Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Edition
DJIA 33414.24 g 270.29 0.80% NASDAQ 12025.33 g 0.5% STOXX 600 462.51 À 0.3% 10-YR. TREAS. À 10/32 , yield 3.401% OIL $68.60 g $3.06 GOLD $2,028.60 À $14.30 EURO $1.1065 YEN 134.74
done tightening after cision to lift rates by a quarter from 3.438% Tuesday. rate rises. But Mr. Powell indi-
5
Business & Finance percentage point marked the The Fed has now raised its cated that calculation could Wednesday
10th straight increase Fed’s 10th consecutive rate in- benchmark federal-funds rate shift now and that officials +0.25 pct. pt.
crease aimed at battling infla- by a cumulative 5 percentage would need to see signs of 4
BY NICK TIMIRAOS tion. It will bring its bench- points from near zero in March stronger-than-expected growth,
F ed officials signaled
that they might be
done raising interest rates WASHINGTON—Federal Re-
mark federal-funds rate to a
range between 5% and 5.25%, a
2022, the most rapid series of
increases since the 1980s. The
hiring and inflation to continue
raising rates. The Fed’s next
3
for now after unanimously serve officials signaled they 16-year high. rate influences other rates meeting is June 13-14. 2
approving another quar- might be done raising interest Stocks retreated after the throughout the economy, such Please turn to page A2
ter-point increase at their rates for now after approving decision after rising earlier in as on mortgages, credit cards
1
latest policy meeting. A1 another increase at their meet- the day. The Dow Jones Indus- and business loans. Treasury yields slide after
Treasury yields fell and ing that concluded Wednesday. trial Average fell about 270 “I think that policy is tight,” Fed’s move................................ B10
U.S. stocks ended lower in “People did talk about paus- points, or 0.8%, while the S&P Mr. Powell said. But he said, Stocks end lower after latest 0
the wake of the meeting, ing, but not so much at this 500 and Nasdaq Composite in- “we are prepared to do more if rise.................................................. B11 2005 ’10 ’15 ’20 ’23
with the S&P 500, Nasdaq meeting,” Fed Chair Jerome dexed closed down 0.7% and greater monetary policy re- Heard on the Street: More Note: Chart shows midpoint of range since 2008.
and Dow losing 0.7%, 0.5% and Powell said at a news confer- 0.5%, respectively. U.S. govern- straint is warranted.” rate increases can wait..... B12 Source: Federal Reserve
0.8%, respectively. B10, B11
The SEC voted 3-2 to adopt
a rule requiring more disclo-
sure from public companies
about share repurchases
starting in the fourth quarter,
Epstein Courted
Washington’s latest move to
rein in such transactions. A1
The FTC proposed bar-
Notable Friends
With Favors
ring Meta Platforms from
profiting off data it collects
from young users, accusing
the firm of misleading par-
ents and repeatedly violat-
ing a 2020 privacy order. A1 BY KHADEEJA SAFDAR meetings the two men sched-
AND DAVID BENOIT uled that year.
The World Bank’s exec-
In 2016, a nonprofit linked
utive board approved Ajay
Lawrence Summers wanted to Epstein donated $110,000 to
Banga as its next presi-
$1 million to fund an online Ms. New’s nonprofit, which
dent, putting him in
poetry project his wife was develops video content about
charge of an effort to ex-
developing. The former Trea- poetry, according to tax re-
pand lending capacity and
sury secretary and onetime cords.
fight climate change. A2
Harvard University president The documents reviewed by
The CFTC voted to sus- turned to Jeffrey Epstein. the Journal, which include
pend its inspector general af- “I need small scale philan- thousands of pages of emails
ter an oversight body found thropy advice. My life will be and schedules from 2013 to
that he engaged in “substan- better if i raise $1m for Lisa,” 2017, provide new details
tial misconduct,” people fa- Mr. Summers said in an email about the nature and fre-
miliar with the matter said. B1 to Epstein in April 2014, refer- quency of Epstein’s contacts
ring to his wife, Elisa New, a with an array of powerful peo-
Johnson & Johnson’s big
Harvard professor. “Mostly it ple long after he was a regis-
consumer-healthcare busi-
will go to make it a pbs series tered sex offender. He had
ness priced its IPO at $22
and for teacher training. pleaded guilty in 2008 to so-
a share, a level that would
Ideas?” liciting and procuring a minor
value the new company at
Epstein replied that they for prostitution.
OSTOROZHNO NOVOSTI/REUTERS
President Vladimir Putin as he of Nordic states. nies will need to jump through drive a stock’s price higher.
Asia, sending the measure to
An adviser to Mr. Zelensky, more hoops to buy back their Along with dividends, they are
Biden for an expected veto. A2
By Bojan Pancevski, Mykhailo Podolyak, suggested stock under a rule approved one of the main ways compa-
In the week since Biden Thomas Grove those responsible were domes- by regulators Wednesday, nies return spare cash to their
announced his re-election bid, and Ann M. Simmons tic opponents of Mr. Putin. Washington’s latest move to investors.
legal developments in Wash- If Ukraine or its supporters rein in such transactions. Democrats have long criti-
ington and Arkansas have un- tries to rally support for his were behind the attack, it The Securities and Exchange cized the transactions, saying
derscored the potential liabil- war effort in Ukraine. would highlight serious vul- Commission voted 3-2 to adopt they distort the tax system
ities son Hunter Biden could
present for the campaign. A4
Russia said an electronic- nerabilities at the heart of U.S. in Talks a rule requiring more disclosure and encourage companies to
warfare system downed two Russian power days ahead of from public companies about distribute profits to investors
Iranian forces seized a unmanned aircraft, which ex- Victory Day, a major Russian With Russia share repurchases starting in and executives rather than in-
ploded over the Kremlin holiday commemorating vic- Blinken says Washington the fourth quarter. The SEC’s vesting in workers, technology
Panama-flagged oil tanker in
grounds. The Kremlin said no tory over Nazi Germany. ‘intensely’ working to free two Republican commissioners or production. Buybacks by
the Strait of Hormuz, the U.S.
one was injured and no major The drone strike comes be- WSJ’s Gershkovich.............. A8 voted against the rule, and the S&P 500 companies hit a re-
Navy said, marking the sec-
damage was caused. Please turn to page A7 U.S. Chamber of Commerce said Please turn to page A6
ond time in less than a week
that Iran has captured a com-
mercial ship in the region. A9
On Top of Meta Faces Restrictions
This edition of The Wall Street Journal was originally published in the United States and reprinted locally for regional distribution.
U.S. NEWS
Banga Is Approved to Lead World Bank
Mastercard’s ex-CEO term ends. philanthropies, to usher in the of officials from the U.S. and ing its resources and its policy U.S. official said, noting that
The 63-year-old Mr. Banga fundamental changes in devel- other major nations who say know-how to more effectively the support from the 25-mem-
will take over as the is a former chief executive of opment finance that this mo- the bank can spend more to catalyze private capital,” he ber board was “very strong.”
U.S. presses for money Mastercard who also held ment requires,” Mr. Biden said. fight climate change without said during an April speech. A Russian embassy spokes-
leadership roles at Citigroup Many developing nations compromising its core work to “We need to get the private man didn’t respond to a re-
to fight climate change and PepsiCo. are cautious of the climate ef- help the poor. sector to be a constructive quest to comment.
He arrives at an institution fort, worrying that it might re- “My logic is that the climate player in this mission. “ During the bank’s semian-
BY YUKA HAYASHI trying to balance competing sult in fewer resources for al- aspect is not separated from The U.S., the largest share- nual meeting last month,
priorities. The U.S. and other leviating poverty and other development,” Mr. Banga said. holder of the World Bank, has member countries approved a
WASHINGTON—The World wealthy nations have been economic development pro- Mr. Banga has said he sup- traditionally nominated U.S. plan to free up extra lending
Bank’s executive board ap- pressing the bank to lend grams. ports the idea of having the citizens as World Bank presi- capacity of $5 billion a year by
proved Ajay Banga as its next more money to programs that Developing nations were hit World Bank take on more risk dents. The practice has drawn reducing the equity-to-loan ra-
president on Wednesday, put- would fight climate change, particularly hard by the pan- and leverage its existing assets the ire of developing nations, tio to 19% from 20%.
ting the India-born American but have been reluctant to demic and higher food and en- to raise more funds. But he but Mr. Banga ran uncontested As it takes on that addi-
businessman in charge of an contribute more funds. ergy prices, and they are has also noted that, given the for president. tional risk, the bank must also
effort to expand lending capac- They have pushed the bank struggling with ballooning potentially trillions of dollars Russia abstained from vot- protect its triple-A status from
ity and fight climate change. instead to tolerate more risk debt loads. The pandemic in- needed to address climate ing to confirm Mr. Banga, credit-rating firms to raise
Mr. Banga, who was nomi- by making additional loans creased the number of people change, the lender must find breaking from the tradition of funds at rock-bottom rates.
nated for the post by Presi- with its existing funding. living in extreme poverty for ways to encourage the private unanimous board support for a Besides the capital it receives
dent Biden, is serving a five- Mr. Biden called Mr. Banga the first time in at least four sector to channel more funds new president, according to from member governments,
year term starting June 2. He a transformative leader. decades, according to the to clean energy projects people familiar with the situa- the bank’s primary sources of
is succeeding David Malpass, a “Ajay will also be integral in World Bank. around the world. tion. Mr. Banga is “starting off financing are the bonds it sells
Trump nominee who is step- bringing together the public In an interview last month, “The World Bank can play a with full faith and confidence and interest it collects on
ping down a year before his and private sectors, alongside Mr. Banga endorsed the view central role in this effort by us- of the membership,” a senior loans.
U.S. WATCH
Biden’s Solar Tariff
Exemption Targeted
BY DAVID HARRISON ment’s probe was under way.
The investigation prompted U.S.
The Senate voted 56-41 on buyers to pause imports from
Wednesday to block a move by those countries, worried that
the Biden administration to they could be subject to retro-
temporarily remove tariffs on active tariffs.
solar materials imported from In December, the Commerce
Southeast Asia, sending the Department found that four
measure to President Biden’s Chinese solar-cell manufactur-
desk for an expected veto. ers ship their products through
Nine Democrats sided with the four countries to avoid U.S.
Republicans in favor of the res- tariffs. The four countries to-
olution, while one GOP law- gether account for 80% of U.S.
maker, Sen. Rand Paul of Ken- solar-material imports.
tucky, voted against the Nick Iacovella, a spokesman
measure. The Senate’s vote fol- for the Coalition for a Prosper-
lows the House’s passage of the ous America, which represents
measure by a vote of 221-202 manufacturers, said the admin-
with 12 Democrats in support. istration’s exemption undercuts
Lawmakers who want to the goal of last year’s Inflation
overturn the tariff exemption Reduction Act, which offered in-
say the White House’s stance
harms U.S. solar manufacturers
MEGAN VARNER/GETTY IMAGES
U.S. NEWS
Vaccine
Cleared for
Experimental Drug Slows Alzheimer’s
BY PETER LOFTUS gen, which are rolling out an from Eisai and Biogen, to work scientific and medical officer. score known as the clinical-de-
FAA Plans
U.S. NEWS
McGrath, according to lawyers prosecutors are nearing a de- classified whistleblower dis-
involved in the case. They are cision on whether to charge closures.” On Twitter, Mr.
five of the 11 women who were Hunter Biden, who has said he Grassley said, “What we don’t
sexually harassed by the 65- handled his affairs legally and know is what, if anything, the
year-old Democratic scion dur- appropriately. His lawyers had FBI has done to verify these
ing his three terms as governor, requested the meeting to pres- claims or investigate further.”
according to a report by Attor- ent their view of the evidence The FBI said it had received
ney General Letitia James. and get an update on the sta- the subpoena and declined to
The subpoenas were sent in Former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, shown last year, has said he is a victim of ‘cancel culture.’ tus of the investigation. make any further comment.
late March and April, according Hunter Biden appeared with
to the lawyers. They are part of duce a pandemic memoir as yer said Wednesday that seek- claims the Commission on Eth- lawyers days later in a court-
Mr. Cuomo’s defense against a well as how the former gover- ing testimony and records from ics and Lobbying in Govern- room in Batesville, Ark., in
federal lawsuit filed by an un- nor’s aides edited a Health De- other accusers was “part of ment is unconstitutional be- connection with a child-sup-
The president’s son
identified state trooper, known partment report on Covid-19 routine discovery.” The former cause it is too independent port dispute with the mother has said he handled
as Trooper 1, who said he deaths in nursing homes. governor hasn’t had a chance from the governor’s office. of his 4-year-old child. More
touched her inappropriately on Mr. Cuomo has denied to question these women, law- An ethics commission than two years after being or-
his affairs legally
her back and stomach while she touching anybody inappropri- yer Rita Glavin said. spokeswoman said it doesn’t dered to pay child support, he and appropriately.
was assigned to his gubernato- ately and apologized if his ac- Ms. Boylan’s lawyer, Julie comment on pending litigation. had asked in September to re-
rial security detail. tions made anybody feel un- Gerchik, said her client has al- Ms. Boylan, a former state duce the monthly payments,
Trooper 1 also said in court comfortable. He said his ready participated in two inves- economic development adviser with his lawyer citing a “sub-
papers that Mr. Cuomo’s behav- investigators—including Ms. tigations. and former congressional candi- stantial material change” in White House spokesman Ian
ior was part of a pattern of ha- James and his fellow Demo- “The extreme nature of this date, in December of 2020 be- his finances. Sams said House Republicans
rassment that included multiple crats in the state Assembly who latest subpoena directed at my came the first woman to pub- During a two-hour court were floating “anonymous in-
other women, citing Ms. pushed for impeachment—were client demonstrates that Mr. licly say she had been sexually hearing this week, Judge Holly nuendo,” adding, “When it
James’s report. The judge in politically motivated. Cuomo has no qualms about harassed by Mr. Cuomo. She Meyer of the Independence comes to President Biden’s
the case has set a discovery More recently, Mr. Cuomo continuing his harassment of said the governor suggested County circuit court said personal finances, anybody
deadline for July. said he was a victim of “cancel the women he abused and is they play strip poker during a Hunter Biden would need to sit can take a look: He has offered
The latest subpoenas seek culture.” Last year, he made using taxpayer dollars to do trip on the state airplane, some- for a deposition and provide an unprecedented level of
depositions from the women, several public appearances at so,” Ms. Gerchik said. thing that he denies. written answers to questions transparency, releasing a total
as well as records of certain churches in a bid to revive his A state judge ruled in Janu- Ms. Commisso’s lawyer con- about his finances, including art of 25 years of tax returns to
communications they had be- public standing, and he cur- ary that Mr. Cuomo is entitled to firmed she had been subpoe- sales and other transactions, the American public.”
fore and after they said publicly rently hosts a weekly podcast. reimbursement for his legal de- naed and said he would let the according to news reports. The The demand to the FBI
that they had been harassed, The subpoenas are Mr. fense in the Trooper 1 lawsuit process play out. In addition to judge also criticized Hunter Bi- came weeks after Congress re-
according to people familiar Cuomo’s latest step to push because the alleged conduct speaking with state investiga- den’s legal team for redacting, ceived a letter alleging im-
with the matter. The requested back against his accusers. His took place while he was in office. tors, Ms. Commisso in 2021 told or blacking out, more informa- proper political interference in
records include certain commu- lawyers previously attempted Ms. Glavin said in response, the Albany County sheriff’s of- tion than she thought necessary the criminal investigation into
nications with state investiga- to subpoena Ms. James’s office “There’s no harassment, only fice that Mr. Cuomo reached un- in court filings, local news out- Hunter Biden. In the letter, a
tors, other accusers and the and the state Assembly for re- due process of law. So the real der her shirt and groped her lets reported. Lawyers for lawyer for an Internal Revenue
news media, the people said. cords of their investigations, question is what are the attorney breast during a 2020 encounter. Hunter Biden didn’t respond to Service supervisory special
Mr. Cuomo resigned in Au- according to court filings. Both general, the Assembly, and Ms. Ms. Liss confirmed she re- requests for comment. agent said his client had infor-
gust of 2021 after investigators parties objected to the subpoe- Boylan fighting so hard to hide?” ceived a subpoena but declined On Monday, Rep. James mation suggesting a “failure to
working for Ms. James released nas; a decision is pending. Mr. Mr. Cuomo also sued the to comment further. Mariann Comer (R., Ky.), chairman of mitigate clear conflicts of in-
their conclusions and as state Cuomo’s lawyers said during a state’s new ethics watchdog Wang, an lawyer representing the House Oversight Commit- terest in the ultimate disposi-
lawmakers moved forward with February hearing that they last month after it revived a Mmes. McGrath and Limmiatis, tee, said the case could un- tion of the case.”
impeachment proceedings. In would also like to subpoena prior effort to claw back mil- said her clients would “comply earth financial information The IRS supervisor is seek-
addition to the alleged harass- other State Police personnel lions of dollars the governor with appropriate legal process sought by Republican lawmak- ing whistleblower protections.
ment, lawmakers reviewed the who were present during was paid for his book project, while ensuring that we also ers, particularly details about A spokesperson for the IRS
allegedly improper use of state Trooper 1’s alleged harassment. for which he signed a $5.1 mil- protect our clients against im- his income from selling his hasn’t responded to requests
resources by Mr. Cuomo to pro- The former governor’s law- lion contract. The lawsuit proper burdens or harassment.” artwork. for comment.
of Trump supporters to kill ing point for conservatives last to undermine our everyday way
police during the Jan. 6, 2021, year after the school board ap- of life.”
attack on the U.S. Capitol, fed- proved rules giving students in
eral prosecutors said, adding grade seven or higher the abil- Part of policy nullified
to the tally of people with mil- ity to request a “gender support The status of the Linn-Mar
itary or law-enforcement expe- plan” that called for teachers policy is a bit murky after
rience charged in the riot. and peers to address them by a Iowa Republican Gov. Kim
Police body-camera footage new name and with new pro- Reynolds in late March signed
showed the former supervi- nouns without parental notifi- into law a bill that nullified at
sory agent, Jared L. Wise, tan- cation. It also allowed students least part of the policy the
gling with officers outside the to use locker rooms and bath- district passed a year ago. The
Capitol, investigators wrote in rooms corresponding to their district issued a statement af-
court filings filed Monday, preferred gender identity. ter the law’s passage saying it
calling them Nazis and encour- The school district said at The Linn-Mar Community School District’s rules that let some students request a ‘gender support plan’ would abide by the new re-
aging rioters attacking the po- the time it was simply making have divided parents. Geralyn Jones, left, opposes the rules and pulled her two children out of district quirements and that “all indi-
lice line to “Kill ’em! Kill ’em!” official practices it had been in- schools. Kara Larson, right, who also has two children in the school district, wants schools to accept viduals in the district will be
“You guys are disgusting,” formally following for years to the gender identities students choose for themselves. required to use bathrooms,
Mr. Wise yelled at the officers, avoid discrimination com- changing rooms, and other fa-
according to the filings. “I’m plaints. A recently passed state presidential bid May 22, met Do you favor or oppose cation-related laws in 2023 that cilities defined in the law, in
former—I’m former law en- law repealed at least portions with parents and children dur- requiring schools to notify target the rights of “lesbian, accordance with that individ-
forcement.…You are the Nazi. of the policy, including the use ing a recent visit here and said parents if their child uses a gay, bisexual, transgender, ual’s biological sex.”
You are the Gestapo.…. Shame of bathrooms. in a subsequent interview that different name or gender queer or questioning students,” A national organization,
on you!” “What we saw was a major parents had been pushed out of identity at school? the American Civil Liberties Parents Defending Education,
He “clapped his hands and uprising from parents who said too many school decisions. “The Union says. also sued the district in August
raised his arms in triumph” af- don’t enact this policy, and they conservative party should be The new transgender laws on behalf of anonymous Linn-
ter entering the Capitol wear- did it anyway,” said U.S. Rep. the party of parents,” he said. Oppose have drawn criticism from Mar parents who sought an in-
ing a dark mask before fleeing Ashley Hinson, a Republican Former Vice President Mike 27% some Democrats who say youth junction to prevent the policy’s
through a window, investiga- who represents the area and Pence focused on Linn-Mar dur- Favor are at heightened risk of de- implementation. The case is
tors wrote. Agents with the has two sons enrolled in the ing a recent visit to nearby Ce- 65% pression and even suicide if being considered by an appel-
Federal Bureau of Investiga- district. “This is an issue that dar Rapids, criticizing what he they aren’t allowed to be ac- late court, after a federal judge
tion received a tip in January every candidate should be talk- called “radical gender ideology” cepted as having a different in September denied the par-
2022 that Mr. Wise, 50 years ing about because Iowans want in public schools in remarks to gender identity than the one at ents’ motion for an injunction.
old, had been inside the Capi- to know where they stand.” conservative activists at a pizza their birth. Several district parents said
Undecided
tol that day. restaurant. “The school needs to be a they no longer have confi-
Mr. Wise, who left the bu- Scott, Pence weigh in A Linn-Mar school board 7% safe place for kids who don’t dence in the school board.
reau in 2017 after 13 years, As declared and prospective election in November, with four Note: Percentages don’t add up to 100 because have that safe place at home,” “I just couldn’t trust that
was charged with four misde- presidential candidates visit of seven seats up for election, of rounding. said Kara Larson, a 47-year-old they had my kid’s best inter-
Source: Wall Street Journal poll of 1,500
meanor counts, including dis- Iowa, they are doing just that in will likely give 2024 candidates registered voters, April 11–17; margin of error Democrat and executive assis- est,” said Geralyn Jones, a 31-
rupting the orderly conduct of efforts to woo the social con- added opportunities to weigh in +/– 2.5 pct. pts. tant who has two children in year-old mother who pulled
government business and un- servatives who dominate the just ahead of the first GOP the Linn-Mar school district. her two young children from
lawfully entering a restricted state’s Republican caucuses. Ms. presidential primary nomina- sports participation, bathroom The school district declined district schools last fall and
building. He was arrested Hinson and other Republicans tion balloting in January or use and medical care. Propo- to comment. started home schooling them.
Monday in Bend, Ore. think parental involvement in February. nents have made various argu- A Wall Street Journal poll Ms. Jones, who opposes the
A lawyer representing Mr. public schools could also carry The issue’s role in the presi- ments to push for the laws, in- conducted nationwide April school district’s policy change
Wise couldn’t be reached for political potency for the GOP in dential primary race comes as cluding sports parity and 11-17 showed 65% of voters—in- and is the county chair of a
comment. The FBI declined to next year’s general election. some Republican-led states, in- protecting children from sexual cluding 90% of likely GOP pri- group called Moms for Liberty,
comment on his employment Sen. Tim Scott (R., S.C.), ex- cluding Iowa, have passed legis- assault. mary voters—favor requiring plans to send her children to a
history. pected to formally announce his lation to regulate transgender Nine states have passed edu- schools to notify parents if private school next year.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, May 4, 2023 | A5
A6 | Thursday, May 4, 2023 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
GWEN SCHNEIDER
their own, Ms. Drago said. “It abella’s bedroom was too Schneider, who is headed to
is obscene. You can go to any small to accommodate the Roanoke College in Salem, Va.,
extreme.” more than 20 invited guests. friends decorated her bedroom
On top of the baby showers, Ms. Tenembaum hung red- with balloons and streamers in
gender-reveal extravaganzas, and-silver streamers from the Gwen Schneider, of Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y., celebrates her decision to attend Roanoke College. the school’s maroon color. One
birthday parties, and kinder- windows, a custom Alabama guest made gluten-free cup-
garten, middle-school and banner on the wall and set up baum said. prise or directed by the guest ticed the events are spreading. cakes with maroon icing.
high-school graduations, a bouquet of balloons that Isabella, 17, was already of honor. Some teens create Ms. Weinstock, owner of In Gwen’s community of
comes another milestone cele- spelled Bama. Isabella’s working on a 22-page Google their own registries, similar to Sweet Ali Confections, said Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y., bed
bration for children: the bed friends filled the bed with slideshow listing places to buy ones for weddings and baby she recently received orders parties are low-key affairs, she
party. their own gifts: Alabama specific gifts when she got the showers, to make sure they from Maryland and the Chi- said, typically organized and
Students in the early days shirts, pillows and mugs, red news from Alabama. get the gifts they want. cago suburbs. paid for by close friends.
of Covid-19 started announc- Nike and white Converse Like many of her peers, Is- Vendors serving bed-party “I had a grandma call me The 18-year-old high-school
ing their college choices by sneakers. abella had scrolled Pinterest clients say the events are con- last week to place an order for senior has been to four of the
decorating an inflatable bed, That evening, about 80 boards devoted to bed parties centrated in the areas around her granddaughter,” Ms. Wein- parties and is organizing three
usually outside, with piles of friends came to dinner. “Who- and followed influencers that New York, New Jersey and stock said. “I made a comment others.
campus merchandise. As pho- ever invented bed parties and featured them. “My bed was Connecticut. that it’s all for the picture. For her own party, Gwen
tos of the swag-covered beds commitment parties, congrat- inspired by other beds I’ve Alison Weinstock, who And she said, ‘Yeah, obvi- said, “I didn’t make a list. I
have spread online, the dis- ulations you hit the jackpot in seen,” she said. makes custom desserts with a ously.’ ” was just happy with whatever
plays have become increas- this community,” Ms. Tenem- Bed parties are either a sur- college colors and logo, no- Chase Turnof, a 17-year-old I would get.”
WORLD NEWS
Fire Erupts at Russia Fuel Depot Belarusian
Blogger
Suspected Ukraine
drone attacks near
Crimea come ahead
Sentenced
of expected offensive To Prison
BY BOJAN PANCEVSKI BY ANN M. SIMMONS
AND IAN LOVETT
Roman Protasevich, the Be-
KYIV, Ukraine—A fuel depot larusian activist who was ar-
in a strategically important rested after the government
area of Russia caught fire scrambled a jet fighter to di-
early Wednesday in an appar- vert his Ryanair flight from
ent drone attack, the latest in Greece, was sentenced to eight
a series of such assaults and years in prison.
acts of sabotage on Russian- The Minsk Regional Court in
held territory ahead of an ex- the Belarusian capital Wednes-
pected Ukrainian offensive. day found Mr. Protasevich
The oil storage in the guilty of organizing riots, call-
southern village of Volna in ing for acts of terrorism and
the Krasnodar region near oc- insulting Belarusian President
cupied Crimea caught fire as a Alexander Lukashenko, among
result of “the fall of a drone,” other crimes, Belarus’s state
according to multiple state news agency Belta reported.
media outlets. The dissident blogger will
ROMAN SOKOLOV/TASS/ZUMA PRESS
Kremlin
JOURNALISTS DON’T
Struck by
YURI KOCHETKOV/EPA/SHUTTERSTOCK
WORLD NEWS
line sabotage days before the penhagen. Mr. Tice and at least five other
explosions took place. “I don’t have a smoking missing Americans who are be-
Russian maritime activity gun,” he said. “But in my opin- lieved to have been detained
isn’t unusual in the Baltic Sea, ion, there is no doubt as to by the Assad regime.
where the explosions that took who was behind it.” Mr. Biden raised Mr. Tice’s
the natural-gas pipelines out Russia’s foreign ministry case last weekend at the White
of commission last year. said Wednesday that allega- House Correspondents’ Dinner,
A senior European official tions that it was involved in where the journalist’s mother,
familiar with the investigation the Nord Stream sabotage Debra Tice, was in the audience.
into the explosions said the were “part of the Western “We are not giving up,” Mr.
movements of the Russian misinformation campaign to Biden told Ms. Tice and the au-
vessels have long been known ensure that those who ordered dience. “We are not ceasing
to investigators and have been and perpetrated this act of in- our effort to get him, find him,
dismissed as unlikely to be ternational terrorism are and bring him home.”
connected with the attack. never identified.”
Still, evidence of the Rus- Last September, underwater explosions tore apart three of the four main Nord Stream pipes. Four Nordic public broad-
sian ships so close to the site casters have reported that at
of the blasts and just days be- Four days earlier, on Sept. SS-750, which can be equipped Andromeda and its six passen- least three Russian ships able
fore the explosions has caused 22, a Danish naval patrol ves- with a small submarine. gers, some of whom had to perform underwater opera-
a fresh stir around one of the sel, P524 Nymfen, took 112 The existence of the 112 Ukrainian passports, German tions were present near the
most closely guarded investi- photographs of several Rus- photographs was earlier re- officials briefed on the probe blast sites between June and
gations into who is responsi- sian vessels near the blast ported by Information, a Dan- said. September last year.
ble for the attacks. site, the Danish Defence Com- ish daily. Some analysts have ex- The ships included the Rus-
Last Sept. 26, a series of mand said in a response to a Following the pipeline sabo- pressed skepticism that a sail- sian naval research vessel Si-
underwater explosions tore freedom of information re- tage, initial suspicions in many ing yacht could have played a biriakov, the tugboat SB-123
apart three of the four main quest from The Wall Street European capitals focused on key role in such an act of sab- and a third, unidentified ves-
Nord Stream pipes, which are Journal. Russia, which denied any in- otage—involving several ex- sel, according to the Danish
built to carry natural gas to The command declined to volvement. U.S. officials are in- plosions at an underwater Broadcasting Corporation.
ASSOCIATED PRESS
Germany from Russia. release the photographs be- vestigating the possibility that depth of 260 feet. The vessels sailed with
The blasts were powerful cause of what it said was their a pro-Ukrainian group was re- The photos of the Russian their position transmitters
enough to register with seis- intelligence value. It added, sponsible for the attack, the ship have provided fuel for al- turned off, but their move-
mologic measuring stations. following another freedom of Journal previously reported. ternative theories. ments were tracked using in-
Russia and Western govern- information request, that 26 Investigators in Germany The chance that the Russian tercepted radio communica-
ments agreed the blasts were of the photographs were of a have focused on the possible vessel captured in the photo tions sent to Russian naval Austin Tice disappeared in
sabotage. Russian vessel designated as role of a sailing yacht called was near the blast site without bases. Syria in mid-August 2012.
one American company.” have concerns about whether give third-party app develop- children and teens under 18—a
Some lawmakers and Presi- such a nexus exists” for the ers access to users’ private in- provision that aims at the
dent Biden have proposed re- limits on use of children’s’ formation after promising to company’s core business of
stricting targeted advertising data. cut off such access if users showing ads to users based on
to children. The FTC action He voted for Wednesday’s had not used those apps in the what it learns about their in-
could limit Meta’s ability to do action, which was approved on previous 90 days. In certain terests.
that but wouldn’t affect other a 3-0 vote, but added that he circumstances, Facebook con- The FTC also wants the
companies. looks forward to hearing addi- Meta vowed to contest the newest allegations from the FTC. tinued to allow third-party company to pause on the
As part of the FTC’s pro- tional arguments and “will app developers to access that launch of new products and
posed sanctions, Meta—which consider these issues with an tive director of Fairplay, a ers’ privacy. The FTC filed a user data until mid-2020, the services unless it receives
changed its name from Face- open mind.” nonprofit that advocates for complaint against Facebook in FTC said. written confirmation from the
book in October 2021—would Some Meta critics charac- children’s online privacy. 2011 and obtained an order in In addition, the FTC has independent assessor that its
be prohibited from profiting terized the FTC move as a The agency news release, 2012 barring the company asked the company to respond privacy program is in full com-
from data it collects from us- long-overdue response to a which specifically cited kids’ from misrepresenting its pri- to allegations that, from late pliance with privacy protec-
ers under 18. range of harms to kids caused data from virtual reality as vacy practices. 2017 until mid-2019, Facebook tions.
It would also be subject to by the company’s products. part of its proposed ban, came The FTC later alleged that misrepresented that parents The FTC would place new
other new limitations, includ- “The FTC has rightly recog- less than a month after Meta Facebook violated that order, could control with whom their limits on future uses of facial-
ing on its use of facial-recog- nized Meta simply cannot be opened its Horizon Worlds by engaging in misrepresenta- children communicated through recognition technology. For
nition technology, and would trusted with young people’s metaverse to teens. tions related to the use of mil- its Messenger Kids product. example, Meta would be re-
be required to provide addi- sensitive data and proposed a The proposal marks the lions of Facebook users’ data The FTC also said an inde- quired to obtain users’ affir-
tional protections for users. remedy in line with Meta’s third time the agency has by a political analytics firm, pendent third-party assessor, mative consent for any future
FTC Commissioner Alvaro long history of abuse of chil- taken action against the com- Cambridge Analytica. empowered to oversee the uses of facial-recognition tech-
Bedoya also questioned the dren,” said Josh Golin, execu- pany for failing to protect us- In 2019, Facebook agreed to company’s privacy protections nology.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, May 4, 2023 | A9
WORLD NEWS
SINGAPORE—China’s moves
vast country during the annual day,” said Ye Tianle, a Shanghai cial survey data released Sun- North Asia at Standard Char-
Labor Day holiday, an encour- resident who skipped town day showed Chinese factory ac- tered in Hong Kong.
aging sign that the country’s with her cousin for a three-day tivity unexpectedly shrank in Still, Mr. Ding and other
consumer-led economic re- trip to Fuzhou in the southeast. April, a victim of faltering economists caution that the
bound is powering ahead even For the wider economy, the global spending as consumers durability of a consumer-led
as factories start to struggle. hefty pickup in travel was a and businesses in the U.S., Eu- revival in China remains un-
For many Chinese, the ex- positive sign after the feeble rope and Asia confront high and certain, reflecting stubbornly
citement of the five-day break 3% expansion in gross domes- rising interest rates, persistent high unemployment, especially
around May 1, which com- tic product that China recorded inflation and pockets of weak- among young people, and con-
memorates the labor move- in 2022. The government has ness in the financial system. tinuing weakness in the prop-
ment in much of the world, set a growth target of around China’s Golden Week holi- erty sector, which is tightly
was another sign of life re- 5% for 2023. Many economists day “shows that pent-up de- linked to household wealth
A Chinese liaison team works with police in the Solomon Islands. turning to normal after the expect the economy to notch mand is strong and excess sav- and consumer confidence.
his wife, Soon-Yi Previn, at back: “Glenn laughs so tail,” Mr. Barak said. He said
Epstein’s mansion and invited hard!!!!” he remembers the trip in Flor-
Epstein to film screenings In 2019, when Epstein was ida was to visit a U.S. military
Ehud Barak, the former charged with sex trafficking, installation in Tampa.
Israeli prime minister, visited the Dubins told the Journal “I never participated in any
THIBAULT CAMUS/ASSOCIATED PRESS
Epstein dozens of times and through a spokesman that party or any other improper
accepted flights on Epstein’s they were “horrified,” and event around [Epstein], and
private jet while visiting Ep- that they had continued their never met him with girls or
stein’s mansions in Florida friendship after his 2008 minors, or even adult women
and New York. guilty plea because they be- in improper context or behav-
Leon Black, the billion- lieved he had rehabilitated ior,” Mr. Barak said.
aire co-founder of private-eq- himself.
uity giant Apollo Global Man- Dr. Andersson-Dubin, a phy-
agement, scheduled more than sician and former Miss Swe- Reid Hoffman
100 meetings with Epstein den, has said she dated Ep- Mr. Hoffman, the LinkedIn
from 2013 to 2017. stein in the 1980s. Epstein co-founder, has apologized for
Mr. Hoffman said he met connected Mr. Dubin to JP-
‘So many of these billionaires ‘Woody never had a business his interactions with Epstein,
with Epstein to raise funds for Morgan Chase, which bought knew him....Nobody ever said meeting with Epstein and not including inviting him in 2015
the Massachusetts Institute of control of his hedge fund, to a dinner in Palo Alto with
Technology, and that he re- Highbridge Capital Manage-
“Watch out for him.” ’ once spent time with him Silicon Valley leaders. After
grets interacting with Epstein ment, in 2004 for more than without Soon-Yi also being Epstein was arrested in 2019,
after his conviction. Mr. Al- $1 billion. Epstein earned a fee Barnaby Marsh Mr. Hoffman said he had met
len’s spokeswoman said the for the transaction, the Jour-
present.’ with him to help raise funds
filmmaker went with his wife nal has reported. for MIT at the request of the
to group social events at Ep- The documents also reveal Spokeswoman for Woody Allen then director of MIT’s Media
stein’s townhouse. Mr. Black Epstein offering help to one of and Soon-Yi Previn Lab, Joi Ito.
declined to comment. He the Dubins’ daughters, as he The documents reveal that
stepped down after an Apollo did for the children of other eral dinners, the documents The documents reveal new de- not once spent time with him Epstein had plans for Mr. Hoff-
investigation found he paid contacts. show. tails about some of their activ- without Soon-Yi also being man and Mr. Ito to visit his
Epstein for tax planning and In 2012, Epstein emailed Mr. Summers didn’t solicit ities and how often they met. present,” the spokeswoman private island in March 2014
estate advice. the Dubins’ daughter that he donations for Harvard from They were scheduled to get to- said. and in November 2014. On the
Mr. Barak said he often vis- would arrange modeling jobs Epstein after his conviction gether nearly every month in In October 2014, Epstein second date, Epstein planned
ited Epstein when he traveled for her with apparel brands. In and didn’t personally receive 2014 and 2015. planned for Mr. Allen to give to travel with both men from
to New York. He said he met 2014, he scheduled a meeting money from him, his spokes- In November 2012, an assis- lessons on film editing at his Palm Beach to the island for a
interesting people at Epstein’s between her and a professor woman said. “Their interac- tant to Mr. Allen sent one of townhouse to a group of weekend and then fly together
townhouse where they would at Harvard, where she was a tions primarily focused on Epstein’s assistants a note: guests watching Alfred Hitch- to Boston.
discuss politics and other top- student, the documents show. global economic issues,” she “Woody was wondering if Jef- cock’s “Psycho,” the docu- When the venture capitalist
ics. A spokeswoman for the Du- said. frey would be interested in ments show. had a flight scheduled to land
“In retrospect, [Epstein] bins said Epstein didn’t make But he did solicit donations watching his new film either late at night in New York on
seems to be a terrible version introductions for modeling for Ms. New, his wife. In 2014, today or tomorrow?” Epstein Dec. 4, 2014, Epstein arranged
of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, but jobs for their daughter. The Ms. New, a professor of Eng- said he was available. Terje Rød-Larsen for Mr. Hoffman to stay over-
at the time seemed to be an spokeswoman reaffirmed the lish, was hoping to expand to Epstein and Mr. Allen also On the guest list for the night in his townhouse, the
intelligent person, socially Dubins’ 2019 statement, which the general public her Harvard planned visits to the studio of 2014 film session with Mr. Al- documents show. The follow-
well connected and of wide ar- also said: “Had they been coursework about poetry. She artist Jeff Koons in 2013, and len, the documents show, was ing morning, Mr. Hoffman was
eas of interest, from science to aware of the vile and unspeak- established the nonprofit that to Sotheby’s auction house in Terje Rød-Larsen, a Norwegian scheduled to attend a “break-
geopolitics,” Mr. Barak said. able conduct described in received the Epstein donation 2017, the documents show. Mr. diplomat who helped negotiate fast party” with Epstein, Mr.
He said that he never partici- these new allegations, they and later created a public-tele- Koons didn’t respond to re- the Oslo Accords in the 1990s. Gates and others, according to
pated in any parties or activi- would have cut off all ties long vision series, the spokes- quests for comment. The documents reveal Ep- the documents.
ties with girls or women. ago and certainly never al- woman said. Epstein arranged for Mr. Al- stein also made plans for Mr. Mr. Hoffman told the Jour-
The documents show that lowed him to be in the pres- Mr. Marsh said Epstein len to join dozens of dinners Rød-Larsen to visit his private nal he only once visited Ep-
the disgraced financier kept a ence of their children.” asked him multiple times if at Epstein’s townhouse. Mr. island in 2012. The diplomat stein’s island residence, Little
busy schedule, filling his days the Templeton Foundation Allen went with his wife, Ms. came so frequently to Ep- St. James, for an MIT fund-
with meetings with politicians, could donate to Ms. New’s po- Previn. Epstein’s staff some- stein’s townhouse—dozens of raising trip with Mr. Ito. He
executives and celebrities, in- Lawrence Summers etry project. Templeton didn’t times ordered Mr. Allen flour- times from 2013 to 2017—that said he regrets ever meeting
cluding at his New York town- Epstein donated millions of donate to the project, he said. less chocolate cakes and bot- the staff knew to have cucum- with Epstein and his last inter-
house and his residence in the dollars to Harvard during Mr. Harvard declined to com- tles of Beck’s beer, the bers on hand for his gin, the action with Epstein was in
U.S. Virgin Islands. Summers’s tenure as the uni- ment beyond its 2020 report documents show. documents show. 2015.
Prosecutors alleged in 2019 versity’s president from 2001 on its ties with Epstein, which “Woody and Soon-Yi lived Mr. Rød-Larsen resigned in “It gnaws at me that, by
that Epstein had abused girls to 2006. Harvard has said it found he donated $9.1 million in the same neighborhood as 2020 as president of the Inter- lending my association, I
and had run a sex-trafficking decided to reject donations before 2008 and had visited Epstein and were frequently national Peace Institute after helped his reputation, and
ring. He died that year in jail from Epstein after his 2008 the campus dozens of times invited to dinner parties at his Norwegian newspaper DN re- thus delayed justice for his
awaiting trial in what the New guilty plea in Florida. after his conviction. townhouse,” said a spokes- ported he visited the town- survivors,” Mr. Hoffman said
York City medical examiner Mr. Summers, who remains woman for the couple. “There house frequently, had received in an email. He said he met
said was a suicide. a Harvard professor, had more were always other guests at a $130,000 personal loan from with Epstein to discuss sci-
Barnaby Marsh, then an ex- than a dozen meetings sched- Woody Allen those gatherings.” Epstein, and had accepted ence projects at universities.
ecutive at the large charitable uled with Epstein from 2013 Epstein was known to have “Woody never had a busi- about $650,000 in donations “While I relied on MIT’s en-
fund John Templeton Founda- through 2016, including sev- been friendly with Mr. Allen. ness meeting with Epstein and from Epstein foundations for dorsement, ultimately I made
tion, met with Epstein roughly the mistake,” he said, “and I
two dozen times, often for am sorry for my personal mis-
breakfast at the townhouse, judgment.”
the documents show. He was Mr. Ito said in an email:
previously known to have met “Reid attended a few fundrais-
with Epstein, but not to that ing events at my request, in-
extent. cluding one trip to Little St.
Mr. Marsh, who advises James, after I confirmed to
wealthy people on philan- Reid that Mr. Epstein had been
thropy, said he went to Ep- an approved donor target for
stein’s townhouse for gather- MIT in accordance with uni-
ings because it was full of versity rules and regulations.”
billionaires and academics After Epstein’s arrest in
who had many of the same in- 2019, Mr. Ito resigned from
terests in charitable giving. the MIT Media Lab and apolo-
Mr. Marsh said Epstein openly gized for accepting funding
MARCO BELLO/BLOOMBERG NEWS
T
from students and colleagues—not the technology. Potential uses in- Memorial Day.” them to know.
to mention a thrashing by late- clude helping supervisors write The resulting note struck an ap- “I hope that people have
he heartfelt email, that night host John Oliver—for relying performance reviews of their sub- propriately reverent tone, encour- enough grace to be, like, ‘OK, this
clever turn of phrase, on a text generator to compose ordinates and assisting human-re- aging employees to enjoy a long is the first time she has done
those pithy bullet points their response to a mass shooting source managers with drafting this,’ ” she says.
in the slide deck—did on another campus. They were re- job descriptions. IBM said this ChatGPT also can smooth
they come from the boss, instated after brief leaves. week it will pause hiring for rough writing by executives who
or a bot? For leaders observing the situa- back-office roles that could soon
Needing high-tech help are non-native English speakers,
Executives are using artificial- tion, it is unclear whether the real be automated. to find the right says Dror Weiss, CEO of Tabnine,
intelligence tools such as Google’s mistake was enlisting a computer ChatGPT has been adopted an Israeli company that makes
Bard and Microsoft-backed Chat- co-author or forgetting to delete faster than many corporate rule
thing to say can feel software to automate lines of
GPT to spiff up their communica- the disclosure—“paraphrase from makers can police, though JPMor- like a cop-out. computer code. Even at an artifi-
tions, though the prevalence is OpenAI’s ChatGPT AI language gan Chase and Verizon are among cial-intelligence business like his,
hard to measure for one big rea- model”—before clicking “send.” the companies that have restricted there is a risk of overpolishing to
son: Some won’t admit to having How many others have done some- usage. With few guidelines, a lot of the point of inauthenticity.
AI assistance, lest employees think thing similar and escaped scrutiny bosses are on their own to deter- weekend and reflect on “the brave Mr. Weiss, who has about 30
less of them by covering their digital tracks? mine when using artificial intelli- men and women who have made employees in Israel and the U.S.,
Leaders are often eloquent or “I don’t think people care if gence boosts efficiency and when the ultimate sacrifice.” Though a says he tries to keep his own voice
think they ought to be. Needing you’re using tools to augment it’s a crutch. bit cliché and repetitive—it went in everything he writes because he
high-tech help to find the right yourself,” says Steve Chase, who Mr. Chase says he treats Chat- on for seven paragraphs—the email doesn’t want messages to sound
thing to say can feel like a cop- heads KPMG’s U.S. consulting prac- GPT like an editor; it can take a could pass for one written by a computer-generated, even if
out. Never mind that immortal tice. “I think they’re bothered long email he’s drafted and make person in the C-suite. they’re computer-aided.
words uttered by the likes of Mo- when you lose the human touch.” it concise. The substance is still Natural-language software “If someone says, ‘Oh, ChatGPT
ses, Susan B. Anthony and Ronald Nearly two-thirds of senior ex- his, but the prose is better. works by drawing on what’s al- probably wrote that,’ it’s a criti-
Reagan were sometimes conceived ecutives expect generative AI to AI is capable of much more, ready in the public domain, which cism that you’re not an indepen-
by others. have a major impact on their or- however. As a test, I typed into might explain the one glaring flaw dent thinker,” he says.
W
orkers have high expecta- increases are delivered,” she said. tures at Nike and Star-
tions for raises this year. Meanwhile, a majority of U.S. bucks and has written a
Their bosses have differ- employees say they are confident book on employee pay
ent ideas. they’ll get a pay raise this year practices and negotiations.
The rising cost of living is and, on average, expect one of Pay disputes are bub-
prompting many employees to 6.7%, according to a recent survey bling up in some industries.
push for a hefty pay increase, and of 2,000 workers by the research On Tuesday, the unions rep-
recent wage gains across the arm of payroll provider ADP. Last resenting thousands of tele-
economy have ratcheted up hopes year, workers received an average vision and movie writers
they will get one. But recession 6.5% increase, ADP data show. went on strike after con-
worries and higher interest rates tract negotiations broke
have companies boosting effi- down over compensation
ciency while containing costs, in- and other issues. Pay and
cluding for labor, corporate bosses
and compensation consultants say.
Businesses are still handing out
substantial pay increases, though
6.7%
Pay increase that U.S. employees
promotions outrank remote-
work policies as workers’
greatest source of dissatis-
faction, according to a re-
less than what they projected last are expecting, on average cent survey by research
fall, according to a new survey of company Morning Consult
nearly 1,000 major employers by of more than 3,500 U.S.
benefits-advisory firm Mercer. workers. Among those con-
On average, employers are giv- Though business has slowed in sidering leaving their jobs,
ing annual merit raises of 3.8% her industry, Kayla Klopotek, 26, 46% said it was because
and total compensation increases asked for a raise at the Madison, they felt underpaid.
of 4.1% in 2023—still the highest- Wis., real-estate company where Lara Stepleman, an as-
reported raises in the survey since she works as a closing coordina- sociate dean at the Au-
the 2008 financial crisis. tor. Facing a 20% rent increase, gusta University’s Medical
The companies also said they she says she pushed for an in- College of Georgia in Au-
were being more cautious in dol- crease that would cover her gusta, Ga., negotiated a
ing out off-cycle raises and bo- higher costs and provide a finan- raise for herself when she
nuses this year, a departure from cial cushion. She made the case by was promoted two years
2022 and 2021, when employers citing her accomplishments, in- pear to be holding steady across base pay rose an average 3.4% be- ago. With state budget cuts loom-
were scrambling to address labor cluding three promotions within the broader economy, according tween October and March, down ing, she’s planning to lobby for
ILLUSTRATION BY JON KRAUSE
shortages and keep talent. Addi- three years, along with her rising to the most recent Labor Depart- from 4.7% in between January and promotions that come with pay in-
tional levels of approval are now expenses. ment figures. September of last year, according creases for her staff instead of an-
required for raises at some com- “I laid it all on the table,” she Among the larger employers to Mercer. other for herself.
panies, while others are limiting says. She ended up getting a 24% that Mercer surveys, base-pay Companies, particularly in tech “That would help them get to
unbudgeted raises to a smaller increase, which she says raises her raises have slowed, as the job and other industries going that money in a year when there
number of employees, said Lauren salary to one that better reflects market shows signs of cooling and through downturns, have been aren’t raises available,” she said.
Mason, senior principal in Mer- her experience and responsibilities. a range of companies embark on scaling back on merit and off-cy- “When the climate is better, I can
cer’s career practice. Wage and benefit growth ap- layoffs. Increases in employee cle raises in recent months, com- make a stronger case for a raise.”
A12 | Thursday, May 4, 2023 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
PERSONAL JOURNAL.
I
overs],” she says.
FORT WORTH, Texas The 73,500-square-foot fitness
was thrilled with the free center and the Tavern, open to ho-
breakfast and spacious room at American Airlines employee site offers extras craved by savvy travelers tel guests and other employees on
my $161-a-night Spring- campus, were empty during
Hill Suites near Dallas/ my afternoon visit. The
Fort Worth Interna- Tavern opens in the late af-
tional Airport last week. ternoon and serves bar food
Until I saw the new air- and alcohol. It’s the only
port hotel across the high- place where hotel guests
way. The 600-room Skyview have to pay their own tab.
6, which opened in late (A per diem covers meals at
January, has a tavern with the hotel cafeteria, market
an airy patio, supersize and coffee bar.)
gym, lap pool, free cruiser Mr. Isom hasn’t spent a
bikes, sushi to go and bath- night in the hotel. Nor has
room mirrors with Blue- his predecessor, Doug
tooth connections. Parker. Mr. Parker, who re-
No expense account or tired last week as Ameri-
loyalty status would get me, can’s chairman, championed
or most of you, a room the hospitality complex sev-
there. The only guests eral years ago as one of
checking into Skyview 6 many ways to improve
work for American Airlines. American’s culture. He
It’s the kind of hotel that fought to maintain the proj-
would make most road war- ect during the pandemic. (It
riors jealous—and one that was paused for six months.)
has American employees al-
ready pushing for similar- Gold standard
quality hotels on the road. American Airlines captain
The airline built the ho- Dennis Tajer is a frequent
tel to house most of the critic of the airline in his
tens of thousands of flight role as spokesman for the
attendants, pilots and other Allied Pilots Association, a
front-line workers who fly union. He stayed there for
in for training each year at five nights in March for an-
its 300-acre corporate cam- nual training and raves
pus near DFW. about the place.
Employees previously A lounge near the main lobby at the Skyview 6 hotel, which was designed expressly for training at American Airlines. He says it couldn’t have
were scattered among sev- been more different than
eral area hotels and Ameri- the “dark, dank hotel” off
can’s rundown lodge for flight at- ing current and retired flight at- they need a study break. Restroom perks the highway he stayed at for train-
tendants, which was razed in 2019. tendants and pilots, on hotel must- Brady Byrnes, American’s se- The bathrooms in the rooms in- ing a year ago.
Among other major U.S. airlines, haves and must-nots. nior vice president of in-flight ser- clude a light under the counter that He used the free bikes to ride
only JetBlue Airways has its own Employees’ touches and avia- vices, says those areas are a re- turns on when employees walk in, a around the campus, dried some
training hotel for employees, a tion nostalgia are everywhere. Art- sponse to employee requests to nod to employees who travel so clothes in the laundry room on his
196-room lodge that opened in Or- work from the airline’s Stewardess make socializing easier without much they wake up wondering floor, worked out in the gym and
lando, Fla., in 2015. College, an industry first in 1957, needing to go into anyone’s room. where they are, says Holly Ragan, enjoyed the tavern and cafeteria.
“It brings energy and just a hangs in the lobby. “This gives them a great oppor- American’s senior manager of cor- He liked the resort vibe so much
sense of connection,” says Robert In the guest rooms, there is a tunity to have the fellowship and porate real estate. he made a return visit to the cafe-
JAKE DOCKINS FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
Isom, American’s chief executive. large cork strip above the desk in say, ‘Bye, I’m done,’ ” he says. “My goodness, we spent so teria room on a separate visit to
each room to display training ma- Employees were adamant about much time on this bathroom,” Ms. Dallas for work. “It just does not
Input from insiders terials, such as a cockpit interior, something they didn’t want in the Ragan says. look and feel like a corporate
American owns but doesn’t oper- and recliners (a pilot request). lounge or anywhere in the com- There’s also a digital clock em- training center,” he says.
ate Skyview 6, a $250 million proj- There are magnetic blackout cur- mon areas: microwave popcorn. bedded in the bathroom mirror and Ever the negotiator, Mr. Tajer
ect. MCR, which owns New York’s tains in the room designed to let Too many travelers in hotels with Bluetooth connectivity, so employ- says American, which the union is
TWA Hotel and nearly 150 others, no light seep through. The safes in microwaves lose track of time and ees can listen to music or podcasts in contract negotiations with,
manages American’s hotel. the room are big enough to store burn it. when getting ready. should now turn its attention to
Nothing at Skyview 6, Mr. Isom laptops and tablets. “I don’t want to smell some- Ellie Boothe, a 27-year-old Phila- picking similar caliber hotels for
says, is “second-rate. Nothing.” There’s a lounge on each floor body else’s food coming down the delphia-based flight attendant who flight crews on layovers.
American solicited input from for employees to hang out—the hallway,” was a common refrain, joined American last year, stayed at “This was the gold standard for
its resident frequent fliers, includ- rooms are single-occupancy—when Mr. Byrnes says. Skyview 6 one night in March for what it could be,” he says.
T
are pretty dismayed at the ers can’t post videos.
witter users are buzz- approach Twitter has been
ing that Bluesky Social taking over the last six How can I join?
might be a text-first months or so, and have been To join Bluesky, you need to
social-media platform good looking for an alternative get on the wait list or know
enough to rival the network that is similar.” someone who can give you
Elon Musk now owns. And On Thursday, Bluesky an- an invite. This kind of crowd
that is no coincidence, since nounced on its platform that control is typical for apps
it was initially backed by it had its biggest single-day that are in test mode. (Re-
Twitter and its co-founder, jump in new users. (The member Clubhouse?)
Jack Dorsey. company didn’t respond to Bluesky plans to remain in-
Bluesky—pronounced several requests for com- vite-only while it works on
“blue sky,” not “blue ski”— ment.) The app has already setting up its moderation
was formed in 2021 inside been downloaded in Apple’s system, CEO Jay Graber
Twitter and launched as an App Store more than wrote in a blog post in
independent organization in 375,000 times worldwide, March.
2022. It operates using an according to consumer-data Users receive one invite
code every two weeks, so
you might have to cozy up to
a few people to get yours.
Who is on Bluesky?
Some prominent figures on
every
the app include author and
TV personality Chrissy Tei-
gen and Rep. Alexandria Oc-
asio-Cortez. Many journalists
have also joined.
What is different
one
from Twitter?
Despite the Twitter-like ap-
pearance, Bluesky is a de-
centralized platform, similar
to Mastodon. It is based on
an open standard that any
open protocol, similar to group data.ai. As of late coder can adopt—again,
email or HTML, so people April, it is the No. 8-ranked compare this to email or a
can create their own servers. social app in the U.S. on iOS webpage, which any tech-
For now, Bluesky is running and No. 22-ranked social app minded person can set up
the main one. in the U.S. Google Play store. using the available protocols.
place to live.
Twitter since taking over in Prominent figures are those operated privately by
October, others aren’t happy flocking to the invite-only a single company, the way
about them. Several celebri- app, and you can try to get Meta Platforms runs Face-
ties and media companies in, too. Here’s what you book and Instagram.
have abandoned it. Many need to know. So while the invite-only
Twitter users were left con- service is hosted by Bluesky
fused after the app removed What is Bluesky? itself, other servers are ex-
legacy check marks in April. While there is a lot of un- pected to roll out. People on
Those seeking alterna- derlying technology that any server could theoreti-
tives aren’t finding anything makes Bluesky different cally see each other’s public
very useful. Some have from Twitter, on its surface posts, though users could
opted to explore new ser- it is very similar. Posts are also create servers using the
vices such as Mastodon or short, 300 characters max. standard and apply their
Learn more at familiar ones such as
LinkedIn. Now they are look-
You can like, reply and re-
post them. There is a
own membership rules.
“In the past, those net-
habitat.org. ing at Bluesky. “What’s hot” feed for popu- works have been harder for
“It’s the closest thing to lar posts and a “Following” the average everyday person
SHUTTERSTOCK
Twitter that is out there,” feed for accounts you follow. to use,” said Mr. Fullerton. On
said Tim Fullerton, president That is pretty much it, for Bluesky, though, it is easier
and CEO of digital marketing now. The app is still in de- for even less tech-savvy peo-
agency Fullerton Strategies. velopment, so there is no di- ple to get on and use, he said.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, May 4, 2023 | A13
ARTS IN REVIEW
ART REVIEW
An Artistic
CLOCKWISE FROM LEFT: ESTATE OF JOAN MITCHELL; BRIDGEMAN ART LIBRARY; JOAN MITCHELL FOUNDATION/ROBERT FRESON
Kinship
Revealed
BY JUDITH H. DOBRZYNSKI Monet
N
(1840-1926) was
St. Louis long dead when
ear the end of “Monet/ Mitchell
Mitchell: Painting the (1925-1992) picked
French Landscape,” up her brushes.
three works by Monet, She began her art
“Water Lilies” (1917-19) education in the
and two titled “The mid-1940s at the
Japanese Bridge” (1918-24), display Art Institute of
an unusual side of the great French Chicago, studying
Impressionist. Together, they show many French mod-
him using highly gestural, squiggly, ernists, including
intertwined brush strokes; intense, Monet, Cezanne
unnatural colors; mere hints of fea- and Van Gogh.
tures like the bridge; exposed ar- Then she left for
eas of canvas, and allover composi- New York, falling
tions that give the paintings a in with the Pollock-
decidedly abstract quality. “Water De Kooning crowd
Lilies” has sometimes been hung of Abstract Expres-
upside down. sionists and forg-
ing a unique style
using a flurry of bold, colorful, dy- ments in expansive views on large- failing, Monet relied on his recol- loved the sunflowers in her garden,
namic brush strokes, from thin scale canvases, often joined in lections to create paintings in the which she celebrated in an immense
drips to thick impasto, in inter- diptychs, triptychs and quadrip- studio; Mitchell said that she diptych titled “Two Sunflowers”
secting layers, with nature as her tychs. Monet frequently painted painted “remembered landscapes (1980). A veritable blizzard of en-
subject. images in series, varying the time that I carry with me,” not specific crusted, intense yellow paint,
In 1959, Mitchell moved to Paris of day, for example; Mitchell cre- places. The water in “Row Row” fringed with black to suggest the
and, in 1968, to Vétheuil, a small ated “suites.” (1982)—a deep-blue diptych with soil, green for leaves, and violet for
town near Monet’s famed home in Their palettes, especially the patches of yellows and violets— sunlight, it bursts with exuberance.
Giverny, northwest of Paris. That is blues, violets and yellows, were could be the Lake Michigan of her Likewise, in the next gallery Monet’s
where “Monet/Mitchell” begins, ze- similar, though his colors were early years or the Seine. great “Water Lilies” (about 1915-26),
roing in on Mitchell’s final 25 years. mostly softer. Late in his career, And they explained their ap- the central panel of a renowned
(Although it had a similar title, the Monet intentionally left parts of proach in a similar way. In 1908, triptych split among three muse-
recent exhibition at the Fondation his canvases primed but unpainted; Monet said he wanted “to express ums, speaks to the joy he took from
Louis Vuitton in Paris was a what I feel.” Mitchell said that na- his pond, which he painted more
broader, much larger show that in- ture appeared in all her paintings than 300 times.
cluded Mitchell’s pastels and draw- “but not directly . . . it’s rather the As good as it is, the exhibition
American artist Joan Mitchell, ings as well as more paintings.)
The show explores the feeling that I have for things.” isn’t flawless. Of its 24 paintings,
above; her painting ‘Beauvais’ Critics had noted the connec- commonalities between Curator Simon Kelly doesn’t at- the Musée Marmottan Monet and
(1986), above right; and Monet’s tions between Mitchell’s work and tempt to match paintings. Rather, the Fondation Louis Vuitton each
‘Wisteria’ (1919-20), below Monet’s by the late 1960s, an affin-
Monet and the abstract he charts the artists’ responses to lent 10. If Mr. Kelly had been able
ity she once acknowledged but painter Joan Mitchell. similar surroundings—trees, for to draw from a larger pool, he may
That Monet came so close to later denied, sometimes adamantly. example. Monet’s lyrical “Water have found even better examples
complete abstraction is just one And there were differences: Monet Lilies With Weeping Willow of the exhibition theme. Still, “Mo-
surprise in this beautiful, uplifting made his reputation with his figu- Branches” (1919) shows the tree’s net/Mitchell” undeniably and de-
exhibition at the Saint Louis Art rative landscapes and usually for example, the exposed white green leaves almost touching his lightfully displays two kindred
Museum. Visitors who think they painted en plein air; Mitchell pro- patches in his enchanting “Wiste- cerulean pond. Mitchell’s crisper spirits, each transfixed by nature
know Monet but expect to gain duced abstract works in her studio. ria” (1919-20) panels suggest sunny “Tilleul” (1978) portrays a linden and sharing that passion with us.
new understanding of the far less Monet never dripped or spattered highlights. Mitchell regularly em- tree, its bare, black, wintry
known Joan Mitchell, a leading paint; Mitchell did. ployed negative space to define her branches thrusting upward. Paral-
second-generation Abstract Ex- But, especially in Monet’s late images, as in “Beauvais” (1986), leling Monet’s attachment to his Monet/Mitchell: Painting the
pressionist, will discover that works (the earliest here dates to whose central white paint and willow, Mitchell depicted her cher- French Landscape
“Monet/Mitchell” illuminates the 1914), they overlapped more, and white canvas suggest the nave of a ished linden many times, including Saint Louis Art Museum, through
practice of both painters—and the commonalities are easy to see cathedral she had just visited. the more abstract “Red Tree” June 25
proves that artistic pairings can in these galleries. Each depicted Under the surface, Monet and (1976). This suite, Mr. Kelly writes
be a powerful motif even when flowers, trees, water, gardens, re- Mitchell had deeper connections. in the catalog, gave her solace. Ms. Dobrzynski writes about art for
the duo is not contemporaneous. flections and other landscape ele- In his late years, with his eyesight Mitchell could be lyrical, too. She the Journal and other publications.
MUSIC REVIEW and feels spontaneous. And Mr. Ben Wendel; his Wendel on bassoon, creating a fas-
Wendel’s arrangements meet many album ‘All One’ cinating contrast. Then, with the
W
cents the various anxieties that del build their ing all of the instruments except for
ith the band Kneebody, the Bess must have felt, as well as the parts deliberately, those of his guests, and that each
music of saxophonist, bas- dreaminess of love’s possibilities. as if they were of his colleagues on the recording is
soonist and composer Ben Mr. Wendel’s arrangement moves in accompanying a part of a unified community of
Wendel is exuberant and often tandem with Ms. Salvant’s inflec- flowering. seekers and learners, which is what
brash. His work on his own has tions; the backing horns transition Mr. Wendel is connects them in his mind. The re-
tended to be more nuanced and from sweet sounds—as if the num- also joined by the cording is his seventh as a leader,
subtle. On his latest recording, “All ber were a Neal Hefti orchestration vocalist José amid others as a sideman, and he
One” (Editions Records, out now), of a post-World War II love story— James, pianist Ti- has engaged in myriad curatorial
he has it both ways. The album fea- to rambunctious, slightly dissonant gran Hamasyan and educational projects. But he
tures duets, a calling card of his, tones that capture the bracing real- and flutist Elena may be best known for “The Sea-
but instead of two instruments on ity of urban life. Pinderhughes. Mr. sons,” a series of duet videos that
each track there are many. By over- “Wanderers” features Mr. James performs were posted monthly online in 2015.
dubbing himself, Mr. Wendel creates Blanchard, who has won accolades the Walter Gross There he worked with videographer
a woodwind choir, and he worked recently for his operas “Fire Shut and Jack Law- Alex Chaloff to depict the evolution
with several high-profile collabora- Up in My Bones” and “Champion”; rence standard of conversational language in jazz.
tors, including trumpeter Terence he also writes for film and has “Tenderly,” and he “All One” might be difficult to turn
Blanchard, guitarist Bill Frisell and worked with Spike Lee on numer- stays faithful to into a live tour given the busy
vocalist Cécile McLorin Salvant. The ous occasions. Mr. Wendel’s compo- the classic rendi- schedules of his associates. But it
ANOUK VAN KALMTHOUT
results are compelling and often re- sition is richly cinematic, evocative aside from brief solos, the drama of tions of the tune, evoking mid-20th- would lend itself well to video pre-
markable. of big skies and rugged terrain. And the piece lies in their exchange. century splendor over the reed sec- sentation, helping to expand jazz’s
Projects involving pre-recorded it makes occasional reference to the Much of Mr. Frisell’s music also tion’s murmurs. On “Speak Joy” footprint in that medium.
music can sound stilted and mechan- trumpeter’s 1991 tune “Wandering recalls the great outdoors, and Mr. with Ms. Pinderhughes, the tune
ical, what we might imagine today as Wonder,” hence the title. At the out- Wendel leans into that on unfolds slowly before she launches Mr. Johnson writes about jazz for
AI jazz, but the music here is lithe set, the two horns intertwine and, “Throughout.” But the sound on a probing solo underpinned by Mr. the Journal.
A14 | Thursday, May 4, 2023 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
SPORTS
International Stars Take Hold knee injury and missed the Phila-
delphia 76ers’ series-opening win
over the Boston Celtics. The MVP
trophy, though, marks the pinnacle
D
thing, as a life—my story, where I
uring the NBA’s All-Star fes- come from, how I got here.”
tivities in February, while In an April showcase against the
players shot rapid-fire 3- Celtics, Embiid made his last, best
pointers and attempted increas- case to award voters (who consider
ingly elaborate dunks, Boris Diaw only regular-season play) by scor-
stepped into a hallway in Salt Lake ing 52 points with astonishing effi-
City’s Vivint Arena and considered ciency, making 20 of 25 shots.
the shape of his own career. Left, Sixers star Joel Embiid drives Asked why international stars
Diaw had played for five fran- to the basket against Giannis have taken hold of the NBA’s MVP
chises across 14 seasons in the Antetokounmpo. Above, Nikola award seemingly overnight—prior
2000s and 2010s, and if he was Jokic playing for Serbia. to Antetokounmpo’s first win in
never his team’s best player—never 2019, Americans had won every
an All-Star himself—he was reliably ness of contact, and his willingness trophy for 11 years—Kim Bohuny,
among its most interesting. He was to absorb and deal out blows, one an international basketball opera-
a sturdy forward who operated like can glimpse the teenager who came tions adviser to the NBA, pointed
an oversized guard: threading up eating elbows in the Greek to a general shrinking of the bas-
cross-court passes instead of shoul- leagues. “For a kid like me who ketball world.
dering into his defender, linking came from nothing, I think the NBA The Lithuanian and Croatian
plays instead of finishing them. spoiled me a little bit,” Antetokoun- stars of the 1980s rarely saw NBA
That career might never have mpo said. “When you go overseas, games on their televisions, prior to
happened, Diaw said, had he been things aren’t the same.” a push by the late commissioner
born in America instead of his na- Branislav Vicentic, who coached David Stern to multiply the league’s
tive France—or had he jumped to a Jokic when he was a junior player overseas distribution. When Sar-
stateside school instead of training in Serbia, sees a similar dynamic in unas Marciulionis and Drazen
in his own domestic pro league as a his former pupil: a one-of-one skill Petrovic joined the league at the
teenager. “If I’m among college set nurtured by a worldview. The turn of the ’90s, they were playing
players, I don’t know if I would Denver Nuggets center is now re- against some athletes they had
have made it to the NBA,” Diaw garded as the cleverest passing big watched only a handful of times.
said. The European system favors man of all time, a designation Vi- By the 2000s, NBA stars were
at the sounds C H E M I C A L D Y E S the Gulf. Messi’s camp insists and $2 billion trying to cap- the Saudi professional league,
28 “Heavens!” E L C H A P O S O L V E
beginning of 6 Stage array he traveled with the club’s ture, despite being flanked by which made him the highest-
29 Ventura R O L E H E L E N H A Y E S
a paragraph, A L A R M E D G E permission. Regardless, the the Brazilian playmaker Ney- paid athlete anywhere in the
runner 7 Pastel hue suspension means he will be mar and French superstar world with a contract worth
and what you S A Y Y O U R G O O D B Y E S
32 Ooze through must do to 8 Like S N U G S L I P S available for only three more Kylian Mbappé. More alarm- around $200 million a year in
the cracks Lexington O L B L U E E Y E S O P E N games this season as PSG ing, he has often looked unin- January.
make sense of R E O I L G L A S S E S
33 Anchor’s each starred Avenue G E T T I N G T O Y E S
clings to first place in the terested—even PSG’s fans Now, as Messi appears to
offering answer 9 •Gin cocktail A R C R E D O L I O N E L French league. have booed him on more head for the exit at PSG, he
N A H A S A P Y OMAMA As relations sour between than one occasion during his may be looking at a similar
▶ Solve this puzzle online and discuss it at WSJ.com/Puzzles. S T Y Q T Y S U S T O O the seven-time Ballon d’Or two seasons. landscape.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, May 4, 2023 | A15
OPINION
Democrats Become the ‘No’ Party BOOKSHELF | By Charlotte Gray
No single no-
tion
served
has
the
The Democrats’ obstruc-
tionism is tied to their view of
how the American system
Surviving
Democratic
Party better
than its asser-
tion that the
should work, which is to say
with no-deviation standards
for behavior, belief and policy
set nationally by Congress, the
On Faith
WONDER
F
to the 1950s. litical street fighting.
The details or truth of these South Carolina Sen. Tim or many of us, the story of Holland during World War II
charges hardly matter any- Scott, who may get into the is embodied in Anne Frank, the Jewish girl who docu-
more. It’s sufficient at all Republican presidential pri- mented in her diary the two years she and her family
times to typecast Republicans mary race soon, took up some spent hiding in a secret annex in Amsterdam to avoid Nazi
as the far right, the extreme Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and other Senate Democrats. of the country’s intense cul- persecution. When Anne was 15, the family was discovered
right, paranoid and currently tural divisions over race and and Anne was sent to her death at the Bergen-Belsen con-
“MAGA” Republicans. Joe Bi- outlays—the spending-reduc- the parties may be changing gender with a speech in Iowa centration camp. But her diary, with its poignant reflections
den must mumble “MAGA Re- tion provisions in the McCar- places. recently. What struck me of an adolescent facing personal and existential challenges,
publicans” in his sleep. thy bill are modest. Discretion- Former South Carolina Gov. about Mr. Scott’s speech was survived and was published to instant acclaim.
It looks as if this script is ary spending, which excludes Haley’s speech was about that he managed to promote The deserved success of Anne’s diary often overshadows
starting to get flipped. Demo- the entitlements tsunami— abortion. After the Supreme reconciliation and optimism other accounts of Dutch bravery during the Nazi occupation.
crats all of a sudden are would fall to fiscal 2022 levels, Court’s decision to overturn without diluting his core One woman who saved lives and gave hope to hundreds of
turning into the party of dug- with annual spending growth Roe v. Wade, abortion played principles. Dutch anti-Nazis, then demonstrated extraordinary com-
in extremes, while Republi- limited to 1% for 10 years, a to- a large role in the midterms, “I see a future where com- passion toward Nazi collabo-
cans are talking compromise tal deficit reduction of $4.8 defeating some Republicans mon sense has rebuilt com- rators after the war, was
and increasingly even recon- trillion. and limiting the party’s gains. mon ground,” Mr. Scott said, Corrie ten Boom, a modest
ciliation with their political On cue, Democrats just said The GOP’s chances in a na- “where we’ve created real single woman in her late 40s
opponents. no. Calling the bill “truly ex- tional election depend on unity, not by compromising when the Ninth Panzer Division
treme,” Senate Majority coming up with a position away our conservatism, but marched into Holland in May
Leader Chuck Schumer told other than a total ban. by winning converts to our 1940. Now Larry Loftis, a
Biden must mumble Mr. McCarthy “to stop wasting Two things are notable conservatism.” former corporate attorney who
any more time on this DOA, about Ms. Haley’s speech. Where are the Democrats’ has written three World War II
‘MAGA Republicans’ dead on arrival, bill.” Mr. Bi- First, it was probably the most Tim Scotts and Nikki Haleys? nonfiction spy thrillers, shines
in his sleep, since he den said the McCarthy bill good-faith effort any public of- At any opportunity, their a spotlight on ten Boom with
was “not negotiable.” House ficial has made in a long time most prominent leaders—Mr. “The Watchmaker’s Daughter.”
won’t talk to them. Democratic Leader Hakeem to come to grips with the divi- Biden, Vice President Kamala The first half of Mr. Loftis’s
Jeffries has “extreme MAGA sions over abortion. Second, Harris, Mr. Schumer—dump book is a chronology of ten
Republicans” on autopilot. the odds that a Democrat ridicule and mockery on the Boom family history and the
House Speaker Kevin During the Obama years, would deliver an abortion opposition. It’s looking a lot early years of the German
McCarthy’s successful effort the Republicans were called speech remotely similar in like a substitute for substance occupation of Holland. The ten
to pass a debt-ceiling bill has “the party of no.” Suddenly, sympathy to pro-life beliefs or argument. Boom family had lived in the same three-story Haarlem house
to be the most unexpected and with the debt ceiling looming are zero. Actually, less than Democrats themselves since 1837 and were devout adherents of the Dutch Reformed
shocking event of the season. and House Republicans put- zero. Democrats are dug in on would say the most prominent Church. Corrie’s father, Casper, had instilled in his children a
No one expected the motley ting an actual plan on the ta- abortion on demand without Republicans today—Donald profound horror of anti-Semitism. As the Nazi grip tightened
crew that opposed Mr. McCar- ble, Democrats have become limits. Most won’t say that out Trump and Ron DeSantis—are and the SS herded Dutch Jews into trucks bound for concen-
thy’s speakership to display the party of no. Someone loud, but that’s because they themselves reflexively belliger- tration camps, the ten Booms welcomed frightened Jews into
unity on anything serious, must have noticed this re- won’t talk about details. Like ent and uncompromising. Fair their home.
such as raising the debt ceil- flexive obstruction wasn’t a the debt ceiling, it’s simply enough. My point is one of There is little sense of Corrie herself during these early
ing. But they did. good look, because on Mon- “nonnegotiable.” simple political observation. chapters, as the archive on which Mr. Loftis relies appears to
Attaching spending reforms day Mr. Biden said he would That isn’t the position of The Democrats’ unto-eternity have few insights into her thoughts at this stage. Instead, the
to a debt-ceiling extension meet with all four congres- most Americans, who want strategy of positioning Repub- author weaves together material from many other primary
normally would be a yawner, sional leaders, though not abortion available but with licans as a party of extremes and secondary sources. Corrie’s actions are almost swamped
the sausage factory at work. until next week. He must be some restrictions later in and obstruction sounds shop- by the stories of other characters, as the ten Boom home
These aren’t normal times. busy. pregnancy. Ms. Haley con- worn. Democrats seem to think absorbs Jewish fugitives as well as “divers”—Dutch men
With inflation persistent and Normally one doesn’t look ceded these conflicts. Virtu- “yes” means just shipping cash avoiding being sent to work in German armaments factories.
the economic future uncer- for campaign speeches some ally no office-holding Demo- into a grateful country. It looks Gradually, Corrie and her family are drawn into the Dutch
tain, voters aren’t yawning 18 months before a presiden- crat ever will. Ms. Haley like the post-pandemic elector- resistance. Meanwhile, the secret residents of the ten Boom
about the Washington sausage tial election to reveal anything hardly speaks for all Republi- ate wants this country im- home, where a hiding place has been constructed behind a
factory. useful, but remarks recently cans, but her sincere conces- proved with something more false wall, discover “a warmth and happiness,” we are told,
By any measure—except the by Republicans Nikki Haley sion to reality was a notewor- than money. “that few Dutch homes enjoyed.” There is an atmosphere of
incumbent president’s no-limits and Tim Scott also suggest thy reversal of partisan roles. Write henninger@wsj.com. harmony, sustained by the ten Booms’ robust Christian faith.
There are birthday parties and prayer sessions, Bible readings
and constant admonitions to “trust the Almighty.” Despite the
Will Trump Prove to Be Another Romney? constant threat of Gestapo house-searches, the ten Booms
risk countless acts of altruism—sheltering refugees, moving
fugitives to new hiding places, organizing the theft of ration
By Karl Rove this year. But much of this reuse the 2012 Democratic gles—even as mistreating his cards, acting as couriers.
P
diffidence likely comes from playbook. Like Mr. Biden, dog. It worked. But the SS are closing in and, in February 1944, Gestapo
resident Biden’s team the widespread sense that Mr. President Obama was vulnera- Team Biden seems to un- agents arrest several members of the ten Boom family,
hopes the 2024 race Biden is a spent force. Even ble headed into his re-election derstand that it needs to fo- including Casper, Corrie and her sister Betsie. It is at this
will mirror the last one. the New York Times editorial- campaign. His stimulus bill cus the 2024 race similarly on point that Mr. Loftis is able to focus more on Corrie—thanks
It won’t, if Republicans are ized two weeks ago that Dem- and Affordable Care Act had savaging the GOP contender. in no small part to several accounts of her ordeal written by
smart. ocrats are right to worry “he provoked the populist tea- They also obviously know ten Boom herself—and the book begins to pick up momentum.
This time, there’s no pan- will simply be too old to be party revolt. His campaign that strategy depends in large After arriving at The Hague’s Scheveningen Prison,
demic to excuse Mr. Biden’s effective in a second term.” needed to change the contest part on how vulnerable a tar- Casper’s poor health quickly deteriorates, and in early
campaigning from his base- There’s a real fear that the get Republicans nominate— March he dies. Corrie is diagnosed with pleurisy days later.
ment. His mental decline will Democratic base might stay hence their fixation on Mr. She sustains herself by reading the Gospels, which a
be obvious, as will his turn to home if Mr. Biden runs. Biden seeks to follow Trump. friendly nurse smuggles in for her. Corrie’s resilient nature
the left. He won’t be able to The president’s brain trust Mr. Biden’s April 24 an- is illustrated in a letter she sends to another sister, who
portray himself convincingly believes this can all be reme- Obama’s example nouncement video cleverly remains at liberty. “We do have much to be thankful for—
as a moderate unifier, as he died if it can replicate the from 2012, when he opened with clips of Mr. an airy cell. . . . Sometimes it may be dark, but the Savior
did in 2020. No wonder Mr. structure of the 2020 contest: Trump’s supporters beating provides His light and how wonderful that is.” Corrie and
Biden is losing indepen- Make the election a choice disqualified his rival. police during the riots on Jan. Betsie’s deeply held Christian convictions impress a Nazi
dents—only 14% said in the between Mr. Biden and Don- 6. Mr. Biden then denounced officer, whose compassion eventually helps spare Corrie’s life.
April 17 Associated Press/Na- ald Trump. “MAGA extremists” as an im-
tional Opinion Research Cen- Mr. Trump’s standing has from a referendum on Mr. age of Mr. Trump—pictured
ter poll that they’d like him to deteriorated since that elec- Obama’s performance to a with Florida Gov. Ron DeSan- Even after her release from a concentration camp,
run for re-election. tion over his role in the Jan. choice between an imperfect tis—flashed on screen. Expect Corrie ten Boom continued to offer support and
And placating his party’s 6, 2021, assault on the Capitol incumbent and an unaccept- to see similar barrages as the
leftists hasn’t produced the and his unending, falsehood- able challenger. campaign wears on if Mr. Bi- show compassion, to Jews and collaborators alike.
sky-high approval he likely filled grievances about what The Obama high command den gets the opponent he so
hoped for among more left- he claims was the “stolen” quickly swung into action, desperately desires.
leaning groups critical to his 2020 election. In the April 19 blasting Mitt Romney well be- Today, the GOP seems un- From Scheveningen, Corrie and Betsie are transferred to
re-election, such as young peo- NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist fore he had won the long, fortunately inclined to nomi- Vught concentration camp, where Corrie works as slave
ple, blacks and self-described Poll, even 23% of Republicans contentious and costly nomi- nate the only man Mr. Biden labor in the Philips factory while Betsie is assigned to the
progressives. Only 14% of Dem- thought Mr. Trump should nation battle on April 24. thinks he can beat. But that sewing room. The sisters continue their Christian ministry,
ocrats under 50 in the March drop out of the 2024 race af- Team Obama recognized that could well change. Ask Rudy with Corrie noting that “we are continually protected by
20 Monmouth University poll ter the Manhattan district at- extolling Mr. Obama’s first- Giuliani, Newt Gingrich and the most extraordinary Providence so that we can hold out
preferred Mr. Biden to run torney indicted him over al- term record and outlining his Jeb Bush, early leaders in in spite of the hard life.” Next, they are packed into boxcars
again, as did 27% of black, His- legedly hiding hush-money vision for the future were in- the 2008, 2012 and 2016 and endure a nightmare journey of three days, during
panic and Asian-American payments to a porn star by sufficient. nomination campaigns, re- which they are given no water, to arrive in Ravensbrück—
Democrats and 22% of very failing to mark it as a cam- So on April 11, it opened up spectively. There’s time for the concentration camp for female prisoners that was
liberal Democrats. paign expense, though the in- on Mr. Romney with an ad- Republicans to get this right. notorious for cruelty and executions. Within weeks,
This notable lack of enthu- dictment was widely panned vertising blast depicting the They’d better. Betsie dies. Corrie continues to spread the Gospel and
siasm is due partially to the by legal experts on the right former Massachusetts gover- provide hope to fellow-sufferers.
base’s unreasonable expecta- and left. Despite all that, Mr. nor as a heartless plutocrat. Mr. Rove helped organize In late 1944, Corrie—now emaciated beyond recognition—
tion of what Mr. Biden could Biden is so weak that he trails Democrats kept this up for the political-action committee is released thanks to a clerical error. Soon she is back in
have done with a 50-50 Sen- Mr. Trump by about half a nearly seven months, pound- American Crossroads and is Holland, where countless thousands are starving to death.
ate and Democratic House his point in the RealClearPolitics ing Mr. Romney as filthy rich, author of “The Triumph of Undaunted, she continues to preach a message of faith and
first two years and with a Re- average, 43.5% to 43.9%. out-of-touch and indifferent William McKinley” (Simon & forgiveness in churches, clubs and private homes. Before
publican-controlled House So expect Team Biden to to people’s everyday strug- Schuster, 2015). war’s end, she sets up rehabilitation centers to support
survivors as well as those who had collaborated with Nazi
occupiers. She spends the final four decades of her life
Gordon Lightfoot, a Great Canadian traveling the world as a missionary, displaying no bitterness
as she explains how her faith sustained her.
Corrie ten Boom’s memoir, “A Prisoner and Yet,” was
By Michael Taube passionate about music as a Mary. “I can’t think of any Gor- country in songs like “Chris- published in America in 1970. It became the basis for both
boy in Orillia, Ontario, and his don Lightfoot song I don’t like. tian Island (Georgian Bay)” the 1971 biography “The Hiding Place” and the 1975 film of
M
Toronto mother encouraged his talent. Every time I hear a song of his, and “Alberta Bound.” “Cana- the same name. Israel awarded her the title of Righteous
y father, a partially re- He sang for local churches, ra- it’s like I wish it would last for- dian Railroad Trilogy,” a 6½- Among the Nations, an honorific for non-Jews who risked
tired lawyer, briefly dio shows and music festivals ever,” Bob Dylan once said. minute ballad about building their lives during the Holocaust to save Jews.
advised Gordon Light- Many of those songs were the Canadian Pacific Railway Corrie’s message was always overtly Christian; her
foot on his estate. The Cana- personal. He described “If You in the late 19th century, was personal papers are held in the Billy Graham Center Archives
dian folk-rock musician, who The humble man we Could Read My Mind,” written arguably his masterpiece. at Wheaton College, a private Evangelical Christian arts
died Monday at 84, often wore during his first divorce, as “a Lightfoot was a great Cana- college in Illinois. Although Mr. Loftis has greatly enriched
his trademark cowboy boots to called ‘Gord’ was the song about the failure of mar- dian, yet remained humble and the ten Boom story with well-researched additional material,
their meetings. Other lawyers best musician the riage.” “Sundown,” his only grounded. There was always a his previous writing experience did not prepare him for the
would poke their heads into No. 1 single in the U.S., was in- smile on his face, and a challenge of writing about a Christian evangelist whose
my father’s office or ask Light- country has produced. spired by a troubled romance. friendly handshake to anyone weapons were faith and grace rather than parachute drops
foot for autographs. “It was al- He turned to fiction and his- who approached—including and hidden radios. As his prose begins to echo the prosely-
ways a popular destination tory in tunes like “Don Qui- my father’s colleagues. tism that characterized Corrie herself, biography slides into
spot when he showed up,” dad and at 12 won a contest and xote” and “The Wreck of the hagiography. Yet Corrie ten Boom’s indomitable faith in the
fondly remembers. appeared at Toronto’s legend- Edmund Fitzgerald.” The lat- Mr. Taube, a columnist for face of evil was extraordinary, and “The Watchmaker’s
Canada has produced many ary Massey Hall. ter, about a freighter that sank Troy Media, Loonie Politics, Daughter” recounts a story that deserves to be remembered.
great musicians, but Light- His songs were recorded by in 1975 in Lake Superior, killing National Post and Epoch
foot, whom many Canadians U.S. musicians like Johnny the 29-man crew, was inspired Times, was a speechwriter for Ms. Gray’s 12th book of narrative nonfiction, “Passionate
affectionately called “Gord,” Cash, Elvis Presley, Harry Be- by an article in Newsweek. former Canadian prime minis- Mothers, Powerful Sons: The Lives of Jennie Jerome Churchill
stood above them all. He was lafonte and Peter, Paul and He also wrote about his ter Stephen Harper. and Sara Delano Roosevelt,” will be published in September.
A16 | Thursday, May 4, 2023 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Trump Picked an EV Loser How ‘Equity Grading’ Can Fail the Students
P
oliticians are lousy at picking business Group. Last November Foxconn agreed to in- Baltimore County Public Schools The confusion surrounding equita-
winners and losers. Consider the elec- vest $170 million in Lordstown, perhaps hoping (BCPS) changed its grading policy in ble grading is that it isn’t solely cen-
2016 to one that mirrors the policies tered on providing scaffolding for un-
tric vehicle startup Lordstown Motors, that Inflation Reduction Act subsidies would
described in “Schools Ditch Home- derprivileged students. Progressive
once hyped by Donald provide a boost. work, Deadlines” (U.S. News, April educators undersell that modernized
Trump. Despite rich govern- Lordstown Motors won’t Yet Lordstown had manu- 27). At that time, I was both a BCPS grading systems are crafted to sup-
ment subsidies and man- be the last casualty of factured only 31 vehicles by teacher and parent. The negative out- port all learners; such acknowledg-
dates, Lordstown this week late February 2023—most of comes outweighed the positive intent. ment would lead to greater support
warned it could soon file for the new industrial policy. which had to be recalled. Los- BCPS adopted a no-zero policy that from all Americans. Traditionally,
bankruptcy. ing patience, Foxconn on April set the lowest possible grade for any schools have been fixated on informa-
Lordstown was among a 21 threatened to withdraw its assignment or test at 50%. This policy tion processing. Grading based on
coterie of EV startups that went public during investment, triggering Lordstown’s bankruptcy allowed students to do minimal deadlines measures student process-
the pandemic through a merger with a SPAC, warning. work—even sometimes no work—and ing speeds, and how fast a student
or blank-check company. Launched in 2018, the As interest rates have normalized, compa- still pass. It replaced test scores well can comprehend material, not the
below 50% with the required mini- ability to comprehend.
electric truck maker had little experience man- nies with little revenue are struggling to bor-
mum. The artificially inflated grade of- The goal of all education is to
ufacturing vehicles. Yet it raised a trunk-load row and raise fresh capital. This is one reason ten propelled students forward who learn and grow as one moves through
of cash with the help of Mr. Trump and the Fed- stocks of other EV startups have crashed from lacked proficiency and encouraged stu- new content, not to learn before an
eral Reserve’s easy money. their pandemic highs, including Canoo (down dents to skip assignments altogether. arbitrary deadline. Deciding to mea-
In 2019 Mr. Trump berated GM CEO Mary 96%), Nikola (99%), Faraday Future Intelligent Under the new policy, teachers sure a student’s success in a course
Barra for shutting down a Chevy Cruze plant Electric (99%), Rivian (90%), Lucid (87%) and were told not to grade homework. Im- based on summative knowledge elimi-
in Lordstown, Ohio. “I asked her to sell it or do Fisker (81%). mediately, 70% of my students nates the practice of punishing stu-
something quickly,” he tweeted. Ms. Barra fol- Shortly after its public debut in November stopped doing homework, making it dents for not knowing content before
lowed orders and provided Lordstown Motors 2021, Rivian commanded a $153.3 billion mar- meaningless to go over the answers in starting the unit of study and instead
a $40 million loan to buy and retrofit the plant. ket capitalization. Now it’s worth less than $12 class. Teachers were encouraged to focuses on their final accumulation of
offer multiple redo opportunities. No knowledge.
Mr. Trump then used Lordstown as a prop in billion. Investors are downgrading Rivian’s
one seemed to consider the extra PROF. JOHN ESSINGTON
his presidential campaign. growth prospects as traditional auto makers work for teachers or the lost instruc- Blackburn College
In September 2020, Mr. Trump flogged a ramp up EV production to meet government tional time for students. Redos can’t Carlinville, Ill.
prototype of its Endurance pickup at a White mandates. be given outside of school hours with-
House event with its then CEO. “The area was Speaking of which, Stellantis announced last out inequity toward students who rely When homework is carefully de-
devastated when General Motors moved out, week that it would offer buyouts to 31,000 on the school bus for transportation. signed, it is an invaluable aid in rein-
and then we worked together, and we made hourly employees to free up cash for its gov- These policies aren’t teaching stu- forcing classroom instruction. Too of-
the deal on the plant,” Mr. Trump boasted. ernment-mandated EV transition. “The compe- dents to be responsible and account- ten, however, homework is little more
“This is a great technology,” and “I heard the tition is fierce, and the cost of electrification able for their work. Inflated grades than busy work. That’s why it has be-
sales are great.” Lordstown hadn’t yet sold a cannot be passed on to the customer,” North only mask a lack of proficiency. Equi- come so controversial. Rather than
single vehicle. American chief operating officer Mark Stewart table grading may decrease the num- throw the baby out with the bathwa-
ber of failing grades, but districts ter, schools need to rethink their
Mr. Trump’s endorsement nonetheless wrote to employees.
that adopt it are the ones failing. grading policies.
fueled investor interest while near-zero inter- Translation: Workers will be collateral dam- SUZANNE DEMALLIE WALT GARDNER
est rates drove a boom in SPACs. After Lords- age in the transition to EVs as they lose their Baltimore Los Angeles
town made its public debut in October 2020, jobs making gas-powered cars. President Biden
its stock surged to $26 a share. Yet amid myr- flogs the jobs created at EV factories, but he
iad manufacturing mishaps, its shares have never mentions the losers elsewhere owing to
sunk to 40 cents. government mandates and subsidies that dis-
In January 2021, its pickup prototype tort investment. Lordstown is a poster child of
Women in Science Aren’t Doing ‘All Right’
burned during testing. As it burned through the new Washington consensus in favor of gov- As one author of the article “Ex- look ahead to the four or five years
cash, Lordstown sold its namesake plant and ernment industrial policy, and it won’t be the ploring Gender Bias in Six Key Do- of postdocs required in many fields
contracted assembly to Foxconn Technology last casualty of the hubris. mains of Academic Science: An Ad- and the six-year deadline to amass a
versarial Collaboration,” which was tenure dossier, compare it to their bi-
featured in your editorial “Women in ological clocks ticking away, and in-
A Fed Pause That Obsesses Science Are Doing All Right” (May 1),
I believe yours is an incomplete con-
stead choose industry, government or
nontenure-track academic jobs. That
T
clusion to make from our huge study. is not “all right” if we want our best
he Federal Open Market Committee early as July, which shows how much investors Yes, women who apply for tenure- and brightest, men or women, to be
raised its benchmark interest rate by long for the days of free money. track jobs do better than men, and the ones running university research
another quarter point on Wednesday, But free or nearly free money for more than women who apply for grants and sub- labs and educating the next genera-
and the multi-trillion-dollar a decade is what allowed infla- mit articles and request letters of tion of Ph.D.s.
question is whether that’s Powell says the central tion to reignite. Mr. Powell recommendation are now doing “all What I hope readers take away
enough to break the inflation bank hasn’t decided, but noted that inflation still hasn’t right”—i.e., as well as men. But from our article is that knee-jerk
women, especially in life sciences, cries of sexism or nonsexism need to
the Federal Reserve helped fallen enough, and he’s right.
markets think he has. If he’s also right, as he aren’t applying to tenure-track jobs in be avoided. The situation of women
to ignite. the first place in proportions com- in science academia is complicated—
Chairman Jerome Powell claimed, that “the U.S. bank- mensurate with their number of much better than it was several de-
said at his post-meeting press ing system is sound and resil- newly minted Ph.Ds. cades ago, but still hampered by the
conference that the FOMC members hadn’t de- ient,” then there’s no reason to ease up now on Some may conclude, “That’s their rigidity of the postdoc and tenure-
cided whether this latest rate increase—the the inflation fight. choice.” But the literature says that track systems.
10th in 13 months—will be the last one in this A pause may be prudent as a caution against the major reason women Ph.D.s don’t PROF. SHULAMIT KAHN
cycle. But it sure sounded as if he hopes it will more uncertain banking trauma, but easing pol- apply to tenure-track jobs is that they Boston University
be enough. icy when inflation is still more than twice as
He was quick to note that the FOMC state- high as the Fed’s 2% target looks more like ca-
ment had dropped language from previous pitulation than victory. Raisian, the Last Knight of the Round Table
meetings that it anticipated further monetary Inevitably, Mr. Powell was asked his views on
I am saddened to read of the ration, I endeavored to learn as much
tightening. He also said current “policy is the debt-ceiling showdown, and on that he death of John Raisian but heartened as I could about his leadership style
tight,” suggesting that real interest rates are swung and missed. He said he isn’t taking sides that Tunku Varadarajan paid tribute and personality.
already about 2%. He pointed to tightening in the fiscal debate, but he sounded an alarmist in “John Raisian, a Guardian of Free- Perhaps one of the most telling tid-
credit availability for borrowers and the Fed’s note about the danger of default and said the dom” (op-ed, April 25). Not long af- bits I learned was about his first time
continuation of quantitative tightening from Fed can’t do much if the worst happens. ter Raisian was appointed director of in front of the Stanford faculty. He
the runoff of its bond portfolio. Markets There’s no need to feed financial fears. A bet- the Hoover Institution, I had the walked to the podium adorned in full
seemed to agree on a dovish interpretation as ter position would be to say he can’t comment pleasure of meeting with him to body armor, reminiscent of the
the dollar fell, gold rose, and bond yields de- on fiscal policy, but the Fed will do whatever it present my recruitment plan for his knights of the Round Table. Needless
clined. can to facilitate market function no matter what chief development officer. In prepa- to say, even his harshest detractors
If the Fed is done tightening for now, the Congress and the White House decide. The Fed’s had to smile. For me, this one antic
spoke volumes about his boldness and
next question that markets will obsess about is job is to calm potential panics, not to play the
when the central bank will starting cutting warning role of Shakespeare’s chorus in the lat-
Why Was the Fed the Last sense of humor. That he guided a pre-
eminent think tank for a quarter-cen-
rates. Forecast markets are betting on a cut as est Beltway melodrama. To Know About Rising Risk? tury underscores his brilliance and
Kudos for your editorial “The Fed resilience. May Stanford continue to
Failed but Wants More Power” (May appoint similar guardians of freedom.
Poland Is the Indispensable NATO Ally 1). I have taught an economics course MARTHA Z. STACHITAS
A
on money and banking for over 40 Ponte Vedra Beach, Fla.
mericans sometimes ask, with good rea- globally is the capability of industry.” years, and one of the counterintuitive
son, why Western Europeans don’t do Poland finalized the purchase of 32 F-35 insights I have always emphasized to
more to defend themselves. Behold Po- fighter jets from the U.S. in late 2019 and early my students is that rising interest Bangladesh Closes the Door
rates aren’t good for banks. Banks
land, a NATO state setting an 2020, but deliveries begin next Regarding Tunku Varadarajan’s re-
Warsaw is doing more year and won’t be completed borrow the money that they lend to
example for all of Europe as it others, and their assets are longer-
view of “I Feel No Peace: Rohingya
goes on an arms-buying spree Fleeing Over Seas and Rivers”
to deter Vladimir Putin or the
than others in Europe until 2030. The first shipment
of missiles for Patriot air-de-
term than their liabilities. That is
(Books, April 29): Canada offered to
precisely the problem at the heart of
next Russian czar. to defend itself. fense systems provided under recent bank failures.
take 30,000 Rohingya, but the Ban-
Last week Poland an- a 2018 agreement finally ar- gladeshi government refused. One
My students can be forgiven for
has to wonder what that government
nounced a $2.3 billion deal to rived this spring. The 250 not understanding that aspect of the
is doing with the millions of dollars
buy missiles and missile launchers from the U.K. Abrams tanks requested in 2021 won’t begin to banking business. But not the Federal
it gets for managing the Rohingya
for its air-defense systems. The company MBDA arrive until 2025. Reserve. It is behind the higher inter-
camps, which rival the ghettos of
says the purchase is “the largest European Poland has tried to offset these delays in part est rates, so this can’t have been a
Nazi Germany. Is Bangladesh profit-
short-range air defence acquisition programme with $12.3 billion in arms purchases from South surprise. Why, then, were the Fed’s
ing off the backs of these people?
bank regulators not actively requiring
in NATO” since the outbreak of the war in Korea, which can deliver some weapons faster. The genocide didn’t stop at Myan-
banks to plan for what everyone else
Ukraine. The Polish shopping list in Seoul includes nearly knew was going to happen to bank
mar’s border. These camps are only a
A year ago Warsaw passed the Homeland De- 200 K2 battle tanks, nearly 50 FA-50 fighter slow, grinding variation.
balance sheets as interest rates rose?
fense Act that mandates defense spending of at planes, as well as hundreds of howitzers and LAURA TOFFENETTI
PROF. JOHN A. FLANDERS
least 3% of GDP, a level it has already exceeded multiple rocket launchers. Senior adviser, Rohingya Culture Center
Central Methodist University
Chicago
this year. Defense spending rose to some $23.5 Plans are also underway to work with Korean Fayette, Mo.
billion for 2023 from less than $14 billion in firms to build hundreds of tanks and howitzers
2022, according to the Polish government. A in Poland. Even before the Russian tanks rolled
separate Armed Forces Support Fund will pro- into Ukraine, Poland was one of only nine of Smartest Guy in the Room Pepper ...
vide up to some $11 billion more this year. NATO’s 30 members to meet the defense-spend- Anyone who reads Vivek Ramas- And Salt
Last year’s law calls for Poland to increase ing benchmark of 2% of GDP. wamy’s op-ed “Prosperity Requires a
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
its military manpower to 300,000 from some Poland’s financial and military commitments Stable Dollar” (May 2) should realize
143,500 in 2022. This will include 50,000 part- to Ukraine now exceed 0.6% of GDP, according that he is the smartest guy in the
time warriors in the Polish Territorial Defense to the Kiel Institute for the World Economy, a room running for president. Unfortu-
Forces. Last autumn Poland had $20 billion in German research outfit. That includes more than nately, intelligence doesn’t seem to
military orders with the U.S. that are in the $2.5 billion in military support—more than resonate with voters (only promises
that can’t be kept do), so his odds to
process of being fulfilled, according to the France, whose economy is about four times
win are long. If, however, a Republican
State Department. In February State approved larger than Poland’s. Poland has provided wins in 2024, Mr. Ramaswamy should
the Polish purchase of another $10 billion in Ukraine with hundreds of tanks. Ukrainian be a candidate for a cabinet position.
Himar rocket launchers and related ammo and troops also train in Poland, and the country is KEN BERRYMAN
equipment. now a refuge for more than 1.5 million Ukraini- Tulsa, Okla.
Yet America’s defense production capacity ans who fled the war.
isn’t keeping up with the demand generated by Poland may be replacing Germany as the in-
Letters intended for publication should
growing global threats. Poland’s top general re- dispensable NATO ally in Europe. The U.S. has be emailed to wsj.ltrs@wsj.com. Please
cently told the publication Breaking Defense some 10,000 service members in the country and include your city, state and telephone
that “we just took our suitcases with money could consider more as their presence has popu- number. All letters are subject to
and [are] going like hell around the world and lar support. As a front-line NATO state, Poland editing, and unpublished letters cannot “No landmark decisions, but I have
be acknowledged.
trying to buy,” but “the biggest friction point deserves front-line treatment for weapons. had several rulings go viral.”
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, May 4, 2023 | A17
OPINION
I
New York its “largest humanitarian cri- While these measures
f you want proof that there’s a sis in recent memory” over could decrease illegal immi-
crisis at the southern border, the past year. Mayor Eric Ad- gration in the long term, they
enter New York City’s subway ams said the city receives won’t mitigate the post-Title
system and listen for the calls “close to 200” migrants a day 42 surge. Ariel Ruiz, a policy
of “chocolate, chicle, y agua.” and that “the national govern- analyst at the Migration Pol-
On my daily commute, I see many ment has turned its back on icy Institute, says that “even
Central and South American women New York City.” The city antic- after the implementation of
pacing across platforms peddling ipates spending $1.4 billion on this plan from DHS,” there
chocolate, gum and water. Many “costs related to housing and likely will be “an increase in
hold young children, some even caring for the asylum seeker migrants being relocated to
breastfeeding. population” in fiscal 2023 New York City but also other
Lucia, a young mother from Ecua- (which ends June 30) and $2.9 cities across the U.S.”
‘W
to include the establishment of a help end the war, even as British ap- office. That abuse was directed no ening the record of those achieve-
e can’t win with Trump Jewish national home, three-fourths peasement of the Arabs made it less against the voters who elected ments. About the unconscionable
and we can’t win with- of the territory was given to the Ha- more urgent to end the British occu- him to keep America resilient. behavior of the rioters the previous
out him,” a friend said, shemite Kingdom of Jordan, and pation. Ben-Gurion’s strategy saw We will never know what more day, she writes, “There is no mistak-
echoing many other sober Ameri- British authorities undertook neutral thousands of Palestinian Jews fight- Mr. Trump might have accomplished ing the impact your rhetoric had.”
cans. But I suggested that recent supervision over the rest. The more ing on the Allied side and as many had his opponents not conspired to The qualities of leadership that had
Jewish history shows a way out of the Arabs rioted in the 1920s and defying British rule to create the prevent him from governing. The made Mr. Trump electable, he him-
the bind Republicans face in regain- ’30s, the more the British gave way state of Israel. near-totalitarian media bias that self abused more damagingly than
ing the White House without its for- to their demands and prevented kept all coverage of him negative his detractors had damaged him.
mer incumbent. Jews from arming in self-defense. makes his achievements all the more Moreover, he gives no hint of cor-
In 1939, as World War II began, This culminated in the British White He saw the need to help admirable. recting his poor judgment, and
the Jewish community of Palestine Paper of 1939, which severely re- In the book “The Case for shows his party and its members
faced simultaneous and competing stricted Jewish immigration and pre- the British fight the Nazis Trump,” which covers only the first none of the loyalty he demands of
challenges from Europe and at home. vented Jews’ rescue from certain while opposing the British half of his presidency, Victor David them. The legal cases against him
Adolf Hitler intended to wipe out death. Hanson touts “massive deregulation, will, one hopes, result in honest ver-
the Jews of Europe. Jews in the The dilemma: The British also occupation of Palestine. stepped up energy production, tax dicts. The political case against him
Land of Israel urgently needed to were simultaneously leading the cuts, increased border enforcement,” is more consequential.
provide refuge for the millions being fight against Hitler. No matter how as well as near-record-low minority It is now more urgent than ever
refused entry everywhere else. They cruel, British policy couldn’t out- This double imperative I offer my unemployment, a strong stock mar- to recover and restore the best of
faced resistance in Palestine, where weigh the need to help defeat the fellow Americans who confront Don- ket and low inflation rates. In for- America, but also more difficult be-
the grand mufti of Jerusalem, Hajj Nazis. Faced with these opposite ald Trump’s bid for the Republican eign affairs, the Abraham Accords cause the former president fails to
Amin Al-Husseini, was determined threats, David Ben-Gurion, head of nomination. The need to support the are enough to secure Trump’s repu- embody the greatness of America
to prevent the fleeing Jews from en- the World Zionist Organization and former president and to defend his tation. Of domestic successes I that he seeks to restore. Sober
tering their homeland. He incited de facto leader of the Jewish state in accomplishments dare not grant him would single out the influence of Ed- Americans will therefore defend the
the local Arab population to vio- formation, declared: “We will help the party’s endorsement, while the ucation Secretary Betsy DeVos in Trump record without supporting
lence, warning the British overseers the British in the war as if there need to defeat him in the primaries trying to keep schools open during his candidacy, and deny him re-elec-
of potential pan-Arab resistance were no White Paper, and fight the must not empower those who sabo- the pandemic, promoting charter tion while defeating those who did
against the British throughout the White Paper as if there were no taged his presidency and remain schools, and shutting down the gov- not allow him to govern.
Middle East. war.” primed to destroy him. ernment’s assault on due process in
Britain had been entrusted with The two-pronged struggle allowed Without question, great wrongs sexual-misconduct proceedings. Ms. Wisse is a professor emerita
the mandate for Palestine after de- for no triangulation, no choice of the were committed against the 45th Yet in her letter of resignation at Harvard and author of the mem-
feating the Ottomans in World War lesser evil. The mufti’s alliance with president, who was baited and dated Jan. 7, 2021, Mrs. DeVos la- oir “Free as a Jew.”
T
Ukraine, both before and after Vladi- battlefield experience—and not the sider nonstate actors as potential Other grass-roots global move-
he Ukraine conflict shows that mir Putin’s invasion, we found an ex- training they need or request. partners. There are several in Kyiv ments—such as the North Atlantic
the U.S. needs to adapt to the tensive ecosystem of informal and The core problem is that the that have been active since Mr. Pu- Fellas Organization—are loosely co-
realities of war in the 21st cen- citizen-assisted efforts to support American bureaucracy is fighting war tin’s 2014 invasion of Crimea. In ordinated groups of individuals troll-
tury. Perhaps the best place to begin Ukrainian soldiers. This network in- as usual. The U.S. defense establish- ing and making light of Russian pro-
is developing unconventional military cludes groups that crowdfunded ment wants to help Ukrainian forces paganda while raising money to buy
partners. modified drones for units on the but can do so only within the scope Defense planners are used drones and 4x4 trucks to donate to
To be sure, the war also shows the front lines, foreign military veterans its political leaders allow. The De- Ukrainian units on the front. The U.S.
value of America’s traditional alli- providing combat medicine and fense Department’s sprawling size to working with other government should consider working
ances. Since February 2022, our joint guerrilla training, and volunteers makes learning from Ukrainian sol- states, but volunteer with such groups, not only because of
civilian-military research team has who supply troops with food, uni- diers’ experiences and expertise ex- their military successes, but also be-
studied Western efforts to provide forms, thermal sights and night-vi- ceedingly difficult. Layers of proce- groups have proved vital. cause of their affordable ways of
military training to Ukrainian troops. sion goggles. dure and regulations smother turning nonlethal assistance into bat-
Many trainers with experience in Iraq Ukrainian soldiers say this support operational innovation and ham- tlefield advantages.
and Afghanistan told us that Ukrai- network is on par with—if less ex- string U.S. advisers trying to adapt to 2014, we met the founder of Anom- Abrams tanks and operational
nian troops are much more motivated pansive than—their own country’s the realities of the Ukrainians’ fight. aly, a company that has been produc- training remain vital, and America
and proficient than Iraqi and Afghan Defense Ministry and Western train- Washington is spending tens of ing and distributing thousands of shouldn’t let up on generously sup-
soldiers were. The relationship is also ers. Most important, it is nimble; the billions of dollars on military equip- trauma kits to Ukrainian troops for plying them. But such efforts can
mutually beneficial: American forces groups can adapt to the soldiers’ im- ment and financial aid for Kyiv. At a pennies on the dollar. Citizen-based and should be enhanced by enlisting
are learning from Ukrainian soldiers’ mediate needs. minimum it seems prudent for the groups understand the formal and in- civic groups and nonofficial experts
engagement with a near-peer adver- Western forces, on the other hand, U.S. military to have more flexibility formal aspects of Ukrainian politics who can provide training and sup-
sary—something the U.S. hasn’t en- have proved significantly less flexi- to respond to the rapidly changing and can identify local power brokers. port to Ukrainian soldiers on a shoe-
countered since the Korean war. ble. Ukrainian soldiers say Ameri- requirements and threats facing They understand conditions on the string budget. At present, the bu-
Yet American support for Ukraine cans often offer training the soldiers Ukrainians on the front. ground, particularly the training and reaucratic and procedure-bound
defense establishment is too uninter-
ested in—and inflexible to allow
for—such partnerships.
PUBLISHED SINCE 1889 BY DOW JONES & COMPANY
Rupert Murdoch Robert Thomson
Notable & Quotable: CDC Ukraine’s open society stands in
stark contrast with its Russian foe.
Executive Chairman, News Corp Chief Executive Officer, News Corp From a May 2 Washington Post re- Nordlund said the CDC reported Its patriots and international sup-
Emma Tucker Almar Latour port: the cases to state health officials who porters can take the initiative in
Editor in Chief Chief Executive Officer and Publisher
have authority over the location fighting to expel Russian forces. In
Liz Harris, Managing Editor DOW JONES MANAGEMENT: Disease detectives at the Centers where the conference occurred. At- this new era of irregular warfare,
Jason Anders, Deputy Editor in Chief Daniel Bernard, Chief Experience Officer; for Disease Control and Prevention tendees said many people at the America can begin integrating local
Neal Lipschutz, Deputy Editor in Chief Mae M. Cheng, SVP, Barron’s Group; David Cho,
Thorold Barker, Europe; Elena Cherney, News;
are probing a new outbreak: the gathering did not mask, socially dis- volunteer groups into military ef-
Barron’s Editor in Chief; Jason P. Conti, General
Andrew Dowell, Asia; Brent Jones, Culture, roughly three-dozen coronavirus tance or take other precautions that forts. If it does—in addition to un-
Counsel, Chief Compliance Officer; Dianne DeSevo,
Training & Outreach; Alex Martin, Print & Chief People Officer; Frank Filippo, EVP, Business
cases linked to their own annual con- the CDC had recommended earlier in shackling itself from bureaucracy at
Writing; Michael W. Miller, Features & Weekend;
Information & Services, Operations; ference last week. the pandemic. . . . “This is, unfortu- home—it will be ready for whatever
Emma Moody, Standards; Shazna Nessa, Visuals; “CDC is working with the Georgia nately, the new normal,” Jay Varma, international challenge comes next.
Elizabeth O’Melia, Chief Financial Officer;
Philana Patterson, Audio; Matthew Rose,
Enterprise; Michael Siconolfi, Investigations;
Josh Stinchcomb, EVP & Chief Revenue Officer, Department of Health to conduct a an infectious-disease expert at Weill
Amanda Wills, Video WSJ | Barron’s Group; Sherry Weiss, Chief rapid epidemiological assessment of Cornell Medicine, wrote in a text Mr. Matisek is a lieutenant colonel
Paul A. Gigot
Marketing Officer confirmed COVID-19 cases that ap- message. . . . Varma added that indi- in the U.S. Air Force and a professor
Editor of the Editorial Page pear to be connected to the 2023 EIS viduals and organizations should of national security affairs at the U.S.
EDITORIAL AND CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS:
Gerard Baker, Editor at Large
1211 Avenue of the Americas
Conference to determine transmis- continue to take coronavirus precau- Naval War College. Mr. Reno is chair-
New York, N.Y., 10036 sion patterns,” CDC spokesperson tions to protect themselves and the man of the political science depart-
Telephone 1-800-DOWJONES Kristen Nordlund said in an email. most vulnerable as needed. ment at Northwestern University.
A18 | Thursday, May 4, 2023 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
WORLD NEWS
WORLD WATCH
BRAZIL certificates to deceive authorities foreigners to present proof of vac- against the Western world’s rounded up come from families teacher were hospitalized.
in Brazil and the U.S. cination against Covid-19 to enter richest mob group. originally from the Calabrian town A father of a student at the
Federal Police Raid Mauro Cid Barbosa, a lieuten- the country, with few exceptions The raids, which occurred of San Luca, clans that have long school in central Belgrade said
Ex-President’s Home ant colonel and one of Mr. Bol- such as those on diplomatic or of- early Wednesday, are the result cultivated international ties, par- the shooter entered his daugh-
sonaro’s closest advisers during ficial government travel. of an international investigation ticularly with South American ter’s classroom, firing at her
Federal police raided the home his presidency, was arrested. Mr. Bolsonaro denied wrong- that spanned 10 countries and drug cartels. Authorities in Bel- teacher and then her classmates
of former President Jair Bolson- Other military men who advised doing, saying he was never several years. The police opera- gium and Germany arrested 15 as they ducked under their
aro in Brasília on Wednesday as Mr. Bolsonaro, a former army asked to present a vaccination tion deals a major blow to the and 24 people, respectively. desks. Most students were able
part of a probe into allegations captain himself, were also among card when entering the U.S. ‘Ndrangheta, which from Italy’s —Margherita Stancati to flee through a back door, a lo-
that he faked Covid-19 vaccina- the six detainees. Mr. Barbosa —Luciana Magalhaes deep, impoverished south has cal official said.
tion records for himself and fam- couldn’t be reached for comment. emerged as a dominant player in SERBIA Police said the shooter was a
ily members to travel to the U.S. Police found evidence on the WESTERN EUROPE the global cocaine trade. student at the Vladislav Ribnikar
The police issued 16 search government’s public health data- Italian authorities on Teenage Gunman school and was born in 2009.
warrants and six arrest warrants base that a false Covid-19 vac- Mass Arrests Target Wednesday said 23 tons of co- Kills Nine at School They said he used his father’s
in Brasília and Rio de Janeiro as cine certificate was issued for Crime Syndicate caine with an estimated retail gun.
part of an investigation into the Mr. Bolsonaro as well as for his value of around 2.5 billion euros, A teenager opened fire at his Mass shootings are ex-
alleged “insertion of false 12-year-old daughter, Laura, Police in Italy, Germany and or $2.8 billion, were confiscated. school in Serbia’s capital on tremely rare in Serbia and in the
Covid-19 vaccination data” into shortly before the family flew to Belgium arrested 200 people The bulk of the arrests took Wednesday, killing eight children wider Balkan region; no such in-
government databases in 2021 Florida in late December, accord- linked to the ‘Ndrangheta crime place in Calabria, the and a school guard before being cidents were reported at schools
and 2022. The data were alleg- ing to a copy of the police report. syndicate, in the most sweeping, ‘Ndrangheta’s home region in arrested in the schoolyard, police in recent years.
edly used to fake vaccination At the time, the U.S. required cross-border operation to date southern Italy. Most of those said. Six more children and a —Associated Press
tyle. Video.
SP ONSORE D BY
DJ TRANS À 0.16%
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
of dividend-paying stocks.
Dividend stocks are shares BY JOE FLINT
of companies that regularly
return a portion of their earn- The Hollywood writers’
ings to shareholders, typically strike could give studios and
in the form of cash. streamers an opportunity to
The majority of companies slash costs by exiting from un-
that Mr. Buffett invests in pay desirable talent contracts if the
out dividends. In fact, this work stoppage drags on for an
year Mr. Buffett’s Berkshire extended period, some enter-
Hathaway is expected to rake tainment executives said.
in about $5.7 billion in cash Members of the Writers
from its stock portfolio, ac- Guild of America, which repre-
cording to an analysis of com- sents some 11,500 writers,
pany filings conducted by Dow $740M $890M $1.01B went on strike this week after
Jones Market Data. Coca-Cola Bank of America Chevron failing to reach a new deal
Nearly a fifth of that money Monday with the Alliance of
will come from Chevron, Motion Picture and Television
which last year became one of Cash that Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway is expected to collect from some of its dividend-paying stocks in the current year. Producers, whose members in-
Berkshire’s biggest stockhold- clude Netflix, Walt Disney,
ings. The oil producer has in- to Dow Jones Market Data. choosing businesses that have nesses as well as in acquisi- stage in an Omaha, Neb., con- Warner Bros. Discovery and
creased its dividends for 36 “That’s what he loves: divi- been able to stand the test of tions and share repurchases. vention center to address Paramount Global.
consecutive years. Berkshire is dends and buybacks,” said time through many economic The company had $128.6 thousands of people attending Late-night shows were the
also poised to collect more Todd Finkle, a professor of en- cycles—and raise their divi- billion in cash and cash equiv- Berkshire’s annual shareholder first casualties of the strike,
than $700 million apiece from trepreneurship at Gonzaga dends, too. That has both in- alents at the end of 2022, ac- meeting. Mr. Buffett typically with most heading into reruns
Coca-Cola, Apple and Bank of University and author of a creased the value of Berk- cording to its last earnings addresses a variety of topics for Tuesday’s programs. In the
America, more than half a bil- book about Mr. Buffett’s ca- shire’s stock portfolio over report. at the meeting, including the event of a prolonged strike
lion dollars from Kraft Heinz reer. time and added to the ample Investors will have a chance economy, his philosophy on in- that affects scripted TV shows,
and roughly $363 million from Where Mr. Buffett has ex- cash pile Berkshire is able to to hear from Mr. Buffett on vesting and, sometimes, his entertainment companies are
American Express, according celled, Mr. Finkle said, is in put to use in its own busi- Saturday, when he takes the Please turn to page B11 expected to try to fill the void
with foreign shows and more
unscripted fare.
A
Abercrombie & Fitch...B1
Advanced Micro Devices
E
Eisai...........................B12
Eli Lilly.................A3,B12
PacWest Bancorp......B11
Paramount Global.......B1
PepsiCo........................A2
Progressive ................. B2
CVS Reports Higher Revenue,
Reduces Outlook for the Year
...................................B11 Estée Lauder...............B4
Alphabet......................B4 F Q
Allseas.......................B10 Qualcomm...................B4
Ford Motor...........B3,B12
Allstate ....................... B2 R
American Express.......B1 G
A.P. Moller-Maersk...B10 General Motors.........B12 Restaurant Brands
Apple...............B1,B4,B12 Goldman Sachs...........B5 International.............B5
Apollo Global Goodyear Tire & Rubber Rivian Automotive ... B12 BY ANNA WILDE MATHEWS
Ruth’s Hospitality.......B3
Management.............B2 .....................................B4 AND SABELA OJEA
Arconic ........................ B2 GSK ............................. A3 S
B H Samsung Electronics CVS Health posted higher
Bank of America.........B1 Harley-Davidson ......... B1 ............................. B4,B12
Stellantis...................B12 revenue in the first quarter
Berkshire Hathaway...B1 H&M ............................ B1
Best Buy ..................... B2 Home Depot................B2 T but downgraded its earnings
Biogen ....................... B12 J-P Tesla.....................B3,B12 projection for the year be-
Bridgestone.................B4
Johnson & Johnson..B10 U cause of the impact of its big-
Brinker International..B5 gest deals since the nearly $70
Kenvue.......................B10 Unibail-Rodamco-
Burger King.................B5
ByteDance...................B4
Kraft Heinz............B1,B5 Westfield..................B2 billion takeover of Aetna in
Lockheed Martin.......B10 W 2018.
C-D
BUSINESS NEWS
tyle. Video.
SP ONSORE D BY
30 Decline
Qualcomm gave a gloomy 20 BY SABELA OJEA
sales outlook as it signaled the
market for smartphones was 10 Estée Lauder shares posted
more turbulent than expected. 0 their largest one-day decline
Qualcomm, which sells on record after the cosmetics
communication and data-pro- –10 company cut its outlook owing
cessing chips crucial in phones –17% to a slower-than-expected re-
from Apple and Samsung, has –20 covery in the Asian travel re-
been whipsawed in recent FY2021 ’22 ’23 tail market.
quarters by flagging handset Note: Latest fiscal quarter ended March 26
Chief Executive Officer Fab-
sales even as it sees growth in The company said weaker demand for cellphones and broader economic issues weighed on its outlook. Sources: S&P Capital IQ; the company rizio Freda said the company
newer markets for its chips, is facing serious headwinds in
including the automotive in- lion in the period. Revenue issues. tomers will remain cautious timing of purchases by a cus- the key market—and they are
dustry. came in ahead of Wall Street Mr. Amon also said that al- with purchases,” Qualcomm tomer that only buys cellular expected to persist until the
“The evolving macroeco- expectations, according to a though the smartphone mar- Chief Financial Officer Akash modems from Qualcomm, the end of 2023. The challenges
nomic backdrop has resulted survey of analysts by FactSet, ket in China is widely expected Palkhiwala said on the call. company said. Apple fits that come as other parts of its
in further demand deteriora- but the profit figure fell short. to rebound later this year, The company is cutting op- description, though Qualcomm business are doing well amid a
tion, particularly in handsets, The company also gave a Qualcomm has seen no signs erating expenses by 5% this didn’t name the customer. The robust recovery in consumer
at a magnitude greater than tepid outlook for its current of that recovery. Qualcomm fiscal year, Mr. Palkhiwala iPhone maker reports quar- demand and a return to
we previously forecasted,” quarter, projecting between sells chips to leading Chinese said, and could make more terly results Thursday. growth in China.
Chief Executive Cristiano $8.1 billion and $8.9 billion in handset makers. cuts as market conditions International Data Corp. “As the shape of recovery
Amon said on an earnings call revenue, below analyst esti- Global handset shipments evolve. He also warned that last week said smartphone for Asia travel retail comes
Wednesday. mates of around $9.1 billion. this year are likely to fall be- some of the problems weigh- shipments in the first quarter into better focus, it is proving
The company reported sales Qualcomm said weaker de- tween 5% and 10%, Qualcomm ing on sales this quarter could fell year-over-year for the sev- to be both far more volatile
of $9.28 billion in its fiscal mand for handsets globally signaled, worse than initially last into the next one, too. enth straight period and were than we expected and more
second quarter, down 17% were weighing on the out- projected. “Until demand nor- The muted outlook also re- down about 14.6% globally. De- gradual relative to what we
compared with a year before. look, as well as problems in malizes and visibility im- flected a larger-than-expected mand should recover by the experienced in other markets,”
Profit tumbled 42% to $1.7 bil- the wider economy and other proves, we anticipate that cus- decline in revenues due to the end of the year, IDC said. Mr. Freda said Wednesday on
a conference call with ana-
lysts.
PUBLIC NOTICES
With New Offering for Ads as it handles elevated inven-
tory levels. The company pre-
viously said its sales decline
would top out at 7%.
BY ALEXANDRA BRUELL “We are going through an
inventory issue, and with the
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that, pursuant to (i) Section 9-610 of the New York Uniform Commercial Code; and (ii) TikTok said it is launching a profit pressure created by this
that certain Amended and Restated Loan Security Agreement, dated March 24, 2021 (as amended, the “Security
Agreement”) by and between MidCap Financial Trust, as administrative agent (“Secured Party”), and U.S. Auto new product that will make it high-inventory issue,” Mr.
Finance, Inc., U.S. Auto Sales, Inc., and USASF Servicing LLC, as Borrowers (“Borrowers”), (iii) that certain Pledge
Agreement dated April 17, 2019 by and between Secured Party and U.S. Auto Finance, Inc., USASF LLC, and USASF possible for publishers to sell Freda added.
National Corp. (as amended, the “Pledge Agreement”), and (iv) that certain Trademark Security Agreement dated
April 17, 2019 by and between Secured Party and U.S. Auto Sales, Inc. as Grantor (the “Trademark Agreement”), shall ads alongside their posts, a Paris-based L’Oréal, the
sell all or substantially all of the tangible and intangible assets of the Borrowers, the Pledged Equity Collateral (as shift for the video-sharing app, beauty giant’s biggest compet-
defined in the Pledge Agreement), and the Trademark Collateral (as defined in the Trademark Agreement) (all of the
foregoing collectively referred to as the “Sale Assets”) to the highest or otherwise best qualified bidder at a public which historically has focused itor, dealt with the same prob-
disposition to be conducted on May 23, 2023 at 10:00 am, Eastern Daylight Time, at the offices of Chapman and Cutler
on independent creators. lem in China, but has already
ANDREW HARRER/BLOOMBERG NEWS
LLP, 1270 Avenue of the Americas, 30th Floor, New York, New York 10020 (the “Public Sale”).
Pursuant to the Security Agreement, the Borrowers granted the Secured Party a security interest in the Collateral The product, Pulse Premiere, absorbed its extra inventory,
as defined in the Security Agreement, including, without limitation, all the Borrowers’ accounts, accounts receivable,
chattel paper, contracts, contract rights, documents, instruments, investment property, securities, security files, is the evolution of TikTok’s Chief Executive Nicolas Hi-
records, and all the proceeds and products of the foregoing. Pursuant to the Pledge Agreement, each pledgor pledged
and assigned to Secured Party all Equity Interests in each Subsidiary owned by each Pledgor, all as set forth in the
Pulse program, which allows an eronimus said last month after
Pledge Agreement. Pursuant to the Trademark Agreement, the Grantor pledged all of its interest in its Trademarks, elite group of creators to col- reporting a 13% increase in
all as set forth in the Trademark Agreement.
In addition, upon request to counsel for the Secured Party at the contact information listed below, information lect half the revenue from video first-quarter sales. “We are
available to the Secured Party regarding the Sale Assets will also be made available including via a secure data room ads that appear just after their back to a dynamic of growth,”
to prospective bidders who execute a non-disclosure agreement.
TERMS OF SALE: The Sale Assets shall, in the Secured Party’s sole discretion, be offered at the Public Sale in bulk TikTok posts. he added.
or in piecemeal, subject to the Secured Party’s security interests and any other valid liens and security interests in
existence, and shall be sold to the highest bidder on an “AS IS, WHERE IS,” “WITH ALL FAULTS,” BASIS, WITHOUT
The new product will offer Estée Lauder’s stock closed
ANY REPRESENTATIONS OR WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, expressed or implied, including, without limitation, similar perks for accounts from down 17.3% at $202.70, its
merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose, condition or title and without any right of setoff or recoupment. All
parties desiring to qualify as a bidder at the Public Sale shall be required to deliver to the Secured Party reasonable select publishers, such as The product will allow publishers to share video ad revenue. largest percentage decrease on
proof of financial ability to consummate the Sale within 5 business days prior to the Public Sale. The purchase price
for any successful bid must be paid to the Secured Party by 12:00 pm Eastern Daylight Time on the first business
Condé Nast, BuzzFeed and NBC. record going back to 1995. The
day after the acceptance of any such bid. All payments toward the purchase of the Sale Assets must be paid by wire While Pulse is only available to raised national security con- have 2.5% of the U.S. digital ad stock was by far the largest
transfer or in cash, certified check or cashier’s check, payable to the Secured Party. The Secured Party reserves the
right to: (i) bid all or a portion of its claim at the Public Sale without cash, certified check or cashier’s check as required the top 4% of its creators’ cerns around data privacy on market this year and its U.S. ad decliner in the S&P 500 index.
of other bidders; (ii) adjourn or cancel the Public Sale without notice; (iii) alter the terms of payment; (iv) abandon posts—based on metrics such the platform. revenue is expected to surge For the year, shares have lost
or elect not to dispose of certain Sale Assets and/or (v) reject all bids. If Secured Party accepts a bid, the prevailing
bidder will receive a secured party bill of sale with no representations or warranties of any kind or nature whatsoever. as likes, watch time and com- TikTok has pushed back 36% to $6.83 billion, according 18.3%.
Additional terms of sale may be announced at the time of the Public Sale.
OTHER INQUIRIES: For further information about how to attend the Public Sale either in person [or via remote link], ments—the new product will against allegations of the com- to a recent forecast from mar- The lowered outlook comes
please contact: David Audley, Chapman and Cutler LLP, 1270 Avenue of the Americas, New York, New York 10020, or
320 South Canal Street, Chicago, Illinois 60606, Telephone: 312.845.2971, e mail: audley@chapman.com.
sell ads against all posts from pany’s ties to the Chinese gov- ket research firm Insider Intel- after Estée Lauder posted a
participating publishers, the ernment and has proposed a ligence. significant profit drop in its
company said. $1.5 billion plan to silo its U.S. While it still represents a latest quarter.
AVIATION The opportunity to sell ads operations from China. The small slice of the digital ad
in social media’s hottest app company also has moved to re- market, TikTok is inching in on
comes as many publishers are assure advertisers by playing the market dominance of Meta
Pilot Shortage?
Supply Chain Excuses?
struggling to deal with tough
economic conditions, resulting
in cost-cutting and layoffs
across the industry.
down the threat of an outright
ban, The Wall Street Journal
reported.
For advertisers, the new
Platforms Inc. and Alphabet
Inc.’s Google, which have
ramped up their short-form
video offerings.
12%
High end of estimate for
For TikTok, the move cre- product is aimed at providing Publishers have embraced decline in full-year sales
ates another revenue opportu- more transparency around TikTok as a place to build their
Jet Card Frustration? nity for the platform, and it where they are putting their brands, but at times have be-
helps to build the site’s rela- media dollars, Mr. Cao said. moaned the lack of opportuni-
EXECUTIVE FLIGHT MANAGEMENT tionship with advertisers and Advertisers have flocked to ties to generate revenue di- Overall for the period ended
publishers. TikTok to reach its young us- rectly on the platform. March 31, Estée Lauder re-
TRANS AMERICAN CHARTER LTD. “It’s about, like, how can we ers. The app has been down- “We have a really strong ported a profit of $156 million,
(630) 536 1610 really diversify our portfolio,”
said Ray Cao, global head of
loaded more than 4 billion
times globally and was the
partnership with YouTube. We
have a really strong partner-
or 43 cents a share, compared
with $558 million, or $1.53 a
www.efmtac.com monetization product strategy
at TikTok.
most downloaded app in 2022,
according to research firm Sen-
ship with Instagram. This part-
nership with TikTok is really
share, for the same period a
year earlier.
The new ad product comes sor Tower. just taking off,” said Pam Stripping out one-time
as the app, which is owned by More than 150 million Amer- Drucker Mann, global chief rev- items, the company’s earnings
37 years of Beijing-based ByteDance, is icans are now on TikTok, the enue officer at Condé Nast. per share came in at 47 cents,
facing a possible ban in the U.S. company has said. “The potential there is pretty missing analyst expectations of
individual solutions. after the Biden administration The company is expected to significant.” 51 cents.
Sales fell 12% to $3.75 bil-
lion, just ahead of analyst ex-
NOTICE OF SALE
Tiremakers Aim for Real-Time pectations for $3.71 billion. On
an organic basis, which ex-
cludes currency effects and
other items, sales fell 8%.
Integrated Software But before that, these com- time, Mr. Helsel said. A real- on them is simmering—but 240
ADVERTISE TODAY panies face a number of com- time system, designed to help not boiling, according to John
Platform Sales and plications, including how to autonomous vehicles make im- Baldwin, senior vice president 230
Service Business power the process and how to mediate driving decisions, and chief product and techni-
(800) 366-3975 integrate data from the tires would be far more power-in- cal strategist at Discount Tire.
30 year history with feeds from other data- tensive, he said. Today’s bat- Autonomous vehicles, he
220
1.25m total revenue, For more information visit: collection sources on the vehi- teries would last just a frac- noted, are moving forward Wednesday
wsj.com/classifieds 210
cle. Typically, autonomous ve- tion of the life of the tire. without advanced data-gener- $202.70
Owner retiring, hicles are equipped with a A process known as energy ating tires, in part because –17.3%
200
Dallas Area configuration of radar, laser- harvesting could be one solu- there are already so many Jan. 2023 May
© 2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. emitting lidar and cameras to tion to the power problem, ac- other spots on the vehicle that
KlayCPA@msn.com | 214-803-3355 All Rights Reserved.
paint a real-time picture of cording to Hans Dorfi, senior can gather data. Source: FactSet
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, May 4, 2023 | B5
BUSINESS NEWS
PRESENTING SPONSORS
Harley said its credit loss rate was 3.2% in the first quarter, up from its typical rate of about 2%.
Bringing Communities
of Support to Students
MARKETS DIGEST
EQUITIES
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago
33414.24 t 270.29, or 0.80% Trailing P/E ratio 22.28 19.36 4090.75 t 28.83, or 0.70% Trailing P/E ratio * 18.61 24.14 12025.33 t 55.18, or 0.46% Trailing P/E ratio *† 26.81 30.01
High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 17.94 17.50 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 18.87 18.62 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate *† 26.05 23.22
trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 2.10 2.08 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield * 1.68 1.46 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield *† 0.85 0.78
All-time high 36799.65, 01/04/22 All-time high 4796.56, 01/03/22 All-time high: 16057.44, 11/19/21
target rate Wednesday Close 3.00 Turkey lira .0513 19.4774 4.2
Barclays Bank 4.50% Hong Kong dollar .1274 7.8500 0.6
3.00 One year ago Euro Ukraine hryvnia .0271 36.9500 0.3
0
t
COMMODITIES wsj.com/market-data/commodities
Finished 3250 –7
Hyundai Capital America HYNMTR 5.500 5.17 March 30, ’26 161 164
motor gasoline 8,618 ... 9,511 8,856 8,896 8,716 t Cigna CI 6.150 5.53 Nov. 15, ’36 215 –6 n.a.
Kerosene-type 2250
Natural gas, John Deere Capital … 4.800 4.07 Jan. 9, ’26 44 –6 50
jet fuel 1,539 ... 1,532 1,440 1,555 1,298 lower 48 states Morgan Stanley MS 3.125 4.69 July 27, ’26 105 –6 94
1250
Distillates 3,872 ... 3,728 3,956 3,782 3,976
Residual fuel oil 233 ... 180 290 168 225 …And spreads that widened the most
250
Propane/propylene 1,105 ... 676 981 906 ... M J J A S O N D J F M A Comerica Bank CMA 7.875 10.59 Sept. 15, ’26 696 148 495
Other oils 4,438 ... 4,580 3,944 4,289 ... 2022 2023 KeyCorp KEY 2.550 6.61 Oct. 1, ’29 321 57 n.a.
Note: Expected changes are provided by Dow Jones Newswires' survey of analysts. Previous and average inventory data are in millions. 31
Nordea Bank NDASS 1.500 5.10 Sept. 30, ’26 147 129
Sources: FactSet; Dow Jones Market Data; U.S. Energy Information Administration; Dow Jones Newswires
United Airlines Holdings UAL 5.875 6.03 April 15, ’29 216 17 177
Exchange-Traded Portfolios | WSJ.com/ETFresearch BPCE BPCEGP 3.500 5.37 Oct. 23, ’27 197 12
12
n.a.
Credit Suisse CS 7.500 5.94 Feb. 15, ’28 251 238
Closing Chg YTD 9
Largest 100 exchange-traded funds, latest session ETF Symbol Price (%) (%) Bank of Nova Scotia BNS 4.500 5.16 Dec. 16, ’25 123 n.a.
TechSelectSector XLK 148.25 –0.84 19.1 Netflix NFLX 5.875 4.74 Nov. 15, ’28 135 9 120
Wednesday, May 3, 2023 Closing Chg YTD
ETF Symbol Price (%) (%) UtilitiesSelSector XLU 68.07 –0.28 –3.4
ETF
Closing Chg YTD
Symbol Price (%) (%) iSh1-5YIGCorpBd IGSB 50.69 0.28 1.7
VanEckGoldMin
VangdInfoTech
GDX
VGT
34.86
377.76
0.35
–0.71
21.6
18.3
High-yield issues with the biggest price increases…
iSh1-3YTreaBd SHY 82.28 0.24 1.4 VangdSC Val VBR 153.49 –0.36 –3.3 Bond Price as % of face value
CnsmrDiscSelSector XLY 145.39 –0.79 12.6 Issuer Symbol Coupon (%) Yield (%) Maturity Current One-day change Last week
CnsStapleSelSector XLP 76.66 –0.82 2.8 iShRussMC IWR 68.12 –0.47 1.0 VangdExtMkt VXF 134.87 0.04 1.5
DimenUSCoreEq2 DFAC 25.13 –0.55 3.5 iShRuss1000 IWB 223.74 –0.65 6.3 VangdDivApp VIG 155.09 –0.74 2.1
iShRuss1000Grw IWF 243.40 –0.50 13.6 VangdFTSEAWxUS VEU 53.88 0.11 7.5 Telecom Italia Capital TITIM 6.375 7.86 Nov. 15, ’33 89.500 1.05 89.853
EnSelSectorSPDR XLE 78.99 –1.89 –9.7
iShRuss1000Val IWD 150.95 –0.81 –0.5 VangdFTSEDevMk VEA 45.92 0.20 9.4 0.90
FinSelSectorSPDR XLF 31.96 –1.14 –6.5
iShRussell2000 IWM 172.33 0.37 –1.2 VangdFTSE EM VWO 39.68 –0.03 1.8
Sprint Capital … 6.875 5.14 Nov. 15, ’28 108.269 108.216
HealthCareSelSect XLV 133.46 –0.13 –1.8
InvscQQQI QQQ 317.29 –0.65 19.2
iShS&P500Grw IVW 63.76 –0.61 9.0 VangdFTSE Europe VGK 62.94 0.32 13.5 Occidental Petroleum OXY 7.875 5.74 Sept. 15, ’31 114.000 0.47 113.445
iShS&P500Value IVE 150.98 –0.85 4.1 VangdGrowth VUG 248.18 –0.53 16.5
InvscS&P500EW RSP 142.01 –0.58 0.5 0.28
iShCoreDivGrowth DGRO 49.84 –0.89 –0.3
iShSelectDiv DVY 113.57 –0.80 –5.8 VangdHlthCr VHT 245.87 0.12 –0.9 Venture Global Calcasieu Pass VENTGL 4.125 5.94 Aug. 15, ’31 88.280 88.687
iSh7-10YTreaBd IEF 100.25 0.65 4.7 VangdHiDiv VYM 103.91 –0.97 –4.0
iShCoreMSCIEAFE IEFA 68.19 0.28 10.6 0.25
iShCoreMSCIEM IEMG
iShShortTreaBd SHV 110.09 0.02 0.2 VangdIntermBd BIV 77.30 0.45 4.0 CSC Holdings CSCHLD 5.250 7.97 June 1, ’24 97.250 97.750
47.93 –0.13 2.6
iShTIPSBondETF TIP 110.03 0.46 3.4 VangdIntrCorpBd VCIT 80.34 0.29 3.7
iShCoreMSCITotInt IXUS 62.45 0.10 7.9
iShCoreS&P500 IVV 409.72 –0.72 6.6
iSh20+YTreaBd
iShUSTreasuryBd
TLT
GOVT
106.29
23.52
0.56
0.45
6.8
3.5
VangdIntermTrea
VangdLC
VGIT
VV
60.59
186.07
0.56
–0.63
3.6
6.8
…And with the biggest price decreases
iShCoreS&P MC IJH 244.34 –0.11 1.0 JPMEquityPrem JEPI 54.40 –0.66 –0.2 VangdMC VO 204.99 –0.46 0.6
iShCoreS&P SC IJR 92.25 0.03 –2.5 Bath & Body Works BBWI 6.750 8.14 July 1, ’36 88.875 –0.75 89.405
JPM UltShIncm JPST 50.21 0.08 0.2 VangdMC Val VOE 132.03 –0.47 –2.4
iShCoreS&PTotUS ITOT 89.78 –0.58 5.9 ProShUltPrQQQ TQQQ 26.88 –1.97 55.4 VangdMBS VMBS 46.86 0.60 2.9 Dish DBS … 7.750 30.92 July 1, ’26 55.250 –0.75 58.500
iShCoreTotalUSDBd IUSB 46.28 0.41 3.0 SPDRBbg1-3MTB BIL 91.42 0.01 –0.1 VangdRealEst VNQ 80.96 –0.39 –1.8
iShCoreUSAggBd AGG 100.09 0.44 3.2 SPDR DJIA Tr DIA 334.11 –0.82 0.8 VangdS&P500ETF VOO 374.88 –0.70 6.7 Transocean RIG 6.800 11.24 March 15, ’38 68.250 –0.75 n.a.
iShESGAwareUSA ESGU 89.83 –0.67 6.0 SPDR Gold GLD 189.11 0.85 11.5 VangdST Bond BSV 76.84 0.33 2.1
iShEdgeMSCIMinUSA USMV 73.15 –0.37 1.5 SPDRPtfDevxUS SPDW 32.57 0.09 9.7 VangdSTCpBd VCSH 76.47 0.30 1.7 Hughes Satellite Systems SATS 6.625 8.88 Aug. 1, ’26 93.750 –0.63 93.875
iShEdgeMSCIUSAQual QUAL 123.89 –0.65 8.7 SPDRS&P500Value SPYV 40.53 –0.78 4.2 VangdShtTmInfltn VTIP 47.98 0.23 2.7
iShGoldTr IAU 38.57 0.84 11.5 SPDRPtfS&P500 SPLG 47.96 –0.72 6.6 VangdShortTrea VGSH 58.59 0.26 1.3 Bausch Health BHCCN 11.000 16.27 Sept. 30, ’28 81.500 –0.56 81.437
iShiBoxx$HYCpBd HYG 74.58 –0.05 1.3 SPDRS&P500Growth SPYG 55.25 –0.58 9.0 VangdSC VB –0.34
iShiBoxx$InvGrCpBd LQD 109.27 0.17 3.6
183.93 –0.04 0.2 Occidental Petroleum OXY 6.200 5.99 March 15, ’40 102.160 103.000
SPDR S&P 500 SPY 408.02 –0.69 6.7 VangdTaxExemptBd VTEB 50.39 0.16 1.8
iShJPMUSDEmBd EMB 85.58 0.32 1.2 SchwabIntEquity SCHF 35.43 0.14 10.0 VangdTotalBd BND 74.17 0.42 3.2 Credit Suisse CS 6.500 23.41 Aug. 8, ’23 95.791 –0.33 96.250
iShMBS MBB 95.30 0.65 2.7 SchwabUS BrdMkt SCHB 47.44 –0.63 5.9 VangdTotIntlBd BNDX 49.03 –0.08 3.4
iShMSCIACWI ACWI 91.10 –0.36 7.3 SchwabUS Div SCHD 70.48 –0.89 –6.7 VangdTotIntlStk VXUS 55.62 0.13 7.5 Prime Security Services Borrower PRSESE 5.250 6.08 April 15, ’24 99.250 –0.30 99.751
iShMSCI EAFE EFA 72.96 0.26 11.2 SchwabUS LC SCHX 48.06 –0.70 6.4 VangdTotalStk VTI 202.49 –0.58 5.9
iSh MSCI EM EEM 38.56 –0.16 1.7 SchwabUS LC Grw SCHG 65.08 –0.46 17.1 VangdTotWrldStk VT 91.92 –0.35 6.6 *Estimated spread over 2-year, 3-year, 5-year, 10-year or 30-year hot-run Treasury; 100 basis points=one percentage pt.; change in spread shown is for Z-spread.
iShMSCIEAFEValue EFV 49.44 0.06 7.8 SPDR S&PMdCpTr MDY 447.83 –0.03 1.1 VangdValue VTV 137.47 –0.82 –2.1 Note: Data are for the most active issue of bonds with maturities of two years or more
iShNatlMuniBd MUB 107.35 0.20 1.7 SPDR S&P Div SDY 122.72 –0.34 –1.9 WisdTrFRTrea USFR 50.34 ... 0.1 Source: MarketAxess
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * Thursday, May 4, 2023 | B9
MARKETS
the postmeeting press confer- gart, head of model portfolio Loewengart said with inflation it all the more important to be as Pine-Sol, raised its sales The bills, dated May 9, 2023, mature on Sept. 5, 2023.
seek institutional investors interest rates slow down deal countries, of some foods con-
for the fund, but qualified in- making and damp the appe- sidered healthy. He cited as
dividuals can also invest, the tite for new funds. Those examples nuts, olive oil and
firm said. firms raised $4.24 billion fruits such as avocados
Folium will primarily seek institutional investors for the fund, but qualified individuals can also invest. Investing in the two sectors across 18 natural resources- and blueberries.
HEARD STREET ON
THE
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS & COMMENTARY
So far, the economy isn’t send- tively hit the pause button, raising and steep slides in the shares of cluding the results of the latest keep raising rates. Inflation has
ing any strong signals that the rates by a quarter point but sig- regional banks this week, have in- survey of loan officers, due for re- been cooling, but is far above the
Federal Reserve should stop rais- naling that it will likely stand pat creased the danger that lending lease on Monday—might be seeing 2% the central bank is aiming for.
ing rates. But Wednesday’s rate in- at its meeting next month. In a will be curtailed to the point more restrictions on lending. The job market is still strong.
crease could be the last for a change from the statement re- where the economy slides into a Adding to the risks facing the Indeed, ADP, in its reading on
while. leased after its prior meeting, the recession. economy, Treasury Secretary Janet employment based on its payroll
Fed policy makers raised their Fed’s policy-setting committee re- In another notable change to its Yellen on Monday said the U.S. data, said Wednesday that job
target on overnight rates by a moved language stating that it postmeeting statement, the central government could become unable growth stepped up in April from
quarter percentage point to a “anticipates that some additional bank said tighter credit conditions to pay all its bills as soon as June March, while the Institute for Sup-
range of 5% to 5.25%, the highest policy firming may be appropri- for households and businesses 1 if Congress doesn’t raise the debt ply Management said its April in-
level since the summer of 2007, ate.” were likely to weigh on the econ- limit. The nonpartisan Congressio- dex of service-sector activity rose.
shortly before the financial crisis It instead said it would weigh a omy. After the prior meeting, nal Budget Office echoed that Maybe on the other side of
struck. The central bank’s tighten- variety of factors in assessing shortly after the failures of Silicon warning in its own assessment, es- banking stress and the debt-ceiling
ing campaign has been the swift- whether it should raise rates Valley Bank and Signature Bank in timating that there is a “signifi- fight the economy will prove resil-
est and steepest since the early again. The watering down of this March, it said “recent develop- cantly greater risk that the Trea- ient enough, and inflation en-
1980s, lifting rates from near zero language is a reflection of how ments” would probably tighten sury will run out of funds in early trenched enough, that the Fed will
just over a year ago. fresh signs of stress in the banking credit conditions. So the Fed, June.” decide to raise rates again.
But on Wednesday the Fed—led system, including the closure of which is privy to information on Absent those circumstances, the But we aren’t there yet.
by Chair Jerome Powell—effec- First Republic Bank early Monday banks that investors aren’t—in- Fed would probably be ready to —Justin Lahart
Drug Class
owner Stellantis beat expectations
across the board, but investors
weren’t impressed. They are more
focused on Tesla’s price war in
electric vehicles and the Federal
Reserve’s interest-rate increases, Eli Lilly’s announcement that
which are pushing up consumers’ its experimental drug slowed de-
monthly vehicle payments. clines in Alzheimer’s patients’
Ford reported quarterly ad- ability to perform daily tasks
justed operating profit of $3.4 bil- means there could soon be two
lion after the market closed Tues- drugs available on the market for
day, versus consensus forecasts of people with early stages of the de-
about $2.5 billion. Yet the shares bilitating disease.
slipped in trading on Wednesday. That is great news for patients
That echoed what happened a after billions of dollars and years
week before when GM not only of studies failed to produce a sin-
beat Wall Street’s expectations but gle treatment that could slow the
raised its guidance, only to see its disease’s progression. The results
JEENAH MOON/BLOOMBERG NEWS
stock fall 4%. are good for not only Eli Lilly but
Both companies noted strong also Biogen, whose new drug
pricing, as did Stellantis, which Leqembi won an accelerated ap-
published revenue numbers proval from the Food and Drug
Wednesday. (It follows the French Administration.
practice of reporting profit only While the two trials were very
twice a year.) For now, pent-up different, Eli Lilly’s experimental
needs after two years of vehicle drug donanemab might have
shortages and a strong economy bested Leqembi when it comes to
continue to support consumer de- Ford reported quarterly adjusted operating profit of $3.4 billion Tuesday. Ford Broncos at the 2023 New York Auto Show. efficacy. For a primary group in
mand. Supply is gradually improv- the study of more than 1,700 pa-
ing following the pandemic semi- four-year deal with GM that set But he gave evidence that the Ford’s first-quarter results, its tients, donanemab slowed pa-
conductor crunch, but not fast the pattern for the unionized in- battle isn’t yet spreading to less- first to feature a new segmenta- tients’ cognitive decline by an av-
enough to give buyers the kind of dustry, but only after a strike that established categories of EVs: Ford tion by product line, showed $4 erage of 36% compared with
negotiating power they used to en- cost the company $3.6 billion and increased prices for its F-150 billion in operating profit from people who received a placebo
joy with dealers. about six weeks of production. Lightning by $11,000 since its gas engines alongside a $722 mil- over 18 months of treatment. Bio-
Nobody expects this dynamic to And that was when inflation was launch. For now, the biggest rival lion loss in EVs. gen’s study achieved a 27% reduc-
last forever, but the unwind is subdued. Stellantis’s idling of a Ford faces in electric pickups is Expensive as they are, EVs tion in cognitive decline.
shaping up to be a slow one, and Jeep factory in Belvidere, Ill., even Rivian, whose stock is down about might be a lower near-term risk to Lilly also reported that about
the manufacturers are doing what as it reports very strong U.S. 84% since its initial public offering Detroit earnings than the Fed’s 47% of the patients who received
they can to prolong it. GM cut profit could put it in the due to persistent growing pains. battle with inflation. So far, rising donanemab had no decline 12
pickup truck production in Febru- crosshairs this time. Whomever Another would-be rival, Lords- rates are only hitting profit in months after the start of treat-
ary to keep inventories in check. the UAW picks to negotiate with, a town Motors, warned Monday manufacturers’ vehicle-finance di- ment.
Stellantis’s inventories, at 1.3 strike could be yet another indus- that its key backer, the Taiwanese visions, but they are preparing for That could leave Biogen (and
million vehicles including dealers’ try disruption that keeps vehicle contract manufacturer Foxconn, a broader impact, GM in particu- partner Eisai), which up until this
stock at the end of March, are prices higher for longer. was claiming a breach of contract lar with voluntary buyouts and, point seemingly held a monopoly
ahead of peers. That is a warning As for Tesla’s price cuts, they to withhold promised funds. last weekend, layoffs. Keeping in the field, with a smaller market
flag: If brands such as RAM and are undoubtedly hitting the core There is no room for compla- costs in check is about all they share than Lilly. Both drugs work
Jeep start to discount, it will be of the EV market: This week Ford cency at Ford as GM gears up to can do. by removing the brain’s plaque
hard for Chevrolet and Ford to cut prices again for its Mustang launch its electric Silverado and Investors are right to focus on buildup, known as amyloid, which
hold firm. But Stellantis might Mach-E, which competes with the Tesla its Cybertruck, both due in hazards ahead rather than smooth is seen as closely associated with
have built inventories as part of Model Y. “We could see the over- limited volumes later this year. driving now. Still, the longer the Alzheimer’s.
preparations for a potential strike capacity in the two-row electric Still, the struggles faced by EV good times keep rolling for De- Investors also are more positive
by the United Auto Workers union utility segment years ago,” Ford startups highlight the value of De- troit’s traditional business, the on the Lilly treatment because,
this fall. Chief Executive Jim Farley told troit’s traditional business in sub- better prepared it will be for the unlike Leqembi, it is has a finite
In 2019, the UAW reached a analysts Tuesday. sidizing the new technology. risks. —Stephen Wilmot duration and many patients are
able to stop after taking the drug
for a year.
Yet while this is clearly a win
for Lilly, it isn’t necessarily a loss
Samsung Is a Case Study in How to Leave China for Biogen.
Not everything went in do-
nanemab’s favor. There were three
deaths in the trial, with at least
“Derisking” is the latest buzz- 18,000 by 2021. Samsung closed its Number of Samsung employees droid phones with affordable two attributed to serious side ef-
word describing Western govern- last phone factory there in 2019. in China prices was one major reason. fects such as brain swelling. The
ments’ strategy toward China. Lower labor costs in other On the other hand, Samsung is rate of brain swelling for Lilly’s
60,000
While it sounds less ambitious Asian countries are a big draw. the top-selling brand in India and drug appears to be greater than
than “decoupling,” the basic idea But geopolitics was probably an Southeast Asia—meaning it can that of Leqembi.
is similar: reducing reliance on important factor. In 2016 and 50,000 produce and sell a chunk of its The bottom line, though, is that
China for manufacturing, espe- 2017, Beijing and Seoul became output in the same places. Apple, the Lilly data, in the long term,
cially for key technological goods. embroiled in a diplomatic spat with its high prices and premium are good news for this entire class
40,000
Driven by both geopolitics and over South Korea’s plan to host a focus, could struggle to achieve of drugs.
commercial needs, the trend seems high-tech U.S. missile-defense ra- that, especially in price-conscious After Biogen presented its
likely to pick up further steam: dar system. In an early preview of 30,000 India. study results, experts were still at
Even Apple, the most visible bene- the coercive economic tactics that Another issue for Apple and odds over whether the effects are
ficiary of the “made in China” phe- China employed against a range 20,000 Samsung is that even if the final significant enough to make an ac-
nomenon in the tech space, is of countries in recent years, Bei- assembly of gadgets is moved out tual difference in patients’ lives.
starting to push its suppliers more jing forced the sale of South Ko- of China, manufacturers will still In a piece titled “Tempering Hype
aggressively toward India and rean conglomerate Lotte Group’s 10,000 depend on suppliers there. During and Hope,” medical journal The
other alternatives. But the practi- China supermarket business and the height of the 2020 Covid-19 Lancet argued that a 0.45-point
calities of even a partial move curtailed tourist visits to Korea. 0 outbreak in China, Samsung found difference on an 18-point scale in
away from China-based manufac- One result is that as Apple and itself scrambling to secure sud- the cognitive score of patients
2011 ’15 ’20
turing are daunting. other big manufacturers scope out denly scarce Chinese components. taking Leqembi compared with
Luckily there is at least one Vietnam and India, Samsung is al- Source: the company Chinese suppliers moved rapidly those on placebo “might not be
conspicuous example of a major ready there in spades—which could up the value chain in recent years clinically meaningful.”
high-technology company that suc- add up to a significant competitive to Morgan Stanley. and now make many high-tech Having two drugs show im-
cessfully relocated large parts of advantage given the difficulties of The fact that the world’s largest electronic components too. provement for patients should
its production apparatus: Sam- replicating China’s scale abroad. smartphone maker managed to Samsung’s success in relocating help ultimately unlock Centers for
sung Electronics. Vietnam has a population of around ditch China may offer some com- its phone business is instructive— Medicare and Medicaid Services
Samsung has significant opera- 100 million. But China’s Guangdong fort for other companies looking but it had a first-mover advantage coverage. The CMS made a rare
tions in China, including for its cru- province has over 125 million. Sam- to derisk. But Samsung’s success and a product mix suitable to decision last year not to pay for
cial memory-chip business. But from sung is Vietnam’s largest foreign in- was related to market factors that lower-income Asian nations. Oth- Biogen’s earlier antiamyloid,
a head-count perspective, it has vestor. It accounted for nearly a could be hard for Apple to repli- ers will try to follow in its foot- Aduhelm.
been edging away from China for fifth of the country’s total exports cate. Samsung’s smartphone mar- steps, at least in part. But for Ap- Being outdone by a stronger
years. The company had over 60,000 last year. The company invested big ket share in China was battered in ple and many other top makers, competitor is never a great feel-
employees in China in 2013 accord- in India: The country accounts for the mid-2010s: Strong competition China will loom large in the global ing. But in this case, a rising tide
ing to its 2014 Sustainability Report, about 20% to 30% of Samsung’s from Chinese companies like Xi- supply chain for a long time. will lift all boats.
but that number fell to less than smartphone production, according aomi that make comparable An- —Jacky Wong —David Wainer*