffold for fibrin formation. From the Departments" of Medicine and Anesthesiology,
Russell's viper venom (Stypven) very rapidly clots Northwestern University Medical School, Chicago, 1L
Address reprint requests' to David Green, MD, PhD, 345 E
shed blood and has been used topically to staunch
Superior St-Rm 1407, Chicago, 1L 60611.
bleeding from lacerations in hemophiliacs. Throm- Copyright 9 1996 by W.B. Saunders Company
bin, usually of bovine origin, is applied alone or 0887- 7963/96/1003-000253.00/0

Transfus'on Medicine Reviews, Vol X, No 3 (July), 1996: pp 171-182 171


172 GREEN, WONG, AND TWARDOWSKI

Table 1. Hemostatic Agents Other than Replacement Blood neurohypophyseal nonapeptide, arginine vasopres-
Components (Plasma, Platelets, Specific Clotting Factors)
sin. It was developed in the 1970s for the treatment
Topical Agents of diabetes insipidus. Deamination of hemicysteine
Alginate (seaweed)
at position 1 and substitution of the D-isomer of
Alum (styptic pencil)
Bismuth subgallate
arginine for L-arginine at position 8 produced an
Collagen analog with minimal pressor effects and markedly
Fibrin glue prolonged biologic effect. DDAVP has been shown
Gelatin Sponges to reduce prolonged bleeding times in a variety of
Oxidized cellulose
congenital and acquired disorders of hemostasis.
Russell's Viper Venom
Thrombin Vasopressin was known to increase factor VIII
Systemic Agents (VIII:C) levels, but could not be used clinically for
Aprotinin this purpose because of its vasoactive properties. In
Desmopressin (DDAVP) 1977, Mannucci et a116described the use of DDAVP
Estrogens
in patients with mild to moderate hemophilia A and
~-aminocaproic acid
Tranexamic acid von Willebrand's disease (vWD). DDAVP in-
Vitamins C & K creased circulating VIII:C and decreased blood loss
after major and minor surgery. Since then, many
resection or injuries of this organ. 8,9 In patients with studies have evaluated the efficacy of DDAVP in
hemophilia and other coagulopathies, fibrin glue decreasing bleeding times and surgical blood loss
has been used to control bleeding after dental in patients with preexisting hemostatic disorders
extractions and circumcision. 1~ A major indica- (hemophilia A, vWD, and primary platelet disor-
tion is the control of oozing from surfaces after the ders) and in patients without a known bleeding
removal of adhesions, as occurs in patients having diathesis.
cardiac reoperations. The glue may be sprayed on Plasma levels of VIII:C, von Willebrand factor
the raw surfaces of the heart or pericardium to stop (vWF) (especially the larger multimers), and tissue-
bleeding from multiple pinpoint sources. 3 plasminogen activator (t-PA) increase twofold to
Adverse reactions have been few, but potentially twentyfold immediately after the administration of
DDAVR 17 Factor release is probably mediated by
significant. Transmission of viral contaminants
from homologous donor plasma is possible, but extrarenal V2 receptors, possibly via a second
infrequent and obviated by using autologous cryo- messenger. 18 The clotting factors most likely are
precipitate. Anaphylactic reactions seem to be rare; released from endogenous storage pools because
they may be caused by constituents in the donor the response to DDAVP administration is almost
plasma or the bovine thrombin. Two instances of immediate. 19 This explains its salutary effect in
severe hypotension were reported after instillation patients with mild to moderate hemophilia A and
of fibrin glue into deep hepatic wounds; entry of the von Willebrand's disease, but its lack of effect in
bovine thrombin into the systemic circulation with those with the severe forms of these diseases. It
an anaphylactic reaction was suspected. 12 There also explains the tachyphylaxis that can develop
have been several reports of patients with pro- after repeated doses because stored factors presum-
longed thrombin times and decreased levels of ably become depleted. Platelet membrane expres-
sion of GPIb 2~ and GPIIb/IIIa21 is also enhanced,
factor V after exposure to the bovine thrombin in
fibrin glue. 13 Antibodies against bovine thrombin which may contribute to the increased platelet
and factor V, some of which cross-react with the adhesiveness observed after DDAVR
patient's factor V and cause bleeding, have been
reported. 14,~s This adverse reaction is more likely Hemophilia and von Willebrand's Disease
after cardiac than neurosurgical procedures, prob- The perioperative use of DDAVP was originally
ably because entrance of the bovine thrombin into described for patients with hemophilia A and
the systemic circulation is greater with the former. v W D 16 and this remains its primary perioperative
indication. In hemophiliacs, a baseline VIII:C con-
DESMOPRESSIN centration of at least 0.10 to 0.15 IU/mL is neces-
Desmopressin (1-desamino-8-D-arginine vaso- sary to ensure a post-DDAVP factor concentration
pressin, or DDAVP) is a synthetic analog of the high enough to promote hemostasis during major
HEMOSTATIC AGENTS FOR SURGERY 173

surgery.19 No response to DDAVP is usually seen in except for aspirin-ingesting cardiac surgery pa-
patients with low factor levels or in patients with tients, this assumption has not been rigorously
high antibody titers to VIII:C. Patients with type I tested.
vWD respond to DDAVP with an increase in the
concentration of vWE 19 DDAVP usually does not
result in increased vWF levels in patients with Cardiac Surgery
type-II disease. In fact, it is contraindicated in type Several studies have suggested that DDAVP is
liB vWD because it may cause platelet aggregation efficacious in reducing surgical blood loss, even in
and thrombocytopenia, although this has recently patients with normal preoperative coagulation. The
been disputed. 2z Type III vWD patients have a majority of these studies have been performed in
complete absence of vWF and DDAVP is not cardiac surgery patients because cardiac surgery
effective. and extracorporeal circulation (ECC) are associ-
ated with an acquired coagulopathy, in part thought
Platelet Disorders secondary to platelet dysfunction. 33 In 1986, Salz-
DDAVP has also been shown to be effective in man et a134 reported a marked reduction in blood
reducing prolonged bleeding times in most forms loss in cardiac surgery patients who received
of congenital and acquired disorders of platelet post-ECC DDAVP compared with placebo. The
f u n c t i o n . 19'2325 It may shorten the bleeding time in DDAVP group also had higher plasma vWF levels
platelet storage pool disease, thromboxane synthe- than the placebo group. Low preoperative vWF
sis defect, and in some patients with Bernard- levels correlated with increased postoperative bleed-
Soulier syndrome. 26 Reports differ on whether ing. This study was followed by many others that
patients with Glanzmann's thrombasthenia respond both supported and refuted the results. The random-
to DDAVR 24,25,27 DDAVP also reduces bleeding ized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies are
times in uremia, 28 cirrhosis, 29 aspirin-induced, 29-3! listed in Table 2. Most found no statistically
and heparin-induced 32 platelet dysfunction. It is significant difference in blood loss and red cell
assumed that a decrease in bleeding time correlates transfusion requirements in patients receiving
with a decrease in surgical blood loss, although, DDAVP compared with placebo. However, the

Table 2. Randomized, Controlled, Double-Blind Studies of the Use of DDAVP in Cardiac Surgery

Blood Loss Decrease in


No. of Patients Transfusions
Reference DDAVP/Placebo Type of Surgery DDAVP (mL _+ SD) P}acebo (mL -+ SD) P (Yes/No)

Salzman et a134 35/35 no p r i m a r y CABG 1,317 -+ 486 2,210 • 1,415 .001 No


Rocha et a1127 50/50 no CABG 458 • 206 536 + 304 NS No
B r o w n et aP 28 10/9 CABG 879 _+ 353 803 +- 405 NS No
Hackmann et al ~29 74/76 m o s t l y CABG 1,138 1,010 NS No
A n d e r s s o n et aP 3e 10/9 1~ CABG 852 + 233 1,020 • 422 NS
Hedderich et al TM 31/31 1~ and 2 ~ CABG 1,716 +- 688 1,826 • 849 NS No
Frankville et al la2 20/20 1~ CABG 790 + 130 687 • 50 NS No
H o r r o w et a137 38/44 1~ and 2 ~ valve and CABG 418 g 386 g NS No
Reich et al ~a3 14/13 CABG and valve 624 • 351 729 -+ 200 NS No
Salmenper~ et aP ~ 15/15 1~ CABG 1,020 1,100 NS
Ansell et a113s 41/42 1~ and 2 ~ valve 1,065 • 647 844 + 508 NS No
deProst et aP 38 47/45 1~ and 2 ~ valve and CABG* 582 • 410 465 -+ 303 NS No
Kuitunen et aP a7 15/15 1~ CABG 950 + 185 1,034 -+ 321 NS No
Marquez et a135 21/22t 1~ CABG 1,157 1,180 NS No
M o n g a n et a138 44/42 1~ and 2 ~ CABG T E G - M A > 5 0 m m 770 -+ 252 865 + 384 NS Yes
M o n g a n et aP 8 13/16 1~ and 2~ CABG T E G - M A < 5 0 m m 881 -+595 1,353+773 <.05 No
Rocha et a136 25/28r 1~ and 2 ~ CABG and valve 552 + 324 439 -+ 228 NS No
Temeck et aP 38 40/43 1~ valve and CABG 1,214 • 493 1,386 • 761 NS No

Abbreviations: CABG, coronary artery bypass grafting; TEG-MA, t h r o m b e l a s t o g r a m - m a x i m u m amplitude.


*Chest tube o u t p u t > 7 5 m L / m J h and bleeding t i m e m o r e than 10 minutes, w i t h i n 6 hours of postsurgery.
t A third g r o u p o f 22 patients received 2 doses of DDAVP, w i t h o u t i m p r o v e d hemostasis.
SA third g r o u p of 28 patients received 2 doses of DDAVP, w i t h o u t i m p r o v e d hemostasis.
174 GREEN, WONG, AND TWARDOWSKI

majority of patients in these studies underwent Other Surgical Procedures


primary coronary artery bypass procedures, a group Kobrinsky et al46 reported a 32% reduction in
of patients at relatively low risk for postoperative blood loss and a 26% decrease in transfusion
hemorrhage. requirements in healthy patients undergoing Har-
Two studies evaluated repeat doses of DDAVP in rington rod procedures who received DDAVP com-
the postoperative period and found them to be of no pared with placebo. However, Guay et a147 could
value. 35,36 Horrow et al37 compared DDAVP with not replicate this result, despite recording larger
tranexamic acid and placebo, whereas Rocha et a136 perioperative blood losses then Kobrinsky et al. 46
compared DDAVP with aprotinin and placebo. Flordal et al48 evaluated 50 patients undergoing
Both tranexamic acid and aprotinin resulted in elective total hip arthroplasty under epidural anes-
significantly less blood loss than DDAVP or pla- thesia who received DDAVP at the start of surgery
cebo. and 6 hours later. There were no significant differ-
Mongan et a138 attempted to identify a subgroup ences in measured intraoperative blood loss or
of patients that might benefit from DDAVP therapy. transfusion requirements between the DDAVP and
They found DDAVP to be efficacious in the sub- placebo groups. However, the total calculated blood
loss was reduced by 310 mL in the DDAVP group.
group of patients who had abnormal platelet func-
Similarly, in patients undergoing total hip arthro-
tion as diagnosed by a post-ECC thromboelasto-
plasty under general anesthesia, Karnezis et a149
gram-maximum amplitude value (TEG-MA) less
found no effect of DDAVP given at skin closure.
than 50 mm.
Wingate et al 5~reported decreased blood loss and
A second subgroup who might benefit from
transfusion requirements in hemostatically normal
prophylactic DDAVP treatment are those patients spinal cord patients undergoing flap reconstruction
receiving aspirin therapy before coronary artery for pelvic pressure sores. This salutary effect was
bypass surgery. Decreased blood loss 39,40 and de- not found in burn patients undergoing debridement
creased transfusion requirements in the DDAVP and grafting, 51 nor in patients undergoing aorto-
group 39,41 have been described. iliac graft surgery. 52
Two studies found no effect of DDAVP on blood An in vitro study suggested that DDAVP may
loss after cardiac operations for congenital heart improve coagulation after reperfusion in liver trans-
disease in children. 42,43 plantation. 53
Cattaneo et a144analyzed 18 randomized, placebo- Thus, the overall evidence does not support the
controlled, double-blind studies of DDAVP and routine use of DDAVP in hemostatically normal
found that patients with larger perioperative blood individuals, although patients undergoing large
loss benefitted most from DDAVP, in terms of a blood loss procedures are more likely to benefit
decrease in blood loss and transfusion require- from its use.
ments. A meta-analysis of 13 randomized, placebo-
controlled studies (774 patients) found an 11% Pharmacology
reduction in blood loss in the DDAVP group, a
DDAVP is available as a concentrated nasal
mean difference in blood loss of 85.8 mL. 45 This
spray and an intravenous preparation (4 ~tg/mL).
difference is statistically (P < .002), but probably
An intravenous (or subcutaneous) dose of 0.3
not clinically significant, a conclusion supported by
~tg/kg, or an intranasal dose of 300 lag yields
the meta-analysis of transfusion requirements in 8
maximal VIII:C and vWF releaseY ,55 DDAVP is
of the studies45: DDAVP did not decrease postopera- metabolized by the kidney and liver. 56 Intravenous
tive transfusion requirements. In conclusion, pro- elimination follows first order kinetics with t]/2 =
phylactic DDAVP probably produces clinically 2.5 - 4.4 hours. The biological effect may last 6 or
significant decreases in blood loss in patients more hours. Repeated doses in 12-24 hours are
undergoing complicated cardiac procedures (reop- usually equally effective as the initial dose in
erations, combined valve replacement-coronary ar- elevating clotting factor levels; however, there may
tery bypass grafting (CABG), double-valve) or in be a decreased response after several doses because
patients with documented platelet dysfunction, but of depletion of clotting factor stores. Twenty-four
not in less complicated procedures (primary CABG to forty-eight hours may be required to reaccumu-
and single valves). late stores. 56
HEMOSTATIC AGENTS FOR SURGERY 175

Side Effects vated protein C, and plasmin. Aprotinin blocks


The side effects of DDAVP are minimal. Facial serine proteinases by binding to their active, serine
flushing and hypotension occur with rapid infusion, containing sites. The specific activity of various
secondary to a direct dilating effect of unknown aprotinin preparations is expressed in terms of
mechanism, and an indirect prostacyclin effect.5v kallikrein inhibitor units (KIU)--amount of aproti-
Tissue plasminogen activator levels increase after nin that decreases the in vitro activity of two
DDAVP administration; however, alpha 2-plasmin biological KIU by 50%. Aprotinin is metabolized
inhibitor levels also increase and there is no in the proximal renal tubules and is not excreted in
increase in fibrin- or fibrinogen-split products) 8 urine. It has a biphasic pattern of elimination with a
Although there are anecdotal reports of coronary rapid phase half-life of about 40 minutes and a
and cerebral thrombosis associated with DDAVP slower phase half-life of 7 hours. 73 Initially isolated
administration, 59,6~a review of the controlled clini- from bovine tissues, aprotinin is now also available
cal trials did not show an increase in thrombotic in the recombinant form. TM
events. 61 Serum sodium concentrations and urine The modern era of aprotinin use began in 1987
output decrease because of the antidiuretic property with a report by Royston et a175 that high doses of
of the drug. Water intoxication, especially with aprotinin decreased blood loss and reduced the
inappropriate intravenous water administration, 17 need for blood transfusions associated with cardiac
and allergy to the preservative chlorobutanol,62 surgery. This observation was confirmed by subse-
have been reported. quent clinical trials and in 1993 led to United States
Food and Drug Administration approval of bovine
ESTROGENS aprotinin for use in cardiovascular surgery.
Estrogens have a variety of effects on hemosta- There are many factors responsible for nonsurgi-
sis. They increase the levels of several clotting cal bleeding during cardiac surgery. Passage of
factors including factor XII, 63 factor VII, 64 and blood through the cardiopulmonary bypass circuit
vWF. 65 They also decrease physiological clotting is associated with massive activation of the contact
inhibitors such as antithrombin III and protein S, 66 system (factor XII, XI, prekallikrein, high molecu-
while increasing plasminogen and decreasing plas- lar weight kininogen), intrinsic coagulation, and
minogen activator inhibitor- 1.17,67Clinically, estro- the complement systems. 76 To prevent dissemi-
gens have been used either alone or with progester- nated coagulation, large doses of heparin are given
one to stem bleeding in patients with renal failure, 68 throughout the bypass period. The half-life of
vascular malformations of the gastrointestinal platelets is decreased, the bleeding time is pro-
tract, 69,7~and vWD71;in the latter, they decreased longed, and abnormal platelet aggregation studies
surgical bleeding. However, to our knowledge indicate platelet dysfunction.77 These adverse ef-
there have not been randomized, placebo-con- fects on platelets are mediated by various factors
trolled trials to determine whether preoperative including mechanical trauma, hypothermia, in-
estrogens decrease blood loss. crease in circulating fibrinogen degradation prod-
ucts (FDPIS), and plasmin-induced changes in
APROTININ GPIb surface receptors. The fibrinolytic system is
Aprotinin is a broad-spectrum serine proteinase activated as manifested by increased levels of
inhibitor used primarily in cardiovascular surgery tissue plasminogen activator, d-dimers, and
to improve perioperative hemostasis. Aprotinin FDPIS. 78 The total-body inflammatory response
was originally tested in Europe in the 1960s for the creates derangement of hemostasis and multiple
treatment of acute pancreatitis, but its efficacy in other organ systems.
that setting remains unproven. 72 However, experi- The exact mechanisms by which aprotinin re-
mental and clinical data accumulated in the last duces blood loss are not fully understood and are
decade have established aprotinin as a useful agent undoubtedly very complex. Because most of the
for improving surgical hemostasis. enzymes of the hemostatic system are serine protein-
Aprotinin is a polypeptide composed of 58 ases, aprotinin can affect multiple steps of coagula-
amino acid residues with a molecular weight of 6.5 tion and fibrinolysis. Aprotinin directly inhibits
kDa. Enzymes inhibited by aprotinin include vari- plasmin, which diminishes fibrinolysis. At higher
ous serine proteinases: trypsin, chymotrypsin, concentrations it inhibits kallikrein, which is ca-
thrombin, glandular and plasma kallikrein, acti- pable of converting plasminogen to plasmin. Sev-
176 GREEN, WONG, AND TWARDOWSKI

eral randomized trials confirm decreased markers Lower doses are being investigated and seem to be
of fibrinolysis (d-dimers, FDP's) in aprotinin- effective.V4,86, 87
treated patients compared to patients who received The incidence of adverse reactions to aprotinin is
placebo. 79,s~ The activity of protein C (a potent low. Anaphylaxis occurs in less then 0.5% of
anticoagulant) is also decreased by aprotinin. patients but the risk is increased after repetitive use.
Whether aprotinin is capable of protecting platelets All patients should receive a test dose before
from activation during cardiopulmonary bypass is administration of the full loading dose. 88 One of the
not clear. Some studies have documented preserva- potential side effects associated with the use of an
tion of platelet receptors GPIb and GPIIb/IIIa, 81 agent that inhibits fibrinolysis is the possibility of
whereas other studies have been unable to confirm inducing a prothrombotic state. Cosgrove et a187
the protective effect of aprotinin on platelet func- reported an increased incidence of perioperative
tion. 82 myocardial infarction (MI) and graft thrombosis in
The efficacy of aprotinin in improving hemosta- aprotinin-treated patients. A subsequent clinical
sis during cardiovascular surgery has been corrobo- trial addressing this issue did not confirm this
rated by multiple clinical trials conducted over the observation, s9 Bidstrup et al90 evaluated the pa-
last several years (Table 3). The shown benefit tency of grafts using magnetic resonance imaging
consists of reduction of blood loss by about 50% and found no difference between placebo and
and similar decreases in blood transfusion require- aprotinin groups. However, the incidence of periop-
ments. The most extensive data exist for patients erative MI was very low. A likely explanation for
undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting, but the increased incidence of thrombosis in the earlier
very similar results have been obtained in the studies was inadequate anticoagulation. Celite acti-
setting of heart valve replacement, valve replace- vated clotting times are prolonged in the presence
ment for active endocarditis, cardiac transplanta- of aprotinin, and do not accurately reflect in vivo
tion, and congenital heart disease. Comparable heparin concentrations. Therefore, less heparin is
effects of aprotinin are seen in situations where the given and thrombosis may occur. When this phe-
risk of perioperative bleeding is high. These in- nomenon was recognized, new reagents such as
clude repeat operations and operations on patients kaolin were substituted for celite, 91 and thrombotic
pretreated with thrombolytics83 or taking aspi- events became relatively infrequent. Isolated early
rin.84,85 reports of strokes and renal insufficiency associated
The most widely used regimen for administering with aprotinin have not been confirmed in clinical
aprotinin is based on the original report from trials.
London's Hammersmith Hospital and consists of a Potential indications for the use of aprotinin are
2 million KIU intravenous bolus after the induction not limited to cardiac surgery. For example, it has
of anesthesia, an additional 2 million KIU in the been effective in decreasing blood loss in ortho-
prime solution of the ECC, and a continuous topic liver transplantation 92 and complex orthopae-
infusion of 500,000 KIU/h until the end of surgery. dic surgeries. 93

Table 3. Clinical Trials of the Use of Aprotinin in Open-Heart Surgery


No. of Blood Loss
Reference Type of Study Type of Surgery Patients Treatment Reduction PValue
Royston et aJ75 Prospective randomized CABG, valve 22 High-dose aprotinin 81% <.001
Blauhat et a179 Prospective randomized CABG 26 High-dose aprotinin 50% <.0082
Havel et al so Prospective randomized CABG 22 High-dose aprotinin 38% <.03
Dietriech et aP39 Prospective randomized CABG, valve 1,784 High-dose aprotinin 35% <.05
Biagini et a1140 Prospective randomized Redo CABG, valve 58 High-dose aprotinin 22% <.01
Cosgrove et a187 Double-blind placebo-controlled CABG 169 High-dose aprotinin, 36% <.001
low-dose aprotinin 23%
Bidstrup et al so Randomized placebo-controlled CABG 96 High-dose aprotinin 40% <.01
Murkin et al s5 Double-blind placebo-controlled CABG, valve patients 54 High-dose aprotinin 50% <.0001
on aspirin
Dementieva et a1141 Randomized placebo-controlled CABG 100 High-dose aprotinin 33% <.005
Green et al TM Randomized placebo-controlled CABG and redo 84 Recombinant aprotinin, 34% <.02
high and low dose
HEMOSTATIC A G E N T S FOR SURGERY 177

In summary, aprotinin is an effective agent for Horrow et a197studied 38 primary and secondary
reducing blood loss and transfusion requirements coronary artery bypass and valve replacement
in the setting of cardiac surgery and other major procedures in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-
operative procedures. It is particularly useful in controlled study of TA. TA, administered before
patients at high risk for perioperative bleeding and and during ECC, significantly reduced 12-hour
it has an acceptable safety profile. The exact blood loss compared with placebo (496 _+ 228 v
mechanism of aprotinin action and other potential 750 _+ 314 mL), and decreased transfusion require-
clinical applications are currently under investiga- ments. A follow-up study comparing TA with
tion. DDAVP and placebo found TA alone reduced blood
loss, and DDAVP did not potentiate the effect.37 A
ANTIFIBRINOLYTIC AGENTS dose-response study of TA found that 10 mg/kg
Epsilon-aminocaproic acid and tranexamic acid bolus before ECC, followed by 1 mg/kg/h infusion,
are synthetic lysine analog plasmin-plasminogen was optimal. 98 Other nonrandomized99,1~176and non-
inhibitors. Epsilon aminocaproic acid (EACA) is blinded studies 99-~~ support the conclusion that
older, cheaper, and ten times less potent than pre-ECC TA decreases blood loss. One study of
tranexamic acid (TA). Both drugs inhibit fibrinoly- post-ECC TA found no positive effect.I~
sis by binding to plasminogen lysine binding sites, A meta-analysis of four double-blinded, placebo-
thus preventing plasminogen from binding to fi- controlled studies of EACA 103,l~ and TA37,97 sup-
brinogen. 17 ports the conclusion that EACA and TA decrease
blood loss and the volume of transfused blood
Cardiac Surgery products, but not the percent of patients requiring
Both EACA and TA have been used to treat and transfusion. 45 No prospective study has compared
prevent excessive bleeding in cardiac surgery pa- the two drugs. A retrospective study comparing
tients. Fibrinolysis has been implicated as a cause EACA with TA found a smaller percent of patients
of post-ECC bleeding; t-PA, fibrinogen and fibrin- receiving TA received blood products.I~ However,
split products increase during ECC. 78 Antifibrinol- equipotent doses of EACA and TA were not used.
ytics not only inhibit the activation of plasminogen, Two nonblinded studies compared TA, aprotinin,
they also block plasmin receptors on platelets, iv and a control group, x~176 The TA groups did not
Plasmin may act as a weak platelet agonist or differ significantly from aprotinin groups, but the
antagonist. 94 Therefore, antifibrinolytics may act to number of patients in each study may not have been
preserve or enhance platelet function and inhibit large enough to detect a difference.
plasminogen and plasmin.
Epsilon-aminocaproic acid has been used in Oral Surgery
cardiac surgery since the late 1950s. However, the There is a high degree of fibrinolytic activity in
early studies were not controlled and primarily saliva. 1~ Oral TA has been used in conjunction
involved surgery for congenital heart disease. 95 with DDAVP to decrease bleeding after oral sur-
Recent randomized, double-blind, placebo-con- gery in patients with hemophilia ~6 and vWDJ ~
trolled studies are listed in Table 4 and support the Topical TA has also been used in hemophiliac
conclusion that prophylactic EACA decreases blood patients to reduce bleeding. 1~ Patients with factor
loss after cardiac surgery. The efficacy of antifibri- XI deficiency,l~~ and acquired VIII:C inhibitors 1]]
nolytics may differ, depending on whether they are have also benefited from perioperative TA. In two
administered before or after ECC. 96 This has not randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled studies,
been studied prospectively, nor has the optimal tranexamic acid mouth wash, prepared by mixing
dose of EACA been evaluated. equal volumes of TA and saline, was efficacious in

Table 4. EACA Studies in Cardiac Surgery

Blood Loss Decrease in


Before ECC Transfusions
Reference No. of Patients Type of Surgery Yes/No EACA mL (-~SD) Placebo mL (-+SD) Yes/No
Vander Salm et a1103 60 CABG No 273 +_ 106 332 -+ 10 0.02
DelRossi et al T M 350 CABG and valve Yes 617 • 44 883 -+ 29 <.05 Yes
Daily et a1142 40 1~ CABG Yes 623 +- 380 845 _+ 339 .012 Yes
178 GREEN, WONG, AND TWARDOWSKI

reducing bleeding episodes in patients receiving the upper genitourinary tract because clots may
oral anticoagulants who underwent oral sur- obstruct the ureters and cause hydronephrosis.17,123
gery.ll2,113 There is no evidence of increased coronary artery
thrombosis when antifibrinolytics are used in car-
Other Surgical Procedures diac surgery, 1~ although thrombus formation on
Patients undergoing prostate surgery may suffer indwelling pulmonary catheters has been re-
primary fibrinolysis secondary to the release of ported/24
t-PA from prostatic tissue. Systemic EACA de-
VITAMINS
creases this type of bleeding. However, intravesical
EACA had no significant clinical effect on bleeding Vitamin C
when administered routinely after transurethral The bleeding gums, perifollicular hemorrhages,
resection procedures,l~4,Jl5 and clots formed in the and giant ecchymoses characteristic of scurvy
bladder may obstruct the urethra. Kang et al H6 rapidly respond to the administration of vitamin C,
described the use of EACA during the reperfusion but there is no evidence that use of vitamin C in
phase of liver transplant surgery in patients for those without deficiency diminishes surgical bleed-
whom the thrombelastogram-maximum amplitude ing.
tracing improved with the in vitro addition of
EACA. A small, retrospective study found no Vitamin K
benefit to prophylactic EACA in liver transplanta- This vitamin is required to complete the synthe-
tion. 117Prophylactic TA significantly reduced wound sis of a number of coagulants (factors II, VII, IX,
drainage and length of hospital stay in a random- and X) and anticoagulants (proteins C and S). 125
ized, double-blind study of breast surgery for Deficiencies of vitamin K occur in patients with
cancer. 118 poor nutrition, fat malabsorption, and in those
The use of EACA to decrease aneurysm rebleed- receiving oral anticoagulant (warfarin) therapy.
ing after subarachnoid hemorrhage is controversi- Vitamin K deficiency is usually recognized by a
al. 119EACA lowers the incidence of rebleeding, but prolongation of the prothrombin time, a common
complications, including decreased cerebral blood preoperative screening test. However, the prothrom-
flow and increased neurologic deficits, j2~ may bin time may be normal in patients with borderline
offset its usefulness. Doses higher than those vitamin K status; in such patients, marked prolonga-
recommended by the manufacturer may actually tion of the prothrombin time appears in the first 2 to
increase bleeding by inhibiting platelet function.12~ 3 days postoperatively, when the vitamin K defi-
ciency is exacerbated by limited oral intake and/or
Pharmacology administration of antibiotics. If vitamin K defi-
Epsilon-aminocaproic acid and TA are available ciency is suspected, the vitamin may be rapidly
in oral and intravenous formulations. Both drugs replaced by giving vitamin K1, 10 mg, subcutane-
undergo minimal metabolism and are excreted ously. Complete correction of the prothrombin time
largely unchanged in the urine. usually occurs within 12 to 24 hours.
A special problem relates to patients receiving
Side Effects oral anticoagulants who require surgery. A recent
Nausea, diarrhea, and hypotension (with rapid study has shown that vitamin K must be given at
injection) have been noted. Myalgias are a known least 4 to 5 days before operation to ensure that the
side effect and myonecrosis is a rare complication prothrombin time will be normalf126 Furthermore,
reported with EACA.122 Antifibrinolytics are contra- age was shown to have a significant influence, with
indicated in disseminated intravascular coagulation a 3.4% slower decline in the prothrombin time per
and in macroscopic and microscopic bleeding of decade of age.

REFERENCES
1. RatnoffOD: Some therapeutic agents influencing hemosta- CD, Thomas DE Tuddenham EGD (eds): Haemostasis and
sis, in Colman RW, Hirsh J, Marder VJ, Salzman EW (eds): Thrombosis (ed 3). Edinburgh, UK, Churchill Livingstone,
Hemostasis and Thrombosis: Basic Principles and Clinical 1994, pp 1057-1073
Practive (ed 3). Philadelphia, PA, Lippincott, 1994, pp 1104- 3. McCarthy PM: Fibrin glue in cardiothoracic surgery.
1118 Transfus Med Rev 7:173-179, 1993
2, Verstraete M: Haemostatic drugs, in Bloom AL, Forbes 4. DePalma L, Criss VR, Luban NL: The preparation of
HEMOSTATIC AGENTS FOR SURGERY 179

fibrinogen concentrate for use as fibrin glue by four different of bleeding time by 1-deamino-8-D-arginine vasopressin in
methods. Transfus 33:717-720, 1993 various bleeding disorders. Lancet 1:1145-1148, 1984
5, Quigley RL, Perkins JA, Gottner RJ, et al: Intraoperative 24. Mannucci PM: Desmopressin: A nontransfusional form
procurement of autologuosu fibrin glue. Ann Thorac Snrg of treatment for congenital and acquired bleeding disorders.
56:387-389, 1993 Blood 72:1449-1455, 1988
6. Sequin JR, Picard E, Frapier JM, Chaptal PA: Aortic valve 25. DiMichele DM, Hathaway WE: Use of DDAVP in
repair with fibrin glue for type A acute aortic dissection. Ann inherited and acquired platelet dysfunction. Am J Hematol
Thorac Surg 58:304-306, 1994 33:39-45, 1990
7. Saltz R, Sierra D, Feldman D, et al: Experimental and 26. Kemahli S, Canatan D, Uysal Z, et al: DDAVP shortens
clinical applications of fibrin glue. Plast Reconstr Surg 90:726- bleeding time in Bernard-Soulier syndrome. Thromb Haemostas
727, 1992 71:675, 1994 (letter)
8. Stechison MT: Rapid polymerizing fibrin glue from autolo- 27. Sweeney JD, Hoemig LA, Behrens AA, Bloom ML:
gous or single-donor blood: Preparation and indications. J Hand surgery in Glanzmann's thrombasthenia. Am J Hematol
Neurosurg 76:626-628, 1992 41:140-141, 1992 (letter)
9. Kram HB, Clark SR, Ocampo HE et al: Fibrin glue sealing 28. Mannucci PM, Remuzzi G, Pusineri F, et al: Deamino-8-
of pancreatic injuries, resections, and anastemoses. Am J Surg D-arginine vasopressin shortens the bleeding time in uremia. N
161:479-481, 1991 Engl J Med 308:8-12, 1983
10. Rakocz M, Mazar A, Varon D, et al: Dental extractions in 29. Mannucci PM, Vicente V, Vianello L, et al: Controlled
patients with bleeding disorders. The use of fibrin glue. Oral trial of desmopressin in liver cirrhosis and other conditions
Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 75:280-282, 1993 associated with a prolonged bleeding time. Blood 67:1148-1153,
11. Martinowitz U, Varon D, Jonas P, et al: Circumcision in 1967
hemophilia: The use of fibrin glue for local hemostasis. J UrN 30, Lethagen S, Rugam P: The effect of DDAVP and placebo
148:855-857, 1992 on platelet function and prolonged bleeding time induced by
oral acetyl salicylic acid intake in healthy volunteers. Thromb
12. Berguer R, Staerkel RL, Moore FA, et al: Warning: Fatal
Haemostas 67:185-186, 1992 (letter)
reaction to the use of fibrin glue in deep hepatic wounds. Case
reports. J Trauma 31:408-411, 1991 31. Flordal PA, Sahlin S: Use of desmopressin to prevent
bleeding complications in patients treated with aspirin. Br J Snrg
13. Banninger H, Hardegger T, Tnbler A, et al: Fibrin glue in
80:723-724, 1993
surgery: frequent development of inhibitors of bovine thrombin
32. Schnlman S, Johnsson H: Heparin, DDAVP and the
and human factor V. Br J Haematol 85:528-532, 1993
bleeding time. Thromb Haemostas 65:242-244, 1991
14. Stricker RB, Lane PK, Leffert JD, et al: Development of
33. Shiffrin JS, GlassDD: DDAVPadministrationforpostby-
antithrombin antibodies following surgery in patients with
pass bleeding, pro: Desmopressin is of value in the treatment of
prosthetic cardiac valves. Blood 72:1375-1380, 1988
post-cardiopulmonary bypass bleeding. J Cardiothorac Vasc
15. Zehnder JL, Leung LLK: Development of antibodies to
Anesth 5:285-289, 1991
thrombin and factor V with recurrent bleeding in a patient
34. Salzman EW, Weinstein MJ, Weintraub RM, et al:
exposed to topical bovine thrombin. Blood 76:2011-2016, 1990
Treatment with desmopressin acetate to reduce blood loss after
16. Mannucci PM, Rugged ZM, Pareti FI, Capitanio A: cardiac surgery. A double-blind randomized trial. N Engl J Med
1-deamino-8-D-arginine vasopressin: A new pharmacological 314:1402-1406, 1986
approach to the management of haemophilia and von Will-
35. Marquez J, Koehler S, Strelec SR, et al: Repeated dose
ebrand's disease. Lancet 1:869-872, 1977
administration of desmopressin acetate in uncomplicated car-
17. HorrowJC: Desmopressin and antifibrinolytics. IntAnes- diac surgery: A prospective, blinded, randomized study. J
thesiol Clin 28:230-236, 1990 Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 6:674-676, 1992
18. Hashemi S, Palmer DS, Aye MT, Ganz PR: Platelet- 36. Rocha E, Hidalgo F, Llorens R, et al: Randomized study
activating factor secreted by DDAVP-treated monocytes medi- of aprotinin and DDAVP to reduce postoperative bleeding after
ates von Willebmnd factor release from endotheliai cells. J Cell cardiopulmonary bypass surgery. Circulation 90:921-927, 1994
Physiol 154:496-505, 1993 37. Horrow JC, Van Riper DF, Strong MD, et al: Hemostatic
19. Lethagen S: Desmopressin (DDAVP) and hemostasis. effects of tranexamic acid and desmopressin during cardiac
Ann Hematol 69:173 180, 1994 (review) surgery. Circulation 84:2063-2070, 1991
20. Sloand EM, Alyono D, Klein HG, et al: 1-Deamino-8 D- 38. Mongan PD, Hosking MP: The role of desmopressin
arginine vasopressin (DDAVP) increases platelet membrane acetate in patients undergoing coronary artery bypass surgery. A
expression of glycoprotein Ib in patients with disorders of controlled clinical trial with thromboelastographic risk stratifica-
platelet function and after cardiopulmonary bypass. Am J tion. Anesthesiology 77:38-46, 1992
Hemato146:199-207, 1994 39. Sheridan DR Card RT, Pinilla JC, et al: Use of desmopres-
21. Lethagen S, Nilsson IM: DDAVP-induced enhancement sin acetate to reduce blood transfusion requirements during
of platelet retention: its dependence on platelet-von Willebrand cardiac surgery in patients with acetylsalicylic-acid-induced
factor and the platelet receptor GP IIb/IIIa. Euro J Haematol platelet dysfunction. Can J Surg 37:33-36, 1994
49:7-13, 1992 40. Gratz I, Koehler J, Olsen D, et al: The effect of
22. Casonato A, Pontara E, Dannhaeuser D, et al: Re- desmopressin acetate on postoperative hemorrhage in patients
evaluation of the therapeutic efficacy of DDAVP in type liB yon receiving aspirin therapy before coronary artery bypass opera-
Willebrand's disease. Blood Coagul Fibrinolysis 5:959-964, tions. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 104:1417-1422, 1992
1994 41. Dilthey G, Dietrich W, Spannagl M, et al: Influence of
23. Kobrinsky NL, Israels ED, Gerrard JM, et al: Shortening desmopressin acetate on homologous blood requirements in
180 GREEN, WONG, AND TWARDOWSKI

cardiac surgical patients pretreated with aspirin. J Cardiothorac 60. Grunwald Z, Sather SD: Intraoperative cerebral infarc-
Vasc Anesth 7:425-430, 1993 tion after desmopressin administration in infant with end-stage
42. Seear MD, Wadsworth LD, Rogers PC, et al: The effect renal disease. Lancet 345:1364-1365, 1995 (letter)
of desmopressin acetate (DDAVP) on postoperative blood loss 61. Mannucci PM, Carlsson S, Harris AS: Desmopressin,
after cardiac operations in children. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg surgery and thrombosis. Thromb Haemostas 71:154-155, 1994
98:217-219, 1989 62. Itabashi A, Katayama S, Yamaji T: Hypersensitivity to
43. Reynolds LM, Nicolson SC, Jobes DR, et al: Desmopres- chlorobutanol in DDAVP solution. Lancet 1: 108, 1982
sin does not decrease bleeding after cardiac operation in young 63. Gordon EM, Douglas JG, Ratnoff OD, et al: The
children. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 106:954-958, 1993 influence of estrogen and prolactin on hageman factor (factor
44. Cattaneo M, Mannucci PM: Desmopressin and blood XII) titer in ovariectomized and hypophysectomized rats. Blood
loss after cardiac surgery. Lancet 342:812, 1993 (letter) 66:602-605, 1985
45. Fremes SE, Wong BI, Lee E, et al: Meta-analysis of 64. Kroon U, Silfverstolpe G, Tengbom L: The effects of
prophylactic drug treatment in the prevention of postoperative transdermal estradiol and oral conjugated estrogens on haemo-
bleeding. Ann Thorac Surg 58:1580-1588, 1994 stasis variables. Thromb Haemostas 71:420-423, 1994
46. Kobrinsky NL, Letts RM, Patel LR, et al: 1-desamino-8- 65. Harrison RL, McKee PA: Estrogen stimulates von Will-
D-arginine vasopressin (desmopressin) decreases operative blood ebrand factor production by cultured endothelial cells. Blood
loss in patients having Harrington rod spinal fusion surgery. Ann 63:657-665, 1984
Intern Med 107:446-450, 1987 66. Caine YG, Bauer KA, Berzegar S, et al: Coagulation
47. Guay J, Reinberg C, Poitras B, et al: Atrial of desmopres- activation following estrogen administration to postmenopausal
sin to reduce blood loss in patients undergoing spinal fusion for women. Thromb Haemostas 68:392-395, 1992
idiopathic scoliosis [see comments]. Anesth Analg 75:405-410, 67. Alkjaersig N, Fletcher AP, de Ziegler D, et al: Blood
1992 coagulation in postmenopausal women given estrogen treat-
48. Flordal PA, Ljungstrom KG, Ekman B, Neander G: ment: Comparison of transdermal and oral administration. J Lab
Effects of desmopressin on blood loss in hip arthroplasty. Clin Med 111:224-228, 1988
Controlled study in 50 patients. Acta Orthop Scand 63:381-385, 68. Livio M, Mannucci PM, Vigano G, et al: Conjugated
1992 estrogens for the management of bleeding associated with renal
49. Kamezis TA, Stulberg SD, Wixson RL, Reilly P: The failure. N Engl J Med 315:731-735, 1986
hemostatic effects of desmopressin on patients who had total 69. van Cutsem E, Rutgeerts P, Vantrappen G: Treatment of
joint arthroplasty. A double-blind randomized trial. J Bone Joint bleeding gastrointestinal vascular malformations with oestrogen-
Surg [Am] 76:1545-50, 1994 progesterone. Lancet 335:953-955, 1990
50. Wingate GF, Lewis V Jr, Green D, et al: Desmopressin 70. Bronner MH, Pate MB, Cunningham JT, et al: Estrogen-
decreases operative blood loss in spinal cord injury patients progesterone therapy for bleeding gastrointestinal telangiecta-
having flap reconstruction of pelvic pressure sores. Plastic sias in chronic renal failure. Ann Intern Med 105:371-374, 1986
Reconstr Surg 89:279-282, 1992 71. Alperin JB: Estrogens and surgery in women with von
51. Haith L Jr, Patton ML, Goldman WT, et al: Diminishing Willebrand's disease. Am J Med 73:367-371, 1982
blood loss during operation for bums. Surg Gynecol Obstet 72. Trautschold I, Werle E, Zickgraf-Rudel G: Trasylol.
176:119-123, 1993 Biochem Pharmacol 16:59-72, 1967
52. Lethagen S, Rugam P, Bergqvist D: Blood loss and safety 73. Fritz H, Wunderer G: Biochemistry and applications of
with desmopressin or placebo during aorto-iliac graft surgery. aprotinin, the kallikrein inhibitor from bovine organs. Drug Res
Euro J Vasc Surg 5:173-178, 1991 33:479-94, 1983
53. Kang Y, Scott V, DeWolf A, et al: In vitro effects of 74. Green D, Sanders J, Eiken M, et al: Recombinant
DDAVP during liver transplantation. Trans Proc 25:1821-1822, aprotinin in coronary artery bypass graft operations. J Thorac
1993 Cardiovasc Surg 110:963-970, 1995
54. Lethagen S, Harris AS, Sjorin E, et al: Intranasal and 75. Royston D, Bidstrup BR Taylor KM, et al: Effect of
intravenous administration of desmopressin: Effect on F VIII/ aprotinin on the need for blood transfusion after repeat open
vWF, pharmacokinetics and reproducibility. Thromb Haemost heart surgery. Lancet 2:1289-1291, 1987
58:1033-1036, 1987 76. Bick RL: Physiology and pathophysiology of hemostasis
55. Mannucci PM, Vicente V, Alberca I, et al: Intravenous during cardiac surgery, in Pifarre R (ed): Blood Conservation
and subcutaneous administration of desmopressin (DDAVP) to with Aprotinin (ed 1). Philadelphia, PA, Hanley and Belfus,
hemophiliacs: Pharmacokinetics and factor VIII responses. 1995, pp 1-44
Thromb Haemost 58:1037 1039, 1987 77. Ray MJ, Hawson GAT, Just SJE, et al: Relationship of
56. Richardson DW, Robinson AG: Desmopressin. Ann platelet aggregation to bleeding after cardiopulmonary bypass.
Intern Med 103:228-239, 1985 Ann Thorac Surg 57:981-986, 1994
57. JohnsRA: Desmopressinis apotent vasorelaxant ofaorta 78. Marengo-Rowe A J, Leveson JE: Fibrinolysis: A frequent
and pulmonary artery isolated from rabbit and rat. Anesthesiol- cause of bleeding, in Ellison N, Jobes DR (eds): Effective
ogy 72:858-864, 1990 hemostasis in cardiac surgery (ed 1). Philadelphia, PA, Saun-
58. Takahashi H, Tatewaki W, Wada K, et al: Plasmin ders, 1988, pp 41-55
generation and flbrin(ogen)olysis following desmopressin infu- 79. Blauhut B, Gross C, Necek S, et al: Effects of high-dose
sion. Am J Hematol 36:255-258, 1991 aprotinin on blood losS, platelet function, fibrinolysis, comple-
59. Hartmann S, Reinhart W: Fatal complication of desmo- ment, and renal function after cardiopulmonary bypass. J Thorac
pressin. Lancet 345:1302, 1995 Cardiovasc Surg 101:958-967, 1991
HEMOSTATIC AGENTS FOR SURGERY 181

80. Havel M, Teufelsbauer H, Knobl P, et al: Effect of dose-response relationship of tranexamic acid. Anesthesiology
intraoperative aprotinin administration on postoperative bleed- 82:383-592, 1995
ing in patients undergoing cardiopulmonary bypass operations. J 99. Yau TM, Carson S, Weisel RD, et al: The effect of warm
Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 101:968-972, 1991 heart surgery on postoperative bleeding. J Thorac Cardiovasc
81. Van Oeveren W, Harder MR Roozendal KJ, et al: Surg 103:1155-1162, 1992
Aprotinin protects platelets against the initial effect of cardiopul- 100. Rousou JA, Engelman RM, Flack J3, et al: Tranexamic
monary bypass. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 99:788-797, 1990 acid signifcantly reduces blood loss associated with coronary
82. Matzdoff AC, Green D, Cohen I, et al: Effect of revascularization. Ann Thorac Surg 59:671-675, 1995
recombinant aprotinin on platelet activation in patients undergo- 101. Speekenbrink RG, Vonk AB, Wildevuur CR, et al:
ing open heart surgery. Hemostasis 23:293-300, 1993 Hemostatic efficacy of dipyridamole, tranexamic acid, and
83. Akhtar TM, Goodchild C, Boyan MKG: Reversal of aprotinin in coronary bypass grafting. Ann Thorac Surg 59:438-
streptokinase-induced bleeding with aprotinin for emergency 442, 1995
cardiac surgery. Anaesthesia 47:226-228, 1992 102. Ovrnm E, Am Holen E, Abdelnoor M, et al: Tranexamic
84. Bidstrup B, Royston D, Mc Guinness C, et al: Aprotinin acid (Cyklokapron) is not necessary to reduce blood loss after
in aspirin-pretreated patients. Perfusion 5:77-81, 1990 (suppl) coronary artery bypass operations. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg
85. Murkin J, Lux J, Shannon RN, et al: Aprotinin signifi- 105:78-83, 1993
cantly decreases bleeding and transfusion requirements in 103. Vander Salm TJ, Ansell JE, Okike ON, et al: The role of
patients receiving aspirin and undergoing cardiac operations. J epsilon-aminocaproic acid in reducing bleeding after cardiac
Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 107:554-561, 1994 operation: A double-blind randomized study. J Thorac Cardio-
86. Concha M, Munoz I: Experience with low-dose Aproti- vasc Surg 95:538-540, 1988
nin, in Pifarre R (ed): Blood Conservation with Aprotinin (ed 1). 104. DelRossi AJ, Cernaianu AC, Botros S, et al: Prophylac-
Philadelphia, PA, Hanley and Belfus, 1995, pp 306-307 tic treatment of postperfusion bleeding using EACA. Chest
87. Cosgrove D, Heric B, Lytle B, et al: Aprotinin therapy for 96:27-30, 1989
reoperative myocardial revascularization: A placebo-controlled 105. Karski JM, Teasdale SJ, Norman PH, et al: Prevention
study. Ann Thorac Surg 54:1031-1038, 1992 of postbypass bleeding with tranexamic acid and epsilon-
aminocaproic acid. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 7:431-435, 1993
88. Leskiw U, Levy J: Antigenicity of protamine and aproti-
106. Blauhut B, Harringer W, Bettelheim P, et al: Compari-
nin in cardiac surgery, in Pifarre R (ed): Blood Conservation
with Aprotinin (ed 1). Philadelphia, PA, Hanley and Belfus, son of the effects of aprotinin and tranexamic acid on blood loss
1995, pp 253-266 and related variables after cardiopulmonary bypass. J Thorac
Cardiovasc Surg 108:1083-1091, 1994
89. Havel M, Grabenwoger F, Schneider J, et al: Aprotinin
107. Stern NS: Primary fibrinolysis after oral surgery. J Oral
does not decrease early graft patency after coronary artery
Surg 33:49-52, 1975
bypass grafting despite reducing postoperative bleeding and use
108. Williamson R, Eggleston DJ: DDAVP and EACA used
of donated blood. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 107:807-810, 1994
for minor oral surgery in von Willebrand disease. Austr Dent J
90. Bidstrup BP, Underwood R, Sapsford RN: Effect of
33:32-36, 1988
aprotinin in aorta-coronary bypass graft patency. J Thorac
109. Sindet-Pedersen S, Stenbjerg S: Effect of local antifibri-
Cardiovasc Surg 105:147-153, 1993
nolytic treatment with tranexamic acid in hemophiliacs undergo-
91. Wang JS, Lin CY, Hung WT, et al: Monitoring of
ing oral surgery. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 44:703-707, 1986
heparin-induced anticoagulation with kaolin-activated clotting
110. Berliner S, Horowitz I, Martinowitz U, et al: Dental
times in cardiac surgical patients treated with aprotinin. Anesthe-
surgery in patients with severe factor XI deficiency without
siology 77:1080-1084, 1992
plasma replacement. Blood Coag Fibrinol 3:465-468, 1992
92. Scudamore C, Randall q, Shackleton C, et al: Aprotinin
111. Hasson DM, Poole AE, deleFuernte B, et al: The dental
reduces the need for blood products during liver transplantation.
management of patients with spontaneous acquired factor VIII
Am J Surg 169:546-549, 1995
inhibitors. JADA 113:633-636, 1986
93. Murkin J: Blood Conservation and Thromboembolic 112. Borea G, Montebugnoli L, Capuzzi P, et al: Tranexamic
Disease after Aprotinin Use for Complex Total Hip Arthroplasty, acid as a mouthwash in anticoagulant-treated patients undergo-
in Pifarre R (ed): Blood Conservation with Aprotinin (ed 1). ing oral surgery. An alternative method to discontinuing antico-
Philadelphia, PA, Hanley and Belfus, 1995, pp 373-89 agulant therapy. Oral Surg, Oral Med, Oral Pathol 75:29-31,
94. Soslau G, Horrow J, Brodsky I: Effect of tranexamic acid 1993
on platelet ADP during extracorporeal circulation. Am J Hema- 113. Ramstrom G, Sindet-Pedersen S, Hall G, et al: Preven-
tol 38:113-119, 1991 tion of postsurgical bleeding in oral surgery using tranexamic
95. Hardy JF, Belisle S: Natural and synthetic antifibrinolyt- acid without dose modification of oral anticoagulants. J Oral
ics in adult cardiac surgery: Efficacy, effectiveness and effi- Maxillofac Surg 51:1211-1216, 1993
ciency. Can J Anaesth 41:1104-1112, 1994 (review) 114. Flanigan RC, Butler KM, O'Neal W, et al: Comparison
96. Horrow J, Strong MD, Van Riper DF: Tranexamic acid of epsilon aminocaproic acid and normal saline for postopera-
after bypass: Too late to help? J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg tive bladder irrigation following transurethral resection of
107:1375-1377, 1994 (letter) prostate. Urology 26:227-228, 1985
97. Horrow JC, Hlavacek J, Strong MD, et al: Prophylactic 115. Sharifi R, Lee M, Ray E et al: Safety and efficacy of
tranexamic acid decreases bleeding after cardiac operations. J intravesical aminocaproic acid for bleeding after transurethral
Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 99:70-74, 1990 resection of prostate. Urology 27:214-219, 1986
98. Horrow JC, Van Riper DE Strong MD, et al: The 116. Kang YG, Lewis JH, Navalgund A, et al: Epsilon-
182 GREEN, WONG, AND TWARDOWSKI

aminocaproic acid for treatment of fibrinolysis during liver 130. Andersson TLG, Solem JO, Tengborn L, et al: Effects of
transplantation. Anesthesiology 66:766-773, 1987 desmopressin acetate on platelet aggregation, von Willebrand
117. McSorley MW, Taraporewalla KJ: Does prophylactic factor, and blood loss after cardiac surgery with extracorporeal
epsilon-aminocaproic acid improve blood loss and coagulation circulation. Circulation 81:872-878, 1990
in liver transplantation? Trans Proceed 23:1941, 1991 13t. Hedderich GS, Petsikas DJ, Cooper BA, et al: Desmo-
118. Oertli D, Laffer U, Haberthuer E et al: Perioperative and pressin acetate in uncomplicated coronary artery bypass sur-
postoperative tranexamic acid reduces the local wound compli- gery: A prospective randomized clinical trial. Can J Surg
cation rate after surgery for breast cancer. Br J Surg 81:856-859, 33:33-36, 1990
1994 132. Frankville DD, Harper GB, Lake CL, Johns RA:
119. Kopitnik TA, Samson DS: Management of subarach- Hemodynamic consequences of desmopressin administration
noid haemorrhage. J Neurol, Neurosurg, Psych 56:947-959, after cardiopulmonary bypass. Anesth 74:988-996, 1991
1993 133. Reich DL, Hammerschlag BC, Rand JH, et al: Desmo-
120. Tsementzis SA, Meyer CH, Hitcbeock ER: Cerebral pressin acetate is a mild vasodilator that does not reduce blood
blood flow in patients with a subarachnoid haemorrhage during loss in uncomplicated cardiac surgical procedures. J Cardiotho-
treatment with tranexamic acid. Neurochirurg 35:74-78, 1992 rac Vasc Anesth 5:142-145, 1991
121. Glick R, Green D, Ts'ao C, et al: High dose ~-aminoca- 134. Salmenpera M, Kuitunen A, Hynynen M, Heinnnen J:
proic acid prolongs the bleeding time and increases rebleeding Hemodynamic responses to desmopressin acetate after CABG:
and intraoperative hemorrhage in patients with subarachnoid A double-blind trial. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 5:146-149,
hemorrhage. Neurosurg 9:398-401, 1981 1991
122. Kane MJ, Silverman LR, Rand JH, et al: Myonecrosis
135. Hackmann T, Gascoyne RD, Nalman SC, et at: A trial of
as a complication of the use of epsilon aminocaproic acid: A
desmopressin (l-desamino-8-D-arginine vasopressin) to reduce
case report and review of the literature. Am J Med 85:861-863,
blood loss in uncomplicated cardiac surgery. N Engl J Med
1988
321:1437-1443, 1989
123. Schultz M, van der Lelie H: Microscopic haematuria as
136. de Prost D, Barbier-Boehm G, Hazebroucq J, et al:
a relative contraindication for tranexamic acid. Br J Haematol
Desmopressin has no beneficial effect on excessive postopera-
89:663-664, 1995
tive bleeding or blood product requirements associated with
124. Dentz ME, Slaughter TF, Mark JB: Early thrombus
cardiopulmonary bypass. Thromb Haemostas 68:106-110, 1992
formation on heparin-bonded pulmonary artery catheters in
137. Kuitunen AH: Haemostatic responses to desmopressin
patients receiving epsilon aminocaproic acid. Anesthesiology
82:583-586, 1995 acetate after primary coronary artery bypass surgery. Ann
125. Green D: Disorders of the vitamin K-dependent coagu- Chirurg et Gynaecol 81:1 l- 18, 1992
lation factors, in E Beutler, MA Lichtman, BS Coller, TJ Kipps 138. Temeck BK, Bachenheimer LC, Katz NM, et al: Desmo-
(eds): Williams Hematology (ed 5). New York, NY, McGraw pressin acetate in cardiac surgery: A double-blind, randomized
Hill, 1995, pp 1481-1485 study. Southern Med J 87:611-615, 1994 (review)
126. White RH, McKittrick T, Hutchinson R, Twitchell J: 139. Dietrich W, Barankay A, Hahnel C, Richter JA: High
Temporary discontinuation of warfarin therapy: Changes in the dose aprotinin in cardiac surgery: Three years' experience in
international normalized ratio. Ann Intern Med 122:40-42, 1995 1.784 patients. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anaesth 6:324-327, 1992
127. Rocha E, Llorens R, Paramo JA, et at: Does desmopres- 140. Biagini A, Comte C, Russo V, Salerno ML: High-dose
sin acetate reduce blood loss after surgery in patients on aprotinin to reduce blood loss in patients undergoing redo open
cardiopulmonary bypass? Circulation 77:1319-1323, 1988 heart surgery. Acta Anaesth Belg 43:181-188, 1992
128. Brown MR, Swygert TH, Whitten CW, et al: Desmopres- 141. Dementieva I1, Dzemeshkevich SL: The use of high
sin acetate following cardiopulmonary bypass: Evaluation of doses of aprotinin to decrease blood loss in aortocoronary
coagulation parameters. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 3:726-729, bypass surgery. J Cardiovasc Surg 35:185-186, 1994 (suppl)
1989 142. Daily PO, Lamphere JA, Dembitsky WR et at: Effect of
129. Hackmann T, Gascoyne RD, Naiman SC, et al: A trial of prophylactic epsilon-aminocaproic acid on blood loss and
desmopressin (l-desamino-8-D-arginine vasopressin) to reduce transfusion requirements in patients undergoing first-time corn-
blood loss in uncomplicated cardiac surgery. N Engl J Med nary artery bypass grafting. A randomized, prospective, double-
321:1437-1443, 1989 blind study. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 108:99-106, 1994

You might also like