Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
cle.13,14 But these are nonphysiologic, invasive, and expensive Four normal, nonlacerated muscles were evaluated by their
treatments. physiologic properties only. Thirty days after the laceration, the
It has been widely accepted that early mobilization or exer- animals were sacrificed to determine the level of improvement
cise after a muscle injury promotes muscle healing. Järvinen7 in regeneration and the extent of fibrosis. The gastrocnemius
reported that mobilization also induces faster and more inten- muscle was isolated and frozen in isopentane precooled in
sive capillary ingrowth from the cell borders of the injury liquid nitrogen. Histologic staining and physiologic analysis
particularly in the early stages of healing. In contrast, Lehto was used to evaluate four muscles from each group. Serial 5m
et al15 reported that the early mobilization induces the produc- sagittal sections were obtained for after surgery histologic
tion of granulation tissue with a parallel orientation but a poor assessment.
penetration of muscle fibers through the connective tissue scar.
However, the therapeutic effect of exercises of an injured Measurement Procedures
muscle on improving muscle regeneration and preventing fi- Muscle regeneration. The degree of muscle regeneration
brosis has not been determined. was evaluated using hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining.
We hypothesized that a mechanical stimulus such as passive The number and diameter of the centronucleated, regenerating
exercise, which enhances the proliferation and differentiation myofibers were monitored within the injection, exercise sites,
of myoblasts in vivo, can also prevent the formation of scar as well as in the control group. In each sample, 8 random fields
tissue. Our aims in this study were to evaluate the muscle within the injured area were selected. The measurements were
healing effect of passive stretching exercise at 3 different performed in a blinded manner in order to ensure the objectiv-
starting times after a laceration injury, compared with the effect ity of the results. Low power (20⫻) and high power (40⫻)
of decorin on the healing of an injured muscle, and to establish images were obtained using a BX50 optical microscopec that
the best starting time of the exercise intervention. was connected to a spot image capture system DP 70 digital
camera.c The number and diameter of the centronucleated
METHODS myofibers were expressed as the number and diameter of
centronucleated myofibers per field and the diameter of the
Experimental Animals myofibers.
Muscle fibrosis. Vimentin is expressed in macrophages,
A total 36 male Sprague-Dawley rats (age range, 8⫺10wk; capillary endothelia, and fibrocytes, and a high level is ex-
weight, 300⫺400g) were used in these experiments. The ani- pressed within the scar tissue of an injured muscle.16 It is
mal research and care committee at the Samsung Biomedical expressed by myofiber early in development and shortly after
Research Institute of Korea approved all the experimental an injury. However, the mature myofibers and regenerating
protocols. A muscle laceration model was developed by lacer- myofibers present in an injured muscle 2 to 4 weeks after injury
ating the gastrocnemius muscle of each leg based on previously do not express vimentin.2,3,5,13,16 Therefore, we used vimentin
described studies.4,5,13,14 The rats were anesthetized by intra- as a marker for fibrosis. Cryosectioned muscles were used for
muscular injection of 0.3mL of ketamine (100mg/mL) and vimentin staining. The slides were blocked in 2% horse
0.2mL of xylazine (200mg/mL). The muscle was lacerated serum for 1 hour, after washing the slides with antivimentin
with a surgical blade (#11) at the largest diameter, through the conjugated Cy3d antibody for 1 hour at a dilution of 1:250.
lateral 50% of their width and 100% of their thickness. A The total vimentin-positive area was measured in 8 random
polydiaoxanon suture material (PDSII 5-0)a was placed at the fields from each sample (n⫽4) of each group. The immu-
medial edge of the lacerated site, with 2mm of the suture nofluorescence was then visualized using BX50 fluorescent
remaining visible on the medial edge of the lacerated site. After microscopy,c captured with a DP70 digital camera. The
the laceration, the hamstring muscle and skin were closed with image gauge, version 3.12,e was used to identify the vimentin
a black silk 4-0 suture,a and the animals were allowed to move positive area, which is represented as a percentage.
freely in small cages and received laboratory chow and water We used Masson modified trichromef to compare the amount
ad libitum. of scar tissue development between the groups, as well as to
further confirm that the vimentin-positive area was a collage-
Procedure nous scar. The image was aggregated using the same tech-
The left gastrocnemius muscles were used as the interven- niques used for vimentin. Olympus DP manager softwarec was
tion group, and right gastrocnemius muscles were used as the used to calculate the percentage area of fibrosis.
controls (laceration only without any treatment, n⫽8). We Contractile properties. Four muscles per group were ex-
divided the intervention group into 2 groups: group E (n⫽24; amined to analyze the fast twitch strength. The rats were
the stretching exercise group) and group D (n⫽8; the decorin anesthetized with 0.3mL of ketamine (100mg/mL) and 0.2mL
injection group). Group E was classified according to the of xylazine (200mg/mL). Both gastrocnemius muscles were then
treatment phase: the inflammatory phase (group E-2 [n⫽8]; removed and mounted in a 5mL double jacketed organ bath at
beginning 2d after surgery), repair phase (group E-7 [n⫽8]; 36°C in Krebs solution (in mmol/L: NaCl⫽113, KCl⫽47,
beginning 7d after surgery), and the remodeling phase (group CaCl2⫽1.2, MgSO4⫽1.2, NaHCO3⫽25, KH2PO4⫽1.2, glu-
E-14 [n⫽8]; beginning 14d after surgery). Manual stretching cose⫽11.5), which was constantly bubbled with a 95% oxygen
exercise was performed daily on group E for 5 days, 15 and 5% carbon dioxide mixture. The initial tension was set at
minutes per session, which consisted of 30° of dorsiflexion of 20mN. The isometric contractions were measured using the
the ankle for 5 seconds followed by release and rest for 5 strain-gauge transducers coupled to a TBM4 strain gauge am-
seconds. We used special positioning equipment made by us in plifierg and recorded on a computer using a data acquisition
order to keep the positions of the left hip and knee immovable. program (WinDaq).h The sampling rate per channel was set to
The decorin (n⫽8) injection was administered along the suture 500Hz. The amplitude of the stimulation-evoked contractions
material using a microsyringe.b Previous studies reported that a was determined using a calculation program (WinDaq Ex).h
decorin injection (50g) at 2 weeks after surgery had the best After 20 minutes equilibration, electric field stimuli were ap-
healing effect.13,14 The left gastrocnemius muscles were in- plied through 2 platinum wire electrodes positioned on the top
jected once with decorin (50g) at 14 days after laceration. and bottom of the organ bath with a 4cm separation. The
muscle was stimulated with square-wave pulses of .25-ms The measurements of the regenerating myofiber diameter
duration at the maximum voltage (100V). The first 1-Hz stim- indicated that only group E-14 achieved a statistically larger
ulus was applied for 6 minutes and the number of muscle diameter than the control group (fig 1).
twitches was recorded. The muscle was weighted after the test,
and the muscle strength was reported as millinewtons per gram. Muscle Fibrosis
The level of fibrosis with vimentin and Masson trichrome
Data Analysis staining was decreased by more than 50% in the exercise
The average and standard deviation of the data were com- groups and decorin group compared with the control (P⬍.05).
pared using repeated-measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) Masson trichrome staining showed that the fibrotic area was
for statistical analysis (P⬍.05). SPSS, version 11.0,i for Win- similar in the muscles treated with decorin and those given
dows was used for statistical analysis. stretching exercise (fig 2). However, vimentin staining indi-
cated that all interventional groups showed a significantly
RESULTS lower level of fibrosis than control (P⬍.05) (fig 3).
Contractile Properties
Muscle Regeneration The strength of the lacerated muscles was determined by
The number of centronucleated, regenerating myofibers was physiologic testing in order to evaluate the fast twitch strength.
significantly higher in all interventional groups than in the The fast twitch strength of all the groups was compared. The
control muscle. Group D showed the highest number of regen- fast twitch in groups E-7 and E-14 was significantly improved,
erated new myofibers. Even though the number of new myo- compared with that of the control group. Group E-14 had a
fibers was significantly lower than in the decorin treated group, slightly higher strength than group E-7, but there was no
group E-14 showed a significantly higher number of new statistical difference. The strength of the muscles in group D
myofibers than the other exercise groups. was strongest among the intervention groups (fig 4).
DISCUSSION myofibers had almost crossed the gap (day 14). On day 21, a
The management of a muscle injury varies, including RICE scar containing interlacing myofibers with little intervening
immediately, additional physical therapies, and medications. connective tissue had formed.
Surgical intervention might be necessary based on the type and One way to get full recovery after muscle injury is to
severity of the muscle injury. The treatment regimen has been enhance the regeneration of muscle cells. In muscle injuries,
empirically adapted from clinical practice. These traditional the release of growth factors at the injured site is an important
treatments usually do not promote a sufficiently rapid recovery step in initiating the healing process. These growth factors can
to satisfy the patients, and the recurrence of the injury is stimulate the growth and differentiation of various muscle-derived
common. This indicates that such treatments also fail to pro- cells.18 These growth factors are known to promote myoblast
vide a full functional recovery and is likely to be ineffective in proliferation and differentiation, which eventually leads to
preventing the formation of permanent scar tissue at an injured muscle regeneration and healing after the injury,4,5 and are also
site.3 believed to be a key factor in the development of fibrosis in
Hurme et al17 described in greater detail the sequence of various tissues.18,19 Kasemkijwattana et al20 reported that the
changes at the ultra structural level, which occurs in the regen- high level of muscle regeneration observed at 7 and 10 days
eration of muscle fibers after a contusion injury. Within 2 days, after the injury decreased over time until 35 days after the
the macrophages had already phagocytosed the necrotic muscle injury. The development of scar tissue began 14 days after the
fiber material. On day 3, satellite cells within the basal lamina injury and gradually increased until 35 days.
cylinders were activated into myoblasts. After 5 to 7 days, the It is likely that the development of the fibrosis is related to
regenerating muscle cells extended out of the old basal lamina the reduction of muscle regeneration, which was also observed
cylinders into the central zone and began to pierce through the 14 days after the injury. Therefore, another way to achieve the
scar. The scar tissue further condensed and the regenerating acceleration of muscle regeneration is to reduce the fibrosis. Li
and Huard3 observed that TGF-1 was strongly expressed in attained histologically by the combined administration of in-
the injured skeletal muscle 3 days after injury. In addition, a sulin-like growth factor-1 to enhance the level of muscle re-
decrease in the expression level was observed 14 days after generation and decorin to reduce the formation of fibrosis.
injury. The in vitro results suggest that TGF-1 can induce the However, the physiologic test revealed that the treatment with
expression of the myofibroblastic markers, such as ␣-smooth decorin alone is the most effective method to restore the
muscle actin and vimentin, in muscle derived stem cells in a physiologic strength of an injured muscle.
dose-dependent manner. Therefore, TGF-1, which is the key The development of biologic factors has important clinical
factor involved in the fibrosis of various tissues, also plays a implications. However, many problems need to be solved be-
role in the development of scar tissue after muscle injury. fore growth factor and growth factor inhibition therapy can be
Accordingly, group D, which was treated with decorin, a used clinically. These include safety issues, the dosage, treat-
TGF-1 inhibitor, showed a significant reduction of fibrosis ment regimes, and effective delivery systems. Fukushima13
and the highest number of regenerated myofibers and the reported that an injection of decorin (50g) 2 weeks after the
highest muscle strength. The increase in the regeneration of muscle laceration had the best effect. A large amount of re-
muscle fibers possibly results from the reduction of fibrosis. combinant protein was required to efficiently improve the
Fukushima et al13 reported that an injection of decorin at 2 healing of a very small mouse muscle. No data have been
weeks after the muscle laceration prevented the muscle fibrosis generated from human trials. Dose finding and toxicity data are
and enhanced muscle regeneration. Sato et al14 reported that not available. Early mobilization exercise or gentle stretching
further improvement in the healing of a muscle laceration is exercise after a muscle injury has been widely used. Experi-
phological and functional study in a mouse model. Am J Sports 19. Badid C, Mounier N, Costa AM, Desmouliere A. Role of myofi-
Med 1999;27:222-9. broblasts during normal tissue repair and excessive scaring inter-
6. Garett WE Jr. Muscle strain injuries: clinical and basic aspects. est of their assessment in nephropathies. Histol Histopathol 2000;
Med Sci Sports Exerc 1990;22:436-43. 15:269-80.
7. Järvinen M. Healing of a crush in rat striated muscle 2. A histo- 20. Kasemkijwattana C, Menetrey J, Day CS, et al. Biologic inter-
logical study of the effect of early mobilization and on the repair vention in muscle healing and regeneration. Sports Med Arthrosc
processes. Acta Pathol Microbiol Scand [A] 1976;83:269-82. Rev 1998;6:95-102.
8. Hurme T, Kalimo H. Activation of myogenic precursor cells after 21. Järvinen M. Healing of crush injury in rat striated muscle. 3. A
muscle injury. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1992;24:801-10. microangiographic study of the effect of early mobilization and
9. Trippel SB, Coutts RD, Einhorn TA, Mundy GR, Rosenfeld RG. immobilization on capillary ingrowth. Acta Path Microbiol Scand
Instructional Course Lectures, the American Academy of Ortho- [A] 1976;84:85-94.
paedic Surgeons. Growth factors as a therapeutic agent. J Bone 22. Bishop JE, Butt RP, Laurent GJ. The role of mechanical force in
Joint Surg Am 1996;78:1272-86. the regulation of fibroblasts function: implications for enhanced
10. Järvinen M, Sovari T. Healing of crush injury in rat striated collagen deposition during pulmonary vascular remodelling. Eur
muscle. 1. Description and testing of a new method of inducing a Respir Rev 1993;3:613-7.
standard injury to the calf muscle. Acta Pathol Microbiol Scand 23. Nakagawa S, Paweel P, Grinnell F. Extracellular matrix organi-
[A] 1975;83:259-65. zation modulates fibroblast growth and growth factor responsive-
11. Border WA, Noble NA. Transforming growth factor beta in tissue ness. Exp Cell Res 1989;182:572-82.
fibrosis. N Engl J Med 1994;10:1286-92. 24. Stauber WT, Fritz VK, Dahlmann B. Extracellular matrix changes
12. Giri SN, Hyde DM, Braun RK, Gaarde W, Harper JR, Pierschbacher following blunt trauma to rat skeletal muscles. Exp Mol Pathol
MD. Antifibrotic effect of decorin in bleomycin hamster model of 1990;52:69-86.
lung fibrosis. Biochem Pharmacol 1997;54:1205-16. 25. Pezzullo DJ, Irrgang JJ. Rehabilitation. In: Fu FH, Stone DA,
13. Fukushima K, Badlani N, Usas A, Riano F, Fu F, Huard J. The use editors. Sports injuries. 2nd ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams
of an antifibrosis agent to improve muscle recovery after lacera- & Wilkins; 2001. p 106-23.
tion. Am J Sports Med 2000;29:394-402.
14. Sato K, Li Y, Foster W, et al. Improvement of muscle healing Suppliers
through enhancement of muscle regeneration and prevention of a. Ethicon Endo-Surgery Inc, 4545 Creek Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45242.
fibrosis. Muscle Nerve 2003;28:365-72. b. Hamilton Co, 4970 Energy Wy, Reno, NV 89502.
15. Lehto M, Duance VC, Restall D. Collagen and fibronection in a c. Olympus Optical, Shinjuku Monolith, 3-1 Nishi-Shinjuku 2-chome,
healing skeletal muscle injury. An immunohistological study of the Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo 163-0914, Japan.
effects of physical activity on the repair of injured gastrocnemius d. C-9080; Sigma Chemical Co, 6050 Spruce St, St. Louis, MO
muscle in the rat. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1985;67:820-8. 63103.
16. Bornemann A, Schmalbruch H. Desmin and vimentin in regener- e. Fujifilm Medical Systems USA Inc, 419 West Ave, Stamford, CT
ating muscle. Muscle Nerve 1992;15:12-20. 06902.
17. Hurme T, Kalimo H, Lehto M, Järvinen M. Healing of skeletal f. Medical Equipment, 170 Vallecitos De Oro, San Marcos, CA
muscle injury: an ultra structural and immunohistochemical study. 92069.
Med Sci Sports Exerc 1990;23:801-10. g. World Precision Instrument Inc, 175 Sarasota Center Blvd, Sara-
18. Menetrey J, Kasemkijwattana C, Day CS, et al. Growth factors sota, FL 34240.
improve muscle healing in vivo. J Bone Joint Surg Br 2000;82: h. DATAQ Instruments, 241 Springside Dr, Akron, OH 44333.
131-7. i. SPSS Inc, 233 S Wacker Dr, 11th Fl, Chicago, IL 60606.