You are on page 1of 4

Work 44 (2013) 93–96 93

DOI 10.3233/WOR-2012-01568
IOS Press

Unforgotten to the unforgettable: How


Arpilleras contributed to Chilean history
informing everyday occupations and social
change
Susan Traini
School of Occupational Therapy, The University of Western Ontario, London, ON, Canada
Tel.: +1 519 643 6851; E-mail: straini2@uwo.ca

Abstract. Objective: The September 11, 1973 Pinochet military coup marks the anniversary of a changed way of life for everyone
in Chile and has influenced people around the world. This paper provides a reflection on the social, political, and personal
injustices faced by the women of Chile during a vicious dictatorship, through the depiction of an Arpillera.
Participants: This paper unfolds the women’s experience of occupational transitions and how they shared their stories of injustices
to the world at a time when almost all other voices of protest had been silenced.
Method: A narrative and historical reflection is used to offer an interpretation of the experiences of transitions among these
women.
Conclusion: Through the art of survival and a shared mission, the women of Chile worked outside of the traditional political
system to effect political change.

Keywords: Occupational transitions, occupational injustice, social injustice, occupational work transitions

1. Introduction social change in a system that undermines ones poten-


tial. Hence, the story is one that represents a common
During my time in Santiago Chile, with fellow stu- transformational theme of survival to a political voice
dents and professors, I had the opportunity to listen to that was manifested through an unexpected life style
many people’s stories about work transitions. Work disruption [4]. Throughout history, women have ex-
transitions are conceptualized as occupational transi- perienced disruptions in their daily lifestyle as a result
tions which influence health and well-being [4]. In oc- of war, politics, and social injustices [1]. As a result,
cupational science, occupational transitions are defined women in the past and present share a common theme
as “life course transitions, both normative, expected
of occupational work transitions through the art of sur-
and unexpected, that involves changes in what people
vival which have led and continue to lead to a political
can do, are expected to do, or need to do” [4, p. 362]. I
will share one story about occupational transitions that voice/social reform of womens rights [1]. Additional-
is most intriguing to me, as it is a story that creatively ly, this story can be transferred to other stories of the
and explicitly represents women’s fight for social and success in achieving personal and social change in the
human justice, in that it is unlike old feminist move- face of system barriers. As a result of my academic
ments that have joined political parties as a way of fur- and practical experience as a student and traveling to
thering their aims [1]. In addition, it is a motivational Chile, my view of occupational transition is that it can
story that unfolds the success of achieving personal and be an individual or shared experience which is defined

1051-9815/13/$27.50  2013 – IOS Press and the authors. All rights reserved
94 S. Traini / How Arpilleras contributed to Chilean history informing everyday occupations and social change

Fig. 1. An image of the Arpillera used in the paper to depict occupational and social injustices faced by women in Chile during the Pinochet
dictatorship. (Colours are visible in the online version of the article; http://dx.doi.org/10.3233/WOR-2012-01568)

by those who have experienced it and researched its vitality and movement, whose principle effect is that of
boundaries. political denunciation” [1, p. 12]. The scenes of “full
vitality and movement” depicted in the Arpillera in Fig-
ure 1will be discussed as they, like many Arpilleras,
2. The story behind the Arpilleras portray protests for occupational and social integrity [1,
p. 12].
I will use an Arpillera to share a descriptive sto- In my opinion, the Arpillera in Figure 1captures the
ry of the political impact on the occupational transi- outcome of the social and occupational injustices and
tions of women in Chile that will shed light on the the changes in the daily occupations of women in the
involvement of women in social reform and the fight realm of everyday life experienced during the Pinochet
for occupational and social justice during a devastat- dictatorship. I will use the Arpillera above to analyze
ing era, the Augusto Pinochet dictatorship in 1973. In some of the social system injustices, and transforma-
my opinion, Pinochet’s dictatorship resulted in many tion of women’s occupations. As part of this analysis
environmental impediments to health promoting occu- I will draw upon the work of Bartolo and Sheahan [2]
pations among women. Health promoting occupations who suggest that a “critical analysis of economic and
involve occupations that provide a sense of meaning, socio-cultural occupational determinants, and their im-
choice, satisfaction, belonging, purpose, and achieve- pact on the form of occupations and occupational en-
ment [2]. From an occupational therapy lens I feel gagement, is the basis for identifying occupational in-
that, the barbaric social constructions of totalitarian- justice” (p. 408).
ism, which characterized Pinochet’s regime, impacted
women’s engagement and participation in health pro-
moting occupations, which has been framed as occu- 3. The depictions in the Arpillera
pational injustice [2]. Hence, I believe that the ability
to engage in health promoting occupations as a per- In the midst of the vibrant landscape, as described in
son and a member of society is occupational and social Chilean history and the story behind the Arpilleras, are
justice. Before I share the occupational and social in- representation s of the implications of a brutal dictator-
justices faced by women in Chile, I will first describe ship; these representations are depicted in the Arpillera
an Arpillera. Arpillera means burlap in Spanish; the in Fig. 1: women teaching school outside due to loss of
backing cloth is often of burlap or other feed or grain electricity in the schools, women filling buckets with
sacks that often make up an Arpillera [1]. The Chilean well water due to the loss of running water, a wom-
Arpillera I will discuss, like all Arpilleras, includes an traveling by horse and buggy due to poverty and
“figures superimposed on cloth to create scenes full of low income, women performing the traditional male
S. Traini / How Arpilleras contributed to Chilean history informing everyday occupations and social change 95

dominated home maintenance occupations like fixing they also had to change their own routines in managing
the roof or, physical labor such as construction jobs, households. The loss of access to water and electricity
and women hanging up burlap flour bags on a clothes drastically added to their work and changed how they
line to dry for use in creating Arpilleras. In contrast, cooked, cleaned and taught the children. The biggest
the Arpillera also depicts activities of a normal Chilean change was the women had to find a way to earn an
lifestyle such as picking fresh fruit from trees, children income. This government underestimated the impact
playing outside, women and children bonding, a wom- of injustice caused by the new regime and the resolve
an feeding birds and most importantly the yellow sun as well as the persistent strength of women of Chile
and the Andes mountains in the backdrop resembling a to survive and overcome the seemingly insurmountable
sign of hope toward regaining a lost way of life. This challenges they faced. Furthermore the Arpilleras were
Arpillera like other Arpilleras helps preserve the mem- viewed as insignificant by military guards and regime
ory of a time period when loved ones disappeared and officials. The women took full advantage of their pre-
the Chilean way of life was impacted by a brutal dic- scribed role as mothers using their minority status and
tatorship; furthermore Arpilleras symbolize the occu- the Arpilleras to fight for change.
pational injustices experienced such as unemployment,
food shortages, and housing shortages experienced dur-
ing Pinochet’s rule [1]. The story behind the story in- 5. The development of the Arpilleras and the
trigued me so I looked further into the social, political, workshops
and historical backdrop underpinning the occupational
injustices and subsequent changes to daily life in the Many women began to participate in the develop-
Arpilleras. ment of Arpilleras which was part of a grassroots social
movement of women and mothers of Chile fighting for
women’s and human rights. Chilean women became in-
4. Historical influences on the occupations of volved in workshops and the development of Arpilleras
women in Chile as one avenue to search for their disappeared relatives
as they would often stitch in pictures of lost loved ones.
On September 11, 1973, General Augusto Pinochet Beyond this their involvement in the production of the
led a vicious military coup against Chile’s demo- Arpilleras through the workshops served as part of the
cratically elected Marxist government [1]. The secret transformation of women, providing them an income,
police, gathered thousands of Socialist Party mem- as a source of employment, a source of emotional and
bers, appointees, union leaders, and other suspected social support and group therapy as they attempted to
protestors [1]. Thousands of husbands and sons were make sense of the loss of family, and a place to learn
detained and tortured; some disappeared and have nev- business management skills.
er been accounted for and many women who supported The Arpillera workshops consisted exclusively of
the socialist party were imprisoned. In addition, this women who met several times a week in a church build-
regime took over the water and electricity utilities in- ing in candle light so they would not be caught and
frastructure to profit from them, making it impossible charged with slander [1]. Most Arpillera workshops
for people with little to no incomes in receiving ba- were organized by the Vicariate of Solidarity, a pro-
sic services they previously assessed under the social- democracy group run by the archbishop of Santiago [1].
ist government. The military under Pinochet shared a The Vicariate was responsible for finding a place to
belief that women were politically passive/uneducated meet, providing supplies in addition to the scraps of
and uninvolved as they were encouraged to remain tra- fabric of the women’s clothes, and buying the com-
ditional in their gender roles as wives and mothers [1]. pleted Arpilleras and selling them abroad. The work-
These political changes, beliefs and actions drastically shops were well organized; the workshop had a trea-
impacted the way of life for the women as depicted surer, a quality control manager, and someone to de-
in the Arpillera. The loss of husbands and sons who liver the completed Arpilleras [1]. Despite the various
worked and provided the means of support left women degrees of labour the workshops were very egalitarian;
who were suffering from these losses with little choice, the workshops were a good example of a successful
but to find a way to survive. In addition to fulfilling democratic social movement. The social interactions
the traditional roles of their husbands, such as earn- within the workshops served to transform them from a
ing an income and performing general maintenance, way of earning money to a social movement [1]. The
96 S. Traini / How Arpilleras contributed to Chilean history informing everyday occupations and social change

experience of having ones anxieties sewn on a piece of fore, the Arpilleras are also lasting legacies depicting
cloth was a form of release; it was a sense of control the occupational transitions of the women during an
and integrity, a protest for social justice. The wom- era in which they had little control; in the face of it all,
en explained the feelings they experienced when they they managed to exert pressure, gain control of their
completed an Arpillera by stating, “A great anxiety at lives, and work together to promote change and oppor-
having to express openly all one’s inner feelings, to tunities for women. The Arpillera and its production
have to sew and put together every detail, but happy represent a support and resource during the political
to denounce what is happening” [1, p. 75]. Another era [4]. The women survived in the dark and managed
woman stated, “The Arpilleras were a beautiful kind to paint a picture of an impossible time that shed light
of therapy for me. I lived alone, coming back to my on women’s rights and abilities, which I like to call the
house to sew and to weep caused me great suffering. art of survival. This story descriptively represents the
To relieve my anguish I made my Arpilleras” [1, p. 74]. art of survival when faced with occupational change
In addition, a woman commented on the outcome of and challenges that may be in ones way of achieving his
the workshops by stating, “The Arpilleristas – house- or her goals. The women of Chile created prosperity
wives, seamstresses, laundresses- assumed a new iden- for other women of their country and around the world.
tity that added an important dimension to their tradi- This transformation of survival to political voice using
tional female role” [1, p. 52]. Chilean women had to Arpilleras or art is a common thread that links many
make a transition from their domestic role in the home women movements around the world [1]. As a result of
to playing the traditional male dominated role as the writing this paper I began to realize that each individ-
sole provider for the family. These new occupations ual or minority can be as powerful as he or she desires
in turn helped to shape new identities. The workshops to be to make a change. The engagement in a shared
provided a place for them to earn money and be politi- mission and creative occupation such as Arpilleras can
cally active which lead to a newly assumed worker and provide a powerful resource through horrific life dis-
activist identity, a shift from the traditional female role ruption that can foster both social and personal change.
of domestic work in the home. Furthermore, I view the Arplileras as representations
of perseverance, determination, and creativity which
are key ingredients to help make it through life’s chal-
6. Conclusion lenges. Thus, these key ingredients can transform per-
sonal challenges of occupational and social injustices,
I came across the Arpillera above in 2010. The wom- into a righteous socio-political movement.
en today continue to make Arpilleras to support women
with low incomes through unemployment transitions
and in turn the story about the transitions of women in References
Chile lives on. An Arpillera is not just an artistic wall-
hanging made of thread and colorful scraps of cloth; [1] M. Agosin, Scraps of Life: Chilean Arpilleras, Williams-
Wallace Publishers, Toronto, ON, 1987.
an Arpillera is a mirage of a story that was destined to [2] L.L. Bartolo and M. Sheahan, Industrial relations reform and
be forgotten, a story of the abuse of power. I use the the occupational transition of Australian workers: A critical
word mirage because the beautiful scenery and colors discourse analysis, Work 32 (2009), 407-415.
displayed in the Arpilleras appear as another piece of [3] L.V. Niekerk, Participation in work: A source of wellness for
people with psychiatric Disability, Work 32 (2009), 455-465.
artistry, yet they tell a story of brutality and occupa- [4] L. Shaw and D.L. Rudman, Using occupational science to study
tional injustices. The mirage-like characteristic of the occupational transitions in the realm of work: from micro to
“wall-hangings” was the key to their success of achiev- macro levels, Work 32 (2009), 361-364.
ing social reform and justice in captive times. There-

You might also like