Republic of the Philippines

MARINDUQUE STATE COLLEGE

GASAN BRANCH
Banuyo, Gasan, Marinduque
Email: mscfisheries@yahoo.com
Tel. No. (042) 753-038

Bachelor of Science in Fisheries

Re-Accredited, Level III Phase 1-AACCUP, Inc.

Which of the arguments presented is the most sound and valid? Support your answers.
The strongest and most convincing argument, in my opinion, is the advantages one. Although
the moral wrongness of discriminating against the disabled and the sanctity of life are both
valid points, the benefit argument is more persuasive. Baby Jane's condition is very critical and
should not be ignored. She has a human right to treatment and surgery, but we also need to
take into account all the circumstances surrounding her case. What's the purpose if you're
going to risk her life, the doctor argued, even if she receives therapy, not much will change, and
she won't truly gain from it.
From your personal viewpoint, how would you decide on the side of Baby Jane Doe?
I think the wisest and safest course of action is to decide against having surgery. Because
surgery is not a simple procedure, the patient's life is more in danger. The worst case for her
condition is that she succumbs to the pain and side effects of the medication. I think it will be
much safer if she just keeps acting the same way since the operation won't help her anyhow.
Whose arguments will you consider in the issue?
My answers to the first two questions, I believe, make it apparent that I will take the benefit
argument into account. I'd rather keep her life safe and allow her to live until the day she can
rather than risk it with a treatment that won't heal her illness and let her have a normal life.
Let us construct the following arguments for the given dilemma:

1. The Benefit Argument

If no one would profit from it, they shouldn't offer the drug to the patients in vials
despite the fact that doing so is not recommended.
The benefit to Lucky's brother comes from the fact that he gained money from the
deed. However, because of the medicine's addictive properties and the fact that Lucky's
brother is providing the drug to the patient in exchange for payment, there is a greater
chance that many patients may become addicted.

2.The Argument on Professional Code of Conduct

A nurse's duty is to support and assist patients who are in need. They are required by
their code of conduct to scrupulously abide by the hospital's rules and regulations. As a
Goal: Provide competent, committed and responsible fishery professionals who are equipped with sufficient knowledge, skills and right attitude in the use of modern practices to Aquaculture and
Coastal Management.
Objectives:
1. Educate students in the field of Fisheries who can contribute to the country’s need for sustainable Fisheries and proper concepts of Fisheries Management, Environmental Management
and Multi-Sectoral Approaches to Coastal Management.
2. Make students knowledgeable in statistical tools, computer use, social equity, extension service, economics and proper handling of fish to reduce losses.
3. Help students acquire knowledge and competencies in all aspects of Fisheries such as Aquaculture, Capture Fisheries, Post-Harvest Fisheries and Aquatic Resources Management and be
capable to do research
 Republic of the Philippines
MARINDUQUE STATE COLLEGE
GASAN BRANCH
Banuyo, Gasan, Marinduque
Email: mscfisheries@yahoo.com
Tel. No. (042) 753-038

Bachelor of Science in Fisheries

Re-Accredited, Level III Phase 1-AACCUP, Inc.

result, Nurse Lucky made a mistake by keeping the vials' discovery under the sink a
secret. The other nurses who took part in the conduct should also face consequences,
including possible license revocation. They might not be held liable as long as their
actions don't affect the patients' health, but what if they do? Therefore, stopping it until
no one is harmed is the best course of action.
3.The Wrongness on the Act of Cheating
Cheating is never appropriate, no matter what the situation. No matter how noble your
intentions may be, irresponsible behavior is never acceptable.

Goal: Provide competent, committed and responsible fishery professionals who are equipped with sufficient knowledge, skills and right attitude in the use of modern practices to Aquaculture and
Coastal Management.
Objectives:
1. Educate students in the field of Fisheries who can contribute to the country’s need for sustainable Fisheries and proper concepts of Fisheries Management, Environmental Management
and Multi-Sectoral Approaches to Coastal Management.
2. Make students knowledgeable in statistical tools, computer use, social equity, extension service, economics and proper handling of fish to reduce losses.
3. Help students acquire knowledge and competencies in all aspects of Fisheries such as Aquaculture, Capture Fisheries, Post-Harvest Fisheries and Aquatic Resources Management and be
capable to do research