Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MOI UNIVERSITY
Tel: (053) 43001-8 P.O Box 3900
(053) 43620 ELDORET
Fax: (053) 43047
KENYA
THE SCHOOL OF ARTS AND SOCIAL SCIENCES
COURSE OUTLINE
SAS 401: POLICY ANALYSIS AND PROJECT
MANAGEMENT
COURSE INSTRUCTOR: Mr. Daniel Simotwo
TOPIC ONE
Introduction To Project Management
Meaning Of Terms
Characteristics of a Project
What is Project Management
What is Management
Types Of Projects
Importance Of Project Management
TOPIC TWO
Principles & Theories Of Project Management
Theory Of Management
Role Of The Community In Project Management
The Role Of A Project Manager
TOPIC FOUR
Stakeholder Analysis
Tools for stakeholder analysis
Stakeholder analysis matrix
SWOT analysis
Venn diagrams
Spider diagram
Problem Analysis
Analysis of Objectives
Analysis of Strategies
TOPIC FIVE
Development of the Project Layout
Steps in Developing a Logframe Matrix
Interrelationships within the Logframe matrix
Activity Scheduling
Resource Scheduling
Steps in Resource Scheduling
TOPIC SEVEN
Project Evaluation
Types Of Evaluations
Steps In Evaluation
Tools In Evaluation
Project Appraisal
Tools And Techniques In Appraisal
TOPIC EIGHT
Project Report Writing
Why Report Writing
Factors To Consider In Report Writing
Types Of Project Reports
Format Of A Project Report
TOPIC NINE
Community Participation
Types Of Participation
Decision Making / Problem Solving
Community Participation In Needs Assessment
Project Sustainability
Why Project Sustainability
Project Sustainability Options
Assessment
Students shall be assessed twice. We shall have one Sit in Continuous Assessment Test and
One term paper. Each shall carry the following weight.
Policy analysis is "determining which of various policies will most achieve a given
set of goals in light of the relations between the policies and the goals". However,
policy analysis can be divided into two major fields.
The area of interest and the purpose of analysis determine what type of analysis is to
be conducted. A combination of policy analysis together with program evaluation
would be defined as Policy studies.
Policy Analysis is frequently deployed in the public sector, but is equally applicable
to other kinds of organizations. Policy analysis has its roots in systems analysis as
instituted by United States Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara during the Vietnam
War. (stopped here for Main group)
Planning (also called forethought) is the process of thinking about and organizing
the activities required to achieve a desired goal. It involves the creation and
maintenance of a plan, such as psychological aspects that require conceptual skills.
There are even a couple of tests to measure someones capability of planning well.
As such, planning is a fundamental property of intelligent behavior.
Also, planning has a specific process and is necessary for multiple occupations
(particularly in fields such as management, business, etc.). In each field there are
different types of plans that help companies achieve efficiency and effectiveness. An
important, albeit often ignored aspect of planning, is the relationship it holds to
forecasting. Forecasting can be described as predicting what the future will look like,
whereas planning predicts what the future should look like for multiple scenarios.
Planning combines forecasting with preparation of scenarios and how to react to
them.
1.1.1 Project
A project can usually be specified as a series of activities leading to a clearly
defined objective (target) which cannot be achieved by normal day to day
activities (FINNIDA, 1991). It has specified objectives, time and resource
frames, and project organization responsible for the achievement of the
objectives.
1.1.2 Programme
Whereas a project is specific, a programme is general. A project is only a part
of a larger development programme of a country/organization. Besides a
particular project there are usually several other ongoing projects in the same
field (FINNIDA, 1991). According to EU (2004), a programme is a package of
projects.
1.1.3.3 Transformatory
The trigger for a project is an existing negative situation, whereas the target of
a project is the desired positive situation. A project is the intervention used to
move beneficiaries from the current negative situation to the future desired
positive situation. Hence a project is a tool of transformation in the livelihood
of the beneficiaries. (KPA group begin here next)
1.1.4 Management
Plunket (1994) defines management as the setting and attainment of
organizational goals/objectives through the five functions that acquire and
utilize effectively; human, financial, material, time and informational
According to Locke (2003); there are four main typologies of projects based on
where they are carried out from and the kind of output. These are: industrial
projects, manufacturing projects, management projects and Research projects.
1. Engineering Projects
This should involve all the projects that are of industrial and manufacturing in
nature.
2. Business Projects
This category would include projects that are aimed at service /Product
output with the core interest of profit making.
3. Academic Projects
In this category we would include projects for research aimed at knowledge
expansion. Examples would include dissertations and theses.
Each of the two has a set of principles which can be viewed collectively as
comprising a theory. Thus we have the theory of management and the theory
of project accruing to processes of category 1 and 2 respectively.
1.5.1Theory of Management
Management has been defined as the setting and attainment of organizational
goals/objectives through the five basic functions that acquire and utilize
effectively: human; financial, material, time and informational resources. It
has also been aforementioned that project management process includes
initiating, planning, execution, controlling and closing a project.
Koskela (2002) deduces that management can be mirrored into three core
principles of planning, execution and controlling. The three forms a closed
loop, that is planning provide a plan which is realized through executing.
Planning
Changes Plans
Controlling
Executing
Corrections
1.5.2.1Theory of Project
The conceptualization of the theory of project starts from the understanding
that project management is about managing work. Turner (1993) put forward
the following assumptions/principles about project management:
i. Project management is about managing work.
ii. In managing work the total work must be decomposed. That is it
should be subdivided into smaller chunks which he refers to as
tasks/activities.
iii. Decomposition of work is aimed at achieving three purposes:
a. Ensuring adequate/sufficient amount of work is done
b. Ensuring that unnecessary work is not done
c. Ensuring that any work done is aimed at achieving/delivering
the stated business/project purpose or objective.
iv. Decomposition and execution of the total project work proceeds with
tasks/activities that are related if at all by sequential dependence. This
relates to undertaking critical path analysis/network analysis.
The four comprises the scope of project management and is outlined in the
Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) and it is the raison detre of project
management.
Programming
Identification
Formulation
Evaluation
Implementation
Thus PCM can be seen as an aid on how to handle the project cycle. It focuses
on what to be done, various methods and outputs expected after
accomplishing the various phases/stages of the project cycle. In modern
project management; successful PCM relies on Logical Framework Approach
(LFA). LFA is an analytical process and a set of tools that help in project
planning and management (EU, 2004).
Manilla paper could be cut in different sizes of chapati like figures. Members
are then asked to give/award them to identified institutions on the basis of
their perceived importance (the greater the importance, the bigger the
chapati). The community is then asked to arrange them close to each other
and within a frame. This helps to depict their relationship to each other as
well as how remotely placed the institution is within the community. Thus
institutions with close relationship are placed next to/overlapped with one
another; institutions that are remote are placed far away from the centre of the
frame (community). This exercise yields a Venn diagram as below.
D
A
E
F
C G
H
Unit Facilitator : Moses Mutua Mutiso 22
Sociology and Psychology Department Moi University
Policy Analysis and Project Management
Client focus
Personnel management
3 2 1 0
Policy and
Financial management planning system
a. All the causes are put below/under the core problem of effects
}
Below the problem
them at the same level in the problem tree. Thus a problem tree will
be as illustrated below.
An illustration of a problem
tree
}
Unit Facilitator : Moses Mutua Mutiso
2 Level24
hierarchy
nd
of causes
Sociology and Psychology Department Moi University
Policy Analysis and Project Management
Simulation of a problem tree for cattle infested with tsetse flies area
Low income
In reference to the problem tree under problem analysis, the objective tree
would appear as below:
Simulation of an objective tree for cattle infested with tsetse flies area
Increased income
The set of criteria selected, can be used to asses various strategies by use of a
strategy/opportunity assessment matrix.
Overall objective 1 8 9
Purpose
2 1 1 7
0 1
0
Results 3 1 1 6
2 3
Activities 4 5
Means of verification are sources from which one can be able to find
information about the indicators of achievement. In the logframe matrix, one
reads across the matrix (column 2 and 3) when analyzing indicators and
means of verification, hence it is referred to as the horizontal logic.
Overall Objective
Purpose +
+ Assumptions
Results
+
+ Assumptions
Activities +
+ Assumptions
Inputs
From the various results established, as per the logframe, activities are
identified which must be undertaken to achieve the results. Such activities are
then arranged by use of an activity schedule. Depending on the magnitude of
the project, how long it will take to commence the implementation of the
project or any other reason; the details of the activity schedule may differ.
Year 1 Year 2
Ref. Results and Responsibility Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
No. Indicative Activities
1.0 Result 1
1.1 Indicative activity 1
1.2 Indicative activity 2
1.3 Indicative activity 3
2.0 Result 2
2.1 Indicative activity 1
2.2 Indicative activity 2
Notes:
Columns 1 (Ref. No.) and 2 (Results and indicative Activities) Each result
identified that needs to be produced so as to attain the purpose of the project
9. Schedule costs
Here costs per planning period are established. The cost per unit as
established under (6) above is multiplied by the quantity required to complete
the task. This is done on the basis of quarters of the year. Thus costs per
quarter are established.
10. calculate the total activities costs
This is arrived at by summing up all quarterly costs to arrive to an annual cost
value/amount. A sum of annual costs will give total project cost in respect to
activities only.
11. Estimate Recurrent costs
Recurrent cost is a monetary value of resources that will be required to
manage the project on a periodic basis e.g. salaries for project management
team.
6. Assign Responsibility
Indicate / spell out who will be responsible for collecting what information
about what indicator of activity.
c) Resource Schedules
In formulation stage/phase as well as at the start of implementation,
costs/resources for various activities are outlined. These are vital reference
documents when carrying out activities so as to establish if the project is on
track.
5. Identify indicators
2. Resource schedule
During formulation, the project management team already established
required resources / budget for implementation. This is a crucial guide when
checking the efficiency of the project.
5. Terms of reference
This is a set of tasks that a contractor in an evaluation is required to attain.
They stipulate the reason(s) why a contractor for an evaluation was hired,
how long s/he is expected to take to accomplish the tasks, what resources are
to be used in the evaluation etc.
PROJECT APPRAISAL
An appraisal is an analysis of a proposed project to determine its merit and
acceptability to the stakeholders. The reason for appraisal is to revise the plans
and justify the decisions on whether or not to undertake the project. This is
done against a set of criteria/factors that ought to be met or fulfilled. Project
appraisal is desirable during identification and formulation stages of the
project cycle. FINNIDA (1991) defines appraisal as an overall assessment of
the relevance, feasibility and sustainability of a project prior to its
implementation.
Relevance:
A project is relevant if it meets demonstrated and high priority needs of the
community. Thus while doing a project appraisal, it is important to find out if
the project:
Is consistent with and supportive of governmental/donor policies and
or developmental priorities.
Has identified key stakeholders and related issues like equity,
institutional capacity, local ownership etc have been analyzed.
Has appropriately analyzed problems of the community.
Has incorporated lessons learnt from experience and collaborated with
ongoing/planned projects.
Feasibility:
A project is feasible if it is well designed and likely to deliver tangible and
sustainable benefits to target group(s). While undertaking appraisal, it is vital
to find out if the project:
Has clear and logical objectives which address clearly identified
needs.
Costs in terms of the resources/inputs are clearly stipulated and that
the project benefits outweigh costs.
Has clear management arrangement in terms of project personnel as
well as supports institutional strengthening and local ownership.
Has clearly identified and acceptable assumptions/risks.
Is likely to be environmentally, technically and socially acceptable
and sustainable.
4. Surveys
This is a research design which can be used to collect data on the issues of
appraisal (relevance, feasibility and good management) of the project.
d) Consistency
1. Inception Reports
This should be produced within the first months of the launch of the project
for example three months. This type of a report helps project managers to
review the design of the project in consultation with stakeholders, update the
first annual work plans. This is vital especially in cases where much of the
design of the project (identification and formulation phases) was undertaken
by people different from those implementing or when there has been a long
time lapse between design and commencement of implementation.
2. Progress Reports
These are reports that shall be produced periodically during the
implementation phase of the project. The interval of their production
normally id agreed upon or stipulated by the stakeholders and may be for on
the basis of for example quarterly, biannually or annually.
3. Completion Reports
These are prepared at the end of the financing period. It comments and
documents on the overall achievements against the original plan, prospects
foe sustainability of benefits, lessons learned as well as recommendations for
follow up actions required.
COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION
TYPES OF PARTICIPATION
According to Mulwa (2008), participation can be classified into two main
groups: passive and active participation.
Extractionist Participation
Normally used by governments where they draw development plans in the
exclusion of their offices and far away from the citizens. They then hand the
blue prints to extensionists in respective ministries for implementation.
Citizens are then required to contribute money or labour as part of
participation to meet the cost of the activities in the budget. This is famously
referred to as cost sharing.
Vertical Participation
1. Problem Identification
Find out what is the problem. What causes it (differentiate symptoms from
causes). Try to define the scope of the problem (how intense it is and whom
does it affect).
The foregoing problem solving model quite resembles the project cycle
management model. Thus it becomes quite imperative that the community
should be at the centre in making choices at each phase of the project planning
and management.
That is; they should be ones to decide what their problem is (most felt), its
scope, how they can solve it, cost each method of solving it, picking the best
way/method to solve it, executing that method as well as evaluating if/not
the implemented decision was as planned and has helped solve their problem.
PROJECT SUSTAINABILITY
Project productivity
The project should be able to produce results which when utilized meets the
most felt need(s) of the community. If the community members do not see or
perceive any goods /services from the project, then such a project s
sustainability is compromised.
Equitability
The results / benefits of the project should reach each and every member of
the project or at least there should be representation of the wider community
who are seen to benefit equally from the project. Thus, there should be no
form of segregation in respect to who should benefit from the project
whether of colour, sex, age, status etc.
Cost
A sustainable project is one whose cost is affordable by the community
members. As such emphasis should be on ensuring that community members
actually contribute or use locally available resources to run the project.
Technical Feasibility
The technology that is used in the project should be one that is familiar to the
community members. Where this is not the case, community members /
selected few should be trained as Trainers of Trainers (TOTs) so as to make
the technology more familiar in the community. More appropriately, the
project managers can promote the use of Indigenous Technical Knowledge
which is more familiar with the community they are working with.
Socio-cultural acceptability
The project should be respectful and considerate of the community s beliefs,
norms, religion etc. Any project activity that undermines a community s socio-
cultural orientation will be met with a lot of resistance and the chance of its
sustainability is quite small. The case of anti Female Genital Mutilation (FGM)
projects in communities of Rift Valley are a living testimony. Thus it is
imperative to involve an education component to the community before you
begin a project that is likely to brush shoulders with a community s socio-
cultural system.
Participation