Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ghidul HSE Romania 2017
Ghidul HSE Romania 2017
edition
Romania
The Health, Safety and Environmental Professionals’ Guide
CONTENTS Romania
4. Editorial 38. Care For Employee 82. Hse – For The Company
Safety: Main Performance Or For The People?
6. Change Management: Of The Managers! What
How Do Management Needs To Be Done? 84. Hse Motivation And Training
Practices Affect Safety?
40. Fire Safety Culture 86. About Fire Prevention
8. Occupational Health And In Romanian Business
Safety Risk Assessment 90. Creating A Proactive
Environment Hse Culture In Romania
By Meva Method
42. Hse Resource Strategies 92. Ergonomics In
10. Hse Education And Culture In A Cost Constrained World The Workplace
14. The Current Experience 46. The Forgotten
And Training Of Romanian 94. H&S Best Practice For
Ohs Professionals 48. Q&A With Hse Managers Use Of Mobile Elevating
Working Platforms Mewps
20. Safety Management - What 64. Protective Gloves
Is It And Why You Should Use It Market – Where To?! 98. Go For Zero Accidents
26. Achieving An Effective 66. Measuring Safety 100. Suspension Trauma Effects
Mindset Change In Hse Performance Beating Following A Fall From Height
The Challenge 102. Health And Vitality Goes
28. Building A Successful
Corporate Safety 70. Confined Space Awareness Through The Stomach
Culture Program 104. Who’s Who In Hse
74. How To Choose A Cable-
30. Safety Culture - Based Fall Protection System 113. Contact Database
Organizational Change Of Inspectorates For
Management 78. It&C Tools Used In Hse
Regulatory Compliance Emergency Situations
32. Safety Leadership Why? 118. Contact Database Of Labor
80. Positive Safety - Is Your
36. Training, Awareness Organization Ready To Look At Inspectorates In Romania
And Competence In Hse Safety From A New Angle?
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted by any means without the prior permission of Govnet Mediacom. Copyright 2017
The content of this publication is compiled based on publicly available information. The transactions presented are sourced from press coverage and press releases issued by
the respective companies as well as other statements publicly released or obtained by the editorial staff of the publication. Any views or opinions presented in this publication
are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of the law firm unless directly quoted in the material.
Romania
EDITORIAL
SHARING HEALTH
AND SAFETY
KNOWLEDGE
Back in 2016 when we first organized bringing this expertise into public debates,
meetings and conferences dedicated to health conferences and publications enhances
and safety, we found a group of professionals the contribution made by HSE experts to
and industry experts eager to share strengthening the field.
information, knowledge and best practice In Romania there are a number of policies,
examples in order to create safer, healthier legislation and standards that need updates
and more enjoyable working environments. when addressing the issues of health and
It was fascinating to see how much energy, safety in general. Through initiatives and
dedication, resource and know-how is legislation change proposals of industry
ADRIAN allocated in order to implement health and associations, private organizations and
ION safety standards throught organizations. companies, we have the opportunity to start
PUBLISHER In 2017, we decided to contribute, as media a culture change, to build programmes that
HSE ROMANIA company, to this process of high quality encourage employers and employees to be
learning and sharing of knowledge by more proactive in supporting rules and
publishing the first ever HSE guide in regulations and take personal responsibility
Romania dedicated to health and safety in staying healthy.
professionals. Therefore, we invited a The call for more rigorous legislative
number of experts and consultants to requirements is prompting businesses to
write editorial pieces and articles to lay a question how they can respond effectively
foundation in health and safety knowledge. and provide a better, safer environment for
To speak about the importance of managing people to work in.
health and safety risk in companies might Also, there is a clear shift to move away
be considered superfluous. Still, we found from safety being about “compliance” and
that the process of keeping workers safe towards something that businesses can use
is a process of continuous learning and as a differentiator to create competitive
improvement. The expertise of the health advantage, as after all, a healthy organization
and safety profession is widely recognized. By starts with healty workers
A study concerning serious and persons employed, while the third injured in 2015 and 183 deaths,
fatal accidents at work in the place was occupied by Latvia with while in the first 9 months of
European Union, published by 3.6 deaths per 100,000 employees. 2016 the total number of injuries
ESAW (European Statistics on On the other hand, Romania reported was 3,317 and 96 deaths,
Accidents at Work), states that registers one of the lowest reported reveal the statistic figures made
over 2.7 million serious accidents rates for the total number of public by the Work Inspection.
and almost 3,700 fatal accidents serious accidents at work, with The frequency index (the number
took place at work time in the EU. under 100 serious work accidents of injured in 1,000 workers) was
Researchers place Romania second, per 100,000 persons employed. also on the rise, from 0.76 in 1,000
with no less than 4 fatal accidents Still, the number of work accidents for the total of the persons having
per 100,000 employees in 2015. in Romania saw a constant increase suffered an accident in 2014 to 0.89
The highest incidence of fatal in the last few years, with 3,604 in 2015 and 0.88 for the first nine
accidents at work was recorded in persons having been injured in months of 2016 ( last available data
Portugal at 4.3 deaths per 100,000 2014 of whom 185 died, 4,300 at print date).
4
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
Change Management
how do management
practices affect safety?
6
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
EXPERTS PLATFORM
OCCUPATIONAL
HEALTH AND
SAFETY RISK
ASSESSMENT BY
MEVA METHOD
M
ost methods of analysis and
evaluation address the risk as
an unwanted event or failure
that occurs during operation
of plant and machinery. They
consider factors that can induce
dysfunction problems or human
error, affecting the following
characteristics of work systems:
reliability; the ability to be
repaired; usability; not to cause
damage to man; the environment;
the installation; the product;
system performance in terms
of production and energy
consumption.
8
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
The use of risk assessment methods of being able to be applied even if resulting in 5 levels of risk. After
should normally be complemented detailed information on the system is quantifying the risk factors,
by the study of the consequences not available from the start. For this prevention measures are proposed
and effects in terms of damage that reason, they are suited both to the for all the identified risk factors and
undesirable events can cause on complex systems security analysis (eg each partial risk level is recalculated
workers, which requires that all risk workshops, factories, installations, as a result of the proposed measures.
factors be identified, their variability etc.) and to the analysis of less The five levels of risk were grouped
and their impact on the risk assessed. complex systems (offices). into three categories: acceptable,
The problem is, however, that According to the methodology tolerable, unacceptable.
there is no universal method of risk assessment, it must be Level 1 - Acceptable; Level 2, 3 -
or predefined solution for risk performed two steps: tolerable; Level 4, 5 - unacceptable.
analysis. Each approach has its Regardless of law 319/2006 or
specificity. Moreover, the methods
are not clearly delimited. There
1 Risk identification - a
process of identifying
derived Government Decisions,
all Romanian regulations have a
are variants and combinations. It is potential hazards and defining their common point - they expressly and
often advisable to start with a rough characteristics; explicitly impose the obligation to
analysis and, after getting an idea of identify and assess the professional
the most important risks, continue
with a more in deep method.
2 Risk assessment – an
estimation process for taking
risks to which workers are exposed
or may be exposed. Specifically,
In the logic of continuous appropriate decisions regarding this means that the employer must
improvement, the risk management preventive measures (to be done at assess the risks to the safety and
system is subject to constant review the workplace and, exceptionally, at health of workers and on the basis
and updating. In this context, the the level of the job). of the assessment to draw up the
researchers of the Risk Assessment The new risk assessment method, preventive and protective measures
and Safety and Health Management unlike the old one, focuses more plan that he will apply to his
Laboratory (ERMSSM) have on eliminating subjective factors company.
developed a new method of assessing in determining the probability Due to the diversity of economic
the risks of injury and professional of manifestation of risk factors. activities it is impossible to make
illness, a method called “MEVA”. Thus, checklists were developed for definitive conclusions about the
The principle of the method is to each risk factor, which establishes choice of the evaluation method.
identify all the risk factors in the a compliance factor for each risk However, it is possible to conclude
system that can be the ultimate factor. Following the identification that the MEVA method is applicable
cause of injury and/or professional of the risk factors and the audit of in all areas of activity. By applying
illness by means of predefined the workplace (law and secondary this risk assessment method, it will
control lists and quantifying the legislation) the check-lists applicable often be seen that the benefits for
risk based on the combination of to the work place/activity are the health and safety management
gravity and probability of risk factor established. Conformance factors are much higher than managers
manifestation. along with exposure times define expected.
The two methods of risk assessment the probability of occurrence of The new evaluation method
of injury and professional illness the risk factor. For the level of elaborated by the INCDPM
developed by the Institute (INCDPM environmental risk factors such as “Alexandru Darabont” meets the
and MEVA) are based on a deductive noise, lighting, air temperature, will requirements for the evaluation of
reasoning, with the help of which also be taken into account the values each risk and provides an overview
is studied the chain between two determined by measurements. of the extent of the risk to which a
or more events. These methods In the MEVA method, the risk worker who will occupy or occupy a
of assessing the risks of injury are matrix is defined by 5 classes of certain job position in an economic
simple and have the great advantage severity and 5 probability classes, unit is exposed
ING. EDUARD SMIDU ING. VICENŢIU CIOCIRLEA ING. IULIAN IVAN CHIM. ALINA TRIFU
NATIONAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE OF OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY
9
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
HSE
Education
and Culture
10
HELPING COMPANIES
GAIN THE LEADING EDGE
Develop the capabilities of your leaders and supervisors to deliver sustainable
operational and cultural improvements with DuPont Sustainable Solutions.
www.sustainablesolutions.dupont.co.uk
For additional information contact:
Copyright © 2017 DuPont. All rights reserved. The DuPont Oval Logo, DuPont™, and all products denoted with ® or ™ are trademarks or
registered trademarks of E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company or its affiliates.
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
In the past three years we have tried to graduation rate has not been 100%, and
complete this lack of HSE education by the analysis of failures has provided
training programmes adapted to each information about the “gaps” in the HSE
company and to each level of training. training of the participants and the new
I have the surprise that many do not training directions to be followed. The
even know the legal basis (rights and project is also completed by an evaluation
obligations) and that they do not have sheet which is taken into account for
responsibilities. In order to make both a potential professional promotion or
the managers and the heads of the stimulation of the participants.
ADRIAN workplaces aware, it was necessary to
CAMPEAN In conclusion, I would like us to
have a training programme which should
HSE EXPERT understand that we have a big need for
present the effects of not taking the safety
HSE education, especially at the level of
measures (court decisions) and the cost-
HSE experts, both formal and informal,
benefit analyses from which they should
but the training basis, the contents and
understand that the HSE professional
especially the final evaluation must
training is an investment in people, and
be re-analyzed, focused on results
not an expenditure.
which provide a high level of quality
There are companies which have a HSE of the graduates. This can be done by
management system, a HSE culture, HSE professional internationally recognized
standards at the central level and which training centers and by an independent
they try to implement in all the locations, examination/certification system. Each
but they face quite big difficulties or the type of training must provide the specific
results do not measure up to the efforts. competences instead of having a single
Following the analysis, I have stated that programme by which all the competences
there is not the necessary basis on which should be obtained. This means that
a HSE “culture” should be implemented there must also be training levels in
and that their efforts will not have the line with the international practice (see
expected results if the workers, the heads ENETOSH, ENSHPO, OSHA USA,
of the workplaces, the line management etc), which defines at least two levels of
do not have a strong HSE education. training for the HSE experts, but also
This thing is obvious because the safety the experience (seniority) which they
at the workplace does not come with must acquire to participate, graduate
a management system, but by each and exert this profession, followed by
participant in the production process, by regular programmes for completing the
their proactive actions or even predictive competences, and their certification is
actions. granted by independent organizations
which establish the minimum level of
We have realized together that no HSE
performance of the experts not only by
culture could be developed without a
graduating from training programmes,
strong HSE educational basis and the
but also by their achievements in their
awareness and accountability of all the
activity area. Thus, they manage to make
stakeholders.
an efficient selection between those
The trainings which have resulted who have performance and those who
following the analysis of the training complete a training course, namely they
needs have been adapted to the specifics separate the right of practice from that of
of the activity and to the participants’ professional training.
level of competence, having a minimum
Without an educational programme made
graduation scale established, without
by all the stakeholders together, we will
compromises in terms of attendance, the
not be able to have a pool of HSE experts
proactive activity of the participants in
who perform in their activity and grant
the training and their responsible testing.
the respect necessary for this profession
The surprises have been quite big, the
12
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
T
his is a study about the current experience and
training of Occupational Health and Safety
(OHS) professionals in Romania. Methods:
occupation requiring specialized skills)
and this research will evaluate the existing
knowledge from courses and training and
Questionnaires have been chosen for the career development needs, will discuss future
research since it is important to be objective, steps that may be necessary to be a professional
while reflecting the values, perceptions and (working in a recognized profession).
interests of the respondent. Participants: This research also aims to thoroughly analyze
The population of interest is the whole OHS the transformation in the OHS field and present
profession. A sample was drawn through the current experience and training needs of
CORNELIA
ARSSM (Romanian Association for Health and Romanian OHS professionals. The aim of the
BOHALTEANU
Safety) members - these being the boundaries research is also to help professionals to obtain
CORNELIA
of the study. Ethics: Ethical dilemmas around answers about their daily practices that are best
WORK
access, who and how are accessed, was resolved answered through systematic investigation, or
PROTECTION
by working with and for a professional the research process`.
association. Conclusions and recommendations The study is being undertaken by an insider,
for future research: The study shows that being herself a practitioner, and therefore gains
an OSH practitioner isn`t yet a well-developed insights from experience but may be influenced
profession in Romania, but outlines us the by personal perception.
necessary steps needed to become professionals.
There are some recommendations for the THE OBJECTIVES INCLUDE:
future of OHS practitioners behind this study, To review the ways of becoming an
first being ENSHPO or EUSAFE certification OHS professional, through literature
for those wishing to have their experience highlighting the legislative requirements
acknowledged, although all the participants and competences with the EUSAFE Project
could easily be included in the EurOSHM (2010-2012).
(manager) category - they fulfill all the To evaluate the perception of Romanian
requirements. OHS practitioners about the quality of their
The research evaluates the changing training training and preference for delivering of
needs in line with the development of health future training (survey)
and safety and its integration in the work To estimate the demand for development of
system, from the appearance of the first a professional code of ethics for Romanian
legislative provisions in 1864 until the present OHS professionals and to identify potential
time, in the context of the much needed barriers (survey)
14
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
To evaluate colleagues` women (question no.2), with about evidence of skill and knowledge
professional experience and 20 years of experience in health and within a field of professional practice.
training level, in order to safety (question no.3), all of them The Romanian OHS practitioners
establish the current training have a university degree (question are aware about the necessity of a
needs of the Romanian OHS no.4) and plenty of HSE courses voluntary code of ethics and they
professionals. (question no.5), one third of them express very clear their point of view
In the past 25 years, Romania are in this field before 1996 prior to about this problem (question no.17
has gone through major political, Law no.90/1996 (question no.7), all of and no.18).
economic, social and cultural them are full time OHS practitioners ENSHPO have the instruments for
transformations, all necessary in and more than a half have their own certifying skills and competencies,
the context of Romania`s accession consultancy company (question no.6). ARSSM as an ENSHPO member
to the European Union (EU). The The year of their authorization could certify members and
admittance in the EU, the alignment (question no.7) shows if they were others willing professionals. The
of national legislation and OHS examined by a commission of the study proved that Romanian
standardization across Europe, forces Labor Ministry (a few of them were practitioners easily meet the
the profession to reach faster the in a special position – they were minimum requirements and criteria
European requirements for quality members of Labor Inspection and the for eligibility of individuals for
and competence; the question that exams weren`t necessary), or had just EurOSHM, standard:
arises is: are the Romanian OHS submitted a file, what the distribution Many of them have a university
professionals prepared? of participants is, based on the area degree or at least at Bachelor level
of activities (question no.8) and their All of them have plenty of
THE METHOD experience on areas of economic occupational safety and health
The questions raised by looking at activities (question no.9). training courses at a professional
ontology, what is there to be known? Types of courses and their utility level, more than the minimum
can be asked to find out where scale are presented by questions required of at least 250
the practitioners started and how no.9 and 10 and also, other not cumulative hours most of them
they accumulated their knowledge so useful courses completed by examined
and experience comparing this to the participants. If we are talking The legal requirement in
objective standards and discovering about courses and their ways of Romania for professional work
any gaps, with the purpose of creating improving the training needs of experience first was 10 years and
the pattern of the perfect practitioner. the professionals, we can check 5 years nowadays, more than the
The development of a profession was question no.11 where the participants minimum required by ENSHPO,
examined from its very beginning to expressed their opinion about courses for at least two years full-time
present time, including the legislative that require improvement. These since the completion of the
requirements. three questions are very useful occupational safety and health
for professional trainers and their training
Questionnaires schools. Many of them have done
They consist of a written list of The Romanian OHS professional Continuous Professional
questions for gathering information, is also interested in continual Development (CPD), between
by asking people directly to discover professional development (CPD), 1998-2006, as it was a legal
things, and they are producing ways of granting credits and requirement and after that
quantitative data. utility of selected ways for CPD year, many of them have done
(question no.12 and no.13). The other courses for improving
Coding the data levels of competency established by their knowledge in a changing
The process of transforming words the EUSAFE Project (2010-2012), legislative environment. Some
in numbers is called coding the manager and technician, are accepted of them were participating in
data. Coding, in essence, entails the by participants and they wish their conferences and seminars without
attribution of a number to a piece years of professional experience to be knowing that they were adding to
of data, or group of data, with the validated not compared to education their CPD experience.
express aim of allowing such data to (question no.15). All of them agreed with the
be analysed in quantitative terms. The participants are very interested necessity of having a code of
in certification by an international ethics and agreed to respect such
Results organization like ENSHPO - knowing a code.
The age of the participants shows that ARSSM is an ENSHPO member, If we are looking to minimum
that the ones more interested in this (question no.16) and they agree with requirements and criteria for
research are of more than 50 years Ferguson and Ramsay (2010:28) that eligibility of individuals for
old (question no.1), a few of which are certification is viewed as credible EurOSHM (a university degree or at
16
Amromco Energy is the largest and oldest independent oil and gas producer in Romania. Since
its founding in 2002, Amromco has grown to be Romania’s largest independent oil and gas
producer and the third-largest producer in the country.
Amromco focuses on its niche market- the exploitation and redevelopment of mature
oil and gas fields through the application of cutting-edge technical and operational
practices.
With over 200 employees, 90% of them in Romania, Amromco has invested over
$ 300 million in Romania over the past decade. The Company has a strong track
record of operating in Romania, as illustrated by the accomplishment of bringing
more fields on-line than any other independent operator over the past 10 years.
Amromco benefits from its strong relationships with Romanian and other
regional producers and service providers. Amromco also gains from its strong
financial relationship with First Reserve Corp., the world’s largest private equity
firm solely focused on energy and Mercuria, one of the world’s largest
integrated energy and commodity trading companies.
Amromco is well placed to partner with international investors in the high-potential niche
market of exploiting mature oil and gas fields in Romania and neighbouring countries.
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
least at Bachelor level; occupational studies (courses) with a length of 180 If we are looking ways of granting
safety and health training courses hours in health and safety. Former credits and utility of selected ways
at a professional level, at least members of local inspectorate were for CPD we can check question no.14.
250 cumulative hours at least 120 required to have university studies These results could be the starting
hours examined; professional work for being an inspector, so all HSE point for organizing CPD for OHS
experience for at least two years practitioners have a high level of professionals in a different way than
full-time since the completion training. just doing another course.
of the occupational safety and An examination procedure done by a All the 27 participants who answered
health training; CPD) most of the Ministry commission required some question no.14 agreed the granting
participants fulfill this EUSAFE time for reviewing and acquiring credits system by participating to
empowerment standard. It should knowledge, continual professional conferences and workshops, as a
therefore be justified the participants development (CPD), a necessary way of accumulating knowledge and
claim to be recognised as OHS learning process for those involved credits simultaneously. We could
practitioners at the European level by in the empowerment procedure. allege that the wider population
validation of their qualifications. This was a good way of selecting the of OHS practitioners is interested
All participants could easily best HSE professionals on specific and very happy about CPD, about
be included in the EurOHSM areas of activities. When this type of learning from others through
(manager) category, because they examination was dropped it was an workshops and conferences.
fulfill the requirements: they all increasing number of practitioners It was a time when attending courses
have university degrees, they have (Inspectia Muncii, HSE, 2014) was mandatory for CPD, but these
attended OHS training courses of without specific economic domain days practitioners proved they have
least 80+180 examined hours, they of activities. Nowadays there are other wishes for improving their
have experience of more than two OHS practitioners with and without skills, knowledge and expertise.
years; the only issues that arise are economical areas specialization and This represents a good way
continuous professional development could be seen equally as a bad and a for ARSSM and other similar
courses and the lack of a Code of good thing, like we said, market will organisations for developing and
Conduct. select them. growing the number of members or
The image of the Romanian OHS finding other people interested of
professionals can be seen in the CPD becoming member of a professional
results from the first nine questions. The Romanian OHS professional association by organizing
There are 25 university graduates, is also interested in continual conferences, workshops and OHS
perhaps because having one was professional development (CPD) and professionals meeting each others
mandatory for doing post university question no.13 proved this interest.
18
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
SAFETY
MANAGEMENT
what is it
and why you
should use it
JEFFREY DALTO
Back in October, 2016, OSHA created a final version of their
SENIOR LEARNING &
new guideline for safety and health management programs, DEVELOPMENT SPECIALIST,
titled Recommended Practices for Safety and Health CONVERGENCE TRAINING/
Programs. In this article, we’ll give a quick overview of OSHA’s CONVERGENCE TRAINING BLOG
safety and health management program guidelines. HTTP://WWW.CONVERGENCETRAINING.COM
52% decrease in workers’ compensation claims But there are also indirect benefits, including reduces costs
associated with:
80% decrease in cost per claim Time lost due to work stoppage
Time lost due to incident investigations
87% decrease in average lost time per claim Training & other costs necessary to replace injured
workers
88% decease in claims per million dollars in payroll Property loss and damage
These indirect costs have been estimated to be at least 2.7
times greater than the direct costs.
20
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
10
Tips for Getting
Started with
Your Safety
Management
7 Key Elements of Program
Safety Management
1
Set safety and health as a top priority
OSHA refers to the following as the “7 core elements” of safety and Always have safety and health as
health programs. a top priority. Tell workers this is a
top priority. Then follow through.
1 MANAGEMENT LEADERSHIP
2
Lead by example
Practice and model the safety
For a safety management it clear that safety and health behaviors you want others to follow
program to work, the are core values of the company. and practice.
organization’s managers have to And they have to demonstrate,
provide leadership, vision, and
resources. They need to make
2 WORKER PARTICIPATION
communicate, and model their
commitment to safety at work.
3 Implement a reporting system
Make sure your organization has
a system for reporting and acting on
injuries, illnesses, incidents, near-misses,
hazards, and safety concerns. Make
A safety management program health hazards than management sure there’s no retaliation for reporting,
won’t work if workers aren’t or safety personnel. In addition, and make sure workers know that.
actively involved and if they they have the most at risk, and
4
don’t continually participate. they are the operational end Provide training
Workers often know more about where the “rubber meets the Train workers how to identify
some job-associated safety and road” in terms of safety. hazards, how to report hazards,
how to control hazards, and of their role
3 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION & ASSESSMENT in the safety management system.
5
Conduct inspections
A hazard is something that can present, or that could have Conduct regular workplace
cause harm at work (see our been anticipated.” Source: inspections and job hazard
articles on the JHA and Risk Recommended Practices for analyses (JHAs) to look for hazards
Management and Safety for Safety and Health Programs
6
more on this). (OSHA 3885), OSHA, October Collect hazard control ideas
According to OSHA, one of the 2016, p. 15. Once hazards are identified,
most common root causes of And because of that, it’s gather ideas for controlling them.
injuries and illnesses at work important to identify and assess Be sure to seek employee input.
is “is the failure to identify hazards.
7
or recognize hazards that are Implement hazard controls
Once hazards are prioritized,
4 HAZARD PREVENTION & CONTROL use the hierarchy of controls
to plan then implement controls.
8
Once you’ve identified workplace hierarchy of controls. Address emergencies and
hazards and prioritized them What does it mean to non-routine situations
for correction, the next obvious control a hazard? Consider safety
step is to address the hazard “Controlling a hazard” is the measures for emergencies and
to eliminate or reduce the way that safety people talk about non‑routine work situations.
risk. This process is known as taking a hazard and either:
9
controlling the hazard, and this Removing its ability to cause Seek input on
phase of safety management harm workplace changes
Before changes at the workplace,
focuses on identifying the Reducing its ability to cause
get employee input on safety and
correct control for each hazard harm hazard issues related to the change.
and putting it into place. So, in everyday language,
10
Controlling Hazards and controlling a hazard is a way
Make improvements
the Hierarchy of Controls to make the workplace safer by Build a process for evaluating
Let’s take a little closer look making a hazardous situation and improving your safety
at hazard controls and the less dangerous. management system on a regular basis.
21
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
Engineering Control(s) Design a solution that controls Encasing a noisy machine inside a sound-
the hazard at its source proof barrier
(requires a physical change at
the workplace)
Safe Work Practice(s) Develop specific rules and Placing warning labels on hazardous
procedures for all workers chemicals
to follow when working in
the presence of or potentially
exposed to a hazard
Administrative Control(s) Developing other work Limiting the amount of time workers can
practices to protect workers work in a noisy area
from hazards
Personal Protective Equipment Protective clothing or Providing hearing protection to people
(PPE) equipment that protects a who work in a noisy area
worker from a hazard
What Is the Hierarchy completely eliminate a hazard, can Substitution to remove a very
of Controls? you? Likewise, using an engineering hazardous chemical with a less
It’s important to work through a control (such as enclosing a noisy hazardous chemical. But it may still
logical progression when you’re machine inside a sound-proof barrier) be necessary to create Administrative
considering controls for a hazard. is going to be better than limiting the Controls that limit the time a worker
That logical progression, from first to number of hours a worker can work is near the chemical, and even then
last, is represented by the hierarchy of in the room with the noisy machine, it may still be necessary to provide
controls. right? You’ll notice that the use of the worker with personal protective
1 Elimination personal protective equipment is equipment (PPE).
2 Substitution at the bottom of the pyramid. That
3 Engineering Controls means it’s the control that should be Use PPE ONLY as a Last Resort
4 Administrative Controls/Work tried last. And that’s because it’s the Although PPE may be of the first
Practice Controls least effective. thing that comes to mind when you’re
5 Personal Protective Equipment thinking of controlling a hazard, it
(PPE) Using More than One Control should never be the first control you
to Control a Hazard turn to. In fact, you should only turn
Why are the controls in the Many times, you’ll find you can’t to PPE as a possible control when all
hierarchy of controls ordered completely control a hazard by using other controls have been exhausted
in the way they are? just one of the controls. and there’s still an unacceptable level
The most effective controls are the What should you do? Use more than of hazard.
ones ranked at the top. Think about one control. For more on this, see our detailed
it--you can’t do much better than For example, you could use article on the hierarchy of controls.
22
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
Your company may and likely does have many workers contractors, staffing agencies, and all people mentioned
who aren’t full-time employees. It’s still important to above are aware of:
communicate and coordinate safety management efforts Hazards that may be present
with these people and organizations, including host How to avoid or control their exposure to those
employers, staffing agencies, temporary employment hazards
agencies, seasonal workers, contractors, sub-contractors, How to contact the most employer to report an injury,
and more. illness, incident, near-miss, or safety concern (and to
The ultimate goal of these efforts is to ensure that whom)
23
Ejendals AB
FEELING IS
Box 7, 793 21 Leksand, Sweden
tel. +46 (0) 247 360 00, fax +46 (0) 247 360 91
info@ejendals.com, order@ejendals.com
www.ejendals.com
BELIEVING
Ejendals of Sweden launches new TEGERA®
Infinity™ safety glove collection based on
proprietary manufacturing technology A wide range of choices
Currently, the Infinity range is being
made available in seven models, but this
G
öran Ström is not a man to preach.
As product manager at Ejendals
AB, the Swedish hand and foot
Boosting workplace productivity
“If you work in car assembly or a
is expected to grow over time. It features
two “single dip” gloves that are ideal for
dry to semi-dry conditions that demand
warehouse, you probably know the
protection company, he prefers to feeling of a rubber-coated glove that a high degree of dexterity, tactility and
let customers make up their own feels a bit stiff and clumsy,” says Ström. control. The three “double dip” models,
minds. So it’s not surprising that on which also use nitrile foam in the dip mix,
“Now imagine a safety glove so snug,
a snowy day in Stockholm, the low- are designed to prevent slippage in oily
comfortable and sensitive it doesn’t feel
key Swede takes a different approach or wet surfaces. Finally, two CUT5 cut-
when presenting the new TEGERA® like you’re wearing a glove at all.” He resistance models are made available with
InfinityTM collection of safety gloves. adds that several of the models are also the company’s proprietary cut-resistant
designed for added slip-resistance in wet fiber (CRF®).
Standing in front of an audience and oily surfaces, including two models
that are graded CUT5 for protection More than just safety gloves
of stone-faced glove professionals “Our ambition was to create a new
who have seen it all, he singles out a against sharp objects.
collection that would not just enhance
volunteer whom he then blindfolds on A unique new technology precision handling and comfort, but
stage. There are a few laughs. Next, According to Ejendals, the secret behind really add to workplace productivity and
he pulls out two coated safety gloves the “Infinity feel” is a proprietary new safety,” says Jan Lundmark, Global Sales
for precision handling. By now, the manufacturing process that combines & Marketing Director at Ejendals AB.
audience is riveted. “Which of these two “This is about more than just a new range
state-of-the-art coating material with
gloves feels softer, smoother and has of gloves. We work closely in long-term
extra-soft and protective fibers. It’s a
a better fit?” he asks. Within seconds, partnerships with end-users to jointly
matter of getting the knit, dip and yarn develop new products and services that
and without hesitation, the blindfolded working together to offer a level of really boost workplace productivity and
volunteer holds up a gloved hand with smooth fingertip control and precision safety. Innovation and a customer-focus is
TEGERA® InfinityTM 8800. “It feels like handling. part of our DNA.”
a second skin,” he says. He is not alone.
Within 15 minutes, the room is buzzing Innovative mix of materials Vision of Zero Accidents
The “dip molding” material used consists According to Lundmark, Ejendals has long
with activity as the glove professionals
of a unique blend of nitrile and water worked with a Zero Accidents ambition in
all come up and experience what Ström
based polyurethane (PU) that provides all aspects of its operations. Together with
calls simply “Infinity feel”. excellent flexibility uncompromising its customers, the company has developed
Popular choice among workers protection and superb fit. This, combined a special Safety Concept, including an
The subject of all the talk – the with the manufacturing technology itself, Ejendals Academy that offers a range
TEGERA® InfinityTM collection – is is the key to making the final product of courses for customers, partners and
what it is. retailers every year.
a new generation of ultra-soft coated
safety gloves designed and developed OEKO-TEX® approval Unique Safety Concept
in Leksand, Sweden by Ejendals AB. for all gloves “The Ejendals Safety Concept is
The family-owned company, with a Over the years, TEGERA® products have something that many of our customers in
staff of 360 and global operations, has gained a reputation across Europe among Europe greatly appreciate. We collaborate
specialized in safety gloves since 1949 safety inspectors and work teams for their very closely with them to find the right
and also owns the JALAS® brand of innovation combination of ergonomics, types of gloves for different applications
performance and, above all, safety. The and can show measureable results in terms
safety shoes. Over the years, TEGERA®
company’s ongoing product development of improved safety and productivity –
gloves have developed an almost cult-
includes a wide range of rigorous testing something we constantly follow up on.
like following at thousands of worksites methods and all aspects of production Now, we’re excited to be bringing this
in Europe and is now expanding its adhere to the global OEKO-TEX® standard way of thinking to the rest of the world,”
global operations. to ensure the highest level of safety. concludes Jan Lundmark.
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
ACHIEVING
EFFECTIVE
MINDSET
CHANGE MADALINA GOGORICI
HSEQ MANAGER,
AMROMCO ENERGY
26
OCCUPATIONAL
SAFETY
through
ISO 45001
WHY PEOPLE NEED ISO 45001 have to neglect these cases and deal only with can plan what exactly they have to implement
FOR WORK PROTECTION accidents which are more visible and generally in order to reduce the risks to the minimum.
Either you are an employee, a manager or an entail immediate corrective action. The measures adopted should aim to solve
entrepreneur, you have the same goal as your According to the World Congress on Safety and the problems which may lead to chronic
colleagues – you do not want anybody to be Health at Work, 860,000 occupational accidents diseases and absences from work, as well as the
injured at the workplace. Read below how resulting in injury occur each day. The total, problems which may cause accidents.
exactly this standard will manage to reduce the direct or indirect, cost of the occupational The ISO 45001 standard requests the top
risks and to create better working conditions in diseases and work accidents is estimated to 2.8 management positions to get involved and to
the organizations all over the world. trillion USD at the global level. prove commitment by their leadership and
Every 15 seconds a worker dies because of In order to survive and to be prosperous, the mentoring activity in order to ensure that the
a work accident or an occupational disease, companies must ensure that they manage workers have the competences appropriate for
and other 153 people suffer an injury at the all the risks correctly. HSE represents an their work and that efficient checks are applied
workplace. Such incidents represent a huge essential aspect, a field in which any company in the “Do” stage. The standard recognizes the
burden for the organizations and the society must prove initiative. Beyond the devastating value of the workers’ involvement and their
in general, the total number of deaths being consequences on people’s lives, the improper consultation for the elaboration and application
more than 2.3 million a year, not to mention HSE management may have a series of of better HSE practices. In the “Check” stage
the more than 300 million non-lethal accidents negative effects upon the organizations: loss of all the main elements which must be taken
in the same time interval. Specially designed employees, interruption of activity, payment into consideration in order to guarantee
to help the companies of all sizes and in all the of damages and indemnities, court actions, that the system works are identified and the
sectors to create a safe working environment damage of reputation, loss of investors, and, improvement opportunities are determined in
for their employees, ISO 45001 should reduce finally, loss of clients/projects. the “Act” stage.
the injuries at the workplace and the incidence
of the occupational diseases all over the world. HOW WILL ISO 45001 WHAT WILL THE ADOPTION
This new standard for management INTERACT WITH OTHER ISO OF THE ISO 45001 STANDARD
systems will become part of the rules for STANDARDS? HOW WILL THIS INVOLVE FOR THE USERS OF
the development of the companies’ activity, INTERACTION AFFECT THE THE OHSAS 18001 STANDARD?
regardless if they choose to adopt it or not. It is hoped that the users of standards like
USERS AT A CONCRETE LEVEL?
The elaboration of the new HSE standard OHSAS 18001 and ILO-OSH Guidelines
HOW WILL ISO 45001 HELP is appropriate because it coincides with will adopt ISO 45001 because it does not
THE ORGANIZATIONS TO the recent publication of freshly reviewed contradict the respective documents, but it
IMPLEMENT AN OCCUPATIONAL standards ISO 9001 (quality management) strengthens the possibility to integrate the
HEALTH AND SAFETY (HSE) and ISO 14001 (environment management) HSE management in the global processes of the
which use a common framework based on risk organization’s activity.
MANAGEMENT SYSTEM? The benefits of adopting the ISO 45001 can be
Of the 2.3 million annual deaths having causes management.
The common points of these standards should found in the fact that it will naturally align to
related to the workplace, the majority – 2
allow the organizations to integrate them easier the formal management approaches adopted for
million – are the result of the occupational
in the internal processes – one of the central other risks faced by the companies within the
diseases and of the health problems related
requirements of all the three standards. set of ISO standards for management systems.
to the profession. The people in this category
ISO 45001 follows an easy PDCA template It s an important benefit for the companies
often suffer from prolonged illnesses caused
(Plan-Do-Check-Act) which provides the which try to simultaneously manage the
by the prolonged exposure to risks. We do not
organizations with a framework in which they requirements of several standards.
28
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
Empowerment meant the program safety gap assessment, and have personal engagement. Here again the
itself. Mission Zero. It became a global their action plan was prepared to level of organizational integration
language spoken each time safety was address the identified gaps. Results is very important. This indicator
discussed. It still is the main value of the identified gaps are discussed must be backed up with documented
our management and all employees and validated by local Operations systems.
guide themselves whether is about an Management Teams. Risk assessment is the way to
operational strategy or a continuous Indicators. It is said that what you systematically explore and evaluate
improvement initiative. It starts with don’t measure you can’t manage. So the, workplace, equipment and
safety and is all about safety. a shift was required in the type of process of job related hazards. Each
The progress of our program was indicators we are looking at measure affiliate plans the execution of risk
supported by the four key pillars of and use the base for our analysis assessment process scheduling the
the Mission Zero program: and actions. As such we focused on different technological units and
moving from lagging indicators to other areas of our sites. This indicator
1 Develop and roll out Safety
Leadership Program
leading indicators. Lagging indicators
measure the final outcomes that result
measures the progress and completion
(%) of this plan.
from our activities, reporting the key Latest revision of EHS documentation
2 Integrate safety into Operations
Engagement strategy (OPEN),
results of the past, therefore lagging
indicators themselves may not provide
was completed 3-5 years ago.
However this is a well-designed and
and facilitate a full safety gap enough information to guide our comprehensive collection of EHS
assessment actions and ensure success (e.g. LTI`s). knowledge we decided to enrich with
The role of leading performance the latest developments (upgrade),
3 Establish leading indicators (so
called business culture drivers)
indicators is to improve future
performance by promoting actions to
and to cover some areas which were
not addressed before (e.g. Change
correct potential weaknesses without management)
4 Update our corporate EHS
standards
waiting for failures to happen.
To get to a point whereas programs
Standards are continuously revised
involving regional EHS teams, as well
are successful require a very as the identified local experts in these
Safety Leadership Program is the important ingredient. Leadership. areas. Beyond the corporate initiatives
way to achieve the organizational Leadership is to guide our safety all affiliates put lot of energy and
alignment and to ensure that we speak culture, and ensure systematic enthusiasm to support the Mission
the same language when it comes to focus on critical gaps. This is why Zero local roll out.
safety. The objective was to reach the implementation of safety gap On the road of having our safety
everyone in Operations who has assessment was crucial, as well as culture program, Mission Zero,
direct reports. the action plans to address the gaps. developed, implemented in embedded
Operations Engagement (OPEN) Granularity and organizational with our overall corporate culture,
is the basis for our Operations. depth (integration) describes what there was an obvious and expected
Integration of safety into OPEN was involvement of the organization into outcome that being: it will get even
critical to ensure the focus, regular driving the improvement actions. more structured and the ideal state of
self-assessment and ownership. Behavior based safety is key in safety will actually get developed and
Safety gap assessment was managed achieving excellence in safety. The as such the conclusion was an obvious
independently of the overall OPEN overwhelming majority of injuries one.
Gap assessment. are behavior related, and thus can We moved from:
All affiliates completed the OPEN be effectively prevented only with Safety is a priority to… Safety is A
VALUE.
All accidents and injuries are
Unsafe Conditions preventable to… All accidents can be
Elimination prevented
Safety management is a line
management first responsibility to…
Injuries
EXPERTS PLATFORM
SAFETY CULTURE -
ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE
MANAGEMENT IULIAN GHERMAN
INDEPENDENT
CONSULTANT
30
A Member of the Constructor Group
Sunaţi-ne azi pentru a programa o inspecţie anuală la 0730 119 609 sau email george.paler@dexion.ro
Acţionaţi responsabil şi programaţi o inspecţie chiar azi, inainte ca un accident să aibă loc! www.dexion.ro
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
EXPERTS PLATFORM
SAFETY
LEADERSHIP
why? MIRCEA RUS
HSE MANAGER
} SUSTAINABLE
LEGISLATION,
Compliance
STANDARDS AND PERFORMANCE
program
PROCEDURES
IMPROVEMENT
TECHNICAL
Management
MEASURES
System
INCIDENT RATE
Audits,
Standards
Engineering
Improvements
HUMAN
BEHAVIOUR } Behavioral
program
Integrity of
LE
A Installations
DE Process
RS
Safety
Team Behaviour
HIP TIME
+
Lifestyle
32
member of
CHIMCOMPLEX SA
BORZESTI
CHIMCOMPLEX SA BORZESTI is one of the largest producer in Romania, with over 60 years of
experience in manufacturing and commercializing of chemical products.
The main activity of CHIMCOMPLEX SA BORZESTI consists of manufacturing and commercializing
of chlor-alkali products, inorganic chlorides, alkylamines and organic solvents.
Chimcomplex is a chemical factory which, using inorganic and organic technologies, has a flexible
and balanced structure of profitable products with a wide use in an constantly changing economy.
Chimcomplex SA Borzeşti will develop friendly performant technologies for the environment and
will became in ten years the most important supplier on the chemicals market from Eastern Europe.
CHIMCOMPLEX SA BORZESTI will permanently collaborate with its internal and external environment
and will continuously adjust its actions to the changes from these environments.
Concern for the environment and discipline and Quality of the products and processes are some of the
most important values of CHIMCOMPLEX S.A. BORZESTI.
The Company`s products are used in various fields of economy, satisfying the customers needs, that
activate in fields like energy, chemistry and petrochemistry, cellulose and paper, pharmaceuticals,
metallurgy, food industry, oil extraction industry etc.
About 60% of the company`s sales are directed to external markets by developing business relationships
with numerous business partners.
In the last years CHIMCOMPLEX S.A. BORZESTI achieved many infrastructure and technology
investments:
residual sulfuric acid 78% solution recon- calcium chloride flakes plant, 12 000 t/year
centration plant; capacity;
two cogeneration plants, producing 15 MWh organochlorinated residues incineration plant;
electrical power, using as fuel methane gas and chlorine liquefying plant modernization;
the hydrogen resulted from the electrolysis upgrading of electrolysis plant by replacement
plant; of second generation electrolysers with the fifth
generation’s one.
www.chimcomplex.ro
1
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
and procedural measures but still system is used to encourage and human behavior (behavior of each
can and want to improve the safety monitor safe working – focus on individual) and learn:
culture, to make the next step in system and numbers. Lots of data to be proactive;
safety awareness in order to bring is collected and analyzed, vary to recognize the dangers (risk
the organization to the next level to audits are performed and people awareness in our daily routine);
achieve zero incidents. begin to feel they know “how how to address unsafe behavior
How can we improve our safety it works”. The effectiveness of to a colleague;
culture? This is a challenging task for the gathered data is not always how to give feedback to each
many companies in all industries. proven thought; other;
The first thing that we need to do PROACTIVE: people try to how to stimulate personal
is to understand the culture of an avoid problems occurring and leadership.
organization and to understand what exist in a constant state of safety
safety culture is: “The safety culture awareness – moving away from In many organizations the safety
of an organization is the product managing safety based on what position or a management position
of individual and group values, has happened in the past to is seen as a position of policeman.
attitudes, perceptions, competencies, preventing what might go wrong When the policeman is on site
and patterns of behavior that in the future. The workforce everybody follows the safety
determine the commitment to, starts to be involved in practice rules because they are afraid
and the style and proficiency of an and the line begins to take over of consequences but when the
organization’s health and safety the safety functions, while safety policeman turns his back or is not
management. Organizations personnel reduces in numbers on the site everybody puts other
with a positive safety culture are and provide advice rather than operations as number one priority
characterized by communications execution. and breaks the safety rules with or
founded on mutual trust, by shared GENERATIVE: safety is without thinking. Why? Why do
perceptions of the importance of integral to everything we they do that? Why do they behave
safety and by confidence in the do – organizations set very like this? The answer is simple: they
efficacy of preventive measures.” high standards and attempt to don’t have a safety leader to follow, a
*ACSNI Human Factors Study exceed them. They use failure leader with positive and horizontal
Group: Third report – Organizing to improve, not to blame. approach, which stimulates
for safety HSE Books 1993. Management knows what is responsibility, ownership, proactivity
The second thing that we need to really going on, because the and avoid using the authority, instead
do is evaluate ourselves in order to workforce tells them. People radiate safety leadership and genuine
understand where we are and how are trying to be as informed as concern.
mature our safety culture is. We possible, because it prepares them
can do this by using the culture for the unexpected. This state of We can improve our safety culture
maturity concept developed in a “chronic unease” reflects a belief by designing a program in our
HSE case study, and which appears that despite all efforts, errors organization which is based on
in the **Shell Hearts and Minds will occur and that even minor real values like respect, happiness,
Understanding your culture tool. The problems can quickly escalate optimism and can combine the
five levels of culture maturity are: into problem solving system. following elements: risk insight,
PATHOLOGICAL: no-one After we understand where we are communication, cooperation,
knows or cares about safety – on the cultural ladder, the third leadership and personal motivation.
people don’t really care about step is to set up our goals – where This program can help us achieve
safety and are only driven by we want to go. In order to reach the the proactive level only if everybody
regulatory compliance and/or not proactive level or generative level the from the organization is committed
getting caught; organization must pass through all to safety and share the same values.
REACTIVE: improvements the levels of the cultural ladder, you Occupational health and safety
are only made following a cannot jump over the stairs. is about legislation, procedure,
serious incident – safety is taken The technical skills might technical measures, organizational
seriously, but only after things bring / promote you to safety or measures; safety leadership is about
have gone wrong (managers management position, but the soft people, about us, about how to take
feel frustrated about how the skills will keep you there and will care of each other to get home safely.
workforce won’t do what they are help you achieve the proactive How Lolly Daskal said: ***“Leaders
told); level and for this we need to are those making a positive impact
CALCULATIVE: management change the strategy and focus on and influencing others to action”
*ACSNI Human Factors Study Group: Third report – Organizing for safety HSE Books 1993
**Shell Hearts and Minds Understanding your culture tool
***Lolly Daskal - https://www.lollydaskal.com/
34
EXPERTS PLATFORM
TRAINING,
AWARENESS AND
COMPETENCE CATALINA
BALAS
AECOM
IN HSE
Health and safety trainings are a lot more than a power point
presentation with legislation guidelines. We all know that health and
safety training is a mandatory requirement, but we often seen that
trainings are made mostly on paper. Training employees in health
and safety matters in the workplace and should not be seen as a
time consuming activity, disruption of daily operations or as a cost.
36
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
37
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
EXPERTS PLATFORM
CARE FOR
EMPLOYEE SAFETY:
MAIN PERFORMANCE OF
THE MANAGERS! WHAT
NEEDS TO BE DONE?
38
EXPERTS PLATFORM
FIRE SAFETY
CULTURE IN
ROMANIAN
BUSINESS
ENVIRONMENT
U
nfortunately, this is the case when
we talk about a possible authentic
Fire Safety Culture in Romania.
Safety culture is a crucial factor in
the survival and development of any
entity.
that do what needs to be done not
because of the rules, the law or the
standards say it, but bucause we care,
Before talking about Fire Safety But how do we get to the fire safety “this is the way we are”.
Culture, it is best to talk about culture? First, we should know that All business entities should get to this
general Safety Culture, as it is the fire engineering has two parts: fire point. It looks like a hard endeavour
big shelter containing Fire Safety protection engineering (deals with that may never end, but it is relatively
Culture. the safety of the building or of the easy in fact, and it is definitively a
As probably we all know, Safety built environment) and fire safety road worth taking, because in terms
Culture is “a system of shared values engineering (dealing with the safety of Fire Safety Culture, the level that
and beliefs about the importance of the person). In Romanian, Fire we have - as a nation, as a society
of health and safety at the Safety Culture is best translated as in Romania - is pretty low. And the
workplace, and the associated way “Cultură de Securitate la incendiu” ones that wake up sooner, will be the
of behaving”(NEBOSH, RRC Guide (Ion Anghel, Constantin POPA, ones that will save lives today and
2017). And we also know that the Ingineria Securității la incendiu, thrive tomorrow.
culture must be shared by everyone 2016). So Fire Safety Culture deals Take a look at the ladder in any image
in a business entity, from CEO to the with that “fire” part of the Safety above and honestly assess for your
last employee. Culture. organisation the level of your (Fire)
The new ISO standards (ISO 9001 There are different steps of the safety Safety Culture.
și ISO 14001), approved in 2015, ladder, in terms of the steps that an Most big fires in Romania in the
impose a more effective implication organisation can be at, when it comes last years occurred in buildings that
of management in obtaining an to the safety culture level, as seen in had all the documentations required
authentic safety culture. “I know picture below. by ISU (by the law). So where is
somebody” or “It will be OK, even Now, same picture can evolve in the problem? If they were OK, why
if it is not OK” should not be there representation of the type of culture continue to get burned down? Maybe
when we talk about risk of fires that and finally a method of behaving there is a fracture between legislation
can kill people. when it comes to “respecting the and reality? Why following the law
Eforts must be done so as every law”. and standards will not ensure a real
employee to be aware of his or her At the last picture, there are five and effective fire protection?
own importance, responsibility steps on the ladder:
and the need to step in. In any field Basic SO, WHAT IS THE PROBLEM?
of business, safety should be first, Reactive We have a fire safety culture, but its
because after a recorded accident, a Compliant level is bad, because:
company loses not just an employee Proactive We are reactive (we respect the
and/or an equipment, but also can Resilient rules not to get caught, after
lose many other possible projects. The resilient type of entity is the one a major fire, you won’t fiind a
40
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
fire extinguisher on the market decision managers do not invest implemented an integrated
shelves, we have all the document in fire safety. And on the long management system, and
for the inspection, but there run, today’s “cheap” may be in fact the HSEQ department is just
are only documents, proper tomorrow’s “expensive”. People following just one manual,
legislation is subject to political work at the lowest level of fire HSEQ Manual (or Integrated
changes and so on). safety permitted by the law. Management System Manual) of
We are not thinking in a the company. All applicable laws
coherent way. Most companies SO HOW ABOUT SOME are in this manual, adapted for
have a Quality manager SOLUTIONS TO SOLVE THIS the company. Unfortunately, this
(responsabil cu calitatea), a Fire PROBLEM? is not the case in all situations.
manager (cadru tehnic PSI), If we start something, invest in safety Law 481/2004 (civil protection
a HSE Manager (Inspector more that you would normally do. law) și 307/2006 (fire protection
SSM), Environment and waste Assess correctly, get proper advice, law) are trying to join starting
manager (Responsabil deseuri and invest proper time, intelligence, 2005 and they are still separated.
si mediu), ISCIR and so on. All know how, not only money. Also we need to implicate more
these persons should be working We need to be proactive (let’s Insurance companies in the fire
together in the same department, respect the rules because we safety….
all under HSEQ manager. Is this care about people and their We need to study by ourselves,
happening? Why not? National belongings or businesses, we and invest with a clearer mind.
legislation is not coherent, but can align the legislation to the This means that sometimes
best practices - ISO standards, realities of today, as we read we will pick in a responsible
they are coherent. Unfortunately and understand the lessons way, a little bit more expensive
in some cases, ISO is important learned by other countries solutions, and not the immediate
only before the audit. that already implemented Fire cheap but perisable solutions.
We have this problem, and it will Safety Engineering at the core Such an attitude, eventually, will
lead to: of their Fire Protection System. make the difference between
Continuation of the bad habits Proactive means that all actors a loser and a winner. HSE
that create more harsh space will not be afraid to speak up and consultancy fall in this category,
between what should be (a good optimize the fire safety related because unfortunately it is sort of
level of fire safety culture) and activities. Proactive means that a Cinderella in today’s business
what we really have (a small all employees will involve by environment.
organized jungle). themselves in a common effort Steps were done in the last years,
People who do not care, they to prevent fires and improve fire in the right direction, but still a lot
leave things flow as it goes, they risk awareness. needs to be done. People start to
have other priorities. We need to be coherent – wake up, (Fire) Safety Culture wise,
Another consequence is that many private companies have and this is good news
Increasing Trust and Accountability
5
GENERATIVE (High Reliability Orgs)
HSE is how we do business SELF-DRIVEN
round here
4
PROACTIVE DRIVEN BY BUSINESS SYSTEMS
Safety leadership and values drive Operational, excellence
continuous improvement
Increasingly informed
3
CALCULATIVE DRIVEN BY SAFETY/SHE STANDARDS
Lead
2
REACTIVE DRIVEN BY STANDARDS
Safety is important, we do a lot Principles, policies, golden rules, fatal
every time we have an accident risk standards, major risk standards, etc
1
PATHOLOGICAL DRIVEN BY THE LAW
who cares as long as Law and regulations are
we’re not caught the primary drivers
41
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
EXPERTS PLATFORM
LOOKING BACK: A
COMMON APPROACH
Historically, a common approach could be
characterised as ‘event driven and reactive’. In
practice, this would develop and manifest itself as
shown in Figures 1 and 2.
An organisation that feels comfortable with
its HSE performance and draw high level
assurance that its HSE Management System
was appropriate.
A major incident occurs either within the
organisation or in a similar organisation
within the same sector.
42
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
s
happen again and so a detailed
rce
sou
investigation must be conducted
s
sse
Re
oc e
to understand the root causes”.
Safety
Pr
Based on these findings the
Resources/
organisation would allocate
Processes
additional HSE resources
to develop processes to Major
better control the identified Incident
weaknesses. Typically, this would
include more detailed procedures,
additional training and increased Time
levels of central assurance i.e.
the resource levels and processes function reduces its staff costs by these circumstances, there is often
would increase in a patchwork 25% by the end of the calendar a feeling amongst staff that they are
to address the causes of past year… Please reflect in your ‘coping rather than managing’ and
incidents. budget submissions”. that the residual risks are increasing
These additional resources and NOTE: Increasingly, this percentage as resources are spread thinly over
more detailed processes then target for staff reductions is set a broad range of risk management
become regarded as the ‘new by some form of benchmarking processes.
norm’. exercise in which the resources levels As mentioned highlighted above, this
Given the cyclical nature of the for the group and/or individual approach is reactive and somewhat
Natural Commodities sectors functions is conducted by an external superficial in the level of risk-based
(e.g. O&G and Mining) some management consulting group. This analysis that is conducted. These
form of economic downturn (as high-level benchmarking highlights short-comings have been recognised
highlighted above for the recent to senior managers that peer and organisations are increasingly
collapse in oil price) will put companies are successful in doing looking for a much more systematic
pressure on costs and resource ‘More with Less’ and gives them and risk-based approach.
levels. comfort that significant cuts are not
In the absence of a structured unreasonable. GOING FORWARD: A
and risk-based approach staff If and when these staff cuts take SYSTEMATIC AND RISK-
reductions would often be made place, there is a perceived resource BASED APPROACH
based on the application of a gap in which the remaining staff As implied in the title, it is
grouplevel cost reduction target feel very concerned that they are no important that such an approach
along the lines of “the recent longer able to effectively implement must be underpinned by a good
collapse in commodity prices has the detailed HSE Management understanding of the organisation’s
had a significant impact on our System that the organisation still has current risk profile and risk
projected cash flows. In view in place i.e. a disconnect develops appetite. A true baseline needs to be
of this it is imperative that each between resources and activities. In established of cost/risk/work being
undertaken by the HSE function
Figure 2. HSE resources: the impact of a downturn and HSE work undertaken by the
front line/external consultants etc
so that informed decisions can be
Economic made. The aim then is to ensure
Downturn
that the resource levels and HSE
management system are appropriate
s
level of risk.
ses
Re
Safety Resource
Pr
43
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
Phase 1: Stop
• Saves costs Internal/
Duplicated XYZ training Assurance
external
• No impact on risk reporting programs activities XYZ
services
or performance
Phase 2: Prioritise
• Risk informed HSE advisory
XYZ programs
• “Need” vs “nice to have” service X
Relative accountabilities and ‘nice to have’ can be deferred – the Christmas-tree had 100 times the
activities. again without an increase in risk. amount of customisation. This adds
EHS management system Examples include, deferment of the a major additional cost in terms of
requirements (including organisation’s participation in a joint- upfront design and subsequent design
development, maintenance and industry research programme or the reviews (e.g. FMEA, HAZOP) and
implementation support). cessation of a systems development equipment/system verification and
The current and likely future project. Again, experience indicates certification.
risk profile e.g. a site that is about ‘savings’ of ~ 15% at this stage. In view of this it is important
to double in size….a site that is to review and ensure that any
closing down etc. Stage 3: Simplify, technical safety and environmental
Once this information has been streamline, standardize engineering inputs account for the
collated HSE ‘activities/expenditure’ All of the activities that reach this benefits of standardization and Stage
are passed through a three stage stage are deemed to be necessary 3 of this systematic process will
‘filter’ process i.e: in order to deliver the desired include this in its scope.
outcomes. As such, the question is Whereas the previous approach
Stage 1: Stop “is there a better (more efficient and generally equates to ‘More with
The aim here is to identify any cost-effective) way of achieving these Less’ this more systematic approach
activities/spend that can be stopped outcomes?”. results in ‘LESS with LESS’. As such,
without increasing the residual risk. For simplify/streamline, this involves the organisation does less ‘stuff ’
For example, there are often risk scrutinising key activities/steps and with less people and yet achieves
controls and associated training asking if they add sufficient value the same outcome in terms of risk
requirements that were previously to the outcomes. If not, they can management outcomes i.e. it develops
included in the HSE management be eliminated saving resources and a more efficient and cost-effective
System that are no longer required costs. Figure 4 illustrates ERM’s approach to the management of the
as the source of the risk has been experience of potential areas for current risks.
removed. Experience to date streamlining.
indicates that ~10% of the resource In terms of standardization, it was DISCUSSION
requirements can be eliminated at clear from the CEO dialogues at the Key points of discussion from the
this stage. recent IHS CERAWeek conference above sections include:
that this subject is very much on
Stage 2: Prioritise the ‘C-Suite’ agenda. For example, ‘Organic’ Growth in HSE
At this stage the aim is to Jeff Immelt (Chairman and CEO Resource Levels
differentiate between those activities of GE) compared the degree of The ‘event driven and reactive’
that are ‘needed’ vs those that are customisation in a Combined Heat approach as described above is
‘nice to have’ in the current climate Power Plant with that of a Sub-sea obviously a simplification of what
on the basis that those that are Christmas tree. His point was that happens in practice i.e. this ‘spikey’
44
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
45
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
THE FORGOTTEN
I
was kindly asked, by Govnet, to write an editorial
regarding the safety of working at height in Romania.
I took me some time to put this article together as
just simply wouldn’t. Would you personally work
150 meters off the ground without being trained
and certified to do so first? If we go just across the
there is simply so many areas surrounding working water to the United Kingdom, all workers who work
at height which are over looked, not respected or at height are required to undergo working at height
considered, that I honestly didn’t know where to start. training, complete the training course and then
Do we start with the state, who have put together hold certification by that or a recognised training
the most basic and vague set of standards & spend no provider to be able to work at height. So, if you are
time enforcing what regulations they’ve crafted? Do reading this and happen to be a parent, ask yourself
DUNCAN we accuse the business owners who willing send their this: Understanding the level of equipment supplied,
MCGINLEY workers out in the field without the right equipment knowing the level of training provided and education
MANAGING and trainings? Do we blame the health & safety for and around working at height, would you allow
DIRECTOR managers who sit in the hot seat of responsibility? one of your own children to work 150 meters off the
PETROLEUM Should we attack the CEO’s, the Financial Directors, ground here in Romania?
SAFETY the Operations Directors of these corporate I attended a meeting in May this year with (I would
SOLUTIONS organisations who willing eliminate the spending of love to inform you as to with whom & which domain)
AND SAFETY the allocated health & safety budget on bringing in the one of the larger corporations here in Romania. This
ACADEMY next contract, or next dollar to the company? Because health & safety executive has been striving for new
the cost of one life is vs cost of training... well… standards in general Occupational Health & Safety,
Where do we start? Is blame going to help improve not just for working at height, within this company for
safety while working at height or steer us in right the last 3-4years. Decisions were taken at an executive
direction? level not to switch from one product to another,
Maybe it’s the law of the land, but it always seems that because the process of entering a new supplier (who
a disaster must take place before “we” decide to listen by the way was offering the right product to replace
to that valuable lesson all our mothers tried so hard to one that wasn’t designed or fit for that particular job)
teach us. “Prevention is better than cure”. I believe it’s into their internal procurement system as it was just a
time we take more preventative action, than simply too long and difficult process. Now you’ll be thinking
adopting the policy of an ostrich. I’ve heard many a story like this before and as I’m sure
My background, until 2016, has laid outside of you’d be right, but then it got worse. This company
Occupational Health & Safety, but after my short time has over 2000 workers who work at height every
in the field I feel it completely necessary that we as a day, all day, come wind, snow, hail or shine. From
nation need to stand together to improve the current these over 2000 workers, not one has undergone any
regulations, rewrite the rules & the legislation and training by a recognised training company, not one of
set new and higher standards for all those who work these 2000 workers are qualified to or has any form
at height. The state must be part of this initiative of certification that allows them to work at height.
and not for simply rewriting legislation, so the blame Again, I won’t disclose who they are, but if the largest
can be shifted over to site managers or company corporations who work on the largest project sites,
executives once people do not comply, but construct a have this many people at risk, and daily, then I think
definitive plan on how they intend to not only enforce, it’s more than just the Romanian State that needs a
but educate. If they continue to postpone or ignore, hard kick. State officials, health & safety managers,
then this year there will be another 450 + accidents CEO’s, Financial Directors, Operations Directors
while working at height and another 50 + of those and all others who have the authority need to view
will be fatal as there are almost every year here in working at height differently. A different course of
Romania. PS: these statistics are from the Building action must be taken. The time has come to think
& Construction domain and exclude: Oil & Gas, further and do more, to ensure that those who go to
Telecommunications, Automotive, Electrical, Wind work daily and at height, and do all the jobs most of
Energy, Forestry, Agriculture, Aviation etc. us reading this article wouldn’t dream of performing,
So, let’s consider education. As a business owner, you are safer than they have been for too long. They put
certainly would not work with an accountant who their own lives at risk to ensure we have fuel in our
wasn’t qualified or held certification in accountancy. cars, crystal clear cell phone reception, clean clear
If in need, you wouldn’t undergo surgery without views from our 30th floor office windows, food on
knowing the surgeon had his or her doctrine. You our plates.
most definitely wouldn’t stand in court alongside When will the lives of the ones who do the tough jobs,
your lawyer, knowing they hadn’t passed the bar. You no longer be forgotten?
46
MADALINA CONSTANTIN CRISTIAN MIHAELA GINO LAIOS ALEXANDRU CATALINA ANCA PUIU
GOGORICI POPA OLTEANU TAMPU PHILIP BURADA BALAS ENGIE
AMROCO HSE EXPERT BLACK SEA CARGILL MORRIS FORD AECOM BUILDING
ENERGY OIL AND ROMANIA ROMANIA ROMANIA SOLUTIONS
GAS
QA &
HSE guide got together with the industry leading
experts to answer some of the most burning
questions you always wanted to know about
health safety and environment.
Which are the
01
main challenges
of implementing
health and
safety programs
and strategies in
Romania?
I would say that we are still struggling with the transition Main challenges are coming from poor risk awareness
from the old-fashioned “labor protection” to the modern of employers (usually, small employers are considering
concept of “health and safety culture”. The challenges are that HSE tasks are completed when HSE booklets are
a conjunction of contributing factors which involves most signed by employees) and poor safety behavior from
of the stakeholders: employees, employers and authorities. employees (principle “may work like this”)
The employees are used to do what they are told, without really
acknowledging the implications their action have on their own and
other’s safety. Of course, this is mainly related to the level of H&S CRISTIAN OLTEANU - BLACK SEA OIL AND GAS
education, experience and, most of all, to the routine associated to
each activity. On top of it, the history of reactive safety left only In a global, complex and dynamic organization, the
coercive marks in the collective memory of the work force, thus implementation of health and security programmes
leading to a generalized attitude of rejecting the concepts of H&S. and strategies is a fundamental goal in order to create a
In addition, the tremendous paperwork is always a burden on safe environment for carrying out activities. Cargill has
the activity. This leads us to the next stakeholder: the employer. committed to provide a safe work place for its employees
Throughout my carrier I’ve discussed with numerous managers and contractors, and the main challenge in achieving this
(from large to small companies) which were overwhelmed by the goal is to develop a sustainable EHS culture. This is possible by
incredible amount of documents which had to be “produced” in transitioning from a mindset that the company requires safety at
order to comply with the legal requirements. As a sad joke, we work to a mindset where team members have a conscious need to
cannot omit the famous “stamp and signature” which is required on work safely, to avoid work accidents, where we have the faith and
most of the documents. An employer always has a fear of “missing, joy to come back healthy to our loved ones, from a mindset that
just because there are so many. The authorities should be an active says “it’s good it didn’t happen” to the joy of identifying unsafe
part in setting success goals for the development of H&S programs actions/conditions, which translates into improved working
and strategies. The legal frame is here, aligned with the European ways and increased safety. In simple words, the transition from
one, but the implementation approach has still a lot of room for a procedure/obligation/rule to organizational culture.
improvement. I’m referring again to unnecessary bureaucracy, lack
of flexibility towards innovation, and reactive culture. My strong
belief is that the way to improve Romanian’s approach regarding
H&S is by creating authentic partnerships between industry and MIHAELA TAMPU - CARGILL ROMANIA
authorities. Both parts have lessons to learn from each other’s
experience and we can progress towards a positive national H&S Main challenges are around having a culture of health
culture only by sharing in a constructive way. and safety. It is fair to say that building a safety culture
in Romania is a major task of itself and is much about
MADALINA GOGORICI - AMROMCO ENERGY understanding two things: you can’t buy health and there
is no such thing as 100% safe. But with the right tools, a
state of care towards people, meaningful programs and focusing
Lack of participation from all stakeholders, from top on education and awareness in terms of safety, a safe and sound
management, to employees and to state (authority) environment can be achieved. Then if we talk about strategies
representatives. Partly because of complacency, partly and programs those are to be built on what it works not only
because incompetence and list can continue. Bad written, culturally but mainly on specific industries. Cause each industry
understood and applied legislation in HSE (SSM) and fire has its own specific safety aspects that need to be undertaken
emergency (SU) and solved. Nevertheless, basic safety is something that needs
to be present irrespective of industry.
CONSTANTIN POPA - HSE EXPERT
GINO LAIOS - PHILIP MORRIS ROMANIA
48
Q&A Romania
I think the most important challenge is dealing with people’s culture in Starting with the pre-adherence period,
terms of safety. Someone once told me: “Culture is what we do when there Romania consecutively adopted a series of
is nobody watching us”. Unfortunately, safety culture and awareness OSH strategies and programmes meant to
are not one of the strongest points of Romanians and the best picture transpose the EU legislation in the area into
of this one you can get by looking at a normal day’s traffic in a busy city: the national legislation and to set up an adequate
drivers using mobile phone while driving, not using seat belts (you can even institutional framework for the implementation
buy fake seat belt buckles at traffic lights), pedestrians not using crossings on of the transposed legislation at national level. At
highly circulated streets or vans parked in such a way that they obstruct both this point, Romania is open to implement HSE
traffic flow and visibility of the drivers. Add this kind of behavior to a work programs and strategies, at least on private sector,
environment where hundreds of cars and material handling vehicles are moving but, I think that in the transition period of Romania
in tight areas and you have the perfect recipe for a serious accident. from an economy governed by the state ownership
to the market economy and the beginning of the
privatization process was really challenging and the
ALEXANDRU BURADA - FORD ROMANIA
safety professionals needed to start from scratch:
safety culture. In 2006, alongside with the socio-
The main challenge of implementing of HSE Programs and Strategies in economic changes of the labor market, the need of
Romania is a low culture of HSE inherited from the communist period new regulations in terms of worker safety and health
and perpetuated to the next generations. became more than evident. Therefore, the Law No.
319 of 14 July 2006 on safety and health of workers
was the result of the social partners’ consultation. It
DAN BAJALIU - LINDE GAZ ROMANIA reflects the transformations suffered by the Romanian
society as a whole during the transition from the state
The main challenge is the fact that there is no HSE culture in our country. economy to the market economy and a free market.
HSE is still considered a connex part the companies, that has the purpose
of paper making and pushing. HSE related programs are usually costly CATALINA BALAS - AECOM
and there is no direct and visible benefit as it doesn’t bring quantifiable
earnings.
Awareness of employees as to the importance
of complying with all H&S rules.
RALUCA PINTEA - BRENNTAG
49
02
Which are the long term benefits
of implementing a strong HSE
culture in a company?
Low costs and low risks – lower levels of absenteeism Long term benefits of implementing a strong HSE
and staff rotation, a lower number of accidents and culture can be outlined as follows: reducing number
reduction of the threat represented by court actions; of work related accidents and environmental releases,
ensuring a better continuity of the activity, which reducing associated costs, an overall better HSE
increases productivity – by avoiding incidents, accidents, performance of company, increasing of company value,
defects and interruptions of the activity process; improvement a better company image , reduced insurance premiums, access
of the position and a better reputation among suppliers, clients to bank loans with lower interest rates.
and other partners. The prevention of work accidents and
serious occupational diseases and the promotion of employees’
CRISTIAN OLTEANU - BLACK SEA OIL AND GAS
health during the entire professional life, starting even with
the first job, is vital for allowing a period of activity as long
as possible. Therefore, the measures adopted in this respect
contribute to the prevention of the effects of demographic
aging on long term. Less loss. Loss can be in this order: people suffering,
(work) environment deterioration, business downfall.
RODICA STEGERAN - ROFA TEXTIL PRODUCT
CONSTANTIN POPA - HSE EXPERT
50
Q&A Romania
A poor HSE culture translates into constant monitoring, policing and Workplace sa fet y, employee
coaching being necessary in order to maintain the standards. This is satisfaction and, last but not least,
almost never sufficient in order to eliminate or at least significantly reduce increased profits to the company in
risks, not to mention it requires significant resources. In a manufacturing the medium and long term.
facility or on a construction site you would constantly need professionals
on the shop floor. With a strong HSE culture, the organization almost runs OANA HUTA - UNIVERSAL ALLOY
itself and is therefore leaner. H&S are integrated into daily business and seen
as part of the job rather than something extra which normally a specialized
department is responsible for. Not only your risks are lowered but the cost to A strong HSE culture goes together
maintain the standards is significantly reduced. with healthy and motivated employees
and ultimately leads to a successful
organization.
ALEXANDRU BURADA - FORD ROMANIA
Implementing a strong HSE culture in a company eventually leads to a ANCA PUIU - ENGIE
low (striving for zero) accidents and incidents rate. Employees more BUILDING SOLUTIONS
and more tend to appreciate that the company takes care of their well-
being. Besides this, a work related accident is more expensive than all
the investemnts needed to prevent it. The benefits are for both the company
and the employees.
First of all, implementing a strong
RALUCA PINTEA - BRENNTAG
HSE culture in a company helps
employees feel safe and satisfied about
We believe that nothing is so important that it cannot be done safely the environment in which they work.,
and a safe working environment is the strength of sustainable and while the turnover of employees is kept to
profitable business. Our goal is to offer a culture where health and a minimum. At the same time, the profit
safety are an integral part of our professional activities and where margins increase and the accident costs
nothing is impossible to make sure the people are not harmed. That is and the workers’ accident compensation
why, in the process it is important to involve the employees and to take go down.
into consideration both their needs and opinions. For us, in Skanska, all our development and
construction activities as driven by a health
and safety culture and we definitely do not
RADU ALEXANDRU - DS SMITH accept any shortcut.
The most important benefit is a safe environment for the employee, MIRCEA BOSIE - SKANSKA
recognition of the company and a very good image. Working in a safe PROPERTY ROMANIA
company is always appreciated. Being safe gives you a sense of personal
security. The stress felt working in an unsecure operation area cannot
be measured.
51
03
First thing that we do in order to make this progress happen is to As we are a fresh player in the local oil &
report the signs that provide reactive indicators like near misses gas business, we are committed to invest in
or accidents. After reporting them, we investigate what went safety training and coaching, promote risk
wrong and why it happened and implement the lessons learned assessments studies and visible felt leadership,
from each incident that occurred. And we don’t stop here with sponsor emergency preparedness programs,
the process. It is important to make everyone on the working site conduct regular audits to assess our performance,
remember the lessons learned. This way, they can start looking ahead and celebrate our successes through the annual Safety
and prevent a potential incident. By following this sequence, in Skanska Awards recognition program.
we have changed our approach from a reactive, to a proactive one.
CRISTIAN OLTEANU - BLACK
MIRCEA BOSIE - SKANSKA PROPERTY ROMANIA SEA OIL AND GAS
52
Q&A Romania
Any good strategy in terms of safety has to start with a proper risk Implementing continuous improvement
assessment process. Being reactive is actually accident management programmes in the organization to
not safety management. Moving from one to another can only be prevent accidents and certification of the
achieved by fully understanding the meaning of risk assessment. It management systems.
is not a paperwork exercise, it is not a safety professional’s job, it is not
something that we need for showing to the labor inspector when he is auditing
OANA HUTA - UNIVERSAL ALLOY
our facility. It is an ongoing process that should start at the very design phase
of any process, machinery, construction or installation and has to keep on
going. A good risk assessment saves time, resources and sometimes even lives. A committed management - acting as role
models -, seeking face-to-face discussions
ALEXANDRU BURADA - FORD ROMANIA with employees and being curious in how
to improve every day, is key to a strong
HSE culture.
One way is via more systematic work processes and planning. We have
a HSE strategy roadmap that sets out goals for 2020 and our journey
BOGDAN GUTU - F&R WORLDWIDE
towards these. We have already drawn up an Annual Operating Plan
for 2017, defining clear steps, activities and programs. But Group-wide
processes, standards and plans are just one angle. More needs to be done Accident analysis to remediate the root
in terms of best practice sharing and learning from incidents and repeat cause; SLTs (Safety Leadership meetings –
findings from audits. Linde has seen tangible successes in some regions with monthly); Inspection and Job hazard analysis
a significant reduction in both personal injury and vehicle incidents. There programs; Incentive/Recognition programs
are best practice stories out there on the ground to be told and we tell those that recognize complying, reporting,
stories vividly and widely. In Linde we also constantly identify new ways of suggesting, involvement. Safety education and
involvement at all levels of our organization and in all locations. For this we training.
are launching thematic communications campaigns for awareness and also
for getting feedback from our employees. One of those recent initiatives took
place on the 28th of April “Linde Safety Day”. It marked the day when Linde CATALINA BALAS - AECOM
sites around the world collectively hosted events dedicated to one important
goal: Zero Incidents in the workplace. This was the second year in which The We all know that we do not wish to be
Linde Group observed the United Nations “World Day for Safety and Health reactive, so I develop some ways to become
at Work”— a day to come together and reflect on where we stand and how more proactive. If we are looking in
we can do better. literature, we can definitely find some
examples, but I prefer to speak a little bit
DAN BAJALIU - LINDE GAZ ROMANIA about my way. From my point of view a key
to be proactive is to improve comunication, in
order to anticipate possible issues. We should be
Is all about having a system in which meaningful safety data is being more oriented towards the employees, in order to
collected and analyzed. The outcome should be meaningful actions, establish a relation. Also we can make a habbit for
tackling the root cause on behaviors and discipline. One strategy our employees, to contact us for new proposals
could be designing safety tools that fit to the environment for which and examples.
are intended to be used. Another strategy could be allocating resources
to a specific area or process to ensure an overall safer work environment.
Practical examples are having EHS built-in in the project management and ANCA PUIU - ENGIE
supplier selection, onboarding of new comers, contractor’s management. BUILDING SOLUTIONS
GINO LAIOS - PHILIP MORRIS ROMANIA Raising awareness on all levels is the key of
making this change. Having all employees,
on all levels understand that HSE is not only
Choose proactive and competent HSE managers. Empower all employees the job of the HSE Team and that everybody
no matter the rank. Lead by example. Invest (not just money) in HSE. has at least a moral responsibility to the person
sitting next to them will change the dynamics of
CONSTANTIN POPA - HSE EXPERT this activity.
One of the most appropriate action could be to involve closely the people RALUCA PINTEA - BRENNTAG
in the risk assessment process. You should never rush it up and neither
to be performed on the desk. People have to understand that their safety The way we interpret what somebody wants
relies on individual awareness first and second on company processes is based on our perception of that person.
and procedures. You have to look in the mirror and ask yourself if you We change mindset and behavior assuring
are safe in that environment, if not, you have to do something. To be ourselves we are perceived as leaders in
proactive in direction of HSE you have to have a strong respect for humans and health and safety. In a positive culture
environment. The civic attitude plays an important role, and this is coming people receive more feedback for the safe
from education. Nowadays the key role in HSE is continuous education and behavior rather than the unsafe one. We receive
awareness of people along stretching the personal benefit. easier guidance on unsafe behavior if we feel that
the things we do well are also observed.
GABRIELA FISTIS - DENKSTATT ROMANIA
RADU ALEXANDRU - DS SMITH
53
04
Alignment of HSE objectives with organization operational If I have the proper access and power, I convince
targets is performed as part of Annual Management the top management that a positive safety
Review Meeting, by assigning stewardship of a specific culture starts with them. I do not need to
HSE objective to a nominated manager. allign operational targets with HSE objectives,
because I consider that the first should include and
imply the latter. Many times with important clients,
CRISTIAN OLTEANU - BLACK SEA OIL AND GAS
the safety records and set safety objectives made the
difference between gaining or losing a contract.
The reference points in this programme include the CONSTANTIN POPA - HSE EXPERT
following: the new health concept, the evaluation of the
safety risks for all the installations and plant, the detailed
analysis of the environmental situation for all the working
points. In our objectives we follow every risk with due care
and we consider that the work protection objectives have not One of our company’s brand claims is “Safety 1st”.
been fulfilled until we reduce or diminish the risk. The continuous In our domain (chemical distribution) HSE is a
development and analysis of the HSE standards, the management of very important part in daily operations. Doing
the crisis and emergency situations and the environment protection any activity in an unsafe manner could lead to a
are also important objectives. stop-operations point and this is fully understood.
54
Q&A Romania
MIRCEA BOSIE - SKANSKA PROPERTY ROMANIA GINO LAIOS - PHILIP MORRIS ROMANIA
55
Why is incident
05
reporting critical?
There are several reasons that incident reporting is critical To establish a coherent and efficient data
and these can be outlined as following: legal reasons ensuring collection system; validation of comparison
compliance with legal requirements; moral reasons ensuring methods in order to carry out statistical
to workers a healthy and safe workplace (This can be achieved analyses by different criteria; ensuring the
throughout lessons learned to derive from incidents happened record by which the rights arising out of a work
inside company. On certain instances the organization does not accident or occupational disease are registered
learn from those incidents to avoid re-occurrence) and financial reasons and preserved; establishment of prevention and
ensuring that reporting and investigating incidents will support better prophylactic measures for avoiding similar events
performance of company, by future avoidance of costs involved in in the future; establishment of similar procedures
accidents. On the other hand, incident reporting and lessons learned at national level in the management of the problems
from these incidents are improving industry knowledge by sharing related to work accidents and occupational diseases.
them among companies.
RODICA STEGERAN - ROFA
CRISTIAN OLTEANU - BLACK SEA OIL AND GAS TEXTIL PRODUCT
57
Which are the measures
06
you have implemented to
engage stakeholders in
joining your HSE objectives?
This could be a major challenge, especially in bigger companies, Independent hands on audit on the HSE
due to different perceptions. So in order to be more expressive management system, with clear observations
and sensitive, I prefer to explain them how important is and set future corrections for better results
HSE culture and how it could impact their family, children, No matter the result of the audit: I improved
environment, etc. In most of the cases this comparison between reporting by at least 50% as soon as possible –
HSE rules and family life / family habbits / family rules, make participation of all stakeholders. Solved the reported
sense and convince stakeholders to join HSE objectives. issues in order to show the people that their report is
important. Improved authentic training.
ANCA PUIU - ENGIE BUILDING SOLUTIONS
CONSTANTIN POPA - HSE EXPERT
As previously mentioned, Skanska’s culture is based in Health Several measures are envisaged to be
and Safety. Each and every employee is already engaged and implemented during future development
committed to this and everybody is looking in the same direction. of company operations such as: Involving
When talking about our partners, we have recurrent meeting senior management and supervisors in
with them during which we carry discussions on how to improve risk assessments, accident investigations,
safety conditions on the site. Supervisors are enrolled into our training development of safe systems & procedures, being
programs and every worker participates to dedicated site meetings in accompanied by employees or their representatives on
which we share and debate health and safety aspects, like supervisor safety tours & inspections, giving responsibilities for
orientation training, competency trainings or various Toolbox Talks mentoring young & inexperienced workers. Supporting
sessions. Also, the workforce is invited to communicate with site active involvement in safety committee meetings
management during the VOICE (Views of Operatives in Construction
Environment) meetings.
CRISTIAN OLTEANU - BLACK
SEA OIL AND GAS
MIRCEA BOSIE - SKANSKA PROPERTY ROMANIA
58
Q&A Romania
The employees’ safety is a crucial aspect of our organization and it Luckily I am coming from an organization
is the number one priority for us. Everybody in the organization where health and safety is the first item on any
plays a role in ensuring its own health and safety, but also the management meeting agenda. As mentioned
others. before, all employees, starting from senior
management and all the way to the shop floor
operator have safety objectives integrated into their
RADU ALEXANDRU - DS SMITH
operational objectives. The main objectives are set
together with the top management and agreed and
cascaded down throughout the organization. We all
have an important role to play in ensuring a safe and
Setting HSE Targets for all levels, including for Top Management. healthy environment. This does not happen overnight
Our ability to manage risk in our business will underpin all of course: in a young organization with la weak safety
our efforts to create a strong safety culture. Risk management culture it is not easy to implement something like this.
requires people at all levels to understand the events that could It all comes down to good leadership: if you have the top
occur and know how to prevent them, respond to them and monitor management on your side, afterwards it is a continuous
the key controls. This is not just a front line or site level activity. Each process of monitoring, coaching, implementing and
of us is responsible for managing risk. The key to improving safety is adjusting robust safety processes. Also, important is
an increased awareness of self, others and situation, supported by clear keeping as many stakeholders as possible involved in
communication between workers and management. This motivates developing first the objectives and then the processes and
and enables people to take personal ownership for safety, make better procedures. I find it really easy to impose a standard if
decisions and respond in safer ways. people understand the reasons behind it, the advantages it
brings and most important: they tailored it themselves to
suit their daily business. A safety professional at the end
DAN BAJALIU - LINDE GAZ ROMANIA of the day is a generalist not a specialist when it comes to
industrial processes and has to rely on the experience and
knowledge of the engineers and workforce to develop a
good safety standard.
The measures taken in our organization start from the allocation
of funds and resources necessary for the creation of healthy ALEXANDRU BURADA - FORD ROMANIA
conditions at the workplace, the constant evaluation of the
working conditions through the continuous assessment of
risks and their prevention, information of the workers in the
occupational safety field, elaboration of specific instructions for
each separate workplace and reduction of stress at the workplace by The main measure is regular, respectful face-to-face
creating a pleasant environment. The environment protection plays a communication to understand needs, expectations
very important role in this programme. All these can be done only in a and concerns.
team, with the contribution of all the stakeholders.
BOGDAN GUTU - F&R WORLDWIDE
RODICA STEGERAN - ROFA TEXTIL PRODUCT
59
How are you
measuring
and
evaluating
the safety
culture in your
07
company?
By a regular and additional training at the workplace, by If you have enough experience, as soon as you set foot
exercises for the management of crisis and emergency in a company, you will see signs of good or bad level in
situations. All these trainings are followed by tests safety culture. There are clear methods or indicators
and surveys for workers’ consultation. to assess safety culture level (and these methods must
be used also), but I repeat, a good HSE Specialist (not
necessarily experienced in years, but experienced in good
RODICA STEGERAN - ROFA TEXTIL PRODUCT
HSE experiences), will sniff the real situation pretty fast,
even in few days.
From tactical to strategical and operational level, we
are monitoring a lot of indicators, which are specific CONSTANTIN POPA - HSE EXPERT
to each companies. An important factor is to be
transparent and show all employees the results, in this
way they can all see how good or bad they performed. Generally, the level of Safety Culture is measured
and evaluated in a company by:
using Safety Attitude Surveys (using survey
ANCA PUIU - ENGIE BUILDING SOLUTIONS
questionnaires to elicit workforce attitudes):
Safety Management audits (using an audit process
and trained auditor to examine the presence and
KPIs are clearly defined and well documented, effectiveness of safety management systems); Safety
concentrating in particular on Risk Management. Culture Workshops (involving a cross-section of the
The performance assessment is done through EHS workforce to consider perceptions of the safety culture and
audits and inspections, and we measure the number elicit improvement ideas); Leading (and lagging) Safety
of unsafe situations/working conditions, near misses, Performance Indicators (e.g. analyzing data on the number of
number of SIFs drawn up per year (high risk activities for employee safety improvement ideas suggested and actioned,
which risk mitigation measures are taken). the number of safety tours performed, or root cause analysis
of near misses).
MIHAELA TAMPU - CARGILL ROMANIA
CRISTIAN OLTEANU - BLACK SEA OIL AND GAS
Leading and Lagging indicators
Number of incidents, number of near-misses, number
of reports, number of non-conformities in internal or
CATALINA BALAS - AECOM external audits, e.t.c.
60
Q&A Romania
Our main KPI’s are LTIR, TRIR, TRAR and Severity We have many tools of doing that ranging from field
Rate, together with near misses and misloads. All audits focused on behavior monitoring, incident/
incidents, accidents, near misses and misloads accident analysis as well as dedicated surveys where
are analyzed as they happen and we pay special we actually express their opinion on how business
attention to those cases when they repeat themselves is conducted. I do however believe there is yet no tool
– this is a sign of incorrect procedures or procedures that available for precisely measuring culture. By observation,
are not fully understood. audits and surveys you can only get an idea of the level of
safety culture in a company as well as general trends. This is
enough though to guide you in developing new improvement
RALUCA PINTEA - BRENNTAG
strategies.
By setting measurable goals that are constantly ALEXANDRU BURADA- FORD ROMANIA
monitored.
61
Romania Q&A
To know where exactly we are. Managers like and work with Only if employees feel safe and are healthy, a company
numbers and facts. And all safety reports should be based on will optimize success.
factual information.
BOGDAN GUTU - F&R WORLDWIDE
CONSTANTIN POPA - HSE EXPERT
Health and Safety performance shall be measured in
Safety is, at the end of the day, about human life. And it is the order to observe, improve and sustain performance
individual human contribution that enables the whole team to go of an organization.
home safely. Showing the human side of the picture is another
factor that can contribute towards improving safety performance CRISTIAN OLTEANU -
and bringing about zero incidents. In Linde we urge everyone to BLACK SEA OIL AND GAS
share their experiences and learnings on safety as widely as possible.
The more we learn from one another, the easier it will be to develop
and maintain a truly mature safety culture. If you cannot measure it, you cannot improve it. In
health and safety, continuous improvement is a
fundamental base towards having an injury-free
DAN BAJALIU - LINDE GAZ ROMANIA environment with no accidents or occupational
illness.
SHE performance level gives you the real image of your company
safety status. Good-quality performance measurement tools will MIRCEA BOSIE - SKANSKA
not just identify problems but will help companies understand PROPERTY ROMANIA
what caused them and what sort of changes are needed to address
them. Checking performance against a range of pre-determined
measures is one of the most frequently used techniques of monitoring. The measurement of performances is necessary for
Selecting the right measures to use is the critical step. Using the wrong a better awareness raising of the workers taking
measures will cause a lot of unnecessary and unproductive effort, with into account the risks to which they expose and
little benefit to companies. for a careful communication which helps discover
new risks.
CATALINA BALAS - AECOM
RODICA STEGERAN - ROFA TEXTIL PRODUCT
Traditionally this is based on the number of incidents or accidents.
It gives one an image of where their organization is in terms Is all about people. And about a culture of care.
of health and safety, helps with objective setting, continuous Businesses do not exist without the people and
improvement and keeps focus on the preventive activities. As therefore measuring health & safety means
in some companies the number of accidents and incidents is measuring the overall health and safety of the
becoming insignificant, recently new more complex indicators have organization you are part of.
been developed in order to measure performance. The goal is in the
end the same. GINO LAIOS - PHILIP MORRIS ROMANIA
62
Q&A Romania
09
How do health and safety
policies and procedures
influence business strategy?
A hard question to answer. In an utopic world Healthy workers are more productive and obtain top
(ony few companies even in western cultures), quality products; A smaller number of accidents and
SAFETY IS FIRST, so any strategy will be illnesses contributes to the reduction of absenteeism.
based on safety among other actors. Now, in In other words, to lower costs and reduction of
real life, unfortunately, only smart companies interruptions in the production process; An optimized
will apply this. Smart companies, but on the long run. equipment and work environment according to the needs
of the work process and maintained in good condition contribute
to a better productivity and quality, as well as to the reduction of
CONSTANTIN POPA - HSE EXPERT
risks for workers’ health and safety; Less accidents and illnesses
mean less damages and risks in terms of responsibility.
To run a successful business you need to manage
the quality of your product or service, and the RODICA STEGERAN - ROFA TEXTIL PRODUCT
productivity of your business. You also need
to manage the health and safety of the people
In any mature organization health and safety is part of the
who work for you. The way you do these things
business in my view. Health and safety must be seen as an
is determined by your management system.
integrated part of the day to day activities and considered
from second one of when a new business plan starts being
CATALINA BALAS - AECOM developed. This is normality. I have experience with various
companies for which health and safety is just something required
on top of everything else and I can tell you that where safety is
Our highest priorities are the safety and health missing most likely quality is missing as well, and all the other
of our employees, customers, suppliers, important metrics together with it. It can be used in my view
community and the protection of the as criteria for selecting your business partner: a good safety
environment. Continuous growth in the record most likely translates into “trustworthy”, the opposite
areas mentioned, are fundamental elements of being also true.
the sustainable growth of our company and it is
pursued as an integral feature of all business processes,
programs and in the overall Linde business strategy. ALEXANDRU BURADA - FORD ROMANIA
63
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
PROTECTIVE
GLOVES MARKET
– where to?!
64
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
EXPERTS PLATFORM
MEASURING BEATING
SAFETY THE
PERFORMANCE CHALLENGE
66
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
they measure workplace incidents Key Performance Indicators Managers have a variety of tools
in the form of past accidents and (KPIs) are objective and easy and methods to measure, evaluate,
injuries. They include things like to gauge and collect, reliable and improve safety performance.
the frequency and severity of and immediate indicators of They can use safety audits and
injuries, lost workdays, and total performance levels, cost-effective surveys, safety occurrence reports,
compensation costs. Lagging to gather, and owned and and safety investigations to measure
indicators tell you how many understood by the organization. performance, to name a few. They
people got hurt and how badly, KPIs include things like: also can use safety reviews, which
but not how effective your system The number of injuries per year are ideal when introducing new
is. Amount of training delivered technologies, implementing new
Performance Targets (Goals) are compared to the original plan procedures, and structural changes
based on good data, in-depth Environmental indicators in operations; and internal safety
analysis, an understanding Investigations closed within so studies, which are well suited
of risk improvement, sound many days for assessing things like system
baselines, and the causes and Attendance levels deficiencies. Companies need to
preventability of accidents. Days lost per FTE tailor these tools and methods of
Often, they focus on a company’s Number of specific illnesses measuring effectiveness to meet their
safety management processes. Building a safety system that specific needs.
In addition to including things incorporates these elements takes it Companies also have a wide variety
like reductions in lost time and out of the realm of being just a list of tools they can use to improve
medically treated injuries, good of rules and regulations and boosts safety performance. For example,
performance targets can include adoption. prequalification of contractors in the
the number of audits opened/ hard hat industries is critical. So is
closed and time, the percentage MEASURING, EVALUATING, safety training. But savvy companies
of PPE compliance, and employee AND IMPROVING are using technology to boost
participation rate. PERFORMANCE and measure safety performance,
67
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
goals, identify measures that indicate supervisors, health and safety team FOCUS ON COMPLETENESS
an effective program and that members, and key workers here. AND OPERATION OF SYSTEM
emphasize activities needed to reach This effort provides a core group of Whatever approach you take to
these goals. Safety goals can include resources to draw on and gets critical assessing safety performance, it must
things like reduce recordable injuries personnel on board early that can focus on a system’s completeness
by 10 percent over the next five years lead the change. and the operation of its critical
or provide 12 monthly safety training elements for it to do its job. To do
programs with 90 percent attendance
over the next fiscal year.
5 Establish a steering committee
with authority to get things
that, you’ll need to collect evidence
from documents, observations, and
done. Composed of management, interviews to gauge the adequacy
ESTABLISHING A employees, union people, and safety and implementation of the system’s
SAFVETY CULTURE staff, this committee can help key elements. In other words, you’ll
Adopting a consistent safety facilitate, support, and direct the need to create an auditing process
management process is imperative if effort to establish a safety culture. that targets potential problems and
a company wants to improve safety that deals with them head on before
performance. Without a consistent
ongoing effort, a company will fail
6 Align the organization. To
do that, you need to create
harm happens, Plus, the process must
help you assess a system’s strengths,
to eliminate performance gaps or a shared safety vision along with weakness and performance gaps.
cut compensation costs. Also critical key policies, goals, measures, Measuring safety performance is a
to improving safety performance operational and strategic plans. challenge. That’s because no single
is establishing a safety culture and This process includes getting unit of measurement does it. It’s too
getting everyone on board. The ownership to provide key resources, complicated for that. But measuring
first step in this process is to get holding supervisors and managers performance is imperative. Failing
ownership and senior management accountable, and making sure to do so puts your company at an
buy-in. Without it, a safety culture management sets the example. enormous risk. It also undermines
will never take root. your safety program and hurts
Below are eight key steps to creating
a safety culture and getting buy-in
7 Develop a system of
accountability. The system
your bottom line. Measuring safety
performance, on the other hand,
company-wide: should cover all levels of the provides a solid basis for continuous
organization. Strong safety cultures improvement. Doing that boosts
1 Find a compelling reason for
creating a safety culture. Then
have individuals that hold themselves
accountable.
not only efficiency, productivity,
and competitiveness but also
tell everyone about why you’re survivability and profitability—all
making changes. It encourages
adoption.
8 Define specific roles and
responsibilities. Initially, you
good things for your company
68
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
MIRCEA TADIO
HSE EXPERT
EXPERTS PLATFORM
CONFINED SPACE
AWARENESS
70
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
71
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
the confined space and the work that necessary to check that it is free from resuscitation equipment that will
will be performed in it. both toxic and flammable vapours depend on the likely emergencies
The necessary precautions to reduce and that it is fit to breathe. Testing identified. The emergency team need
the risk will depend on the nature should be carried out by a competent to be properly trained, sufficiently fit
of the confined space, the associated person using a suitable gas detector to carry out their task, ready at hand,
risk and the work involved. Everyone which is correctly calibrated. Where and capable of using any equipment
involved will need to be properly the risk assessment indicates that provided for rescue, for example
trained and instructed to make sure conditions may change, or as a further breathing apparatus, lifelines and
they know what to do and how to do it precaution, continuous monitoring of fire-fighting equipment. Rescuers also
safely. The required entrance form or the air may be necessary. need to be protected against the cause
work permit must provide guidance, Many accident investigations reveal of the emergency.
every entry must be documented. that knowledge, skills and experience A large proportion of fatal accidents
There are some elements named are often lacking when it comes to in confined spaces occur during
below that are not exhaustive, but testing the atmosphere inside of a rescue attempts. Colleagues respond
many of them are key to be considered container before entering it. The impulsively without having properly
when preparing a Confined Space selection of the right gas detector assessed the situation in advance.
Program. and its correct operation are vital for Rescuers are often injured or killed
All entries must be supervised by a minimising risks. due to the same causes which
confined space entry supervisor and When it comes to so-called clearance originally endangered the colleague
performed by workers who receive measurements, miscalculations are in the confined space. If a colleague
the training required at the attendant common as a result of measurements has lost consciousness due to gas in
or entrant level and who are suitable being taken in the wrong places. the container, the rescuer will also
for the type of work that is supposed Often the wrong sensor technology be affected if he or she enters the
to be performed. Supervisors should is also used. For example, an EX space without a proper respiratory
ensure that the necessary precautions sensor only measures whether protective device.
are taken, check safety at each stage gas is present in an explosive In addition to all that are above, please
and may need to remain present concentration but does not detect take in consideration that a proper
during work in progress. All involved any toxic substances which may also training is an important premise for
must be aware about own tasks and be contained in the atmosphere. avoiding accidents during work in
responsibilities, error or confusion Some toxic concentrations are so confined spaces. Training sessions
can lead to risky situations. low that they are not displayed by simulate a real work scenario and
Mechanical and electrical isolation the EX sensor reading, even though start, for example, by demonstrating
of equipment is essential if it could a risk of intoxication is present. An the correct way to take clearance
otherwise operate, or be operated, EX sensor generally only measures measurements and the use of personal
inadvertently. If gas, fume or vapour volume percent, allowing it to detect protective equipment followed by
could enter the confined space, a risk of explosion but not a possible entry and exit exercises. Participants
physical isolation of pipework needs to intoxication, which may already be are also trained in how to respond
be made. In all cases a check should be in the ppm range (ppm: parts per in stressful situations and low
made to ensure isolation is effective. million). For this, there are special visibility in interiors as well as in the
Ensuring a proper ventilation by photoionisation detectors (PID evacuation of unconscious and injured
increasing the number of openings sensors) which can detect harmful persons.
and therefore improve ventilation. substances in the ppm range. Also, information and consultation
Mechanical ventilation may be Provision of special tools as is very important to be taken in
necessary to ensure an adequate non-sparking tools and specially consideration. Some companies are
supply of fresh air. This is essential protected lighting are essential where not even aware that their factory/
where portable gas cylinders and flammable or potentially explosive site includes confined spaces.
diesel-fuelled equipment are used atmospheres are likely. In certain This means that there is no risk
inside the space because of the dangers confined spaces (for example inside of assessment because a hazard has not
from build-up of engine exhaust. metal tanks) suitable precautions to been recognised. A joint inspection
Warning: carbon monoxide in the prevent electric shock include usage of with an experienced safety expert
exhaust from petrol-fuelled engines extra low voltage equipment (typically and a detailed risk assessment
is so dangerous that use of such less than 25 V) and, where necessary, can reveal that even a supposedly
equipment in confined spaces should residual current devices. “harmless” large basin, or cavities
never be allowed! Provide an emergency rescue plan for maintenance access can all be
Testing the atmosphere may be and provide suitable rescue and classified as confined spaces
REFERENCES:
1. Drägerwerk AG & CO Confined spaces in the chemical industry – where no two jobs are the same;
2. HSE broshure - Safe work in confined spaces;
72
Reduce
accidents,
increase
productivity
Go for Zero
Guide Book
GO FOR
ZERO
ACCIDENTS
AT WORK
HOW TO
CHOOSE A
CABLE-BASED
FALL PROTECTION
SYSTEM
WHAT STANDARD SHOULD by more than one person simultaneously.
A HORIZONTAL CABLE As with EN795:2012, even if their intended
SYSTEM BE TESTED TO? use is restraint, anchor devices designated
A system should be tested the relevant as such are now required to be also capable
standards applicable to that region. of fall arrest. Test methods are based on
two users falling simultaneously with a
EUROPE combined mass of 200 kg with additional
EN 795:1996 has now been withdrawn users being tested using a 100 kg mass for
and replaced with EN 795:2012 (recently each additional user.
harmonised), which is The MSA Latchways Constant Force
supported by the technical post range has been tested and is
specification CEN TS compliant to both EN795:2012 and
16415:2013. The intention of 100
CEN TS 16415:2013.
this change, was to ensure kg
consistent performance of SHOULD A SYSTEM
anchor devices across. EN BE TESTED BEYOND
795:2012 specifies the requirements and THE STANDARD?
test methods for single user fall protection Yes. Ideally a fall protection system should be
anchor devices. Even if their intended use is tested for foreseeable misuse.
restraint, anchor devices designated as such As the world leaders in fall protection—
are now required to be also capable of fall and with an overarching importance on
arrest. user safety—MSA has always believed in
CEN TS 16415:2013 specifies requirements testing not only to the standard but above
and test methods for anchor devices for use and beyond it. MSA has always considered
74
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
200 100
HOW DO MSA Static load testing (Stage 2)
kg kg TEST BEYOND For MSA to determine an appropriate
THE STANDARD? ‘factor of safety’, each Stage 1 test is
subject to a static load held for a given
that the Latchways systems should Representative Roof Testing period of time.
be easy-to-use, however test their MSA undertake extensive testing of Where a Factor of Safety of 2 is
products for any foreseeable misuse. complete and representative roofing required, the whole construction,
systems. including the Constant Force post
HOW DO YOU KNOW A This means that they construct a must be able to withstand a static
SYSTEM IS COMPLIANT? 6m x 6m build-up of a roof, taking load equivalent to twice the working
A system should be independently into consideration the supporting load achieved during Stage 1. In the
tested via a notified body and structure such as purlins, decks, case of the Constant Force post, 10
evidenced by a Declaration of spacer system, insulation and outer kN must be increased to 20 kN, held
Conformity Certificate. waterproofing covering. Testing in for three minutes, with no failure
The Latchways Constant Force post this manner ensures that Latchways of the complete system. When all
has been independently tested by systems can gain Manufacturer Stage 1 and Stage 2 tests have been
test house SATRA and Declaration approvals for the Constant Force successfully conducted the Constant
of Conformity certificates can be post to be installed on a specific roof Force post can be installed in a fall
provided on request. type. arrest application to the given roof
MSA has now tested the construction.
WHAT MARKINGS SHOULD A Latchways system on over 500
COMPLIANT SYSTEM CARRY? roof types (with between 6-10 WHAT OTHER PERFORMANCE
In accordance with EN 795: 2012, a tests on each), each backed-up by RELATED FEATURES SHOULD
system should be clearly marked to Manufacturer Approval Letters. A FALL PROTECTION
display the following information The manufacturer approval, ensures SYSTEM PROVIDE?
Means of identification, e.g. that the installation of a Constant
manufacturer’s name, supplier’s Force post system will neither Omni-directional testing
name, or trademark compromise the integrity of the A system should be tested to ensure
Manufacturer’s production batch roof, nor the guarantee given by that, in the event of a fall, it can still
or serial number or other means the Roofing Manufacturer. With perform no matter in which direction
of traceability over 40 years’ experience, MSA has the user falls.
Model and type/identification formed valuable partnerships with The Constant Force post if tested
Number and year of the industry-leading roofing system to ensure it can deploy in any
document to which the manufacturers to ensure a holistic direction—it is able to achieve this
equipment conforms approach, and new relationships are using the technology of the unique
Pictogram or other method to formed on a regular basis. Constant Force energy absorber.
indicate the necessity for users to
read the instructions for use Dynamic performance Corrosion testing
The Latchways Constant Force post testing (Stage 1) To ensure durability of a system, it
system carries all of these markings: This testing is conducted by using a should be subjected to recognised
300 kg mass (the equivalent of three accelerated corrosion testing regimes.
SHOULD A SYSTEM BE TESTED users falling simultaneously)—in During this testing, a system
BEYOND THE STANDARD? excess of EN 795: 2012 and CEN TS should be able to show its corrosion
As the world leaders in fall 16415:2013—dropped through a free resistance in conditions that could
protection—and with an overarching fall distance of 1.5 m, on a single normally be expected in service, i.e.
importance on user safety—MSA has post connected to a representative urban, rural, coastal and general
always tested believed in testing not roofing system. This means that industrial applications.
only to the standard but above and the Constant Force post system The Constant Force post (and
beyond it. MSA has always considered can accommodate up to three users accompanying componentry) has
that the Latchways systems should connected at any one time working been tested to 1000 hours of Acetic
be easy-to-use, however test their at any point along the length of the Salt Spray in accordance with BS EN
products for any forseeable misuse. system, even within the same span. ISO 9227:2006 and Neutral Salt Spray
in accordance with ASTM B117-03
DRAGOS STATE
300
kg GENERAL MANAGER
ALPACCESS
75
SKANSKA
SAFETY WEEK
THE REAL-ESTATE
SECTOR BEYOND
BUILDINGS AND
NUMBERS
T
wo of the most important principles
valued by Skanska all over the world,
safety and health, were emphasized,
of being a leader in safety. As a way of
keeping this promise, a new concept, the
Safety Pledge, was introduced in 2013,
workshops and watch the local firefighting
brigade perform rescue from heights by
wires and ladders. Warren O’Brien, Senior
for the 12th year in a row, during their during the Safety Week. According to Project Manager from Skanska United
Safety Week Program. this concept, all the employees of Skanska Kingdom shared the best practices related
Skanska, one of the largest worldwide must acknowledge the Safety Pledge, to organizing daily coordination meetings
developers and constructors, is well- which may refer to three elements: a and pre-task planning.
known in the market for the fact that personal promise of congratulating Moreover, since Skanska also values the
it values the safety and the health of its employees who work safely, stopping fact that children should be educated
employees and partners. Skanska shares or preventing those who do not work in a way that makes them be aware of
a vision that goes beyond numbers. safely and giving details regarding safety the importance of safety, on May 13th,
Therefore, health and safety, are elements in the department in which they work, the Campus 6 site hosted an ergonomic
that are equally important for the state of each time they engage in a conversation workshop dedicated to children aged 4
mind as they are for the body. related to safety. to 10 years which consisted in delivering
For this reason, in 2005, Skanska started In 2017, 12 years after the first edition, information that promotes health,
organizing the Safety Week Program, a Safety Week took place from May 8th to prevention and correction of children’s
one week event that includes interesting May 12th worldwide and the approached posture.
and inspiring activities dedicated to concept was Plan – Do – Check – Act Skanska’s Safety Week Program is
the employees, tenants, contractors and (PDCA), with the sub-theme of Health getting more and more complex year
partners. The Safety Week is highly and Well-being. PDCA represents an after year and although new activities
important for the company, since it important concept for Skanska and is are introduced yearly, the purpose of the
provides the chance to emphasize the role meant to prevent the safety hazards. event stays the same. Even though the
played by safety throughout the Skanska’s Each day of the week had a specific program lasts for a week, Skanska would
values: care for life, be better together, act topic. Therefore, Monday was dedicated like the participants to remember that
ethically and transparently and commit to the Planning, Tuesday was reserved safety and health do not end with this
to customers. However, these principles for Doing, Wednesday was dedicated to training, but it is also important to take
are not limited to the company’s Checking, Thursday to Acting and Friday care of their life every day either at work
employees only, since Skanska takes care to health and well-being. The activities or at home. After all, at the end of each
of all its stakeholders’ wellbeing. that were part of the program took work day, everyone is entitled to come
Skanska’s Safety Week is organized place on all Skanska Romania working home unharmed.
yearly all over the world and approaches sites as well as at the headquarter of the As a follow-up activity, Skanska
new concepts which are meant to raise company. held a training for 30 students from
awareness regarding the wellbeing at the This year, during the Safety Week in the Technical University of Civil
workplace and in the private life and to Romania, participants could promptly Engineering of Bucharest and involved
encourage people to think differently and check their personal health or well-being them in activities that explained the
treasure life. by visiting some mobile stands, have importance of health and safety at the
Since the beginning, Skanska organized optometric consultations, assess their body workplace, the safety standards and the
actions that are important for safety. In posture, receive first aid trainings, practice way Skanska contributes to the education
2012, Skanska made the commitment the use of fire extinguishers, attend of its employees on the sites.
Plan each day
... think about your own health and safety!
Plan
Act
Do
Check
www.skanska.ro
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
EXPERTS PLATFORM
A
ny company success relies on an internal a context for evaluating and collaborating with
performant management. Management other stakeholders at the company level to create a
of compliance with regulations and competitive internal compliance environment.
different national or EU requirements is not an Such IT&C application help you as HSE
easy job. You have to be consistent, persistent responsible to manage fast compliance
and very focus. I know many persons who face requirements, to inform other important
difficulties in handling the compliance, due to stakeholders about potential impacting laws and
internal resource first and second due to major implications/obligations and establish action
operational or technical implication. Usually, plans to comply. To work only in a single tool is
GABRIELA the persons involved in legal requirements much easier than to roll out different spreadsheets
FISTIS identification and compliance matters are or some files. IT tools helps you in minimizing
DENKSTATT always support functions and they have to effort, losing important data and information, as
ROMANIA have a delegated authority to empower for well as tracking the reoccurrence rate.
implementation different specific requirements.
This authority delegation is missing and when it What can you do with such compliance
exists this is improper communicated internally, management IT application?
thus the responsible person cannot lead the Stay current with legal information, up to date
process and neither assure a high compliance with your specific impacting requirements
rate. Monitor the organization’s compliance profile
To improve the compliance performance within and conformance in easily configurable and
an organisation, CEOs, GMs should give some usable dashboard
power to people which are involved in this process. Checking compliance with specific operational
Task delegation and tracking/controlling of legal requirements accessing audit section
implementation will always be a challenge. Status quo evaluation of compliance
Enforcing legal requirements is a great challenge. performance by site (manageable also for multi-
From my experience, I can say that there is site companies) using score card system
no company that complies 100% with legal Permitting obligation monitoring
requirements, but the fact that it has an internal Comply with ISO 14001, ISO 18001 by listing a
process to be updated with new legal requirements, specific HSE legal applicable data base
has proper controlling and monitoring process Reduce all resource needed to inform different
of compliance and identifies objectively its stakeholders from the company by using task
performance, is already a step forward. management
Nowadays, the easiest way to be updated with Inform decision making (top management)
legal requirements, to catch very fast the new with a view on the balance between
inputs and to delegate very fast tasks to comply performance and risk
is to use an IT&C application which lowers the Monitor progress of controls, their
personal effort and brings you a lot of benefits effectiveness, possible reoccurrence and issue
and a proper compliance control even from the management activities using dashboards, status
top management perspective (e.g. Think!Legal tracking, and robust reporting
or Bwise). The top management has to be aware Audit reporting and action planning with
in time about different new potential constrains archiving possibility
coming from legal requirements in order to take Using a HSE compliance management IT
proper decisions. application will bring you more time as HSE
IT application provides up-to-date information responsible to involve relevant functions in solving
on the specific and applicable legislation to potential challenges and will focus the entire
the business segment, highlighting the legal organization toward more widely and systematic
obligations that impact the business, and creates approach in regulatory compliance
78
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
EXPERTS PLATFORM
POSITIVE SAFETY
IS YOUR ORGANIZATION
READY TO LOOK AT SAFETY
FROM A NEW ANGLE?
I
n increasingly complex work environments,
safety becomes more than the absence
of accidents. Managers are challenged to
approaches to safety management often do
not instill positive emotions in workers
or managers. Although the goal of safety
identify and build on “what works well”, and is unequivocally defined as “to go home
employees at the sharp end have to be able to healthy at the end of each workday”, routinely
make situational, safe decisions. repeating this mantra has done little overall
In the last decades, approaches to achieve to foster a positive thinking about safety.
the goal of zero industrial injuries have been Instead, remarks such as ”Safety…oh yes, these
increasingly characterised by – sometimes horrible safety moments we need to have at
extensive – management systems built on the beginning of each meeting discussing
rules and procedures. On the other hand, the emergency exits…” heard in a recent
many industries nowadays rely on highly conversation may be more indicative of how
skilled workforces, for which safe methods many people – both workers and managers –
of working should ideally be an engrained feel about safety in every-day life. To really
part of their skills and abilities. For many achieve a lasting change in an organisation’s
engaged managers and safety professionals, values when it comes to safety, it is therefore
the tendency of organisations to look at worth looking at safety in a new way –
safety only as a formalized set of rules and “Positive Safety”.
procedures in a work environment that also
requires the ability to make safe, situational WHAT DOES “POSITIVE
decisions in complex, non-textbook type SAFETY” MEAN AND
situations is increasingly becoming a HOW IS IT DIFFERENT?
dilemma. There is an increasing perception
that these systems and procedures do not 1. Safety Instills Positive Emotions
always live up to the expectations, and may The goal of Positive Safety is to talk about
even create an excessive burden that reduces safety in a way that instills positive emotions
an organisation’s ability to look at safety in a beyond the basic goal of going home safely
positive, engaging way. at the end of a workday. While “going home
In addition, there are still managers and healthy” remains the key objective in Positive
safety professionals who believe that unsafe Safety, positive emotions are centered around
employee behaviours are the source of all (or meaningful and tangible aspects of employee
most) evil and that the majority of accidents empowerment (on an individual basis) and
is caused by employees who are just behaving organizational care (on a collective basis),
unsafely. rather than around “avoiding having an
It has to be acknowledged that today’s incident”.
80
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
KICK- OFF: ARE WE EXPLORE: WHERE DESIGN: HOW DO DEPLOY: LET’S LIVE
READY FOR DO WE STAND? WE INSTILL POSITIVE SAFETY
POSITIVE SAFETY? POSITIVE SAFETY?
KICK-OFF EXPLORE DESIGN DEPLOY THROUGH
· Leadership · Field exploration: · “Roadmap TAILORED TOOLS
engagement “What are the to Positive · Positive Event Analysis
· Current status useless things we Safety” Field Expert “Rule Reviews”
review ask you to do?” and Streamlining
· Safety language · What does success · Positive Competency
2. Safety Is “The exercises look like? Development
Presence of Positives” · Positive Competency · Expert Crews for Critical
Assessement Task Reviews
Many organisations currently still · Leadership · Locally developed team
monitor safety mainly in terms of Workshops initiatives
what is going wrong – counting
accidents, incidents, near misses,
unsafe behaviours or unsafe is investing in the installation of (“measures were inadequate…”) and
conditions. Even replacing lagging fixed fall prevention measures such the hindsight bias (“it was predictable
indicators (such as accident statistics) as guards and railings where this that…”), which can be significant
by leading ones does not solve the is feasible rather than relying on barriers preventing real learning
fundamental implication of this personal tie-off in all situations). from past events. Positive safety
approach, i.e. that safety is defined In increasingly complex strives to overcome these barriers by
through (the absence of) negative environments Golden Rules will identifying and analyzing exemplary
events. only be able cover certain, typically things that go right and use this
In “Positive Safety”, organisations standardized, situations. Employees information to become better at
instead identify the positive aspects at the sharp end, however, constantly identifying signals, indicators and
that make them safe, and thus have to make situational decisions baseline requirements for safe
characterize safety by “things that about safe methods of work which performance. When performed by
go right”. Safety thus becomes the go far beyond what could be defined mixed teams of shopfloor experts,
presence of positives rather than in a simple Golden Rule. In Positive supervisors and HSE experts, such
the absence of negatives. The ability Safety, organisations will develop investigations will provide a real
to have effective systems to gather, the competence of workers on the basis for effective and positive
analyse and use data based on “things sharp end and empower them to organizational learning.
that go right” poses new challenges make situational, safe decisions. To
which require new ways of thinking ensure that this competence becomes THE ROAD TO
as well as new ways of obtaining organizational knowledge rather POSITIVE SAFETY
meaningful information. than remaining individual expertise, The figure below outlines the process
organisations will implement to embed Positive Safety as “the”
3. Positive Safety Means intelligent programmes to assess, way of safety thinking within an
Enabling People to Make develop and share competencies. This organisation. It follows a four stage
Situational, Safe Decisions will include advanced mentoring approach, with initial kick-off and
In many working environments, and coaching approaches, a sharp exploration phases followed by the
“Golden Rules” related to safety contrast to classical classroom design of a roadmap with individual,
have been established which apply training exercises which are still tailored steps and activities to
regardless of the situational context. predominant in many companies. drive employee engagement,
Establishing such Golden Rules empowerment and organsiational
makes sense to define expectations 4. Positive Safety learning. The implementation phase
for employee behaviours in the light Means Investigating or “deployment” can be adjusted and
of typical serious workplace hazards. Why Things Go Right tailored to the specific needs of an
In exemplary organisations, these A fourth but equally important organisation and can be integrated
Golden Rules will be established on aspect of Positive Safety is with other, existing approaches or
the basis of reliable organizational establishing a new way of looking at programmes.
measures and technical equipment event investigations. Investigations Looking at safety from this new
that enable workers to follow the of “bad” things that have happened angle will help accumulate individual
Golden Rules in an efficient and – such as accidents and incidents – skills into an organisational culture
effective way (a typical example are often prone to the outcome bias of making situational safe decisions.
It will drive a safety culture
ANNETTE NIENHAUS TECHNICAL characterised by empowerment,
DIRECTOR PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT & COMPLIANCE involvement and continuous
ASSURANCE, ERM GMBH learning
81
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
EXPERTS PLATFORM
82
Stress Management: Awareness of stress
factors and how to overcome them
Nowadays our daily activity is led by can generate stress could lead to doing it, in your own company interest.
too much complexity and bureaucracy minimizing risk and moving the • Building internal Stress
which has built up around health, organization towards best practice in Management Support Structures
safety and environmental aspects. One managing stress at work. This structure will offer support for
of the main reason is the compliance Stress management methods and staff who experience stress problems,
aspects with different regulatory techniques are defined by each which may or may not be work-related.
requirements but also the alignment organisation and put focus on physical This structure could be internal or
with company specific requirements and psychological techniques and on external support, and had to fit to the
set up around a nice HSE strategy. We the need to modify the stress culture purpose and should be easily accessible
many times heard managers saying through organizational development. and neutral, meaning that from this
that we already have the knowledge to There are potential benefits which structure cannot be part managers
make the HSE strategy a reality. Is this could be provided to mitigate the stress which lead team within organisations.
true or not? Sometimes there is a gap and combine with health improvement • Effective communication strategy
between management overview and which are recently well accustom into This will ensure that all staff are aware
the ground floor reality. WE HAVE the HR process like: food subsidize, of the support structures available,
TO OPEN UP. transport subsidize, regular health about the wellbeing programs and
By keeping things as simple and checks, health programs or trainings. how to access them. In the same time
straightforward as possible we can First the organisation has to be aware this will demonstrate commitment
ensure that our businesses enable a about the most impacting stress factors from the top management of the
successful and productive path. and to work with them. organisation to stress management and
We forgot that our main assets are That’s why the organisational staff well-being.
the humans, no matter the type of the environment must have a PRO stress • Train your employees
business looks like. We have to take release attitude and this has to be Implement specific soft skills training
care about them. openly and widely communicated programs. Outdoor team buildings
Stress is one of the most undoubtable and to promote `a positive manager programs, psychological wellbeing
aspect which is not easy to be behaviour` a most common action and resilience training are key to
manageable within an organisation. part of the stress prevention. In preventing stress and creating a
Most of the organisations does not combination with this attitude, the stronger team communication.
touch this subject very openly. Health organisation has to coop to some Managers should not neglect the
and safety strategies within companies more actions in order to release impact and risk occurred due to the
are enclosing this concept in their area organisational stress such as: stress issues. This has to be addressed,
of interest and started to apply methods • Offer flexible working hours be part of the internal risk management
of work stress release. • Launching health and wellbeing process and a comprehensive and
The enforcement law in different program - fit to the needs of transparent proactive program has
countries is trying to control this employees. to be implemented, which would lead
aspect by clearly defining some The program can vary from promoting to mitigation of any major health
specific stress factors which can be indoor activities either on company problems.
critical in situations like: hazards, site, either on external locations and Monitoring the implemented programs
post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), here we can give some examples: would give you a clear overview of
supervision, multi-tasks, project Yoga relaxation session, massage the improvements, if you will set up
complexity, new products, cultural session, dancing classes, meditation the most appropriate indicators, to
diversity or even production diversity. areas, fitness classes etc. All of these drive the process on long term. This
Risk Management approach also programs could bring happiness, has a has to be part of the business strategy
defined stress management at work protentional to become an important and has to be integrated into the
place as being a critical point in the method for promoting physical activity people management process of the
actions employees can take in stressful in a public health perspective, thus organisation.
situations and how these can affect improving health and quality of life, Stress related to working environment
the organisational environment. and decreasing disease burden for could lead to high rate of employee
Human stress can be work related or individuals. turnover, and if you would count
a combination with external factors Employees have identified different that one employee costs the company
(family relationships, personal illness, benefits from health and wellbeing between 700-1000 euro for the first
financial concerns, lack of skills and programs which might include: month… at least, you can easily count
competences, etc.). improved attitude and morale, team the loses for your company if you will
Even that the topic is a sensitive one, work, higher job satisfaction and not minimise the turnover and you will
managers are also defining their stronger engagement, improved not take care properly in a proactive
leading strategies of skills evaluation productivity and human health. manner about this sensitive aspect.
for each employee category and The design of a good wellbeing
business efficacy keeping a close look program is not an easy job, and has
to the manners how stress management to be well pre-pared in order to be
can affect these important factors for successful. Just copying others does not GABRIELA FISTIS
organisational success. Assessing of make sense, and could not fit to your MANAGING DIRECTOR
the most impacting aspects which need. You have to be pretty critical in DENKSTATT ROMANIA
83
EU legislation and directives give minimum requirements for
occupational health and safety at work, this statute regulation
can only be viewed as a foundation for a robust safe system
of work and companies Safety policies and procedures.
Motivation for health and safety must come from within the
organisation itself to create a positive safety culture that is
the norm.
EXPERTS PLATFORM
HSE
MOTIVATION
AND TRAINING
84
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
organisation leading into downtime, height with no fall protection or not client, all of the guys are compliant
loss of production, investigation, clipped on with harness. As a result, to the safe systems of work and
fines and legal penalties, increased operatives were being excluded from with training and communication
insurance costs, and most site at an alarming rate and new the supervisors are now writing
importantly loss of reputation. ones bought in who did the same, the weekly risk assessments . An
this resulting in work stoppages and additional motivation for safe
6 A moral duty to send
employees home at the end of
stand downs. With communication
and the co operation of the safety
work practices is an initiative
called ”Zero for Heroes” whereby
the day in the same condition that team and with minimal downtime, workers can nominate individuals
they arrived at work prioritising the highest risk
activities, we internally trained
7 The cost to the organisation
doesn’t have to be expensive
approximately 260 employees for
work at height, harness inspection,
Regular toolbox
and sometimes free of cost a positive also introduced a safety incentive talks at the start
employee safety induction to new
employees, visitors or external
scheme whereby giving lunch
vouchers for positive safety
of the week
contractors lays down rules, sets compliance, awardees of this were or shift gives
standards, gives confidence in the
company, and ensures compliance
congratulated and photographs
taken showing awards were put on
information to
with statutory regulation. Regular posters and displayed throughout the workers
toolbox talks at the start of the site, lunch on the site canteen was
week or shift gives information about 5 lei, the motivation for safety
to the workers, a welder who uses grew and awards were given for or groups and charities who require
an angle grinder every day maybe any exemplary safe practice. We assistance and following 28 days
doesn’t know that if he hasn’t got arranged with the two safety guys on the project without accident or
face protection on to EN166b may on site to train them with IOSH incident, the project will donate to
have a fragmenting cutting disc managing safely, which they did whatever cause is nominated, this
coming towards his face at 80 in their own time, both are still month being a young boy with a
Metres a second or 288 kilometres doing very well for themselves debilitating illness who requires
an hour, or a trained first aider that in the safety industry, the project specialist equipment to aid with his
puts a fellow worker in the recovery won the global safety award for the rehabilitation. In house training
position after a fall from height in a manager of the partnering company, on the project is usually completed
harness and has been left suspended the client actively participated in over lunchtimes, with the project
after suffering suspension trauma the scheme giving fuel vouchers supplying lunch.
(Authostatic syncope) would on a monthly basis, the recipe
possibly kill him because of reflow
of toxic blood to the system. What
for this success …motivation and
training, giving a knowledge base
8 An appointed HSE
representative from the
cost would this have not only to build on. The project completed workforce gives direct information
the company but the individual with no recordable accidents and from management and safety
and his family and their future, workers had additional certification meetings and more importantly
as mentioned before knowledge is and awareness for their next provides feedback from the
power and if the organisation has employment. A big success for very workforce. With regard to training
knowledge this equates to power not little outlay, and motivation for HSE needs the operatives will be more
only in terms of safety but in terms for the Romanian workforce. motivated by relevant training they
of productivity and future growth. have requested.
To emphasise this point, I will give B. SWEDEN, Having relocated to Romania from
a couple of case studies that I have (CURRENT PROJECT) the UK three years ago, I have seen
personally been involved with: This project in comparison is more the motivation for change and
safety aware, and risk assessments development of a positive health and
A. ROMANIA are completed on a weekly and safety culture from the Romanian
Employed as a safety consultant on daily basis, work at height training people and going forward, I believe
a power station build for a principal is given as a matter of course to that Romania’s integration into the
contractor, working directly for the all new employees as well as a EU will provide the legislation for
CEO of the company during a joint comprehensive induction from the Romanian organisations to develop
venture, operatives were working at company I am consulting for and the and flourish
GRAHAM HICKS - MIIRSM, GRAD IOSH, DIP RSA, ACIEH, HICKS SAFETY AND CONSULTING, PLOIESTI
TEL +40 720439724, E MAIL HSE.HICKSON@BTINTERNET.COM, WEB HICKSAFETY.CO.UK
85
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
EXPERTS PLATFORM
ABOUT
FIRE
PREVENTION
86
FOCUS ON SAFETY
to improve business performance
®
and ™ are trademarks owned by Ansell Limited or one of its affiliates. © 2016 All Rights Reserved.
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
88
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
EXPERTS PLATFORM
CREATING A PROACTIVE
HSE CULTURE IN ROMANIA
We can increase fire safety during Shall be established by the Designer WHAT IS A FULL, WELL
operation without additional costs by and the Insurer. ARTICULATED, EFFICIENT
creating a proactive organizational THE REALITY is a practical AND REAL FIRE PROTECTION
HSE culture in Romania problem and it depends on: COMPOSED OF?
the correct realization of the This is much more than the sum
ANY FIRE PROTECTION MUST entire designed concept of fire of national legal requirements and
BE EFFICIENT AND REAL! safety approved by the competent it incorporates three directions of
Any discussion about ensuring bodies’ activity:
a certain level of fire protection the preservation of its permanent
must -mandatorily - start with the
clarification of two terms:
and perfect functionality during
operation.
1 Structural (passive) protection
with measures related to the
What does an efficient fire Shall be established by the building, of passive type.
protection mean? Beneficiary and the Insurer.
What does a real fire protection
mean?
As the level of fire safety
requirements varies from one
2 Technical (active) protection
with measures which are
country to the other (depending related to the technological systems
THE EFFICIENCY is a conceptual on the economic power and implemented, of active type
problem and it depends on: national priorities), it results that
the minimum level generally
accepted and legally imposed at
the compliance with the national
requirements in the field lead to
3 The organizational protection
(procedures and trainings),
national level, with the direct an own national level of fire safety with measures which are related to
relation between this level and which does not imply - automatically the implementation in the people’s
the organization of the respective - the achievement of the most behavior of a coherent and efficient
company (economic, social efficient solution possible. Thus, due concept of fire safety in order to
concept, financial power, etc.). to its weaker economic power, the avoid human error. This direction
the level of requirement of the level of requirement of fire safety in represents – in fact- the control
Insurer; Romania is at a more reduced value. of the efficient implementation of
90
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
WHAT CAN WE DO TO
INCREASE THE LEVEL OF FIRE
SAFETY DURING OPERATION SPC
IN ROMANIA? PROPOSAL
At present, in Romania there is:
91
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
ERGONOMICS
IN THE WORKPLACE
MADALIN DAVID
TERRITORY SALES MANAGER
ROMANIA & BULGARIA
EJENDALS
92
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
MEWPs hazards
Most fatal and serious injuries involving MEWPs arise from:
Entrapment: operator trapped between part of the basket and a fixed structure, e.g.
when maneuvering in confined overhead areas of steelwork. Operators may become
trapped against the platform controls, and if this happens they may not be able to stop
the machine running.
Overturning: the machine may overturn throwing the operator from the basket
Falling: an operator may fall from the basket during work activities
Collision: the vehicle may collide with pedestrians, overhead cables or nearby vehicles
These hazards should be identified within a risk assessment and suitable control measures put in place.
94
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
Echipamentele incadrate la cea mai inalta categorie – in clasa a III a de protectie, cum ar fi, de exemplu,
echipamentele de protectie rezistente la arc electric, se conformeaza prevederilor Directivei 89/686/EWG
si se supun unui audit anual din partea institutului de certificare.
Produsele rofa din aceasta categorie sunt auditate de DEKRA Exam GmbH. Astfel se certifica conformitatea
cu prevederile standardelor de-a lungul anilor. Marcajul de conformitate CE certifica respectarea prevederilor
legale, declaratiei de conformitate si concordanta echipamentelor de serie cu mostra martor.
Produsele rofa sunt create conform standardelor tehnice de ultima ora pentru a raspunde celor mai stricte
exigente. Recertificarea echipamentelor are loc o data la 5 ani. Astfel se asigura adaptarea echipamentelor
deja certificate la cerintele actualizate ale standardelor.
rofa verifica in laboratorul propriu atat tesaturile si produsele finite cat si accesoriile achizitionate de la
furnizori, in conditii de spalare si uscare industriala atat in centrifuga cat si in tunel de vant. Prin aceasta,
se asigura continuitatea calitatii ridicate a produselor, a intregului proces de fabricatie.
La rofa, o echipa extrem de experimentata si competenta va sta la dispozitie pentru a va asista in alegerea
adecvata a imbracamintii de lucru si echipamentelor individuale de protectie, reparatiile acestora conform
cu cerintele standardelor si aplicarea elementelor de personalizare.
EXPERTS PLATFORM
GO FOR ZERO
ACCIDENTS
M
anaging safety risks to prevent workplace
accidents from happening is both a humane
and an economically sound strategy
of any damaged equipment or materials
cost of continuing all or part of the
employee’s wages, in addition to
to protect or even improve company compensation
profitability. Every workplace accident reduced morale among employees, and
generates cost, and potentially includes a perhaps lower efficiency
severe human toll that impacts morale and increased insurance rates
productivity. cost of administrative follow-up and
paperwork
THE COST OF WORKPLACE Investing in solutions to manage workplace
ACCIDENTS safety risks enables companies to control
Every accident can have a severe human these costs while protecting or even
cost, and almost always generates significant improving productivity and profitability.
indirect costs. These can include:
time lost by an injured employee SAFETY POLICY AND
time lost by employees and supervisors MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
attending the injured employee A safety policy should enable your company
clean up and start up of operations to be compliant with all applicable
interrupted by the accident workplace safety legislation, and to
time to hire or to retrain individuals emphasize its ambition and commitment
to temporarily replace the injured to avoid workplace accidents. It should
employee include a firm management commitment, a
time and cost for repair or replacement communications system, a system to ensure
98
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
99
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
SUSPENSION
TRAUMA
EFFECTS FOLLOWING A FALL FROM HEIGHT
100
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
Therefore, the time spent in a temporary loss of consciousness and into a horizontal position, a natural
vertical position while unconscious postural tone (balance and ability to reaction, is likely to cause a massive
is minimal. This has a significant stand) due to a decrease in the quality return of deoxygenated (and possibly
bearing on the result of the collapse. and/or quantity of blood flow to the toxic) blood to the heart, which is
Assuming no injuries caused during brain. The brain is not good at coping unable to cope, causing cardiac arrest.
the collapse of the soldier, return to with low blood oxygen or low glucose Tolerance to the effects of orthostasis
consciousness will ensue quickly and levels and, in such circumstances, appears to vary between individuals.
recovery is likely to be rapid. syncope can occur. The warning However, evidence shows that given
If a person is suspended in a harness symptoms that are given before sufficient time, orthostatic shock,
in a situation in which the legs are syncope, such as palpitations, nausea, pre-syncopal effects and syncope
immobile, for example, due to injury dizziness, sweating and confusion will occur The onset of these
after a fall, there is no such “natural” are known as pre-syncope. When a effects can be exacerbated by various
move to the horizontal. The time person is upright, for example, stood factors. These include the shock of
spent in this unmoving suspended up or suspended in a harness, blood experiencing the event that caused
position, with the legs below the has to be forced against gravity to the them to be suspended and immobile
heart can have fatal consequences. head, which requires special blood in the first place, the injuries suffered
The fundamental cause of orthostatic pressure regulation. The body does by the casualty, their harness comfort
syncope seems to be venous pooling. not take kindly to anything that level, and possibly their psychological
interferes with its blood circulatory state.
Venous pooling system, such as venous pooling,
Venous pooling is the accumulation and sets off a series of intended Post Rescue
of blood in the veins (typically in the compensatory reactions at the first (Reflow Syndrome)
legs) due to gravity. Some venous signs of any imbalance, the result of Death can occur during or just after
pooling when a person is stood up is which are the symptoms experienced rescue caused by the casualty being
normal. Muscular action in moving in pre-syncope. The body is now in a moved to a horizontal position,
the limbs, together with one-way state of (orthostatic) shock. resulting in a massive return of
valves in the veins, normally assists venous blood to the heart, which
the return of blood in the veins back Further effects is unable to cope and fails (cardiac
to the heart. If the legs are completely Loss of consciousness assures that arrest). It is possible that the unusual
immobile, these “muscle pumps” do a suspended person will not be level of toxins in the venous blood
not operate and an excess of blood moving his or her limbs, so venous plays a part in the effect on the heart.
accumulates in the veins, which are pooling will increase, which will in Death can also occur sometime after
capable of considerable expansion turn reduce the circulating blood rescue, due to renal failure. This is
and, therefore, considerable capacity. volume even further. In addition, any caused by the lack of blood oxygen
Retention of blood in the venous restrictions of the femoral arteries to the kidneys due to the effects of
system reduces the circulating blood and veins caused by the harness venous pooling. The underlying
volume available to the heart. Thus, straps could be a contributory causes of suspension trauma are
the circulatory system is disturbed. factor to venous pooling. Thus, the examined by referring to the findings
During excessive venous pooling, detrimental effects are increased. of the literature already reviewed and
cardiac output and arterial pressure These include not only a potentially other literature.
fall, which may critically reduce fatal reduced blood flow to the
the quantity and/or the quality of brain, but also the effect on other Self Rescue
(oxygenated) blood flowing to the vital organs, such as the kidneys. There are many products on the
brain and precipitate syncope. To The kidneys are also very sensitive market that can be attached to a
demonstrate venous pooling simply to blood oxygen levels and renal harness as well as harnesses with
stand barefoot in a static position and failure as a result of excessive venous rescue systems built in, typically
observe the veins in the feet start to pooling is a real possibility. Unless webbing that allows the suspended
fill and swell, movement of the legs the casualty is rescued very quickly person to stand using foot loops. In
will cause the swelling to return to and unless the rescuers follow a the event of this not being available
normal particular procedure, the effects bringing the knees up to the torso
of venous pooling and syncope are will reduce the onset of venous
Syncope likely to lead to death, as the brain pooling, contracting and relaxing the
A common term for syncope is and kidneys are deprived of vital muscles within the legs may also slow
fainting. Syncope is described as the oxygen. Moving the casualty quickly the pooling process
GRAHAM HICKS - MIIRSM, GRAD IOSH, DIP RSA, ACIEH, HICKS SAFETY AND CONSULTING, PLOIESTI
TEL +40 720439724, E MAIL HSE.HICKSON@BTINTERNET.COM, WEB HICKSAFETY.CO.UK
101
Romania EXPERTS PLATFORM
GABRIELA
ALINA
ROTARU
QSE MANAGER
NUTRE FARMING
F
or most of us, when you think
about farming you remember
about large fields with grains
and grandparents’ yard. At
Nutre Farming we are talking
about cultivation of more
than 18,000 ha, so things have
different dimensions. We are
talking about agriculture,
based on rigorous culture
planning, keeping count of
soil quality, crop rotation,
technological processes,
equipment, risks that may
appear and other specific
needs.
From health and safety
point of view, farming is a
challenging activity with
high risks, taking into
consideration working
environment, operational
processes, machines and
102
EXPERTS PLATFORM Romania
requirements. And yes, sometimes it extinguishers, alarm system in case women bathrooms; women are more
happens to receive penalties. of fire. sensitive to men germs, we want to
In October 2016, we received For environmental area: for waste prevent undesired contamination.
penalties from DSV because we collection, it is needed external For kitchen facilities have purchased
had an internal canteen, which contract with authorized company stainless steel furniture and
wasn’t authorized. At the end of that for collecting animal and non- professional cooking machines.
control, canteen was closed and we animal waste. In order to assure From health and safety point of
had to choose: either we give up this proper waste collection it is needed: view, one of most important part
project or we are going to do it by five europubes for food waste with of utilities is proper number of
the book. Nutre Farming stood up to special pedal (brown - biodegradable stainless steel washbasins, we have
initial decision and decided to invest scrap, gray - residual and metallic eight: one to row material room to
to a new canteen. For this project waste, blue - paper and cardboard, first preparation of vegetable and
we had in mind only our employees, green - glass, yellow - plastic); seven stainless steel washbasins
to give them a hot meal in order to stainless steel pedal pubes to be to cooking area (for the staff foot
make more easy working conditions. used inside cooking area, oil waste operated washer, double washbasin
Decision has been taken, a mixt collector, grease skins and bones for fish and meat, double washbasin
team has been formed and we started waste separator, refrigerated for vegetables and eggs, double
developing project specifications container for meat waste. Also there washbasins for dishes).
with all needed steps. Who is must be a collection for water waste We should not forget about people,
interested what are major actions disposal and there are enough drains who have to attend hygiene
in order to open a canteen for his and leaks. courses and run special medical
employees, he should know that From technical point of view, you examinations.
he has to add a new CAEN code have to make sure that PRAM Very few people will actual serve
for this type of activity. Also he measurements are done and also lunch to canteen, because most of
has to submit need documents ISCIR approval for heating system. them will be on the field. So we had
to Public Health office: technical As health and safety norms, next to find a solution to transport food to
report, framing plan, sketch with to working equipment, that has to the working place. For that, a proper
structure details, statement on the have different colors for cooking and cost effective solution was to
legal possession of space, statement personal compared with responsible use termoboxes with controlled
regarding hygiene conditions, people for cleaning, an important temperature in order to keep the
urban certificate if building suffers part is to have proper sanitary ware. food hot and good to be served.
changes. For the beginning will be Cleaning products must be for If you are wandering what will be
obtained and operation notice, after catering and food industry activities. the costs to all that: for start-up it
that with the same file completed Must be cleaned not only working will be around 30,000 Euro, and for
with operation notice as well, can be surfaces, but proper cleaning must one year around 100,000 Euro. Does
obtained operating permit. be assured for vegetables and eggs, it worth it? From our point of view,
For ANSVSA permit, you have to where are used different type of yes – because we have control on
prepare a similar file, but next to that detergents. Also, a detail attention food quality, ingredients, preparation
you have to make sure that you meet to recipients used for cleaning, so process, transportation – in order
other specification that will assure there must be a minimum 3 types to make sure everything is good
that people health is not put to risks. of double mop divided bucket: red quality. For us, it was better than
Major aspects for this area are: to for bathrooms meaning that toxic catering.
assure a feasible cleaning program, products are used, green for cooking Now that you have already a business
pest control programs, hygiene area meaning that cleaning is done plan, take a cooking book and start
programs checked by sanitation tests, with nontoxic products, blue for doing the job and prepare the meal!
temperature control with calibrated hall or dressing room, meaning Do not forget that each day, to pick-
thermometers, documents outlining that neutral cleaning products are up some samples and store them for
traceability. used. Always use a double mop minim 48 hours, recommended 72,
We didn’t meet conditions for bucket, in order to make sure that and with an established periodicity
fire prevention permits, anyhow cleaning water does not become a run sanitary tests.
we established safety measures as contamination source. Second “must”
well: permanent light signaling, is to have different mops for men and Good appetite!
103
WHO’S
WHO IN
WHO’S
WHO IN
Romania
105
WHO’S
WHO IN
MIHAELA LICHIARDOPOL
ENVIRONMENT& EMERGENCY SITUATION
OFFICER ART(AUTOLIV ROMANIATOTAL)
Area of specialty: Environment &Emergency Situation
Professional distinctions, awards and recognition: Environment Specialist, Environment
Auditor for ISO 14001, OH SAS 18001 Auditor
Education and professional background: Transylvania University Brasov
106
Romania
WHO’S
WHO IN
Romania
107
WHO’S
WHO IN
108
Romania
WHO’S
WHO IN
Romania
109
WHO’S
WHO IN
110
Romania
WHO’S
WHO IN
OBEADA GEORGIANA
HEAD OF EHS DEPARTMENT
Area of specialty: Risk assessment, Environment, Health and Safety Audit, Incidents
and accidents investigation, SEVESO guideline
Education: Bachelor in Engineering and Industrial Environmental Protection
MBA in Quality Management; Postgraduate course of H&S Risk assessment and audit
Environment Management System Auditor
Professional background: SCHAEFFLER ROMANIA, Brasov, 2007 - present
MIRCEA BOSIE
EHS MANAGER
SKANSKA PROPERTY ROMANIA
Area of specialty: Health and Safety
Professional distinctions, awards and recognition: NEBOSH certification IGC1, ICC1,
ICC2, Accident Investigator – Ian Langston,
Education and professional background: Technical University “Gheorghe Asachi”,
Iasi, Construction Civil Engineer, Risk Assessor, H&S Coordinator, Internal auditor
Romania
111
WHO’S
WHO IN
112
Romania
WHO’S
WHO IN
Romania
113
WHO’S
WHO IN
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
“AVRAM IANCU” AL JUDETULUI CLUJ “DROBETA” AL JUDETULUI MEHEDINTI
City: CLUJ NAPOCA City: DROBETA TURNU SEVERIN
Chief inspector: Colonel Ion MOLDOVAN Chief inspector: Colonel Florentin DRAGOMIR
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Colonel Pavel BALTARU Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel
Deputy chief inspector: Bd. 21 Decembrie 1989, nr. 69-71, cod Liviu BURUGA
postal 400124 Deputy chief inspector: Maior Florin DRAGHIA
Tel: 0264 591255 Address: Str. Portului, nr. 2, cod postal 220234
Fax: 0264 593873 Tel: 0252 311212
Email: isujcj@yahoo.com Fax: 0252 311213
Website: www.isucj.ro Email: informarepublica@isumehedinti.ro
Website: www.isumehedinti.ro
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
“IANCU DE HUNEDOARA” AL JUDETULUI HUNEDOARA Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
City: DEVA “BISTRITA” AL JUDETULUI BISTRITA-NASAUD
Chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Viorel DEMEAN City: BISTRITA
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel Chief inspector: Colonel doctor inginer Constantin FLOREA
Claudiu ACHIM Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Colonel inginer Liviu
Address: Str. George Cosbuc, nr. 26, cod postal 330012 Marcel POP
Tel: 0254 214220 Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Ilie RINZIS
Fax: 0254 211212 Address: Str. Sigmirului, nr. 16, cod postal 420158
Email: isuhd@isuhd.ro; isuhd@yahoo.com Tel: 0263 239404
Website: www.isuhd.ro Fax: 0263 236198
Email: isubistrita@yahoo.com
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA Website: www.isu-bistrita.ro
“UNIREA” AL JUDETULUI ALBA
City: ALBA IULIA Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
Chief inspector: Colonel Cornel OPRISA “HOREA” AL JUDETULUI MURES
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel City: TARGU MURES
Nicolae NEGOITA Chief inspector: General de brigada Dr. Ing. Dorin OLTEAN
Deputy chief inspector: Colonel Silviu DOGAR Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel
Address: Str. A. I. Cuza, nr. 10, cod postal 510193 Calin HANDREA
Tel: 0258 810411 Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel inginer Daniel LAZAR
Fax: 0258 810425 Address: Str. Horea, nr. 28, cod postal 540036
Email: isujab@isualba.ro Tel: 0265 269661
Website: www.isualba.ro Fax: 0265 269660
Email: contact@isumures.ro
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA Website: www.isumures.ro
“LOCOTENENT COLONEL DUMITRU PETRESCU” AL
JUDETULUI GORJ Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
City: TARGU JIU “CAPITAN DUMITRU CROITORU” AL JUDETULUI SIBIU
Chief inspector: Maior Traian SUTA City: SIBIU
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel Chief inspector: Colonel Laurentiu Cosmin BALCU
Augustin MALACU Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Colonel Virgil GIURGIU
Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Lucian GHEORGHITA Deputy chief inspector: Maior Claudiu NAN
Address: Calea Bucuresti, nr.9 J, cod postal 210146 Address: Str. Vasile Cirlova, nr. 16-22, cod postal 550017
Tel: 0253 211212 Tel: 0269 211212
Fax: 0253 211706 Fax: 0269 211928
Email: office@isugorj.ro Email: relatii.publice@isusibiu.ro
Website: www.isugorj.ro Website: www.isusibiu.ro
114
Romania
WHO’S
WHO IN
Romania
115
WHO’S
WHO IN
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
“MAIOR CONSTANTIN ENE” AL JUDETULUI BACAU “BASARAB I” AL JUDETULUI DAMBOVITA
City: BACAU City: TARGOVISTE
Chief inspector: Colonel Ioan MIHALACHE Chief inspector: Colonel Mirel PIETREANU
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel First deputy chief inspector: Colonel Ilie CONSTANTINESCU
Ilie HALASANU RAOUL
Deputy chief inspector: Colonel Alfons RAILEANU Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Cezar Nicolae DINCA
Address: Str. Milcov, nr. 49, cod postal 600168 Address: Soseaua Gaesti, nr.9, cod postal 130087
Tel: 0234 550000 Tel: 0245 611212
Fax: 0234 575053 Fax: 0245 634020
Email: office@isubacau.ro Email: contact@isudb.ro; pompieriidambovita@yahoo.com
Website: www.isubacau.ro Website: www.isudb.ro
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
“PODUL INALT” AL JUDETULUI VASLUI “ALEXANDRU DIMITRIE GHICA” AL JUDETULUI TELEORMAN
City: VASLUI City: ALEXANDRIA
Chief inspector: Colonel Ghiorghe BLAGOCI Chief inspector: Colonel Marius STANCU
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Capitan Bogdan Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Colonel Valentin
APETREI POMPILIU MANEA
Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Nicolae TATARU Deputy chief inspector: Colonel Cristian CRACIUNESCU
Address: Str. Castanilor, nr. 9, cod postal 730151 Address: Str. Carpați, nr. 7, cod postal 140050
Tel: 0235 311212 Tel: 0247 311113
Fax: 0235 312110 Fax: 0247 313143
Email: isuvaslui@isuvaslui.ro Email: isuteleorman@isuteleorman.ro
Website: www.isuvaslui.ro Website: www.isuteleorman.ro
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
“TARA BARSEI” AL JUDETULUI BRASOV “MIHAI VITEAZUL” AL JUDETULUI COVASNA
City: BRASOV City: SFANTU GHEORGHE
Chief inspector: Colonel Ioan-Stelian RECHITEAN Chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Adrian Constantin NASTUTA
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel
Lucian MARCIU Viorel TIMAR
Deputy chief inspector: Maior Marcel RUGINA Address: Str. Oltului, nr. 31-33, cod postal 520027
Address: Str. Mihai Viteazul, nr. 11, cod postal 500174 Tel: 0267 315350
Tel: 0268 428888 Fax: 0267 311182
Fax: 0268 543537 Email: covasna@isujcv.ro
Email: contact@isujbv.ro Website: www.isujcv.ro
Website: www.isujbv.ro
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA “VLASCA” AL JUDETULUI GIURGIU
“CAPITAN PUICA NICOLAE” AL JUDETULUI ARGES City: GIURGIU
City: PITESTI Chief inspector: Colonel Emil APOSTOL
Chief inspector: Maior Bogdan OLAR Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Maior Alexandru
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Maior Cristian COVACI
BARBULESCU Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Alin Mihai ROSU
Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Daniel SOARE Address: Str. Dorobanti nr. 19, cod postal 080385
Address: Str. Traian, nr. 26, cod postal 110424 Tel: 0246 215150
Tel: 0248 217400 Fax: 0246 219149
Fax: 0248 611301 Email: inspectorat@isugiurgiu.ro
Email: rel.pub@isuarges.ro Website: www.isugiurgiu.ro
Website: www.isuarges.ro
116
Romania
WHO’S
WHO IN
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
“DEALUL SPIRII” BUCHAREST-ILFOV “GENERAL EREMIA GRIGORESCU” AL JUDETULUI GALATI
City: Bucharest City: GALATI
Chief inspector: Colonel Flaviu-Dorel CHISCOP Chief inspector: Colonel Ion TOMA
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Colonel Orlando Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel
SCHIOPU Fanel Catalin RACOVITA MIC
Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Florin STAN Deputy chief inspector: Colonel Vasile ONU
Address: Calea 13 septembrie nr.135, sector 5, cod postal 050719 Address: Str. Mihai Bravu, nr. 36, cod postal 800208
Tel: 021 2075500 Tel: 0236 460441
Fax: 021 3165116 Fax: 0236 460645
Email: contact@isubif.ro Email: relatiipublice@isujgalati.ro
Website: www.isubif.ro Website: www.isujgalati.ro
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
“SERBAN CANTACUZINO” AL JUDETULUI PRAHOVA “BARBU STIRBEI” AL JUDETULUI CALARASI
City: PLOIESTI City: CALARASI
Chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Mihai DRAGAN Chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Adrian PADURARU
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Maior Iulian
Dumitru ELISEI CIMPEANU
Deputy chief inspector: Colonel Florin STEFAN Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Ionel RUSCAREANU
Address: Str. Rudului, nr. 96, cod postal 100304 Address: Str. Bucuresti nr. 344, cod postal 910058
Tel: 0244 595366 Tel: 0242 311818
Fax: 0244 597000 Fax: 0242 314062
Email: isu_ph@isuprahova.ro Email: contact@isucalarasi.ro
Website: www.isuprahova.ro Website: www.isucalarasi.ro
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
“NERON LUPASCU” AL JUDETULUI BUZAU “BARBU CATARGIU” AL JUDETULUI IALOMITA
City: BUZAU City: SLOBOZIA
Chief inspector: Colonel Nicolae DANUT Chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Laurentiu BACU
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Colonel Viorel Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Colonel Florian LICA
GAVANEANU Deputy chief inspector: Colonel Daniel STANCIU
Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Constantin ROTARU Address: Str. Lacului, nr 23, cod postal 920012
Address: Str. Bistritei, nr.51, cod postal 120112 Tel: 0243 232396
Tel: 0238 721301 Fax: 0243 230088
Fax: 0238 713973 Email: dispecerat@isujialomita.eu; contact@isujialomita.eu
Email: isubuzau@yahoo.com Website: www.isujialomita.eu
Website: www.isubuzau.ro
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA “DUNAREA” AL JUDETULUI BRAILA
“ANGHEL SALIGNY” AL JUDETULUI VRANCEA City: BRAILA
City: FOCSANI Chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Cristian ION
Chief inspector: Colonel Viorel BALLA Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Colonel Jenica LAZAR Georgica BURLACU
Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Vasilica HANTOIU Deputy chief inspector: Capitan Razvan ILIESCU
Address: Str. Dornisoarei, nr. 10 , cod postal 620087 Address: Bd. Dorobantilor, nr. 468, cod postal 810091
Tel: 0237 611212 Tel: 0239 611212
Fax: 0237 625701 Fax: 0239619669
Email: office@isujvn.ro Email: situatii_urgenta@isubraila.eu
Website: www.isujvn.ro Website: www.isubraila.eu
Romania
117
WHO’S
WHO IN
Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA Institution: INSPECTORATUL PENTRU SITUATII DE URGENTA
“DOBROGEA” AL JUDETULUI CONSTANTA “DELTA” AL JUDETULUI TULCEA
City: CONSTANTA City: TULCEA
Chief inspector: Colonel Daniel-Gheorghe POPA Chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Daniel PETROV
Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel Deputy chief inspector for labor relations: Locotenent colonel
Vladut ION Vasile SOAVA
Deputy chief inspector: Maior Mihai GEORGESCU Deputy chief inspector: Locotenent colonel Doru ORGHIEV
Address: Str. Mircea cel Batran, nr. 110, cod postal 900663 Address: Str. 1848, nr. 16, cod postal www.isudelta.ro
Tel: 0241 617381 Tel: 0240 524300
Fax: 0241 616342 Fax: 0240 523700
Email: urgente@isudobrogea.ro Email: isudelta@isudelta.ro
Website: www.isudobrogea.ro Website: www.isudelta.ro
LABOR INSPECTORATES
118
Romania
WHO’S
WHO IN
Romania
119
WHO’S
WHO IN
120
Romania
WHO’S
WHO IN
Romania
121
WHO’S
WHO IN
122
Romania
Romania’s Business News Gate
www.govnet.ro