You are on page 1of 9

Instructions

Rubric  

Scoring
Vilas  Playroom  Assessment  Rubric  (VIPAR)  ©  

Instructions  

There  is  a  dream  playroom  in  all  of  our  imaginations.  Time,  
space,  budget  constraints  and  infection  control  guidelines  aside,  
we  all  know  what  we  would  provide  children  and  families  if  we  
were  able  to  do  so.  The  VIPAR©  is  intended  to  present  the  best  
possible  scenario,  and  to  measure  how  your  playroom  is  meeting  
the  needs  of  all  pediatric  patients  and  families  at  your  hospital.  
Use  this  rubric  as  a  quality  checklist  to  assess  playroom  design  
and  operation.  Score  each  category  based  upon  observation  and  
investigation.  Add  together  the  18  category  scores  to  reach  a  
total.  Use  key  at  bottom  of  rubric  to  interpret  total  score.  It  can  
be  helpful  to  underline  or  highlight  specific  items  to  be  improved  
within  each  category.  

Once  a  score  is  obtained,  determine  which  improvements  


are  within  the  department’s  control  to  improve.  Set  goals  and  
deadlines  for  improvement.  This  rubric  is  not  intended  to  make  
you  feel  that  your  playroom  is  substandard  in  any  way.  The  
hope  is  that  it  will  guide  you  towards  making  some  small  or  
significant  changes  that  will  improve  the  quality  of  play  
available  in  your  hospital.  

Deborah  B.  Vilas,  MS,  CCLS,  LMSW  ©2015   2  


Return  to  title  page  
Vilas  Playroom  Assessment  Rubric  (VIPAR)  ©  
Rubric  
Category   3  =  Meets  Optimum  Patient   2  =  Meets  Many  Patient   1  =  Meets  Some  Patient   Score  
Needs   Needs   Needs  
1. Room  Size o The  playroom  size  is  large o The  playroom  size o The  room  allows  for  no
enough  for  many  children somewhat  limits  the more  than  several  adults
and  family  members  to number  of  children  and &  children  to  be  there  at
play  comfortably adults  who  can  be  there  at the  same  time
o There  is  generous  space the  same  time o There  is  no  space  for  gross
for  gross  motor  activity o There  is  some  space  for motor  activity
o Storage  space  is  plentiful gross  motor  activity o Storage  is  inadequate
inside  and  outside  the o Adequate  storage  space  is and/or  far  away  from  the
playroom available  inside  or  outside playroom
the  playroom
2. Nature o The  playroom  has  many o There  are  windows  and o There  are  no  windows,  no
large  windows  and  natural natural  light natural  light,  no  live
light o Some  cabinets,  shelves  or plants,  and  no  materials
o Cabinets,  shelves  and furniture  are  made  with from  the  child’s  natural
furniture  are  made  with natural  materials,  such  as environment
natural  materials,  such  as wood o There  is  no  pet  therapy
wood o Sometimes  programming program  or  activities  that
o There  is  a  horticulture allows  for  activities connect  children  to  nature
program connecting  children  to
o Found  objects  in  nature their  natural  environment
are  incorporated  into (bringing  in  snow  for  play)
materials  and  activities,
representing  the  child’s
natural  environment
o Pet  therapy  programming
is  available
o There  is  a  fish  tank  in  the
room
3. Universal o The  room  and  all  activities o The  room  and  most o The  child  cannot  access
Design   and  toys  are  accessible  to activities  and  toys  are room  without  adult  help
Accessibility   children  who  are  either accessible  to  children  who o Most  activities  and  toys
ambulatory  or  in are  either  ambulatory  or are  inaccessible  to
wheelchairs in  wheelchairs children
o There  is  room  for  IV  poles o There  is  room  for  IV  poles, o There  is  little  or  no  room
and  personal  items,  plenty personal  items,  some for  IV  poles,  personal
of  outlets  to  plug  IVs  into, outlets  to  plug  IVs  into, items,  few  outlets  to  plug
and  seating  for  all  children and  seating  for  most IVs  into,  and  seating  for
and  caregivers children  and  caregivers few  children  and
o There  are o There  are  some caregivers
accommodations  to  take accommodations  to  take o There  are  no
into  consideration  children into  consideration accommodations  taking
with  special  needs,  such  as children  with  special into  consideration
sensory  issues,  immobility needs,  such  as  sensory children  with  special
or  developmental  delays issues,  immobility  or needs,  such  s  as  sensory
o Activities  and  toys  are developmental  delays issues,  immobility,  or
adaptable  to  meet  the o Activities  and  toys  are developmental  delays
needs  of  all  children adaptable  to  meet  the o Activities  and  toys  are  not
Deborah  B.  Vilas,  MS,  CCLS,  LMSW  ©2015   3  
Return  to  title  page  
Vilas  Playroom  Assessment  Rubric  (VIPAR)  ©  
 
Category   3  =  Meets  Optimum  Patient   2  =  Meets  Many  Patient   1  =  Meets  Some  Patient   Score  
Needs   Needs   Needs  
o Many  sinks,  chairs,  tables   needs  of  most  children   adaptable  to  meet  the  
and  work  surfaces  are   o Some  sinks,  chairs,  tables,   needs  of  most  children  
child-­‐sized  and  conducive   and  work  surfaces  are   o Sinks,  chairs,  tables  and  
to  small  group  interaction   child-­‐sized  and  conducive   work  surfaces  are  not  
to  small  group  interaction   child-­‐sized  or  conducive  to  
small  group  interaction  
4.  Room  Set  Up:   o There  are  distinct  areas  (or   o The  organization  of  the   o The  organization  of  the    
Developmental   playrooms)  that  address   room  shows  some  insight   room  shows  little  or  no  
Appropriateness   various  developmental   into  developmental  needs   insight  into  developmental  
stages  (infant,  toddler,   for  gross  or  fine  motor   needs  for  gross  or  fine  
preschooler,  school-­‐age,   activity   motor  activity  
adolescent)   o There  are  distinct  areas   o There  are  no  distinct  areas  
o Infant  area/room  has  mat   that  address  some  of  the   that  address  some  of  the  
for  tummy  time  play,   various  developmental   various  developmental  
mirrors  at  ground  level,   stages  (infant,  toddler,   stages  (infant,  toddler,  
and  accessible  toys  on  low   preschooler,  school-­‐age,   preschooler,  school-­‐age,  
shelves   adolescent)   adolescent)  
o The  organization  of  the   o Many  toys  &  activities  are   o Most  toys  are  inaccessible  
room  shows  widespread   accessible  without  adult   without  adult  assistance  
insight  into  developmental   assistance  
needs  for  gross  and  fine    
motor  activity  
o Toys  and  activities  are  
accessible  without  adult  
assistance  
5.  Hours  &   o The  playroom  is  open  and   o The  playroom  is  open  and   o The  playroom  is  not  open    
Staffing   staffed  daily  for  a   staffed  daily  for  a  portion   daily  
significant  portion  of  the   of  the  day   o It  is  not  staffed  often  
day  and  evening   o Children  are  welcome  with   when  it  is  open  
o Children  are  able  to  access   and  without  caregivers   o Children  are  not  welcome  
playroom  easily  and  all  are   o There  is  either  inpatient  or   without  caregivers  
welcome  with  and  without   outpatient  access  
caregivers    
o There  are  playrooms  or  
times  for  both  inpatient  
and  outpatient  access  
6.  Staff  Training   o Playroom  staff  and   o Playroom  staff  has   o Playroom  staff  has    
volunteers  have  had  skills-­‐   received  theoretical   received  no  formal  
based  and  theoretical   training  in  the  value  of   training  in  the  value  of  
training  in  the  value  of   play  and  at  least  one  play   play,  play  theory,  or  play  
play  and  a  variety  of  play   technique   techniques  
techniques   o These  include  but  are  not  
o These  include  but  are  not   limited  to  child-­‐centered  
limited  to  child-­‐centered   play,  the  Greenspan  
play,  the  Greenspan   Floortime©  approach,  
Floortime©  approach,   loose  parts,  and  filial  play  
loose  parts,  and  filial  play.  
7.  Family   o All  family  members  are   o Family  members  are   o Siblings  are  not  permitted    
Centered  Care   welcome  at  all  times   welcome   playroom  access  due  to  
Deborah  B.  Vilas,  MS,  CCLS,  LMSW  ©2015       4  
Return  to  title  page  
Vilas  Playroom  Assessment  Rubric  (VIPAR)  ©  
 
Category   3  =  Meets  Optimum  Patient   2  =  Meets  Many  Patient   1  =  Meets  Some  Patient   Score  
Needs   Needs   Needs  
o There  is  programming  for   o There  are  certain  times  or   infection  control  
siblings   spaces  for  siblings  to  play  
o Siblings  are  welcome  with   o Siblings  need  to  be  
or  without  caregivers   accompanied  by  a  
caregiver  
8.  Cultural   o When  a  child  walks  in,   o There  are  several  signs  of   o There  are  few  or  no  signs    
Competency   s/he  sees  him/herself  and   multiculturalism   of  diversity  in  the  décor  
culture  represented  in   represented  in  décor,   o Diverse  toys,  art  materials  
o Language   books  or  toys   or  books  are  not  available  
o Décor  
o Toys  
o Found  objects  in  
nature  
o Books  
o Art  materials  
o There  are  familiar  items  
representing  the  child  and  
his/her  community  
9.  Gender   o The  room  offers  décor  and   o There  are  some  gender-­‐ o The  toys  and  décor  are    
Sensitivity   toys  that  are  gender-­‐ neutral  toys  available   gender  specific  and  
neutral     promote  gender  
o Children  are  encouraged   stereotypical  play  
to  play  with  all  toys  and   o Toys  are  categorized  or  
not  deterred  from  crossing   labelled  by  gender  
gender  boundaries  (eg:  
Girls  can  play  with  trucks,  
boys  can  play  with  dolls)  
o Toys  and  materials  are  not  
categorized  or  labeled  by  
gender  
10.  Non-­‐Medical   o There  is  a  policy  stating   o There  is  a  policy  stating   o There  is  no  policy  stating    
Zone  Policy   that  invasive  medical  care   that  invasive  medical  care   that  invasive  medical  care  
and  assessment  are  not   and  assessment  are  not   and  assessment  are  not  
permitted  in  the  room   permitted  in  the  room   permitted  in  the  room  
o The  policy  is  consistently   o It  is  not  always  enforced    
enforced  and  respected   or  respected  
11.  Technology   o Up-­‐to-­‐date  technology   o  Some  technology  is   o There  is  no  technology    
Access  &  Policy   (video  games,  internet   available   available  or  there  are  no  
access)  is  available  to   o There  are  informal  policies   policies  governing  its  use  
appropriate  age  set   governing  its  use   o Room  is  not  a  TV  free  zone  
o There  are  policies   o The  policy  is  not  always  
governing  the   enforced  or  respected  
developmentally  
appropriate  use  of  
technology,  including  
following  AAP  guidelines  
for  screen  time  limits  
o Playroom  is  a  TV  free  zone  
except  for  video  game  
Deborah  B.  Vilas,  MS,  CCLS,  LMSW  ©2015       5  
Return  to  title  page  
Vilas  Playroom  Assessment  Rubric  (VIPAR)  ©  
 
Category   3  =  Meets  Optimum  Patient   2  =  Meets  Many  Patient   1  =  Meets  Some  Patient   Score  
Needs   Needs   Needs  
playing  and  movie  events.  
The  policy  is  consistently  
enforced  and  respected  
12.  Toy  Cleaning   o There  is  a  written  policy   o There  is  an  informal  policy   o Toy  cleaning  is  haphazard    
Policy   regarding  toy  cleaning  that   regarding  toy  cleaning  
is  adhered  to   that  is  adhered  to  
o There  are  clearly  marked  
bins  for  dirty  toys  in  a  safe  
place  
13.  Theft   o There  is  a  written  policy   o There  is  a  written  policy   o There  is  no  theft    
Deterrence   regarding  how  to  deter   regarding  how  to  deter   deterrence  policy  
Policy   theft  and  loss  of  toys,   theft  and  loss  of  toys,    
including:   including  some  of  these  
o A  lending  policy   components:  
o Toys  being  clearly   o A  lending  policy  
marked  a  property  of   o Toys  being  clearly  
the  playroom   marked  a  property  of  
o Appropriate  signage   the  playroom  
o Locked  storage  space   o Appropriate  signage  
o Toys  being  routinely   o Locked  storage  space  
picked  up  and  returned   o Or  toys  being  routinely  
to  playroom  by  staff  or   picked  up  and  returned  
volunteers   to  playroom  by  staff  or  
volunteers  
14.  Types  of   o There  is  an  abundance  of   o There  are  some  open-­‐ o There  are  hardly  any    
Toys   open-­‐ended,   ended,  developmentally   open-­‐ended,  
developmentally   appropriate  toys  that   developmentally  
appropriate  toys  that   encourage  symbolic  and   appropriate  toys  that  
encourage  symbolic  and   expressive  play:   encourage  symbolic  and  
expressive  play:   o Loose  parts  and   expressive  play:  
o Loose  parts  and   sensory  play  (blocks,   o Loose  parts  and  
sensory  play  (blocks,   water  and  sand  tables)   sensory  play  (blocks,  
water  and  sand  tables,   o Infant  &  toddler  toys   water  and  sand  tables,  
dolls,  playhouse   (noisemakers,  nesting   dolls,  play-­‐house  
materials,  miniatures,   blocks,  large  pop-­‐ materials,  miniatures,  
animals,  dress  up   beads,  cause  &  effect   animals,  dress  up  
materials,  rescue  toys,   toys)   materials,  rescue  toys,  
art  materials)   o Preschool  toys  (dolls,   art  materials)  
o Infant  &  toddler  toys   playhouse  materials,   o Infant  &  toddler  toys  
(noisemakers,  nesting   miniatures,  animals,   (noisemakers,  nesting  
blocks,  large  pop-­‐ dress  up  materials,   blocks,  large  pop-­‐
beads,  cause  &  effect   rescue  toys,  art   beads,  cause  &  effect  
toys)   materials)   toys)  
o School-­‐aged  toys  (table   o School-­‐aged  toys  (table   o School-­‐aged  toys  (table  
games,  puzzles  and   games,  puzzles  and   games,  puzzles  and  
open-­‐  ended  art   open-­‐  ended  art   open-­‐  ended  art  
materials  &  crafts   materials  &  crafts)   materials  &  crafts  
o Adolescent  activities   o Adolescent  activities   o Adolescent  activities  
(pool  table,  ping  pong   (pool  table,  ping  pong   (pool  table,  ping  pong  
Deborah  B.  Vilas,  MS,  CCLS,  LMSW  ©2015       6  
Return  to  title  page  
Vilas  Playroom  Assessment  Rubric  (VIPAR)  ©  
 
Category   3  =  Meets  Optimum  Patient   2  =  Meets  Many  Patient   1  =  Meets  Some  Patient   Score  
Needs   Needs   Needs  
table,  air  hockey)   table,  air  hockey)   table,  air  hockey)  
o Gross  motor  toys  and  
vehicles  for  climbing,  
rolling,  pedaling  and  
rocking  
15.  Condition  of   o  All  toys  have  all  of  their   o  Many  toys  have  all  of   o Many  toys  have  missing    
Toys   components   their  components   components  
o Clear  labeling,  signage  and   o Clear  labeling,  signage  and   o Signage  and  infection  
policies  for  infection   policies  for  infection   control  policies  are  
control  make  clean  toys   control  make  clean  toys   missing  or  are  not  clear  to  
accessible  for  playroom   accessible  for  playroom   staff,  volunteers  or  family  
and  in  room  use   and  in  room  use  in  most   members  
o Staff,  volunteers  and   instances  
family  members  can  easily   o Staff,  volunteers  and  
follow  the  policies   family  members  can  
follow  the  policies  
16.  Activities   o There  are  daily  scheduled,   o There  are  weekly   o There  are  no  scheduled,    
staff  led  therapeutic   scheduled,  staff  led   staff  led  activities  
activities.  These  include   activities.  These  include   o If  such  activities  occur,  
directive  and  non-­‐directive   directive  and  non-­‐ they  are  rarely  therapeutic  
medical  play  activities   directive  medical  play   and  tend  to  be  close-­‐
such  as:   activities  such  as:   ended  
o hospital  bingo   o hospital  bingo   o There  is  no  organization  to  
o volcanoes   o volcanoes   promote  attendance  
o open  medical  play   o open  medical  play   o There  is  rarely  enough  
o directive  medical  play   o directive  medical  play   staffing  or  resources  for  
o medical  art   o medical  art   bedside  play  activities  for  
o Children  may  participate   o Organization  is  informal   children  who  cannot  leave  
or  not  as  they  please   and  may  or  may  not  be   their  rooms  
o There  is  organized  and   advertised  
proactive  advertisement   o There  is  often  enough  
(overhead   staffing  and  resources  for  
announcements,   bedside  play  activities  for  
schedules,  flyers  and  one-­‐   children  who  cannot  leave  
one  invitations)  to   their  rooms  
encourage  participation  
o There  is  always  enough  
staffing  and  resources  for  
bedside  play  activities  for  
children  who  cannot  leave  
their  rooms  
17.  Medical  Play   o There  is  a  well-­‐stocked   o There  are  some  medical   o There  are  no  medical  play    
medical  play  area  in  the   play  materials  accessible   toys  visible  or  accessible  
room.  Items  include:   to  all  children    
o Doll  bed    
o Dolls  representing  
various  skin  colors  
o Real  and  play  medical  
equipment  
Deborah  B.  Vilas,  MS,  CCLS,  LMSW  ©2015       7  
Return  to  title  page  
Vilas  Playroom  Assessment  Rubric  (VIPAR)  ©  
 
Category   3  =  Meets  Optimum  Patient   2  =  Meets  Many  Patient   1  =  Meets  Some  Patient   Score  
Needs   Needs   Needs  
o Pencils  
o Paper  
o Play  phone  
o Toy  microscope  
o Bandaids©  
o Tape  
o Gauze  
o Syringes  (safely  
deactivated)  
o Tubing  
o Alcohol  preps  
o X-­‐ray  
o IV  pole  
18.  Books  &   o Literacy  is  present  through   o Some  signs  of  literacy  are   o There  are  few  if  any  books    
Literacy   signage  and  labeling  of   present  through  labeling   available  
toys  and  materials  in  the   or  artwork   o Artwork,  toys  and  areas  
children’s  native  language   o There  is  some  accessible   are  not  labeled  
o There  is  a  developmental   reading  material  across  
range  of  accessible   the  developmental  range  
reading  material,  including   o The  books  represent  some  
therapeutic  books  that   range  of  cultural  diversity  
address  hospitalization,  
self-­‐  esteem  and  body  
issues  
o The  books  represent  a  
wide  range  of  cultural  
diversity  
Page  3     0  
Page  4     0  
Page  5     0  
Page  6     0  
Page  7     0  
Page  8     0  
TOTAL      
0
 
 

   

Deborah  B.  Vilas,  MS,  CCLS,  LMSW  ©2015       8  


Return  to  title  page  
Vilas  Playroom  Assessment  Rubric  (VIPAR)  ©  
 
Scoring  
Meets  Optimum  Patient  Needs:     45-­‐54  
Meets  Many  Patient  Needs:     36-­‐44  
Meets  Some  Patient  Needs:     28-­‐35  
Needs  Significant  Improvement:     18-­‐27  

Deborah  B.  Vilas,  MS,  CCLS,  LMSW  ©2015       9  


Return  to  title  page  

You might also like