You are on page 1of 8

CHAPTER 1- INTRODUCTION TO QUALITY Customers – Customer driven quality is fundamental to

The Business Imperative high-performing organizations. Clearly, meeting the


“The first job we have is to turn out quality merchandise expectations of customers is the goal of any business.
that consumers will buy and keep on buying. If we produce
it efficiently and economically, we will earn a profit, in TYPES OF CUSTOMERS
which you will share.” - William Cooper Procter 1. Consumers
Ultimate buyers of goods and services
IMPORTANCE OF QUALITY 2. External customers
QUALITY is uniquely positioned to accelerate organizational Business-to-business
growth through better execution and alignment 3. Internal customers
Anyone who receives goods or services from someone
- provides the voice of the customer critical to developing
else within an organization.
innovative products and services.
- can provide an organization with a competitive edge
INTEGRATING QUALITY PERSPECTIVE IN THE VALUE
- “No quality, no sales. No sales, no profit. No profit, no jobs.”
CHAIN
Quality Profile – Motorola, Inc. The quality perspectives at different points in the value
- Leader in the U.S. quality revolution during the 1980s chain are important to ultimately create and deliver goods
- Pioneer in continual reduction of defects and cycle times and services
- Exceptional practices in managing human assets, sharing The customers is the driving force for the production of
data and information with employees, customers, and goods and services, and customers generally view quality
suppliers, and aligning all its business processes with key from either the transcendent or the product perspective.
organizational objectives. - Individuals in different business functions—for
example, the designer, manufacturer or service
provider, distributor, or customer- speak different
WHAT IS QUALITY?
“languages”. Thus, different quality perspective at
Quality can be a confusing concept, partly because people
different points in the value chain are important to
view quality subjectively and in relation to differing criteria
ultimately create and deliver goods and services that
based on their individual roles in the production-marketing
will satisfy customers need and expectations.
value chain.
In addition, the meaning of quality continues to evolve as
QUALITY PERSPECTIVES
the quality profession grows and matures.
For example, one study that asked managers of 86 firms in
the eastern United States to define quality produced
several dozen different responses, including the following.
• Perfection
• Consistency
• Eliminating waste
• Speed of delivery
• Compliance with policies and procedures
• Providing a good, usable product
• Doing it right the first time
• Delighting or pleasing customer
• Total customer service satisfaction Formal

DEFINITIONS OF QUALITY
1. Transcendent Perspective: excellence HISTORY OF QUALITY MANAGEMENT
-to rise above or extend beyond ordinary limits As the philosopher GEORGE SANTAYANA said, “those who
-judgemental definition of quality cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.’’
2. Product Perspective: quantities of product attributes Thus, an understanding of the history of quality can be
-quantity of some product attribute
quite insightful. Quality has been an important aspect of
3. User Perspective: fitness for intended use
production operations throughout the history.
-how well the product perform its intended functions.
4. Value Perspective: quality vs. price
1. Ancient History
-relationship of product benefits to price - Zhou Dynasty in China
5. Manufacturing Perspective: conformance to specifications
2. The Age of Craftsmanship
-Consumers and Organization want consistency in goods and - Skilled workers during the Middle Ages
services. - Industrial Revolution
-Specification are targets and tolerance determined by 3. Early 20th Century
designer of goods and services - Separate quality departments
6. Customer Perspective: meeting or exceeding customer - Ford Motor Company
expectations - Statistical methods and quality assurance
- totality of features and characteristics of a product or Professional societies and publications
services that bears on its ability to satisfy given needs.
4. Post World War II
- Evolution of quality management in Japan
- W. EDWARDS DEMING – Father of total quality
management. 14 points
- JOSEPH JURAN – founder of range of quality
techniques. Quality Management Approach
5. U.S. “Quality Revolution”
- Quality crisis around 1980
- Growth of product quality awareness in
manufacturing industries
6. Early Successes CONTEMPORARY INFLUENCES ON QUALITY
- Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award (1987) In 2011, the American Society for quality identified eight
- Books, consulting, training key forces that will influence the future of quality.
7. From Product Quality to Total Quality Management
- “Little Q” vs. “Big Q” and TQM 1. Global Responsibility- an organization must be fully
aware of global impact of its local decisions and realize
MANAGEMENT FAILURES that as demand grows for the planet’s finite resources,
- Cynicism and disinterest waste is increasingly unacceptable. Global
- “No, TQM isn’t dead. TQM failures just prove that responsibility also involves, labor practices, human
bad management is still alive and kicking.” rights, consumer rights, fair operating practices, and
EARLY MANAGEMENT FAILURES contribution to society.
1. Poor Strategies 2. Consumer awareness- With today’s technology such as
2. Flawed Organizational approaches internet, twitter, facebook and Instagram, consumer
3. Flawed Management System have access to a wealth information on which to make
purchasing decision.
PERFORMANCE EXCELLENCE 3. Globalization- Globalization no longer means just an
1. Role of leadership opportunity for organizations to enter new markets.
2. Strategic plans Today, firms must contend with a growing number of
3. How data and information's use in decision making competitors and sources of lower-cost labor and
4. Improved environmental conditions assume the risks associated with global supply chains.
4. Increasing rate of change- Technology has shifted the
- From the perspective , the product focused notion of rate of change into an entirely new gear, which brings
quality evolved into a new concept called with its opportunities and threats.
PERFORMANCE EXCELLENCE- define as an integrated
5. Workforce of the future- Competition for talent will
approach to organizational management.
increase, and along with technological advances, will
- Focus on customer value, organizational sustainability,
change how and where work is done.
improvement of effectiveness and capabilities, and
6. Aging population- as people live longer, organizations
organizational and personal learning
face higher cost for healthcare and social welfare
program.
EMERGENCE OF SIX SIGMA 7. Twenty-first century quality- quality is not the
- a customer-focused, results-oriented approach to same as it was 50 years ago, even five years ago.
business improvement Quality is moving beyond the organization’s walls to
- -New approached of quality improvement during 1990’s encompass a customer’s entire experience either the
- -customer focused, result oriented approach organization rather that just the quality of the product
- -integrate many traditional quality improvement which or service.
are validated and tested over the years.
8. Innovation- according to study, INNOVATION is ‘’the
pursuit of something different and exciting.’’
GLOBALIZATION OF QUALITY
Innovation lies at the heat of organizational survival. As
-due to high competition around the world. The global
the study states, “if the innovation means the ability of
marketplace, domestic and even international organization
a company to anticipate customer needs—expressed or
realized that, in order to survive in the competition they
unexpressed, known or unknown—and bring products
need to defend on high quality.
or services to the marketplace that excite customers,
- Many countries have mounted efforts to increased quality
then clearly innovation in the fuel of growth in today’s
awareness, including conferences, seminars, radio show, school
essay contest, pamphlet distribution, publications & etc. changing world, and more so tomorrow.”

CURRENT AND FUTURE CHALLENGES  These eight forces will impact how organizations
- The challenge today is to ensure the managers continue configure themselves, how managers plan and lead,
to focus on quality management performance and how all workers will perform to achieve quality. As
excellence through their organization. ASQ noted “Quality should shape society. Ultimately,
- A former Xerox president DAVID KEARNS observed, quality methodology will be used to build a better
“Quality is a race without a finish line.” world.”
GROWTH OF MODERN QUALITY MANAGEMENT
MANUFACTURING SYSTEMS Critical Differences Between Service And Manufacturing
Quality management is rooted in manufacturing; therefore, • Customer needs and performance standards are more
that is where we will begin. In image below, it illustrates a difficult to identify and measure.
typical manufacturing system and the key relationships • Services requires a higher degree of customization.
among its function. • Output is intangible.
• Services are produced and consumed simultaneously.
• Customers are often involved in actual process.
• Services are more labor-intensive than manufacturing.
• Services handle large numbers of transactions.

COMPONENTS OF SERVICE QUALITY


 PEOPLE “If we take care of our people, they will take
care of our customers.”
 TECHNOLOGY - E-commerce
- Computers and information technology

QUALITY IN BUSINESS SUPPORT FUNCTIONS


FINANCE AND ACCOUNTING
- The FINANCE function is responsible for obtaining fund,
controlling their use, analyzing investment opportunities,
and ensuring that the firm operates cost effectively and
QUALITY IN MARKETING
ideally profitably.
- Marketing and sales personnel are responsible for
- Financial and accounting personnel who have contacts
determining the needs and expectations of consumers.
with the customers can directly influence the service their
company provides.
QUALITY IN PRODUCT DESIGN - For example, in many countries, employees chart invoice
- Product design and engineering functions develop accuracy, the time needed to process invoices, and the time
technical specifications for products and production processes
needed to pay bills. In addition, they can apply quality
to meet the requirements determined by the marketing
improvement techniques to improve their own operations.
function.

LEGAL SERVICES
QUALITY IN PURCHASING
- A firm’s legal department attempts to guarantee that the
- A purchasing agent should not simply be responsible for
firm complies with laws and regulations regarding such
low-cost procurement but should maintain a clear focus on
things as product labeling, packaging, safety, and
the quality of purchased goods and materials.
transportation; designs and words its warranties properly;
satisfies its contractual requirements; and has proper
QUALITY IN PRODUCTION PLANNING AND SCHEDULING
procedures and documentation in place in the event of
- Poor quality often results from time pressures caused by
liability claims against it. The rapid liability suits have made
insufficient planning and scheduling.
legal services and important aspect of quality.

QUALITY IN MANUFACTURING AND ASSEMBLY


QUALITY ASSURANCE
- Both technology and people are essential to high-quality
- Because some managers lack the technical expertise
manufacturing.
required for performing needed statistical test or data
analyses, technical specialist usually in the “Quality
QUALITY IN PROCESS DESIGN
Assurance Department’ they are the who assist the manger
- Manufacturing processes must be capable of producing
in these tasks.
output that meets specifications consistently.
Quality assurance specialist perform special statistical
studies and analyses and may be assigned to work with any
QUALITY IN FINISHED GOODS INSPECTION AND TESTING of the manufacturing or business support functions.
- The purposes of final product inspection are to judge the - A customer driven quality focus must involve every
quality of manufacturing, to discover and help to resolve function in the organization, including manufacturing,
production problems that may arise, and to ensure that no service and business support functions. Quality is needed
defective items reach the customer. everyone’s responsibility.

QUALITY IN INSTALLATION AND SERVICE COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE


-Service after the sale is one of the most important factors Competitive Advantage denotes firm’s ability to achieve
in establishing customer perception of quality and customer market superiority.
loyalty. - Is driven by customer wants and needs.
- Makes significant contribution to business success.
QUALITY IN SERVICES - Matches organization’s unique resources with opportunities.
-SERVICE is defined as “any primary or complementary - Is durable and lasting.
activity that does not directly produce a physical product – - Provides basis for further improvement.
that is, the non-goods part of the transaction between - Provides direction and motivation.
buyer (customer) and seller (provider).”
 To meet or exceed customer expectations,
Quality and Profitability organizations must fully understand all product
attributes contribute to customer value leads to
satisfaction in loyalty.

CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AND ENGAGEMENT


CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
 The result of delivering a product or service that

meets customers requirements.


 "Customer satisfaction is vital to keeping customer
and growing business."
 Customer satisfaction and loyalty have evolved into a
new concept called CUSTOMER ENGAGEMENT.
 customer satisfaction drives PROFITABILITY.
 CUSTOMER ENGAGEMENT - refers to customers
investment in a commitment in or commitment to
brand product offerings.

THE AMERICAN CUSTOMER SATISFACTION INDEX


 During 1994, The University of Michigan business
Quality and Business Results school in the American Customer Satisfaction for
 Hendricks and Singhal study of quality award winners Quality (ASQ), release the first ACSI.
 Performance results of Baldrige Award recipients  American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI) - an
Example: The overall Net Promoter (NP) scores (a loyalty economic indicator that measures customer
metric defined by the level of repeat sales and referrals) for satisfaction at the national level.
MEDRAD, a manufacturer of medical imaging devices, were
consistently 60 percent or higher compared to the 50
percent or higher marks for other organizations nationwide.
MEDRAD’s global customer satisfaction ratings using the NP
system steadily increased from 50 percent to 63 percent,
surpassing the best-in-class benchmark of 50 percent.

Quality and Personal Values


 Personal initiative has a positive impact on business
success
IDENTIFYING CUSTOMER
 Quality-focused individuals often exceed customer
The first step in being customer focus is to understand
expectations
 Quality begins with personal attitudes
who are your customers.
 Attitudes can be changed through awareness and
effort (e.g., personal quality checklists) WHO WILL BE YOUR TARGET MARKET?
Customers are those people who ultimately purchase and
“Unless quality is internalized at the personal level, it will use a company's product.
never become rooted in the culture of an organization.”
“Thus, quality must begin at a personal level (and that
means you!).” AT&T's CUSTOMER - SUPPLIER MODEL

CHAPTER 2: CUSTOMER FOCUS


CUSTOMER FOCUS
 might be the most important principle of quality
management.
 Without customers, you don't have a business
 Customer are important because they are the
consumers of product/service
 Customers generate profit by means of patronizing a
product
 OKYAKUSAMA- means customer or honorable guest
TWO TYPES OF CUSTOMERS
1. Internal Customer - The recipient of another's output
 Perceptions of value and satisfaction are influence by
(which the product or services or any information)
means of many factors throughout the customers
inside the organization.
overall purchase, ownership, and service experience.
2. Satisfiers (wants)
2. External Customers - those who fall between the -requirements that customers expressly say they want.
organization and the consumer, but are not part of 3. Exciters/Delighters (never thought of)
the organization. -new or innovative features that customers do not
expect or anticipate.
FUNDAMENTAL QUESTIONS TO IDENTIFY CUSTOMERS
1. What goods and services are produced by your work?  INNOVATIONS, however, are not excited or
2. Who uses this products and services? delighters for long.
3. Who do I call, write, or answer questions for?  As a customer became familiar with them,
4. Who supplies the inputs to my process? exciters/delighters become satisfiers over time.

CUSTOMER SEGMENTATION GATHERING DEVICE OF THE CUSTOMER


Customers generally have different requirements and THE VOICE OF THE CUSTOMERS - customers requirements,
expectations. as expressed in the customer's own terms.
1. Geography-is to accessible by your customers? Location
2. Demographic - age, limit, occupations, or gender of SOME OF THESE APPROACHES FOR GATHERING
customers that will use the product. CUSTOMER INFORMATIONS INCLUDE:
3. Usage- the amount of customers that will use the 1. Comment cards and formal surveys
product. How long it will last. 2. Focus groups
4. Volumes 3. Direct customer contact
5. Level Of Service 4. Field intelligence
5. Complaints
UNDERSTANDING CUSTOMER NEEDS 6. Internet and social media monitoring
-It begins with a diff understanding of the people who
might use whatever product or services that eventually ANALYZING VOICE OF THE CUSTOMER DATA
emerges from its work, drawing from anthropology, AFFINITY DIAGRAM
psychology, biomechanics, and others.  A useful tool for organizing large volume of
information efficiently and identifying natural
QUALITY DIMENSIONS OF GOODS AND SERVICES patterns for group in the information.
DAVID A GARVIN - he suggested that the product have  Main ingredient of the KJ METHOD, develop in the
multiple dimensions of quality. 1960s by KAWAKITA JIRO, a Japanese anthropologist.

MULTIPLE DIMENSIONS OF QUALITY LINKING CUSTOMER NEEDS TO DESIGN,


1. Performance -primary operating characteristics. Battery life
PRODUCTION, AND SERVICE DELIVERY.
2. Features - different applications or standard
VOC information must be link to design production and
3. Reliability - It can last for a period of time
delivery process.
4. Conformance to rules and regulations according to law
5. Durability - product doesn't break easily. Ex.Shockproof
A study of internet bank service found that customers
6. Serviceability –warranties & availability of spare parts
perceive quality along three bread categories;
7. Aesthetics - overall appearance of the product
1. CUSTOMER SERVICE QUALITY - reliability,
responsiveness, competence, courtesy, credibility, access,
For services, research has identified; communication, understanding the customer,
5 PRINCIPAL DIMENSION IN CUSTOMERS PERCEPTION IN collaboration, and continuous improvement.
QUALITY. 2. BANKING SERVICE PRODUCT QUALITY - product
1. Reliability - The product can survive in specific condition quality and diverse features.
2. Assurance - ability to convey trust into a customers 3. ONLINE SYSTEM QUALITY - content, accuracy, ease
3. Tangibles - equipment or machineries used to of use, timeliness, aesthetics, and security.
perform the service
4. Empathy- degree of caring for the customers MANAGING CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP
5. Responsiveness - ability to respond or conform to Customer relationship can be fostered through strategic
customer's needs partnership and alliances using TECHNOLOGY to
facilitate better communication with customer linkages to
THE KANO MODEL OF CUSTOMER REQUIREMENT internal operations.
NORIAKI KANO - professor emeritus of the Tokyo
University of Science. BUILDING A CUSTOMER FOCUSED ORGANIZATION
-suggested SEGMENTING CUSTOMERS REQUIREMENT in  It must be built on good politics, good people, and
two three groups: good processes.
1. Dissatisfiers (must haves)  An organization fosters customer satisfaction and
-basic requirements that customers expected in a engagement by developing trust, communicating
product or service.
with customers, and effectively managing the -customers doesn't repeat purchase
interactions and relationships with customer.
MEASURING CUSTOMER LOYALTY
KEY PROCESSES  SATISFACTION is different from LOYALTY.
1. Making sincere commitments to customers COMMONLY USED FACTORS TO MEASURE CUSTOMER
2. Intruding quality customer contact LOYALTY:
3. Selecting and developing customer contact employee 1. Overall satisfaction
-selecting a representative of the organization for 2. Likelihood of the first time purchaser to repurchase
addressing complaints 3. Likelihood to recommend
4. Managing complaints and service recovery 4. Likelihood to continue purchasing the same product
-vital element to maintain customer relationship or service
-resolving in addressing customer complaints 5. Likelihood to increase frequency of purchasing
6. Likelihood to switch to different provider
MEASURING CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AND
ENGAGEMENT
CHAPTER 3 : WORKFORCE FOCUS
SOME APPROACHES THE TRUCK CUSTOMER
WORKFORCE
SATISFACTION -Refers to everyone who is actively involved in
1. Transactional Customer Satisfaction Index accomplishing the work of an organization.
-immediate response/ feedback from customers
2. Relationship Customer Satisfaction Workforce Satisfaction is strongly related to customer
- specific features that a customer likes satisfaction, and ultimately to business performance.
3. Competitive Study
-comparison between products or services
THE EVOLUTION OF WORKFORCE MANAGEMENT
FREDERICK W. TAYLOR
DESIGNING SATISFACTION SURVEY
-promulgate the departure from the craftmanship
 The first step in developing a customer survey is to
concept. (1990’s)
determine its purpose; that is, what research
-He introduce a management approached knowns as
question does the organization wants to answer?
Scientific Management that focuses on the idea of
 Customer satisfaction measurement should not be
scientific selection of employees based on their
confined to external customers.
capabilities.
 The next issue to address is, who should conduct the
survey?
HAWTHORNE STUDIES
 Likert scale -commonly used in measuring the response.
The Hawthorne Studies are credited with focusing
managerial strategy on the socio-psychological aspect of
human behavior organizations.

ANALYZING AND USING CUSTOMER FEEDBACK WORKFORCE MANAGEMENT


DEMING stressed the importance of using customers -also called Human Resource Management or HRM- this
feedbacks to improve a company's products and is an organizational function which facilitates the most
processes. valuable asset of the organization –its employees
 Many businesses for example, the managers annual
bonuses to a customer satisfaction result.
THREE STAGES OF EMPLOYMENT CYCLE
-This feedback from customers drives motivation to
1. Pre Hire- Planning , Job Analysis
employees to produce high quality products.
2. Hire- Recruitment and Selection
3. Post Hiring -Training and Development, Appraising ang
WHY MANY CUSTOMER SATISFACTION EFFORTS FAIL?
Managing Performance, Compensation, Health and
Determining and using customer satisfaction should be
Safety, Separation
viewed as a key business process.
 Just going through the motions can often lead to failure.
Strategic Human Resource Management
1. Poor measurement schemes
- Is concerned with the contributions HR strategies make
-improper distribution of demographics
organizational effectiveness, and how this contributions
2. Failure to identify appropriate quality dimensions
are accomplished.
3. Failure to weight mentions approximately
4. Lack of comparison with leading competitors
-it is important to know the strengths and HIGH PERFORMANCE WORK CULTURE
weaknesses of the organization Performance- simply means the extent to which
5. Failure to measure potential and former customers individual contributes to achieving the goals and
6. Confusing loyalty with satisfaction objectives of an organization.
High Performance- refers to work approaches used to 2 MOST COMMON TYPE OF MOTIVATION
systematically pursue ever-higher level of overall 1. Extrinsic Motivation: This type of motivation refers to
organizational and human performance. factors that are outside of the person
2. Intrinsic Motivation: is a type of motivation that
KAY KENDALL and GLENN BODISON occurs within the individual
-propose five “Conditions of Collaboration” that
characterized a culture of high performance: FACTOR’S OF MOTIVATION
1. Respect •Leadership
2. Values •Recognition and Appreciation
•Meaning and Purpose
3. Purpose
•Positive Company Culture
4. Communication
•Professional Development Opportunities
5. Trust •Job Enhancement Opportunities
PRINCIPLES OF WORKPLACE ENGAGEMENT •Financial Benefits
AND MOTIVATION •Flexible Work Schedules
•Pride
Workforce Engagement
•Open Communication
-refers to the extent of workforce commitment, both
•Staying up to date on Company Matters
emotional and intellectual , to accomplishing the work, •Job Security
mission, an vision of the organization. •A positive work environment
-employees are motivated through exciting work,
responsibility, and recognition. Engagement means that
DESIGNING HIGH PERFORMANCE WORK SYSTEM
workers find personal meaning and motivation in their work.
Work Design –refers to how employees are organized in
formal and informal units, such as department and teams
Engagement means that workers find personal meaning
Job Design – refers to responsibilities and task assigned
and motivation in their work
to individuals.

TOP 10 DRIVERS OF WORKFORCE ENGAGEMENT JOB DESIGN CHARACTERISTICS:


1. Commitment to Organizational values
1. Task significance
2. Knowing that customers are satisfied with products
2. Task Identity
and services. 3. Beliefs that opinions count
3. Skill Variety
4. Clearly understand work expectations
4. Autonomy
5. Understand of how personal contributions help meet
5. Feedback from the Job
customer needs.
6. Being recognized and rewarded fairly
SEVERAL COMMON APPROACHES TO WORK DESIGN:
7. Knowing that senior leaders value the workforce
1. Job Enlargement
8. Being treated equally with respect
2. Job Rotation
9. Being able to concentrate on the job and work processes
3. Job Enrichment
10. Alignment of personal work objectives to work plans

EMPOWERMENT
Employee Involvement (EI)
-simply means giving people authority.
-refers to any activity by which employees participate in
work related decisions and improvement activities, with
TEAMWORK
the objectives of tapping the creative energies of all
Team – is a group who work together and cooperate to
employees and improving their motivation.
share work and responsibility.
Teamwork breaks down the barriers among individuals,
Employee Suggestion System
departments, and line and staff functions
Is a management tool for the submission, evaluation, and
implementation of an employee's idea to save cost,
MOST COMMON TEAMS ARE:
increase quality, or improve other elements of work such
1. Management Teams
as safety.
2. Natural Work Teams
3. Self-Managed Teams
MOTIVATION
4. Virtual Teams
Saul W. Gellerman defined motivation as “the art of
5. Quality Circles
creating conditions that allow every one of us, warts and
6. Problem Solving Teams
all, to get his work done at his own peak level efficiently.
7. Project Teams

Motivation refers to the process that guides and


WORKPLACE ENVIRONMENT
maintains behaviors that help employees work towards a
Employee’s are the key stakeholder of any organization.
particular goal or effectively perform tasks.
Health and Safety have always been priorities in the most
companies.
WORKFORCE LEARNING AND DEVELOPMENT
Compensation and Recognition
-refers to all aspect of pay and reward, including
promotions, bonuses, and recognition, either monetary
and non- monetary, individual or group.

PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT
Performance Appraisal- is a process for subjectively
evaluating the quality of an employees work.

ASSESSING WORKPLACE EFFECTIVENESS,


SATISFACTION, AND ENGAGEMENT
-Voice of the employee’s (VOE)
-Formal Surveys

MEASURING WORKFORCE ENGAGEMENT


Q12 – an instrument implemented by the
GALLUP ORGANIZATION
-These include factors like knowing what is expected in
one’s work; having the right materials and equipment to
do the job, receiving recognition and feedback on
progress and development; having opinions that count,
feeling of importance of the job; and opportunities to
learn grow and develop.

You might also like