Professional Documents
Culture Documents
research-article2016
FASXXX10.1177/1938640016669794Foot & Ankle SpecialistFoot & Ankle Specialist
〈 Review
〉
The 3-Step Pyramid Insole
Treatment Concept for
David Pomarino, MSc, Juliana Ramírez-
Llamas, MSc, Stephan Martin, MD, and
Andrea Pomarino, MD
“
pyramid insole treatment concept for therapeutic techniques;
children with ITW. Methods. Fifty- forefoot; toe; midfoot;
four articles in English, German, and toe walking .. . differentiating the clinical signs
Spanish were reviewed. There were
comparative, retrospective or case will help understand the adequate
I
studies, classifications or literature diopathic toe walking
reviews and they were divided (ITW) or habitual toe treatment approach in between the
according with these categories. All walking is a medical
the literature reviewed was published condition in which
different modalities that are currently
between 2000 and 2015. Results. There
are some studies that proved the 3-step
children are able to available.”
support their heel on the
pyramid insole treatment concept as ground on request;
an effective option compared with other however, the gait is characterized by a combination with botulinum toxin type
therapeutic modalities such as physical support on their forefoot during the A5,7-10; there are surgical procedures that
therapy, casting, botolinum toxin type 1,2
double support phase. ITW is diagnosed aim to lengthen the Achilles tendon11,12
A (BTX), and surgery. Conclusion. in the absence of a developmental, and physical therapy along with other
There is a wide spectrum regarding neurological, or neuromuscular condition conservative treatments.9,13,14 Ceasing of
3-5
the therapeutic options for children known to cause toe walking. this idiopathic gait pathology is not
with ITW, from physical therapy to The cause of ITW is unknown. There always accomplished by these
surgery options. However, any of these are studies that attribute this to a family approaches.
DOI: 10.1177/1938640016669794. From the Praxis Pomarino, Hamburg, Germany (DP, JR, AP); and Department for Pediatric and Neuro-orthopaedics, Hannover Medical
School, Hannover, Germany (SM). Address correspondence to Juliana Ramírez-Llamas, MSc, Praxis Pomarino, Rahlstedter Bahnhofstrasse 9, 22359, Hamburg, Germany;
e-mail: julir83_ramirez@yahoo.com.
For reprints and permissions queries, please visit SAGE’s Web site at http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav.
Copyright © 2016 The Author(s)
Table 1.
Idiopathic Toe Walking Literature.
solution for children with ITW using the the children with ITW type I and 95% of to be treated with insoles, physical
3-step pyramid insole treatment concept the children with ITW type II had their therapy, and night splints (step 2) and
and comparing this approach with other ITW resolved in less than 1 year. about 80% of the children can be treated
therapeutic modalities. Children who were 5 years of age or only with insoles and physical therapy
In a first retrospective study, ITW younger when they started the treatment (15%) (step 1). About 13% of the
patterns were classified. Three different developed a plantigrade gait within the children drop out from this treatment
types were identified allowing treatment first year of treatment; while children modality (Figure 3).
with the pyramid insole concept.15 The older than 5 years needed about 2 years In another study, Bernhard et al17
data of 555 children were compiled and of treatment to develop a gait pattern in compared different conservative and
analyzed. The children were divided into which the heel is in contact with the invasive treatment option for children
3 types according to the clinical signs. A ground during walking. According to the with ITW. The therapeutic treatment
total of 311 children were type I, 222 parents, children walked about 80% of options compared were physical therapy,
children were type II, and 22 children the time with a plantigrade gait pattern splints, insoles as conservative
were type III. They were treated at the end of treatment. treatments, and BTX injections and
according to the 3-step pyramid insole It was concluded that for children with surgery as invasive options.
treatment concept. ITW who need treatment, about 2% In the study by Bernhard et al,17 the
According to Pomarino, the gait needed to be treated with BTX, insoles, main objectives of physical therapy for
pathology resolves spontaneously in physical therapy, and night splints (step children with ITW, are to obtain
about 15% of the children. About 90% of 3); about 5% of the ITW children needed stability of the trunk muscles, and to
Table 2.
Literature Selected for Review.
forefoot, the calf was heart shaped, number of sessions needed to achieve a concept has proven to be an efficient
presented wrinkles on the skin over the positive effect or ceasing of the treatment for children with ITW. The
Achilles tendon area, and had a lumbar tiptoe gait. combination of physical therapy and
lordosis of 40°. The ankle range of In the case of casting, there are a insoles, and in some cases the night
motion was 5°/0°/50° and the mother variety of methods that are used in every splints, has shown to be effective and
reported that the child walked on the study (below or above the knee). The does not have general risks or
forefoot about 70% of the time. After main idea of wearing a cast is to contraindications. According to Bernhard
analyzing the gait pattern and lengthen the calf muscles. However, it is these insoles have shown an
electromyogram, it was found that the hard to walk with the cast; therefore, it is improvement of gait in 70% of the
heel support was present only during the hard to help the child to adopt a subjects studied. According to Pomarino
first steps and was absent during the different walking pattern. Serial casting and Bernhard,39 about 64.5% of the
following steps. Most of the weight was has shown a reduction of the resistance children react positively to the pyramid
supported on the forefoot. Also there to passive dorsiflexion and a stretching insole treatment, in about 26.5% of the
was elevated activity of the anterior tibial effect on the gastrocnemius muscle.22 children the insoles do not have any
muscle. Other studies have shown that the effect therapeutic effect, and about 9.6% of the
After undergoing the 3-step pyramid is not lasting so that the long-term children refuse to use the insoles.
insole treatment concept for 10 weeks success from this treatment technique is Anecdotal references have
and receiving physical therapy, the ankle controversial.5 The samples in these demonstrated an improvement when gait
range of motion increased to 10°/0°/50°. studies were rather small. is analyzed.45 Before treatment the child
The mother reported that the child Pähr Engström46 compared 2 groups of supported the heel just during the first
reduced toe walking; the insoles showed ITW patients that received treatment with step of ambulation, but for the
that there was weight support on the BTX. One group received BTX plus subsequent steps the forefoot received
heel and the electromyogram showed a casting and the other group was treated the whole weight during walking. It was
decrease on the anterior tibial muscle only with BTX. The conclusion of this found that after 10 weeks of treatment a
activity. During gait analysis, it was study was that adding a treatment with child exhibited a different gait pattern in
observed that the heel received some BTX prior to casting does not improve which it consistently supported the heels
weight during the stance phase. the outcome. on the ground while walking.
There have been some studies in which In a retrospective study, Pomarino
BTX is injected in the calf muscles and et al16 observed and treated 700 children
Discussion the treatment was combined with with the pyramid insole concept. In the
Presently, there is a wide spectrum of bracing or with bracing and physical study, the activity of the anterior tibial
possibilities for the treatment of ITW, therapy. This option seems to be muscle was found to be markedly
ranging from different conservative effective; it has shown improvements of increased in the electromyographic
options to BTX and surgery. There are the gait pattern and the range of motion examination of a 4-year-old girl during
also different approaches and of the ankle 3 months after the walking. The results show that before the
combinations of treatments; however, treatment.35,47 Here also the number of treatment the anterior tibial muscle was
there is no single solution that offers subjects studied was limited. active during stance phase and swinging
100% reliability for children affected The main goal of surgery is to lengthen phase, after 8 weeks of treatment the
with ITW. the triceps surae muscle tendon complex activity of the muscle had decreased
Physical therapy is one of the most in order to increase the dorsiflexion of significantly.
accepted options at the present time to the ankle; there are various surgical
treat this condition; however, there is a techniques. With methods like Achilles
lack of information about the treatment tendon lengthening and the Valpius Conclusion
in order to evaluate the results.8 Many procedure, children who toe-walk had Presently, there are a large variety of
studies explain the main goals of an improvement of the gait parameters treatment options to treat ITW. Physical
physical therapy such as the and an improvement of the ankle therapy, serial casting, BTX type A,
lengthening of the gastrocnemius dorsiflexion when studied 13 months step-by-step treatment approach and
muscle, the mobilization of the ankle, after surgery. Surgery seems to be a good surgery were reviewed. However, none
and balance and coordination exercises. solution for this gait pathology; however, of these therapeutic options seem to
Nevertheless, the studies are not precise it has the risk inherent to surgery and the offer a definitive solution to the
on the protocols used during the majority of the parents prefer casting and affected children. Some of these
treatment sessions.41 Also the literature conservative treatments over invasive approaches seem to be more effective
regarding the successful if procedures. than others; however, in literature the
physiotherapy does not discuss Compared with the reviewed articles information about the long-term effect
long-term effects, success rate, or the 3-step pyramid insole treatment is missing.
Three of the studies that were reviewed result of cast treatment for idiopathic toe the literature. J Rehabil Med. 2014;46:
seem to support the 3-step pyramid walking. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2013;95: 945-957.
400-407. 22. Fox A, Deakin S, Pettigrew G, Paton R.
insole treatment concept. The treatment
with pyramid insoles seems to be an 9. Williams CM, Michalitsis J, Murphy A, Serial casting in the treatment of idiopathic
Rawicki B, Haines TP. Do external stimuli toe-walkers and review of the literature.
effective treatment solution in about 64% impact the gait of children with idiopathic Acta Orthop Belg. 2006;72:722-730.
to 70% of the cases. It seems that toe walking? a study protocol for a within- 23. Pomarino D, Stock S, Zörnig L, Meincke
classifying the clinical characteristics subject randomized control trial. BJM P, Walther C, Klawonn M. Therapie
among toe walkers and finding the Open. 2013;3(3):e002389. doi:10.1136/ des habituellen Zehenspitzenganges
reason of toe walking help determine the bmjopen-2012-002389. mittels typisierung und stufenkonzept.
adequate treatment approach. However, 10. Engstrom P, Gutierrez-Farewik EM, Orthopaedie Praxis. 2011;47:520-526.
more research is suggested on the fields Bartinak A, Tedroff K, Orefelt C, Haglung- 24. Pomarino D, Pomarino A. Der
Akerlind. Does botulinum toxin A improve idiopathische Zehenspitzengang. Paed.
of finding the causes. the walking pattern in children with 2010;16:117-121.
The number of subjects in the studies idiopathic toe walking? J Child Orthop.
25. Gámez-Iruela J, Sedeño-Vidal A,
in many of the studies is limited. A lot of 2010;4:301-308.
Fernández-Herrera D. Efectividad del
uncertainty remains regarding this gait 11. Hemo Y, Macdessi SJ, Pierce RA, Aiona tratamiento en el abordaje de la marcha de
pathology and there is still a vast MD, Sussman MD. Outcome of patients puntillas idiopática: revisión sistemática.
territory to learn and explore concerning after Achilles tendon lengthening for Fisioterapia. 2015;37:35-40.
this idiopathic condition. treatment of idiopathic toe walking. J 26. Pomarino D, Klawonn M, Röwekamp M,
Pediatr Othop. 2006;26:336-340. Walther C, Stock S. Aktivitätsmessungen
12. McMulkin ML, Baird GO, Caskey PM, des M. tibalis anterior bei habituellen
References Ferguson RL. Comprehensive outcomes of Zehenspitzengängern. Paediatr Praxis.
1. James M. Anderson Center of Health. surgically treated idiopathic toe walkers. J 2011;77:101-114.
Evidence-based care guideline for Pediatr Orthop. 2006;26:606-611. 27. Pomarino D, Klawonn M, Schulz G, Stock
management of idiopathic toe walking in 13. Clark, Sweeney JK, Yocum A, McCoy S, Mundt D, Pomarino A. Morphologische
children and young adults ages 2 through SW. Effects of motor control intervention Veränderung am Musculus tibialis
21 years. Cincinnati Children’s Hospital for children with idiopathic toe walking: anterior bei Zehenspitzengängern. Paed.
Medical Center; 2011. https://www. a 5 cases series. Pediatr Phys Ther. 2009;15(04):186-189.
guideline.gov/summaries/summary/33571. 2010;22:417-426. 28. Williams CM, Tinley P, Rawicki B.
Accessed August 31, 2016. Idiopathic toe walking: have we
14. Stott NS, Walt SE, Lobb GA, Reynolds
2. Sala DA, Shulman LH, Kennedy RF, Grant N, Nicol RO. Treatment for idiopathic progressed in our knowledge of the
AD, Chu ML. Idiopathic toe walking: a toe walking: result at skeletal maturity. J causality and treatment of this gait type? J
review. Dev Med Child Neurol. 1999;41: Pediatr Orthop. 2004;24:63-69. Am Podiatr Med Assoc. 2014;104:253-263.
846-848. 29. Jahn J, Vasavada AN, McMulkin ML.
15. Pomarino D, Klawonn M, Stock S, Zornig
3. Williams C, Tinley P, Curtin M. Idiopathic L, Martin S, Pomarino A. Stufentherapie Calf muscle-tendon lengths before and
toe walking and sensory processing des habituellen Zehenspitzenganges. after Tendon-Achilles lengthening and
dysfunction. J Foot Ankle Res. 2011;4 Orthopaedie Praxis. 2010;4:161-168. gastrocnemius lengthening for equinus
(suppl 1):P59. cerebral palsy and idiopathic toe walking.
16. Pomarino D, Kaumkötter R, Klawonn M, Gait Posture. 2009;29:612-617.
4. Hoppestad B. Toe walking in children: et al. Der habituelle Zehenspitzengang.
a benign phase of youth, or a harmful Stuttgart, Germany: Schttauer, 2012. 30. Pomarino D, Klawonn M, Zörnig L, Stock
condition requiring treatment. http:// S, Pomarino A, Walther C. Der kindliche
physical-therapy.advanceweb.com/ 17. Bernhard MK, M. Neef M, Merkenschlager Zehenspitzengang. Orthopaedie Praxis.
Archives/Article-Archives/Toe-Walking-in- A. Idiopathisher Zehenspitzengang— 2010;10:481-488.
Children.aspx. Accessed August 31, 2016. eine wichtige kindliche Gangvariante.
31. Pomarino D, Hengfoss C, Pomarino A.
Orthopaedie Praxis. 2010;46:349-354.
5. Fox A, Deakin S, Pettigrew G, Paton R. Der idiopathische Zehenspitzengang-
Serial casting in the treatment of idiopathic 18. Pomarino D, Dittmer J, Klawonn M, häufigkeit und ursachen. Paediatr.
toe-walking and review of the literature. Wesrphal N, Rubtsova I, Zörnig L. 2009;73:453-460.
Acta Orthop Belg. 2006;72:722-730. Relevanz der therapietreue bei behandlung 32. Babb A, Carlson WO. Idiopathic toe-
des habituellen Zehenspitzenganges. walking. S D Med. 2008;61:53, 55-57.
6. Pomarino D, Ramirez J, Pomarino A.
Orthopaedie Praxis. 2011;47:481-486.
Habitual toe-walking: family predisposition 33. Williams CM, Tinley P, Curtin M, Wakefield
and gender distribution [published 19. Pomarino D, Zörnig L, Stock S, Klawonn S, Nielsen S. Is idiopathic toe walking
online July 1, 2016]. Foot Ankle Spec. M, Dietz B, Walther C. Fehldiagnose really idiopathic? the motor skills and
doi:10.1177/1938640016656780. habitueller Zehenspitzengang. Kinder-und sensory processing abilities associated with
Jugenmedizin. 2011;2:96-99. idiopathic toe walking gait. J Child Neurol.
7. Van Kujik AA, Kosters R, Vugts M, Geurt
AC. Treatment for idiopathic toe walking: 20. Pomarino D, Zörnig L, Meincke P, 2014;29:71-78.
a system review of the literature. J Rehabil Rubtsova I. Klassifikation des habituellen 34. Pomarino D, Klawonn M, Stock
Med. 2014;46:945-957. Zehenspitzenganges. Neurepaediatr Klinik S, Pomarino A. Morphologische
Praxis. 2011;4:120-123. Veränderungen bei Erwachsenen mit
8. Engström P, Bartonek A, Tedroff K, Orefelt
C, Haglund-Akerlind Y, Gutierrez EM. 21. Van Kujik AA, Kosters R, Vugts M, Geurt persistierendem Zehenspitzengang.
Botulinum toxin A does not improve the AC. Treatment for ITW: a system review of Internistische Praxis. 2010;50:313-321.
35. Kühl A, Pomarino D. Neue 39. Pomarino D, Bernhard MK. Behandlung 44. McEwen-Hill J, Weber D. Two boys
Behandlungskonzepte bei idiopathischem des idiopathischen Zehenspitzenganges. with idiopathic toe walking treated with
Zehenspitzengang. Praxis Physiotherapie. Paed. 2006;12. different AFO design. ACPOC News.
2008;53-57. 40. Pomarino D. Der Fuß—Fundament des Körpers 2009;15:5-16.
36. Brunt D, Woo R, Kim HD, Ko MS, Senesac Teil V, idiopathische Zehenspitzengang. 45. Stock S, Zörnig L. Habitueller
C, Li S. Effect of botulinum toxin type A Physiotherapie Med. 2004;4:23-30. Zehenspitzengang. Z Physiotherap.
on gait of children who are idiopathic toe- 41. Bernhard MK, Merkenschlager A, 2010;11:52-55.
walkers. J Surg Osthop Adv. 2004;13: Pomarino A. Neue Therapiekonzepte 46. Engstrom P. Idiopathic toe walking
149-155. des idiopathischen Zehenspitzenganges. children; prevalence, neuropsychiatric
37. Pomarino D, Kühl A, Kühl F, Pomarino Kinder-und Jugendmagazine. 2006;4. symptoms and the effect of botulinum toxin
A. Kasuistik eines 23-jährigen mannes 42. Hirsch G, Wagner B. The natural history A treatment; 2012. https://openarchive.
mit persistierendem Zehenspitzengang- of idiopathic toe walking: a long-term ki.se/xmlui/handle/10616/41078. Accessed
erfolgreiche therapie. Paed. 2007;13. follow-up of fourteen conservatively treated August 31, 2016.
38. Zimbler S. Idiopathic toe walking: children. Acta Paediatr. 2004;93:196-199. 47. Jacks LK, Michels DM, Smith BP, Koman
current evaluation and management. 43. Lundequam P, Buck Willis F. Dynamic LA, Shilt J. Clinical usefulness of botulinum
Orthop J Harvard Med School. 2007;3: splitting home therapy for toe walkers: a toxin in the lower extremity. Foot Ankle
98-100. case report. Cases J. 2009;2:188. Clin. 2004;9:339-348.