You are on page 1of 7

Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy

Diane M Wong, A3 Technologies LLC, Aberdeen, MD, USA


Alexander A Bol’shakov, A3 Technologies LLC, Aberdeen, MD, USA and Applied Spectra Inc., Fremont, CA, USA
Richard E Russo, A3 Technologies LLC, Aberdeen, MD, USA, Applied Spectra Inc., Fremont, CA, USA and
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, USA
& 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

specific requirements for the sample to fluoresce, be


Abbreviations
IB inverse bremsstrahlung
Raman-active or infrared-sensitive. It is truly a universal
technique, where any sample type can yield a LIBS
ICP-AES inductively coupled plasma-atomic
spectrum.
emission spectrometry
ICP-MS inductively coupled plasma-mass
spectrometry
Theory of Laser-Induced Breakdown
LIBS laser-induced breakdown
Spectroscopy
spectroscopy
LSD laser-supported detonation
In practice, LIBS is a very simple spectroscopic techni-
LTE local thermodynamic equilibrium
que to implement. A high-powered laser beam (com-
MPI multiphoton ionization
monly 10-ns pulsed infrared 1.06 mm radiation) is focused
UV ultraviolet
through a lens to produce a plasma. The emitted light is
collected, often through a fiber optic cable, and directed
into a spectrometer (Figure 1). However, the physics and
chemistry of the plasma initiation, formation, lifetime,
Introduction
and decay are very complicated. Much progress has been
made in recent years toward elucidating the physics
Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) is a
of the plasma generation processes. Studies that have
powerful analytical technique that can be used for the
been performed to characterize the LIBS plasma include
detection and characterization of materials. In LIBS, a
local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) models, hydro-
focused laser beam is used to generate a plasma plume on
dynamic and kinetic models, nonuniform plasmas, and
the surface of solid and liquid samples or inside the
plasmas generated in a vacuum.
sample volume of gases, liquids, and aerosols. Each ex-
There are two main processes that can initiate ion-
cited atom in the plasma emits a unique set of spectral
ization of atomic and molecular species in laser-induced
lines, particularly in the optical region of the spectrum.
breakdown. The first is the direct ionization of the
Therefore, this optical emission can be collected and
sample by multiphoton ionization (MPI), and the second
analyzed to determine the chemical composition of a
is the inverse bremsstrahlung (IB) absorption processes.
sample. A LIBS plasma can be generated as a single event
In MPI, atoms or molecules undergo simultaneous ab-
using just one laser pulse or using repetitive laser pulses.
sorption of sufficient numbers of photons to cause ion-
As a result, localized microanalysis with lateral and depth
ization (or the ejection of electrons from the valence to
profiling information is easily obtained. Remote sensing
the conduction band, in the case of metals) (eqn [1]).
of materials is also possible with LIBS, since only photons
need to come in direct contact with the sample. The
ability to perform analyses on samples at a standoff M þ mðhvÞ- M þ þ e  ½1
distance is especially important when dealing with
hazardous materials, samples located in a dangerous If EI is the ionization potential, then m, the number of
environment, or in physically inaccessible locations. photons, must be greater than the integer part of (EI/
LIBS has a distinct advantage over many other tech- hn þ 1). MPI is only significant at wavelengths that are
niques since little or no sample preparation is needed shorter than B1 mm and at high laser power, that is,
before analysis, and it can be used for rapid real-time greater than 1010 W/cm2. When the wavelength is sub-
analysis in field operations. Quantitative analytical results stantially longer than B1 mm, it is statistically unlikely
can be obtained from LIBS by using conventional (one- for an atom or molecule to absorb enough photons to
element) or multivariate calibration. Recently, cali- increase the energy of the neutral above its ionization
bration-free LIBS analysis has been demonstrated as the potential. This process is also important at low pressures,
semiquantitative determination of elements, based on when few collisions are occurring due to the low particle
theoretical plasma models. With LIBS, there are no density of the medium.

1281
1282 Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy

Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy


Laser
(LIBS)
power supply

Laser head Focusing lens Laser spark

Unknown material
Input optical fiber
Collection lenses
PC

Spectrograph

Delay generator

Detector controller

Figure 1 Schematic diagram of a typical lab bench LIBS setup.

IB processes involve the absorption of a photon by one in the number of free electrons, resulting in cascade
or more seed electrons present in the focal volume at the ionization. IB processes can be so dramatic that all the
beginning of the laser pulse. These initial free electrons species ablated from the surface of the substrate can
may be generated through the presence of cosmic rays, or be ionized causing such an increase in plasma growth
by the Earth’s natural radiation. The first few photons in that the entire laser pulse can be coupled into the plasma.
a laser pulse can also produce seed electrons from dust, This results in the plasma becoming so optically opaque

negative ions, such as O2, organic vapors, or from atoms that the substrate becomes shielded from the remainder
and molecules present in the atmosphere via MPI. Seed of the laser pulse.
electrons are not necessary for ‘pure’ MPI processes. Both MPI and IB absorption can contribute to cascade
In IB, the absorption of a photon raises the electron ionization. The dominant process will depend on the
energy to a higher state in the continuum. This process wavelength of the laser radiation, laser intensity, and
must occur in the vicinity of a heavy particle, such as an density of the medium in which the laser breakdown
atom, ion, or molecule so that momentum is conserved. occurs. IB-dominated breakdown is important at high
In normal bremsstrahlung processes, high-energy elec- pressures, when collisional effects are strong, and at
trons emit radiation as they slow down upon interacting wavelengths longer than 1 mm. At shorter irradiation
with a gas or a solid. This term comes from the German wavelengths (o1 mm) or at low densities of molecules,
words, bremsen, which means to slow down, and strah- the possibility of electrons colliding with neutral species
lung, which means radiation. Electrons will typically lose is small. Therefore, MPI dominates usually at these
energy by rotational and vibrational excitation of neutral shorter wavelengths and in low-density media. Cascade
molecules, excitation of electronic states, and by attach- ionization continues throughout the duration of the laser
ment of electrons. However, in IB processes, electrons pulse and results in the ionization and dielectric break-
acquire energy from the absorbance of photons and down of gases, vaporized particles, and the creation of a
collisions with atoms, ions, and molecules. If the energy plasma.
of the free electron is greater than the ionization po-
tential of a neutral species, it can ionize a molecule (M)
by colliding with it. This produces two lower-energy free Plasma Life Cycle
electrons, which can gain more energy from the electric
field, causing ionization of other neutrals and two more The plasma generated by a focused laser beam in LIBS
electrons (eqn [2]). has a distinct, time-dependent life cycle. For a plasma to
be created, the breakdown threshold must be reached.
e  þ M- 2e  þ M þ ½2 This breakdown threshold is usually defined qualita-
tively as the minimum irradiance needed to generate a
With the increase in the population of ions and electrons visible plasma. With the exponential increase in the
in the focal volume, the probability of electron–photon production of free electrons and ions by IB and MPI
neutral collisions also increases, resulting in electron processes, the plasma begins to expand from the initial
multiplication and cascade growth. As more and more focal volume. Ablated materials, such as particulates,
electrons repeat the process, there is a geometric growth ions, molecules, neutrals, and electrons, are also present
Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy 1283

in the plasma that forms at the surface of the sample in LIBS Emission Signal Enhancement –
solids and liquids. The ionization potential of gases is Background Gas Effects
generally higher than that of liquids and solids, but they
too can be readily analyzed by LIBS. Using higher- Different background gases are often utilized to enhance
energy densities, gases can be ionized with a tightly the quality and intensity of the LIBS plasma, especially
focused laser to produce a plasma in the sample volume. for the analysis of complicated or difficult samples. The
A sonic boom is produced from the initial expansion of use of argon gas is a common technique to effectively
the plasma. The compression wave front, or shock wave, enhance the LIBS emission signal. In this method, a
emanates from the focal volume of the plasma. The wave steady stream of gas is directed toward the focal volume
front is traveling well above the speed of sound, on the of the plasma. This increases both the intensity and
order of 105 ms–1. For comparison, the speed of sound in quality of the signal by displacing the background air and
air is B345 ms–1 at 211C. As the plasma expands, it making it easier to generate a plasma. Calculations of
continuously emits spectroscopic signals from all con- electron densities and plasma temperatures of plasmas
stituent components in the sample. When the plasma created in difference background gases show that argon
cools through radiation and other loss mechanisms, the produces the highest temperatures and electron densities,
ionized species recombine to form neutral atoms and followed by ambient air. Helium is associated with the
molecules. lowest temperatures and densities.
Throughout the lifetime of the plasma, the emission When laser ablation is performed in a vacuum, lower
spectrum changes as a function of time. In the earliest temperatures are attained and lower concentrations of
phase, there is a strong white light component, which electrons are seen in the plasma volume than in a gaseous
contains little useful spectroscopic information. This environment. Since there is no pressure counteracting
continuum light consists mainly of bremsstrahlung free plasma expansion in the vacuum, the expansion rate
and recombination radiation. Recombination radiation is is increased whereas the cooling rate is decreased as
caused by the recombination of free electrons and ions. compared to expansion in a gas. This decrease in cooling
As stated earlier, bremsstrahlung radiation is caused by rate of the excited electrons can be explained by the
the decrease in the translational energy that occurs when dominance of elastic collisions. Since cooling is inversely
ions and electrons slow down upon collision with a gas or proportional to the mass of the background gas, heavier
solid. This is in contrast to IB processes, which cause gases like argon have a less efficient cooling capacity than
cascade ionization during the initial breakdown event. helium or air. Therefore, using argon will produce higher
After the laser pulse, the continuum gradually fades plasma temperatures with greater electron density than
allowing the weaker spectroscopic signals from the one produced in ambient air or gases with lower atomic
elements of interest to be detected. This occurs in a time masses, like helium. Argon also displaces the nitrogen
frame that is much longer than the laser pulse duration, and oxygen molecules in the air. This effectively elim-
which in a nanosecond laser is on the order of 10 ns. inates any interference from these molecules in the an-
Since the weaker signals only appear as the continuum alysis of species that contain nitrogen and oxygen atoms,
fades, the collection of the spectroscopic signal of interest including organic compounds.
should be delayed. When argon gas is utilized, a laser-supported det-
Time parameters in LIBS are important consider- onation (LSD) wave can be observed at the tip of the
ations when obtaining emission spectra. At low laser vapor plume 3 ns after the laser pulse. An LSD wave
pulse energies, that is, several millijoules, the time occurs when a shock wave front, expanding at supersonic
delay may need to be less than 1 ns in duration to ob- speeds, is transmissive enough to allow the incoming
tain an optimal signal. With higher laser powers, the laser energy to penetrate the boundary of the plasma
delay may be several microseconds. Too short a and the surrounding atmospheric gases. The shock wave
gate width will not allow enough signal to be processed is powerful enough to compress and heat the gases
across the detector. Too long a gate width will allow surrounding the plasma, thus allowing for strong optical
too much ambient light to enter the detector thus ad- absorption of the incoming laser radiation. The com-
versely affecting the signal to noise ratio. Optimization pression of background gases by the shock wave en-
of the time delay and gate width should be performed hances the conversion of kinetic energy into thermal
on the individual samples to maximize the relative energy in the vapor plume by slowing the rate of vapor
intensities of the emission lines for the signatures plume expansion. As a result, the vapor plume generated
of interest. Sample properties, such as substrate, matrix, with a background gas of argon continues to increase in
and concentration, and experimental conditions such as temperature and electron number density after the laser
laser power, wavelength, and pulse width, can all influ- pulse ends. The LSD is thought to create an area of high
ence the temperature and energy density of the plasma temperature and low gas density above the vapor plume,
(Figure 2). which allows the expansion of the plume to continue, in
1284 Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy

(b)

(a)

(c) 500 000


Orange truck
(d)

400 000

LIBS emission
300 000

200 000 Pb

100 000

0
390 400 410 420
Wave length (nm)

Figure 2 (a) A commercial LIBS instrument (RT100 -HP) developed by A3 Technologies, LLC (Aberdeen, MD, USA) and Applied
Spectra, Inc. (Fremont, CA, USA). (b) The emission plasma can be seen underneath the focusing objective. (c) A spectrum was taken of
the paint used on a (d) toy truck. It clearly shows that the paint was contaminated with lead (Pb).

addition to supplying energy to the plume, which LIBS Emission Signal Enhancement –
is well after the end of the laser pulse. This contrasts Double Pulse
with the behavior of the plasma in helium where
the vapor plume electron number density reaches a The use of double laser pulses is another method that has
maximum at the end of the laser pulse. The phenom- been used to produce significant enhancements of the
enological difference between the two gases can LIBS signal. One limitation of the LIBS technique has
be explained as a function of the mass and ionization been its lower sensitivity compared to other spectro-
potential of the two gases. Argon has mass of 40 amu and metric techniques such as atomic absorption and in-
an ionization potential of 15.759 eV versus 4 amu and ductively coupled plasma atomic emission and mass
24.587 eV for helium. The smaller atomic mass at spectrometry (ICP-AES and ICP-MS). Typically, single-
helium means that it is less efficient of preventing vapor pulse nanosecond LIBS has limits of detection in the
plume expansion since it creates less drag than the parts-per-million range whereas other commonly used
heavier argon atoms. The higher ionization potential elemental analysis methods can detect analytes in the
also means the background gas is less ionized parts-per-billion range or lower. The use of double or
during laser ablation so no LSD wave occurs. Since multiple laser pulses has developed as a strategy to
there is no LSD wave, more laser energy is absorbed overcome this deficiency. The term, double pulse, is
by the vapor plume. As a result, the electron density defined as using two laser pulses to produce a LIBS
and temperature of the plume reach a maximum plasma that are separated in time by nanoseconds or
at approximately the center of the pulse width of the microseconds. Since a majority of the laser energy is
laser. absorbed by the target sample and vapor plume,
Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy 1285

successive laser strikes can be used to reheat the plasma using femtosecond lasers since the formation of the
containing the ionized species, causing significant in- plasma plume occurs only after the laser pulse has ended.
creases in the emissions of the species present in the These factors improve significantly the reproducibility of
plume. The first double-pulse experiments were con- the analysis.
ducted in bulk aqueous solution by two overlapping, Use of short-wavelength (ultraviolet, UV) lasers pro-
laser-induced plasmas. Using this technique, detection vides more efficient and reproducible ablation and hence
limits were improved by orders of magnitude over a is more accurate than the infrared lasers. Advantages of
single-nanosecond pulse. In a dense medium, like water, the UV irradiation are associated with more efficient
the first pulse forms a bubble in the solution, which absorption in the sample bulk (i.e., smaller losses due to
reduces the plasma quenching of the second pulse. reflection from the surface and less absorption in the
Temperature and signal enhancements seen in double- plume above the sample surface), as well as a lower
pulse LIBS are probably due to (1) rarefaction of at- number of steps required for MPI as compared to the
mosphere by the first pulse creating a lower-pressure laser-induced breakdown in the infrared. Because of
volume where plasma excitation is more efficient and (2) the higher photon energy, the UV radiation can break
a larger portion of laser energy of the second pulse lattice bonds even in a single-quantum absorption event.
being absorbed in the analyte containing plasma, instead Ablation by short-pulse UV lasers is a direct and very
of being absorbed at the sample surface or in the efficient method of microextraction. Fractionation effects,
atmosphere. which can cause the ratios of elements in a plume to
There are many variations in the double-pulse differ from the stoichiometry of the sample, are min-
method. It has been used in liquids, on liquid surfaces, imized by utilizing this technique. Although fractionation
with solids, gases, and thin films. Different pulse and laser cannot be entirely avoided, ablation with short-pulse UV
configurations have been studied including the use of lasers reduces the difficulties associated with calibration,
different laser wavelengths, energies, pulse widths, and reproducibility, and accuracy of the analysis.
beam geometries. As with argon, the use of double-pulse The elimination of heat transfer and meltdown effects
LIBS can be used to remove atmospheric nitrogen and in the femtosecond mode becomes of particular signifi-
oxygen from the plasma volume. This allows the analysis cance for local lateral and layer-by-layer analyses where
of nitrogen- and oxygen-containing compounds to pro- one must avoid thermal ‘mixing’ of neighboring areas in
ceed without interference from nitrogen and oxygen the sample. The UV focus spot can be reduced to a
atoms in the air. The initial laser pulse displaces the smaller size compared to the infrared. However, use of
ambient air whereas the emission from the second pulse short-wavelength lasers can result in the deterioration of
is used in the analysis of the compound of interest. Of resolution in layer-by-layer analysis.
these two enhancement techniques, the double-pulse
technique has a major advantage over the use of argon
because it can be used in remote or standoff detection Standoff (Remote) Detection Using LIBS
applications.
One of the advantages of LIBS over other analytical
methods is the ability to analyze samples remotely.
LIBS Reproducibility and Accuracy Samples need not be placed inside the instrument, or
Enhancement even be in the same proximity, for analysis to occur. The
only requirements are the abilities to direct photons to
For analytical purposes, it is desirable that the extracted the sample and collect the resulting emission spectrum. If
mass is independent of possible heterogeneity in the a medium is relatively transparent to the laser beam, and
sample. Very short pulses can be used, for example, to the beam is able to strike its intended target with suf-
eliminate the effect of thermalization and heat transfer ficient energy to create an emitting plasma, LIBS analysis
across the sample. For pulses of B1000 fs and shorter, the is possible. This is extremely important when samples are
duration of the laser pulse is sufficient to heat up only the physically inaccessible, in a hazardous location or when
electrons in the vicinity of the laser-illuminated spot on the substance to be analyzed is potentially dangerous
the sample surface. An explosion-type ejection of these (Figure 3).
electrons causes simultaneous destruction and ejection of There are many examples of remote LIBS in the lit-
the cold lattice material due to the Coulomb forces. erature. Rapid analysis of metals including Cu, Zn, Al, Ni,
Thus, in the femtosecond mode, the process of instant- Mo, and Pb has been done at moderate distances of 0.5–
aneous vaporization and ionization of the sample can be 2.4 m to demonstrate the utility of this technique for
greatly simplified, without inducing heat transfer across identification and sorting purposes in industrial appli-
the sample and without shielding of the laser irradiation cations. Remote LIBS in combination with specific laser
by the plasma plume. Shielding is not relevant when ablation techniques has also been shown to be of great
1286 Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy

Standoff LIBS High-resolution ICCD Spectral data for analysis


spectrograph system

Samples at 50 m

Telescope
Collected light
Chemometrics
Plasma

Laser beam
Reference spectra

NO YES
Explosive detection
and identification
LIBS data are compared to a library of reference
spectra for identification of unknown samples

Figure 3 Schematics of the standoff LIBS system used as a 50-m remote detector of explosive materials in Mojave Desert. The
sensor concept and the chemometric identification algorithms were developed and successfully field-tested by A3 Technologies, LLC
(Aberdeen, MD, USA) and Applied Spectra, Inc. (Fremont, CA, USA) in collaboration with the US Army Research Laboratory (Aberdeen
Proving Ground, MD, USA).

value in the cleaning of cultural heritage objects, such as concentrations of parts-per-million. Enhancement of the
statues, architectural structures, and other archeological LIBS signal can be accomplished with the use of argon
materials. gas that increases the temperature and the electron
Since LIBS can be performed remotely and with no density of the emission signal. The double-pulse laser
part of the instrument coming in direct contact with the technique can also enhance signal quality by reheating
specimen, it can be very useful in applications where the plasma as well as displacing the oxygen and nitrogen
contamination of equipment is an issue. LIBS has been present in ambient air. Femtosecond UV laser pulses
used with success in spent nuclear fuel reprocessing plants offer advantages in accuracy and in reproducibility of
where a laser beam can be introduced into a highly LIBS spectra due to the elimination of heat transfer,
radioactive chamber through leaded glass to analyze both shielding, and fractionation effects. Recent developments
radioactive and nonradioactive deposits coating a dissolver in both laser technology and basic understanding of the
basket. No decontamination of equipment is necessary plasma physics have allowed LIBS to be used reliably and
since the system does not come into physical contact with with great sensitivity in a wide variety of analytical
the highly radioactive surfaces. Other industrial appli- applications.
cations include the identification of carbon contamination
in molten steel, analysis of mineral melt at 1600 1C, and
remote analysis of high-voltage insulators. In summary, See also: Atomic Absorption, Methods and
remote LIBS is used for process control applications in Instrumentation, Atomic Emission, Methods and
metallurgy, mineral, and coal industries, and also for en- Instrumentation, Environmental and Agricultural
vironmental control, detection of explosive residues, cul- Applications of Atomic Spectroscopy, Laser Ablation ICP-
tural heritage monitoring, and planetary exploration. MS.

Conclusion
Further Reading
LIBS is a versatile spectroscopic tool that can be easily Abhilasha RKT (1995) Line-emission enhancement in laser-ablated
implemented for the characterization and detection of carbon plasmas. Applied Physics B: Lasers and Optics 61: 63--67.
substances. Since excited atoms of all elements emit in Babushok VI, DeLucia FC, Gottfried JL, Munson CA, and Miziolek AW
(2006) Double pulse laser ablation and plasma: Laser induced
the optical segment of the spectrum, there are no re- breakdown spectroscopy signal enhancement. Spectrochimica
strictions on the type of samples to be analyzed. LIBS can Acta, Part B: Atomic Spectroscopy 61B: 999--1014.
be used for real-time analysis of materials as a remote or Bogaerts A, Chen Z, and Bleiner D (2006) Laser ablation of copper in
different background gases: Comparative study by numerical
portable system. Little or no sample preparation is re- modeling and experiments. Journal of Analytical Atomic
quired and the technique is sensitive to residues in Spectrometry 21: 384--395.
Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy 1287

Bol’shakov AA, Ganeev AA, and Nemets VM (2006) Prospects in Scaffidi J, Angel SM, and Cremers DA (2006) Emission enhancement
analytical atomic spectrometry. Russian Chemical Reviews 75: mechanisms in dual-pulse LIBS. Analytical Chemistry 78: 24--32.
289–302. Singh J and Thakur SN (2007) Laser-Induced Breakdown
Cremers DA (1987) The analysis of metals at a distance using laser-in- Spectroscopy. Oxford: Elsevier.
duced breakdown spectroscopy. Applied Spectroscopy 41: 572--579. St Onge L, Detalle V, and Sabsabi M (2002) Enhanced laser-induced
Cremers DA and Radziemski LJ (1989) Laser-Induced Plasmas and breakdown spectroscopy using the combination of fourth-harmonic
Applications. New York, NY: Marcel Dekker. and fundamental Nd: YAG laser pulses. Spectrochimica Acta, Part
Cremers DA and Radziemski LJ (2006) Handbook of Laser-Induced B: Atomic Spectroscopy 57b: 121--135.
Breakdown Spectroscopy. West Sussex, UK: Wiley. Wen S, Mao X, Greif R, and Russo RE (2007) Experimental and
De Giacomo A, Dell’Aglio M, De Pascale O, and Capitelli M (2007) From theoretical studies of particle generation after laser ablation of
single pulse to double pulse ns-laser induced breakdown copper with a background gas at atmospheric pressure. Journal of
spectroscopy under water: Elemental analysis of aqueous solutions Applied Physics 101: 123105--123115.
and submerged solid samples. Spectrochimica Acta Part B 62: Wen S, Mao X, Liu C, Greif R, and Russo RE (2007) Expansion and
721--738. cooling of the laser induced plasma. Journal of Physics: Conference
Mao X, Wen S, and Russo RE (2007) Time-resolved laser induced Series; Eighth International Conference on Laser Ablation 59:
plasma dynamics. Applied Surface Science 253: 6316--6321. 343--347.
Miziolek AW, Palleschi V, and Schechter I (2006) Laser-Induced Whitehouse AI (2006) Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy and its
Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS), Fundamentals and Applications. application to the remote characterisation of hazardous materials.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Spectroscopy Europe 18: 14--21.
Nimmrichter J, Kautek W, and Schreiner M (eds.) (2005) Lasers in the Winefordner JD, Gornushkin IB, Correll T, et al. (2004) Comparing
Conservation of Artworks: Springer Proceedings in Physics, vol. several atomic spectrometric methods to the super stars: Special
116. Vienna, Austria: Springer. emphasis on laser induced breakdown spectrometry, LIBS, a future
Russo RE, Mao X, Liu H, Gonzalez J, and Mao SS (2002) Laser ablation super star. Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry 19:
in analytical chemistryFA review. Talanta 57: 425--451. 1061--1083.
Salle B, Mauchien P, and Maurice S (2007) Laser-induced breakdown
spectroscopy in open-path configuration for the analysis of distant
objectsFA review. Spectrochimica Acta Part B 62: 739--768.

You might also like