Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com/2018/07/16/compliance-101-
defining-an-internal-control/
MODULE CONTENT
TOPICS:
ASSESSMENT METHOD/S:
https://www.investopedia.com/
https://www.myaccountingcourse.com/accounting-
dictionary/management-control-systems
https://www.marketing91.com/management-control-system/
https://bizfluent.com/facts-6817611-importance-internal-controls-
corporate-governance.html
Learning Objectives:
Management
How can this be done? Well, this in most instances means dealing with different
resources and allocating them to correct roles and purposes. Management
Bachelor of Science Bulacan Date Developed:
Aug 2020
in Accounting Polytechnic Page 3 of 16
Date Revised:
Information Systems College Sept 2020
Governance, Business Developed by:
Ethics, Risk Management, Document No. Ms. Rachael Louise
and Internal Control Revision No.:02
20-GBER 323
(GBER 323) De Guzman, LPT
includes guidance and monitoring of these resources as well. You are
essentially managing how other people perform a specific role and use
resources, instead of doing it yourself. As a manager, you are essentially a
facilitator – if A needs to be done, you find B to do it and provide him the strategy
and the resources to do it.
OK, so that explains the core concept, but what about the functions of
management? You need to identify and understand the key components of
management as well. The first component is the different functions of
management. The definitions can be different depending on the situation, but
generally, five functions are identified as the core functions of management.
These are planning, organizing, staffing, leading, and controlling.
The other key part of management is the resource types it entails. The most
common forms of resourcing include: human resources, financial
resources, technological resources and natural resources. You could use the
above functions to allocate, control and monitor the different forms of resources.
You are combining the functions you have at hand – planning, staffing and so
on – with the resources, such as financial resources. The clearest example is
having the function of staffing and using the human resource funding to hire in
new staff.
SYSTEMS
The key to systems, especially in the case of MSCs, is the structure of which they
are formed and often perform. Every system comes with input, output and
feedback mechanism. The system is able to maintain itself even when the
surroundings are changing and it has a specific set of boundaries within which
is operates. The picture here illustrates the idea of a system in a business context
perfectly.
You have an input, the business system and the output. You also have the
feedback mechanism. The business system would be the strategy the
business uses to create a specific output. If the output is to provide cheap
shoes, the business strategy is manufacturing of the shoes with the specific
elements this entails.
The input, therefore, is the resources (materials, labor, equipment) you need
to achieve the output. So, you take the resources, you implement them with
your chosen strategy, and you get the results. The results then provide
feedback to inputs on the performance of the system. Perhaps you didn’t
receive as many shoes as you wanted and so, you can increase input. For
example, buy more materials, hire more people and so on.
In the case of the example above, your pre-determined result might be to have
1,000 good quality shoes with an individual shoe costing $50 to make. The
feedback might show you that occasionally the cost of shoes rises to $70 and
you know you need to tweak the input or the processes you use, as you’ve
deviated from the wanted results.
Control
Finally, you have the concept of control. As stated above, control is one of the
functions of management. In this context, it refers to the process of analysis
and corrective action. When controlling, you are essentially monitoring
whether you are receiving an expected result of a process (or during it) or if the
outcome deviates from the expectation.
But with the rise of modern technology, control can be used to foreseeing an
error. This has changed the function and made it increasingly important part of
the management process. For example, your shoe production facility might have
monitoring systems that help you realize the shoes are not being finalized as
quickly as they should in order to make 1,000 pairs. You are essentially able to
see that you would encounter a problem; instead of just realizing a problem has
occurred.
The above has hopefully started your mind to process the concept of MCS, as
you are aware of the special meaning and interconnectedness of the specific
concepts that make it. But let’s look a bit closer to what MCSs are and how they
are defined in the modern context.
One of the first definitions of MCSs is from 1972 when Ernest Anthony Lowe,
professor at the University of Sheffield, published an article called On the Idea
of a Management Control System. According to Anthony Lowe, an
organization would need to establish a specific system to control and plan
the different operations it is going through. He identified four reasons for
the necessity of the systematic management control:
Anthony Lowe also described in his book how management control systems are
the processes “by which managers ensure that resources are obtained and
used effectively and efficiently in the accomplishment of the organization’s
objectives“.
So, what can you actually do with such as system? It essentially allows you to
perform the following functions:
Management control systems are the formal and informal structures put
in place by a business that compare the goals and strategy of the
organization against the actual outcomes. In other words, it measure
how well the functions of a business and the business as a whole
perform and meet objectives. This comparison is then reviewed and used
to drive managerial decisions.
Most businesses that successfully use MCS use both financial and
nonfinancial measures. While it makes sense to use financial measures since
the data is usually readily available and most businesses are very conscious
about dollars and cents, it is important not to discount nonfinancial measures.
Nonfinancial measures significantly impact businesses of all types and must be
monitored.
Leah should track employee turnover. By using this control system, she will
know if more employees are leaving than usual and can look into why this might
be happening.
Remember, it is important to align the goals of MCS and operational goals of the
organization so that both of them can complement each other. Moreover, in case
of differences, the management control system will end up being worthless and
ineffective.
It can be done by dividing the responsibilities as per the new framework so that
the control becomes more focused on the new system
The reward structure is a part of MCS, and it can be done by tying the rewards
with the achievement of goals. It includes monetary reward like raise, bonus
or material reward like access to the health club, pass for food court, or a
voucher that you can reimburse.
Internal controls are the practical aspects of corporate governance. They are the
policies and procedures that a firm uses to ensure compliance with its own moral
code. The goals of internal corporate governance controls typically include:
Promoting efficiency. Internal controls can take time, which has the
potential to lower efficiency. Internal controls can also prevent mistakes,
though, which improves efficiency in the long run.
Of course, even the best internal control activities can’t prevent every mistake.
An effective internal control framework will minimize errors, though.
Money and information have a clear path through a company with good internal
controls, and that path can be easily retraced. This allows shareholders to feel
confident about their investments and customers to feel confident about any
goods or services they’ve purchased. Companies can show proof of good
corporate governance.
Internal audits may take place on a daily, weekly, monthly, or annual basis.
Some departments may be audited more frequently than others. For example, a
manufacturing process may be audited on a daily basis for quality control, while
the human resources department might only be audited once a year. Audits may
be scheduled, to give managers time to gather and prepare the required
documents and information, or they may be a surprise, especially if unethical or
illegal activity is suspected.
1. Assessment Techniques
Assessment techniques ensure an internal auditor gathers a full understanding
of the internal control procedures and whether employees are complying with
internal control directives. To avoid disrupting the daily workflow, auditors begin
with indirect assessment techniques, such as reviewing flowcharts, manuals,
departmental control policies or other existing documentation. If documented
procedures are not being followed, direct discussion with department staff may
be necessary.
2. Analysis Techniques
Auditing fieldwork procedures can include transaction matching, physical
inventory count, audit trail calculations, and account reconciliation as is
required by law. Analysis techniques may test random data or target specific
data, if an auditor believes an internal control process needs to be improved.
3. Reporting Procedures
KEY TAKEAWAYS:
✓ An internal audit offers risk management and evaluates the
effectiveness of a company’s internal controls, corporate governance,
and accounting processes.
✓ Internal audits provide management and board of directors with a
value-added service where flaws in a process may be caught and
corrected prior to external audits.
Internal controls have become a key business function for every U.S. company
since the accounting scandals in the early 2000s. In their wake, the Sarbanes-
Oxley Act of 2002 was enacted to protect investors from fraudulent accounting
activities and improve the accuracy and reliability of corporate disclosures. This
Importance to Auditors
Operational Efficiency
No two systems of internal controls are identical, but many core philosophies
regarding financial integrity and accounting practices have become standard
management practices. While internal controls can be expensive, properly
implemented internal controls can help streamline operations and increase
operational efficiency, in addition to preventing fraud.
KEY TAKEAWAYS:
✓ Internal controls are the mechanisms, rules, and procedures
implemented by a company to ensure the integrity of financial and
accounting information, promote accountability and prevent fraud.
✓ Besides complying with laws and regulations, and preventing employees
from stealing assets or committing fraud, internal controls can help
improve operational efficiency by improving the accuracy and timeliness
of financial reporting.
✓ Internal audits play a critical role in a company’s internal controls
and corporate governance now that the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 has
made managers legally responsible for the accuracy of its financial
statements.