You are on page 1of 14

Articles

Height and body-mass index trajectories of school-aged


children and adolescents from 1985 to 2019 in 200 countries
and territories: a pooled analysis of 2181 population-based
studies with 65 million participants
NCD Risk Factor Collaboration (NCD-RisC)*

Summary
Background Comparable global data on health and nutrition of school-aged children and adolescents are scarce. We Lancet 2020; 396: 1511–24
aimed to estimate age trajectories and time trends in mean height and mean body-mass index (BMI), which measures See Comment page 1465
weight gain beyond what is expected from height gain, for school-aged children and adolescents. *Members listed at the end of
the Article, and affiliations listed
in the appendix
Methods For this pooled analysis, we used a database of cardiometabolic risk factors collated by the Non-Communicable
Disease Risk Factor Collaboration. We applied a Bayesian hierarchical model to estimate trends from 1985 to 2019 in Correspondence to:
Prof Majid Ezzati, School of
mean height and mean BMI in 1-year age groups for ages 5–19 years. The model allowed for non-linear changes over Public Health, Imperial College
time in mean height and mean BMI and for non-linear changes with age of children and adolescents, including London, London W2 1PG, UK
periods of rapid growth during adolescence. majid.ezzati@imperial.ac.uk
See Online for appendix
Findings We pooled data from 2181 population-based studies, with measurements of height and weight in 65 million
participants in 200 countries and territories. In 2019, we estimated a difference of 20 cm or higher in mean height
of 19-year-old adolescents between countries with the tallest populations (the Netherlands, Montenegro, Estonia,
and Bosnia and Herzegovina for boys; and the Netherlands, Montenegro, Denmark, and Iceland for girls) and
those with the shortest populations (Timor-Leste, Laos, Solomon Islands, and Papua New Guinea for boys; and
Guatemala, Bangladesh, Nepal, and Timor-Leste for girls). In the same year, the difference between the highest
mean BMI (in Pacific island countries, Kuwait, Bahrain, The Bahamas, Chile, the USA, and New Zealand for both
boys and girls and in South Africa for girls) and lowest mean BMI (in India, Bangladesh, Timor-Leste, Ethiopia, and
Chad for boys and girls; and in Japan and Romania for girls) was approximately 9–10 kg/m². In some countries,
children aged 5 years started with healthier height or BMI than the global median and, in some cases, as healthy as
the best performing countries, but they became progressively less healthy compared with their comparators as they
grew older by not growing as tall (eg, boys in Austria and Barbados, and girls in Belgium and Puerto Rico) or
gaining too much weight for their height (eg, girls and boys in Kuwait, Bahrain, Fiji, Jamaica, and Mexico; and girls
in South Africa and New Zealand). In other countries, growing children overtook the height of their comparators
(eg, Latvia, Czech Republic, Morocco, and Iran) or curbed their weight gain (eg, Italy, France, and Croatia) in late
childhood and adolescence. When changes in both height and BMI were considered, girls in South Korea, Vietnam,
Saudi Arabia, Turkey, and some central Asian countries (eg, Armenia and Azerbaijan), and boys in central and
western Europe (eg, Portugal, Denmark, Poland, and Montenegro) had the healthiest changes in anthropometric
status over the past 3·5 decades because, compared with children and adolescents in other countries, they had a
much larger gain in height than they did in BMI. The unhealthiest changes—gaining too little height, too much
weight for their height compared with children in other countries, or both—occurred in many countries in sub-
Saharan Africa, New Zealand, and the USA for boys and girls; in Malaysia and some Pacific island nations for boys;
and in Mexico for girls.

Interpretation The height and BMI trajectories over age and time of school-aged children and adolescents are highly
variable across countries, which indicates heterogeneous nutritional quality and lifelong health advantages and
risks.

Funding Wellcome Trust, AstraZeneca Young Health Programme, EU.

Copyright © 2020 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an Open Access article under the CC BY 4.0 license.

Introduction community. During school ages (typically 5–19 years),


Growth and development through childhood and these factors amplify or mitigate adversity in infancy and
adolescence are affected by social, nutritional, and early childhood and, if healthy, can help consolidate
envir­onmental factors at home, at school, and in the gains from early childhood and correct some nutritional

www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020 1511


Articles

Research in context
Evidence before this study stunting in children younger than 5 years together with data on
We searched MEDLINE (through PubMed) for articles published various measures of underweight and overweight at different
from inception up to Aug 2, 2020, with no language restrictions, ages, but did not have data on height in older children and
using the following search terms: (“body size”[mh:noexp] adolescents, nor did it analyse trends.
OR “body height”[mh:noexp] OR “body weight”[mh:noexp] OR
Added value of this study
“birth weight”[mh:noexp] OR “overweight”[mh:noexp] OR
To our knowledge, this study presents the first comparable
“obesity”[mh] OR “thinness”[mh:noexp] OR “Waist-Hip
estimates of height in school-aged children and adolescents for
Ratio”[mh:noexp] OR “Waist Circumference”[mh:noexp] OR
all countries in the world and does so alongside estimates of
“body mass index”[mh:noexp]) AND (“Humans”[mh]) AND
BMI, which together are pathways from nutrition and
(“Health Surveys”[mh] OR “Epidemiological Monitoring”[mh]
environment during childhood and adolescence to lifelong
OR “Prevalence”[mh]) NOT Comment[ptyp] NOT Case
health. We also analysed age trajectories of mean height and
Reports[ptyp]. Articles were screened according to the inclusion
BMI to investigate ages when growth in different countries was
and exclusion criteria described in the Methods section.
more versus less healthy and to identify the need for
We found global or multicountry studies on trends over time in
intervention.
height for adults and for children younger than 5 years, but not
for school-aged children and adolescents. One multicountry Implications of all the available evidence
study used cross-sectional height data in 53 community-based Age trajectories and time trends in mean height and BMI of
samples and reported height differences in children aged school-aged children and adolescents were highly variable
10–17 years. We found three studies on trends in body-mass across countries and indicated heterogeneous nutritional
index (BMI) or overweight in children and adolescents, but only quality and life-long health advantages and risks. Global and
one of these studies separately reported trends for children aged national nutrition and health programmes should extend to
5–19 years. We found multiple studies in individual or small children and adolescents in school years to consolidate gains in
groups of countries on trends in height, BMI, or both. In terms children younger than 5 years and enable healthy growth
of considering combined changes in height and BMI, the Lancet through the entire developmental period.
Series on the double burden of malnutrition used data on

inadequacies and imbalances.1–3 Therefore, investing in Methods


the nutrition of school-aged children and adolescents is Data sources
crucial for a healthy transition to adulthood. For this pooled analysis, we used a database of cardio­
Height and body-mass index (BMI) are anthropometric metabolic risk factors collated by the Non-Communicable
measures of the quality of nutrition and healthiness of Disease Risk Factor Collaboration (NCD-RisC). The data­
the living environment during childhood and adolescence base and its criteria for data inclusion and exclusion are
and are highly predictive of health and developmental described in the appendix (pp 39–42). We used data from
outcomes throughout life.4–7 Having low height and the NCD-RisC database from 1985 to 2019 for analysis of
excessively low weight for one’s height, represented by BMI and from 1971 to 2019 for analysis of height. Children
low BMI, increases the risk of morbidity and mortality, aged 5 years in data from 1971 were born in 1966, and
impairs cognitive development, and reduces educational hence were 19 years old in 1985, as were children aged
performance and work productivity in later life.4,5,7 High 6 years in data from 1972 through to 19-year-old adolescents
BMI is associated with higher risk of disability and in data from 1985. Additionally, for analysis of height,
premature death in adulthood and with poor mental participants aged 20–30 years were included and assigned
health and educational outcomes.6,8 to their corresponding birth cohort, because mean height
Much of global health and nutrition research and in these ages would be at least that when they were aged
policy has focused on the period from preconception to 19 years, given that the decline of height with age begins
age 5 years.9,10 For school-aged children and adolescents, in the third and fourth decades of life. The inclusion of
global information is available only for BMI11 and, to our data from different years provided multiple observations
knowledge, no study has reported global trends in height of each birth cohort during their life course, which in turn
for these ages. In this study, we present consistent and helped to estimate the relevant parameters in the height
comparable global estimates of height and BMI for model that used birth year as its time scale. A list of the
school-aged children from 1985 to 2019 and assess how data sources we used in this analysis and their charac­
countries perform in terms of children and adolescents teristics is provided in the appendix (pp 49–89).
growing taller without excessive weight gain. We also
evaluate height and BMI trajectories by age to understand Primary outcomes
when growth is more or less healthy and to identify the Our primary outcomes were population mean height
need for intervention. and mean BMI from ages 5 to 19 years. BMI accounts for

1512 www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020


Articles

the weight gain that is simply due to becoming taller, and paper. Country and Regional Data Group members,
hence measures being underweight or overweight for a ARM, BZ, and MS had full access to the data in the study.
person’s height. When presenting results, we refer to The corresponding author had final responsibility for the
gains in height as a healthy trend because the relationship decision to submit for publication.
between height and health is positive and continuous.
We refer to BMI gain as unhealthy except in countries Results
where mean BMI was more than 1 SD lower than the We pooled 2181 population-based measurement surveys
median of the WHO reference (ie, lower than 18·7 kg/m² and studies, with anthropometric measurements on
for girls and 19·6 kg/m² for boys at age 19 years). We also 50 million people aged 5–19 years and 15 million people
compared mean height and BMI with the median of the aged 20–30 years. We used at least one data source for
WHO growth reference12 (appendix pp 90–93) at each age 193 of 200 countries and territories for which estimates
from 5 to 19 years. We used the WHO reference because were made, covering 98·7% of the world’s population
it provides growth curves for both height and BMI and is in 2019 (appendix p 94–95), and at least two data sources
used for monitoring in most countries. We started our for 177 countries, covering 98·0% of the world’s
analysis from age 5 years because children enter school population. Of these 2181 data sources, 1289 (59·1%)
at or around this age, and their nutrition, physical activity, were sampled from national populations, 360 (16·5%)
and health are influenced by food and environment at covered one or more subnational regions, and the
their homes, schools, and communities. remaining 532 (24·4%) were from one or a small num­
ber of communities. Regionally, data availability ranged
Statistical analysis from approximately three data sources per country in
We used a Bayesian hierarchical model to estimate Oceania to approxi­mately 46 sources per country in the
mean height and mean BMI by country, year, sex, and high-income Asia-Pacific region.
age. The model is described in detail in a statistical In 2019, the 19-year-olds who were on average the tallest
paper13 and related substantive papers11,14 and is sum­ in the world lived in northwestern and central European
marised in the appendix (pp 43–45). Briefly, the model countries: the Netherlands (mean height 183·8 cm,
had a hierarchical structure in which estimates for each 95% credible interval [CrI] 181·5–186·2), followed by
country and year were informed by its own data, if Montenegro, Estonia, and Bosnia and Herzegovina for
available, and by data from other years in the same boys; and the Netherlands (170·4 cm, 168·3–172·4),
country and from other countries, especially those in followed by Montenegro, Denmark, and Iceland for girls
the same region and super-region, with data for similar (figure 1A). The 19-year-olds who were on average the
time periods. The extent to which estimates for each shortest in 2019 lived in south and southeast Asia,
country-year were influenced by data from other years Latin America, and east Africa: Timor-Leste (160·1 cm,
and other countries depended on whether the country 158·0–162·2), followed by Laos, Solomon Islands, and
had data, the sample size of the data, whether they were Papua New Guinea for boys; and Guatemala (150·9 cm;
national, and the within-country and within-region 149·4–152·4), followed by Bangladesh, Nepal, and Timor-
variability of the available data. Leste for girls. The 20 cm or higher dif­ference between
The model allowed for non-linear time trends and non- countries with the tallest and shortest mean height
linear changes in mean height and BMI with age, represents approximately 8 years of growth gap for girls
including periods of rapid growth during puberty, and and approximately 6 years for boys. For example, 19-year-
the earlier age of these growth spurts in girls than in old girls in four countries (Guatemala, Bangladesh,
boys. We used observation year—the year in which data Nepal, and Timor-Leste) had the same mean height as
were collected—as the time scale for the analysis of BMI that of 11-year-old Dutch girls, and those in another
and birth year as the time scale for the analysis of height, 53 countries—such as Burundi, India, Indonesia, Laos,
consistent with previous analyses.11,14 For BMI, substantial Pakistan, Peru, the Philippines, and Yemen—had the
societal changes that affect nutrition and physical activity same mean height as that of 12-year-old Dutch girls
might affect children of different ages simultaneously, (figure 2). Similarly, 19-year-old boys in 11 countries
whereas for height, these effects accumulate in each throughout Asia, Latin America, and sub-Saharan Africa
birth cohort and a cohort’s height-for-age monotonically had the same mean height as that of Dutch boys
increases from childhood to late adolescence. aged 13 years.
The computer code for the model is available online, as Although northwestern European children and For the model code, estimates,
are our country and regional estimates both in numerical adolescents were on average the tallest in the world in and visualisations see
http://www.ncdrisc.org/
format and as interactive visualisations. All analyses 2019, much of this advantage was achieved before the
were done with R (version 3.5.1). late 20th century, and many of these countries had below
median height change from 1985 to 2019 (figure 1B,
Role of the funding source appendix pp 96–296). By contrast, central European
The funders of the study had no role in study design, countries such as Montenegro and Poland achieved a
data collection, analysis, interpretation, or writing of the substantial part of their height advantage since 1985,

www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020 1513


Articles

A Girls Boys

Caribbean Caribbean
American Samoa Fiji Montenegro Seychelles American Samoa Fiji Montenegro Seychelles
Bahrain French Polynesia Nauru Solomon Islands Bahrain French Polynesia Nauru Solomon Islands
Bermuda Kiribati Niue Tokelau Bermuda Kiribati Niue Tokelau
Brunei Maldives Palau Tonga Brunei Maldives Palau Tonga
Cape Verde Marshall Islands Samoa Tuvalu Cape Verde Marshall Islands Samoa Tuvalu
Comoros Mauritius São Tomé and Príncipe Comoros Mauritius São Tomé and Príncipe
Cook Islands Federated States of Micronesia Vanuatu Cook Islands Federated States of Micronesia Vanuatu
Height (cm) Height (cm)

150 155 160 166 171 160 166 172 178 184

Caribbean Caribbean

American Samoa Fiji Montenegro Seychelles American Samoa Fiji Montenegro Seychelles
Bahrain French Polynesia Nauru Solomon Islands Bahrain French Polynesia Nauru Solomon Islands
Bermuda Kiribati Niue Tokelau Bermuda Kiribati Niue Tokelau
Brunei Maldives Palau Tonga Brunei Maldives Palau Tonga
Cape Verde Marshall Islands Samoa Tuvalu Cape Verde Marshall Islands Samoa Tuvalu
Comoros Mauritius São Tomé and Príncipe Comoros Mauritius São Tomé and Príncipe
Cook Islands Federated States of Micronesia Vanuatu Cook Islands Federated States of Micronesia Vanuatu
Height change (cm) Height change (cm)

–1 0 2 4 5 7 −3 0 2 4 7 9

Figure 1: Height and height change by country and territory


(A) Mean height of 19-year-olds in 2019. (B) Change in mean height of 19-year-olds from 1985 to 2019.

Dutch-equivalent age (years)


11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Girls Boys

Caribbean Caribbean
American Samoa Fiji Montenegro Seychelles American Samoa Fiji Montenegro Seychelles
Bahrain French Polynesia Nauru Solomon Islands Bahrain French Polynesia Nauru Solomon Islands
Bermuda Kiribati Niue Tokelau Bermuda Kiribati Niue Tokelau
Brunei Maldives Palau Tonga Brunei Maldives Palau Tonga
Cape Verde Marshall Islands Samoa Tuvalu Cape Verde Marshall Islands Samoa Tuvalu
Comoros Mauritius São Tomé and Príncipe Comoros Mauritius São Tomé and Príncipe
Cook Islands Federated States of Micronesia Vanuatu Cook Islands Federated States of Micronesia Vanuatu

Figure 2: Growth gap for 19-year-olds in 2019 by country and territory


The growth gap is the difference between 19 years and the age at which a Dutch girl or boy, who had the highest height in the world, achieved the height of 19-year-
olds in different countries.

1514 www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020


Articles

especially in boys. However, the largest gains in height Late-adolescence BMI was also high for boys and girls in
over the past 3·5 decades were those in some emerging Middle Eastern and north African countries such as
economies, including China (largest gain for boys and Kuwait and Bahrain; in Caribbean islands such as the
third largest for girls) and South Korea (third largest for Bahamas; in Chile, the USA, and New Zealand; and, for
boys and second largest for girls), and through parts girls, in South Africa. The mean BMI of 19-year-old boys
of southeast Asia, the Middle East and north Africa, and girls was lowest (approximately 21 kg/m² or lower)
and Latin America and the Caribbean. Nonetheless, how in countries in south Asia (eg, India and Bangladesh),
much mean height changed from 1985 to 2019 varied southeast Asia (eg, Timor-Leste), and east and central
substantially, even within this group of countries. For Africa (eg, Ethiopia and Chad), as was it for 19-year-old
example, gains in mean height at age 19 years in China girls in Japan and some central European countries (eg,
were larger than in India by 3·5 cm (95% CrI 1·8–5·1) Romania and Bosnia and Herzegovina). The highest and
for boys and 2·3 cm (0·9–3·7) for girls. By contrast lowest worldwide BMIs were approximately 9–10 kg/m²
with emerging economies, the height of children and apart, equivalent to about 25 kg of weight.
adolescents, especially boys, has on average stagnated or Change in late-adolescence BMI from 1985 to 2019
become shorter since 1985 in many countries in sub- ranged from small changes (less than 0·5 kg/m²) in both
Saharan Africa.10 sexes in Japan and some European countries (eg, Italy,
Pacific island countries in Oceania had the highest Russia, and Denmark) and, for girls, in some central
mean BMI in the world in 2019, surpassing 28 kg/m² Asian (eg, Armenia) and sub-Saharan African countries,
for 19-year-olds in many of these nations (figure 3A). to increases higher than 3 kg/m² in Malaysia and some

A Girls Boys

Caribbean Caribbean
American Samoa Fiji Montenegro Seychelles American Samoa Fiji Montenegro Seychelles
Bahrain French Polynesia Nauru Solomon Islands Bahrain French Polynesia Nauru Solomon Islands
Bermuda Kiribati Niue Tokelau Bermuda Kiribati Niue Tokelau
Brunei Maldives Palau Tonga Brunei Maldives Palau Tonga
Cape Verde Marshall Islands Samoa Tuvalu Cape Verde Marshall Islands Samoa Tuvalu
Comoros Mauritius São Tomé and Príncipe Comoros Mauritius São Tomé and Príncipe
Cook Islands Federated States of Micronesia Vanuatu Cook Islands Federated States of Micronesia Vanuatu
BMI (kg/m2)

19 22 24 27 30

Caribbean Caribbean

American Samoa Fiji Montenegro Seychelles American Samoa Fiji Montenegro Seychelles
Bahrain French Polynesia Nauru Solomon Islands Bahrain French Polynesia Nauru Solomon Islands
Bermuda Kiribati Niue Tokelau Bermuda Kiribati Niue Tokelau
Brunei Maldives Palau Tonga Brunei Maldives Palau Tonga
Cape Verde Marshall Islands Samoa Tuvalu Cape Verde Marshall Islands Samoa Tuvalu
Comoros Mauritius São Tomé and Príncipe Comoros Mauritius São Tomé and Príncipe
Cook Islands Federated States of Micronesia Vanuatu Cook Islands Federated States of Micronesia Vanuatu
BMI change (kg/m2)

–1 0 1 2 3 4

Figure 3: BMI and BMI change by country and territory


(A) Mean BMI of 19-year-olds in 2019. (B) Change in mean BMI of 19-year-olds from 1985 to 2019. BMI=body-mass index.

www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020 1515


Articles

Central and eastern Europe East and southeast Asia High-income western countries* Oceania Sub-Saharan Africa
Central Asia, the Middle East, and north Africa High-income Asia-Pacific Latin America and the Caribbean South Asia
Girls
30

28
Mean BMI (kg/m2)

26

24

22

20

18
145 150 155 160 165 170 175 145 150 155 160 165 170 175 145 150 155 160 165 170 175

Boys
30

28
Mean BMI (kg/m2)

26

24

22

20

18
155 160 165 170 175 180 185 155 160 165 170 175 180 185 155 160 165 170 175 180 185
Mean height (cm) Mean height (cm) Mean height (cm)

Figure 4: Combined change from 1985 to 2019 in mean height and mean BMI of 19-year-olds
Each arrow shows one country. For each country, the arrow begins at mean height and BMI values in 1985 and ends in mean height and BMI values in 2019. Each arrow
colour refers to countries in one region. BMI=body-mass index. *Countries in northwestern Europe, southwestern Europe, and English-speaking high-income countries
(Australia, Canada, Ireland, New Zealand, the UK and the USA).

countries in Oceania for both sexes, in China for boys, respective WHO growth reference12 at each age
and in Mexico for girls (figure 3B). from 5 to 19 years (figure 5A). This comparison showed
From 1985 to 2019, 19-year-old girls in some countries that, in many countries, mean height through­out late
in central Asia (eg, Armenia and Azerbaijan) and 19-year- childhood and adolescence was lower than the median
old boys in some European countries (eg, Portugal, of the WHO growth reference (figure 5A, appendix
Denmark, Poland, and Montenegro) had moderate-to- pp 297–98). Exceptions to this pattern were much of
large gains in height alongside small or no increases in Europe and a few countries in the Caribbean and
BMI (figure 4). Meanwhile, children grew much taller Polynesia (eg, Dominica for boys and girls and French
in some countries (eg, girls in South Korea, Turkey, Polynesia for girls), where mean height throughout
Vietnam, and Saudi Arabia), while their BMI increased late child­hood and adolescence was higher than the
about the same as the global median. Both these trends median of the WHO reference by about 3 cm or more.
were healthier than those of boys and girls in much of Elsewhere, either height advantage (ie, having mean
sub-Saharan Africa and in New Zealand and the USA, height higher than the WHO reference median) at
boys in Malaysia and some countries in Oceania, and 5 years was diminished or reversed as children grew
girls in Mexico, where little or no height gain occurred, older, or height disadvantage (ie, having mean height
much larger weight was gained, or both, relative to other lower than the WHO reference median) increased.
countries. This progres­sive falling behind as children grew older
Boys born in 2000 (ie, who were aged 19 years was especially noticeable in middle-income countries
in 2019) gained from 53·4 cm to 71·3 cm of height in Latin America and the Caribbean (eg, Chile and
from their 5th to 19th birthday in different countries Uruguay), the Middle East and north Africa (eg, United
(appendix pp 96–296); for girls born in the same year, Arab Emirates), and sub-Saharan Africa (eg, Mauritius
height gain from their 5th to 19th birthday ranged and South Africa), where children had optimal height
from 43·8 cm to 55·5 cm in different countries. We at age 5 years, but by the time they reached age 19 years,
compared the mean height and mean BMI of children their height was shorter than the median of the WHO
born in 2000 in each country with the median of the reference, by about 2 cm or more. A small number of

1516 www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020


Articles

A Height gap to WHO reference


Girls Boys

vina
Papua New bique

Icelan and Herzego


Solomon Islan

Timor-Leste
Mozam
Timor-Leste

a
Bangladesh
Madagasc

Monteneg s

Monteneg s
Guatemala

Denmark ro

Estonia ro
vin
Netherland

Netherland
Guatemapal
Mar Camb ria
Philippinives

ic
Bang ascar
Slo venia nds rzego

Mad ppines
Am uania blic

Latv h Republ
Slo ok Isla nd He a
Ma

Guinea
IndonePeru
Mald sia

Nepal

Co snia a Samo

Phili lands
shal

Czec ark
Mya odia

Laos
Yemen
Lith ch Repu
Iceland

Ne
rsh akis ei

Cam men

Bosnia
Laos

ag
ladesh

Denm d
Serb a
Latvia

ds
l Is dia
Estoni
ar
all Is tan

Ma Mala da
es

Cze ia
nmar

la
Bo rican

Slo kia
b
Ye ds

Slova ia
Ukravenia
P

Libe nia
urita wi

o
lan

Cro ine
19 19
Bru ndi

Rw nesia i
Bu utan

Ind Brun e

Se atia
Sie

Fin land nia


Bh India s
ru

an
Niu vakia

Lit rbia
n

o
Ho cuad ue

rra
18 18

Po hua
Mo

nd or

Le ia
E biq via

No land
D ustr s

My P ania n
Be e
za Boli gua a

A laru

o
ura

G wed ay
17

e
17

Sw roat inica
C om ia
m

Ind ar
n
an eru

S rw
D erm en
Nic ri L

Pu erm inic y
Af

m
Ta Bhu

B om an
ia
U e ia

er ud a
gh
16 16

nz ta
es
ara ank

E
S

Fr krain den
an Pa cuad

lyn

to a
o
en e
D M ist

Ric
Po
El R Co alaw an 15 Bu kist or 15

ch
d ce
Sa n lan ay Z ru an ee m
Co lvad go i 14 Fin orw any Co am ndi 14 Gr elgiu d a
mo or
N erm uda Ma mor bia B elan on ud
Lib ros arb
Solo Rw eria 13 G rm
Be nga u
L ld
Sri esoth es
iv
os
13 Ir ban rra nd B
Le do a a
mo Leso anda
Pap n Is th 12 To kela a
To nad Equ Guine Boli nka
La o 12 An tigu lia
An stra
ua N Tan land o uda ato a B via
ew zan s
Gu ia
11 Gre ece
Gre land and B
arb ria
Côte l Guin au
iss 11 Au nada and
Ca itzerl
Mala inea 10 Po tigua s d'Iv ea 10 Sw nada
Ethio ysia An ado ines V oir
Gre rus
9 nad The anuatu e 9
Sierra Zambia
pia Barb orra e Gre Gam Bela nce
And t Lucia nt and th Tajik bia Fra ria
Leon
Eritre e
8 Sain t Vince
ista 8 Aust mbourg
Beni n
Naurua 7 Sain mbourg An n 7 Luxe Islands sia
Luxe ania Afghan gola Cook ch Polyne
Co
Mexico
6 Rom ist
DR Congan 6 Fren
Equatori lombia Cana a
da o
al Guine
a 5 Australi aland Uganda 5 UK ia
Roman aland nadines
Angola New Ze Ethiopia New Ze cent and the Gre
Belize Bulga ria Viet nam Saint Vin
Tajikistan Central African Repub
Russia lic Niue oa
Nigeria Ireland Malaysia American Sam
Panama France Eswatini Barbados
Bahrain Switzerland Nauru Jamaica
Benin Jamaica Federated States of Micronesia USA
Vietnam Fiji Honduras Tunisia
Oman UK South Africa Russia
Japan Senegal Namibia Hungary
Uganda Samoa Saint Lucia
Lebanon Nicaragua North Mac
rica Kiribati
South Af ire Tuvalu Libya
edonia
vo Togo
Côte d'I ssau China a Turkey
Bi Panam
Guinea Iraq The Ba
Niger
Moroc
a Belgiu ha m as o Cape co
Guine e) Trinid m Mexic a Sene Verde
avill USA ad and To Ghanpé Spai gal
razz ia
go (B Arab Geo bago nci
d Pri enya Toke n
Con Saudi hana
G tini Sou rgia é an K n Trin lau
a Cap th Kore Tom abo Isra idad an
E ritius
sw S ão G ze
u Pue e Verd a Beli ea Geo el d To
Ma Togo a Mo rto R e rg bag
Eritr lau Se ia o
Syri nd Ma ldov ico Pa bia Bra ychell
aila e Turk lta a ra r Ch zil es
Th Chil a Sa me d A ado a
i Ira ina
ny Lib int K nista Sau l Salv goli e Mo n
Ke dan H ya itts a n E on bw So ldo
Jor alau a Se ung nd M ba ea u
Ka th va
in i
P an
y lic Br ych ary Ne
v Zim Gu out n To zak Ko
Gu pub sia A az elle is b a
Dji kist alia O ng hs rea
S lge il s A ccu a tan
Re ne Alb urin ria be m M lger pied
Th ige alu )

an ro Uz So
N uv le
inc ay

an am ali ia
T vil

ric ic
Pr agu

Pa
Zim Djib ige é
N ip

za

Af of M ia e les
o r

ail ria
Isr ad an

Ku rda Ko a
nd ar

az

l tin
Ar babw uti

rgy Syr nd
ae
Ch otsw

Jo ong tin rea pub


wa n ng
éa P

ra s
Br

nt ate
me e

ian
l

zst ia
B ain

H rgen Ko n Re
a
o(

it
Ce St
Mo oma nia

Om an
Sp ali

A r th ica
te
ng
Ven ngo lia

C an
M ly

No min
d rrit
Co

te
ezu lia

Ita rkey stan

Do ypt e
Burk Colom had
om

ra or
Ma Gabo ela

ina bia
Tu akh bia

Eg rinam
a

de y
oT

urita n

Kaz e Gam

Su ly
Jap so
Ky
Kuw nia

Fe
S

Th ia

Ita oa mas
n

SA

Fa
ait

Cam Sudan
Tun guay

Sam Baha
a
Kyrg Cuba

R,
Guya on
Uru enland

The lta
Nam stan

na
Gre rbaijan

Ma menis

Ch
Uzbek ibia

Cypr ti
is
Aze ina Faso

Turk ugal
ero
Costa istan

Bahraius
Burk pore

Port ay
Hai

ina
Singa ied Pale

Uruguaria
Rica
Sudan

Chile
Occup al

Bulg d Arab Em
yz

us
on

Portug ina

Unite a
United Ara Vanuatu

a
Argent Korea

Albani a
b Emirates

Qatar
North an Republic

Costa Ric n
Botswan

Singapore
Cyprus

Iran Dominic

Fiji Azerbaija
Haiti

of China)
Morocco

Greenland
Mauriti
Kiribati
Hong Kong SAR, China
Taiwan (province of China)

Egypt

Venezuela
Qatar
Camero

North Macedonia

Iraq
Paraguay
Cuba

S aint K itts and Nevis


Armenia

lic
Height gap (cm)

tan
Taiwan (province
stinia

irates
n terr

−15 −10 −5 0 5 10
itory

BMI gap to WHO reference


Fed
era

Amer

ic
Cook Islands
ted

American Tokelau
Fren

Unit

epubl
Timor-Leste

ina

French Kiriba es

Cook Islands
Sta
Sa

ican Sa lau

Sri La ascar

ed A
ch Po Kuwait

gov
Romania
int

Tokelau

Tonga
tes

Nauru

an R
Samoa

Madag m
Tuvalu
Vin

Senega o
Niue

Mya bodia
Cam nka

rze

Ethiopia

Bang -Leste
rab Em Qatar
Vietna

Jap gladesh

DR Cong
of M Kir hile

Nauru
Tuvalu
India
lynesi

Ban nmar

Polyne ti

Cen ladesh
Samoa
Pa
moa

Nep tral Afric


Tonga
cen

India l
Ch iopia nd He

Niue

Niger
Bah Fiji

Eth snia a es

Palau
t a apu

icro ibati
Th

Bo ilippin

Timor
Iraq

a
nd a N B Zea land

irat
rain

Leb moa
Ph an
eB

19
K

sia
P

nesi

Th udi Chil nd

uwa

Cha al
th ew arb lan s

Sa SA
ah USA t

ano
e B Ara e
C as

19
e G G ad d

Leso ea
Eritr d
Sa

Bu tho
a

Bah mas

18
am

Pak rundi
it
La men al

An
ah bia

U in
ren uin os

Se ad

Ke dan n
Ye neg

Ne Be Islan ico
Eg ines

tig
Su ista
ra
a

18
M
ad ea

w rm ds

17
Ne hall
M

yp

ua
ars Pue Gu
Pa

Ze ud
le)
ar
w Is

an Oc
S os
Er roat n

Bh nya
ha rto in
pu
s

17 M im cc a
M otsw an
vil

ala a
C uda

cu
ia

d
Z oro an
16
ll
aN
za

D Bar lic pie


B ut

Co yan babw o
Co epa ea

az

So ub dP m m e
ew

lom Gr omin bud a


16
Br
N r it

15 ep
ng l

hin An ales or ar u
o(

R ea

on eenla ica a hR ,C tig tin Au Be


str lize
sa
15 Bis
os
Sain Isla nd ec an AR ua ian
tK
itts Qa nds 14 Cz akist ives ng S an te
d B rrit Fiji a
ali ea
in la
an Beli tar
d N ze 13
P ald Ko
M ong ia Sain oloS ar or 14 Gu ngo ibia
H str rlan ro
d t K mo Br buda y A am n
Sou Pan evis
th am 12 Au itze neg itts n Is un
a n la ei 13 N abo i
G alaw ines
BermAfrica a Sw onte n
11 M raine go
d N ds
M ev 12 M ilipp m
Ph tna
Sau Austra da
u
Uk Con Suri exic is
di A lia 10 DR nmark
nam o 11 Vie ana eone
Gh rra L
Jam bia
ra lic Cost Cypru e
Mex ca
ai 9 De iland
Tha uania ican Re
pub a
Barb Rica
s 10 Sie eria a
Nig ldives l Guine
Peru
ico
8 Lith tral Afr ado
s 9 Ma atoria r
Cen ina Faso Iraq Equ agasca
Boliv
Esw ia 7 Burk nd O
Vene man 8 Mad
El Salvaatini Pola stan zuela
7 Japan da
do
Ecuado r 6 Kyrgyz sia Egyp
Canada t Rwan
Vanuatu
r
5 Indone 6 Liberia
Cyprus Vanuatu
Yemen
United Arab Algeria Niger
Saint Vin
cent and
the GrenadHaiti
5 Mali
Emirates Moldova ines Zambia
Venezuela Burund i Libya Uganda
Jordan Portugal Andorra Sri Lanka
UK Serbia Serbia Indonesia )
Andorra South Korea Austria Congo (Brazzaville
Oman Kazakhstan Bulgaria Laos
Costa Rica Namibia Malta South Africa
Malta The Gambia Slovakia Somalia
Nicaragua France Peru Seychelles
la Benin Togo
Guatema o Nigeria Uruguay
Lesoth mark The Gambia
Somalia Den
Libya Greece Belgium
uras Angola Cambod
Hond ei Israel
Haiti ary Cape Ve ia
Brun co Tajikist Hung Guinea rde
to Ri Singap an UK
Puer wanda Burkin
R ium Bots ore lvador Kyrgyz a Faso
Slov wana El Sa nama
Belg uay Pa Eswat stan
g Equ ia ak jan
Uru ada at ze rbai s Tanza ini
n Sierr rial o A ru Hon nia
Gre razil Bela an
B lic Gu a Leo Guinea Jord nia Mo g Kong
ub Bela inea B ne ve Mo zambiq SAR, C
Rep nisia ru is sau S ntina
lo
ican Tu nada
Cô s Cu ngolia ue hina
in Cap te d'Iv e
A rman ia
rg y
Ma ba
Do
m Ca roon Tu e V oire
me bia Ge ston ia Gu urita
Ca lom nd Se rkm erde E nes r Cô yan nia
Co Icela ria Ma yche enist o o Dji te d a
Ta li lles an icr ad a
Sy cia Lib iwa o f M Ecu aic a Be bou 'Ivoir
Lu ory M er n ( tes Jam enad zil Pa nin ti e
int rit n G oz ia prov Sta Gr Bra gro It rag
Sa ter ano Lu eor amb inc ted C aly uay
b a ne ia K zec
u d

ian Le xe gia iq r
rag n

eo e te org
Fed Ira azak h Re
Pa Finla

G Cu ay

tin m ue on Ge
Sw me rag ago

s fC
Ar aly ritan
Ma uya ba

bo hin n hs pu
ale M
itz nis ua
rk a b
m
Afg Arge laysia a

It au uti

ur ta bli
Tu Nic To
n

P a)
erla tan
en

Ar ethe mbo tan


M jibo nia cedo

d g n c
the ist a

nd
d
ia

m rla ur
N xe anis

pie
D ve Ma
Ne han tin

an
rla an

en n g
Slo rth a

Ma elan ria

Lu fgh ia

c u
ad
n

Lat nds

No and

Oc
ia ds
la d

A nis n
Ic y
id
Zim Keny ia

Ug inea

Sou Hond ysia

Tu de s
ia

Trin
a
v

Gu ina

Sw aurit d
th ura
No bwe

Ch ania

Alb orea

M ailan
Mon rway

Alb ce

e
ania

Th raine ala
Bulg a

Gre ia
goli
aria

Ch in

Uk atem
Russ h Kore
ba

an

Bosn omé an acedo ina


Norto

Gu eria
pa
d Tobarael

Tog name

d Pri nia
e

Alg
go

iu
Suri bia
Bhut

zego cipé

Norwkistan
d

Zam i

Dom vina
Turkey

nia
Malaw ius

Taji land
Irelan

Gabon

Maurit

Ru a
Is

Estonia

Greence
Morocco
Germany

Iran Spain
Azerbaijan

ican Re ssia
Uzbekistan

inic

Fran
Principé
Hungary
Sweden

Comoros
Tanzania

Saint Lu blic
Ghana

Boliv
cia

Croatia (province
Turkey

Taiwanva

a
Romania

Moldo
a

Uzbekis
Lithuania

Cameroon

y
Portugal

Poland
Singapore
F inland
Ireland
pu

Nor th Kore

L atvia
C olombia
hM

BMI gap (kg/m2)


ad an

ia
d Her
Nort
São Tomé and
Trinid

tan
ia an
T

Domin
São

of Chin

−4 −2 0 2 4 6 8
a)

Central and eastern Europe Central Asia, the Middle East, and north Africa East and southeast Asia High-income Asia-Pacific High-income western countries*
Latin America and the Caribbean Oceania South Asia Sub-Saharan Africa

(Figure 5 continues on next page)

www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020 1517


Articles

B Height gap to world median


Girls Boys

vina
Papua New bique

Icelan and Herzego


Solomon Islan

Timor-Leste
a

Mozam
Timor-Leste

Bangladesh

Monteneg s
Denmark ro
Madagasc os

vin
Guatemala

Monteneg s
Netherland

Estonia ro
Netherland
Guatemapal
Philippinives

Mar Camb eria


Slo venia nds rzego

ic
Bang ascar
Am uania blic

Slo ok Isla nd He a

Mad ppines
Ma

Latv h Republ
IndonePeru
Mald sia

Co ia a Samo

Guinea
Nepal

Phili lands
shal
Lith ch Repu
Latvia d

Laos
Mya odia
rsh Pakis nei

Czec ark
Cam men

Yemen
Ne

Bosnia
La

Icelan

Serb a

ag

Denm d
ladesh
Estoni

ds
l Is
all Is tan

ar

Cze ia

Bosnerican

Ma Malawda
es
nmar

la
b

Slov kia
Ye

Slova ia
ia
Lib nia
urita i
land

n
odia

Cro raine
19
Bru ndi

e
19
Bu utan

Rw esia
Ind Brun ne

Se atia
Sie

Fin land nia


Bh India s

Be e ia
ru

an

Lit rbia
Ho cua ique

on ei

Uk
18
Niu vak

rra
18
Mo

Po hua
nd or
E b via

Le dia r
za Boli gua a

S orw d
Au laru

My P nia
ura

17

n
Uk wed tia a
C om ia

o
m

G wed ay
S roa inic
17

la
In a
D tr
d

an eru

D erm en
Nic ri L

Af
s

Pu erm inic y
ia

Ta Bhu

B om an
gh
16

es

er ud a
ar ank

16
S

Fr rain en

N
nz ta
an E

lyn
a

Pa cuad

a n

to a
D M ist en e

o
Po
15

Ric
El R Co alaw an ch d Bu kist or 15
S n
Co alvad go i lan ay Z ru an ce
14 Fin orw any Co am ndi ee m
mo o
r N erm uda Ma mor bia
14 Gr elgiu d
B elan on ud
a
L
Rw iberia s
r o
13 arb
Solo
mo Leso anda
G rm
Be nga u L ldiv s
Sri esoth es
o
13 Ir ban rra nd B
Le do a a
Pap n Is th 12 To kela a
To nad
Lan o 12 An tigu lia
ua N Tan lands o uda Equ Guine Boli ka An stra
ew zan
Guin ia
11 Gre ece
Gre land and B
arb ato a Bis via
rial sau 11 Au nada and
G Ca itzerl
Mala ea
Ethio ysia
10 Po tigua s
C ôte uine
d'I a 10 Sw nada
An ado ines V voir Gre rus
Sierra Zambia
pia 9 Barb orra e Gre
nad The anuat e
Gam u 9 Bela nce
And t Lucia nt and th
Leon
Eritre e
8 Sain t Vince
Tajik bia
istan 8 Fra ria
Aust mbourg
g
Naurua 7 in
Sa mbo
Luxe ania
ur Be
An n
ni
7 Luxe Islands sia
Afghan gola Cook ch Polyne
Co
Mexico
6 Rom ist
DR Cong an 6 Fren
Equatori lombia Cana a
da
al Guine
a 5 Australi aland Uganda
o
5 UK ia
Roman aland
Angola New Ze nadines
Ethiopia New Ze cent and the Gre
Belize Bulgaria Vietnam Saint Vin
Tajikistan Russia Central African Repub
lic Niue oa
Nigeria Ireland Malaysia American Sam
Panama France Eswatini Barbados
Bahrain Switzerland Nauru Jamaica
Benin Jamaica USA
Fiji Federated States of Micronesia
Vietnam Honduras Tunisia
Oman UK Russia
Japan Senegal South Africa
Namibia Hungary
Uganda Samoa Saint Lucia
rica Lebanon Nicaragua
South Afvoire Tuvalu Kiribati North Mac
edonia
Libya
Côte d'I ssau China Togo
Turkey
Bi a
Guinea Iraq The Ba Panam er Moroc
a Belgiu hamas Nig Cape co
Guine e) m
Mexic a
o
avill
Trinid Sene Verde
razz rabia USA ad and To Ghanpé Spai l ga
go (B A bago
Con Saudi Ghana Geo ri n ci Toke n
i Sou rgia P
and Kenya n Trin lau
atin th
Cap Kore To m é o
Esw ritius
Pue e Verd a Săo Gab lize Isra idad an
u Ge el d To
Ma Togo a Mo rto R e Be ea bag
Syri d Ma ldov ico Eritr lau Sey orgia o
n Tu lta a Pa bia Bra chell
aila e Ch zil es
Th Chil a Sainrkme d
ra
i A ador a Ira ina
ny Lib t K istn
Sau l Salv ngoli e
Ke dan H ya itts a an Mo n
w
Jor alau a Se ung nd E
Mo bab ea i So ldo
P an Br ych ary Ne in t Ka uth va
y c Alg azil elle vis Zim Gu bou n To zak Ko
Gu publi sia S e s Dji kista lia O ng hs rea
Re ne Alb urin ria A ccu a tan
be ma M lger pied
in ay

an ro
Th ige alu )

an am Uz So
N uv le
Pr gu

ric f Mic
Zim Djib ige é

ali ia
T vil
N cip

f ia e Pa
nd ara

o r

Isr had wan

za

A o les
ail ria

Ku rda Ko a
Ar abw uti

ral tes
ae
C s
éa P

az

tin
rgy Syr nd

Jo ong ntin rea pub


wa n ng
So enia e

t
Bo ain

Br

n a ian
ia

H rge Ko n Re
a

Ce d St
Sp ali

o(

it
t
Ven goli a

Om tan

A r th ica
M ly

te
ng
li
b

C an
ezu a

te

No min
m

rrit
Ita rkey stan
Mo ma
om

Co

zs

ra
Ma Gabo ela

Do ypt e
Tu zakh bia

Burk Colo had

or
a

ina mbia

de
urita n

Eg rinam
Ka Gam
oT

y
n

Kuw nia

Th isia

Su ly
Jap so

Fe
Ky
ait

Tun guay d

Ita oa mas

SA
n
Fa
Kyrg Cuba

e
Uru enlan

Cam Sudan

Sam Baha
a
Nam stan

Gre rbaijan

Guya on

R,
The lta
Aze ina Faso
Uzbek ibia

Ma menis
na
Costa istan

Burk pore

Ch
Cypr ti

Turk ugal
ero
Singa ied Pale
Rica

Port ay
Hai
us
Sudan

Occup al
yz

ina
on

Uruguaria
Portug ina
United Ara Vanuatu

Argent Korea

Botswanus
Chile

Bulg d Arab Em
b Emirates

Bahrai
North an Republic

Unite a
Cyprus

Iran Dominic

a
Haiti

Morocco
Taiwan (province of China)
Hong Kong SAR, China

Albani a
Kiribati

Qatar
Egypt
Qatar
Camero

North Macedonia

Costa Ric n
Taiwan (province Singapore
Mauriti

Fiji Azerbaija
Greenland
Armenia
of China)
Venezuela

Iraq
Paraguay
C uba

S aint K itts and Nevis

lic
Height gap (cm)

tan
stinia

irates
n terr

−15 −10 −5 0 5 10
itory

BMI gap to world median


Fed
era

Amer
ted

ic
Cook Islands
Fren

American Tokelau
Unit
Timor-Leste

epubl
ina

French Kiriba es
Sta
Sa

C ook Is lands
ican SaPalau

Sri La ascar
ch Po Kuwait

gov

ed A
Romania
int

Tokelau
tes

Tonga
Nauru

an R
Madag m
Samoa
Vin

Tuvalu

Mya bodia
Cam nka
Niue

Senega o
rze

Bang -Leste
Ethiopia
Vietna

Jap gladesh
of M Kir ile

rab Em Qatar

DR Cong
India
lynesi

Ban nmar

Nauru
Tuvalu
Polyne ti
moa

Cen ladesh
cen

Samoa

Nep tral Afric


Tonga
Ch iopia nd He

India l
Niue
Bah Fiji

Niger
Eth snia a es

Palau
Th
t a apu

icro ibati

Bo ilippin
Iraq

Timor
a
nd a N B Zea land

eB

rain

irat
Leb moa
Ph an

19
sia
K
nesi
P

Th udi A Chil nd

u
th ew arb lan s

Cha al
ah USA t

Sa SA

wait
ano
Ch as

eB
e G G ad d

19
Sa

Le trea
d

Bu sotho
am

Bah amas

18
La me al

Su kista i

An
Pa rund
ah rabia e
ren uin os

Se ad

U in

n
Ye neg

Ke dan n
Ne Be Islan ico

Eri
Eg es

tig
ra
S os n

18
ad ea

M P ew

17
w r m ds
Ne hall
M

ua
yp

ars ue Gu
in

le)

Pa
ar

Ze ud

Oc
w Is

an
Er roat n

B ya
s

ha rto in
pu

17
vil

M im occ a
M ots an

cu
ala a
C uda
ia

d
16
Z or wan
n
za

ll

pie
aN

D Bar lic
B hut

Co yan babw o
Co epa ea

az

m m e

So ub dP
lom Gre om bud a
16
Br
N r it

15 ep hin An alest
ng l

u
o(

or ar

on enla inica a
R ea

h R an ,C tig inia Au Be sa
Sain R str lize Bis
15
os

Isla nd e c A
tK
itts Qa nds 14 Cz akist ives ng S
P ald Ko
ua
an n te ali
d B rrit Fiji a
ea
in la
an Beli tar
d N ze 13 M ong ia Sain Solo ar or 14 Gu ngo ibia
H str rlan ro
d t K mo Bru buda y A am n
Sou Pan evis
th am 12 u
A it ne ze g it t sa n Is
nd land ei
n 13 N abo i
G alaw ines
BermAfrica a Sw onte
11 M raine go M ev
N s 12 M ilipp m
Ph tna
Sau Austra da
u
Uk Con Suri exic is
di A lia 10 DR nmark
nam o 11 Vie ana eone
Gh rra L
Jam bia
ra lic Cost Cypru e
Mex ca
ai 9 De iland
Tha uania ican Re
pub a
Barb Rica
s 10 Sie eria a
Nig ldives l Guine
Pe
ico
8 Lith tral Afr ado
s 9 Ma atoria r
Boliv ru Cen ina Faso Iraq Equ agasca
Eswat ia 7 Burk nd O
Vene man 8 Mad
El Salva ini la zu
do 6
Po yzstan
Kyrg sia Egyp
ela
7 an
Jap da
Rwan
Ecuado r Canadat
Vanuatu
r
5 Indone
Vanuatu 6 Liberia
Cyprus Yemen
United Arab
Algeria Niger
Saint Vin
cent and
the GrenadHaiti
5 Mali
Emirates Moldova ines Zambia
Venezuela Burundi Libya Uganda
Jordan Portugal Andorra Sri Lanka
UK Serbia Serbia Indonesia )
Andorra South Korea Austria Congo (Brazzaville
Oman Kazakhstan Bulgaria Laos
Costa Rica Namibia Malta South Africa
Malta The Gambia Slovakia Somalia
Nicaragua France Peru Seychelles
la Benin Togo
Guatema o Nigeria Uruguay
The Gambia
Lesoth Somalia Denmark Belgium
Libya Greece
uras Angola Cambod
Hond ei Israel
Haiti ary Cape Ve ia
Brun Tajikist Hung K Guine rde
co
to Ri Singap an U
Burkin a
Puer wanda
R ium Bots ore lvador Kyrgyz a Faso
El Sa nama
Belg uay Slov wana Pa jan Esw stan
g
Uru ada Equ akia rb ai Tanzaatini
n Sierr atorial A elarus
ze
Gre Brazil G B an Hon nia
a u Mo g Kong
c Gu Leo inea Jord nia
ubli Be inea B ne ve Mo zambiq SAR, C
Rep isia Côtelarus issau Slo ntina
ic an Tun da e y Cu ngolia ue hina
min na Ca d'I Arg rman ia Ma ba
Do Ca roon Tur pe Ve voire G e ton Gu urita
me bia Se km rde Es nesia r Cô yan nia
Ca lom nd M ych enis
Co Icela yria ro do Dji te d a
S cia Taiwali elles tan f Mic Ecua aica Be bou 'Ivoir
Lib a o a
Lu ory M er n ( tes Jam nad zil Pa nin ti e
int rit n G oz ia prov Sta e
Gr Bra gro It rag
Sa ter ano Lu eor amb ted C aly uay
ian Leb
inc era ne ia K zec
u d

xe gia iq te org
rag n

eo
Fed Ira azak h Re
Pa Finla

G Cu ay

in m ue on Ge
Sw men rag go

t fC
les
Ar aly ritan
M uy ba

bo hin n hs pu
itz ist ua

M
rk ica a
Tu N Tob
m
Afg rge laysia a

It au uti

a ur a ta bli
erla an
A a an

dP
Ar eth mbo tan

)
en

n c
M jibo nia cedo

g
m erla ur
Sy nd

N xe anis
d
Ne han tina

ia

pie
D ve Ma

an

en n g
Lu fgh ia
rla an

Ma elan ia
Slo rth a

cu
ad

Ic r

ia ds
la d

A nis n
n

Lat nds

Oc
No and
the ist

Sou Hond ysia


id

Tu ede ius
Zim Keny ia

Ug inea

ia

s
Trin

Sw aurit d
v

Gu ina
ba a

th ura
No bwe

Alb orea

M ailan
Ch ania
Mon rway

ania
Alb ce

Th raine ala
Bulg a

Gre ia

Ch in

Uk atem
goli
aria

Russ h Kore

Bosn Tomé an acedo ina

Gu eria
an

a
Norto

d Pri nia
d Tobarael

Alg ay
Tog name

p
e
go

zego cipé

Norwkistan
Suri bia
Bhut

Dom vina
d

Zam i

Taji land
Turkey

nia
Malaw ius

inica
Irelan

Greence
Gabon

Maurit
Is

ican Re Russia
Estonia

Morocco

Fran ia
Germany

Iran
Azerbaijan

Spain

Saint Lublic
Uzbekistan
Principé

Boliv
Hungary
Sweden

Comoros

cia
Tanzania
Ghana

Croatia (province
Turkey
Romania

Taiwan va
a

Moldo
Lithuania

Cameroon Uzbekis
Portugal
Nor th Kore

Poland
pu

Finland

Singapore
C olombia
Ireland
Latvia
M
ad an

d Her

BMI gap (kg/m2)


orth
Săo Tomé and

tan
N
Trinid

ia an

Domin
Săo

of Chin

−4 −2 0 2 4 6 8
a)

Central and eastern Europe Central Asia, the Middle East, and north Africa East and southeast Asia High-income Asia-Pacific High-income western countries*
Latin America and the Caribbean Oceania South Asia Sub-Saharan Africa

1518 www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020


Articles

countries (eg, Russia for boys and girls and Iran for France, and Croatia), Japan, and Seychelles progressively
boys) slightly reduced the gap to the WHO reference moved towards healthier BMIs relative to other countries,
median during late childhood and adolescence. and the difference between their BMI and the global
For BMI, the deficit relative to the WHO reference median changed from positive to negative. By contrast,
median at age 5 years, which was seen mainly in sub- girls and boys in countries such as Kuwait, Bahrain,
Saharan Africa and south and southeast Asia, generally Fiji, Jamaica, and Mexico; and girls in South Africa and
became smaller or disappeared as children grew to New Zealand had a progressively higher BMI relative to
adolescence and reached age 19 years (figure 5A). For the global median as they became older.
girls in South Africa and girls and boys in Canada, China,
and some countries in Oceania, the Middle East and Discussion
north Africa, and Latin America and the Caribbean, We identified highly variable age trajectories and trends
mean BMI was similar to the WHO reference median for over time in the height and BMI of school-aged children
5-year-old children, but exceeded the WHO reference and adolescents across countries and territories. These
median as the children became older. cross-country differences show that childhood and adoles­
Comparing height and BMI in each country with the cence are crucial periods in differentiating countries in
median of all countries (figure 5B) showed that children terms of how they shape these determinants of lifelong
and adolescents in some countries had a consistent health.
height advantage or disadvantage relative to those in Our results are consistent with findings from both
other countries at every age. This was especially the case studies of adolescents in individual countries and global
for countries at the top (eg, the Netherlands, Denmark, studies of adult height, which show substantial variation
Montenegro, Estonia, and Iceland) and the bottom in how much height has changed throughout the
(eg, Timor-Leste, Laos, Nepal, Yemen, and Guatemala) of world.14 One study,15 assessing cross-sectional height in
the global ranks at age 19 years. For other countries, 53 community-based samples, found substantial cross-
children’s height caught up with or fell behind their population variation in height differences from ages
comparators during school ages. For example, children in 10–17 years, which is consistent with our findings on
some European countries (eg, girls in Belgium and boys age trajectories. Our results are also consistent with
in Austria) and Latin America and the Caribbean (eg, girls previous global analyses11 in terms of regions and
in Puerto Rico and boys in Barbados) had about the same countries with the highest and lowest BMI, but previous
height as Dutch children at age 5 years, but progressively studies had not considered age trajectories.
fell behind such that, by the time they were 19 years old, Our study has strengths in scope, data, and methods:
they were more than 5 cm shorter than Dutch adolescents. we presented novel estimates of height in school-aged
By contrast, the height of children and adolescents in children and adolescents for all countries in the world,
Latvia, Czech Republic, Morocco, and Iran progressively and we did so alongside estimates of BMI. We used
improved relative to others as they approached age an unprecedented scale of population-based data from
19 years. 193 countries and territories covering approximately
When age-specific mean BMI was compared with the 99% of the world’s population, while maintaining a high
global median (figure 5B), whether a country had low standard of data representativeness and quality. Data
(eg, countries in south and southeast Asia) or high were analysed according to a consistent protocol, and
(eg, the USA, Chile, and countries in Oceania) mean the characteristics and quality of data from each country
BMI relative to others, persisted more than was the case were rigorously verified through repeated checks by
for height. Nonetheless, some differences in age trajec­ NCD-RisC members. We used a statistical model that
tories of BMI occurred across countries. For example, accounted for non-linear changes in height and BMI
girls and boys in some European countries (eg, Italy, throughout childhood and adolescence, and we used all
available data while giving more weight to national data
than to subnational and community sources.
As with all global analyses, our study has some
Figure 5: Age trajectory of height and BMI for 19-year-olds in 2019
limitations. Despite our extensive efforts to identify
Mean height and BMI of 19-year-olds in 2019 (ie, those born in 2000) at each age
from 5 to 19 years compared with the median of the WHO growth reference12 (A) and access worldwide population-based data, some
and the world median (B). Each cell represents the difference between the height countries, espe­cially those in the Caribbean, Polynesia
or BMI of children and adolescents in one country and the median value for a and Micronesia, Melanesia, and sub-Saharan Africa, had
given age of the WHO growth reference (A) and all countries (B). Countries are
fewer data sources than in other regions. The scarcity of
ordered by decreasing height or increasing BMI in adolescents at age 19 years in
2019. The median of the WHO growth reference and world median are presented data is reflected in the larger uncertainty of our estimates
in the appendix (pp 90–93). Results reported as Z scores of the WHO growth for these countries and regions compared with those for
reference are presented in the appendix (pp 297–98). A comparison of height and other countries. Of the studies used, less than half
BMI gap between boys and girls is presented in the appendix (pp 299–300).
had data for children aged 5–9 years compared with
BMI=body-mass index. SAR=Special Administrative Region. *Countries in
northwestern Europe, southwestern Europe, and English-speaking high-income nearly 90% with data for children aged 10–19 years,
countries (Australia, Canada, Ireland, New Zealand, the UK and the USA). which increases the uncertainty of findings for the

www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020 1519


Articles

younger age groups. BMI is an imperfect measure of the Fully establishing the drivers of the observed height
extent and distribution of fat in the body, but it has the and BMI trajectories and trends requires data on these
major advantage of having consistent and comparable determinants and their distributions in different
data in many population-based surveys, especially com­ countries.
pared with measures such as body fat measured by dual- Our findings on the heterogeneous age trajectories
energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA), which is complex and time trends of height and BMI in late childhood and
and costly and cannot be used in surveys. A systematic adolescence raise the need to rethink and revise two
review reported that BMI and DEXA-measured body common features of global health and nutrition pro­
fat were highly correlated.16 We compared height and grammes. First, we need to overcome the disconnect in
BMI in each country with the median of the WHO research and practice between reducing undernutrition,
growth reference.12 Although the reference is the current particularly short stature, and preventing and managing
international comparison tool,17 unlike that of children overweight and obesity.11,19,21 Second, the finding that
younger than 5 years, it is not based on a multicountry children in some countries grow healthily to age 5 years
sample of predominantly healthy and well-nourished but do not continue to do so during school years shows
children.12 Consequently, the reference might be affected an imbalance between investment in improving nutrition
by slower growth as the sample children grew older.18 and growth before age 5 years and doing so in school-
Future studies should also evaluate the socio­economic aged children and adolescents.38 Therefore, our findings
and geographical patterns of height and BMI in these should motivate policies and interventions at home, at
ages, as has been done for children younger than 5 years school, in the community, and through the health system
and adults.19,20 to support healthy growth during the entire period
Several factors that interact throughout childhood and from birth to adolescence through enhanced nutritional
adolescence, and possibly across generations, might quality, healthier living environment, and provision of
be responsible for the heterogeneous worldwide age high-quality preventive and curative care. These mea­
trajectories and trends of height and BMI.21 First, there sures include agricultural and food system policies39 that
is an important genetic component to height22,23 and, to increase the availability and reduce the cost of nutritious
a lesser extent, to BMI24 within populations. However, foods that help children grow taller without gaining
genetics explains a small part of the variation across excessive weight for their height; (conditional) cash
countries or the changes over time, especially for transfers and food vouchers towards nutritious foods
BMI.25–28 That genetics has a small role in height and for low-income families; free healthy school meal
BMI at the population level relative to nutrition and programmes; fiscal and regulatory policies that restrict
environment is also supported by the finding that the the consumption of unhealthy foods, especially pro­
height of migrant descendents typically converges to the cessed carbohydrates; the provision of affordable healthy
height of their new country within a few generations.29–31 housing, clean water, and sanitation; and the provision of
Second, some of the observed differences in height and facilities for play and sports in the community and at
BMI might be intergenerational or due to exposures school. Taking these actions would enable children to
and experiences during pregnancy, mediated through grow taller without gaining excessive weight, with
birth length and weight.21 Third, the age of puberty lifelong benefits for their health and wellbeing.
onset, which is influenced by diet, physical activity, Contributors
and weight gain during childhood, might affect height ARM, ZB, RB, and ME designed the study. Members of the Country and
gain during the adolescent growth spurt and in late Regional Data Group collected and re-analysed data and checked pooled
data for accuracy of information about their study and other studies in
adolescence.32 Although some studies have found a their country. ARM, BZ, and MS led the data collection. ARM led the
negative association between age of pubertal onset and statistical analysis with input from BZ, JB, JEB, CJP, and ME and
final height,33 others have found that age of pubertal prepared results. Members of the Pooled Analysis and Writing Group
onset does not affect final height, because an earlier contributed to study design, collated data, and checked all data sources
in consultation with the Country and Regional Data Group. ARM and
puberty onset might be compensated by a more intense ME wrote the first draft of the report with input from other members of
or longer period of peak height velocity.34 No comparable the Pooled Analysis and Writing Group. Members of the Country and
global data exist on age at menarche and timing of Regional Data Group commented on the draft report. ME oversaw
pubertal growth, but national data indicate substantial research. The authors alone are responsible for the views expressed in
this Article and they do not necessarily represent the views, decisions,
changes in some countries. Finally, all of these pathways or policies of the institutions with which they are affiliated.
are influenced by food and nutrition,28,35,36 including
NCD Risk Factor Collaboration (NCD-RisC) pooled analysis and writing
energy balance, and adequacy and quality of nutrients, Andrea Rodriguez-Martinez, Bin Zhou, Marisa K Sophiea,
especially proteins, fats, and micronutrients.18,21,37 There James Bentham, Prof Christopher J Paciorek, Maria LC Iurilli,
is also an important effect from the occurrence and Rodrigo M Carrillo-Larco, James E Bennett, Mariachiara Di Cesare,
treatment of infections, which itself is influenced by Cristina Taddei, Honor Bixby, Gretchen A Stevens, Leanne M Riley,
Melanie J Cowan, Stefan Savin, Goodarz Danaei, Adela Chirita-Emandi,
water and sanitation, and whether episodes of infections Prof Andre P Kengne, Prof Young-Ho Khang, Prof Avula Laxmaiah,
are effectively treated in a timely manner. Similarly, Prof Reza Malekzadeh, Prof J Jaime Miranda, Prof Jin Soo Moon,
physical activity at home and school can influence BMI. Stevo R Popovic, Prof Thorkild IA Sørensen, Maroje Sorić, Gregor Starc,

1520 www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020


Articles

Ahmad A Zainuddin, Prof Edward W Gregg, Prof Zulfiqar A Bhutta, Alexandra M Cucu*, Liufu Cui*, Felipe V Cureau*, Graziella D’Arrigo*,
Prof Robert Black, Prof Majid Ezzati. Eleonora d’Orsi*, Liliana Dacica*, María Ángeles Dal Re Saavedra*,
Jean Dallongeville*, Albertino Damasceno*, Camilla T Damsgaard*,
NCD Risk Factor Collaboration (NCD-RisC) country and regional data, listed
Goodarz Danaei*, Rachel Dankner*, Thomas M Dantoft*,
alphabetically
Parasmani Dasgupta*, Saeed Dastgiri*, Luc Dauchet*, Kairat Davletov*,
Leandra Abarca-Gómez*, Ziad A Abdeen*, Shynar Abdrakhmanova*,
Guy De Backer*, Dirk De Bacquer*, Giovanni de Gaetano*,
Suhaila Abdul Ghaffar*, Hanan F Abdul Rahim*,
Stefaan De Henauw*, Paula Duarte de Oliveira*, David De Ridder*,
Niveen M Abu-Rmeileh*, Jamila Abubakar Garba*,
Karin De Ridder*, Susanne R de Rooij*, Delphine De Smedt*,
Benjamin Acosta-Cazares*, Robert J Adams*, Wichai Aekplakorn*,
Mohan Deepa*, Alexander D Deev*, Vincent Jr DeGennaro*,
Kaosar Afsana*, Shoaib Afzal*, Imelda A Agdeppa*,
Abbas Dehghan*, Hélène Delisle*, Francis Delpeuch*,
Javad Aghazadeh-Attari*, Carlos A Aguilar-Salinas*,
Stefaan Demarest*, Elaine Dennison*, Katarzyna Dereń*,
Charles Agyemang*, Mohamad Hasnan Ahmad*, Noor Ani Ahmad*,
Valérie Deschamps*, Klodian Dhana*, Meghnath Dhimal*,
Ali Ahmadi*, Naser Ahmadi*, Soheir H Ahmed*, Wolfgang Ahrens*,
Augusto F Di Castelnuovo*, Juvenal Soares Dias-da-Costa*,
Gulmira Aitmurzaeva*, Kamel Ajlouni*, Hazzaa M Al-Hazzaa*,
María Elena Díaz-Sánchez*, Alejandro Diaz*, Zivka Dika*,
Amani Rashed Al-Othman*, Rajaa Al-Raddadi*, Monira Alarouj*,
Shirin Djalalinia*, Visnja Djordjic*, Ha TP Do*, Annette J Dobson*,
Fadia AlBuhairan*, Shahla AlDhukair*, Mohamed M Ali*,
Maria Benedetta Donati*, Chiara Donfrancesco*, Silvana P Donoso*,
Abdullah Alkandari*, Ala’a Alkerwi*, Kristine Allin*,
Angela Döring*, Maria Dorobantu*, Ahmad Reza Dorosty*,
Mar Alvarez-Pedrerol*, Eman Aly*, Deepak N Amarapurkar*,
Kouamelan Doua*, Wojciech Drygas*, Jia Li Duan*,
Parisa Amiri*, Norbert Amougou*, Philippe Amouyel*,
Charmaine A Duante*, Priscilla Duboz*, Rosemary B Duda*,
Lars Bo Andersen*, Sigmund A Anderssen*, Lars Ängquist*,
Vesselka Duleva*, Virginija Dulskiene*, Samuel C Dumith*,
Ranjit Mohan Anjana*, Alireza Ansari-Moghaddam*,
Anar Dushpanova*, Vilnis Dzerve*, Elzbieta Dziankowska-Zaborszczyk*,
Hajer Aounallah-Skhiri*, Joana Araújo*, Inger Ariansen*, Tahir Aris*,
Ricky Eddie*, Ebrahim Eftekhar*, Eruke E Egbagbe*, Robert Eggertsen*,
Raphael E Arku*, Nimmathota Arlappa*, Krishna K Aryal*,
Sareh Eghtesad*, Gabriele Eiben*, Ulf Ekelund*,
Thor Aspelund*, Felix K Assah*, Maria Cecília F Assunção*,
Mohammad El-Khateeb*, Jalila El Ati*, Denise Eldemire-Shearer*,
May Soe Aung*, Juha Auvinen*, Mária Avdicová*, Ana Azevedo*,
Marie Eliasen*, Paul Elliott*, Reina Engle-Stone*, Macia Enguerran*,
Mohsen Azimi-Nezhad*, Fereidoun Azizi*, Mehrdad Azmin*,
Rajiv T Erasmus*, Raimund Erbel*, Cihangir Erem*, Louise Eriksen*,
Bontha V Babu*, Maja Bæksgaard Jørgensen*, Azli Baharudin*,
Johan G Eriksson*, Jorge Escobedo-de la Peña*, Saeid Eslami*,
Suhad Bahijri*, Jennifer L Baker*, Nagalla Balakrishna*,
Ali Esmaeili*, Alun Evans*, David Faeh*, Albina A Fakhretdinova*,
Mohamed Bamoshmoosh*, Maciej Banach*, Piotr Bandosz*,
Caroline H Fall*, Elnaz Faramarzi*, Mojtaba Farjam*,
José R Banegas*, Joanna Baran*, Carlo M Barbagallo*, Alberto Barceló*,
Victoria Farrugia Sant’Angelo*, Farshad Farzadfar*,
Amina Barkat*, Aluisio JD Barros*, Mauro Virgílio Gomes Barros*,
Mohammad Reza Fattahi*, Asher Fawwad*, Francisco J Felix-Redondo*,
Abdul Basit*, Joao Luiz D Bastos*, Iqbal Bata*, Anwar M Batieha*,
Trevor S Ferguson*, Romulo A Fernandes*, Daniel Fernández-Bergés*,
Rosangela L Batista*, Zhamilya Battakova*, Assembekov Batyrbek*,
Daniel Ferrante*, Thomas Ferrao*, Marika Ferrari*, Marco M Ferrario*,
Louise A Baur*, Robert Beaglehole*, Silvia Bel-Serrat*,
Catterina Ferreccio*, Eldridge Ferrer*, Jean Ferrieres*,
Antonisamy Belavendra*, Habiba Ben Romdhane*, Judith Benedics*,
Thamara Hubler Figueiró*, Anna Fijalkowska*, Günther Fink*,
Mikhail Benet*, James E Bennett*, Salim Berkinbayev*,
Krista Fischer*, Bernhard Föger*, Leng Huat Foo*, Maria Forsner*,
Antonio Bernabe-Ortiz*, Gailute Bernotiene*, Heloísa Bettiol*,
Heba M Fouad*, Damian K Francis*, Maria do Carmo Franco*,
Jorge Bezerra*, Aroor Bhagyalaxmi*, Sumit Bharadwaj*,
Oscar H Franco*, Ruth Frikke-Schmidt*, Guillermo Frontera*,
Santosh K Bhargava*, Zulfiqar A Bhutta*, Hongsheng Bi*, Yufang Bi*,
Flavio D Fuchs*, Sandra C Fuchs*, Isti I Fujiati*, Yuki Fujita*,
Daniel Bia*, Elysée Claude Bika Lele*, Mukharram M Bikbov*,
Matsuda Fumihiko*, Takuro Furusawa*, Zbigniew Gaciong*,
Bihungum Bista*, Dusko J Bjelica*, Peter Bjerregaard*,
Mihai Gafencu*, Andrzej Galbarczyk*, Henrike Galenkamp*,
Espen Bjertness*, Marius B Bjertness*, Cecilia Björkelund*,
Daniela Galeone*, Myriam Galfo*, Fabio Galvano*, Jingli Gao*,
Katia V Bloch*, Anneke Blokstra*, Simona Bo*, Martin Bobak*,
Manoli Garcia-de-la-Hera*, Marta García-Solano*, Dickman Gareta*,
Lynne M Boddy*, Bernhard O Boehm*, Heiner Boeing*,
Sarah P Garnett*, Jean-Michel Gaspoz*, Magda Gasull*,
Jose G Boggia*, Elena Bogova*, Carlos P Boissonnet*, Stig E Bojesen*,
Adroaldo Cesar Araujo Gaya*, Anelise Reis Gaya*, Andrea Gazzinelli*,
Marialaura Bonaccio*, Vanina Bongard*, Alice Bonilla-Vargas*,
Ulrike Gehring*, Harald Geiger*, Johanna M Geleijnse*, Ali Ghanbari*,
Matthias Bopp*, Herman Borghs*, Pascal Bovet*, Lien Braeckevelt*,
Erfan Ghasemi*, Oana-Florentina Gheorghe-Fronea*,
Lutgart Braeckman*, Marjolijn CE Bragt*, Imperia Brajkovich*,
Simona Giampaoli*, Francesco Gianfagna*, Tiffany K Gill*,
Francesco Branca*, Juergen Breckenkamp*, João Breda*,
Jonathan Giovannelli*, Glen Gironella*, Aleksander Giwercman*,
Hermann Brenner*, Lizzy M Brewster*, Garry R Brian*,
Konstantinos Gkiouras*, Justyna Godos*, Sibel Gogen*,
Lacramioara Brinduse*, Sinead Brophy*, Graziella Bruno*,
Rebecca A Goldsmith*, David Goltzman*, Santiago F Gómez*,
H Bas Bueno-de-Mesquita*, Anna Bugge*, Marta Buoncristiano*,
Aleksandra Gomula*, Bruna Goncalves Cordeiro da Silva*,
Genc Burazeri*, Con Burns*, Antonio Cabrera de León*,
Helen Gonçalves*, David A Gonzalez-Chica*, Marcela Gonzalez-Gross*,
Joseph Cacciottolo*, Hui Cai*, Tilema Cama*, Christine Cameron*,
Margot González-Leon*, Juan P González-Rivas*,
José Camolas*, Günay Can*, Ana Paula C Cândido*, Felicia Cañete*,
Clicerio González-Villalpando*, María-Elena González-Villalpando*,
Mario V Capanzana*, Nadežda Capková*, Eduardo Capuano*,
Angel R Gonzalez*, Frederic Gottrand*, Antonio Pedro Graça*,
Vincenzo Capuano*, Marloes Cardol*, Viviane C Cardoso*,
Sidsel Graff-Iversen*, Dušan Grafnetter*, Aneta Grajda*,
Axel C Carlsson*, Esteban Carmuega*, Joana Carvalho*,
Maria G Grammatikopoulou*, Ronald D Gregor*, Tomasz Grodzicki*,
José A Casajús*, Felipe F Casanueva*, Ertugrul Celikcan*, Laura Censi*,
Else Karin Grøholt*, Anders Grøntved*, Giuseppe Grosso*,
Marvin Cervantes-Loaiza*, Juraci A Cesar*, Snehalatha Chamukuttan*,
Gabriella Gruden*, Dongfeng Gu*, Emanuela Gualdi-Russo*,
Angelique W Chan*, Queenie Chan*, Himanshu K Chaturvedi*,
Pilar Guallar-Castillón*, Andrea Gualtieri*, Elias F Gudmundsson*,
Nish Chaturvedi*, Norsyamlina Che Abdul Rahim*, Chien-Jen Chen*,
Vilmundur Gudnason*, Ramiro Guerrero*, Idris Guessous*,
Fangfang Chen*, Huashuai Chen*, Shuohua Chen*, Zhengming
Andre L Guimaraes*, Martin C Gulliford*, Johanna Gunnlaugsdottir*,
Chen*, Ching-Yu Cheng*, Bahman Cheraghian*, Angela Chetrit*,
Marc J Gunter*, Xiu-Hua Guo*, Yin Guo*, Prakash C Gupta*,
Ekaterina Chikova-Iscener*, Arnaud Chiolero*, Shu-Ti Chiou*,
Rajeev Gupta*, Oye Gureje*, Beata Gurzkowska*,
Adela Chirita-Emandi*, María-Dolores Chirlaque*, Belong Cho*,
Enrique Gutiérrez-González*, Laura Gutierrez*, Felix Gutzwiller*,
Kaare Christensen*, Diego G Christofaro*, Jerzy Chudek*,
Seongjun Ha*, Farzad Hadaegh*, Charalambos A Hadjigeorgiou*,
Renata Cifkova*, Michelle Cilia*, Eliza Cinteza*, Frank Claessens*,
Rosa Haghshenas*, Hamid Hakimi*, Jytte Halkjær*, Ian R Hambleton*,
Janine Clarke*, Els Clays*, Emmanuel Cohen*, Hans Concin*,
Behrooz Hamzeh*, Dominique Hange*, Abu AM Hanif*,
Susana C Confortin*, Cyrus Cooper*, Tara C Coppinger*,
Sari Hantunen*, Rachakulla Hari Kumar*,
Eva Corpeleijn*, Simona Costanzo*, Dominique Cottel*, Chris Cowell*,
Seyed Mohammad Hashemi-Shahri*, Maria Hassapidou*, Jun Hata*,
Cora L Craig*, Amelia C Crampin*, Ana B Crujeiras*, Semánová Csilla*,

www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020 1521


Articles

Teresa Haugsgjerd*, Alison J Hayes*, Jiang He*, Yuan He*, Yuna He*, Bernard Maire*, Marjeta Majer*, Marcia Makdisse*, Päivi Mäki*,
Regina Heidinger-Felso*, Mirjam Heinen*, Tatjana Hejgaard*, Fatemeh Malekzadeh*, Reza Malekzadeh*, Rahul Malhotra*,
Marleen Elisabeth Hendriks*, Rafael dos Santos Henrique*, Kodavanti Mallikharjuna Rao*, Sofia K Malyutina*, Lynell V Maniego*,
Ana Henriques*, Leticia Hernandez Cadena*, Sauli Herrala*, Yannis Manios*, Jim I Mann*, Fariborz Mansour-Ghanaei*,
Victor M Herrera*, Isabelle Herter-Aeberli*, Ramin Heshmat*, Enzo Manzato*, Paula Margozzini*, Anastasia Markaki*,
Allan G Hill*, Sai Yin Ho*, Suzanne C Ho*, Michael Hobbs*, Oonagh Markey*, Eliza Markidou Ioannidou*, Pedro Marques-Vidal*,
Albert Hofman*, Ingunn Holden Bergh*, Michelle Holdsworth*, Larissa Pruner Marques*, Jaume Marrugat*, Yves Martin-Prevel*,
Reza Homayounfar*, Clara Homs*, Wilma M Hopman*, Rosemarie Martin*, Reynaldo Martorell*, Eva Martos*,
Andrea RVR Horimoto*, Claudia M Hormiga*, Bernardo L Horta*, Stefano Marventano*, Luis P Mascarenhas*, Shariq R Masoodi*,
Leila Houti*, Christina Howitt*, Thein Thein Htay*, Aung Soe Htet*, Ellisiv B Mathiesen*, Prashant Mathur*, Alicia Matijasevich*,
Maung Maung Than Htike*, Yonghua Hu*, José María Huerta*, Tandi E Matsha*, Christina Mavrogianni*, Artur Mazur*,
Ilpo Tapani Huhtaniemi*, Constanta Huidumac Petrescu*, Jean Claude N Mbanya*, Shelly R McFarlane*, Stephen T McGarvey*,
Abdullatif Husseini*, Chinh Nguyen Huu*, Inge Huybrechts*, Martin McKee*, Stela McLachlan*, Rachael M McLean*,
Nahla Hwalla*, Jolanda Hyska*, Licia Iacoviello*, Jesús M Ibarluzea*, Scott B McLean*, Breige A McNulty*, Sounnia Mediene-Benchekor*,
Mohsen M Ibrahim*, Norazizah Ibrahim Wong*, Nayu Ikeda*, Jurate Medzioniene*, Parinaz Mehdipour*, Kirsten Mehlig*,
M Arfan Ikram*, Violeta Iotova*, Vilma E Irazola*, Takafumi Ishida*, Amir Houshang Mehrparvar*, Aline Meirhaeghe*, Jørgen Meisfjord*,
Muhammad Islam*, Sheikh Mohammed Shariful Islam*, Christa Meisinger*, Ana Maria B Menezes*, Geetha R Menon*,
Masanori Iwasaki*, Rod T Jackson*, Jeremy M Jacobs*, Gert BM Mensink*, Maria Teresa Menzano*, Alibek Mereke*,
Hashem Y Jaddou*, Tazeen Jafar*, Kenneth James*, Kazi M Jamil*, Indrapal I Meshram*, Andres Metspalu*, Jie Mi*, Kim F Michaelsen*,
Konrad Jamrozik*, Imre Janszky*, Edward Janus*, Juel Jarani*, Nathalie Michels*, Kairit Mikkel*, Karolina Milkowska*, Jody C Miller*,
Marjo-Riitta Jarvelin*, Grazyna Jasienska*, Ana Jelakovic*, Cláudia S Minderico*, GK Mini*, Juan Francisco Miquel*,
Bojan Jelakovic*, Garry Jennings*, Anjani Kumar Jha*, J Jaime Miranda*, Mohammad Reza Mirjalili*, Daphne Mirkopoulou*,
Chao Qiang Jiang*, Ramon O Jimenez*, Karl-Heinz Jöckel*, Erkin Mirrakhimov*, Marjeta Mišigoj-Durakovic*, Antonio Mistretta*,
Michel Joffres*, Mattias Johansson*, Jari J Jokelainen*, Jost B Jonas*, Veronica Mocanu*, Pietro A Modesti*, Sahar Saeedi Moghaddam*,
Torben Jørgensen*, Pradeep Joshi*, Farahnaz Joukar*, Dragana P Jovic*, Bahram Mohajer*, Mostafa K Mohamed*, Shukri F Mohamed*,
Jacek J Jóźwiak*, Anne Juolevi*, Gregor Jurak*, Iulia Jurca Simina*, Kazem Mohammad*, Zahra Mohammadi*, Noushin Mohammadifard*,
Vesna Juresa*, Rudolf Kaaks*, Felix O Kaducu*, Anthony Kafatos*, Reza Mohammadpourhodki*, Viswanathan Mohan*, Salim Mohanna*,
Eero O Kajantie*, Zhanna Kalmatayeva*, Ofra Kalter-Leibovici*, Muhammad Fadhli Mohd Yusoff*, Iraj Mohebbi*, Farnam Mohebi*,
Yves Kameli*, Kodanda R Kanala*, Srinivasan Kannan*, Marie Moitry*, Drude Molbo*, Line T Møllehave*, Niels C Møller*,
Efthymios Kapantais*, Khem B Karki*, Marzieh Katibeh*, Joanne Katz*, Dénes Molnár*, Amirabbas Momenan*, Charles K Mondo*,
Peter T Katzmarzyk*, Jussi Kauhanen*, Prabhdeep Kaur*, Michele Monroy-Valle*, Eric Monterrubio-Flores*,
Maryam Kavousi*, Gyulli M Kazakbaeva*, Ulrich Keil*, Kotsedi Daniel K Monyeki*, Jin Soo Moon*, Mahmood Moosazadeh*,
Lital Keinan Boker*, Sirkka Keinänen-Kiukaanniemi*, Roya Kelishadi*, Leila B Moreira*, Alain Morejon*, Luis A Moreno*, Karen Morgan*,
Cecily Kelleher*, Han CG Kemper*, Andre P Kengne*, Suzanne N Morin*, Erik Lykke Mortensen*, George Moschonis*,
Maryam Keramati*, Alina Kerimkulova*, Mathilde Kersting*, Malgorzata Mossakowska*, Aya Mostafa*, Anabela Mota-Pinto*,
Timothy Key*, Yousef Saleh Khader*, Davood Khalili*, Jorge Mota*, Mohammad Esmaeel Motlagh*, Jorge Motta*,
Young-Ho Khang*, Kay-Tee Khaw*, Bahareh Kheiri*, Marcos André Moura-dos-Santos*, Malay K Mridha*,
Motahareh Kheradmand*, Alireza Khosravi*, Ilse MSL Khouw*, Kelias P Msyamboza*, Thet Thet Mu*, Magdalena Muc*,
Ursula Kiechl-Kohlendorfer*, Stefan Kiechl*, Japhet Killewo*, Boban Mugoša*, Maria L Muiesan*, Parvina Mukhtorova*,
Dong Wook Kim*, Hyeon Chang Kim*, Jeongseon Kim*, Martina Müller-Nurasyid*, Neil Murphy*, Jaakko Mursu*,
Jenny M Kindblom*, Heidi Klakk*, Magdalena Klimek*, Elaine M Murtagh*, Kamarul Imran Musa*, Sanja Music Milanovic*,
Jeannette Klimont*, Jurate Klumbiene*, Michael Knoflach*, Vera Musil*, Norlaila Mustafa*, Iraj Nabipour*,
Bhawesh Koirala*, Elin Kolle*, Patrick Kolsteren*, Jürgen König*, Shohreh Naderimagham*, Gabriele Nagel*, Balkish M Naidu*,
Raija Korpelainen*, Paul Korrovits*, Magdalena Korzycka*, Jelena Kos*, Farid Najafi*, Harunobu Nakamura*, Jana Námešná*, Ei Ei K Nang*,
Seppo Koskinen*, Katsuyasu Kouda*, Viktoria A Kovacs*, Vinay B Nangia*, Martin Nankap*, Sameer Narake*, Paola Nardone*,
Sudhir Kowlessur*, Slawomir Koziel*, Wolfgang Kratzer*, Matthias Nauck*, William A Neal*, Azim Nejatizadeh*, Keiu Nelis*,
Susi Kriemler*, Peter Lund Kristensen*, Steiner Krokstad*, Liis Nelis*, Ilona Nenko*, Martin Neovius*, Flavio Nervi*,
Daan Kromhout*, Branimir Krtalic*, Herculina S Kruger*, Chung T Nguyen*, Nguyen D Nguyen*, Quang Ngoc Nguyen*,
Ruzena Kubinova*, Renata Kuciene*, Urho M Kujala*, Ramfis E Nieto-Martínez*, Yury P Nikitin*, Guang Ning*,
Enisa Kujundzic*, Zbigniew Kulaga*, R Krishna Kumar*, Toshiharu Ninomiya*, Sania Nishtar*, Marianna Noale*,
Marie Kunešová*, Pawel Kurjata*, Yadlapalli S Kusuma*, Oscar A Noboa*, Helena Nogueira*, Teresa Norat*, Maria Nordendahl*,
Kari Kuulasmaa*, Catherine Kyobutungi*, Quang Ngoc La*, Børge G Nordestgaard*, Davide Noto*, Natalia Nowak-Szczepanska*,
Fatima Zahra Laamiri*, Tiina Laatikainen*, Carl Lachat*, Youcef Laid*, Mohannad Al Nsour*, Irfan Nuhoglu*, Eha Nurk*, Terence W O’Neill*,
Tai Hing Lam*, Christina-Paulina Lambrinou*, Edwige Landais*, Dermot O’Reilly*, Galina Obreja*, Caleb Ochimana*,
Vera Lanska*, Georg Lappas*, Bagher Larijani*, Tint Swe Latt*, Angélica M Ochoa-Avilés*, Eiji Oda*, Kyungwon Oh*, Kumiko Ohara*,
Laura Lauria*, Avula Laxmaiah*, Maria Lazo-Porras*, Claes Ohlsson*, Ryutaro Ohtsuka*, Örn Olafsson*,
Khanh Le Nguyen Bao*, Agnès Le Port*, Tuyen D Le*, Jeannette Lee*, Maria Teresa A Olinto*, Isabel O Oliveira*, Mohd Azahadi Omar*,
Jeonghee Lee*, Paul H Lee*, Nils Lehmann*, Terho Lehtimäki*, Altan Onat*, Sok King Ong*, Lariane M Ono*, Pedro Ordunez*,
Daniel Lemogoum*, Naomi S Levitt*, Yanping Li*, Merike Liivak*, Rui Ornelas*, Ana P Ortiz*, Pedro J Ortiz*, Merete Osler*,
Christa L Lilly*, Wei-Yen Lim*, M Fernanda Lima-Costa*, Clive Osmond*, Sergej M Ostojic*, Afshin Ostovar*, Johanna A Otero*,
Hsien-Ho Lin*, Xu Lin*, Yi-Ting Lin*, Lars Lind*, Allan Linneberg*, Kim Overvad*, Ellis Owusu-Dabo*, Fred Michel Paccaud*,
Lauren Lissner*, Mieczyslaw Litwin*, Jing Liu*, Lijuan Liu*, Cristina Padez*, Ioannis Pagkalos*, Elena Pahomova*,
Wei-Cheng Lo*, Helle-Mai Loit*, Khuong Quynh Long*, Luis Lopes*, Karina Mary de Paiva*, Andrzej Pajak*, Domenico Palli*,
Oscar Lopes*, Esther Lopez-Garcia*, Tania Lopez*, Paulo A Lotufo*, Alberto Palloni*, Luigi Palmieri*, Wen-Harn Pan*,
José Eugenio Lozano*, Janice L Lukrafka*, Dalia Luksiene*, Songhomitra Panda-Jonas*, Arvind Pandey*, Francesco Panza*,
Annamari Lundqvist*, Robert Lundqvist*, Nuno Lunet*, Dimitrios Papandreou*, Soon-Woo Park*, Suyeon Park*,
Charles Lunogelo*, Michala Lustigová*, Edyta Łuszczki*, Winsome R Parnell*, Mahboubeh Parsaeian*, Ionela M Pascanu*,
Guansheng Ma*, Jun Ma*, Xu Ma*, George LL Machado-Coelho*, Patrick Pasquet*, Nikhil D Patel*, Mangesh S Pednekar*,
Aristides M Machado-Rodrigues*, Suka Machi*, Luisa M Macieira*, Nasheeta Peer*, Sergio Viana Peixoto*, Markku Peltonen*,
Ahmed A Madar*, Stefania Maggi*, Dianna J Magliano*, Alexandre C Pereira*, Marco A Peres*, Napoleón Pérez-Farinós*,
Sara Magnacca*, Emmanuella Magriplis*, Gowri Mahasampath*, Cynthia M Pérez*, Valentina Peterkova*, Annette Peters*,

1522 www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020


Articles

Astrid Petersmann*, Janina Petkeviciene*, Ausra Petrauskiene*, George S Stergiou*, Jochanan Stessman*, Ranko Stevanovic*,
Emanuela Pettenuzzo*, Niloofar Peykari*, Son Thai Pham*, Jutta Stieber*, Doris Stöckl*, Tanja Stocks*, Jakub Stokwiszewski*,
Rafael N Pichardo*, Daniela Pierannunzio*, Iris Pigeot*, Ekaterina Stoyanova*, Gareth Stratton*, Karien Stronks*,
Hynek Pikhart*, Aida Pilav*, Lorenza Pilotto*, Francesco Pistelli*, Maria Wany Strufaldi*, Lela Sturua*, Ramón Suárez-Medina*,
Freda Pitakaka*, Aleksandra Piwonska*, Andreia N Pizarro*, Machi Suka*, Chien-An Sun*, Johan Sundström*, Yn-Tz Sung*,
Pedro Plans-Rubió*, Bee Koon Poh*, Hermann Pohlabeln*, Jordi Sunyer*, Paibul Suriyawongpaisal*, Boyd A Swinburn*,
Raluca M Pop*, Stevo R Popovic*, Miquel Porta*, Georg Posch*, Rody G Sy*, Holly E Syddall*, René Charles Sylva*, Moyses Szklo*,
Anil Poudyal*, Dimitrios Poulimeneas*, Hamed Pouraram*, Lucjan Szponar*, E Shyong Tai*, Mari-Liis Tammesoo*,
Farhad Pourfarzi*, Akram Pourshams*, Hossein Poustchi*, Abdonas Tamosiunas*, Eng Joo Tan*, Xun Tang*, Frank Tanser*,
Rajendra Pradeepa*, Alison J Price*, Jacqueline F Price*, Yong Tao*, Mohammed Rasoul Tarawneh*, Jakob Tarp*,
Rui Providencia*, Jardena J Puder*, Iveta Pudule*, Soile E Puhakka*, Carolina B Tarqui-Mamani*, Radka Taxová Braunerová*, Anne Taylor*,
Maria Puiu*, Margus Punab*, Radwan F Qasrawi*, Mostafa Qorbani*, Julie Taylor*, Félicité Tchibindat*, William R Tebar*, Grethe S Tell*,
Tran Quoc Bao*, Ivana Radic*, Ricardas Radisauskas*, Tania Tello*, KR Thankappan*, Holger Theobald*,
Salar Rahimikazerooni*, Mahfuzar Rahman*, Mahmudur Rahman*, Xenophon Theodoridis*, Lutgarde Thijs*, Nihal Thomas*,
Olli Raitakari*, Manu Raj*, Ellina Rakhimova*, Sherali Rakhmatulloev*, Betina H Thuesen*, Lubica Tichá*, Erik J Timmermans*,
Ivo Rakovac*, Sudha Ramachandra Rao*, Ambady Ramachandran*, Anne Tjonneland*, Hanna K Tolonen*, Janne S Tolstrup*,
Jacqueline Ramke*, Elisabete Ramos*, Rafel Ramos*, Lekhraj Rampal*, Murat Topbas*, Roman Topór-Madry*, Liv Elin Torheim*,
Sanjay Rampal*, Vayia Rarra*, Ramon A Rascon-Pacheco*, María José Tormo*, Michael J Tornaritis*, Maties Torrent*,
Mette Rasmussen*, Cassiano Ricardo Rech*, Josep Redon*, Laura Torres-Collado*, Stefania Toselli*, Pierre Traissac*,
Paul Ferdinand M Reganit*, Valéria Regecová*, Luis Revilla*, Thi Tuyet-Hanh Tran*, Dimitrios Trichopoulos*, Antonia Trichopoulou*,
Abbas Rezaianzadeh*, Lourdes Ribas-Barba*, Robespierre Ribeiro*, Oanh TH Trinh*, Atul Trivedi*, Lechaba Tshepo*, Maria Tsigga*,
Elio Riboli*, Adrian Richter*, Fernando Rigo*, Natascia Rinaldo*, Shoichiro Tsugane*, Azaliia M Tuliakova*, Marshall K Tulloch-Reid*,
Tobias F Rinke de Wit*, Ana Rito*, Raphael M Ritti-Dias*, Fikru Tullu*, Tomi-Pekka Tuomainen*, Jaakko Tuomilehto*,
Juan A Rivera*, Cynthia Robitaille*, Romana Roccaldo*, Maria L Turley*, Per Tynelius*, Themistoklis Tzotzas*,
Daniela Rodrigues*, Fernando Rodríguez-Artalejo*, Christophe Tzourio*, Peter Ueda*, Eunice Ugel*, Flora AM Ukoli*,
María del Cristo Rodriguez-Perez*, Laura A Rodríguez-Villamizar*, Hanno Ulmer*, Belgin Unal*, Zhamyila Usupova*,
Ulla Roggenbuck*, Rosalba Rojas-Martinez*, Nipa Rojroongwasinkul*, Hannu MT Uusitalo*, Nalan Uysal*, Justina Vaitkeviciute*,
Dora Romaguera*, Elisabetta L Romeo*, Rafaela V Rosario*, Gonzalo Valdivia*, Susana Vale*, Damaskini Valvi*, Rob M van Dam*,
Annika Rosengren*, Ian Rouse*, Joel GR Roy*, Adolfo Rubinstein*, Johan Van der Heyden*, Yvonne T van der Schouw*, Koen Van Herck*,
Frank J Rühli*, Jean-Bernard Ruidavets*, Hoang Van Minh*, Irene GM van Valkengoed*, Dirk Vanderschueren*,
Blanca Sandra Ruiz-Betancourt*, Emma Ruiz Moreno*, Diego Vanuzzo*, Anette Varbo*, Gregorio Varela-Moreiras*,
Iuliia A Rusakova*, Kenisha Russell Jonsson*, Paola Russo*, Patricia Varona-Pérez*, Senthil K Vasan*, Tomas Vega*,
Petra Rust*, Marcin Rutkowski*, Charumathi Sabanayagam*, Toomas Veidebaum*, Gustavo Velasquez-Melendez*, Biruta Velika*,
Elena Sacchini*, Harshpal S Sachdev*, Alireza Sadjadi*, Giovanni Veronesi*, WM Monique Verschuren*, Cesar G Victora*,
Ali Reza Safarpour*, Sare Safi*, Saeid Safiri*, Olfa Saidi*, Nader Saki*, Giovanni Viegi*, Lucie Viet*, Salvador Villalpando*, Paolo Vineis*,
Benoit Salanave*, Eduardo Salazar Martinez*, Diego Salmerón*, Jesus Vioque*, Jyrki K Virtanen*, Marjolein Visser*,
Veikko Salomaa*, Jukka T Salonen*, Massimo Salvetti*, Sophie Visvikis-Siest*, Bharathi Viswanathan*, Mihaela Vladulescu*,
Margarita Samoutian*, Jose Sánchez-Abanto*, Sandjaja*, Susana Sans*, Tiina Vlasoff*, Dorja Vocanec*, Henry Völzke*, Ari Voutilainen*,
Loreto Santa Marina*, Diana A Santos*, Ina S Santos*, Lèlita C Santos*, Sari Voutilainen*, Martine Vrijheid*, Tanja GM Vrijkotte*,
Maria Paula Santos*, Osvaldo Santos*, Rute Santos*, Sara Santos Sanz*, Alisha N Wade*, Aline Wagner*, Thomas Waldhör*, Janette Walton*,
Jouko L Saramies*, Luis B Sardinha*, Nizal Sarrafzadegan*, Elvis OA Wambiya*, Wan Mohamad Wan Bebakar*,
Thirunavukkarasu Sathish*, Kai-Uwe Saum*, Savvas Savva*, Wan Nazaimoon Wan Mohamud*, Rildo de Souza Wanderley Júnior*,
Mathilde Savy*, Norie Sawada*, Mariana Sbaraini*, Marcia Scazufca*, Ming-Dong Wang*, Ningli Wang*, Qian Wang*, Xiangjun Wang*,
Beatriz D Schaan*, Angelika Schaffrath Rosario*, Ya Xing Wang*, Ying-Wei Wang*, S Goya Wannamethee*,
Herman Schargrodsky*, Anja Schienkiewitz*, Karin Schindler*, Nicholas Wareham*, Adelheid Weber*, Niels Wedderkopp*,
Sabine Schipf*, Carsten O Schmidt*, Ida Maria Schmidt*, Deepa Weerasekera*, Daniel Weghuber*, Wenbin Wei*, Aneta Weres*,
Peter Schnohr*, Ben Schöttker*, Sara Schramm*, Stine Schramm*, Bo Werner*, Peter H Whincup*, Kurt Widhalm*,
Helmut Schröder*, Constance Schultsz*, Aletta E Schutte*, Indah S Widyahening*, Andrzej Wiecek*, Rainford J Wilks*,
Sylvain Sebert*, Aye Aye Sein*, Rusidah Selamat*, Vedrana Sember*, Johann Willeit*, Peter Willeit*, Julianne Williams*, Tom Wilsgaard*,
Abhijit Sen*, Idowu O Senbanjo*, Sadaf G Sepanlou*, Victor Sequera*, Bogdan Wojtyniak*, Roy A Wong-McClure*, Andrew Wong*,
Luis Serra-Majem*, Jennifer Servais*, Ludmila Ševcíková*, Jyh Eiin Wong*, Tien Yin Wong*, Jean Woo*, Mark Woodward*,
Svetlana A Shalnova*, Teresa Shamah-Levy*, Morteza Shamshirgaran*, Frederick C Wu*, Jianfeng Wu*, Li Juan Wu*, Shouling Wu*,
Coimbatore Subramaniam Shanthirani*, Maryam Sharafkhah*, Haiquan Xu*, Liang Xu*, Nor Azwany Yaacob*, Uruwan Yamborisut*,
Sanjib K Sharma*, Jonathan E Shaw*, Amaneh Shayanrad*, Weili Yan*, Ling Yang*, Xiaoguang Yang*, Yang Yang*, Nazan Yardim*,
Ali Akbar Shayesteh*, Lela Shengelia*, Zumin Shi*, Kenji Shibuya*, Mehdi Yaseri*, Tabara Yasuharu*, Xingwang Ye*,
Hana Shimizu-Furusawa*, Dong Wook Shin*, Youchan Shin*, Panayiotis K Yiallouros*, Moein Yoosefi*, Akihiro Yoshihara*,
Majid Shirani*, Rahman Shiri*, Namuna Shrestha*, Khairil Si-Ramlee*, Qi Sheng You*, San-Lin You*, Novie O Younger-Coleman*,
Alfonso Siani*, Rosalynn Siantar*, Abla M Sibai*, Antonio M Silva*, Safiah Md Yusof*, Ahmad Faudzi Yusoff*, Luciana Zaccagni*,
Diego Augusto Santos Silva*, Mary Simon*, Judith Simons*, Vassilis Zafiropulos*, Ahmad A Zainuddin*, Seyed Rasoul Zakavi*,
Leon A Simons*, Agneta Sjöberg*, Michael Sjöström*, Gry Skodje*, Farhad Zamani*, Sabina Zambon*, Antonis Zampelas*,
Jolanta Slowikowska-Hilczer*, Przemyslaw Slusarczyk*, Liam Smeeth*, Hana Zamrazilová*, Maria Elisa Zapata*, Abdul Hamid Zargar*,
Hung-Kwan So*, Fernanda Cunha Soares*, Grzegorz Sobek*, Ko Ko Zaw*, Tomasz Zdrojewski*, Tajana Zeljkovic Vrkic*, Yi Zeng*,
Eugène Sobngwi*, Morten Sodemann*, Stefan Söderberg*, Luxia Zhang*, Zhen-Yu Zhang*, Dong Zhao*, Ming-Hui Zhao*,
Moesijanti YE Soekatri*, Agustinus Soemantri*, Reecha Sofat*, Wenhua Zhao*, Shiqi Zhen*, Wei Zheng*, Yingfeng Zheng*,
Vincenzo Solfrizzi*, Mohammad Hossein Somi*, Emily Sonestedt*, Bekbolat Zholdin*, Maigeng Zhou*, Dan Zhu*, Yanina Zocalo*,
Yi Song*, Thorkild IA Sørensen*, Elin P Sørgjerd*, Maroje Sorić*, Julio Zuñiga Cisneros*, Monika Zuziak*.
Charles Sossa Jérome*, Victoria E Soto-Rojas*, Aïcha Soumaré*, *Contributed equally.
Slavica Sovic*, Bente Sparboe-Nilsen*, Karen Sparrenberger*,
Declaration of interests
Angela Spinelli*, Igor Spiroski*, Jan A Staessen*, Hanspeter Stamm*,
ME reports a charitable grant from the AstraZeneca Young Health
Gregor Starc*, Maria G Stathopoulou*, Kaspar Staub*, Bill Stavreski*,
Programme, and personal fees from Prudential and Scor, outside the
Jostein Steene-Johannessen*, Peter Stehle*, Aryeh D Stein*,

www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020 1523


Articles

submitted work. MS reports grants from the EU Horizon 2020 research 18 Butte NF, Garza C, de Onis M. Evaluation of the feasibility of
and innovation programme under Grant Agreement number 774548, international growth standards for school-aged children and
during the conduct of the study. All other authors declare no competing adolescents. J Nutr 2007; 137: 153–57.
interests. 19 NCD Risk Factor Collaboration (NCD-RisC). Rising rural body-mass
index is the main driver of the global obesity epidemic in adults.
Acknowledgments Nature 2019; 569: 260–64.
The NCD-RisC database was supported by a Biomedical Resource and 20 Paciorek CJ, Stevens GA, Finucane MM, Ezzati M. Children’s
Multi-user Equipment Grant from the Wellcome Trust (101506/Z/13/Z) and height and weight in rural and urban populations in low-income
was expanded to include children and adolescents with partial support by a and middle-income countries: a systematic analysis of population-
charitable grant from AstraZeneca Young Health Programme. The analysis representative data. Lancet Glob Health 2013; 1: e300–09.
in this paper was partly supported by the STOP project which received 21 Wells JC, Sawaya AL, Wibaek R, et al. The double burden of
funding from EU Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme malnutrition: aetiological pathways and consequences for health.
under Grant Agreement 774548. The content of this publication reflects Lancet 2020; 395: 75–88.
only the views of the authors, and the European Commission is not liable 22 Dubois L, Ohm Kyvik K, Girard M, et al. Genetic and environmental
for any use that may be made of the information it contains. contributions to weight, height, and BMI from birth to 19 years of
age: an international study of over 12,000 twin pairs. PLoS One
Editorial note: the Lancet Group takes a neutral position with respect to 2012; 7: e30153.
territorial claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. 23 Jelenkovic A, Sund R, Hur YM, et al. Genetic and environmental
References influences on height from infancy to early adulthood: an individual-
1 Prentice AM, Ward KA, Goldberg GR, et al. Critical windows for based pooled analysis of 45 twin cohorts. Sci Rep 2016; 6: 28496.
nutritional interventions against stunting. Am J Clin Nutr 2013; 24 Silventoinen K, Jelenkovic A, Sund R, et al. Genetic and
97: 911–18. environmental effects on body mass index from infancy to the onset
2 Georgiadis A, Penny ME. Child undernutrition: opportunities of adulthood: an individual-based pooled analysis of 45 twin cohorts
beyond the first 1000 days. Lancet Public Health 2017; 2: e399. participating in the COllaborative project of Development of
Anthropometrical measures in Twins (CODATwins) study.
3 Alderman H, Behrman JR, Glewwe P, Fernald L, Walker S.
Am J Clin Nutr 2016; 104: 371–79.
Evidence of impact of interventions on growth and development
during early and middle childhood. In: Bundy DAP, Silva N, 25 Brandkvist M, Bjørngaard JH, Ødegård RA, Åsvold BO, Sund ER,
Horton S, Jamison DT, Patton GC, eds. Child and adolescent health Vie GA. Quantifying the impact of genes on body mass index
and development. Washington (DC): The International Bank for during the obesity epidemic: longitudinal findings from the HUNT
Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank, 2017. Study. BMJ 2019; 366: l4067.
4 Tanner JM. Growth as a mirror of the condition of society: secular 26 Robinson MR, Hemani G, Medina-Gomez C, et al. Population
trends and class distinctions. Acta Paediatr Jpn 1987; 29: 96–103. genetic differentiation of height and body mass index across
Europe. Nat Genet 2015; 47: 1357–62.
5 Strauss J, Thomas D. Health, nutrition, and economic
development. J Econ Lit 1998; 36: 766–817. 27 Jelenkovic A, Hur YM, Sund R, et al. Genetic and environmental
influences on adult human height across birth cohorts from
6 Park MH, Falconer C, Viner RM, Kinra S. The impact of childhood 1886 to 1994. eLife 2016; 5: e20320.
obesity on morbidity and mortality in adulthood: a systematic
review. Obes Rev 2012; 13: 985–1000. 28 Grasgruber P, Sebera M, Hrazdíra E, Cacek J, Kalina T. Major
correlates of male height: a study of 105 countries. Econ Hum Biol
7 Paajanen TA, Oksala NKJ, Kuukasjärvi P, Karhunen PJ. 2016; 21: 172–95.
Short stature is associated with coronary heart disease: a systematic
review of the literature and a meta-analysis. Eur Heart J 2010; 29 Bogin B, Hermanussen M, Scheffler C. As tall as my peers—
31: 1802–09. similarity in body height between migrants and hosts.
Anthropol Anz 2018; 74: 365–76.
8 Caird J, Kavanagh J, O’Mara-Eves A, et al. Does being overweight
impede academic attainment? A systematic review. Health Educ J 30 Alacevich C, Tarozzi A. Child height and intergenerational
2014; 73: 497–521. transmission of health: evidence from ethnic Indians in England.
Econ Hum Biol 2017; 25: 65–84.
9 Black RE, Allen LH, Bhutta ZA, et al. Maternal and child
undernutrition: global and regional exposures and health 31 Bogin B, Smith P, Orden AB, Varela Silva MI, Loucky J.
consequences. Lancet 2008; 371: 243–60. Rapid change in height and body proportions of Maya American
children. Am J Hum Biol 2002; 14: 753–61.
10 Stevens GA, Finucane MM, Paciorek CJ, et al. Trends in mild,
moderate, and severe stunting and underweight, and progress 32 Frisch RE, Revelle R. Height and weight at menarche and a
towards MDG 1 in 141 developing countries: a systematic analysis of hypothesis of critical body weights and adolescent events. Science
population representative data. Lancet 2012; 380: 824–34. 1970; 169: 397–99.
11 NCD Risk Factor Collaboration (NCD-RisC). Worldwide trends in 33 Limony Y, Kozieł S, Friger M. Age of onset of a normally timed
body-mass index, underweight, overweight, and obesity from 1975 pubertal growth spurt affects the final height of children. Pediatr Res
to 2016: a pooled analysis of 2416 population-based measurement 2015; 78: 351–55.
studies in 128·9 million children, adolescents, and adults. Lancet 34 Vizmanos B, Martí-Henneberg C, Clivillé R, Moreno A,
2017; 390: 2627–42. Fernández-Ballart J. Age of pubertal onset affects the intensity and
12 de Onis M, Onyango AW, Borghi E, Siyam A, Nishida C, Siekmann J. duration of pubertal growth peak but not final height.
Development of a WHO growth reference for school-aged children Am J Hum Biol 2001; 13: 409–16.
and adolescents. Bull World Health Organ 2007; 85: 660–67. 35 Grasgruber P, Cacek J, Kalina T, Sebera M. The role of nutrition
13 Finucane MM, Paciorek CJ, Danaei G, Ezzati M. Bayesian and genetics as key determinants of the positive height trend.
estimation of population-level trends in measures of health status. Econ Hum Biol 2014; 15: 81–100.
Stat Sci 2014; 29: 18–25. 36 Das JK, Salam RA, Thornburg KL, et al. Nutrition in adolescents:
14 NCD Risk Factor Collaboration (NCD-RisC). A century of trends in physiology, metabolism, and nutritional needs. Ann N Y Acad Sci
adult human height. eLife 2016; 5: e13410. 2017; 1393: 21–33.
15 Haas JD, Campirano F. Interpopulation variation in height among 37 Floud R, Fogel RW, Harris B, Hong SC. The changing body:
children 7 to 18 years of age. Food Nutr Bull 2006; health, nutrition, and human development in the western world
27 (suppl growth standard): S212–23. since 1700. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011.
16 Martin-Calvo N, Moreno-Galarraga L, Martinez-Gonzalez MA. 38 Tumilowicz A, Beal T, Neufeld LM, Frongillo EA. Perspective:
Association between body mass index, waist-to-height ratio and challenges in use of adolescent anthropometry for understanding
adiposity in children: a systematic review and meta-analysis. the burden of malnutrition. Adv Nutr 2019; 10: 563–75.
Nutrients 2016; 8: 512. 39 Hawkes C, Ruel MT, Salm L, Sinclair B, Branca F. Double-duty
17 de Onis M, Habicht JP. Anthropometric reference data for actions: seizing programme and policy opportunities to address
international use: recommendations from a World Health malnutrition in all its forms. Lancet 2020; 395: 142–55.
Organization Expert Committee. Am J Clin Nutr 1996; 64: 650–58.

1524 www.thelancet.com Vol 396 November 7, 2020

You might also like