Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The effects of a soft tissue mobilization procedure, the Rolfing pelvic lift, on
parasympathetic tone was studied in healthy adult men. Parasympathetic tone
was assessed 1) by quantifying the amplitude of the respiratory sinus arrhythmia
from the heart rate pattern and 2) by measuring heart rate. Heart rate patterns
were assessed during the pelvic lift and during the durational touch and baseline
control conditions. Two groups of healthy subjects were tested: Group 1 con-
tained 20 subjects aged 26 to 41 years, and Group 2 contained 10 subjects aged
55 to 66 years. In Group 1, the pelvic lift elicited a somatovisceral-parasympathetic
reflex characterized by a significant increase in parasympathetic tone relative to
durational touch and baseline conditions. Group 2 did not exhibit a parasympa-
thetic change during the pelvic lift. The results of this study contribute to our
understanding of pelvic mobilization techniques and may help to explain why
these techniques have been clinically successful in treating myofascial pain
syndromes and other musculoskeletal dysfunctions characterized by reduced
parasympathetic tone and excessive sympathetic activity.
Key Words: Autonomic nervous system; Cardiac, general; Manual therapy; Physical
therapy.
Mobilization of the bony pelvis and and medical literature of the last two have been associated with an increase in
the surrounding soft tissues has been decades.5-7 Advocates of these tech- parasympathetic nervous system (PNS)
used in medical practice since the begin- niques have recommended pelvic .mo- tone and a corresponding decrease in
ning of recorded history. Ancient bilization for various clinical problems sympathetic nervous system (SNS) ac-
Chinese, Egyptian, and Greek medical that involve autonomic nervous system tivity.“,”
accounts all describe pelvic manipula- (ANS) dysfunctions. Pelvic lift also is comparable to the
tions and associated changes in breath- Scientific evaluation of soft tissue ma- facilitated pelvic tilt exercise described
ing, arterial pulse, body temperature, nipulative treatments is difficult because in the physical therapy and occupational
and muscle tone.’ Several schools of of the scarcity of experimental studies, therapy literature.12,13 The pelvic tilt
manual therapy, including chiropractic, the difficulty in quantifying treatment originally was devised by Paul Williams
osteopathic, and Rolfmg, have rediscov- outcomes, and the speculative nature of as part of a series of back exercises.13
ered and further developed these mobi- the neurophysiological mechanisms of The facilitated pelvic tilt and related
lization practices in the United States in ANS action.8.9 Homogeneous subject pelvic mobilization techniques, how-
the last century.24 A resurgence of in- samples undergoing standardized treat- ever, currently are used with adults, chil-
terest in soft tissue manipulative tech- ment procedures must be examined to dren, and infants in various therapeutic
niques is evident in the physical therapy establish the ANS responses associated contexts: 1) to activate selected thoracic
with a given manipulation. Such infor- and abdominal breathing pattems,l.14 2)
mation will allow more appropriate se- to inhibit hyperactive behaviors,‘.‘4 3) to
J. Cottingham, MS, is Certified Advanced Rolf-
ing Practitioner, Staff Manual Therapist. and Re- lection of manual therapy for specific inhibit shoulder elevation and retrac-
search Associate, Frances Nelson Health Center, conditions. tion,‘4-‘7 4) to reduce hyperextensive
1306 Carver Dr, Champaign, IL 6 I820 (USA). This study examined the pelvic lift
S. Porges, PhD, is Director, Developmental As-
neck and back patterns,6.7.‘5-‘7 and 5) to
sessment Laboratory, and Professor, Department of mobilization procedure and associated reduce chronic soft tissue pain associ-
Human Development, College ,of Education, Uni- changes in ANS tone. Pelvic lift is a soft ated with excessive SNS activity.‘.‘4.16.”
versity of Maryland at College Park, College Park,
MD 20742.
tissue manipulation from the Rolfing The posterior pelvic tilt has been dem-
T. Lyon, MD, is Medical Director, Frances Nel- method of manual therapy and move- onstrated to reduce electromyographic
son Health Center. and Associate Instructor of ment education. It involves a combina- activity in the lumbosacral regions of
Family Practice Medicine. College of Medicine,
University of Illinois, 190 Medical Science Bldg. tion of posterior tilting and pelvic trac- healthy young adults when compared
506 S Mathews Ave. Urbana, IL 6 I80 I. tion with concurrent moderate pressure with anterior pelvic tilt and baseline
This research was supported III part by a basic
research grant from the Rolf Institute to the Frances
to the epigastrium.4.‘0 Lumbosacral de- measurements.”
Nelson Health Center. compression, a similar technique, is in- The results of experimental investi-
Thrs article HIS submrrted Janum IT. 1987: was volved in osteopathic manipulative gations of ANS reflexes and tactile stim-
w/h rhr aurhors for WY,S,O~ ./UIII wck.c. ond wm
accrpred June 22, 1987. Poreurml Cor1/71cr of Inrrr- techniques.” Both the pelvic lift and the ulation also ,support the clinical obser-
es,. 4. lumbosacral decompression maneuvers vations that pelvic mobilization appears
Fig. 1. Electrocardiogram exhibiting respiratory sinus arrhythmia. Heart rate increases rhythmically at inspiration and decreases at expiration.
5.0
We assessed the dependent variables
of vagal tone and heart rate during se- y 5.6
quential 30-second periods within each z
I- 5.4
three-minute condition. Heart rate in
2
beats per minute was calculated as twice z 5.2
the number of interbeat intervals within 5.0
each 30-second period. We calculated
the vagal tone index by extracting the 4.0
amplitude of RSA from the beat-to-beat 4.6
pattern. This procedure necessitated the
following steps: I) conducting a time- 4.4
series analysis. 2) applying a moving 4.2
polynomial filtering procedure that re- BASELINE PELVIC DUTUI;lU~AL
moves the heart rate vanability associ- LIFT
ated with baseline trends and periodic Fig. 2. Mean vagal tone (with associated standard error In parentheses) as a functton of the
activity slower than respiration. 3) band- treatment condttrons for Group 1 (young men) and Group 2 (older’men).
Simple-efkcts /)o\! /20(, tests of univar- the level of PNS tone. The increased sive increase In rigidity of the aorta and
late ANOVAs for Groups 1 and 2 dcm- vagal tone during the pelvic lift returned peripheral arteries. and reduced ANS
onstrated that only Group 1 exhibited to the initial baseline level upon cessa- conditionability.‘” The older subject
significant differences among the five tion of the maneuver. indicating that group may have exhibited reduced sen-
treatment conditions (F = 12.5: df = the elicited response did not persist after sitivity in receptor response to the tactile
4,64; p < .OOOS). Examination of the removal of the stimulus. This finding stimuli provided by the pelvic hft.‘3,‘8
treatment means and standard errors in supports the initial hypothesis that a Another possible explanation, sup-
Group I clearly indicated that this sig- somatovisceral-PNS reflex would be ported by the significantly lower levels
nilicant var-iance was related solcl) t o elicited bq the pelvic lift.“ of Lagal tone found in Group 7 than in
the increase in vagal tone during the The study results also demonstrate Group I, is that aging is associated with
pelvic lift (Fig. 2). The control treatment that vagal tone is a more sensitive ANS a general reduction in brain stem car-
of durational touch did not significantly index for assessing pelvic lift than heart diac vagal o utflo w, which limits the so-
influence vagal tone. A significant group rate. This finding may be due to the matovisceral-PNS response to the pelvic
effect (F = 8.4; df = 1,23; p < .Ol) specificity of the vagal tone asiessment. lift.26.*‘.32
indicated that the young subjects in Vagal tone was defined as the compo- What aspects of the pelvic lift account
Group 1 had a higher overall vagal tone nent of the heart rate variability that is for its somatovisceral-PNS conse-
than the older subjects in Group 2. associated with respiration’s phasic quences? The pelvic lift has two distinct
Heart rate as a dependent variable was modulation of the vagal cardioinhibi- mechanical components: I) moderate
not sensitive to the manipulations (Fig. tory efferents (ie, RSA amplitude).2R-‘2 sustained pressure to the epigastrium
3). A significant group effect (F = 7.7; Heart rate, in contrast, is a more global and 2) firm posterior tilting and traction
df = 1,23; p < .05) demonstrated that ANS index of heart rate variability that to the pelvis. Experimental studies on
the young subjects in Group 1 had a involves PNS and several other (eg, ANS reflexes have demonstrated that
lower heart rate than the older subjects SNS, intrinsic, and mechanical) com- both deep pressure to the abdominal
in Group 2. The order of manipulation ponents.‘2 region and tactile stimulation to the
did not significantly influence the two In the older age group, the pelvic lift back and sacral nerve roots produce
dependent variables. did not elicit an ANS response. This PNS cardiovascular reflexes and altera-
finding is supported by studies on aging tions in respiratory pattems.‘4.‘s-20 Both
and ANS activity. Elderly subjects have mechanical components of the pelvic
DISCUSSION shown more difficulty than younger lift, therefore, probably contribute to the
subjects in responding to changes in am- somatovisceral-PNS response. Addi-
To our knowledge, this study repre- bient room temperature and in recover- tional experimental investigation is
sents the first attempt to quantify the ing resting pulse rate and respiratory needed to evaluate the relative impor-
effects of a soft tissue mobilization pro- volume after displacement by exercise.23 tance of the two mechanical elements
cedure on ANS function (ie , cardiac va- Subjects over 60 years of age also have and whether they act synergically to
gal tone) under controlled conditions. exhibited less predictability in the ANS elicit the observed somatovisceral-PNS
The data clearly demonstrate that the reflexes that control heart rate, pupil reflex.
Rolfing pelvic lift produces an increase size, and gastrointestinal tract.23 Other Although we conducted this study on
in cardiac vagal tone in young, healthy research has demonstrated that the ag- healthy adults. the results have possible
male subjects. Neither durational touch ing process is associated with less su- clinical implications. Our finding that
nor the baseline conditions influenced domotor activity (ie, sweating), progres- the older subjects did not exhibit a va-
gotonic reflex response to the pelvic lift
86 implies that elderly clinical populations
may not be as responsive to soft tissue
84
m Group 1 mobilization as younger populations.
a2 r-J Croup 2 The assessment of a patient’s PNS tone
80
to a given soft tissue procedure may
181 ,:2-91 x=71 provide a useful criterion for determin-
-
78 12-4) ing the appropriateness of manual ther-
apy.
Another clinical implication of this
study pertains to the finding that in the
younger subjects. pelvic lift produced a
transient increase in PNS tone, suggest-
ing a relaxed. nurturing physiological
68 6 state. This finding contrasts with the
b
66 // heightened arousal and “fight-flight” ac-
tivity associated with increased SNS
64
tone.” ‘” Furthermore. ASS investiga-
62 tions by Gellhorn have demonstrated a
60 - - - general law, of reciprocit!: When one
BASELINE PELVIC BASELINE DURATIO NAL BASELINE ANS division is excited. the other divi-
LIFT TO UC H sion is inhibited to maximize the re-
Fig . 3. Me a n he a rt ra te (with associated standard error in parentheses) as a function of the sponse of the stimulated branch.‘” The
treatment conditions for Group 1 (young men) and Group 2 (older men). increased PNS tone elicited by the pelvic