Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spoken Latin:
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 191.101.81.46, on Learning,
03 Jul 2018Teaching, Lecturing
at 22:29:43, subject and Research
to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at 47
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2058631018000065
comprise an academic introduction to think English is part of his national to be reachable by train. I would like to
British literature written in Latin, and heritage. A Briton may like Schiller, but make sure in this article that we all remain
provide an overview of its periods and will never pretend that the German alert to this too, and so reap the fruits of
genres. It will dwell on detailed language has a significant presence in his their decades of work in the area
commentary and discussion of specific national culture. However, a Briton is (Licoppe, 2014).
key texts (Monmouth, More, Francis aware that Latin has an inextricable and Two European endeavours stand out
Bacon), and further explore the rich pervasive part in his national history and above the rest in their success and their
cultural connection between Britain and is core to his cultural heritage. A German practical achievement, the Académía
the rest of Europe (e.g. epistolography feels that Latin is intrinsic to his national Vívárium Novum, based near Rome
between More and Erasmus). Once again culture too. A Hungarian considers Latin (Italy), and the Cursus Æstívus Latínitátis
the module will be delivered in Latin. the very same way as well. It is a very Vívæ Matríténsis, held yearly in the
These two modules constitute a giant powerful experience to meet Germans, summer in Madrid (Spain).
stride for spoken Latin in the United French, Hungarians, Poles, and feel that The Académía Vívárium Novum
Kingdom. In an intensive regime of full we are communicating in a language, the (https://vivariumnovum.net/) is based in
Latin language immersion, they bring only language, that we can all feel is really a Renaissance villa next to ancient
together ancient and modern scholarship ours in the same way, a language that Tusculum, and currently holds the
to advance knowledge of two important automatically immerses us all in a culture greatest reputation in the spoken Latin
areas: the genuine nuances of idiomatic that we all feel is our own in the same way. world, deservingly so on account of the
usage in the Latin of the native period in For some reason, although the level of fluency participants reach. It
classical Rome, and the often neglected British are known for their ease to travel hosts male youths under 24 for free
and yet exuberant and momentous around the world, I have had quite a hard during the academic year (October to
treasure of national British literature time trying to persuade fellow British June), and has an extended summer
originally produced in the Latin language Latin speakers to go abroad to meet the school (four or eight weeks) open to all
through the ages. wider international community we are a genders and ages. Many illustrative videos
part of. I hope the readers of these lines can be found on YouTube. Most of the
will be encouraged to be a bit more students behind the recent flourishing of
The international dimension of adventurous.
When UK Latinists discuss
living Latin at Oxford have strong links
with this academy.
speaking Latin institutions that promote speaking Latin, The Cursus Æstivus Latinitatis Vivæ
their hearts and thoughts often fly first to Matritensis (CÆLVM) is a now five-year-
As we have seen, the British Latinist has the USA. This is understandable, but it old initiative in Madrid (http://www.
an increasing number of occasions to get somewhat circumvents the experiences I culturaclasica.com/?q=caelum) which
involved in spoken Latin at home. This was commending above that come from readers of this journal should mark as
has to be celebrated, every local communing with Latin speakers of uniquely specialising in teacher training
opportunity seized and all endeavours different mother tongues. for spoken Latin through intensive
fostered. However, the larger provision is I am satisfied that good information summer courses of one week. It attracts
still to be found abroad. This is not a bad has been gathered in the literature (Hunt, about 180 Latin teachers every summer.
thing, for various reasons. It is not 2016; Lloyd, 2016), regarding the Some Spanish is used at the opening and
uncommon to suspect that initiatives of Professor Terence Tunberg closing of the course, but all other
communication in Latin is some kind of at the University of Kentucky (Institute course activity takes place in Latin. A
pretence which only works because we are for Latin Studies & Conventiculum good sample video (more on YouTube)
all thinking of the same English words Latinum), as well as those of the is this one from the 2014 event:
and expressions hiding beneath the incomparable Reginald Foster’s disciples https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=
amusing sounds. There is no better way to at the Paideia Institute, of Nancy 2f5VpyFoznU&index=2&list=PL6PTtr
allay this suspicion than to start speaking Llewellyn at the North American Institute PBAg9xuW8733IZ3IzYKIcQEVcmF
Latin with native speakers of German or of Living Latin Studies (SALVI), and of The Collegium Latinitatis (http://
Polish, and realise that we indeed the amazing Justin Slocum Bailey at www.collegiumlatinitatis.com/) is an
understand each other in Latin through Indwelling Language. Information also initiative of a passionate group of Latin
Latin alone, and that there is no circulates about the work of Jason Harris teachers from Valencia (Spain) closely
underlying common language that could at University College Cork, in Ireland, and involved in the CÆLVM. They are
explain the phenomenon. The Latin we Christopher Rico at the Polis Institute, in likewise intent on improving teaching
have all been learning from our Cicero or Israel. The reader should easily be able to standards of Latin at all levels of
our Seneca still communicates. This is in find much more on all of these wonderful education. They teach Latin literature in
itself an experience of the vigour of the endeavours through the internet, and I Latin, and also organise guided visits in
language worth going abroad for. But wholeheartedly commend experiencing Latin of the Museo del Prado in Madrid
there is more. I am persuaded that living each and every one of them. (there are videos on YouTube).
the international dimension of Latin is As Tunberg points out in his online The most veteran organisations
essential to understand the real cultural videos though, the breeding ground of all however, which in many ways set the
importance of this language. A Hungarian this was in continental Europe, where the foundations for all of the aforementioned,
may admire Shakespeare, but will never initiatives still thrive, and which happens and which are still active to various
48 Spoken Latin:
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 191.101.81.46, on 03 Learning,
Jul 2018 atTeaching, Lecturing
22:29:43, subject andCambridge
to the Research Core terms of use, available at
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2058631018000065
extents, and so worth exploring, are in took place in Kentucky 27–31/7/2017). way that develops the linguistic instincts
Germany and Belgium. Its website used to have a section aimed at conducive to fluency. It is also the method
The Societas Latina Saravipontana of gathering information on all current living of choice for the aforementioned
the University of Saarland is the child of Latin initiatives, but they seem to be speaking Latin initiatives of Oxford and
late Cælestis Eichenseer, one of the most currently unable to offer such a crucially London. The enhanced version produced
influential spoken Latin advocates of his needed service. The academy has suffered by the Académía Vívárium Novum is
time. It still publishes the Latin periodical many vicissitudes in its long history supported by a tremendous wealth of
Vox Latina and organises two spoken (Licoppe, 2014) and needs our resources: https://vivariumnovum.it/
Latin seminars per year (click on seminaria involvement in order to be able to provide catalogo/latino/corso-base
Latinitatis vivæ at: http://www.voxlatina. a cohesive and effective centre for Ørberg recorded the text of his
uni-saarland.de/). speaking Latin endeavours at an method himself with very good
The Septimanæ Latinæ Europææ, international level. pronunciation, despite rather fast diction,
now very popular and attracting a younger A good way to obtain further probably in an attempt to fit as much as
crowd of school and university students, information and support for speaking possible onto every tape! Now iTunes has
also has two spoken Latin seminars each Latin is through the many Latin Circles audio files of all of this, most of them
year, at Amöneburg in Hessen and that spread from Seattle to Hong Kong. free: https://itunes.apple.com/us/
Freising near Munich (http://www. Their websites (not all of them active) can album/familia-romana-latine-audio/
septimanalatina.org/). be found listed in several places, and for 528790763
The Latinitati Vivæ Provehendæ instance here: https://www.google.com/ Ørberg’s method is somewhat similar
Associatio (LVPA) also organised maps/d/viewer?mid=1IErsi89dopBy to the graded reading approach of Reading
immersion seminars, often in Eastern 9tPtiW2h12stDWs&hl=en_US&ll=8.800 Latin, but is completely self-explanatory
Europe (mostly Poland, although I once 841462142246%2C133.480009&z=1 in Latin, and so requires no use of any
attended a wonderful one in Serbia), but Of course, even more information vernacular at all.
I am uncertain about its current activities than this can be found through Google, Lingua Latina per se illustrata does not
(http://www.lvpa.de/). and the scores of spoken Latin videos on refer to any modern contexts. In case of
A now independent scion of the YouTube. any specific interest in that direction, a
above is the Schola Æstiva Posnaniensis, good option, among a few others, would
which organises summer courses in Poland be Robert Maier et al., Piper Salve, Cursus
(https://scholaaestivaposnaniensis.
wordpress.com/).
Some notes on Latin school Vivæ Latinitatis, Recanati, ELI s.r.l., 1998.
This was produced by the organisers of
In Brussels, the long-standing teaching the Septimanæ Latinæ Europææ
Fundatio Melissa (http://www. mentioned above. The website says it is
fundatiomelissa.org/) hosts a Circulus Many good textbooks for teaching now out of print, but they have a new
Latinus and publishes the Latin periodical Latin have been published and are in use version: http://www.maierphil.de/
Melissa. Also in Belgium, the Schola Nova in this country. A number of recent ones PiperSal/
(watch the video at: http://www. have included conversational elements, Of course, a wonderful method is
scholanova.be/) is a private school that some dialogue and a grammatical the one I also mentioned above,
offers a strongly Græco-Latin curriculum progression inspired by the advances in Desessard’s Lingua Latina sine molestiá; but
with a living approach. pedagogy made in the vernaculars. this is more for self-study, and not so
In the Netherlands, the Athenæum Examples of this go from the charming practical for an actual face-to-face class.
Illustre (http://www.athenaeumillustre. Minimus to the Cambridge Latin Course. There is certainly still much room for
org/) has organised since 2012 many Based on progressive reading, Reading improvement in the area of textbooks to
spoken Latin conferences, with activities Latin also comes to mind. teach Latin in a communicative manner,
in Amsterdam and other cities like Leiden; English being a global language, all and I and others have this very much in
although, again, I am unsure about its of these methods are well known abroad, mind. However, a word of warning is
current situation (many magnificent and have received praise. However, the necessary. Sufficiently good methods for
videos on YouTube). method currently most widely and almost teaching classical languages this way were
In Italy, the Schola Latina (http:// unanimously used internationally, both in already produced, here in Britain of all
www.scholalatina.it/) is run by a number Europe and in America, by all those places, by W.H.D. Rouse, and as early as
of previous partners of «Vívárium interested in spoken Latin is the the beginning of the 20th Century. A
Novum» who have returned to Montella, following: number of reasons can be adduced to
where it all started. They also offer explain why his attempts were not more
summer courses. • Hans H. Ørberg, Lingua Latina per se successful. A crucial factor in the fate of
This international network of illustrata, Hauniæ apud Museum those initial efforts would appear to have
initiatives finds some coordination Tusculanum 1991 [1981] https:// been that, at the time (Rouse was active at
through the Académía Latínitátí Fovendæ lingualatina.dk/wp/ Perse 1902–1928), the number of
(http://www.academialatinitatifovendae. initiatives and opportunities to master
org/). One of its greatest contributions is This method teaches classical Latin speaking Latin that we have today were
the scholarly conference it organises fully grammar and the 3000 words most not yet available. No matter how good a
in Latin every four years (the latest one frequently found in the classical texts in a range of textbooks we have, if the
Spoken Latin:
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 191.101.81.46, on Learning,
03 Jul 2018Teaching, Lecturing
at 22:29:43, subject and Research
to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at 49
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2058631018000065
teachers themselves cannot develop the Association for Latin Teaching (ARLT) before, because a lot of vocabulary and
required skills to exploit them, then the Summer School, and did so again in 2017. most of grammar is there stored in their
whole endeavour may not succeed. Now The interest generated this second time memories, however passively. The
that Latin teachers are finally able to find was much keener. I intend to continue to attendants of the UCL Living Latin
abundant relevant training for the use of cooperate with the ARLT to finally bring Workshop and at the ARLT Summer
spoken Latin in the class, we have the the old designs of founder W.H.D. Rouse School 2017 were themselves surprised,
opportunity to make communicative to their practical fruition. I know for a though I was not, that they could follow
approaches flourish and deliver wider fact that the will is there very much alive. my lecture without trouble, and they
success. A much needed resource is a proved this with their relevant enquiries.
Required training in this context is database of schools interested in this During lectures delivered in Latin,
threefold. First of all, those aspiring to approach. Only a few days before I sat to students can thus receive the content
teach Latin in a living manner should be write this I was approached by a teacher knowledge imparted to them, and they
fluent in Latin themselves to be able to do from a school in Italy trying to put further enrich their Latin enhancing their
so. Recommendations on ways to achieve together a KA1 Erasmus + project for a familiarity with the language itself.
this have already been provided. period of job shadowing of one or two There are unfortunately even fewer
Even being a completely native teachers with a school equally interested instances of lecturing in Latin than there
speaker of one’s own language does not in sharing experiences and comparing are of language teaching through Latin.
automatically make one a good language results obtained by teaching Latin with Two shining instances of the latter
teacher of the same. Specific training is the communicative approach. I was practice and its viability are exemplified in
needed in the practical and effective unable to suggest any schools. I believe the delivery of a whole university
teaching of that language. For a living she eventually found what she wanted, programme in Latin at the University of
mode (communicative approach), this kind but interested schools should have a Kentucky, and the programmes offered by
of training is widely and often very means to be in touch with each other and the Polis Institute that are accredited by
conveniently available in the case of a know who else is trying this approach for supporting universities in Italy and Spain.
global language like English. One of the sharing and support. Other than that, I know that some
best things that those aspiring to teach university lecturing in Latin was taking
Latin as a spoken language could be place in Germany, at least in three
advised to do is to get one of those TEFL/ different universities, although I have
TESOL courses under their belts, so that Lecturing in Latin at university struggled to find further evidence online.
they can then transfer the strategies. Certainly a world-famous classicist,
Finally, for the last five years there is Teaching of the language has generally Professor Michael von Albrecht, emeritus
now also a specialised teacher training been seen as a pursuit for primary and from Heidelberg (https://de.wikipedia.
course for spoken Latin, which should secondary education contexts. However, org/wiki/Michael_von_Albrecht),
certainly be completed, even if it more and more universities are now lectured in Latin, and remains one of the
means crossing the Channel for sunny having to teach Latin language ab initió, so most active proponents of living Latin
Spain: http://www.culturaclasica. this is surely their concern too. Also, (many videos can be found in YouTube).
com/?q = caelum universities are where the future primary The same can be said of Professor
For the success of any attempts to and secondary education teachers of Wilfried Stroh, emeritus from Munich
promote living Latin teaching at school, Latin receive their training in the (https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wilfried_
three efforts therefore need to be language. Effective Latin teaching is thus Stroh). I believe also Professor Axel
undertaken: the responsibility and concern of Schönberger of Frankfurt lectures in
university departments for these two Latin (https://www.uni-frankfurt.
• training teachers to speak Latin fluently crucial reasons. de/43605276/schoenberger).
and with complete practical I am further persuaded that speaking In Spain, the University of Valencia
confidence; Latin is beneficial not only for language is integrating lecturing in Latin too. Dr.
teaching, but for also the more specifically Jorge Tárrega shares online his notes,
• training teachers in the effective and academic type of lecturing which deals bibliography, practical work, etc. for his
methodologically up-to-date teaching with matters of literature, philosophy, courses on Sallust or Latin Morphology
of languages, first their own, and then history, and the like. I provided and Syntax, which he teaches entirely in
Latin; and demonstrations of this type of teaching Latin: http://jortaga.blogs.uv.es/
both at the UCL Living Latin Workshop In this context it will be a pleasure
• producing textbooks which are and at the ARLT Summer School 2017 by for me to be able to contribute to the
purposefully adapted (in the type of delivering a lecture-seminar on existing international provision the
activities, progression, etc.) to the intertextuality between Geoffrey of aforementioned two modules of the UCL
needs of teaching Latin as a spoken Monmouth and Virgil. The reason this Summer School 2018 which will be
language. works is that even students who can only likewise delivered in Latin this summer. I
communicate in Latin say to a 10% or hope to see many readers of this journal
There is a lot of work to do, but also a lot 20% level of adroitness can actually taking the chance to benefit (http://www.
of reason for hope. In 2005 I offered understand spoken Latin to around 80% ucl.ac.uk/prospective-students/study-
three spoken Latin sessions at the or 90% if they have learnt the language abroad-ucl/summer-school).
50 Spoken Latin:
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 191.101.81.46, on 03 Learning,
Jul 2018 atTeaching, Lecturing
22:29:43, subject andCambridge
to the Research Core terms of use, available at
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2058631018000065
Latin scholarship in Latin Owen written by Professor Jonathan G.F.
Powell, well-known editor of Cicero in Academic research on the practice
Beyond lecturing as part of a fully-
the Bibliotheca Oxoniensis and for a time and benefits of speaking Latin
visitor of the London Latin Circle, where
fledged university course awarding credit,
he demonstrated some of the most The last section of my contribution must
there are many international conferences
impeccable use of spoken Latin I have go to the increasing academic activity
where a number of public lectures are
ever heard: written in the vernacular but about
delivered in Latin. There is a greater
spoken Latin. This is highly
abundance of this type of practice in the
• Jonathan G.F. Powell. (1986). De recommended reading for those
area of so-called ‘Neo-Latin’ studies,
Iohanne Audoeno, scriptore interested in this area beyond the
where scholars are perhaps more attuned
epigrammatum Cambrobritanno. In O. necessary confines of the present article.
to the perennial use of the language,
Dilke & G. Townend (edd.), Acta Most importantly, an absolutely
although not only in that area. A couple
omnium gentium ac nationum conventus sexti pioneering PhD thesis entirely on this
of samples:
Latinis litteris linguæque fovendis: matter was defended only last year:
Britannia Latina. Kendaliæ, Wilson,
• On Jacobus Pontanus (Naples) [see
pp. 130–134. • Lloyd, Mair E. (2016). Living Latin:
12:12 onwards]: https://www.youtube.
Exploring a Communicative Approach to
com/watch?v = 8YC8dVMPtW4
A Google search attests that this is quoted Latin Teaching Through a Sociocultural
in at least three subsequent pieces of Perspective on Language Learning: http://
• On Thomas More and his Utopia
scholarship. oro.open.ac.uk/48886/
(Amsterdam): https://www.youtube.
Scholarly periodicals like Mnemosyne,
com/watch?v = wQbsB4zp_d0
Hermes, Museum Helveticum, etc. also still The editor of the Journal of Classics
publish articles in Latin from time to time. Teaching himself had just the year before
Many of these lectures are subsequently
Again, just from friends (Polish and published a crucial book on Latin
published in written form. In this context,
Spanish), a couple of examples can teaching that devotes attention to the
and although no longer strictly speaking
illustrate this: matter of active use of the language:
instances of spoken Latin, it is relevant to
bring to mind the abundance of written
• Hunt, Steven. (2016). Starting to Teach
scholarship published in Latin. • Konrad M. Kokoszkiewicz (Mnemosyne
Latin: https://www.amazon.co.uk/
Participation in that scholarly debate 58, 2005) A. Gellius Noctes Atticae
Starting-Teach-Latin-Steven-Hunt/
necessitates a capacity to deal with the 16.2.6: tamquam si te dicas adulterum
dp/1472537912
expression of new ideas in Latin which is negent (one among various others, the
very much akin to the capacity to speak last one in Eranos 2010-11: http://
Beyond that, highly informative are also
fluent Latin. Classicists not trained in www.obta.uw.edu.pl/ ~ draco/)
the findings of a Census Latinus carried
these skills cannot have ready access to
• Jorge Tárrega Garrido (Museum Helveticum out in 2009, which were published just in
much relevant scholarship, let alone
71, 2014) De hominum appellationibus 2017 too, with a new edition of the same
produce it.
in Ciceronis Epistulis ad Atticum: http:// expected to take place this year:
To put but one example, not just a
www.e-periodica.ch/digbib/%20
Latinist, a Hellenist as well, specialising
view?var = true&pid = mhl- • Eduardo Engelsing, Census Latinus
say in Homeric studies, should be able to
001:2014:71::143 2009: Goals, Data Collected,
contend with the extensive Latin treatises
Importance, Perspectives: https://
preceding the various volumes of Van der
muse.jhu.edu/article/658989/pdf
Valk’s edition of Eustathius’s commentary Although several universities still accept
on the Iliad, Latin scholarship which is as PhD theses in Latin (certainly von
A not so off-the-press contribution of 2012
recent as 1971. Students whose Latin only Albrecht’s Heidelberg), I am not sure
also makes for very interesting reading:
allows them to deal with classical texts for how often this option has been used (see
which there are bilingual editions and above for the need of a compilation of
• Neil Coffee, Active Latin: Quo
translations are excluded from much that scholarship in Latin). The jewel in the
Tendimus?: http://www.academia.
is valuable. crown of this section must therefore be
edu/3830834/Active_Latin_Quo_
I have long believed that a good the whole 400 pages of a recent PhD
Tendimus
research project would be the compilation thesis of 2015 defended at the
of a comprehensive bibliography of all University of Valencia:
classical scholarship written in Latin in the
contemporary period (from 1789), • Mª Luisa Aguilar, Studia Varroniana: de Conclusion
hopefully with a record/analysis of their titulis Varronis eorumque origine ac
citation rates by further (Latin and rationibus (resumen in Spanish, pp. I hope this article can stimulate and guide
non-Latin using) scholarship. I-XLIV, but body in Latin, pp. 1–389): readers in trying out the experience of
While we wait for that, I will provide http://roderic.uv.es/bitstream/ speaking Latin and exploring some of the
just a couple of examples from friends. I handle/10550/46825/tesis_mlaguilar. many possible avenues now open in this
have in front of me an article on John pdf ?sequence=1&isAllowed=y direction. Students are certainly
Spoken Latin:
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 191.101.81.46, on Learning,
03 Jul 2018Teaching, Lecturing
at 22:29:43, subject and Research
to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at 51
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2058631018000065
expressing more and more interest in this
approach for the obvious reasons of References Patrick, R. (2011). TPRS and Latin in the
classroom. Experiences of a US Latin
greater immediacy and enhanced mastery teacher. JCT 22, pp. 10–11.
Avitus, A.G. (2008). De vivá institutione Latiná
in a language they genuinely love, and per rete, Melissa 142 (2008) pp. 2–4.
teachers and academics should be able to Stray, C. (2011). Success and Failure:
accompany and inspire them in this Hunt, S. (2016). Starting to Teach Latin, London, W.H.D Rouse and direct-method Classics
pursuit. I know for a fact that many long Bloomsbury. teaching in Edwardian England. JCT 22,
to do so. pp. 5–7.
I also hope that greater knowledge Licoppe, G. (2014). Academia Latinitati Fovendæ,
and awareness fosters more fluid eius historia per motum Latinitatis vivæ considerata Tunberg, T. (2011). The use of Latin as a
communication among those interested in (1952–2012), Bruxellis, Melissa. spoken language in the Humanist Age. JCT
22, pp. 8–9.
forwarding this approach and that they Lloyd, M. (2016). Living Latin: An Interview
dare to support each other and increase with Professor Terence Tunberg. Journal of
the cohesion and inclusivity of the Classics Teaching 34, pp. 44–48.
growing numbers of teachers and scholars
interested in spoken Latin worldwide.
52 Spoken Latin:
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 191.101.81.46, on 03 Learning,
Jul 2018 atTeaching, Lecturing
22:29:43, subject andCambridge
to the Research Core terms of use, available at
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2058631018000065