Professional Documents
Culture Documents
0
Contents
Background ..................................................................................................................................................2
Energy consumption in residential buildings ............................................................................................2
Solar panels vs. solar collectors ................................................................................................................3
Cradle to Cradle (C2C) ..............................................................................................................................4
Project aim ...............................................................................................................................................4
Test facilities ................................................................................................................................................5
Solar simulator .........................................................................................................................................5
Flow set-up ...............................................................................................................................................5
Solar collector system ..............................................................................................................................6
Heat storage vessel ..................................................................................................................................8
Project execution .........................................................................................................................................9
The 7 phases of design .............................................................................................................................9
Phase 1: Framing the question .............................................................................................................9
Phase 2: Concept/Ideation ...................................................................................................................9
Phase 3: Selection ................................................................................................................................9
Phase 4: Detailing .................................................................................................................................9
Phase 5: Realization............................................................................................................................10
Phase 6: Testing/Finalizing .................................................................................................................10
Phase 7: Evaluation ............................................................................................................................10
Materials ................................................................................................................................................11
Interim presentation ..............................................................................................................................11
Realization phase ...................................................................................................................................12
Testing of the final design ......................................................................................................................13
Final report .............................................................................................................................................14
Bibliography ...............................................................................................................................................15
Further reading ..........................................................................................................................................15
Appendix A. Materials and components ....................................................................................................16
Appendix B. Thermal conductivities of some selected materials ...............................................................19
Appendix C. DBL-schedule..........................................................................................................................20
1
Background
Climate change and global warming are the main challenges in modern society. In 2015, 195 countries
joined the Paris climate agreement, which sets out a global action plan to limit global warming to less
than 2 degrees for example by drastically decreasing CO2 emissions.
When analyzing the residential energy consumption by households in the EU (Figure 2), it is seen that
63.6% is used for space heating and 14.8% for water heating (hot tap water, etc.). So most CO2 reduction
can be achieved by reducing energy losses and/or by heating with renewable energy resources, like solar
and wind energy. However, in the Netherlands, in 2018 only a very small part of the energy consumption
was coming from renewable energy sources; the majority is coming from natural gas (Figure 3). To
reduce the number and intensity of earthquakes in the province of Groningen, the Dutch government is
lowering the production of the Slochteren natural gas field in the coming years. This enhances the search
for alternative energy sources for space and water heating in Dutch households even further. The Dutch
government aims to get a gas-free residential sector in 2050 (Ministerie van Economische Zaken, 2016).
2
Figure 2. Residential energy consumption in the EU in the year 2019 (Eurostat, 2021)
Figure 3. Total final consumption in the residential and services sectors by source in the Netherlands, 2000-2018 (IEA, IEA World
Energy Statistics and Balances (database), 2020)
To achieve this, the Dutch government is aiming to reduce the heat demand in the existing housing stock
through improved insulation. The remaining heat demand can be provided by heat pumps, solar heat
systems, or heating networks that use residual heat or geothermal energy. The ambition is that new
homes and other new buildings will no longer be heated via natural gas and that by 2021, 30,000 to
50,000 existing homes will also be converted annually to become gas-free (Santen, 2017). As a result,
from 2021 a substantial part of the annual new buildings should be gas-free.
In the summer, a solar water heater supplies almost all of the hot water demand. This does not work in
the winter, not even with a large solar water heater. But if there is less sunlight, the system can be
combined with a boiler, a small size seasonal heat storage system, or a heat pump. In this DBL project,
we will focus on the boiler system.
3
Cradle to Cradle (C2C)
Next to a sustainable product, also the production process should be sustainable. Most methods for
sustainable product development focus on limiting the harmfulness of the product. The product is seen
here as the chain of origin (extraction of raw materials, production), use (energy consumption), and
disposal (reuse, waste incineration, or dumping). However, a product can be made even more
sustainable by the concept of “cradle to cradle” (C2C) (McDonough & Braungart, 2002; EPEA, 2020).
The central idea of the philosophy behind cradle to cradle is that all materials used after their lifetime in
one product can be usefully reused in another product (McDonough & Braungart, 2002). The first
difference with conventional reuse is that there is no loss of quality and no residual products that are still
deposited. In this philosophy, a product should be designed in such a way that the product can be easily
taken apart and all components can be fully recycled into new products (Werf, 2009). Also, the number
of materials should be minimized.
Project aim
In this project, we focus on the design of a solar water heating system (Figure 4).
The aim is to design a solar water heating system according to the C2C concept. With the solar heat
system, 1 liter of water should be heated up as much as possible within a limited time frame of 20
minutes.
The system should be designed such that it could be built by the workshop and afterward tested in the
TFE-laboratory using an "artificial sun”. Also, the C2C concept has to be demonstrated. For example, you
should be able to show that all components can be recycled, directly (reuse of components) or indirectly
(as raw material for new products). It should also be shown that you minimized the number of materials
needed for creating a full solar collector system and thereby reduce the payback time of the system.
4
Test facilities
The system should be designed such that it would be possible to test it using a solar simulator. The total
budget for the full system is 25 TU/e-coins, which is equal to €100.
Solar simulator
In the laboratory for Thermo Fluids Engineering (Connector building) an experimental set-up is present.
The setup includes a compact area (test surface 2 m x 1.3 m) AAA-rated Eternal Sun solar simulator
(Figure 5) which simulates the spectrum of the sun in compliance with the international standard for
solar simulators (IEC 60904-9, 2007). The simulator produces a global irradiance of 1000 W/m2 in the
place of the collector at a distance of 10 cm from the artificial sky. During operation, the outside of the
solar simulator will be heated up to approximately 60oC (Katiyar, Balkom, Rindt, Keizer, & Zondag, 2017).
Flow set-up
During the project, you will design a solar collector system and a heat storage vessel. It should be
designed such that it is possible to integrate both systems into an existing general setup (Figure 6). The
setup consists of a cart on top of which a wooden frame is placed. It should be possible to mount your
solar within this frame. At the bottom of the cart, the design space for the heat storage vessel is located.
The solar collector and the heat storage vessel are connected via tubes (material: polyurethane, outer
diameter 12mm, wall thickness 2 mm, total tube length approximately 6 m) in which in- and outlet
temperatures and the mass flow are measured. The mass flow can be controlled via a pressure water
pump (Lilie SHURflo Soft LS 4144, max. discharge pressure 3.1 bar) and a bypass system. The flow range
can be chosen between 0.1 – 3.0 l/min.
5
Figure 6. General test set-up.
It should be possible to easily connect the solar collector to the general set-up via compression fittings.
Therefore copper tubing needs to be used. You can choose from copper pipes with diameters of 12mm,
15mm, or 22mm. These inlet and outlet ports (copper pipes with a free accessible length of at least 10
cm) need to be located at the feedthrough (Figure 8, white area).
Optional during the experiments is to place a glass panel (tempered glass, thickness 4mm) on top of the
design space (see Figure 7). This option comes with an additional cost of 2.50 TU/e coins (see Appendix
A).
6
a)
b)
Figure 7. a) General overview and b) zoom-in (side view) of the solar collector design space
7
Heat storage vessel
The design area for the heat storage vessel is located at the bottom of the cart (Figure 7a). The
dimensions are 600 mm x 1400 mm x 600 mm (width x length x height). The heat storage vessel will be
connected to the flexible tubing of the general set-up via two copper pipes (inlet and outlet). For easy
mounting, these copper pipes protrude at least 10 cm and are connected to the inlet and outlet of your
heat storage vessel using compression fittings. An example is given in Figure 9.
Note that if you use a cylinder as a storage vessel only 1 inlet/outlet port can be made at the bottom or
top of the heat storage vessel. However, other designs are also allowed as long as a copper pipe (at least
10 cm) can be used for the connections to the flexible tubes of the general set-up (via compression
fittings).
Figure 9. Exploded view of an example for an inlet/outlet of the heat storage vessel.
8
Project execution
The project will be executed according to the schedule as described in Appendix C.
We have chosen to execute the project according to the 7 phases in a design. A general description is
given in the text below.
Phase 2: Concept/Ideation
The concept phase (sometimes also called “ideation”) is used to find as many ways possible in which the
assignment can be approached; ways to create something special, unusual, unexpected. This means
stretching the range of possible answers as far as possible (or even looking for apparently impossible
options). The concept phase is there to challenge the students to keep an open eye for innovative ideas
and to come up with creative solutions, connections, and new viewpoints.
Outcome: at least 3 different concepts
Phase 3: Selection
From the concept solutions, one preferred product is selected by examining them in the light of the RPC
(for example by using a decision matrix). The student has to use synthetic skills to select the most
promising concept solution. Should all concept solutions fail to satisfy all requirements, it might be that
the requirements can be redefined so that the selected product is capable to satisfy all of them.
Outcome: choice of 1 concept (including motivation)
Phase 4: Detailing
Now that the preferred solution has been chosen, it is time to start detailing the product as a whole and
all its components. The detailing phase is a mix of using existing knowledge for theoretical optimization
and practical implementation possibilities. The result of the detailing phase is a list of necessary
components (chassis, motors, batteries, etc.) and equations, modeling functions, physical parameter
sets, etc. With this numerical model, calculations need to be done to support the decisions and to
predict the overall performance of the system.
The RPC (defined in phase 1) keeps being the guideline: all parts must be chosen to satisfy the RPC. This
might also be a reason to go back to the definitions in phase 1 and refine (or redefine) the RPCs.
9
The detailing phase also comprises the chance to choose your parts to optimize the product, where
necessary on an interdisciplinary basis.
Additional information on modeling with Matlab: webinar “getting started with Matlab”:
https://nl.mathworks.com/products/matlab/getting-started.html
https://nl.mathworks.com/videos/getting-started-with-matlab-68985.html
Outcome: final design & numerical model to support choices for final design
Phase 5: Realization
All (model- and/or design-) components need to be made or ordered and assembled.
Outcome: prototype of your solar heat system: solar collector + heat storage vessel.
Phase 6: Testing/Finalizing
After all separate parts have been tested and assembled, the product is ready. Now it can be tested to
see how its performance compares to the RPC and modeling outcomes. These tests must follow a preset
test plan.
Outcome: test results + discussion and analysis of measurement and design
Phase 7: Evaluation
During the project, choices need to be made, sometimes on solid argumentation (including numerical
modeling), sometimes on educated guesses, and sometimes by just picking something to be able to
move on. In the evaluation, all choices made during the process are put to the test, to see whether (or
how) they have influenced the result; to see whether, in hindsight, different choices could have led to
better results. The findings should be supported by modeling outcomes.
Outcome: discussion, main conclusions, and at least 3 suggestions for design improvement
10
Materials
In the 5th phase, you will build a solar collector and a heat storage vessel. You will have a limited budget
of 25 TU/e-coins for constructing both subsystems (exchange rate: €1 = 0.25 TU/e-coin).
A single aluminum plate (L x W x H= 1620mm x 670mm x 2mm) will be provided. During the experiments,
a glass cover can be used (additional costs: 2.50 TU/e-coins). Other materials have to be ordered. For
practical reasons, we limited the materials that can be used for the construction to the components that
are described in Appendix A. Due to the delivery time for some of these components, you need to supply
us with a list of required materials no later than Tuesday 17th May 2022 (groups 1-16) or Wednesday
18th May 2022 (groups 17-32).
If you order black paint you will need to indicate which components need to be painted by the teacher’s
assistant. You are not allowed to paint components on your own. The construction phase will start in
week 22.
Interim presentation
We want you to prepare a video recording of the presentation. You can use Teams or PowerPoint to
record your video. Each group is allowed to choose representative student/s to give the presentation in
the video. The video needs to be a maximum of 5 minutes long. Per group a time slot of 10 minutes is
allocated: a maximum of 5 minutes for the video followed by 5 minutes of discussion and feedback. You
must limit the video to 5 minutes to have sufficient time for discussion.
You will play your video in front of a small committee of experts. In the video at least the following
aspects should be mentioned (read the Rubric for the presentation to check the evaluation criteria):
• Final design of the solar collector and heat storage vessel, including a motivation of the choices made.
• Choice of materials and assembly sequence, including a clear motivation whether this is in agreement
with the C2C concept.
• An overview of the (numerical) model, including main assumptions that are made, a flow chart or a
schematic drawing of the test set-up with heat fluxes, and an overview of the main equations that are
used.
• Experimental protocol for testing, including required mass flows and expected temperature rise.
It is advised to practice your pitch in the DBL meeting. The tutor can use the rubric “Presenting Skills” to
give feedback.
The interim presentations are scheduled on Tuesday 24th May 2022 (groups 1-16) and Wednesday 25th
May 2022 (groups 17-32) (detailed time schedule: see next page).
One day in advance (before 18h00) the video presentation should be uploaded to Canvas.
11
Table 1. Time schedule for interim presentations.
Realization phase
The construction phase is scheduled in the same time slots (D or E) as the regular DBL meetings. The
workshop location is the PROTO/zone (Traverse building). You may only work on your system during
these scheduled hours. The exact time slots are indicated in the schedule on the last page of this manual.
The ordered materials are distributed during the first time slot. Standard tools will be supplied as well.
Only 3 students per group are allowed in the laboratory during the building phase. Make sure that all
groups members contribute to the solar heat system.
For students who are building in the PROTO/zone is not compulsory to be present at their group
meeting.
12
Testing of the final design
In week 24, you can test your design in the TFE laboratories (Connector building). Due to the large
number of groups, you only have one time slot of 60 minutes in total. See time schedules in Table 3
(groups 1-16) and Table 4 (groups 17-32). Also here the time limits are very strict. So, be well prepared!
Table 3. Time schedule for testing (groups 1-16) on Thursday 16 June 2022 (meeting location: entrance of Connector building)
Table 4. Time schedule for testing (groups 17-32) on Friday 17 June 2022 (meeting location: entrance of Connector building)
13
Final report
Reports should be written according to the writing guidelines which are listed in the Writing Manual (see
Canvas).
The final reports need to be submitted via Canvas before Friday 24th June 2020, 23:59.
14
Bibliography
EPEA. (2020, April 10). Introduction to Cradle to Cradle. Retrieved from Youtube:
https://youtu.be/QMsF1P-_vWc
Eurostat. (2021). Energy consumption in households. Retrieved from Statistcs Explained:
https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-
explained/index.php?title=Energy_consumption_in_households
IEA. (2020). Retrieved from https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/top-ten-co2-emitting-end-
uses-in-selected-iea-countries-2018
IEA. (2020). IEA World Energy Statistics and Balances (database). Retrieved from www.iea.org/statistics
IEC 60904-9. (2007). Photovoltaic devices - Solar simulator performance requirements. IEC.
International Energy Agency. (2017). Energy Efficiency Indicators - Highlights. (G. Tonolo, U. Ziebinska, &
M. Silva, Eds.) Paris: OECD/IEA.
Katiyar, M., Balkom, M. v., Rindt, C. C., Keizer, C. d., & Zondag, H. A. (2017). Numerical model for the
thermal yield estimation of unglazed photovoltaic-thermal collectors using indoor solar simulator
testing. Solar Energy, 903-919.
McDonough, W., & Braungart, M. (2002). Cradle to Cradle : Remaking the Way We Make Things (1st ed.).
New York: North Point Press.
Ministerie van Economische Zaken. (2016). Energieagenda: naar een CO2-arme energievoorziening. Den
Haag: Rijksoverheid.
Rutte, M., Buma, S., Pechtold, A., & Segers, G.-J. (2017). Vertrouwen in de toekomst: Regeerakkoord 2017
– 2021. Den Haag.
Santen, H. v. (2017, Oktober 10). Dit zijn de klimaatmaatregelen van Rutte III op een rij. NRC.
Werf, M. v. (2009). Cradle to Cradle in Bedrijf. Schiedam: Scriptum.
Further reading
Textbooks on heat and mass transfer
15
Appendix A. Materials and components
Available construction materials. Other materials may also be used up to total system price of 25 TU/e-
coins (= €100)
Table A.1. Materials and components for building the solar collector and heat storage vessel. Prices are in TU/e-coins.
Description TU/e-coins
(€1 = 0.25 TU/e-coin)
Soft copper tube, outer diameter12 mm, wall thickness 1.0 1.99
mm
Soft copper tube, outer diameter 15 mm, wall thickness 1.0 2.49
mm
Soft copper tube, outer diameter 22 mm, wall thickness 1.1 3.99
mm
PVC tube, outer diameter 40 mm, wall thickness 1.8 mm, 0.77
max. length 2 m
PVC tube, outer diameter 50 mm, wall thickness 1.8 mm, 0.90
max. length 2 m
PVC tube, outer diameter 110 mm, wall thickness 2.2 mm, 2.37
max. length 2 m
16
Description TU/e-coins
(€1 = 0.25 TU/e-coin)
PVC end cap**, inner diameter 40 mm, wall thickness 2.2 mm 0.19
PVC end cap**, inner diameter 50 mm, wall thickness 2.2 mm 0.26
PVC end cap**, inner diameter 110 mm, wall thickness 2.2 mm 0.43
17
Description TU/e-coins
(€1 = 0.25 TU/e-coin)
Miscellaneous
PVC glue -
Black paint (price per unit, not for the aluminum plate) 1.20
18
Appendix B. Thermal conductivities of some selected materials
Table B.1. Thermal conductivity of the construction materials.
Acrylate 0.20
Copper 400
Glass 0.96
Pinewood 0.12
Polystyrene 0.03
PVC 0.19
Trespa 0.30
19
Appendix C. DBL-schedule
20