Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HUMANITARIAN CIVIL-MILITARY
COORDINATION IN EMERGENCIES:
TOWARDS A PREDICTABLE MODEL
FOREWORD
The Regional Consultative Group (RCG) on Humanitarian This revised publication was produced through
Civil-Military Coordination (CMCoord) for Asia and collaboration between the ASEAN Coordinating Centre for
the Pacific is a key forum for supporting and elevating Humanitarian Assistance on disaster response, the United
coordination, building relationships, and sharing learning Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
to enhance and strengthen emergency response. When – Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific, the Australian
the RCG was formed in 2014, it was tasked with improving Civil-Military Centre and Humanitarian Advisory Group.
awareness and enhancing the predictability of CMCoord Expert practitioners and researchers contributed their
mechanisms, and their respective functions, during large- time to ensure the information is accurate and accessible.
scale disaster response. As a result, the RCG initiated Like the initial version, the publication will be regularly
the development of the first version of Humanitarian updated to reflect operational environments accurately.
Civil-Military Coordination in Emergencies: Towards
a Predictable Model, which focused on explaining the As the current Chair of the RCG, we recognize that effective
legislation, coordination mechanisms, approach to and humanitarian CMCoord enables timely, efficient and
leadership of disaster management in the five most effective response, and we appreciate every investment
disaster-prone countries in Asia: Bangladesh, Nepal, and effort of the relevant individuals, governments and
Indonesia, Myanmar and the Philippines. The publication organizations in the revision of this publication. We trust
was launched in 2017, and soon became a key reference for that it will receive due attention and support future
the CMCoord community. deployments of military and civilian actors in the region.
ii
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This publication is funded by the Australian Civil-Military This publication has been produced as a collaboration
Centre (ACMC). between Humanitarian Advisory Group and key
humanitarian civil-military stakeholders in the Asia-
Research team: Bethia Burgess, Brittany Card, Pamela Pacific region, namely the ASEAN Coordinating Centre for
Combinido, Beth Eggleston, Pip Henty, Jesse McCommon, Humanitarian Assistance on disaster management (AHA
Aung Naing, Khodadad Hosaain Sarker, Sumino, Tika Centre), Australian Civil-Military Centre (ACMC), and the
Surapati, Bishan Wagle, Putu Hendra Wijaya United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian
Affairs (UN OCHA), Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific
Graphic design: Jean Watson (ROAP).
Copy edit: Campbell Aitken Humanitarian Advisory Group wishes to thank members
of the Regional Consultative Group (RCG), the AHA Centre,
Cover photo: Indonesian volunteers and soldiers worked
ACMC, UN OCHA-ROAP, the Center for Excellence in
together to distribute humanitarian aid to victims of
Disaster Management and Humanitarian Assistance
the earthquake and tsunami disaster in Palu Central
(CFE-DM), the UN OCHA country offices and national and
Sulawesi, Indonesia - October 8, 2018. Photo: Tino Adi P /
regional consultants for all their support in preparing and
Shutterstock
reviewing this document.
iii
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION 6
BANGLADESH 25
INDONESIA 49
Disaster Risk Profile 51
Key Policies, Plans and Frameworks for Civil-Military Coordination 53
Key Civilian Responsibilities in Disasters 55
Key Military Responsibilities in Disasters 65
Humanitarian Civil-Military Coordination Mechanisms 67
Case Study: Lombok Earthquake Response 69
Case Study: Sulawesi Earthquake and Tsunami Response 70
Acronyms and Abbreviations 72
References 74
iv
MYANMAR 77
Disaster Risk Profile 79
Key Policies, Plans and Frameworks for Civil-Military Coordination 81
Key Civilian Responsibilities in Disasters 82
Key Military Responsibilities in Disasters 90
Humanitarian Civil-Military Coordination Mechanisms 93
Case Study: 2015 Flood Response 94
Acronyms and Abbreviations 96
Reference List 98
NEPAL 99
Disaster Risk Profile 101
Key Policies, Plans and Frameworks for Civil-Military Coordination 103
Key Civilian Responsibilities in Disasters 104
Key Military Responsibilities in Disasters 114
Humanitarian Civil-Military Coordination Mechanisms 118
Case Study: July 2019 Monsoon Response 121
Case Study: Gorkha Earthquake Response 2015 123
Acronyms and Abbreviations 125
References 127
PHILIPPINES 129
Disaster Risk Profile 131
Key Policies, Plans and Frameworks for Civil-Military Coordination 133
Key Civilian Responsibilities in Disasters 135
Key Military Responsibilities in Disasters 144
Humanitarian Civil-Military Coordination Mechanisms 148
Case Study: Typhoon Mangkhut (Ompong) Response 150
Case Study: Typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda) Response 151
Acronyms and Abbreviations 153
References 155
CONCLUSION 157
v
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
INTRODUCTION
This publication is an initiative of the Regional Consultative be an invaluable forum to increase learning, cooperation
Group (RCG) on Humanitarian Civil-Military Coordination and collaboration between civilian and military actors. The
for Asia and the Pacific. This is the second edition, an Asia Pacific is the only region in the world that has formed
update of the original document published in 2017; a Consultative Group for Humanitarian Civil-Military
it enables a common understanding of civil-military Coordination to complement the Global Consultative Group
coordination (CMCoord) mechanisms and their functions on Humanitarian Civil-Military Coordination.
in disaster response. It focuses on the five countries the
RCG prioritises as highly vulnerable to large-scale natural This update seeks to ensure that the guidebook maintains
disasters: Bangladesh, Indonesia, Myanmar, Nepal and the its accuracy and practicality for the region. It captures new
Philippines. and revised policies, plans and frameworks at regional and
national levels, explaining the roles and responsibilities
The RCG on Humanitarian Civil-Military Coordination for of diverse actors and coordinating bodies in each context.
Asia and the Pacific is a multi-stakeholder, regional forum This update was developed in collaboration with key
that brings together humanitarian, civilian and military regional stakeholders to boost regional ownership and
actors involved in disaster planning, preparedness and uptake of the resource.
response. Over the last six years, the RCG has proved to
SECRETARIAT
N E PA L
M YA N M A R
BANGLADESH
MEMBERSHIP
Members include Member
PHILIPPINES States, representatives from
the Armed Forces, regional
organizations, academia /
think tanks, international,
national and local NGOs/
CSOs, UN organizations and
international organizations,
Red Cross / Red Crescent
Movement, donors, private
I N DO N E S I A
sector.
6
2020
International Non-Governmental Association of South East Asian NGOs, Civil Society Organizations
Organizations (INGOs), United Nations Nations (ASEAN), South Asian (CSOs), national military personnel,
(UN) funds, agencies and programs, Association for Regional Cooperation national, provincial and local
foreign military personnel, Red Cross/ (SAARC), regional offices of governments.
Red Crescent (RCRC) movement. intergovernmental organizations and
other supporting regional bodies.
APPROACH
Steering Committee
National consultants
This update utilised a robust mixed methodology In order to capture and verify the most up-to-date
method. The research was guided by a Steering information from each country context, our research
Committee comprising representatives from the ASEAN team included national researchers from each of the
Coordination Centre for Humanitarian Assistance on five countries profiled. National researchers led data
disaster management (AHA Centre), UN OCHA ROAP, the collection in-country, and conducted both desk review and
Australian Civil-Military Centre (ACMC) and Humanitarian key informant interviews with humanitarian, government
Advisory Group (HAG). These partnerships ensured that and military actors to triangulate sources as the research
the document remained practical and relevant for the progressed.
region and facilitated close working relationships with the
National Disaster Management Offices (NDMOs) and OCHA
offices in each of the five countries.
7
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
This second edition provides important updates on the evolution of CMCoord in Asia over the last four years. These
changes are underpinned by three key themes in the region.
The localisation discussion does not affect the military This concept has not been operationalised across all
in the same way as the civil humanitarian community. contexts. CMCoord has shifted away from a standardised
However, more localised structures have emphasised model in order to be contextualised and adaptable at the
the prominent role of national militaries, police and national level. The HuMOCC is mentioned in countries
government actors as both early responders and leaders of where the model has been adapted.
response. Recently, many Asian countries have increased
their capabilities and strengthened their structures
to more effectively meet humanitarian needs without
international assistance. 3. COUNTRY-LEVEL REFORM
Additionally, regionalism has strengthened with In line with the shift towards a more localised
developments such as One ASEAN, One Response, humanitarian architecture and strengthened national
adopted in September 2016, to increase the speed, scale capabilities, there have been significant changes and
and solidarity of disaster response. ASEAN and SAARC updates to national legislation and disaster management
have both worked to strengthen regional cooperation and bodies. As the region faces more frequent and severe
collaboration in disaster management, offering numerous natural disasters, many countries have revised and
trainings and regional capabilities that have advanced strengthened existing policies and established new
considerably since the first edition in 2017. procedures to meet growing demand. This second edition
captures these changes to provide the best overview of the
current system.
8
ASIAN REGION
HUMANITARIAN CIVIL-MILITARY
COORDINATION IN EMERGENCIES
Nepali Army clearing rubble after earthquake damage in Nepal 2015. Photo: manjitkhadka / Shutterstock
9
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
HUMANITARIAN CIVIL-MILITARY
COORDINATION IN ASIA
The historical evolution of civil-military relations in Asia In addition to regional influences, both global and national
is distinct from that in other geographical regions and policy shifts and reforms in the last five years are having a
influences current roles of civilian and military actors major impact on humanitarian response. Climate change,
in disaster response. It shapes the unique coordination urbanisation and increasingly frequent natural disasters
mechanisms in each country, and recognition of this is are driving these shifts. The key global policies affecting
integral to successful regional and international support in the structure of humanitarian response and the shape of
disaster response. preparedness include the Agenda for Humanity, the 2030
Agenda for Sustainable Development, and the Sendai
Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015-2030.
AGENDA FOR HUMANITY SENDAI FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER 2030 AGENDA FOR
RISK REDUCTION 2015-2030 SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
The Agenda for Humanity is a five- The Sendai Framework for Disaster The Agenda is a commitment to
point plan that emerged from the Risk Reduction 2015-2030 outlines eradicate poverty and achieve
World Humanitarian Summit (WHS). seven clear targets and four priorities sustainable development by 2030
for action to prevent new and reduce worldwide, ensuring that no one is left
It outlines the changes needed to
existing disaster risks: behind.
alleviate suffering, reduce risk and
lessen vulnerability on a global scale. (i) Understanding disaster risk; The adoption of the 2030 Agenda
Global leaders and all humanitarian was a landmark achievement, giving
(ii) Strengthening disaster risk
actors are called upon to act on five a shared global vision towards
governance to manage disaster risk;
core responsibilities. sustainable development for all.
(iii) Investing in disaster reduction for
Core responsibility four – Changing
resilience; and
People’s Lives: From Delivering Aid
to Ending Need – outlines the need to (iv) Enhancing disaster preparedness
reinforce, not replace, national and for effective response and to “Build
local humanitarian and development Back Better” in recovery, rehabilitation
systems. and reconstruction.
10 ASIAN REGION
2020
• Indian Ocean Tsunami – international militaries, • Second RCG Session on Humanitarian CMCoord for
including personnel and assets deployed. Asia and the Pacific.
• ASEAN-UN Joint Strategic Plan on Disaster
Management 2016-2020 developed.
• July - ASEAN Agreement on Disaster Management • ASEAN Leaders sign the ASEAN Declaration on One
2016
and Emergency Response (AADMER) signed. ASEAN One Response.
2005
• First ASEAN Regional Disaster Emergency Response • Inclusion of Chapter 6 on the use of military assets
Simulation (ARDEX), Selangor, Malaysia, to test and and capacity in ASEAN SASOP.
validate SASOP. • The Member States of the South Asian Association
for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) ratify the SAARC
Agreement on Rapid Response to Natural Disasters
• Standard Operating Procedure for Regional Standby (SARRND).
Arrangement and Coordination of Joint Disaster Relief
and Emergency Operations (SASOP) endorsed.
2008
2017
• ASEAN-led coordinating mechanism to respond to and the Pacific.
Cyclone Nargis, and establishment of Tripartite Core • OCHA organized pilot UN CMCoord Course for ASEAN.
Group comprised of Myanmar, ASEAN and UN.
deployed. response.
• Finalisation of Asia-Pacific Regional Guidelines for • Multiple major disasters in the ASEAN region -
2018
the Use of Foreign Military Assets in Natural Disaster Flood in Laos, Myanmar and other countries in the
Response Operations (APC-MADRO). Mekong region, Earthquake in Lombok Indonesia,
Typhoon Mangkhut in the Philippines, triple disasters
(earthquake, tsunami and liquefaction) in Central
• ARF-DiREx in Manado, Indonesia. Sulawesi.
2011
• ASEAN Coordinating Centre for Humanitarian • ASEAN-ERAT and UNDAC interoperabiity tested on
Assistance on Disaster Management (AHA Centre) the ground.
established. • OCHA releases Recommended Practices for Effective
Humanitarian Civil-Military Coordination of Foreign
Military Assets (FMA) in Natural and Man-Made
Disasters.
2012
the Philippines. The Armed Forces of the Philippines on HADR test the AMRG on HADR.
respond alongside Foreign Military Assets (FMA) from
2019
more than 22 countries. Lessons learned resulted in • The AHA Centre developed and tested its own ASEAN
the development of One ASEAN One Response. Civil -Military Coordination curriculum for its ASEAN-
ERAT Level 2 capacity building program.
• South Asian Forum on Preparedness for Regional
• Introduction of the concept of ASEAN Military Ready Disaster Response on the Implementation of the
SARRND.
2014
ASIAN REGION 11
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Multiple regional bodies have roles in disaster management and therefore influence humanitarian CMCoord. Their
influence is exerted through inter-governmental bodies, disaster management guidelines, periodic meetings, deployable
response teams and exercises. Both civil and military actors are involved in many of these initiatives, and their intent is to
support national mechanisms.
ASEAN
Coordinating Standard Operat-
Centre for ing Procedure for ASEAN
ASEAN ASEAN Humanitarian Regional Standby Emergency
Committee Agreement Assistance Arrangements Rapid Disaster
on Disaster on Disaster on disaster and Coordination Assessment Emergency Declaration
Management Management management of Joint Disaster Teams Logistics of One
and Emergency Relief and Emer- System ASEAN One
ACDM Response AHA gency Operations ASEAN- for ASEAN Response
AADMER Centre SASOP ERAT DELSA OAOR
The Use of Establish Establishment Introduction Introduction
ASEAN
ASEAN Military ASEAN Multi- of ASEAN of ASEAN of ASEAN
Defence
Assets and National Centre for Military Military
Ministers
Capacities in Coordination Military Ready Group Ready Group
Meeting
Association ADMM
Humanitarian Centre SOP Medicine
AMRG on AMRG on
Assistance and for militaries ACMM HADR Military HADR
of Southeast Disaster Relief MNCC Representa-
Asian Nations HADR tive to the AHA
ASEAN - Concept Paper Centre
South Asian
Association SAARC Natural Disaster SAARC Disaster
for Regional Rapid Response Mechanism Management Centre
Cooperation NDRRM SDMC
SAARC
Asia-Pacific
APEC Emergency Task Force for APEC strategy on Response to
Economic
Preparedness Working Group Emergency Preparedness and Preparedness for Natural
Cooperation
Disasters and Emergencies
APEC EPWG TFEP
12 ASIAN REGION
2020
RUSSIA
J A PA N
AF GH AN I STAN
CHIN A
N EPAL BH UTAN SOUTH
KOREA
PA KI STAN
V IE T N A M TA IWA N P R O V IN C E O F C H IN A
M YA N -
I ND I A MAR HONG KONG
B A N G LA - L AO P D R
DE SH THAILAND
CAMBO DIA P H I L I P P IN E S
BRUNEI DARUSSAL AM
M A L AY S I A
SR I L ANKA
PA P U A
M AL DI V ES SI NG A P O R E N E W G U IN E A
IN D O N E S IA
A U S T R A L IA
NEW
ZEALAND
ASIAN REGION 13
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
ARDEX
ARDEX – The ASEAN The AHA Centre co- The Host Country, other Every two years.
Regional Disaster organises and co-chairs ASEAN Member States,
Emergency Response the conduct of ARDEX with ASEAN and the relevant
Simulation Exercise. the host ASEAN Member UN and international
State (AMS). The ARDEX organisations. The Host
aims to practice, assess and Country in consultation
review disaster emergency with the AHA Centre will
response mechanisms determine the actors who
under the SASOP. will be involved.
ERE AP
International Search and The simulation exercise is The exercise brings Yearly.
Rescue Advisory Group a ‘command post’ exercise together 500 participants
(INSARAG) Asia-Pacific involving management and (220 international, 280
Earthquake Response decision-making elements national) from 27 countries:
Exercise (ERE AP). of both the national urban search and rescue
disaster response and the teams, emergency medical
international humanitarian teams, UN and ASEAN
relief community. The assessment teams,
exercise aims to practice humanitarian country team,
national and INSARAG and militaries.
response and coordination
methodologies based on a
humanitarian response to a
7.2-magnitude earthquake.
REGIONAL AGREEMENTS
ASEAN AGREEMENT ON DISASTER disaster risk reduction, it was a landmark development.
MANAGEMENT AND EMERGENCY RESPONSE This agreement laid the foundation for the current
approach the ASEAN takes to disaster management and
has enabled the joint nature of planning, preparedness and
Signed in July 2005, AADMER came into force in December
response throughout the region.
2009. As the world’s first legally binding agreement on
14 ASIAN REGION
2020
Enacted in 6 Sep 2016, the One ASEAN One Response The AHA Centre manages the ASEAN ERAT capability.
declaration envisions an ever-stronger and ever-expanding Under the leadership of the affected NDMO of the ASEAN
bond of sectors and stakeholders within the ASEAN Member State, the ASEAN-ERAT’s role is to reinforce
community in responding to disasters. As a vision, it sees the capacity of the NDMO through its core functions, i.e.
ASEAN as a community of peoples, not just a collection of coordination, rapid needs and damage assesment, and
governments. It encapsulates all stakeholders in ASEAN, facilitation of incoming relief assistance. ASEAN ERAT
be they National Disaster Management Organizations guidelines were developed by the ASEAN Committee
(NDMOs), military, health providers, corporations, non- for Disaster Management (ACDM) working group on
governmental organizations, academe, and youth. One preparedness and response. The ASEAN-ERAT’s role is
ASEAN One Response also envisions the region as part also endorsed as the official ASEAN resource under the
of the global disaster management community, hence declaration of One ASEAN One Response.
recognizing the potential of the ASEAN community to assist
communities outside the region in times of disaster, as a
way for ASEAN to contribute positively to the world.
One ASEAN, One Response is supported by the
ASEAN Joint Disaster Response Plan (AJDRP). This
SAARC AGREEMENT ON RAPID RESPONSE plan recognizes the mutual commitment to continued
TO NATURAL DISASTERS and enhanced partnership between ASEAN and its
partners. It also acknowledges the regional context,
The SAARC Member States signed the SAARND in 2011 which is characterised by increasing self-reliance
to operationalize the National Disaster Rapid Response and the determination of ASEAN Member States to
Mechanism (NDRRM). This agreement was ratified by all lead domestic disaster management and response
Member States in 2016. The SAARC Disaster Management and to collaborate and cooperate with each other in
Centre is currently functioning as the main implementing times of disaster emergencies. The scenarios and its
agency; however, it is still awaiting formal approval for its associated plans are exercised as part of the ARDEX.
establishment so it can be fully operational.
Request or Request or
offer assistance offer assistance
Supporting Affected
AHA Member
Member
Centre State
State
Ac
ti v
a ti Activation & Mobilization t
on en
&
Mo ym
b il p lo
iz a De
tio
n
ASEAN
ERAT
ASIAN REGION 15
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
In 2019, the AHA Centre piloted the ASEAN Civil-Military Coordination Course for the ASEAN-ERAT and ASEAN
militaries. The course aims to build the capacity of ASEAN-ERAT as a Civil-Military Coordination Specialist, to
familarize the ASEAN militaries to the ASEAN systems, as well as to build network and relationship that help them to
mount humanitarian responses.
DELSA is a key mechanism to allow a swift provision Depot World Food Progamme (UNHRD-WFP). In 2016, the
of relief items to the affected ASEAN Member States AHA Centre launched the DELSA Catalogue to describe
following a disaster. DELSA was established in 2012 to available stockpiles and to map out needs for types of
develop a regional relief item stockpile and to support disaster. In 2019, the AHA Centre also established two
capacity development of the AHA Centre and ASEAN satellite warehouses in Manila, the Philippines and
Member States in emergency logistics operations. This Chai Nat, Thailand with approval and support from the
is also in collaboration with UN Humanitarian Response Governments of the Philippines and Thailand.
Reproduced from AHA Centre fact sheet ‘DELSA Disaster Emergency Logistics System For ASEAN’
16 ASIAN REGION
2020
CHI NA
SOUTH J A PA N EMT certified
KOREA
PA K I S TA N CISAR,
CSAR
INSARAG-certified
USAR teams
THAI LAND
MALAYS I A
I ND ON E S IA
S I NGAPO RE
F IJ I
AU S T R A L IA
NSW,
QLD NEW
ZEALAND
ASIAN REGION 17
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
A f f e c t e d M e m b e r S t a t e
ASEAN Urban Search Emergency UN Disaster Cluster System Disaster ASEAN Joint
Emergency and Medical Teams Assessment Resources Emergency Disaster
Response and Rescue Teams Coordination Logistics Response Plan
Assessment System for
CAPABILITIES
AHA Centre INSARAG Response and OCHA Resident AHA Centre AHA Centre
Assessment Coordinator/
Teams Humanitarian
Coordinator
CIVILIAN ACTORS
AHA Centre ASEAN Coordinating Centre for Humanitarian OCHA Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
Assistance on disaster management
INSARAG International Search and Rescue Advisory Group
18 ASIAN REGION
2020
A JOCCA is a physical on-site coordination system government’s response efforts as a manifestation of One
designed to enhance ASEAN’s collective response, ASEAN One Response.
particularly during large-scale disaster emergencies in
the ASEAN region, and to support the government of the During a Catastrophic or Major natural disaster in the
affected ASEAN Member State. region, when international assistance might be required,
the JOCCA and the ASEAN ERAT can work alongside the
A JOCCA can provide a direct coordination interface On Site Operations Coordination Centre (OSOCC) and the
between ASEAN responders and the NDMO of the affected UNDAC team, to facilitate joint coordination of incoming
ASEAN Member State. This coordination system allows assistance to support the affected country’s disaster
ASEAN entities to effectively support the affected response.
NDMO/LEMA
Operations Section Planning Section Logistics Section Admin & Finance Section
Civil Military
Coordination Situation Facilities
Coordination
Information Telecommuni-
Liaison
Management cations
Public
Assessment Transportation
Information
Reception/
Departure Centre
To support the NDMO of the affected To establish a physical space as To establish a coordination interface
Member State to establish an on-site a single point of service for state at the ground level with relevant
coordination system in receiving actors, civil society organizations, United Nations and the international
and coordinating incoming relief private sector actors and other ASEAN humanitarian community including
assistance in a large-scale disaster responders involved in the emergency civil and military coordination.
emergency from ASEAN. response operations in the affected
country.
ASIAN REGION 19
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
UN-CMCoord definition:
OCHA IN THE REGION
UN-CMCoord is the dialogue and coordination
between civilian and military actors in humanitarian OCHA Regional Office for Asia Pacific (ROAP) works with
emergencies. It is essential for protecting and regional partners to tailor global guidance on humanitarian
promoting humanitarian principles, avoiding CMCoord to the regional context, strengthen humanitarian
competition, minimizing inconsistencies and, when CMCoord for response preparedness, and increase the
appropriate, pursuing common goals. Basic strategies predictability of CMCoord processes and platforms during
range from cooperation to coexistence. Coordination a response.
is a shared responsibility facilitated by liaison and
common training.1
20 ASIAN REGION
2020
AHA Centre ASEAN Coordinating Centre for Humanitarian Assistance on disaster management
APC – MADRO Asia-Pacific Regional Guidelines For The Use Of Foreign Military Assets In Natural Disaster Response Operations
IFRC International Federation of the Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies
SASOP Standard Operating Procedure for Regional Standby Arrangement and Coordination of Joint Disaster Relief and
Emergency Operations
ASIAN REGION 21
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
UN United Nations
US United States
22 ASIAN REGION
2020
REFERENCES
AHA Centre. ASEAN ERAT Guidelines.
ASEAN. Standard Operating Procedures for Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Relief HADR.
ASEAN; United Nations. ASEAN-UN Joint Disaster Response Plan (AJDRP) 2016-2020. 2016.
ASEAN. Asian Pacific Regional Guidelines for the Use of Foreign Military Assets in Natural Disaster Response Operations
(APC-MADRO).2014.
ASEAN. Standard Operating Procedure for Regional Standby Arrangements and Coordination of Joint Disaster Relief and
Emergency Operations (SASOP). 2009.
ASEAN Defense Ministers’ Meeting. The Use of ASEAN Military Assets and Capacities in Humanitarian Assistance and
Disaster Relief HADR- Concept Paper. 2009.
Multinational Planning Augmentation Team. Multi-National Force Standing Operating Procedures (MNF-SOP). Version 3.3,
2019.
UN OCHA. “Disaster Response in Asia and the Pacific: A Guide to International Tools and Services” (https://www.unocha.
org/sites/unocha/files/ROAP_DisasterGuide.pdf).
ASIAN REGION 23
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
24
BANGLADESH
HUMANITARIAN CIVIL-MILITARY
COORDINATION IN EMERGENCIES
Cyclone Sidr and high tide destroy villages in Southkhali in District Bagerhat , army distributes relief goods by boat.
Photo: Joerg Boethling / Alamy Stock Photo
25
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
1997
evolved over several decades, and is formally recognised
• Standing Orders on Disaster outline the roles and
in the Disaster Management Act 2012, Standing Orders
responsibilities of the Armed Forces Division and
on Disaster (SOD) in 2010 and updated SOD (2019).
the Armed Forces Services – Army, Navy and Air
The Government of Bangladesh has made significant Force.
advances in disaster management, demonstrated during
the response to Cyclone Roanu in May 2016, landslide in
2004
Chittagong in 2017, and floods in 2019. • Severe monsoon floods.
management facilitated by the South Asian Association for • Cyclone Sidr and floods. Bangladesh Armed Forces
Regional Cooperation (SAARC) Member States. responds, supported by 49 countries.
Pacific Resilience Disaster Response Exercise • First PR DREE: hosted by Bangladesh Armed
Forces and the United States (US) military.
& Exchange 2017
2010
more than 1,400 participants from 13 nations to: • National Disaster Management Act adopted.
Disaster Response Coordination Center (NDRCC) • National Strategy on the Management of Disaster
and Climate-induced Internal Displacement
• Strengthen partnerships and communication
established.
between multiple agencies and nations in the event
of a catastrophic disaster in Bangladesh • Disaster Management Policy established.
• Undertake scenario planning, including for search
and rescue and logistical obstacles • NPDM (2016-2020) established.
2016
• Increase coordination between international and • Cyclone Roanu: Bangladesh Armed Forces
domestic organizations and agencies. responds.
2017
26 BANGLADESH
2020
KEY FACTS
Official name: People’s Republic NEPAL
of Bangladesh
Jamuna
Rajshahi
Official language: Bengali
Ga
ng e s
Dhaka
Disaster focal point: National Disaster Hazrat Shahjalal Int.
Management Council (NDMC); Ministry of
Disaster Management and Relief (MoDMR)
INDIA Khulna
Military: Bangladesh Armed Forces
Mongla Shah Amanat Int.
Payra
Police: Bangladesh Police Chittagong
Bay of Bengal
MYANMAR
50 km International airports Major seaports
GENERAL INFORMATION
Bangladesh has been affected by more than 200 natural disasters over the last 30 years. Bangladesh’s geographical
position, low-lying terrain, monsoon activity and large number of rivers make it highly vulnerable to natural hazards. Over
the past five decades, storms (52%) have been the most frequent disaster to affect Bangladesh, followed by floods (31%).
Storm
x149
Flood
x90
Epidemic
Earthquake Drought Landslide
x30
x9 x5 x6
Source: Emergency Management Database (EM-DAT), Center for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (CRED), 2020
BANGLADESH 27
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
2020 Floods
Cyclone Roanu
June - September
21 May 2016 | Category 1
5.4 million Rangpur
1.3 million
252
27
US$711 million
Jamuna
Rajshahi US$600 million
Ga
ng e s
Dhaka
Source: Emergency Management Database (EM-DAT), Center for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (CRED), 2020
28 BANGLADESH
2020
National Earthquake
Contingency Plan
2009
Disaster Management Act No 34 (2012). The Disaster Disaster Management Policy 2015. The National
Management Act provides the legal basis for disaster Disaster Management Policy 2015 was developed
risk reduction (DRR) and emergency response in compliance with section 19 of the Disaster
management in Bangladesh. This Act defines the Management Act 2012. The policy is intended to ensure
organizational structure of disaster management good governance, participation and accountability of
at national and local levels, and details the all stakeholders in disaster management. The main
responsibilities of all government departments and purpose of this policy is to design and implement
committees related to the disaster management hazard-specific strategies based on disaster risk
system. assessment.
Standing Orders on Disaster (1997, revised 2010) National Plan for Disaster Management 2016-2020.
further revised and updated in 2019. The SOD detail The NPDM 2016-2020 was built on the achievement,
the roles and responsibilities of each government learning and challenges of the previous plan (2010-
body engaged in disaster management – ministries, 2015) in order to ensure coordinated disaster risk
committees, departments and other organizations. It management by the relevant stakeholders. This
also provides for the establishment of coordination plan carefully considers the principles of the Sendai
processes at national and local levels. Declaration and framework for DRR, SDGs, and
national plans and strategies. The action plan identifies
National Strategy on the Management of Disaster and the areas of investment and emphasizes risk-informed
Climate-induced Internal Displacement (2015). The development planning. The main purposes of the
strategy outlines processes for the management of plan are protecting lives and resources, protecting
climate-induced internal displacement that supports investments, effective recovery, and reconstruction
the implementation of the Sendai Framework and the to restore life and livelihoods in the shortest possible
United Nations (UN) Sustainable Development Goals time. Due to COVID-19, revisions and updates for the
(SDGs). The strategy focuses on internal displacement next plan have been postponed.
caused by natural disasters; it does not address
cross-border displacement issues. Three phases are National Earthquake Contingency Plan (2009).
addressed: pre-displacement, displacement and post- This plan outlines processes for building the capacity
displacement. of all responding agencies, delineates roles and
responsibilities, and addresses preparedness
measures for responding to earthquakes.
BANGLADESH 29
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
National Disaster
Management Council
Divisional Disaster
Management Committee
Zone/
Upazila
District Disaster
Management Committee
Upazila Disaster
Management Committee Union
Union Disaster
Management Committee
30 BANGLADESH
2020
Key functions:
Established by: the SOD (2010, revised in 2019).
• Review the national disaster management system
• Provide strategic guidance in formulation of Key functions:
disaster management laws, policy and strategies for
• Advise the MoDMR on DRR, emergency response
implementation
preparedness and humanitarian assistance activities
• Promote awareness of disaster management among
• Consider overall disaster risks, and if necessary,
policymakers
recommend formation of sub-committees involving
• Evaluate disaster preparedness, response and
communities
recovery measures after a natural disaster.
• Promote the evaluation of the challenges and
opportunities related to disaster management
Leadership: Chairperson – Prime Minister.
• Recommend release of funds for special projects on
Composition: 52 members of public and private emergency response methods
organizations, civil society and UN agencies. • Propose long-term recovery plans.
Military representation: Army Chief, Navy Chief, Air Leadership: Chair of the standing committee, MoDMR.
Force Chief, and the AFD Principal Staff Officer.
Composition: 47 members of public and private
organizations, including non-governmental
INTER-MINISTERIAL DISASTER organizations (NGOs), business communities, civil
society and the Bangladesh Red Crescent Society
MANAGEMENT COORDINATION COMMITTEE
(BDRCS).
The IMDMCC is responsible for facilitating policymaking, Military representation: AFD Director General
planning, and implementation of measures for DRR and (Operation and Planning).
emergency response management.
Key functions:
• Risk reduction activities
• Emergency response, rehabilitation and
reconstruction
• Evaluating emergency preparedness status and
recommend corrective measures
• Approving response and recovery plans
• Promoting preparedness activities, such as fire
evacuation drills and search and rescue exercises
• Ensuring whole-of-government coordination in
emergency response and relief and rehabilitation
operations.
BANGLADESH 31
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
SUBDISTRICT
DISTRICT Upazila/
NATIONAL DIVISION
AND CITY Pourashava/
Union/Ward
The administrative levels in Bangladesh are divisions, districts, upazilas, pourashavas and unions. Each of these
levels has a DMC. The SOD detail their duties and responsibilities. The City and District DMCs have one representative
from the Bangladesh Armed Forces, fire brigade and civil defence. All committees include police and other law
enforcement agencies.2
32 BANGLADESH
2020
Divisional Disaster
Management Committee
Upazila Disaster
Management Committee Upazila-level Officers
of line agencies
Chair: Upazila Chair
UnionDisaster
Management Committee Union-level local
government representatives
Chair: Union Parishad Chair
BANGLADESH 33
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Function: MoDMR is responsible for advising NDMC Regional/provincial representation: MoDMR also
and IMDMCC on disaster-related decision-making. consists of the Department of Disaster Management,
The Disaster Management and Relief Division (DMRD) which provides technical advice to the DMRD for the
is situated within MoDMR. MoDMR is the focal point coordination of disaster management actions from the
for disaster management. It has focused its efforts on national to the local level.3
promoting community resilience to hazards in order to
reduce the effects of natural disasters on vulnerable
populations.
Function: MoHA has a key role in search and rescue Police, Rapid Action Battalion, Ansar, Village Defense
operations, security, relief operations and disaster Party, Border Guard Bangladesh and Bangladesh Coast
information management. These tasks are accomplished Guards. MoHA deploys the security forces, directed by
through the law and order protection forces under its the Deputy Commissioner or Upazila Nirbahi Officer, to
control including the Fire Service and Civil Defense, the affected areas.
Function: The PMO is responsible for strategic oversight activities of the National Disaster Management Council.
of all disaster management plans and policies. It The PMO is also responsible for the establishment of
provides instructions to all Ministries/Divisions a Disaster Monitoring and Coordination Cell (MCC) for
and other government agencies on their roles and civil-military coordination.
responsibilities in disaster response and coordinates the
MINISTRY OF DEFENSE
34 BANGLADESH
2020
COORDINATION MECHANISMS
National emergency response is organized into sectoral clusters led by the national government and supported by
international agency co-leads. The cluster system has been activated for several responses, including for Cyclone Roanu
and the floods in 2016 and 2019.
INTER-CLUSTER GROUPS
Eight inter-cluster working groups have been established at the national level: Cash, Community Engagement,
Forecast-based Action, Gender in Humanitarian Action (GIHA), Localisation, Needs Assessment, Information Management,
and Private Sector Partnership.4
BANGLADESH 35
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
NATIONAL EMERGENCY OPERATIONS CENTER The HCTT is a working group within the Local Consultative
Group (LCG) which provides an operational-level forum
In 2015, a National Emergency Operations Center (NEOC), for the coordination of disaster preparedness, response,
also termed the National Disaster Response Coordination and recovery across sectors. The HCTT also acts as
Center (NDRCC), was established by the Secretariat of the coordination platform for the sectoral clusters.
the MoDMR as a coordination mechanism for disaster Membership of the HCTT includes all cluster lead
response. The responsibilities of NEOC include organizing agencies, donor representatives, elected representatives
search and rescue activities and coordinating responding of the International NGO (INGO) Forum Emergency
agencies and organizations.5 The NEOC has been activated Sub Group, representatives of the NGO community, the
in several recent disasters, including in the responses to International Federation of the Red Cross (IFRC), and the
floods in 2015 and 2019. Bangladesh Red Crescent Society (BDRCS).7
In 2019, the Government of Bangladesh, through the When the Government of Bangladesh requests and/or
approved revised SOD, recognized the present cluster accepts international assistance, coordination between
coordination through the Humanitarian Coordination Task the HCTT, the UN Resident Coordinator and the national
Team (HCTT) as a tool for effective coordination with the response systems and bodies, including NDMC and lead
international community.6 government agencies, is initiated.9
36 BANGLADESH
2020
Displacement
Child Protection Management Education Early Recovery Food Security Gender Based Violence
Lead: MoWCA Lead: MoDMR Lead: MoE Lead: MoLGRDC Lead: SAG Lead: MoWCA
Co-lead: UNICEF Co-lead: IOM Co-lead: UNICEF/SAVE Co-lead: UNDP Co-lead: WFP/FAO Co-lead: UNFPA
Community Localisation
Cash Anticipatory GiHA Information Lead: CARITAS, Tec. Needs Private Sector
Engagement Management
Co-Lead: DDM & Action Co-Lead: DWA & Co-Lead: NIRAPAD & Assessments Partnership
OXFAM Co-Lead: DDM & BBC
Lead: BDRCS UNWomen Lead: RCO & MoDMR START Funds BD Co-Lead: DDM &CARE Lead: TBC
MA
Updated on 20 June 2020 **Aligned with Government of Bangladesh Standing Order on Disaster 2019
Source: UNOCHA Bangladesh
OSOCC
On-Site Operations
Coordination Centre
UN Resident Ministry of Supported: UNDAC
Coordinator Foreign Affairs
RDC
Reception and Departure
Centre
Humanitarian Cluster System in Bangladesh Supported: UNDAC
USAR
Urban Search
Humanitarian Coordination Task Team (HCTT) and Rescue
Supported: INSARAG
Co-Chair: MoDMR and UNRCO
EMT
Emergency Medical Team
Supported: WHO
BANGLADESH 37
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
The Armed Forces also has specific standing orders for its 21,280 14,000
personnel personnel
involvement in HADR operations.10
NAVY AIR
FORCE
38 BANGLADESH
2020
The Prime Minister’s Office establishes a MCC, operated by the AFD. Through this mechanism, coordination efforts,
including the use of military assets, are channelled to the IMDMCC and NDRCC of the MoDMR. The IMDCC is responsible
for decision-making with the MCC.1112
HADR is a key focus area for the AFD. In addition to the Bangladesh Ministry of Defence, the AFD and the Army, Navy and
Air Force have constituted responsibilities in disaster response.
SOD 2010,
revised in 2019
KEY DOCUMENT
!
NORMAL TIMES ALERT AND WARNING DISASTER RESPONSE RELIEF & REHABILITATION
• Designate a Disaster • Operate the control room • Deploy relevant units • Assist to conduct survey
Management Focal Point. along with the MCC in the of Army, Navy and Air and assessment of
Prime Minister’s Office Force to assist the civilian rehabilitation needs at
• Establish contact and
and keep active for 24/7. authorities in response, disaster affected area.
continuous liaison
humanitarian assistance
with Natural Disaster • Maintain communication • Assist in rehabilitation
and rehabilitation
Response Coordination with NEOC that is and reconstruction
activities.
Group (NDRCG) and coordinated by MoDMR. activities in coordination
MoDMR. • Collect information with MoDMR.
RESPONSIBILITIES
BANGLADESH 39
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Bangladesh Government
MoDMR
One Stop
Other Agencies DIMT MNCC HQ Foreign Military
Coordination Cell
Research and
Planning Wing Operations Wing Logistics Wing Media Wing
Development Wing
40 BANGLADESH
2020
CIVIL-MILITARY COORDINATION PLATFORM The key functions of the Civil Military Coordination
Platform are to:
An emerging practice in UN-CMCoord development
1. Provide recommendations to the National Platform
globally, as well as in Asia and the Pacific, is the
for Disaster Risk Reduction for formulating strategy
development of a platform to facilitate information sharing,
for effective coordination in DRR and humanitarian
task division and the coordination of operational planning
response activities.
between humanitarian and military actors, through the
Humanitarian-Military Operational Coordination Concept 2. Establish effective coordination and communication
(HuMOCC) in natural disaster response. In Bangladesh, the with the national and local DMCs and responding
HuMOCC platform has been realised by the Civil Military agencies to implement a humanitarian assistance
Coordination Platform. program.
3. Provide assistance to the Bangladesh Regional
The Coordination Platform, established in the SOD 2019, Consultative Group in strengthening coordination
includes representation of higher-level officers from between civil and military actors in a humanitarian
government ministries and departments, the UN systems, assistance program.
and the BDRCS.
4. Implement the Bangladesh Consultative Group’s
activities coordinating with the Regional Consultative
Group (RCG).
5. Assist local DMCs in implementing humanitarian
assistance program in a coordinated manner.
USAR
Urban Search
MNCC Humanitarian Coordination Task Team (HCTT) and Rescue
Multi-National Supported:
Military Co-Chair: MoDMR and UNRCO INSARAG
Coordination
Centre
Lead: AFD EMT
Foreign Military Assistance (FMA) Emergency Medical
Team
Supported: WHO
BANGLADESH 41
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
CIVIL-MILITARY COORDINATION
an
Amph
INDIA Khulna The AFD provided 146 disaster management teams and
76 medical teams for deployment, and prepared 12,500
relief packages, 16 water purification units and 14 water
bladders. A total of 531 Army patrol teams which had been
already deployed to fight the COVID-19 crisis were also
available to assist the local government with response.
ABOUT THE RESPONSE The AFD coordinated with the Disaster Monitoring and
Coordination Cell of the Prime Minister’s Office, the
The ‘super cyclone’ Amphan reached Bangladesh on MoDMR and the Department of Disaster Management, as
20 May 2020. The greatest impact was felt in Satkhira well as several other ministries and agencies.
and Khulna, with total damage affecting 19 districts.
The Government of Bangladesh (GoB) prepared for the
cyclone through the leadership of the MoDMR, facilitating
coordination meetings with all relevant stakeholders from
16 May.
15 UNRCO Bangladesh, HCTT Response Plan – Cyclone Amphan – United Nations Bangladesh Coordinated Appeal (June-September 2020).
16 “Cyclone Amphan: Armed Forces begin post-disaster activities in affected areas,” Dhaka Tribune, 21 May 2020.
42 BANGLADESH
2020
INDIA
Dhaka
B A N G LA DES H
I N D IA
r
Sid
ne o
ycl
fC
ho
Pat
Bay of Bengal
0 50 100 Km
The Bangladesh Air Force immediately mobilized 18 Provided support to district administration in
coordination, needs assessment, assigning
helicopters and five navy ships to deliver food, medicine
location and relief items for NGOs, and security.
and other relief supplies. The key activities that the military
executed were:
BANGLADESH 43
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
44 BANGLADESH
2020
BANGLADESH 45
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
UN United Nations
US United States
46 BANGLADESH
2020
REFERENCES
Armed Forces Division, Prime Minister’s Office, Bangladesh. Standard Operating Procedure of Bangladesh Multinational
Coordination Centre. 2019.
Asian Disaster Reduction Center (ADRC), Information on DRR of the member countries: Bangladesh. 2020.
Center for Excellence in Disaster Management and Humanitarian Assistance. Bangladesh: Disaster Management
Reference Handbook. 2020.
“Cyclone Amphan: Armed Forces begin post-disaster activities in affected areas.” Dhaka Tribune. 21 May 2020.
Management Database (EM-DAT), Center for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (CRED). 2020.
Ministry of Disaster Management and Relief, Government of Bangladesh. National Plan for Disaster Management (2016-
2020).
Ministry of Disaster Management and Relief, Government of Bangladesh. Standing Orders on Disaster (2019).
Ministry of Food and Disaster Management, Government of Bangladesh. Standing Orders on Disaster (1997, revised 2010).
Ministry of Food and Disaster Management, Government of Bangladesh. National Plan for Disaster Management 2012-
2015.
Ministry of Food and Disaster Management (MoFDM); Asian Disaster Preparedness Center (ADPC); Comprehensive
Disaster Management Programme (CDMP). National Earthquake Contingency Plan. 2009.
National Strategy on the Management of Disaster and Climate-induced Internal Displacement. 2015.
Office of the UN Resident Coordinator, Bangladesh. Humanitarian Coordination and Collaboration in Bangladesh
Handbook. 2020.
UNRCO Bangladesh. HCTT Response Plan – Cyclone Amphan – United Nations Bangladesh Coordinated Appeal (June-
September 2020).
BANGLADESH 47
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
48
INDONESIA
HUMANITARIAN CIVIL-MILITARY
COORDINATION IN EMERGENCIES
Indonesian soldiers with New Zealand military personnel unload relief goods at the
Mutiara SIS Al-Jufrie Airport in Palu on October 8, 2018, Central Sulawesi, Indonesia.
Photo: Ivan Damanik/ZUMA Wire/Alamy Live News
49
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
2002
Indonesia has been shaped by several contextual factors in • Republic of Indonesia Law 3 on National Defence
recent decades, including the frequency and scale of natural enacted.
disasters as well as the historical role of the Indonesian
Armed Forces (Tentara Nasional Indonesia, TNI). TNI is • Indian Ocean Tsunami – TNI responds and FMAs
a primary responder in disaster response and has been from more than 35 countries are deployed.
2004
deployed frequently as part of Indonesia’s Military Operations • Republic of Indonesia Law 34 Concerning National
Other Than War (MOOTW) doctrine.1 Its leading role in Armed Forces enacted. Outlines the main tasks of
disaster response has been influenced by its organizational TNI in MOOTW.
structure, military practices, clear chain of command and
coordination, and ability for rapid deployment.2 • Republic of Indonesia Law 24 Concerning Disaster
2007
Management enacted. The BNPB and Badan
In previous large-scale disasters, such as the 2004 Indian Penanggulangan Bencana Daerahs (Provincial and
Ocean tsunami, the 2009 West Sumatra earthquake and the District Disaster Management Agencies, BPBDs)
are created.
2018 Sulawesi earthquake and tsunami, foreign military
assets (FMAs) have been deployed to support several
response operations. Indonesia has developed legal and • Government Regulations 21 and 23 outline
policy frameworks to regulate international assistance and Guidelines for Disaster Management and
Participation of International Institutions and
was one of the first countries to incorporate International
2008
Agency Coordination (MAC) Center and the Multi-National • West Sumatra earthquake. TNI deployed. GoI
Coordination Center (MNCC). The Government of Indonesia welcomes international assistance from both
civilian actors and military forces.
(GoI) is currently undertaking a review of the Disaster
Management Law, which is expected to further clarify the role
of TNI in humanitarian assistance and disaster relief (HADR). • BNPB Guideline 22 on the Role of the International
Organizations and Foreign Non-Government
Organizations during Emergency Response
developed.
2010
Medan
Pacific
Manado Ocean
Padang
Palembang Makassar
Bandung
Indian
Jakarta Semarang
Ocean Surabaya
Yogyakarta
202,445 Fatalities
Source: Emergency Events Database (EM-DAT), Center for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (CRED), 2020.
INDONESIA 51
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
86,018 210,000
104 1,948
Medan Pacific
Manado Ocean
Padang
Triple disaster–Mentawei Makassar
earthquake and tsunami, Bandung
and Mt Merapi eruption Jakarta Semarang Lombok earthquake
26 October 2010 Surabaya 5 August 2018 | Magnitude 7.0
164,000 Yogyakarta 445,000
52 INDONESIA
2020
LAWS, REGULATIONS
& GUIDELINES
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 3 of 2002 Government Regulation Number 23 of 2008
on National Defense. This law outlines the role of TNI Concerning Participation of International Institutions
in MOOTW. and Foreign Non-Governmental Organizations in
Disaster Management. This regulation outlines
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 34 of 2004 provisions that govern the involvement of international
Concerning the National Armed Forces. This law organizations in disaster management in Indonesia. It
further delineates the main tasks of TNI in MOOTW, stipulates the authority for determining participation,
including supporting disaster response through planning and reporting processes, and outlines
facilitating humanitarian relief and management of roles and responsibilities for managing international
internally displaced persons. involvement in all phases of disaster management.
Law of the Republic of Indonesia, Number 24 of 2007 BNPB Guideline Number 6 of 2018 on the Acceptance
Concerning Disaster Management. This law is the of International Assistance in Disaster Emergency. As
main legal document guiding disaster response in well as providing guidance on managing international
Indonesia. It contains provisions for the responsibilities assistance, this guideline outlines specific
and authority of the government, disaster response responsibilities for TNI in the management of disaster
and relief, emergency status, and disaster aid financing response, including coordinating mechanisms for the
and management. This law is currently undergoing an entry of foreign military personnel and capabilities.
extensive review process (see update below).
INDONESIA 53
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Minister of Defence Regulation Number 35/2011. National Disaster Response Framework (2018). The
This regulation outlines TNI’s assistance to local NDRF was finalised in 2018, and fulfils the mandate
governments and in responding to disasters. of Disaster Management Law No. 24 of 2007 to clarify
roles and responsibilities in disaster management. It
Disaster Management Strategic Policy (2015–19). serves as a guidance document and sets strategy and
This policy focuses on natural disaster mitigation, doctrine for how all stakeholders build, sustain and
with one of the seven focus areas being natural deliver core capabilities in disaster response in an
disaster management. The three strategic objectives integrated manner. It affirms the coordination role of
are disaster risk reduction, reduction of disaster BNPB and BPBDs and sets guidelines for collaboration
vulnerability and increased disaster management with national and international partner organizations.
capacity. The updated Strategic Policy 2020–24 is
currently in development.
The GoI is currently revising the Disaster Management Law (Law Number 24 of 2007). This will redefine the
roles and responsibilities of key disaster management stakeholders, including the BNPB and TNI. It will
emphasise disaster risk reduction, and clarify plans, processes and alignment between national and local
disaster management authorities. Additionally, as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, the revised disaster
management law will include plans and policy for responding to non-natural disasters.
At the time of writing, draft legislation was being considered by the Indonesian House of Representatives.
The GoI has conducted several group discussions with relevant stakeholders to ensure that the revision
incorporates lessons from past disasters and addresses multi-sectoral issues. The review is expected to
expand the role of TNI in disaster management and to clarify its role in HADR.
54 INDONESIA
2020
BNPB is the primary body responsible for coordinating preparedness, response, prevention and mitigation, and
rehabilitation and recovery, as mandated in Law Number 24 of 2007 Concerning Disaster Management.
Technical Unit
INDONESIA 55
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
BNPB OVERVIEW
Established by: Law of the Republic of Indonesia, Authority: BNPB is the key coordinating body in disaster
Number 24 of 2007 Concerning Disaster Management; response. It is responsible for preparing for, directing
Presidential Regulation Number 8 of 2008 Concerning and managing all aspects of disaster management
the Disaster Management Agency. efforts. BNPB also controls the mobilization and use
of equipment in disaster response that may come
Key functions: Provides guidelines and directions on from outside Indonesia.6 The Head of BNPB is directly
disaster management and emergency response; leads accountable to the President. BNPB can draw on human
on disaster management including preparedness and resources, equipment, and logistics from relevant
response. portfolio agencies, TNI and POLRI.
Deputies:
Emergency operations center (EOC): EOCs are
• System and Strategy established at the national, provincial and district
• Prevention and Preparedness levels to monitor potential disasters and provide data
• Emergency Response and information during disasters to BNPB and other
• Rehabilitation and Reconstruction government agencies.
• Logistics and Equipment.
56 INDONESIA
2020
INDONESIA 57
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
BNPB
Function: Supports BNPB in disaster response. MoSA also manages TAGANA, a volunteer group that
The Ministry of Social Affairs (MoSA) has central consists of around 40,000 individuals across the country.
warehouses where relief supplies, such as preserved TAGANA assists with command posts, rapid response,
food and tents, are kept in case of emergency. When rescue, logistics, and humanitarian services.
there is an emergency, the MoSA establishes temporary
distribution points for areas affected by the disaster. Provincial representation: The MoSA is represented
at provincial and district levels of government.
MINISTRY OF HEALTH
BNPB
Function: Provides health and medical services in the Provincial representation: The MoH is represented
aftermath of a disaster. The Ministry of Health (MoH) at provincial and district levels of government.
has strong response capacity and thus will often be
the first organization on the ground. It has a network of
nine regional crisis centers coordinated by a national
crisis center in Jakarta. The MoH and the World
Health Organization (WHO) have also established a
joint warehouse which has capacity to rapidly supply
materials to disaster zones.
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
Function: The Ministry of Defence (MoD) has a key role • Formulate key policies regarding the mobilization of
in coordinating international humanitarian and military TNI in disaster management
assistance. States providing international military • Establish organizational policies, infrastructure
assistance must obtain written approval from the MoD and budget support to respond to natural disasters,
and TNI in coordination with BNPB. Additional functions displacement and humanitarian assistance
include: • Stipulate policy regarding FMA in disaster response.
58 INDONESIA
2020
COORDINATION MECHANISMS
INCIDENT COMMAND SYSTEM
Indonesia uses the Incident Command System also SKPDB adaption of ICS: SKPDB is a coordination
known as Disaster Response Command System (SKPDB) system adapted from ICS to enable effective response
in disaster response. ICS is a standardized, on-scene, to incidents of any size from all levels of government. It
all-hazard incident incident management concept that operationalizes the ICS through 4 core components:
facilitates inter-operability between disaster response
• Emergency response command post: Coordinates,
personnel and other agencies in different jurisdictions.
controls, monitors and evaluates emergency actions
in a disaster. This is the center of command activity.
Operational guidelines: BNPB Regulation No. 10 / 2008,
• Emergency response field post: Operational-level
No. 14 / 2010 and No. 03 / 2016.
action center. Field posts may be located at the heart
Leadership: An incident commander (generally from of the emergency, adjacent to the disaster event,
TNI) is appointed by the head of the district/municipality and/or on site at locations for displaced persons.
or the relevant BPBD as the on-site coordinator and • Emergency response facilitation post: Activated
reports to the head of local government. As the on-site when needed. Coordinates mobilisation of assistance
coordinator, the incident commander has authority at national, regional, or provincial level. Additional
to deploy all available resources and is responsible facilitation posts can be activated as needed. This is
for overseeing the mobilization of human resources, an administrative action team.
equipment, logistics, and rescue operations. The • Emergency response support post: Activated
incident commander also prepares a disaster plan to be when needed. Provides smooth and easy transition
used for the response. of supplies from outside the affected area to the
locations where resources are needed. Additional
The area commander supports the Incident Command support posts may be activated as needed. This is a
Posts in coordinating resources that cannot be managed national-level operational support activity. Support
by the district/municipality, and consolidates and shares posts are most often located at transportation
situation analyses from affected districts/municipalities. hubs, such as airports, to assist with distribution of
domestic and international aid.
Activation: By the President, Governor Regent or Mayor
based on the recommendation of the Head of BNPB or
BPBD at the provincial or district/municipal levels. The
ICS is implemented during the emergency response KEY FUNCTIONS:
phase.
INDONESIA 59
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Incident Commander
Liaison of agencies /
Secretariat
institutions / organizations
Multi-National
JOCCA &
Coordination
OSOCC
Center
PROVINCIAL
Area Command
Incident Command
at affected area
60 INDONESIA
2020
Established by: BNPB Cluster System Decree No. 173 / in a multi-sector response with broad participation of
2014. international humanitarian actors. Some BPBDs have
adapted the cluster approach for small and medium-
Operational guidelines: Guidelines have been developed sized responses.
for the Displacement and Protection, and Health
clusters. Role of military: The major role of TNI in the cluster
system is to provide support for the logistics and
Functions: The cluster approach aims to improve equipment, and search and rescue clusters.
coordination of emergency response among actors from
both government and non-government institutions. Role of police: POLRI is the co-lead of the displacement
The cluster approach is implemented in a large-scale and protection cluster.
disaster or in case the government needs assistance
Inter-cluster coordination: BNPB.
UNICEF /
Ministry of Education (MoE) Education
Save the Children
Ministry of Agriculture
FAO / WFP Food Security and Agriculture
(MoA)
FAO Food and Agriculture Organization UNHCR United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees
IFRC International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies UNFPA United Nations Population Fund
IOM International Organization for Migration UNICEF United Nations Children’s Fund
OCHA UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs WFP World Food Programme
UNDP United Nations Development Programme WHO World Health Organization
INDONESIA 61
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Operational Guidelines: Head of BNPB regulation The MAC Center is a national coordination mechanism for
Number 15 of 2012 regarding Disaster Management EOC disaster response. It is composed of BNPB, the MNCC,
Guideline. the National Forwarding Post (Pospenas), the On-Site
Operations Coordination Centre (OSOCC, when activated),
EOCs, led by BPBDs, are the coordination hubs in disaster cluster lead agencies and the AHA Center, through the
response for multiagency command and coordination, Joint Operations and Coordination Center (JOCCA).
decision-making and information management at the
provincial level. In large-scale emergencies, the MAC Center will be
established at the disaster area. The MAC Center
EOCs have been established in several provinces facilitates provision of support to the local incident
and are linked via a national disaster management command post through the area command post. The MAC
information system. EOCs monitor disaster impacts, and mechanism may also include a Joint Information Center
provide information to the incident commander at the and several smaller working groups.
district/municipality level and area commander at the
provincial level.
Multi-Agency
President Coordination (MAC)
Center
TNI
Multi-
BNPB / National
Cluster leads Coordination
National Ministries BNPB Center
Level Indonesian
Red Cross
National (PMI), UN
JOCCA / agencies,
Forwarding
OSOCC private
Post
sector and
NGOs
Logistics Planning
62 INDONESIA
2020
Humanitarian assistance from international responders To facilitate the entry of international assistance, BNPB –
may be accepted in the following circumstances: in cooperation with the relevant government at the national
• The magnitude of the disaster exceeds the GoI’s ability and local levels of the province or district/city – will:
to respond • Determine the military bases, airports and/or seaports
• Issuance of a statement from the GoI that it will accept that will serve as the entry points for international
offers of assistance from international responders in assistance
line with the needs of the affected population. • Establish the supporting post at each identified
military base, airport and seaport.10
The process for the entry of international assistance is
based on:
The OSOCC is a civilian coordination mechanism for
• Rapid assessments completed by BNPB and/or BPBD,
international humanitarian assistance that may be
and formally approved by BNPB
activated at the request of BNPB, led by UN OCHA
• An initiation letter from BNPB granting access to the
and often co-located with Incident Command Field
requesting organization.
Posts. OSOCC is used as a link between international
responders and GoI.
International assistance will be coordinated by the AHA The purpose of JOCCA is to coordinate the Indonesian
Centre and UN OCHA, prioritising assistance provided contribution to the response with that of ASEAN Member
by ASEAN Member States. The AJDRP outlines the States and other international responders. The United
requirement for a coordination platform for ASEAN Nations Disaster Assessment and Coordination (UNDAC)
Member States to be established in disaster response. team will also establish an OSOCC. JOCCA and OSOCC will
be co-located and share functions between them. They will
In response to a disaster in Indonesia, an ASEAN ERAT will work under the coordination of the MAC Center together
establish the JOCCA at the disaster-affected area with MNCC and the National Forwarding Post.
OCHA AHA
Centre
ASEAN
UNDAC OSOCC JOCCA ERAT
TEAMS
MAC Center
OCHA Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs AHA Centre ASEAN Humanitarian Assistance Centre
UNDAC United Nations Disaster Assessment and Coordination ASEAN ERAT ASEAN Emergency Response and Assessment Team
OSOCC On Site-Operations Coordination Centre MAC Center Multi-Agency Coordination Center
JOCCA Joint Operations and Coordination Centre of ASEAN
INDONESIA 63
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Following a request for and/or acceptance of international Disaster Management (MPBI), the National Platform
assistance by the GoI, coordination between the for DRR (Planas PRB), and the Red Cross/Red Crescent
Humanitarian Country Team (HCT), the Humanitarian/ Movement as an observer. The HCT serves as a forum
Resident Coordinator and the national response systems to monitor emergency response and provide strategic
and bodies, including BNPB, is initiated. direction for humanitarian operations. The HCT is the
embodiment of the global humanitarian coordination
The Indonesian HCT is led by the Resident Coordinator architecture in-country. The team helps ensure effective
and consists of UN agencies, international organizations strategic coordination with GoI, and provides guidance to
and national NGO consortia including the Indonesia cluster leads in ensuring effective operational coordination
Humanitarian Forum (HFI), the Indonesian Society for with respective government partners.
UNDP United Nations Development Programme IFRC International Federation of the Red Cross
UNICEF United Nations Children’s Fund WHO World Health Organization
UNFPA United Nations Population Fund WFP World Food Programme
64 INDONESIA
2020
11 Presidential Regulation (PERPRES) No. 10/2010 on organisational structure of Indonesian Armed Forces, Article 44.
INDONESIA 65
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
TNI is a primary responder in disasters in Indonesia and has been deployed consistently in recent years.
Lead search and rescue Lead the Incident 1. Integrate military 1. Lead the TNI SATGAS
efforts and coordination Command System. response operations PRCRB Unit.
with other agencies. with other agencies.
2. Assist BNPB, BPBD
2. Assist in the and other agencies in
coordination of delivery of response
foreign military services.
forces.
Disaster Prevention and Mitigation, Preparedness and Readiness, Response, Rehabilitation and Recovery
66 INDONESIA
2020
IFRC/RC
Operational guidelines: Law of the Republic of Indonesia The Kogasgabpad was established by the Chief of the
Number 34 of 2004 Concerning the National Armed Armed Forces to mobilize the strength and capability of
Forces; President Instruction Number 5 of 2018. the TNI to carry out its duties in MOOTW. It is an ad-hoc
task force which was first implemented during the Lombok
earthquake and continued during the Central Sulawesi
earthquake and tsunami.
INDONESIA 67
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
FUNCTIONS
an avenue to facilitate information-sharing and ensure the
Supports priority setting on needs and
efficient use of resources.
assistance for the affected area.
Multi-National
JOCCA / OSOCC Coordination
Center
68 INDONESIA
2020
Jakarta
A magnitude 7.0 earthquake occurred on 5 August 2018, 387 TNI soldiers were deployed to support the emergency
located in West Nusa Tenggara Province, Indonesia, response operations. Three naval ships (KRI dr
following a magnitude 6.4 earthquake on 29 July 2018. This Soeharso-990, KRI Karel Satsuit Tubun-356, and KRI
was the strongest and deadliest earthquake recorded in Kakap-811) were deployed, as well as two C130 Hercules
Lombok in recent history. from the Indonesian Air Force. All military assets were
coordinated by the Kogasgabpad and BPBD through the
BNPB and BPBD coordinated the humanitarian response incident command post. The GoI did not request any
in Lombok in the emergency phase. Incident command international assistance and supported a completely
post(s) were established by BPBDs on site. BNPB also nationally led response.
established the Pospenas in Supersemar Field, Tanjung
District, adjacent to the North Lombok Regent office.
LESSONS LEARNED
12 HCT Indonesia, Lessons Learned from Lombok and Sumbawa Earthquake Response, 2018.
INDONESIA 69
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Palu Jakarta
Sulawesi
17
International
aircraft operating
in-country
1 x Airbus A400M Atlas 1 x Lockheed C-130 Hercules
The Indonesian Military Forces (TNI) are
coordinating all foreign military assets
through bilateral meetings with countries
that have been cleared to assist by the REPUBLIC OF KOREA
Government. The TNI has appointed a
dedicated Commander Officer for the
1 x Antonov An-12
3 x Lockheed C-130 Hercules
overall coordination of Foreign Military
3 x Lockheed C-130 Hercules
Assets (FMAs) in Balikpapan, the
designated Operations Hub for the Relief
SINGAPORE
Operation.
1 x Ilyushin Il-76 MALAYSIA
Civil-Military meetings have taken place
in Jakarta between the defence attachés and
the humanitarian community to facilitate 2 x Lockheed C-130 Hercules
the interface between humanitarian FRANCE
and military actors. A Civil-Military
coordination structure will be set up in NEW ZEALAND
Balikpapan to ensure efficient coordination.
2 x Lockheed C-130 Hercules
INDONESIA*
1 x Airbus A400M Atlas 2 x Lockheed C-130 Hercules
CHINA
1 x Lockheed C-130 Hercules
JAPAN
PHILIPPINES
1 x Airbus A400M Atlas
1 x B747
SWITZERLAND
1 x Lockheed C-130 Hercules
1 x Lockheed C-130 Hercules 1 x Eurocopter Malaysia
70 INDONESIA
2020
The 7.5 magnitude earthquake and subsequent tsunami An incident command post was established in Palu City
struck the island of Sulawesi on 28 September 2018, and the Chief of TNI quickly established Kogasgabpad to
approximately 78 kilometres north of Palu. The earthquake coordinate the Army, Navy and Airforce. At the field level in
triggered a three-meter-high tsunami that struck the coast Palu, BNPB’s Pospenas led the response and coordination,
of western Central Sulawesi. The earthquake, tsunami and with support from TNI and all the relevant line ministries,
resulting liquefaction and landslides caused significant including local NGOs. Regular coordination meetings were
damage and loss of life. conducted daily with relevant stakeholders. Additionally,
under guidance from BNPB and MoFA, the ASEAN ERAT
In the wake of the disaster, local responders initiated set up the JOCCA, which was co-located with Pospenas in
rescue efforts for trapped civilians and provided immediate Palu.
assistance to survivors. Search, rescue and retrieval
efforts were conducted by hundreds of villagers, PMI, the TNI coordinated all FMAs through bilateral meetings with
National Search and Rescue Agency (BASARNAS), TNI and those countries approved by the GoI. A dedicated command
local government agencies. officer was appointed for the overall coordination of FMAs
in Balikpapan, the designated operations hub for the
Despite the GoI not directly requesting international relief operation. CMCoord meetings also took place in
assistance, it was allowed to a limited extent. It was Jakarta between defense attachés and the humanitarian
provided through defined channels (focusing primarily on community to coordinate humanitarian and military actors.
Sulawesi), Furthermore, BNPB and the BPBD coordinated A CMCoord structure was established in Balikpapan to
responses to the earthquake and tsunami under the overall streamline regional efforts.14
leadership of the Coordinating Minister for Political and
After a month, Kogasgabpad was dissolved and the
Security Affairs. 13
coordination role was continued by the Provincial
Government of Central Sulawesi, with the support of
Pospenas. Operational coordination was managed through
the national cluster approach, with civil-military issues
mainly addressed through the National Logistics Cluster.
Indonesian national and local NGOs were active participants in government-led clusters and were vital
supporters during both the Lombok and Central Sulawesi disaster response, providing coordination and
immediate frontline assistance, while UN agencies and international NGOs maintained a lower-profile supporting
role. Government ministries led all clusters and BNPB relied heavily upon the AHA Centre in coordination
efforts, which assumed many of the traditional roles of UN OCHA. OCHA still retained its core coordination
mandate but was forced to adapt to a locally and regionally led response.
13 HCT Indonesia, Central Sulawesi Earthquake Response Plan (Oct 2018 – Dec 2018).
14 OCHA, Central Sulawesi Earthquake: International Deployed Assets (as of 07 October 2018).
INDONESIA 71
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
BPBDs Badan Penanggulangan Bencana Daerah [Provincial and District Disaster Management Agency]
72 INDONESIA
2020
SATGAS PRCPB Satuan Tugas Pasukan Reaksi Cepat Penanggulangan Bencana [Disaster Relief Rapid Reaction Force Task Unit]
SKPDB Sistem Komando Penanganan Darurat Bencana [Disaster Response Command System]
UN United Nations
INDONESIA 73
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
REFERENCES
Advanced Training Program on Humanitarian Action. Evaluating Military Engagement in Disaster Response. Reliefweb.
2016.
AHA Centre situation updates on M 7.4 Earthquake & Tsunami Sulawesi, Indonesia. October 2018.
ASEAN. Standard Operating Procedure for Regional Standby Arrangements and Coordination of Joint Disaster Relief and
Emergency Response Operations (SASOP). Version 2.0 April 2018.
BNPB. Blue Print of Satuan Reaksi Cepat Penanggulangan Bencana (SRC PB). Draft As of 1 December 2009.
BNPB and the New Zealand government. Indonesia National Disaster Response Framework. March 2018.
Center for Excellence in Disaster Management and Humanitarian Assistance. Indonesia Disaster Management Reference
Handbook. June 2018.
Dave Hodgkin, Humanitarian Benchmark Consulting. Emergency Response Preparedness in Indonesia. A consultation
report prepared exclusively for the Indonesia Humanitarian Country Team. November 2016.
Evan A. Laksmana. The Indonesian Defence Forces and Disaster Relief Potential Pitfalls and Challenges. 29 November
2010.
Farid Makruf and Tanty S Reinhart Thamrin. Working Paper: Polici Review on Military Operation Other Than War on
Tentara Nasional Indonesia’s Disaster Management. November 2018.
HCT Indonesia, Central Sulawesi Earthquake Response Plan (Oct 2018 – Dec 2018).
HCT Indonesia. Lessons Learned from Lombok and Sumbawa Earthquake Response. 2018.
Head of BNPB regulation Number 173 of 2014 on Disaster Management National Cluster
Humanitarian Advisory Group and Pujiono Center. Charting The New Norm: Local leadership in the first 100 days of the
Sulawesi Earthquake Response. March 2019.
Implementation of PRC PB of the Indonesian National Army in providing assistance to the Local Government in Response
to Natural Disasters.
Indonesian National Army Headquarter. Disaster Management Guideline Number Perkasad/96/XI/2009 dated 30
November 2009.
Indonesian Armed Forces Headquarter. Chief of Indonesian Armed Forces Number: Perpang/35/XI/2007 on Guidelines of
the Rapid Response Task Force of the Indonesian National Army (PRC-PB TNI).
Lt. Col. Erwin S. Aldedharma, Indonesian Navy. The Role of Defense Force in Humanitarian Assistance & Disaster Relief.
Memorandum of Understanding between Badan Nasional Penanggulangan Bencana and Tentara Nasional Indonesia.
Number: MoU 47/BNPB/III/2016. Number: Kerma/6/III/2016 on Cooperation on Disaster Management.
74 INDONESIA
2020
Minister of Defense regulation Number 09 of 2011 on Principles of Implementing The Assistance of Indonesian National
Army in Overcoming Natural Disasters, Displacement and on the provision of Humanitarian Assistance.
Minister of Defense regulation Number 35 of 2011 on the Assistance of Indonesian National Army to the Local Government.
Presidential Decree Number 28 of 2018 on Disaster Management Task Force in West Nusa Tenggara province, Central
Sulawesi province and other affected areas.
Presidential Decree Number 5 of 2018 on the acceleration of post disaster rehabilitation and reconstruction of the
earthquake in West Lombok, North Lombok, Central Lombok, East Lombok, Mataram City and other affected areas in
West Nusa Tenggara Province.
Presidential Decree Number 10 of 2010 regarding Tentara Nasional Indonesia’s Organisational Structure.
Pujiono Center. Localisation in Central Sulawesi Humanitarian Response: These snapshots could change the way you
think!. 2019.
Regional Consultative Group Third Session: Humanitarian Civil-Military Coordination for Asia and the Pacific Summary
Report. 2018.
INDONESIA 75
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
76
MYANMAR
HUMANITARIAN CIVIL-MILITARY
COORDINATION IN EMERGENCIES
Soldiers remove trees from a street in Yangon, Myanmar, 5 May 2008 after Cyclone Nargis devastated Myanmar.
Photo: dpa picture alliance archive / Alamy Stock Photo
77
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Civil-military coordination (CMCoord) in Myanmar has • Cyclone Nargis causes significant destruction.
2008
been shaped by a history of military rule, limited foreign Tatmadaw have a key role in the disaster
engagement, devastating natural disasters and ongoing relief. Bilateral support accepted through the
internal conflicts. The Myanmar Armed Forces (Tatmadaw) Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN).
is one of the primary responders in disaster response in • Standing Order on Natural Disaster Management
to develop a contact list for civil and military actors Plan (ERPP) agreed by humanitarian
currently engaging in natural disaster responses in organizations.
Myanmar. The CM TWG has since been formed, with • Myanmar National Earthquake Preparedness
both civil and military focal points appointed. and Response Plan (EPRP) established.
• Yangon Region EPRP established.
• CM TWG formed.
78 MYANMAR
2020
KEY FACTS
Official name: The Republic of the Union
of Myanmar
I ND IA
Salween
Area: 676,577 km2 Myitkyina
Population: 54,701,719 (2020)
BANGLADESH C H IN A
y
add
Hakha
Irraw
Capital: Naypyitaw
Mandalay
Official language: Myanmar Sagaing V I ET
Disaster focal point: Department of Disaster Magway NA M
Management (DDM), MoSWRR (normal times); Kyaukphyu
LAO
NDMC (disaster response) Bay of
Port
Naypyitaw Loikaw PDR
Military: Tatmadaw Bengal
Yangon
Police: Myanmar Police Force (MPF) Pa-an
Mawlamyine
Thilawa
Port TH A ILA N D
GENERAL INFORMATION
Dawei C A MB ODIA
Myanmar is one of the world’s most disaster-prone Andaman Gulf of
countries. It is highly exposed to natural disasters such Sea Thailand
as flooding, drought, earthquakes and cyclones, and is
affected by ongoing conflict and high levels of population
displacement. Poverty and poor infrastucture compound
Myanmar’s vulnerability to natural hazards. Major airports Major seaports 150 km
139,944 Fatalities
Flood
x33
Storm
Landslide
x12 Earthquake
x10 Epidemic Wildfire
x6
x3 x2
Source: Emergency Events Database (EM-DAT), Center for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters, 2020
MYANMAR 79
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Salween
22 October 2010 | Category 4
>1.6 million
y
add
260,049
Irraw
149
45 Mandalay
US$119 million
US$57 million Shan
Naypyitaw region
Kyaukphyu
Bay of
Bengal Yangon
150 km
80 MYANMAR
2020
Emergency Response
Preparedness Plan
2019
The central role of the military is well articulated in National Disaster Management Rules (2015). The
Myanmar’s disaster-related laws and policies. The National Disaster Management Rules define the
Constitution of the Republic of the Union of Myanmar provisions of the Law, including the functions and
states that ‘the Defence Services shall render duties of government ministries, departments, and
assistance when calamities that affect the Union and agencies; the preparation of disaster management
plans at national and sub-national levels; pre-
its citizens occur in the Union’. For the most part,
disaster preparedness, prevention, and risk
disaster-related laws and policies apply to natural
reduction measures; emergency response activities;
disasters only, not to the persistent sub-national post-disaster rehabilitation and reconstruction;
conflicts in Myanmar. collaboration with international actors; and prescribes
the allocations of the National Disaster Management
Fund, as established by the Disaster Management Law
Disaster Management Law (2013). The National 2013.
Disaster Management Law is the principal law guiding
disaster management in Myanmar. With the support Myanmar Action Plan on Disaster Risk Reduction
of the United Nations Office for the Coordination (2017). The MAPDRR provides a framework for multi-
of Humanitarian Affairs (UNOCHA), the law was stakeholder engagement in disaster risk reduction.
developed to comply with the ASEAN Agreement on It was established in 2012 and updated in 2017 to
Disaster Management and Emergency Response shift the focus of Myanmar’s risk reduction, from a
(AADMER). The law provides for the establishment focus on relief and response to one of preparedness
of disaster management committees, including the and prevention. The action plan sets prioritised
NDMC, the lead committee for disaster management in interventions until 2020 and overall targets through to
Myanmar, and disaster management bodies at all sub- 2030 in three five-year phases. The MAPDRR has an
national and lower levels. Provisions of the Law also increased international focus from its predecessor,
relate to requesting assistance from the Tatmadaw for with a focus on guiding the implementation of both
search and rescue operations, security in disaster- global and regional frameworks, action plans,
affected areas, and for the general delivery of and agreements, including the 2015 Sustainable
assistance to victims. It also provides for cooperation Development Goals (SDGs) and the Paris Agreement on
and liaison with foreign countries and other regional Climate Change.
and international actors when assistance is required to
expedite a response.
MYANMAR 81
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Emergency Response Preparedness Plan (2019). The through coordination among relevant departments and
ERPP establishes predefined roles, responsibilities organisations to reduce the impacts of earthquakes.
and coordination mechanisms for disaster response. It The EPRP is divided into two parts: preparedness
was developed by the UN Humanitarian Country Team measures of government departments and
(HCT) in Myanmar in collaboration with the government communities, and response functions by the NDMC and
to promote effective assistance of impacted its Work Committees.
communities through coordination and communication
between HCT members in preparedness and response. Myanmar National Framework for Community
The overall goal of the ERPP is to mitigate the impacts Disaster Resilience (2017). The Framework for
of disasters and limit fatalities, and it is regularly Community Disaster Resilience is a core document
updated to ensure the Government’s preparation and in promoting the integration of community-based
response procedures are most effective. disaster risk management efforts into broader
sectoral development planning processes, which is
Myanmar National Earthquake Preparedness and otherwise absent from key policies.2 The objectives of
Response Plan (2019). The Myanmar National EPRP the framework are to promote common understanding
was developed in response to significant earthquakes of community disaster resilience, propose
in recent years, as well as forecasts suggesting a coherent approaches, and identify opportunities for
greater likelihood of earthquakes than other natural implementation across various sectors and themes of
disasters in the future. The Plan aims to strengthen development.
the preparedness measures and response functions
The NDMC is the highest decision-making body for disaster management in Myanmar.
Established by: Decree No. 30/2016 of the Cabinet of the Work Committees: 12 Work Committees support NDMC
Republic of the Union of Myanmar on 31 May 2016. through the implementation and coordination of disaster
management activities.
Location within government: NDMC is a separate
Functions of Work Committees:
committee under the Vice-President II. It is not situated
• Formulation of plans for four identified phases:
within a government ministry or department.
mitigation and prevention, preparedness, response
Leadership: Chaired by the Vice-President II and vice- and reconstruction and rehabilitation
chaired by the Minister of Home Affairs and the Minister • Implementation of activities outlined in relevant
of Social Welfare, Relief and Resettlement. guidelines
• Management of disaster response operations
Secretary: Permanent Secretary, MoSWRR. • Management of international assistance in disaster
response
Composition: 28 members including state and region • Education for disaster preparedness
representatives and the Ministers of Home Affairs; • Regulation of reporting to NDMC
Foreign Affairs; Information; Rail Transportation; • Establishment of an early warning system
Energy; Health; National Planning and Construction; • Supervision of the functioning of sub-committees
Education; Communications; Post and Telegraphs; and facilitation of their coordination.
Transport; Commerce; Border Areas; National Races;
Military representation: Minister of Defence, Chief of
Development Affairs and Social Welfare, Relief and
Staff (Army, Navy, Air Force).
Resettlement.
Regional/State representation: Chief Ministers (all
states and regions).
2 Community Based Disaster Risk Management Program (condensed) 2016, 4.
82 MYANMAR
2020
Advisor Group
KEY FUNCTIONS
MYANMAR 83
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
STATE/REGION
Disaster
Management
Body
DISTRICT
Disaster
Management
Body
TOWNSHIP
Disaster
Management
Body
WARD/
VILLAGE TRACT
Disaster
Management
Body
3 Hamish Nixon et al., State and Region Government in Myanmar, The Asia Foundation, 2013.
4 MIMU, (GAD data from 2017) 13,265 village tracts + 3,266 wards; http://themimu.info/mimu-township-profiles-dashboard
84 MYANMAR
2020
Function: The DDM (formerly the Relief and standards and is the National Disaster Management
Resettlement Department) is the central government Organization (Focal Point) to the AHA Centre.
department for disaster management. The DDM was
formed to support the NDMC to provide victims of Sub-national representation: DDM is represented
natural disasters with relief, and implement preliminary at the state and regional levels and at some
measures to minimise loss of lives and property. It districts. According to the DDM expansion
is responsible for conducting Disaster Management plan, all districts and some key townships will
activities in accordance with international norms and have DDM offices in the coming 3–5 years.
Function: With the guidance of the NDMC, DMBs have Sub-national representation: GAD is represented
been formed at all sub-national levels, with GAD at all sub-national levels (state/region, district,
representatives acting as either chair or secretary. township, and ward/village tract). GAD is responsible
GAD is a key department in disaster management and for coordinating disaster response and preparedness
response at all sub-national levels of administration. communications, as well as identifying the location of
GAD has also implemented an early warning system relief camps, arranging disaster management training,
project with DDM, Department of Meteorology and and disseminating early warning information at all sub-
Hydrology (DMH), and JICA. Prior to 2018, GAD sat with national levels.
the Ministry of Home Affairs (MoHA).
Function: The DMH generates weather forecasts the National Multi-Hazards Early Warning Centre
and early warnings for cyclones, storm surges and in 2006, which is operational at all times.5
floods. DMH cooperates with the Tatmadaw and other
ministries to communicate information/warnings, and Sub-national representation: DMH has offices in all
has a strong relationship with DDM. DMH established states and regions, as well as some key districts and
townships based on priority locations for weather and
seismic hazards.
Function: Communication with Myanmar embassies, MoFA coordinates incoming international humanitarian
consulates, foreign embassies, ASEAN, United Nations assistance from non-ASEAN member states.
and international relief organisations. The Ministry of
Foreign Affairs (MoFA) has designated responsibilities
during normal times, pre- and post-disaster, and during
rehabilitation.
5 Ignatio Aguirre-Ayerbe et al. 2020, “An evaluation of availability and adequacy of Multi-Hazard Early Warning Systems in Asian countries: A baseline study”,
International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction (49), p. 5.
MYANMAR 85
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
COORDINATION MECHANISMS
CLUSTER SYSTEM
The Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC) cluster approach is operational in Myanmar, with cluster or sectoral
coordination arrangements in place to support ongoing response in several parts of the country, primarily linked to
conflict-related displacement. The ERPP that has been developed under the Humanitarian Country Team provides for
the possible establishment of additional clusters in the event of a large scale natural disaster. Current coordination
arrangements are summarized below.
WHO Health
UNHCR
Protection
• UNICEF
• Child Protection (Sub-Sector)
• UNFPA
• Sexual and Gender-Based Violence (Sub-Sector)
UNICEF Nutrition
FAO Food and Agriculture Organization UNICEF United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund
OCHA Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs WASH Water, Sanitation and Hygiene
UNFPA United Nations Population Fund WFP World Food Program
UNHCR United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees WHO World Health Organization
86 MYANMAR
2020
The Emergency Operations Centre (EOC) plays a central Composition: Representatives of relevant sub-
role in linking the humanitarian system with the various committees, military representatives, development
government departments at the national level. The EOC partners, ASEAN Emergency Response and Assessment
enables information-sharing between Myanmar and the Team, AHA Centre, HCT-OCHA liaison, cluster leads and
ASEAN Coordinating Centre for Humanitarian Assistance other international teams.
on disaster management (AHA Centre), supports decision-
making, and enables the efficient response of national Activation: First activated in 2015 in response to
organisations during disasters.6 It also has monitoring nationwide flooding.
capabilities and generates specific impact predictions that Key functions:
contribute to early-warning advice. In 2018–19, institutional
• Establish command and control for the disaster
strengthening was conducted through workshops and SOP
response
development. DDM has a plan to establish sub-national • Support operational coordination during the
EOCs in the future. response
• Facilitate international and national coordination
Established by: MAPDRR, in 2013. • Serve as the central point for communication
• Facilitate information collection, analysis and
Leadership: DDM, MoSWRR. dissemination
• Logistics support and resource tracking
• Fast-track visas for international actors.
6 Akiyuki Kawasaki et al. 2017, “Disaster response and river infrastructure management during the 2015 Myanmar floods: A case in the Bago River Basin”, International
Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction (24), p. 154.
MYANMAR 87
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Humanitarian
United Nations
Country Team
Country Team
(UNCT) (HCT)
Chair: RC Chair: HC
Rakhine
Coordination
Group (RCG)
Chair: RCO
Rakhine
Inter Cluster Inter Cluster
Kachin GCM Shan GCM
Coordination Group Coordination Group Kachin Area HCT
(ICCG) - Central (ICCG) (Myitkyina/ (Lashio/Namkham)
National MIAG - Chair: OCHA
Rakhine Bhamo)
Northern Rakhine Chair: OCHA Chair: OCHA
Chair: OCHA Chair: OCHA
Chair: UNHCR/RCO
Education in Education in
Education in Education in
Emergencies: Emergencies:
Emergencies: Emergencies:
Maungdaw UNICEF/Save UNICEF/Save
UNICEF NRC
Interagency the Children the Children
Group (MIAG)
- Northern
Rakhine Food Security: Food Security: Food Security: Food Security:
Chair: UNHCR/ WFP/FAO WFP/FAO WFP WFP
RCO
Health: WHO/
Health: WHO Health: WHO Health: WHO
DoH
88 MYANMAR
2020
Dept of Disaster
Management
(DDM)
National Disaster Humanitarian Country Team
Management Committee (HCT)
(NDMC) Emergency Union
Operations level
Center (EOC)
Inter Cluster
Coordination
12 WORKING COMMITTEES Group (ICCG)
12 WORKING COMMITTEES
Different state level coordiation mechanisms exist in Rakhine, Kachin and Northern Shan States. The DDM, under the state
Ministry of Social Affairs, remains the point of contact for state-level coordination of humanitarian assistance.
KACHIN
Area Humanitarian Country Team
NORTHERN SHAN
General Coordination Meeting (GCM)
Cluster/Sector Groups
MYANMAR 89
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
22,000 23,000
personnel personnel
NAVY AIR
FORCE
7 Thet Naing Zaw & Seunghoo Lim 2017, “The military’s role in disaster management and response during the 2015 Myanmar floods: A social network approach”,
International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 25, p. 3.
8 TN Zaw & S Lim 2017, p. 3.
9 Estimates vary widely, ranging from approximately 350,000 to over 400,000 total active troops. CIA World Factbook estimates: 300–375,000 Army; 15–22,000 Navy;
15–23,000 Air Force (2019). https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/resources/the-world-factbook/geos/bm.html
90 MYANMAR
2020
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
Function: The MoD is responsible for the administration Sub-national representation: The MoD is represented
of the Tatmadaw and assumes a key role in all four at the state and regional level by the State or Regional
stages of disaster management.10 The Union Minister for Minister of Security Affairs, who acts as a point of liaison
Defence is a member of the NDMC, and additional focal for CMCoord at the sub-national level. Other MoD sub-
points are responsible for establishing communications national representation is organized under military
between the NDMC and MoD. The MoD is uniquely command structures rather than regular administrative
constituted, with the Army, Navy and Air Force divisions.
Headquarters co-located within the Ministry.
Function: The Union Minister for Home Affairs is the Sub-national representation: The MPF is represented
Vice-Chair of the NDMC, alongside the Union Minister at state/region, district and township level, and has
for Social Welfare, Relief and Resettlement. The Union some outposts at the village/ward level.
Minister for Home Affairs also chairs the NDMC Work
Committees for Search & Rescue, and Security. The
MPF of approximately 93,000 personnel is administered
by MoHA, and is responsible for security, perimeter
control and transport in disaster responses. The
Department of Fire Services also sits under this Ministry
and is responsible for search and rescue operations.
10 Thet Naing Zaw & Seunghoo Lim 2017, “The military’s role in disaster management and response during the 2015 Myanmar floods: A social network approach”,
International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 25, p 2.
MYANMAR 91
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
NORMAL TIMES ALERT AND WARNING DISASTER RESPONSE RELIEF & REHABILITATION
• Designate disaster • Prepare an action plan for • Assign relief and • Conduct field assessments
communication focal point surface and air transport rehabilitation duties of relief and rehabilitation
and ensure cooperation for evacuation and assist to Military Command needs, set up field
with NDMC focal point. with evacuations. Headquarters. hospitals, if required.
• Form natural disaster • Navy, Air Force and • Communicate information • Assist disaster victims
protection committees at Division Command through the Office of with the construction of
Army, Navy and Air Force Headquarters prepare the Commander-in- temporary shelters.
Headquarters. a disaster calendar and Chief, Military Command
• Assist in setting up relief
hazard and risk maps. Headquarters and local
• Coordinate with Tatmadaw camps and providing
authorities.
on early warning, • Information dissemination immediate access to
evacuation and relief, including sharing DMH • Inspect the formation and shelter, food, water,
forming coordination news with Armed Forces, activities of committees in clothing.
teams. issuing hourly updates on headquarters.
• Assist with removing
warnings to military units.
• Prepare evacuation plans • Monitor the situation and debris, recovering bodies,
and conduct regular drills • Set up 24-hour supervisory provide coordination for and rehabilitating the
and trainings for Tatmadaw centres at Division local authorities as needed. environment.
institutes. Command Headquarters.
• Assist local administration
to ensure access to clean
drinking water.
ARMED FORCES
NORMAL TIMES ALERT AND WARNING DISASTER RESPONSE RELIEF & REHABILITATION
• Training officers and • Issue disaster warnings to • Circulate information • Designate a liaison officer
personnel on natural affected commands, bases, from Division Command for coordination with
disaster management and units; issue orders to Headquarters to DMH. military units and other
and conduct drills for mobilise personnel. organizations.
• Coordinate and assist local
disaster preparedness and
• Supervise and form authorities by deploying • Provide medical services,
response.
working groups with search and rescue teams. sanitation, sewage and
• Coordinate with NDMC and representatives from waste disposal systems,
• Monitor the situation
DMH (army and navy). different units and and deliver supplies by
and submit regular work
designated directorates. aircraft where required.
• Collection of natural reports to Commanders-
disaster data (air force). • Set up communication in-Chief (Navy and Air • Coordinate with the
outposts and ensure Force). relevant ministry to
• Prepare a plan of action for
communications across remove debris.
protection against natural • Send relief teams to
departments.
disasters. disaster-affected areas in • Impact assessment
• Ready transport units and coordination with NDMC, documentation
• Evacuation, search and
aircraft, and deploy back- MoSWRR, MoD and MoHA. including surveys, aerial
rescue, and recovery and
up teams as required. photography and aerial
rehabilitation preparations
patrols.
in disaster-prone areas. • Evacuate the public.
92 MYANMAR
2020
MYANMAR 93
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Tedim Kyunhla
ACTIVATION OF THE EOC
Kalewa Thabeikkyin
Kale Kanbalu Momeik
BANGLADESH Mingin Ye U
Khin-U
Mogok
On August 4 2015, Myanmar
Hahka Kani Butalin
Singu Tangyan activated its national disaster
Hsipaw
Ayadaw Wetlet
Gangaw
Monywa management system through the
Myinmu Sagaing
CHIN EOC for the first time and called
SHAN for international humanitarian
Paletwa MANDALAY
Saw assistance with effective flood
Buthidaung Nyaung U
Maungdaw Kyauktaw response. Through the AHA Centre,
Yethedaung Myauk U
Ponnagyun Minbya Saytottara
Kalaw ASEAN member states deployed
SittwePauktaw Pwintbyu the ASEAN Emergency Response
Myebon
Ann
Magway
and Assessment Team (ASEAN
NAYPYITAW ERAT) and mobilised the Disaster
RAKHINE
MAGWAY Emergency Logistic System for
Kyaukpyu KAYAH
Number of people affected ASEAN (DELSA). The role of the EOC
per Township Toungup
BAGO was expanded from coordination to
Padaung
Less than 2,000 people Shwedaung
Kyaukkyi include emergency management,
2,000 - 10,000 people
Thandwe
Gyobingauk
Myanaung
TH AI L AN D response and logistics. The EOC
Hpapun
More than 10,000 people
Figures of the number of people affected Gwa
Ingapu
involved more than 90 individuals
Hinthada
come from the Relief and Resettlement
Department combined with other sources.
Bago
Kyaikto and 30 organisations and was
Hlegu Bilin
Hmawbi
Hlaingbwe activated for 67 days; for over half
Heavy rains have caused floods and landslides in AYEYARWADY Shwepyithar ThatonHpa-An
several parts of the country during the last two this time it ran a 24-hour response
weeks of July. Cyclone Komen, that made landfall
in Bangladesh on 30 July, has brought strong Myaungmya YANGON
KAYIN
and information service.
winds, heavy rains resulting in floods and MON
landslides in several states and regions in
Myanmar. The Tatmadaw’s role in the 2015
On 31 July, President U Thein Sein issued a flood response was significant,
statement proclaiming (1) Chin State, (2) Sagaing
Region, (3) Magway Region and (4) Rakhine State, with one study identifying military
as natural disaster zones.
The boundaries and names shown and the designations used on this map do not imply official endorsement or acceptance by the United Nations.
agencies as providing the most
Creation date: 3 Aug 2015 Glide number: FL-2015-000089-MMR Sources: RRD, MRCS, ACF, OCHA, Other Gov sources, MIMU Feedback: ochamyanmar@un.org, reliable information sources and
being the most active in information
sharing during the operation.11
In particular, regional military
commands were noted as most
widely engaged (due to their greater
94 MYANMAR
2020
1st Widespread landslide 3rd EOC activates emergency 4-19th AHA Centre In-Country
AUG
26 Aug-end Sep:
SEP
UNDAC deployed
The above infographic shows the chronological order of events from the immediate response to early recovery and a return to normal operations.
resource capacity than local governments) and therefore programs. Both civilian and military actors have since
the most highly responsive actors. While the Tatmadaw’s demonstrated real commitments to strengthening
ability to provide immediate response in the event of CMCoord, at both national and regional levels. National
disasters is recognised, the speed of their response can CMCoord workshops that began in 2016 have produced
limit the efficacy of CMCoord mechanisms. positive outcomes, including the establishment of the
CM TWG in 2019. Greater emphasis on CMCoord is also
Civil-military coordination and the overall disaster apparent in key policy documents such as the 2019 ERPP
response were complicated by several contextual and EPRPs, which provide for, amongst other outcomes:
challenges, including the country’s political transition,
• Establishing protocols for CMCoord
the changing humanitarian system post-Nargis, and
intercommunal tensions in Rakhine and Chin States. • Developing coordination mechanisms between all
During the flood response, cooperation and information- government departments and military commands
sharing between civilian and military actors was sub- • Establishing a formal information exchange
optimal. mechanism for civilian and military responders
• Military participation in regular simulation/
KEY LEARNINGS AND OUTCOMES FOR preparedness exercises organised by government
CIVIL-MILITARY COORDINATION departments
• Enabling access to heavy-duty military equipment in
Strengthening CMCoord was recognised as a key responses, and mobilising personnel in coordination
recommendation as a result of this experience,12 building with civilian agencies.
upon the introduction of HADR into Tatmadaw training
12 Col. Nay Myo Hlaing 2016, “National Civil-Military Coordination System in Myanmar” [presentation], 15th ASEAN Regional Forum Intersessional Meeting on Disaster
Relief, 25-26 February 2016, Naypyitaw.
MYANMAR 95
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
AHA Centre ASEAN Coordinating Centre for Humanitarian Assistance on disaster management
96 MYANMAR
2020
UN United Nations
MYANMAR 97
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
REFERENCES
Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) AHA Centre. Flash Update No 1: Flooding in Mandalay Region, Myanmar –
28 July 2020.
Aguirre-Ayerbe, Ignatio et al. “An evaluation of availability and adequacy of Multi-Hazard Early Warning Systems in Asian
countries: A baseline study”, International Journal of Disaster RIsk Reduction 49 (2020).
Cook, Alistair & Yogendran, Sangeetha 2020. “Conceptualising humanitarian civil-military partnerships in the Asia-Pacific:
(Re)-ordering cooperation”, Australian Journal of International Affairs 74(1).
Government of the Republic of the Union of Myanmar. Ministry of Labour, Immigration and Population, Department of
Population.
Government of the Republic of the Union of Myanmar. Natural Disaster Management Law (Pyidaungsu Hluttaw Law) No.
21, 2013.
Government of the Republic of the Union of Myanmar. Disaster Management Rules, Ministry of Social Welfare, Relief and
Resettlement Notification No. 22 / 2014.
Government of the Republic of the Union of Myanmar 2015. ‘Myanmar Post-Disaster Needs Assessment of Floods and
Landslides, July-September 2015’, (PDNA). November 2015.
Humanitarian Country Team, Republic of the Union of Myanmar. Inter-agency Emergency Response Preparedness (ERP)
Plan. United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, June 2019.
Humanitarian Country Team, Republic of the Union of Myanmar. Inter-agency Standard Operating Procedures, May 2016.
Inter-Agency Standing Committee and the European Commission, INFORM report 2020: Shared evidence for managing
crisis and disaster, EUR 30173 EN. Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg 2020.
Kawasaki, Akiyuki et al 2017. “Disaster response and river infrastructure management during the 2015 Myanmar floods: A
case in the Bago River Basin”, International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 24 (2017), pp 151-159.
Myanmar Information Management Unit (MIMU). MIMU Township Profiles. General Administration Department,
Government of the Union of the Republic of Myanmar 2019.
National Disaster Management Committee, Republic of the Union of Myanmar. Myanmar Action Plan on Disaster Risk
Reduction (MAPDRR) 2017. Naypyitaw, October 2017.
National Disaster Management Committee, Republic of the Union of Myanmar. National Earthquake Preparedness and
Response Plan 2019. Naypyitaw.
National Disaster Management Committee, Republic of the Union of Myanmar. National Framework for Community
Disaster Resilience 2017.
Nay Myo Hlaing, Col. 2016. “National Civil-Military Coordination System in Myanmar” [presentation]. 15th ASEAN Regional
Forum Intersessional Meeting on Disaster Relief, 25-26 February 2016, Naypyitaw.
Thet Naing Zaw & Lim, Seunghoo 2017. “The military’s role in disaster management and response during the 2015
Myanmar floods: A social network approach”, International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 25, pp 1-21.
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP). Manual on Community Based Disaster Risk Management (CBDRM) to
Strengthen Community Resilience in Myanmar (condensed) 2016.
United States of America Central Intelligence Agency. World Factbook 2019, ‘East Asia/Southeast Asia – Burma’.
98 MYANMAR
NEPAL
HUMANITARIAN CIVIL-MILITARY
COORDINATION IN EMERGENCIES
Khokana, Nepal, 6th May, 2015. Nepali Police hand over belongings while helping dig out belongings for residents. A major 7.9
earthquake hit Kathmandu mid-day on Saturday, April 25th, and was followed by multiple aftershocks that triggered avalanches
on Mt. Everest. Credit: PixelPro/Alamy Live News
99
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
1982
new key policies and legislation for disaster risk reduction
• Natural Calamity Relief Act enacted.
(DRR) and response. A new Disaster Risk Reduction
and Management Act (DRRM Act) – which entered into
effect in 2017, replacing the 1982 Natural Calamity Relief
1999
Act – articulates the roles and responsibilities of key
• Local Self Governance Act implemented.
government bodies in disaster response, including the
newly created National Council on Disaster Risk Reduction
and Management (NCDRRM), Ministry of Home Affairs
2008
(MoHA) Executive Committee (EC), and the National • Cluster approach was rolled out for the first time
Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Authority for the response to the Koshi flooding.
(NDRRMA).
2009
The security agencies – the Nepali Army, Armed Police • National Strategy for Disaster Risk Management
Force (APF), and Nepal Police – also have integral roles in (NSDRM) developed.
disaster response. Civil-military coordination (CMCoord)
has been shaped by large-scale natural disasters, in
particular earthquakes and flooding, as well as conflict and
• National Disaster Response Framework (NDRF)
internal instability in the southern region of the country.
2013
developed.
The Nepalese security agencies are primary responders
in disaster operations, and their roles are articulated in • National Strategic Action Plan on Search and
Rescue.
Nepal’s disaster-related laws and policies, as well as the
country’s national coordination structures.
enacted.
Response Framework (NDRF), amended in 2019,
reflects the new DRRM Act as well as the country’s • Local Goverment Operations Act replaced the Local
new federal structure. It outlines frameworks for the Self Governance Act.
mobilization of international humanitarian assistance
and CMCoord. • National Disaster Risk Reduction Policy
2018
established.
• NDRF amended.
released.
100 NEPAL
2020
KEY FACTS
Official name: Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal
GENERAL INFORMATION
Nepal is located near the boundary of the Eurasian and Indian tectonic plates and consequently experiences
frequent seismic activity and periodic large earthquakes. Its mountainous topography and annual wet season
mean that it also experiences frequent landslides and flooding. The most frequent natural disasters affecting
Nepal over the past four decades are floods (40 per cent) and landslides (21 per cent). Although earthquakes
represent only five per cent of all natural disasters that have affected Nepal in this period, they have caused
most of the associated fatalities and disruption.
21,226 Fatalities
Landslide
Epidemic
x25
x18 Storm Earthquake
Drought
x8 x6
x4
Source: Emergency Events Database (EM-DAT), Center for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters, 2020
NEPAL 101
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Nepalgunj Butwal
Hetauda Kathmandu
Dhankuta
Gorkha Earthquake Birgunj
25 April 2015 | Magnitude 7.8 Janakpur Biratnagar
5.7 million
8,831 Flood
US$5.17 billion July 2019
257,786
87
Displaced population Fatalities Economic loss
US$60 million
Source: EM-DAT CRED, 2020.
10
Vulnerability 4.7 59
9
8
Lack of coping capacity 5.8 52
7
6
5
Nepal has experienced a significant decrease in risk 4
of humanitarian crises and disasters in the last five 3
years relative to other nations. Although Nepal’s hazard 2
exposure has increased, its vulnerability has decreased. 1
0
Decreases can be due to a reduction in conflict, or to 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
improvements in socio-economic conditions and disaster
management capacity. INFORM Risk Hazard & Exposure
Vulnerability Lack of coping capacity
102 NEPAL
2020
Constitution of Nepal (2015). The Constitution of Nepal National Disaster Risk Reduction Policy (2018). The
identifies responsibilities for disaster management at NDRR Policy outlines a national policy for DRR, with
the national, provincial, and local levels of government, the long-term goal of sustainable development through
emphasizing that disaster risk management is a risk reduction and climate change adaptation. The
responsibility shared across government ministries. policy outlines numerous objectives, many of which
It also includes provisions for the role of the Armed align with the detailed duties and responsibilities
Forces, stating that in the event of a natural disaster for the national bodies and provincial, district, and
the Nepali Army may be mobilized without prior local committees identified in the DRRM Act.
authorization of the parliament.
Disaster Risk Reduction National Strategic Plan of
Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Act (2017). Action 2018-2030 (2018). The Strategic Plan of Action
The DRRM Act establishes a multi-tiered institutional identifies short, medium, and long-term activities to
approach to DRR and management at the national, mainstream DRR in development and sets targets for
provincial, district, and local levels. It repealed and reducing losses in disaster. Priorities are aligned with
replaced the Natural Calamity Relief Act of 1982, the NDRF and Sendai Framework, and are informed
which previously articulated provisions for disaster by other frameworks, including the Sustainable
operations. The 2017 Act outlines the roles and Development Goals and the Paris Agreement on
responsibilities of the newly created National Council Climate Change.
on Disaster Risk Reduction and Management, EC, and
NDRRMA – along with other bodies. The NDRRMA National Disaster Response Framework (2013,
now functions as a central resource agency for DRR amended 2019). The NDRF provides guidance on the
and management. The Act establishes a central roles and responsibilities of government agencies in
Disaster Management Fund that will include funds disaster response as well as preparedness, and the
received from the Government of Nepal or foreign functions of national coordination mechanisms. The
governments, donations or gifts from organizations NDRRMA and related agencies have a major role in the
or persons, or grants, loans, or donations from implementation of the NDRF. It highlights the primary
international organizations or associations with role of the security agencies (including the Nepali
the approval of the Ministry of Finance. Army) in disaster response, and also outlines core
responsibilities for the direction and coordination of
foreign military assistance in large-scale disasters.
It also designates the government lead agency and
relevant international co-lead of each cluster.
NEPAL 103
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Established by: Disaster Risk Reduction and Composition: Membership is comprised of ministers and
Management Act 2017. secretaries of government ministries, security agency
representation for all four agencies, as well as from the
Key functions: The EC is responsible for implementing central bank, Nepal Telecommunications, Federation of
policies and plans approved by the NCDRRM, including Nepalese Chamber of Commerce and Industries, and
national policies, plans, and frameworks on DRR, Nepal Red Cross Society (NRCS), among others.
response, and recovery. Its other functions include
building institutional capacity for disaster management Military and police force representation: Four
at the national, provincial, district, and local levels and members – the Lieutenant General of the Nepali
mobilizing international, bilateral, and multilateral Army, and Chiefs of Nepal Police, APF, and National
assistance for the disaster management sector. Investigation Department.
Established by: Disaster Risk Reduction and Composition: Membership is comprised of ministers,
Management Act 2017. the leader of the opposition party in the House of
Representatives, chief ministers of all provinces, the
Key functions: The NCDRRM is responsible for Vice Chair of National Planning Commission, Chief
approving national disaster management policies and Secretary of the Government of Nepal, Chief of the Army
plans, providing directives to the EC and the NDRRMA, Staff of the Nepali Army, Secretary of MoHA, and other
and providing disaster management policy guidelines to three nominated members (including one women) who
provincial and local levels. are experts in disaster management.
Chair: Prime Minister. Military representation: One member – the Chief of the
Army Staff (COAS) of the Nepali Army.
104 NEPAL
2020
1 The Government of Nepal, Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Act, 2017, chapter 3, section 9.1.
NEPAL 105
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Chair: Chief Minister. Chair: Provincial Minister of Internal Affairs and Law.
Composition: Membership is prescribed in the rules Composition: Membership shall consist of the
made by the provincial governments. Chairperson and members.
Functions: PDMCs are responsible for preparing Functions: PDMECs are responsible for formulating
policies and plans on disaster management and and implementing medium-term and short-term
providing policy guidance and directions to the Provincial provincial-level disaster management policies, plans,
Disaster Management Executive Committee in each of and programs within the scope of the national policies
the provinces as necessary. approved by the NCDRRM. During a disaster, PDMECs
coordinate with national, provincial, local and other
stakeholders for search and rescue and distribute relief
materials provided by national or international NGOs.
PDMECs also conduct a variety of response activities,
such as the relocation of disaster-affected populations
and the construction of temporary shelter.
2 The Government of Nepal, Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Act, 2017, chapter 3, section 9.1.
3 The Government of Nepal Ministry of Home Affairs, Nepal Disaster Report, 2017. The Asia Foundation, The Roles of Local Governments in Disaster Management and
Earthquake Reconstruction, 2019.
106 NEPAL
2020
NAME NUMBER
Federal provinces 4 7
Districts 77
Kathmandu
PDMC PDMEC
PROVINCIAL
DISTRICT DDMC
LOCAL LDMC
4 Referred to both as provinces and states. As of writing, two of seven states are yet to be named and thus are formally referred to as State 1, State 2.
NEPAL 107
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Function: MoHA is the focal point and coordinating MoHA’s Disaster and Conflict Management Division
ministry for DRR management and is responsible for has four sections, including the National Emergency
the implementation and monitoring of national policies, Operations Center (NEOC). MoHA and the NDRRMA
laws, and standards related to disaster management. coordinate disaster management through disaster
During a disaster, MoHA is responsible for the management committees at the provincial, district, and
overall management of rescue and relief operations, local levels.
including mobilizing the security agencies for disaster
management activities. Cluster leads: Logistics.
Function: MoHP is responsible for delivering training to Sub-national representation: MoHP is represented at
health personnel on disaster response preparedness. It the provincial, district, and local levels. Additionally, the
also coordinates delivery of medicines, equipment, and Government of Nepal and the World Health Organization
treatment to people in need. MoHP’s Health Emergency have established Provincial Health Emergency
Operations Center (HEOC) directly coordinates with Operations Centers (PHEOCs) that are now under MoHP.
NEOC and works closely with provinces during a PHEOCs focus on health sector preparedness and
disaster. response in disasters.
Function: MoFA is responsible for facilitating the clearances, and conveying relief needs identified by
entry of international relief agencies and relief items government agencies to the international community.
into Nepal, including registration processes. It is also The NDRF defines the MoFA’s roles in disaster response.
responsible for coordination of visas and custom
108 NEPAL
2020
COORDINATION MECHANISMS
NATIONAL CLUSTER SYSTEM LOGISTICS CLUSTER COORDINATION
THROUGH HUMANITARIAN STAGING AREAS
National clusters are led by government and international
agency co-leads and are well established in Nepal. The World Food Programme (WFP – the agency co-lead
They have well-defined operational processes that for the logistics cluster), in collaboration with MoHA
both incorporate and support designated government (the lead for the logistics cluster) and the Civil Aviation
response agencies. Cluster operations are strengthened Authority of Nepal (CAAN), constructed three humanitarian
by well-established partnerships between national staging areas (HSAs) for the prepositioning of relief
and international organizations, in part due to Nepal’s supplies in Nepal. The HSAs are located next to airports
vulnerability to natural disasters. in Kathmandu, Dhangadhi, and Nepalgunj. For example,
the HSA in Dhangadhi is slated to store supplies, such as
OVERVIEW shelter materials, water and sanitation equipment, and
health and hygiene kits for at least 60,000 people. The first
Function: The cluster approach facilitates a coordinated HSA, located next to Tribhuvan International Airport in
emergency response from both government and non- Kathmandu, opened one month before the 2015 earthquake
government institutions. It is implemented during and was activated as part of the response. The Dhangadhi
large-scale disasters, or when the government requires and Nepalgunj HSAs were inaugurated around January
international assistance in multi-sector responses with 2020, while construction of additional HSAs in the country
broad participation of international humanitarian actors. are currently ongoing or planned.5
Location: Cluster representatives are co-located at the
NEOC during a response.
NEPAL RED CROSS SOCIETY
Process for activation: The Government of Nepal
The Nepal Red Cross Society (NRCS) is a key actor in the
activates the cluster system, in coordination with the
UN Humanitarian Coordinator, in response to a disaster. immediate and long-term response to disasters in Nepal
As per the 2019 amendment of the NDRF, the NDRRMA and coordinates directly with the government. As a result,
mobilizes clusters for activities during a disaster. it has an institutionalized role in Nepal’s disaster risk
reduction and management structures. NRCS is a member
Coordination: MoHA is responsible for inter-cluster
of disaster response structures at all levels of government,
coordination through the NDRRMA.
including the EC, PDMC/EC, DDMC, and LDMC. When a
Role of the military: Asset and capability support for disaster occurs, the NRCS Disaster Management Division
humanitarian response operations, including logistics (DMD) activates the NRCS Emergency Operation Center at
and infrastructure support (engineering). The Nepali its headquarters in Kathmandu to coordinate its activities.6
Army also undertakes damage and needs assessments,
provides transport capabilities for distribution of relief, NRCS has a strong presence at the provincial, district and
and provides medical assistance through its Medical local level and coordinates with the DDMCs and LDMCs.
Corps. NRCS also has a network of Provincial Committees and
Cluster focal points in provincial areas: Assigned to District Chapters, which receive further support from more
support the cluster system at a subnational level. than 1,500 Sub-Chapters and Cooperation Committees.
Volunteers play a critical role in supporting NRCS’ work.
Operational guidelines: Prior to the 2015 earthquake,
As of 2018, NRCS had over 121,000 active volunteers.7
cluster-based contingency plans were developed
for disaster response. In particular, the clusters
NRCS is also actively involved in humanitarian civil-
develop annual monsoon response plans. For the
2020 monsoon season, MoHA and NDRRMA developed
military coordination with the Nepali Army, Armed Police
the EC-approved detailed Monsoon Preparedness Force and Nepal Police during disasters. For example,
and Response Plan 2020. The Humanitarian Country NRCS and the Army coordinate search and rescue efforts
Team (HCT) also prepared the Monsoon Emergency and NRCS works with the Nepal Police to conduct local-
Response Preparedness 2020 document to support the level assessments after a disaster strikes.
Government’s response.
5 World Food Programme, Inauguration of new humanitarian staging area in Dhangadhi, 2020.
6 Government of Nepal Ministry of Home Affairs, Nepal Disaster Report 2019.
7 Nepal Red Cross Society, Risk Reduction Policies, 2019. Nepal Red Cross Society, “About NRCS,” 2020. IFRC Databank and Reporting System, “Nepal Red Cross
Society,” 2018.
NEPAL 109
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
8 Food security & nutrition merged into one cluster per the 2019 amendment of the National Disaster Response Framework.
110 NEPAL
2020
9 The Government of Nepal, National Disaster Response Framework, 2019, section 3, sub-section 3.7.
NEPAL 111
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Ministry RC/HC
of Home
Chair
Affairs
OSOCC
Executive HCT
Committee OCHA
Inter-cluster
NDRRMA
coordination
112 NEPAL
2020
The infographic below depicts the national and international humanitarian assistance coordination framework in Nepal
as outlined in the NDRF. It shows the coordination process between the Government of Nepal and the HCT, including the
process for launching an appeal for international humanitarian assistance.13
Government of Nepal
Appeal for International (Council of Ministers)
Humanitarian Assistance Declaration of Disaster Emergency/
Crisis Zone by Government of Nepal
Cluster Activation
Provincial Government
Provincial Disaster Management
Council / Executive Committee
(PDMC/EC)
District Disaster
DISASTER Management Committee
(DDMC)
13 The Government of Nepal, National Disaster Response Framework, 2019, section 5, sub-section 5.1.
NEPAL 113
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
14 The Government of Nepal, Disaster Risk Reduction Act, 2017, chapter 8, section 18.
15 The Government of Nepal, Constitution of Nepal, 2015, part 28, article 267.
16 The Government of Nepal, Disaster Risk Reduction Act, 2017, chapter 8, section 18.3 (a) (b), (c) (d).
114 NEPAL
2020
In addition to its military responsibilities, the Nepali Army The APF is a paramilitary force that was established by
is actively involved in disaster management and response the Armed Police Force Act of 2001. The APF is tasked
activities. The Nepali Army has two specialized Disaster with counter-insurgency, counter-terrorism, and border
Management Battalions to conduct humanitarian response security operations in Nepal. The APF also has a mandate
and disaster relief activities. During a disaster, the Nepali for conducting disaster relief operations and providing
Army Headquarters (HQ) Operations Centre manages the relief to individuals affected by natural disasters or
Nepali Army Crisis Management Center, which coordinates epidemics.
with the Army’s sub-national operations centers and the
Multi-National Military Coordination Center (MNMCC). A Disaster Management Division at the APF Headquarters
coordinates with provincial brigades and field units. The
Division carries out central-level coordination with MoHA
Established: 1945. and its Chief represents the APF on the EC. APF personnel
are mobilized as per the DRRM Act 2017. A Disaster
Leadership: President of Nepal; Chief of the Army Staff. Management Training School was established in 2011 to
Upon recommendation of the Council of Ministers, the enhance the capability of APF personnel to manage and
President authorizes the mobilization, operations and respond to disasters occurring in various parts of the
use of the Nepali Army. country.17
Functions: Designated mandate to conduct disaster Functions: Designated mandate to provide relief
response, including search, rescue and relief activities assistance in disaster and epidemic response.
when mobilized by the Government of Nepal.
NEPAL 115
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Two specialist
HADR battalions
Source: Nepal Army, Lessons From the 2015 Earthquake Response, pgs. 4-6
116 NEPAL
2020
Brigade HQ
NEPALI ARMY CRISIS MANAGEMENT CENTER Operations Center
21 The Government of Nepal, National Disaster Response Framework, 2019, section 6, sub-section 6.6.
22 Nepal Army, Lessons From the 2015 Earthquake Response, pgs. 9, 37.
23 Ibid.
NEPAL 117
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
118 NEPAL
2020
National Emergency Operations Center (NEOC) Civil society and private sectors
Search &
Rescue Groups International and regional
Nepali Army Crisis On-Site Operation
agencies
(NA/NP/APF/ Mangement Center Coordination Center
Other) (NACRIMAC) (OSOCC)
Inter-agency executive team
and clusters
Multi-National
Multi-National International supporting team
Military Coordination
Militaries for disaster response
Center (MNMCC)
Based on the experience of leading the MNMCC in the 2015 earthquake response, the Nepali Army’s Lessons
Learned report proposed several changes to the MNMCC structure and coordination. The proposed structure
includes five cells: reception cell, planning cell, coordination cell for coordination with the NEOC and OSOCC, a
liaison cell for the Nepali Army and foreign military liaison officers, and an information management cell.28
Engineering
27 The Government of Nepal, National Disaster Response Framework, 2019, section 5, sub-section 5.10.
28 Nepal Army, Lessons From the 2015 Earthquake Response, 2016 (p. 51).
NEPAL 119
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
HUMOCC OVERVIEW
The HuMOCC is a humanitarian civil-military coordination affected State’s national disaster management authority
(CMCoord) platform that can be used in large-scale with the support of UN OCHA’s Civil-Military Coordination
disasters when it is appropriate for humanitarian and Service (CMCS).
military actors to co-locate, as it provides a physical space
for interaction among humanitarian, national and foreign During the 2015 earthquake response, the HuMOCC
military actors, as well as national police. As a dedicated concept was employed in Nepal as a humanitarian-
space for CMCoord, the HuMOCC facilitates information military-police coordination platform. As part of the
sharing, task division, and the coordination of operational response, the Government of Nepal established a Multi-
planning between humanitarian and military actors in National Military Operations and Coordination Center
natural disaster responses.29 Above all, the HuMOCC’s (MNMCC), which was chaired by the Nepali Army. The
services seek to optimize the use of available military HuMOCC was established by the UN-CMCoord team and
assets to support humanitarian priorities in affected areas. was co-located with the MNMCC. After the establishment
of HuMOCC, all international and national NGOs coming to
The HuMOCC is intended to be complementary to the the MNMCC were channeled to the HuMOCC for necessary
OSOCC but has the flexibility to be established with coordination. The HuMOCC was also referred to as Joint
or without the OSOCC and sub-OSOCCs, as required. Coordinating Committee (JCC).30 The HuMOCC served as
Ultimately, the HuMOCC is scalable and an integral part the physical space for humanitarian and military actors to
of the on-site coordination apparatus established by interact, including key cluster personnel and the Nepali
the international humanitarian community in support Army. Humanitarian capacity gaps identified by civilian
of the affected State’s broader on-site coordination actors, such as the HCT or clusters, were raised at the
requirements. As a result, the HuMOCC is ideally led by the HuMOCC.
Central Natural
Disaster Relief
Committee (CNDRC)
NEOC/Regional and
Nepali Army District DRCs
Foreign
Military Cell 1 UN agencies,
Multi-National INGOs, cluster
Military HuMOCC/ agencies, civil
Cell 2 OSOCC
Coordination JCC society and
Center private sector
Cell 3 actors
Cell 4
29 United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, UN-CMCoord Field Handbook Version 2.0, 2018.
30 Retired Col. Ratindra Khatri, “Civil-Military Coordination after the Nepal Earthquake: Role of the HuMOCC,” Liaison, Volume VIII, 2016.
120 NEPAL
2020
Province 5
Indi a
Province 2
Adapted from ‘Nepal: Monsoon Flooding Flash Update 3’, Office of the Resident Coordinator, Nepal
RESPONSE OVERVIEW
The 2019 monsoon season started on 20 June and convened a cluster meeting at the NEOC in order to provide
remained active until 12 October 2019. The first heavy an overview of the situation and coordinate response
rainfall of the season lasted from 11 to 13 July. The heavy requirements.32 Responding organizations, including
rain resulted in significant flooding and landslides, which humanitarian organizations, were requested by the MoHA
affected multiple areas of Nepal, especially Provinces 1, to prioritize search and rescue, treatment of injured,
2, and 3. By 15 July, approximately 80,000 people were provision of food items, and emergency shelter. In addition
temporarily displaced in Central and Eastern Nepal.31 to central coordination, humanitarian organizations also
coordinated with provincial, district, and local governments
Following the onset of the rains, the EC, chaired by the to meet the needs of affected populations.
Minister of Home Affairs, directed ministries and provincial
and local governments to respond. The MoHA also
31 Office of the UN Resident Coordinator Nepal, Nepal: Monsoon Flooding Flash Update No. 2, 2019.
32 Office of the UN Resident Coordinator Nepal, Nepal: Monsoon Flooding Flash Update No.1, 2019.
NEPAL 121
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
The Nepali Army, Nepal Police and Armed Police Force Prior to the beginning of monsoon season, MoHA
were immediately mobilized by the Government of Nepal developed a monsoon preparedness and response plan
for search and rescue. Personnel from all three security in which it detailed actions for relevant ministries, all
agencies, alongside volunteers from the Nepal Red Cross government levels, and security agencies. Preparedness
Society, also evacuated people from affected areas to actions included developing disaster preparedness plans
shelters in schools and other public places.33 Search and at the provincial and local levels and ensuring ministries
rescue efforts proved challenging as many roads and and security agencies coordinated public awareness
other critical infrastructure were inaccessible due to the campaigns. Similarly, the HCT developed a monsoon
flooding and landslides. To address this challenge, security flooding contingency plan, which detailed its response
personnel worked to clear roads and the Nepali Army used strategy and coordination processes with the Government
boats to access affected areas and employed helicopters of Nepal in line with established frameworks.
for search and rescue. By 15 July, approximately 2,156
people were rescued by security forces.34 The Nepal Following the end of monsoon season, MoHA reflected
Police also played an integral role in responding due on the response to the year’s monsoon-related disasters
to their presence in local communities. Approximately and provided lessons learned in its 2019 Seasonal Disaster
27,380 police personnel were deployed across the country Review. In the review, MoHA identified critical actions that
for search and rescue operations.35 occurred as part of the response to the monsoon. First,
the immediate mobilization of the Government of Nepal’s
civilian and security agency response mechanisms allowed
for the early coordination response efforts. Second,
coordination with provincial and local governments and
the security agencies enabled a prompt response to assist
affected populations. Third, the rapid deployment of
security personnel saved the lives of affected populations,
especially those in high-risk areas; and, fourth, the
mobilization of volunteers, including those part of the
Nepal Red Cross Society, supported response efforts.36
33 International Federation of the Red Cross and Red Crescent, Information bulletin - Nepal: Monsoon floods and landslides, 2019.
34 Office of the UN Resident Coordinator Nepal, Nepal: Monsoon Flooding Flash Update No. 2, 2019.
35 “Floods, landslides claim 43 lives,” The Himalayan Times, 2019.
36 The Government of Nepal Ministry of Home Affairs, Seasonal Disaster Review: Monsoon related disasters in Nepal 20 June to 12 October 2019, 2019.
122 NEPAL
2020
Kathmandu
NEPAL 123
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
An MNMCC was established to facilitate military-to- The tasking of teams was conducted in daily meetings at
military coordination - the first MNMCC activated in the MNMCC with national authorities and the Urban Search
disaster response in Nepal. The MNMCC was chaired by and Rescue Coordination Cell (UCC). The UCC provided
the Nepali Army with the initial participation of foreign daily reports to national authorities and the OSOCC, and
military liaison officers from the following countries: maintained a strong working relationship with both the
Algeria, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Canada, India, Japan, NEOC and the MNMCC.
Pakistan, Singapore, Spain, Sri Lanka, Thailand, the United
Kingdom and the United States. Representatives from The Nepali Army invited the UN-CMCoord team to have a
MNMCC also participated in the HuMOCC. permanent liaison function within the MNMCC to facilitate
information sharing and coordination.
A civilian-led HuMOCC/JCC was established following The HuMOCC/JCC smoothly facilitated requests for
consultation with in-country actors and was co-located assistance and flow of information. It was an integral
with the MNMCC. part of the response process that allowed humanitarian
agencies to access military and civil defence assets.
Key activities for the HuMOCC in the response included: Requests for military assistance by civilian agencies were
prioritised and discussed in the JCC and HuMOCC. They
• Facilitating access to rapid and comprehensive were then proposed to the MNMCC for the support of
assessment information used for operational planning national and foreign military forces.
including the use of FMA.
Representatives of international militaries also
• Advising on the appropriate FMA to be deployed participated as staff officers, and were valuable
to Nepal and sharing priority locations for FMA participants in the HuMOCC/JCC. Key cluster personnel
deployment/coverage based on the NEOC’s priorities. and representatives of the Red Cross/Red Crescent
Movement also participated. The platform was beneficial
• Contributing to achieving and maintaining common
for INGOs with large-scale operations in particular, as it
situational awareness that could be shared amongst
enabled the use of military resources for relief operations
all actors.
in difficult areas to access.
124 NEPAL
2020
HQ headquarters
NEPAL 125
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
UN United Nations
126 NEPAL
2020
REFERENCES
Armed Police Force Act, 2001.
Armed Police Force, “APF Units under the Brigade HQ,” 2020.
Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters Emergency Events Database (EM-DAT CRED), 2020.
International Federation of the Red Cross and Red Crescent, Law and Disaster Preparedness and Response Literature
Review, 2019.
Retired Col. Ratindra Khatri, “Civil-Military Coordination after the Nepal Earthquake: Role of the HuMOCC,” Liaison,
Volume VIII, 2016.
The Asia Foundation, The Roles of Local Governments in Disaster Management and Earthquake Reconstruction, 2019.
The Government of Nepal, Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Rules, 2019.
The Government of Nepal Ministry of Health and Population, Provincial Health Emergency Operations Centre Handover,
Pokhara, 2018.
The Government of Nepal Ministry of Health and Population, Role/Functions of HEOC, 2018.
The Government of Nepal Ministry of Home Affairs, Disaster Risk Reduction National Strategic Plan of Action 2018-2030,
2018.
The Government of Nepal Ministry of Home Affairs, National Policy for Disaster Risk Reduction, 2018.
The Government of Nepal Ministry of Home Affairs, National Position Paper on Disaster Risk Reduction and Management,
2018.
The Government of Nepal Ministry of Home Affairs, National Position Paper on Disaster Risk Reduction and Management,
2019.
The Government of Nepal Ministry of Home Affairs, Nepal Disaster Report, 2019.
The Government of Nepal Ministry of Home Affairs, Nepal Disaster Report, 2017.
NEPAL 127
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
The Government of Nepal, Nepal Food Security Monitoring System Report, 2017.
United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, Regional Consultative Group on Humanitarian Civil-
Military Coordination for Asia and the Pacific–Newsletter, Issue 2, 2017.
United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, UN-CMCoord Field Handbook Version 2.0, 2018.
United Nations Nepal Information Platform, HCT and Cluster Coordination in Nepal, 2019.
United Nations Nepal Information Platform, Nepal: Monsoon Emergency Response Preparedness, 2020.
UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator in Nepal, Monsoon Flooding Flash Update No. 2, 2019.
World Bank, World Development Indicators Database: Nepal Country Profile, 2019.
World Food Programme, Inauguration of new humanitarian staging area in Dhangadhi, 2020.
128 NEPAL
PHILIPPINES
HUMANITARIAN CIVIL-MILITARY
COORDINATION IN EMERGENCIES
A military aircraft passes by the washed out coastal villages in the province of Leyte, Philippines after Typhoon Haiyan.
Photo: ZUMA Press, Inc. / Alamy Stock Photo
129
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Civil-military coordination (CMCoord) and disaster • 2007 National cluster system established.
2007-10
response in the Philippines has undergone a • 2009 Hosted the inaugural ASEAN Regional Forum
significant transformation over the last two decades. Disaster Relief Exercise.
Frequent large-scale disasters and subsequent • 2010 Republic Act 10121 Philippines Disaster Risk
Reduction and Management Act.
national and international responses have shaped the
evolution of disaster management legislation, policy
frameworks and coordination structures. The Armed • Participated in the ASEAN Disaster Emergency Response
Forces of the Philippines (AFP) is a primary responder Simulation Exercise.
2013
in disaster operations and is frequently deployed to • Typhoon Haiyan: AFP responds and FMA from more
assist humanitarian response. than 22 countries deployed, 57 nations overall provide
assistance and Multinational Coordination Centre (MNCC)
Following Super Typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda) in 2013, activated.
which saw the deployment of foreign military
assets (FMA) from 29 states, the Government of • After Action Review (AAR) on Humanitarian Civil-Military
the Philippines’ Department of Foreign Affairs Coordination in Typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda).
(DFA) significantly overhauled the coordination • The National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management
of international humanitarian assistance, and Council (NDRRMC) together with UN OCHA, Office of Civil
specifically civil-military coordination. Incorporating Defense (OCD) and AFP begin efforts to institutionalize
a civil-military coordination framework into national
2014
Coordination in action
• Elected first chair of the RCG on Humanitarian-Civil
Military Coordination for Asia and the Pacific.
2015
The Government of the Philippines hosted the • AFP Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Response
International Search and Rescue Advisory Group Plan established (Operation Plan (OPLAN) Tulong –
(INSARAG) Asia-Pacific earthquake response Bayanihan).
exercise in June 2018. This simulation brought
together nearly 500 foreign and local participants • Philippines joined the Advisory Group for the development
to practice national and international response and of Recommended Practices for Effective Humanitarian
coordination mechanisms, including:
2016
1 CHA (2018) Philippines: Asia Pacific 2018 INSARAG Earthquake Response Exercise.
2 The Pacific Partnership is an annual multinational humanitarian assistance and disaster relief preparedness mission conducted in the Indo-Pacific.
130 PHILIPPINES
2020
KEY FACTS
Official name: Republic of the Philippines
Area: 300,000km2
Philippine
Population: 109,335,155 (2020)
Clark, Angeles Sea
Capital: Manila Port of Manila
Manila Ninoy Aquino, Manila
Official language(s): Filipino and English
South Port of
Batangas
Disaster focal point: National Disaster Risk China
Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC) Sea
Kalibo Daniel Z. Romualdez,
Military: Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) Tacloban
Iloilo
Bacolod Silay
Police: Philippine National Police (PNP)
Cebu
Puerto Princesa Mactan-Cebu
Port
GENERAL INFORMATION of Cebu
Port of Cagayan de Oro
Sulu Lumbia
The Philippines is highly disaster prone due to
its geographic location in the west of the Pacific Sea
Ocean. It is exposed to natural hazards such
as typhoons (tropical storms), landslides and Zamboanga Davao Francisco
Port of Davao Bangoy, Davao
monsoons, as well as earthquakes, volcanic
eruptions and tsunamis related to continental
plate activity around the Ring of Fire. On Celebes Sea
average, the Philippines is struck by 20 tropical
cyclones each year.
Major airports Major seaports
61,615 Fatalities
Storm
x324
Flood
x150 Earthquake Landslide Volcano Mass
Epidemic Drought Movement Wildfire
x31 x29 x22 x22 x10 x3 x1
Source: Emergency Events Database (EM-DAT), Center for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters, 2020
PHILIPPINES 131
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
US$3.8 billion
Bicol Severe Tropical Storm Washi
South China Sea 16 December 2011
Typhoon Bopha (Pablo) Tacloban 430,900
Iloilo
4 December 2012 | Category 5
Cebu 1,439
1.3 million Visayas
US$38 million
1,900 Sulu
Sea
US$900 million Cagayan de Oro
Davao
Mindanao
Sources: IDMC, GAR 2020, EMDAT OFDA-CRED Database Celebes Sea 150 km
132 PHILIPPINES
2020
KEY PLANS
Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction and Management preparedness, disaster response and disaster
Act (DRRM Act, 2010). The DRRM Act outlines rehabilitation and recovery. The NDRRMP also outlines
provisions for the establishment of the National provisions for developing and implementing disaster
Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council risk reduction plans at the regional, provincial, city,
(NDRRMC). It is accompanied by a set of Implementing municipal and barangay levels.
Rules and Regulations that detail the composition
of the National, Regional and Local Disaster Risk Strengthening Disaster Risk Reduction in the
Reduction and Management Councils (DRRMCs) and Philippines: Strategic National Action Plan 2009-2019.
their respective powers and functions, as well as The Plan outlines the key role of AFP in mainstreaming
provisions for the establishment of Local Disaster disaster risk reduction efforts and supporting
Risk Reduction and Management Offices (LDRRMOs) in preparedness for effective disaster response.
every barangay.3
Revised Operations Plan “Tulong Bayanihan 2”
National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management (2019). The Plan provides systems and protocols for
Framework (2011). The Framework translates the AFP in the conduct of Humanitarian Assistance and
country’s Hyogo Framework for Action commitments Disaster Relief operations in each disaster phase
into priority programs, projects, and budgets and is (pre, during, and after). It also details the operational
integrated into the National Disaster Risk Reduction protocols of AFP in relation to personnel, logistics,
and Management Plan 2011-2028 (NDRRMP). communications, electronics, and information system,
education and training, and multi-national coordination
National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management center during disasters.
Plan 2011-2028 (NDRRMP). The NDRRMP outlines key
planning aspects such as timelines, lead agencies,
outcomes and activities according to four themes:
disaster prevention and mitigation, disaster
3 Barangay (Filipino term for village or ward) is the smallest administrative division in the Philippines.
PHILIPPINES 133
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Armed Forces Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Philippines: Metro Manila, Calabarzon, and Central
Response Plan (OPLAN Tulong – Bayanihan) (2016). Luzon. It outlines pre-identified assisting Regional
The Plan outlines the core functions as well as the Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Councils
operational processes and systems to be used by (RDRRMCs) as well as international partners that
the AFP in Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster can support the capacity of the NDRRMCs. The OCD
Relief (HADR) operations. The AFP also holds Regional Office, through the Regional Director, will
membership in several other clusters, including the take charge as Chairperson of the assisting RDRRMC,
Camp Coordination and Camp Management, Logistics, overseeing activities and decisions of the 12 pre-
Emergency Telecommunications, and Health clusters. identified response clusters.
UPDATED: National Disaster Response Plan (NDRP) Enhanced Policy Guidelines on Philippine
for Hydro-Meteorological Hazards Version 2 (2017). International Humanitarian Assistance (2017). The
This multi-hazard plan outlines the processes and proposed Enhanced Policy Guidelines on PIHA seeks
mechanisms for national, regional and local disaster to establish PIHAC, under the NDRP for Hydro-
response, focusing on hydro-meteorological hazards Meteorological Hazards and NDRP for Earthquake
(for example, typhoons, tropical storms and flooding). and Tsunamis, as an institutional framework and
The plan outlines the role of the AFP, which leads the coordinating mechanism for incoming and outgoing
Search, Rescue and Retrieval (SRR) cluster. The 2018 international humanitarian assistance before,
update establishes three new response clusters and during and after emergencies and disasters. PIHAC
specifies mechanisms for CMCoord through the CMCC coordinates with the NDRRMC to manage in kind
and multi-national military-to-military coordination donations, international relief teams and financial
through the MNCC. donations, and ensures that policies and mechanisms
are in line with international agreements at the
National Disaster Response Plan for Earthquake regional and global level.
and Tsunami (2017). The NDRP for Earthquake and
Tsunami outlines key players and mechanisms for Disaster Rehabilitation and Recovery Planning Guide
national, regional and local response to sudden onset (2020). The Disaster Rehabilitation and Recovery
of these disasters. The plan explains specific criteria Planning Guide has been formulated by the National
for activation as well as necessary actions during the Economic Development Authority, and will serve as the
disaster and post-disaster phases. Military forces and recovery and rehabilitation template for national and
assets will be used for damage assessment and SRR local government units to use in their post-disaster
operations. (and post-conflict) recovery planning. The guide
provides templates for a recovery framework, planning
Harmonized National Contingency Plan for the process, institutional arrangements, coordination
Magnitude 7.2 Earthquake (2019). The plan outlines and implementation mechanisms, options for funding
response arrangements in the event of a 7.2 magnitude resources, and proposed monitoring arrangements.
earthquake which might affect three regions in the
President Rodrigo Duterte, in his State of the Nation Address in July 2017, urged the Philippine Congress to prioritize
the crafting of a law that would establish a department solely focused on long-term disaster mitigation, relief and
recovery. This is envisioned as the Department of Disaster Resilience (DRR), which would replace the existing
NDRRMC structure. In the current version of the bills filed both in the House of Representatives and the Senate, the
Department will focus on three key areas:
• Disaster risk reduction
• Disaster preparedness and response
• Recovery and ‘building forward better’4
The functions, structure, mandates, and power of the Department are also outlined in the bill, including the plan to
create a Humanitarian Assistance Action Center (HAAC), an inter-agency one-stop-shop mechanism, responsible for
streamlining the process of managing humanitarian assistance, equipment and services from local or international
sources. The bill also specifies that the Philippines could offer international humanitarian assistance to foreign
states. The military has the same role in disaster preparedness and disaster response, providing support to at-risk
and disaster-affected areas and preventing violence occurring before and in the aftermath of a disaster if necessary.
4 Senate of the Philippines 2019. “Senate Bill No. 205, An Act Creating the Department of Disaster Resilience, Defining Its Powers and Functions, and
Appropriating Funds Therefore,’ <https://senate.gov.ph/lisdata/3046327341!.pdf>
134 PHILIPPINES
2020
The National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC) is the primary body
responsible for coordinating preparedness, response, prevention and mitigation, and rehabilitation
and recovery.
Chair: Secretary of
Department of National
Defense (DND)
Secretariat:
Office of Civil Defense
(OCD)
PHILIPPINES 135
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Established by: Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction and • Secretary of Department of Science and Technology
Management Act (DRRM Act, 2010). (DOST) as Vice Chairperson for Disaster Prevention
and Mitigation.
Key functions: Primary body responsible for • Director-General of National Economic and
coordinating preparedness, response, prevention Development Authority (NEDA) as Vice Chairperson
and mitigation, and rehabilitation and recovery. for Disaster Rehabilitation and Recovery.
Lead on the National Disaster Risk Reduction and
Management Framework. Composition: NDRRMC is composed of 44 member
agencies including, officials from 14 government
Location within government: Situated under the departments; AFP and PNP; the Philippine National Red
Department of National Defense (DND). Cross and other civil society organizations; provincial
Leadership: Chairperson: Secretary of DND; Executive and local governments; social security and insurance
Director: OCD Administrator. organizations; national commissions and councils; and
one representative from the private sector.
Headquarters: Camp General Emilio Aguinaldo,
co-located with OCD, Manila. Military and police force representation: Chief of Staff,
AFP and Chief, PNP.
Vice-Chairs:
• Secretary of Department of Interior and Local Authority: The NDRRMC Chairperson has the authority
Government (DILG) as Vice Chairperson for to call upon other instrumentalities or entities of the
Preparedness. government, non-government and civic organizations
• Secretary of Department of Social Welfare and for assistance, including the power to call on the AFP
Development (DSWD) as Vice Chairperson for Reserve Command to assist in disaster relief. The
Disaster Response. NDRRMC may recommend that the President declares a
state of emergency.
136 PHILIPPINES
2020
disaster activities and programs such as but not limited NATIONAL, REGIONAL
to construction of dams or embankments to mitigate flood AND LOCAL LEVELS
risks, conduct of risk assessment, training, purchase of
life-saving equipment, provision of relief items, shelter,
alternative livelihood, construction / rehabilitation of
damaged infrastructure facilities and evacuation centers.6
ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISIONS OF
THE PHILIPPINES
NDRRMC
Region Rehiyon 18
REGIONAL
Disaster Risk
Probinsiya/
Province 81 Reduction and
Lalawigan
Management
Councils
Municipality Munisipalidad/Bayan 1,489
Village/
Barangay 42,036
neighbourhood
LOCAL
LEAD AUTHORITY BY AFFECTED AREA Disaster Risk
Reduction and
Management
AFFECTED AREA LEAD AUTHORITY Councils/Office
PHILIPPINES 137
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Function: The DSWD, through the Disaster Response Location within government: DReAMB, DSWD.
Assistance and Management Bureau (DReAMB), is
the lead agency for disaster response, planning and Cluster leads: Food and Non-Food Items; Camp
coordination. It is responsible for leading immediate Coordination and Management; IDP Protection.
disaster relief efforts, as well as ongoing monitoring.
In addition to leading the NDRRMC’s disaster Regional/provincial representation: 16 regional
response pillar, DSWD provides technical assistance field offices.
and resource augmentation, camp coordination and
management activities, provision of food and non-
food items, and protection of internally displaced
populations.7
Function: The OCD is the Executive Arm and Location within government: OCD is one of five
Secretariat of the NDRRMC. OCD’s primary role bureaus within the DND.
is to administer the national civil defence and
disaster risk reduction and management programs. Cluster lead: Logistics; Emergency
It also provides leadership on the development Telecommunications.
of strategic approaches and measures to reduce
vulnerabilities and risk. The OCD coordinates the AFP Regional/provincial representation: 17 regional
in the utilization of military assets and provision of offices.
assistance in disaster response.
7 NDRP, 2014, p. 3.
138 PHILIPPINES
2020
COORDINATION MECHANISMS
INCIDENT COMMAND SYSTEM NATIONAL CLUSTER SYSTEM
The Incident Command System (ICS) is a standardized, on- In 2007, the Government of the Philippines established the
scene, all-hazard incident management concept. humanitarian coordination structure of national clusters.10
It was one of the first governments globally to adopt a
It is designed to enable effective and efficient incident national cluster approach based on the UN cluster system,
management by integrating facilities, equipment, and it has been utilised as a coordination platform since its
personnel, procedures, and communications within a adoption. The cluster system was activated in the response
common organizational structure.8 to Typhoon Haiyan in 2013. In 2014, the NDRP amended the
system to include eight response clusters, subsequently
Functions: The ICS facilitates interoperability between used to coordinate the response to Typhoon Hagupit (Ruby)
disaster response personnel and other agencies across in 2014. The system was further updated in the 2018
jurisdictions. version of the NDRP to now include 11 response clusters.
The government structure also includes clusters which
Leadership: Incident Commander. have no counterpart in the global cluster system, such as
the SRR cluster headed by AFP.
Liaison: The Liaison Officer is the point of contact
for representatives of other government agencies,
non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and private Functions: The cluster approach aims to ensure
entities. In either a single or unified command structure, predictability, accountability, inclusivity and partnership
representatives from assisting or cooperating agencies across all sectors involved in disaster response.
and organizations coordinate through the Liaison Officer. It clearly defines leadership roles for government
cluster leads and their responsibilities in establishing
Activation: ICS is activated only in response to disasters cluster operational strategies before, during and after
or emergencies. When an incident is declared as disasters. The objective of the operational strategies
approaching crisis level, the responding Crisis Manager is to ensure cluster partners and other stakeholders
activates ICS.9 It is not a permanent structure and does have a clear understanding of how to coordinate and
not replace existing DRRMCs. contribute to cluster efforts.
Interoperability: The NDRP emphasises the Location: Agency leads of the response clusters convene
interoperability of the Incident Command Team (ICT) and at the NDRRMC Operations Center at Camp Aguinaldo.
response cluster as the two main operating components
Operations protocols: Each response cluster has a
of the Response Pillar. This arrangement supposes
designated operational protocol that guides emergency
that the response cluster acts as the resource provider,
response, including outlining the roles of the cluster
providing personnel and other material resources to the
lead and focal point, and coordination mechanisms
ICT as the resource employer, while both are linked by the
with the NDRRMC, the Operations Center, government
NDRRMC-Emergency Operation Center.
agencies, the AFP and other groups.
PHILIPPINES 139
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
• UNHCR Protection
Department of Social Welfare • Child Protection Working Group
• GBV UNFPA
and Development (DSWD] • Gender-Based Violence Sub Cluster
• Child protection UNICEF
Department of Information
• WFP Emergency Telecommunications
and Communications
Department of National
Defense (DND) through
Search, Rescue and Retrieval (SRR)
the Armed Forces of the
Philippines (AFP)
International Humanitarian
Department of Foreign Affairs Assistance
(DFA)
• In-kind Donations Sub Cluster
• International Relief Teams Sub
Cluster
• Financial Donations Sub Cluster
140 PHILIPPINES
2020
Responsible Official
COORDINATION
DRRMC
Operational Coordinator
EOC
Clusters
PHILIPPINES 141
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
The Philippine International Humanitarian Assistance If the Government of the Philippines requests and/or
Cluster (PIHAC) is the main institutional framework and accepts international assistance, coordination between
coordinating body for the mobilization of international the HCT agency co-leads for the clusters, the Resident
assistance. Coordinator/Humanitarian Coordinator (RCHC) and the
national response systems and bodies, including NDRRMC
The guidelines also aim to institutionalise the Philippines and DSWD, is initiated. The HCT is composed of 24 UN
International Humanitarian Assistance Reception Center agencies, international NGOs (INGOs), private sector
(PIHARC)–a one-stop-shop facility to screen, facilitate representatives and donor agencies, led by the UN RCHC.
and expedite the processing and entry of international There are currently 11 NDRRMC response clusters, led by
humanitarian teams, equipment, and in-kind donations. government departments and agencies and supported by
HCT agency co-leads.
PIHAC
LEAD: DFA
IN-KIND DONATIONS SUB CLUSTER INTERNATIONAL RELIEF TEAMS SUB CLUSTER FINANCIAL DONATIONS SUB CLUSTER
Lead: DSWD Lead: DOH and DND through AFP Lead: DOF and DBM
KEY FUNCTIONS
• Coordinates with NDRRMC in advising the need to call for international assistance at the onset of disaster
• Establishes procedures for handling international donations
• Manages and clarifies issues arising from handling of international humanitarian assistance
HUMANITARIAN COORDINATION PROCESS
• Ensures that policies and mechanisms are in line with international agreements at the regional and global level
RCHC
DILG DND Chair
Prepared- DSWD
ness Response
HCT
OCHA
NDRRMC
Secretariat ICC
OCD Inter-cluster coordination
DND Department of Defense NDRRMC National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council
DOST Department of Science and Technology NEDA National Economic and Development Authority
DSWD Department of Social Welfare and Development OCD Office of Civil Defense
DILG Department of the Interior and Local Government OCHA Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
HCT Humanitarian Country Team RCHC Resident Coordinator/Humanitarian Coordinator
ICC Inter-cluster coordination
142 PHILIPPINES
2020
National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC) Humanitarian Country Team (HCT)
Lead: Chairperson Lead: UN RC/HC
Inter-Cluster Coordinator
(OCHA)
WASH Child
MDM SRR ETC PIHA LO Protection
(UNICEF)
(DILG) (DND-AFP) (DICT) (DFA) (DILG-PNP) (UNICEF)
RH
ETC Early Recovery &
(UNFPA) Livelihood
(WFP)
(UNDP)
Government Non-Government
DA Department of Agriculture FAO Food and Agriculture Organization UNDP UN Development Programme
DepED Department of Education IFRC International Federation of the Red Cross UNFPA UN Population Fund
DOH Department of Health ILO International Labor Organization UNHCR UN High Commissioner for Refugees
DOLE Department of Labor and Employment IOM International Organization for Migration UNICEF UN Children’s Fund
DSWD Department of Social Welfare and Development OCHA UN Office for the Coordination of WFP World Food Programme
OCD Office of Civil Defense Humanitarian Affairs WHO World Health Organization
After Typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda), the Philippines HCT established and endorsed technical working groups and
communities of practice to support the inter-cluster coordination group and HCT on technical matters relevant to
gender in humanitarian assistance, cash transfer programming in emergency, community engagement, information
management and public–private partnership.
PHILIPPINES 143
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
ARMY
101,000
personnel
25,000 19,000
personnel personnel
144 PHILIPPINES
2020
FOUR FUNCTIONS
• Engineering units may be • Preposition assets and • Conduct SRR operations. • Engineering units may
tasked to construct dykes relief goods in disaster- be tasked to rebuild
• Conduct evacuations of
and other flood control prone areas, including communities and
affected communities.
systems and structures. relief items from DSWD infrastructures.
and other concerned • Clear road debris and
• Assist in the inspection
agencies. provide assistance in the
of buildings for safety
transportation of relief
occupancy. • Strengthen capacity
goods and rescue and
through training
medical teams.
and procurement of
RESPONSIBILITIES
44 member agencies, including the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) and the Philippine National Police (PNP)
PHILIPPINES 145
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Functions: The SRR cluster is a national mechanism that Support Agencies: DSWD, DILG, PNP, DFA, DOH,
coordinates and deploys all available search and rescue Philippine Coast Guard, Bureau of Fire Protection,
teams from government, civil society, the private sector Department of Public Works and Highways, Philippine
and the international community. Atmospheric Geophysical and Astronomical Services
Administration, and other agencies.
Lead agency: DND and AFP lead the SRR cluster.
Act as lead agency of the Search, • Assist DRRMCs and other agencies • Integrate military response
Rescue and Retrieval cluster in delivery of response services and operations with other agencies.
1. Coordination of all search and recovery efforts.
• Assist in the coordination of foreign
rescue teams. • Contribute to disaster prevention military forces.
2. Retrieval operations in and mitigation efforts.
coordination with other cluster.
146 PHILIPPINES
2020
Functions: This mechanism facilitates coordination with Functions: The Center operates as a facility for OCD
NDRRMC and OCD for government agencies, NGOs, the and AFP in implementing command, control and
private sector and international humanitarian actors. coordination for HADR operations. Coordination with
It handles response operations and early recovery non-military organizations, including NGOs and INGOs,
requests for assistance, and provides support to the is also one of the functions of the OCD-AFP Coordination
clusters. The CMCC coordinates with MNCC, NDRRMC Center.
and OCD to ensure assistance is streamlined and not
duplicated.
13 SOP No. 3: Civil-Military Coordination Center (CMCC) AFP-Vision 2028L A Word-class Armed Forces, Sources of National Pride, OTAG/OJ7, General Headquarters,
Armed Forces of the Philippines, 2015.
PHILIPPINES 147
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
14 Multinational Coordination Center, US Pacific Command Training and Exercises Directorate (J7), PowerPoint Presentation, 2015.
15 OPLAN Tulong-Bayanihan AFP Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Response (HADR) Plan PowerPoint presentation, 2016.
16 Multinational Force Standing Operating Procedures (MNF SOP) V. 3, 2015.
17 OPLAN Tulong-Bayanihan AFP HADR Plan PowerPoint presentation, 2016.
18 Thomas Parker et al., ‘The U.S. Pacific Command Response to Super Typhoon Haiyan,’ Joint Force Quarterly 82, no. 3rd Quarter (July 2016): 54–61.
148 PHILIPPINES
2020
Assisting State
National Government
Government
United AHA
Nations Center Department of National
Defense (DND)
OCHA
WFP JOCCA Multi-National NATIONAL
others
Armed Forces of
Coordination LEVEL
NDRRMC Center (MNCC)
the Philippines
(AFP)
CMCOORD OCC Ops Dip IO/M MNF
HUMOCC
MDRRMC
REGIONAL
LEVEL
19 US Pacific Command, Training & Exercises Directorate (J7), Multi-National Coordination Center, Powerpoint, 2015.
PHILIPPINES 149
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
Around 39,000 families were pre-emptively evacuated and assisted in command and control, road clearing,
before Typhoon Mangkhut (local name: Typhoon Ompong) transport assistance for evacuations, security provision,
hit parts of northern and southern Luzon on 16 September and supported law enforcement in collaboration with the
2018. The NDRRMC instituted red alert protocols, and PNP. The AFP has built-in organisational structures that
military personnel from the army, navy, air force and their are tasked to conduct HADR in the event of disasters. It
reserves were called upon to assist in disaster response does not act independently, but works in unison with and
and relief operations. supports the NDRRMC and the humanitarian community.
150 PHILIPPINES
2020
Western Eastern
Region IV-B Samar Samar
Roxas
Aklan
Tacloban Borongan
Capiz Bantayan
Ormoc
Antique
Iloilo
Leyte
Guiuan
50 KM
Negros
Occidental
Cebu
Southern
Manila
Region VI Leyte
Cebu
Coordination hubs
Bohol
SHIPS: AIRCRAFT:
Source: UN OCHA Philippines HELICOPTERS:
LEYTE CEBU CAPIZ L-50 - HMAS Tobruk C-130 (Hercules) UH-60 (Blackhawk)
Region VII
(Landing Ship Heavy)
LPD - HMTS Ang Thong
V-22 (Osprey)
P-3 (Orion)
Lynx Mk8
Australia Israel Canada Sea King Mark 4
(Landing Platform Dock) C-2 (Greyhound) Merlin (AW-101)
Thailand Italy United Kingdom
FOREIGN MILITARY DEPLOYED ASSETS
LST - Landing Ship Dock AN-225 - Antonov 225 (Mriya) AC313
Beligum New Zealand HMAS - Her Majesty’s Australian Ship IL-76 - Ilyushin 76
PHILIPPINES: Foreign Military
Indonesia Sweden Deployed Assets HMS - Her Majesty’s Ship C-27 (Spartan)
Japan USA
SAMAR ROWPU - Reverse Osmosis Water A330 - Airbus A-330
Singapore CN-235 (Casa)
USA USA RUSSIA
USAR - Urban Search and Rescue SINGAPORE
KDC-10
South Korea USS - United States Ship
USA
AIRCRAFT CARRIER, USS GEORGE WASHINGTON 1x AN-225 2x C-130
Creation date: 30 Dec 2013 Data Source: OCHA and MNCC 3x IL-76
Feedback: marinosj@un.org www.unocha.org Reliefhttps://philippines.humanitarianresponse.info
www.reliefweb.int Flights, USAR,
2x Cruisers (Antietam, Cowpens) 16x C130s
Medical teams, Food & medical supplies.
2x Destroyers (Mustin, Lassen) 14x V22 Osprey
1x Supply Ship (Charles Drew) 3x P3
ISRAEL
2x LSD - Dock Landing Ship 2x C-2 THAILAND
(Germantown and Ashland) 1x C-12 Field Hospital
1x Submarine Tender (Emory Land) 1x LPD (HMTS Ang Thong)
148 pax; advanced multi-
1x Pathfinder (USN Bowditch) 8x UH-60 (Blackhawk) 1x LST
department medical facility, with
1x LPD (Denver) 2x C-130
approx 100MT of humanitarian & medical
1x Dry Cargo Ship (Richard Byrd) 6x TWPS 2x SH60
supplies. Search & Rescue.
1x Replenishment Oiler (Yukon) (Tactical Water Purifications Systems)
MALAYSIA
UNITED KINGDOM ITALY
5x C-130
1x C130
LT. AIRCRAFT CARRIER (ILLUSTRIOUS) as of 25/11/13 1x C-27
1x Frigate (HMS Daring) Departs 25/11/13 3x Lynx (HMS Daring) 30 Person Medical Team
1x C130J 3x Sea King Mk 7 (HMS Illustrious) BRUNEI
1x Merlin
BELGIUM 1x Offshore Patrol Vessel
1x CN235
CANADA Field Hospital
1x A330
DART: 350+/-. DART camp located at soccer field 2x CC-177 (C-17)
INDONESIA
4 mobile medical teams. Construction (repair key infrastructure) 1x Challenger Jet 1 x C130
Water purification and engineering (road clearance). 3x Bell 416
3x ROWPU
THE NETHERLANDS Delivery of Relief Supplies
1x KDC-10
JAPAN Delivery of Relief CHINA
Supplies
1x Hospital Ship (Peace Ark)
1x LST (Osumi) 2x C130 3x CH-47
1x AC313
1x DDH (Ise) 3x UH1
1x Replenishment (Towada) 2x SH-60
SWEDEN
2x LCAC Medical Teams 1 x C130 INDIA
1x C-130
REPUBLIC OF KOREA AUSTRALIA
46 Air and Logistic Personnel 2 x C130 1x L-50 (HMAS Tobruk)
QATAR
Engineering Team: 6 Excavators - 12 Dump Trucks - 2 Loaders 2x LCM8 2x C-17 NEW ZEALAND
2 Bulldozers - 2 Water Purifying Vehicles. 2x LARC
2 x C130 1 x C130
Security & Recovery Team Coordination Team Medical Team Water containers, generators,
2x C17
tarpaulins & chainsaws.Relief Supplies
Creation date: 30 Dec 2013 Data Source: OCHA and MNCC Feedback: marinosj@un.org www.unocha.org www.reliefweb.int https://philippines.humanitarianresponse.info
PHILIPPINES 151
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
20 Center for Excellence in Disaster Management and Humanitarian Assistance, ‘Advances in civil-military coordination in catastrophes: How the Philippines turned
lessons learned from Super Typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda) into best practices for disaster preparedness and response’, 2015, p.5.
152 PHILIPPINES
2020
PHILIPPINES 153
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
OPLAN Tulong – Bayanihan The Armed Forces Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Response Plan
UN United Nations
154 PHILIPPINES
2020
REFERENCES
Armed forces of the Philippines. SOP No. 3: Civil-Military Coordination Center (CMCC) AFP-Vision 2028L AWord-class
Armed Forces, Sources of National Pride, OTAG/OJ7, General Headquarters. 2015.
Center for Excellence in Disaster Management and Humanitarian Assistance. Advances in civil-military coordination in
catastrophes: How the Philippines turned lessons learned from Super Typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda) into best practices for
disaster preparedness and response. 2015.
Government of the Philippines. Armed Forces Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Response Plan. 2016.
Government of the Philippines, Department of National Defense. National Disasters Response Plan: Earthquake and
Tsunami. 2018.
Government of the Philippines. National Disaster Response Plan for Hydrometeorological Hazards. 2014.
Government of the Philippines. National Disaster Response Plan for Hydrometeorological Hazards. Version 2. 2016.
Government of the Philippines. National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Framework. 2011.
Government of the Philippines, National Disaster Risk Reduction Management Council, ‘Enhanced Philippine International
Humanitarian Assistance’. 2017.
Government of the Philippines, National Disaster Risk Reduction Management Council, ‘Harmonized National Contingency
Plan for the Magnitude 7.2 Earthquake’. 2019.
Government of the Philippines, National Disaster and Risk Reduction Management Council, ‘Implementing Guidelines on
the Use of Incident Command System (ICS) as an On-Scene Disaster Response and Management Mechanism under the
Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction and Management System (PDRRMS)’. 2012.
Government of the Philippines, National Economic Development Authority. Disaster Rehabilitation and Recovery Planning
Guide. 2020.
Government of the Philippines. Operational Guidelines on Philippine International Humanitarian Assistance Cluster, draft.
2016.
Government of the Philippines, Office of Civil Defense. National Disaster Risk Reduction Plan 2011-2028 (NDRRP). 2011.
Government of the Philippines. Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Act. 2010.
Government of the Philippines, Philippine Statistics Authority, ‘Provincial Summary: Number of Provinces, Cities,
Municipalities and Barangays, By Region’. 2017.
Government of the Philippines, Senate of the Philippines, ‘Senate Bill No. 205, An Act Creating the Department of Disaster
Resilience, Defining Its Powers and Functions, and Appropriating Funds Therefore,’ 2019.
Government of the Philippines. Strengthening Disaster Risk Reduction in the Philippines: Strategic National Action Plan
2009-2019.
PHILIPPINES 155
Regional Consultative Group I Towards a Predictable Model
IDMC. Emergency Events Database (EM-DAT) Center for Research on the Empidemiology of Disasters. 2020.
Jhesset Enamo, ‘UP Keeps Project NOAH Afloat’. Phillipine Daily Inquirer. 2017.
Kassandra Collins, ‘Pacific Partnerships 2019 Conclude Mission Stop in Philippines’. Indo-Pacific Command. 2019.
Mara Cedepa, ‘House Okays Bills Creating Department of Disaster Resilience.’ Rappler. 2018.
Multinational Coordination Center. US Pacific Command Training and Exercises Directorate (J7). PowerPoint Presentation.
2015.
National Disaster Coordinating Council Circular. Institutionalization of the Cluster Approach in the Philippine Disaster
Management System, Designation of Cluster Leads and their Terms of Reference at the National, Regional and Provincial
Level. 2007.
OPLAN. Tulong-Bayanihan AFP Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Response (HADR) Plan PowerPoint presentation.
2016.
Renzo Acosta, ‘Senate to Prioritize Creation of Department of Disaster Resilience’. Philippine Daily Inquirer. 2020.
Thomas Parker et al., ‘The U.S. Pacific Command Response to Super Typhoon Haiyan,’ Joint Force Quarterly 82, no. 3rd
Quarter, pp. 54–61. 2016.
156 PHILIPPINES
2020
CONCLUSION
This publication reflects significant changes that have
taken place in the region over the last five years. This is
a result of changes at both the global and national level
responding to shifting humanitarian needs.
157